Confessional fictions? A memoir in lies? Other Shane Hintons follows eight Shane Hintons (not including the author) through the forking paths of a life, where visceral Florida realism meets the surreal and the absurd.
A Christ-haunted childhood manifests in the form of supernatural horrors––a pact with the devil, an encounter with the ghost of a dead friend. Adolescent anxieties resurface in fatherhood, where one Shane Hinton hunts suburban iguanas in an alcoholic stupor, and another waits to die beside his algae-covered swimming pool. Each story marks an inflection point, where decisions cannot be undone, and the Shane Hinton who begins the story emerges a different person.
Ten years after his debut collection, Pinkies, which the writer Lidia Yuknavitch described as the “lovechild” of Kafka and Flannery O’Connor, Hinton continues to reveal the terror and beauty of being alive. And as an offspring of those authors, Hinton delivers moments of grace in the strangest a childhood friendship with a dead pet goat, life-affirming messages from a swarm of sewer flies, and an uncomfortable conversation with the Other Shane Hinton.
Shane Hinton leaves copies of his old book where the tide can take them.
He had boxes of Radio Dark in a closet — his 2019 novel, written during the worst stretch of his mental health. Termites came. He had to move everything from the walls. He found the boxes and realized he had too many. So he started putting them in places where they would not survive: gas pumps, bathrooms, the top of a tower, the shoreline at low tide, on a sundial before a thunderstorm. He puts each one next to a trashcan. He likes that part.
This is also a story in Other Shane Hintons. One of the eight Shanes is the Shane reckoning with the boxes — the artifact of a darker self he did not think he would outlive.
A surreal collection of half true stories, full of the fears of youth, the anxieties of adulthood. Its greatest strength is in its setting. This book can sling southern gothic with the best of them. Each story is so short that it has to be concise in establishing itself but they work together to create the setting as you move from story to story. The stories themselves I would describe as seven good, one great. They can be a little blunt and a few end with a direct statement of the message, but I never found myself bored. The idea of telling an overarching story through the many forms a person takes throughout their lives and their relationships to others is 5 stars, but I think a few of the stories needed a little more time in the oven.
“I was gentle with them. Their life cycle must be short, I figured. A few days, maybe. Who was I to shorten an already abbreviated life? I knew I could be inconsiderate, not thinking about the experiences of others. I was self-absorbed. I was suffering but I thought no one else was. In trying to be better, when I could, I sometimes found myself showing too much care toward things that didn't deserve it.”
This is a rather surreal collection of short stories. I will say that they mostly are not as described in the blurb - there isn't a strong sense in most of them of being at a crossroads, making a choice that forecloses other options. Only one story really had that vibe. I can't say that I liked the stories much, but I did find them engaging, and well-written.