I really don't know what I thought of this book. I had so much fun reading it and would absolutely recommend the series, but did I think this book was necessary? No. No, I did not. Would I have read it had I not adored the friendship between Nora, Iris and Wes? No, I probably wouldn't. Hence the 3.5 star rating.
But did I love the friendship group, the sisterly love, the sweet sapphic romance? I absolutely did. Nora and the gang are some of my new favourite book characters, and this book only furthered that love. They were even more fleshed out than before, and the backstory and world grew so much more. It was fun, that's for sure, and I was hooked, finishing the book in two days.
I did, however, have some gripes about the book - and the fact it even exists.
Firstly with the way it was written. Call it a pet peeve, but when a successful standalone inherits a sequel, I like there to be some consistency between the two... such as a similar plot structure, for example. This book just wasn't as thrilling as the first, even though it was also set over a short space of time, and was incredibly action-packed. The sense of mystery wasn't... well, anywhere. It was an action book, and a little too gory, and kind of just felt like the author having a lot of fun with an existing world.
Which brings me to my second point. I'm not really a fanfiction girl, but I'm sure some fabulous fanfiction has been written about Tess Sharpe's books - and this book felt exactly like that. A fanfiction of a successful standalone, which finished on a cliffhanger. I would have much preferred for this book to maybe be a completely new mystery with the same characters, like the sequel to AGGGTM, for example. Instead, the book sort of... ruined a lot of the cliffhanger aspect, which was something I loved about book one. It was a lot less subtle, and spelt out plot points which were deliberately kept ambiguous at first.
I also found it sort of lazy how Tess Sharpe used perspective, here. We don't need to hear from every character's perspective, just because Nora isn't present in the scene. I would have loved for the book to have just been told from Nora's POV... or even Iris's!
All in all, I did really, really enjoy this book. But it also brought up many questions for me about the importance of creating a sequel that will compliment a successful standalone, instead of milking its success. A lot of mystery books do this well... and unfortunately, I don't think this was one of those times.