Note before reviewing: this is the second installment of a series called Carnal Games, centered around a BDSM club (Carnal) and a group of its regulars. Each book in the series focuses on a different couple. 7 Days (formerly titled Cherry Auction), follows Domnhall and Brooke; Unholy Obsession is about Domnhall's sister Moira and Bane. If you would like to read Unholy Obsession, do read 7 Days first; I read 7 Days prior to this ARC in order to best review it.
Stasia Stark writes erotica. The Carnal Games series involves BDSM related content. Unholy Obsession does not beat around the bush, instantly putting the centered couple together. When we start reading, we learn they've already had a sexual encounter at Carnal, and that it was a re-awakening for the both of them. For Moira, it was the first time in a long time she felt anything since falling out with her brother; for Bane, it was a reconnection with a part of himself he's felt he had to hide away for the past few years.
(I wish this scene was the actual start of the book, rather than mentioned as a memory / afterthought. Show, not tell! Although the couple's chemistry sizzles regardless, it would've helped drive home how and why they both experienced this first moment as highly impactful on their lives moving forward. Even a flashback would've worked. The scene is available as a bonus scene on Stasia Black's website, though.)
Despite sharing this indulgence together, these two people couldn't be more different from one and other. Moira ia a self-proclaimed sex addict, whereas Bane is a priest. A legitimate priest. A man of God who just happens to also be a dominant. (He's an Episcopal priest, so no vow of celibacy.)
I'm not religious, so I'm good with it. In fact, I didn't really experience their relationship or their brand of BDSM as all that dark or taboo, though I could understand mostly from Bane's own PoV chapters why it certainly is frowned upon in their lives and why it was an important plot point. And yeah, there is a scene that is very, very... well. Let's just say there's altar worship and then there's ALTAR WORSHIP, okurrrr. But none of it is shocking to me, and so it didn't feel as all that dark. 7 Days delivered more in that regard.
But this isn't to say 7 Days is the better book of the two. I think Unholy Obsession is, in terms of the romance. Moira and Bane both are very sympathetic characters with a lot of layers to them; Moira is feisty and goes through life with everything seemingly gliding off her like water off a duck's back, but she's very sensitive and vulnerable. And so incredibly misunderstood and unsupported. Treated like shit. I found her endearing in a way. Bane, 3 years her senior at age 25, is emotionally intelligent and mature, and he just gets Moira in a way no one else does. He sees her, but he also understands her and what she needs.
It's refreshing to read about a dominant personality who actually is a big fat teddy bear underneath it all and utilizes his dom role as a way to help his sub just be herself. There is no dubious consent. There is give and take despite their roles, especially when it comes to daring to be vulnerable and open. There is clear communication. There is safety, physically and emotionally. I love their relationship. Plot's gotta be plottin', that's the nature of the beast, but at its core, despite it all, their relationship is very solid. A bit of a whirlwind, but solid enough to be believable and to be invested in.
Now plot wise, Unholy Obsession takes a backseat to 7 Days. Because 7 Days is wild. It's just insane. Unholy Obsession focuses more on the romance and Moira's and Bane's personal growth both individually and together, whereas 7 Days is also a decent thriller. Some interesting shit does go down in Unholy Obsession, mostly involving Bane's family background, but I struggled with plot holes and a messy, confusing timeline. One side character's arc goes Off The Fucking Rails and it's distracting, abrupt and kinda unexplained. Another major plot point is explained away but then there's also another explanation that's not... really... clear? There is a lot of chaos in the timeline; the amount of months passed make no sense and are likely errors.
Furthermore, Stasia Black also focuses a bit too heavily on the couple featured in the third not-yet-published installment of Carnal Games. We're not reminded of who they are again, and then much of their relationship development is given away. Will book 03 be a parallel timeline? Probably. But I'm not sure I'm interested in reading that when I've basically read the epilogue already. Besides, Unholy Obsession hands down has the best male and female main character in Bane and Moira. I feel the Carnal Games series maybe hit a high there that's going to be hard to top. Do I need to read more about this band of people beyond this installment? For some of them, I already know their story. And the rest... well, they seem like assholes not really worth any more of my time.
Thank you NetGalley for the ARC!