What do you think?
Rate this book


Audible Audio
Published April 15, 2025
So, I want to start by saying, I’ve now read everything Milena McKay has published thus far and I am irrevocably a fan of hers. Minus A Whisper of Solace (where I’m certainly in the minority lol), I have loved her books- most notably These Thin Lines and The Headmistress. And while I adore her writing, something was missing for me this time.
3 Stars
“Drama is inherent to our world, amor.”
This story follows Juliette Lucian-Sorel as she navigates the cutthroat world of a ballerina at the top of her game. This was rife with intrigue, dramatics, and through it all a blossoming romance with the one woman who could rival her talent, Katarina Vyatka.
I think Juliette was an okay MC. I didn’t love her, but I didn’t hate her either and I think that’s partially why this faltered for me. Following her single POV throughout, I struggled to care. It felt hard to connect to her because while we’re told everyone loves her as the golden girl - the princess of Paris - I just didn’t feel it. I felt like we were told to believe this sentiment without really seeing it.
On the other hand, I did really like Katarina. She was intriguing, complicated, a force to be reckoned with and a total ice queen. Whew. I’m a big fan of the ice queen trope, so of course Katarina was great. I can admit, the mystery behind her character wouldn’t have been attained from having her POV, but I can’t help but wish we had gotten it anyway.
The progression of the romance didn’t work for me. There were small scenes to build up the tension between the two, but once they got together it just ended. Fast forward and they’re just comfortably in a relationship and we get to see none of it. While the romance was important to the story, it definitely took a backseat to the ballet plot. So, when shit hits the fan, and it does, I just didn’t feel the intense need to root for them like I wish I had.
This has miscommunication in spades- if that’s a trope you don’t like, I don’t think this would be for you. Juliette spends almost the entire book making assumptions and pushing things under the rug without tackling them. I could’ve screamed at how many times she could’ve spoken up and gotten the answers she needed, but instead she stayed silent and the story went on. And she wasn’t the only one to keep secrets where communication could’ve solved the problems in seconds.
Then the third act breakup hits. Yes, it’s there. And the lengthiest part of the miscommunication ensues. Surprisingly, this is where I realized the story really went downhill for me. The similarities to These Thin Lines seemed almost formulaic- I loved that book with a burning passion so seeing a very similar arc progression here made things predictable and it sort of saddened me.
Overall, I cannot stress how much I love Milena McKay and her writing- this one just didn’t hit the mark for me, but I’m sure it would for so many others. The care and research she put in for many of the topics covered in this story was obvious. I did really enjoy and feel immersed in the world of ballet that she created. So I would recommend giving this one a go or either of the others I referenced above. I will always recommend her books.
Also, the cover on this? It’s superbly beautiful and a perfect fit.
﹌﹌﹌﹌﹌﹌﹌﹌﹌﹌﹌﹌It’s release day so why not add another book to my CR 🤫 I’m so excited for this!!
Sapphic rival ballerinas you say? Written by Milena McKay? Absolutely.

