Colorist Humor, DNF
I’m disappointed to have to write this, as I truly enjoyed the first volume of the series. However, the discriminatory humor in this volume is something that can’t be ignored. (Even describing what is in the book gets upsetting, so be warned.) As a summary, this volume introduces Bai Yu, an ethnically Chinese individual with skin so dark it is described as “black.” The color of Bai Yu’s skin is repeatedly picked on, not just as a single thoughtless comment, but repeatedly throughout the book. Furthermore, Bai Yu is portrayed as a cowardly and rather dim-witted individual.
For context, lightly pigmented skin is highly valued in many Asian countries. This stems from the historical association between light colored skin and wealth, as nobles were able to protect their skin from the sun and tanning. The difference in culture helps explain why something like this was considered more acceptable in China, where it was originally published. Still, the cultural difference does not change the fact that this is colorism, or make the end result any less destructive or offensive. Like many others, Danmei is my escape, and I have no interest in my escape having this kind of bigotry.