All of American literature is a tragedy. What we're living through now isn't a tragedy, however – it's a horror novel. Why bother writing when the world's on fire?
Rising authoritarianism. Covid. Inflation. Wealth disparity. War. Climate change. While every time period is marked by apocalyptic fears, it certainly seems like our current anxieties aren't ill placed. And yet, art and literature persist.
In captivating and culturally savvy prose, Ed Simon grapples with the notion that writers and their work ought to distract readers from the dire situation we face in these fetid days of the Anthropocene. He also addresses the wider question of what it's like to write during what could be the last decades of human civilization, arguing that to craft imaginative spaces through the magic of words isn't superfluous. Instead it exists at the core of human experience – as it always has and always will.
Examining creativity as it has manifested in similarly dire circumstances in human history – in a broad range of authors and texts, such as the Bible, Boccaccio's Decameron, Voltaire, Octavia Butler's Parable of the Sower, and Stephen King's The Stand – Writing During the Apocalypse eschews the easy defeatism of nihilism. Instead, it offers a hopeful perspective on the various ways that literary expression can endow a meaningless world with meaning and generate a spark in the darkness.
With the infamous four horsemen as its guide, Writing During the Apocalypse honors the literary life even during the end of the world.
Very dramatic and, to me, incredibly overwritten (I'm all for purple prose but if I feel like I need to crack open a thesaurus or check if the book was published a century ago you might be doing too much). What I mean by dramatic is that Simon repeats over and over that we might be the last or one of the last two generations (which one, I ask, since there are like five or six alive right now), and I just don't get the time scope of this. But he really is obsessed with this, stating that there basically is no reason for any one person to still fight the climate catastrophe, unless it's simply to make us feel better, because it is entirely pointless and won't change anything. What kind of fucking opinion is this? Simon can't be all holier than though and pretend that poets are gods and oh so important and will save the world because literature is so important while also at the same time pretending that actual, physical acts to keep one more species from dying out or working towards a better future, even if we all die anyway (because we all will, he agrees with me here while he drones on about billionaires being scared of death as if billionaires aren't scared of everything), is pointless. Especially if we're going to die within the next fifty years as he seems to assume, maybe we can save a bit more of the world then, no? But despite him also saying stuff like "the planet has existed before us and will exist after us", he seems to not really differentiate between the end of humanity and the actual end of the world, conflating our end with the end of the planet, which is a huge pet peeve of mine. Let this beautiful planet survive us.
To the international reader, this book is very US-centric. I would probably have to reread it to grasp everything the author was trying to say, but I don't think I care enough to do so. He talks a lot about the (end of the) Roman Empire, possibly only to draw parallels to the modern day USA, but I find it incredibly ingenious as a US-focused book and therefore author to ignore the literal apocalypse Native Americans went through. A few parts of this book are about the Covid pandemic, which I always hugely struggle with, especially when it's compared to pandemics like the Black Death or others where 70-90% of the population died. Usually I find it interesting how the Covid pandemic affected the author or the character they're talking about, but once again it's all just very dramatic. I'm aware that being an essential worker in rural Germany at the time isn't comparable to lockdown in a big city in the US with no healthcare and I truly think that it was a scary time, but it wasn't apocalyptic. The world very obviously, especially visible through social media, kept on turning. People knew what was happening from basically the get go. And I struggled with Simon's obvious empathy and suffering for all the people who died, when in the parts about war he's much more clinical, even quoting that one saying about deaths in such multitude becoming a statistic. I just don't understand how people dying in a pandemic is a tragedy when people dying in a war isn't.
To finally end this, I'm not sure if I missed most of the parts where Simon "offers a hopeful perspective on the various ways that literary expression can endow a meaningless world with meaning", which is what I was mostly interested in when picking this book up. There are instances, like when he talks about Station Eleven or AI, but I wanted more. More hopefulness overall, but also more focus on how we are social, creative creatures. How maybe it's an apocalypse unto itself that we're forced and manipulated into giving that up, that a lot of the depression and feeling of meaninglessness in our lives comes from the fact that we don't create because TikTok's dopamine rush is easier, because books like this tell us there is no reason to try anyway because we're already doomed. We are. Doesn't mean there is no meaning in being creative and trying to save the world even if we can't save ourselves. (There, no need to read the book now ;) )
“Every human is a universe; each individual in victory and defeat, love and hatred, desire and revulsion, is more complicated than all great literature, more beautiful than every painting, truer than all of the axioms of philosophy”
I liked it a lot, even tho people are right, Ed Simon falls easily into pessimism and repeats himself througt the book.
Quotes :)
- 'Adam Trooze [...] : in the "polycrisis, the shocks are disparate, but they interact so that the whole is even more overwhelming than the sum of the parts." '
- 'We are stalked by four horsemen, and their names are pandemic, authoritarianism, technocracy, and climate change. Their children are war, meaninglessness, and collapse.'
- 'If your concern is with the rhetorical excesses of a few college kids on Twitter, but you’re silent about the growing fascist cult currently in control of the federal executive, the federal judiciary, half of the federal legislature, and a majority of state governments (not to speak of the awesome power of the military), then you’ve already voted with your words.'
- 'They gave us the ability to think about the unthinkable before it happened; the chance to see the unseeable before it was on our newsfeeds. If the vision of the screen is anemic, that’s not necessarily our fault—we measure the horror with the tools which we’ve inherited.'
- 'White supremacists think that only their votes count and will do anything to enforce that conviction.'
- 'Our national story is a Jekyll and Hyde tale about the best and worst aspirations at conflict within the Manichean breast of a nation which fancied itself Paradise but ended up somewhere further south.'
- 'In Marginalia, I wrote that in our current moment "awareness of death is as repressed [as] sex was to the Victorian," and what better example of repressing this awareness than the sanitized fantasy of dotcom millionaires and billionaires pretending that technological immortality is not just possible but likely ?'
- 'Hans Moravec [...] says that he has "already mentioned the possibility of [digitally] making copies of oneself, with each copy undergoing its own adventures" and that, as a result, "Concepts of life, death and identity will lose their present meaning," can one fault me for feeling that we’ve left the domain of science and entered that of a secularized religion, a positivist theology which enshrines technology as the engine of teleology ?'
- 'Transhumanists attend TED talks about how death for them is "optional," while advocating for a system that denies the poor based on "pre-existing conditions," and so we witness the new ugenicist doublethink logic of a type of genocide.'
- 'Philosopher Glenn Albrecht’s concept of "solastagia." This neologism, Vermeulen explains, encompasses the "psychological pain experienced when one’s sense of belonging is undone by environmental change," contrary to nostalgia where "staying home makes you sick because the place that was once home is being destroyed before your very eyes." '
- 'If Hurston’s characters were looking at God, then I felt like I was looking at something strangely more terrifying—humanity’s hubris altering the seasons.'
- 'In the New Left Review, Frederic Jameson argued that it is "easier to imagine the end of the world than to imagine the end of capitalism." '
- 'Scranton reflects that "we might wish we could take Nietzsche’s place. He had to cope only with the death of God… while we must come to terms with the death of our whole world." '
- ' "We live as though we are going to die tomorrow," wrote Jerome, "yet we build as though we are going to live always," or, as David Byrne sang, "Why stay in college? Why go to night school? … I ain’t got time for that now." '
I read this as part of Goodreads' Spring challenge and it made for such a thought-provoking reading experience. Each of these essays felt like a poignant glimpse into how our humanity will shine before it's blotted off the earth (although I would say my religious perspective put a different spin on this). Lots to digest, and I picked up a lot of further readings on apocalypses. I always say I can't bring myself to read apocalypse fiction, but it turns out non-fiction makes me feel quite different. Ultimately, I agree with Simon that the arts will be important up until the last of the earth fades away and beyond.
I would have liked more development of an answer to "why write?" in these times (answer mostly coming at the end and too abbreviated), but this is an interesting and timely reflection.
Boy was this fucking depressing. Great prose tho. Def everyone keep making art but do NOT read this if you are pregnant lmao it won’t be good for your mental health
The way the book is set up intrigued me. Simons’ whole premise is that our society is on the verge of apocalyptic ruin, and that we are starting to hear the hoof beats of the four horsemen. The horsemen are given titles that relate eerily to modern times. The white horse is pandemic, the red horse is authoritarianism, the black horse is technological advancement (ai), and the pale horse is climate change. I enjoyed this modern rendition, but not the “it’s too late to reverse our doom and everyone who is reading this will likely face an awful death rather than the hospital bed surrounded by friends and family that has become normalized” approach. I don’t endorse sugar coating, and I believe the truth should be accurately conveyed (no matter how dull), but the overall message being “keep writing even when everything sucks!” felt less impactful when the majority of the book was nihilistic remarks. My biggest gripe with this book is the number of literary references the author makes to articulate his points, but without going into detail about the reference. Some of them are quite niche, so subtext would have been helpful. It comes across as trying to sound as intellectual as possible when the general idea could be articulated in fewer words. It often feels like you have to have read a hundred other poems and books to understand what he’s saying, which isn’t realistic unless literature is your profession and world. That’s not to say there weren’t stand out moments I enjoyed!
A few quotes I liked:
“The task of war literature is to transform shadows into pictures, to put flesh upon the bones of mere statistics.”
“We feared robots before we even built them, and yet, we built them anyway.”
There was another quote I’m having trouble finding again, though I wrote the latter half down. It commented on life’s unpredictability, saying that being victorious in the moment doesn’t negate that “…we still might die of a heart attack on the track.”
I had a really hard time getting into this book and that's fine. It was way more America-centric than I expected so a whole lot of things went way over my head (because they lacked explanation) and I didn't find the scope to be what I wanted it to be. But that's more of a me problem than anything else. And this is no insult to Simon but I listened to the audiobook and the orator's voice had me rolling my eyes a lot. Although to be fair some of the sentences really annoyed me in their exaggeration or sanctimonious nature as well--ala the whole, wishing to be in Europe felt simultaneously insulting to both the colonial history of America (even though he mentions this briefly) and the assumption of Europe as some form of tablua rasa (as if the whole of Europe wasn't affected by its own feudalism and serfdom). Not to mention, I have a hard time trusting any man who can't pronounce Iraq and Iran the way they can pronounce Italy or Ibiza.
I think the demographic for this book is good for middle to upperclass American white folks and that's okay. If you're looking for someone who can discuss various historical events and literary pieces from all over the world, and the reader still getting it, I highly recommend anything by Amitav Ghosh. He does a great job discussing historical and political events from around the world (with the lens of the Anthropocene in mind) and readers still getting it--regardless of where you're from.
I'm torn about this book, because for a solid 88% of it, there is a pervasive feeling that the author wants you to despair, to carry around the knowledge that everything is changing for the worse like an iron ball in your chest, knowing that you might not have caused it, but there is also nothing you can do about it. I find this to be alarmist and detrimental in that it causes panic rather than rational thought about how to navigate a changing world. Then, for the last 11%, and mildly interspersed through the text it will speak of *hope*, of an Auschwitz prisoner calling others out of hovels to watch a beautiful sunset, and it makes me lower my hackles, because I feel that *that* is the core of what makes humans adaptable, capable and strong in the face of despair: *hope*.
It brings to mind The Parable of the Sower often, the world Butler forsaw, the way the characters choose to navigate it, and where her novel feels gritty and dark there is also a looking to the future that this book feels like it lacks. As though the loss of the past is such a grievous wound that we are unable to move forward, rather than a tragedy we will instead have to combat with hope, and community and adaptability.
The future does look grim, but if all you see is what we are losing, what we fear to lose, instead of how to persevere and how to create, even in the darkness, then despair will be the only thing you *can* see.
I may be a bit biased, as this book is pretty navel gazing for someone of my politics, but I enjoyed it.
It’s easy to feel hopeless in what feels like, and probably is, the end of the world. And while this book rambles on, and comes to no real conclusions other than, we must keep on because we have no choice, but you’re not crazy for feeling hopeless, camaraderie at the end of the world is nice.
It’s a bummer, but an interesting bummer.
—-
Nonsense
This book contains at least four instances of the word Potomac. I know at least four because I might have missed a first one because the narrator whiffs it so hard on the pronunciation that I almost didn’t understand what he was going for. But then clocked it every other time because he whiffs it again, nails it, and then somehow whiffs it again at the end.
There is some other questionable pronunciation throughout the book, but this is a pretty famous river. How did no one clock it?
In times of crisis, we must decide again and again whom we love. Frank O'Hara 1957 Meditation in an Emergency
Right from this opening quotation, I am needing to argue. Shouldn't that be what we love ? which includes people and pets I assume.
Yesterday I returned this to the library, having renewed to the max, and finished a few weeks ago already. With 8 pages of notes to go through, I am going to let my review simmer a bit.
Though we knew this day would come...it still took us by surprise. p3