Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Vineyards of War #2

The Soldier's Daughter

Rate this book
Violet Nash has grown up in the shadows of her father Charlie’s shattered dreams. It’s been years since he walked away from the battlefields of France, a WWI hero but his heart in tatters, only to see it broken all over again in the worst way possible.

In search of a new beginning, they set sail for Tasmania, Australia to fulfill his dream of setting up a whisky distillery. Violet shows a rare talent for the fine art of distilling and blending and plans to follow in his footsteps. But some secrets cannot be forgotten, and as the Second World War rages on, Charlie feels a pull once more to play his part and is lured back into action.

It comes as no surprise to Violet when Charlie’s footsteps lead him straight back to Champagne, where open arms, future hopes and past ghosts lie waiting. Charlie must prove his bravery in the ultimate act of courage, but it is Violet, the soldier’s daughter, who will fight to claim his lasting legacy.

402 pages, Kindle Edition

Published September 30, 2025

206 people are currently reading
475 people want to read

About the author

Fiona McIntosh

71 books2,011 followers
Fiona writes best selling historical adventure-romance alongside the heroic-romantic, often brutal, fantasy she built her career upon. She lives in Australia but frequently roams the world meticulously researching the locations and gathering material for her historical novels that have international settings. Her books are published worldwide and in various languages.
Her most recent historical fiction has gathered such a following that she is now hosting a tour in 2014 to Paris and Provence so eager readers can walk in the footsteps of her characters.


Librarian Note: There is more than one author in the Goodreads database with this name.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
475 (49%)
4 stars
376 (39%)
3 stars
94 (9%)
2 stars
10 (1%)
1 star
5 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 116 reviews
Profile Image for Karren  Sandercock .
1,332 reviews408 followers
September 7, 2025
1930, Skockando, Moray Speyside, Scotland. Violet Nash is Charlie’s daughter a World War One sniper and hero, he left France with his heart broken and found love with her mother and to have it hurt again. Here, Charlie uses his chemist skills to make and blend whisky and Violet wants to follow in her dad’s footsteps.

Considered to be outsiders, the Nash’s decide to immigrate to Tasmania, a fresh start and the weather is very similar and believe it’s the perfect place to grow and malt barley and re-establish Glen Corbie. Violet is a talented blender and distiller in her own right and she wants to be the first female in centuries to change and refine whisky industry and she has lots of ideas.

When the Second World War breaks out, the old soldier feels torn, Charlie wants to return to England and use his experience to help and this means leaving Violet behind, she’s not happy about it but understands.

Charlie returns to Reims, Champagne, where he met Sophie Méa Delancré a fifth generation champenoise, the lady who broke his heart all those years ago and here he has to face his hopes and dreams, regrets and ghosts of his youth.

I received a copy of The Soldiers Daughter by Fiona McIntosh from Penguin Random House Australia/ Storm Publishing UK and NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. I read the previous book The Champagne War, so I was very familiar with the background, what happen and the characters.

The narrative takes the reader from Scotland, to Australia, England and France and back again, not only does Charlie show his bravery, courage and dedication, so does Violet, Sophie and her son Raphael.

I felt really emotional reading this novel, I have close ties to Scotland and the Moray area, and I learnt a lot about history and women making whisky and how life completes a full circle and just like the seasons. Five stars from me, I highly recommend for lovers of well written and character driven historical fiction.
Profile Image for Brenda.
5,120 reviews3,026 followers
September 24, 2025
Violet Nash and her father, Charlie, were living the dream in Scotland, where the whiskey distillery was established. Glen Corbie, Charlie had named it, and Violet was following in his footsteps, deeply involved in the business with her sharp intelligence making her able to see it all happening. Charlie's wife and Violet's mother, Ellen, had passed unexpectedly and they were both grieving, and when the depression threatened to pull Glen Corbie under, both Violet and Charlie decided Tasmania was were they should go, to set up whiskey making in Australia. Success was in their sights as they worked their way towards the end game - five years in the barrel - but suddenly war began again.

Charlie had been a hero in WWI - Captain Charlie Nash - and while a humble hero, and now almost sixty, he felt he should play his part in bringing down the Germans once again. This time, because of his age, he wouldn't be in the front line. Violet was heartbroken to see him go, but was sure he'd be alright. Charlie was sent into Reims where he would be running a team. The Champagne district was familiar to him; he was there in WWI as well...

The Soldier's Daughter is another spectacular historical novel by Aussie author Fiona McIntosh which I loved. She can't do anything wrong IMO, and this one was no exception. Violet & Charlie; Angus; Sophie - excellent characters who kept me turning the pages. The settings of Scotland; a minor part in London; Tasmania and France, although all different, felt incredibly real. I can't recommend The Soldier's Daughter highly enough, especially to fans of the author and the genre.

With thanks to NetGalley & Penguin AU for my digital ARC to read and review.
Profile Image for Angela.
682 reviews255 followers
October 13, 2025
The Soldier's Daughter by Fiona McIntosh

Synopsis /

Violet Nash has grown up in the shadows of her father Charlie’s shattered dreams. A WWI hero haunted by memories of French Champagne caves where he once found love and redemption, he flees from the Scottish Highlands to Tasmania with his fierce daughter, determined to transform barley into liquid gold—the whisky that will be their salvation.

As Violet masters the ancient alchemy of whisky-making learned in Scotland’s distilleries, she becomes her father’s greatest achievement—and his deepest vulnerability.

When Hitler’s war machine rolls across Europe, Charlie cannot resist the call to return to occupied France. His destination is the Champagne region where Sophie Delancré still tends her vines under Nazi occupation, and where a young man’s reckless courage will demand the ultimate sacrifice.

As Charlie vanishes into the deadly game of resistance and espionage, Violet must forge her own path through grief and rage, determined to reclaim her father’s legacy.


My Thoughts /

First and foremost, a huge THANK YOU to NetGalley, Storm Publishing and author, Fiona McIntosh for providing me with a copy of this publication, which allows me to provide you with an unbiased review.

From the moment I began to read McIntosh's latest offering, The Soldier's Daughter, I had the distinct feeling of déjà vu. And with every page read that feeling remained, and in fact, kept getting stronger. I had to pause at one point to make sure I hadn't already read this one, which confused me to no end as I was sure this one was a new release! The last Fiona McIntosh novel I'd read was titled The Champagne War; but wait! Could it be? Of course! The Soldier's Daughter is its sequel !

Now that my world has righted on its axis and my feelings of déjà vu have turned into tidings of comfort and joy; let's begin anew.

This time the story opens in 1935 and spans to the end of WWII with place settings that transition fluidly between Scotland, Australia, England and France.

As this reader has come to expect from this author, McIntosh's pinpoint attention to detail and hugely evocative descriptions of place and time transported this reader both visually and emotionally.

The prologue sets the scene: 10-year-old Violet Nash in a schoolyard squabble being marched to the Principal's office for corrective behaviour. We learn that Violet's mother had passed away suddenly three years ago and that it's just Violet and her father, Charlie now. Violet, headstrong and outspoken (but not rude or impolite), declares to her father that she no longer wishes to attend school, rather, wants to follow in her father's footsteps as a master whiskey distiller. And with the conclusion of the prologue, the anchor has been weighed – whiskey is now slowly fermenting its way firmly into the narrative.

Having survived one war, Charlie Nash never thought he'd have to live through another. He'd thought he could live out his days with his wife and young daughter doing what he loved most – farming his land and producing whiskey. Losing his wife unexpectedly some years ago, Charlie has doubled down on his efforts to care for his daughter, by making sure he leaves her something worth inheriting once he's gone. Charlie’s dream was to grow malt barley and establish a whiskey of distinction – something Violet could continue to grow and build upon after he'd died.

But life has other things in mind for Charlie Nash. When Hitler’s war machine rolls across Europe, Charlie once again heeds the call to arms and returns to occupied France. Taking up a role as a Resistance spy, he finds himself in Epernay and once again Sophie Delancré a fifth generation champenoise, is thrust into his life. Again, the author navigates the horrors of war - the sacrifices people made – both willingly or unwillingly; and the grief, resilience and bravery shown by those whose lives traversed both World Wars. All the while, Violet's own story is growing. Even though she might not be doing the 'fighting', she's still fighting her own war – grieving, creating and surviving all at once – living a life where legacy and memory ferment alongside courage and sacrifice.

With thanks to NetGalley and especially to one of my favourite publishers, Storm Publishing 💗 for the much appreciated arc in return for an honest review. All opinions expressed in this review are my own. The publication date is currently set for September 30, 2025.
Profile Image for Helen.
2,928 reviews66 followers
October 16, 2025
Another brilliant story from masterful storyteller Fiona McIntosh I fell into this one and could barely put it down as I traveled through the 1930’s 1940’s and then onto the 1950’s through Scotland, England, Tasmania and France through World War 2 and after, getting to know Violet Nash and reacquainting myself with Captain Charlie Nash, a must read.

Violet Nash is her father’s daughter in so many ways she and her father are making whiskey in Scotland at their distillery, Glen Corbie although young Violet knows what she wants in life, Charlie had fought in the great- war came home to England married Ellen, Violet’s mother and then they lost her and they have both thrown themselves into making whiskey but when the depression comes and they are forced to close their distillery they move to Tasmania and start over again growing the barley for their whiskey and very successfully and then World War 11 happens and Charlie after all he went through in the first war enlists to help in this one only this time not on the front line and he ends up in Epernay again and meeting up with Sophie Delancre champagne maker, the woman that Charlie never let go of.

Violet was devastated and angry that her father was going to war again but nothing will change his mind and Violet carries on with the farm and distillery making decisions and doing very well thinking of her father always, Charlie meets up with people from his past when he arrives in Reims their hearts are bursting with happiness at meeting again and opening up to each other and when Charlie steps up to protect Sophie’s son Raphael life will change again for both families.

I loved Charlie when I read The Champagne War and was thrilled to see him get his story and there are so many more in this story that had me feeling very emotional while reading it but a beautiful story it is of love and courage, I loved the characters so much, Violet is so strong and determined will she ever find love? The story is a beautiful, moving and emotional one, it is one that I highly recommend it truly is one not to be missed.
Profile Image for Grandma Susan.
386 reviews259 followers
September 17, 2025
I loved Violet Nash’s story, a fictional main character. . This book takes us through several stages of life, beginning with childhood. The making of whiskey and champagne was intriguing. The different and unique geographic locations were interesting. There were sad tears and happy tears. The characters seemed to leap off the page. Highly recommend!

I was blessed with an ARC. Thank you NetGalley. The opinions expressed are my own and unbiased.
Profile Image for Carolyn.
358 reviews5 followers
October 24, 2025
The Soldier's Daughter by Fiona McIntosh is the sequel to The Champagne War.

It's also a celebration of the author's twenty five years of writing ✍️ including some cleverly intertwined excerpts from previous novels and works.

In the Soldier's Daughter we meet once again the beautiful, aristocratic, Sophie Delancre and Charlie Nash with some new characters such as Violet and Raphael to name some.

The Soldier's Daughter is primarily about learning all aspects of making whisky but it's also about the methods used in champagne as in The Champagne War.

I really loved hearing all about whisky making and all the different methods used and the wood used for the barrels and how it flavours the whisky.

You'll be swept away from Knockando, Scotland to Richmond, Tasmania all the way back to Epernay in France.

Picture yourself on a steam train 🚂 billowing with clouds of smoke and a whistle blowing as you travel through all the locations in the story including many parts of England. There's also ferry ⛴️ and boat 🚢 rides.

It's a novel about grief and despair and how we pick ourselves back up after experiencing severe loss.

The Soldier's Daughter is also a Christmas 🎄 novel ~ so do yourself a favour and put this on your Christmas 🎄 list so you, too can taste the flavours and spices of Christmas 🎄 in The Soldier's Dram including plum pudding, nutmeg, cinnamon, a hint of ginger 🫚, bonfires, butterscotch and toffee apples 🍎.

Congratulations 🎊 to Fiona McIntosh on her Twenty Fifth Anniversary of Writing ✍️ ❤️ Novels 📚.

I loved this one so much and hope to continue with you on your journey.

Ps. Note: The Recipe for Christmas 🎄 New Year Shortbread is at the back of this novel.
Profile Image for Lisa.
407 reviews8 followers
September 9, 2025
Read as an ARC (but without an expected review). I really enjoyed this historical fiction that covers the time period between and into WWII as well as women in the alcohol trade during that period. The setting moves from Scotland to Australia to occupied France and all are lovingly described romantic settings by the author. The reason for the four stars are the sometimes jarring efforts to insert interesting tidbits of historical information that drew me as a reader from the storyline. I think this vast epic could even have been written as multiple books to prove more depth to the characters and storylines. It was a great read.
Profile Image for Nancy Mazgajewski.
296 reviews9 followers
October 8, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley for the opportunity to read this novel before its release date. I was intrigued by the premise of whiskey making in both Australia and Scotland. I have also traveled to Reims, France and toured a champagne vineyard.

Unfortunately, the book did not deliver the punch that I thought it would. I found it to be repetitive.
Profile Image for Helen.
26 reviews1 follower
January 9, 2026
I loved every moment of this. Scotland, Tasmania, France, the whisky, the characters, historical fiction 👏👏Definitely a Helen book.
Profile Image for EmG ReadsDaily.
1,637 reviews146 followers
February 1, 2026
A rich historical tale, set between Scotland, England, France and Australia.

I loved learning about the women making whiskey, and the variety of richly depicted characters in this story.
Profile Image for Aryani Siti.
303 reviews4 followers
October 18, 2025
I loved reading it. Such a great story—it made me teary and really touched my heart.

It’s about Violet and her father, Charlie, who moved to Tasmania to start a new life after the war. Charlie dreams of making whisky, and Violet shares his love for it. I liked how the book also tells the process of making whisky—it’s so interesting and written in a beautiful way.

I love how strong and brave Violet is, just like her dad. The story shows love, courage, and how the past can still stay with us.

Fiona McIntosh writes with so much feeling and makes the history come alive. It’s emotional, heartfelt, and full of hope. I couldn’t put it down.

LOVED IT!!
Profile Image for Karen Bowness.
181 reviews6 followers
January 3, 2026
This is one of those stories that feels rich and immersive without ever losing sight of the characters. At the heart of it is Violet Nash and her relationship with her father, Charlie, and I found their bond after the loss of Violets mother so beautiful. Violet is such a strong, determined character, especially in the way she carves out her own path in a world that doesn’t make it easy for her.

I loved how the story moves between Scotland, England, Tasmania and France, and how the production of whisky is woven so naturally into the story. From learning the craft in Scotland to building a distilling life in Tasmania, the whisky-making felt like more than just a backdrop - it’s part of the family’s identity and legacy. The sections set in France, particularly in the Champagne region, add another emotional layer, tying Charlie’s wartime experiences to love, loss and unfinished business.

Overall, it’s a heartfelt, character-driven novel with fascinating historical detail and a strong sense of place. A really satisfying read that lingers long after you’ve finished it.
Profile Image for Diane.
595 reviews23 followers
November 6, 2025
The Champagne Wars is a story that I will love forever. The Soldier's Daughter is the continuation of the story of Captain Charles Nash after the end of WWI. Charlie meets his wife Ellen who is a nurse on the battlefield and, when the war is over, Charlie keeps his promise to meet with her again. In the years that follow, a daughter Violet is born. Charlie's dream is to make whisky so when that dream is shattered in Scotland and following the death of Ellen, restless Charlie moves with his daughter to Tasmania to begin again.

When WWII breaks out, Charlie feels the pull once more to play his part and, though his daughter disagrees with him, he goes back into action. It is not long before he finds himself once more in France and in the presence of the unforgettable Sophie.

Though a continuation of the Charlie Nash story from The Champagne Wars, The Soldier's Daughter stands alone as an emotional and uplifting story. I love both books.
Profile Image for Karyn.
301 reviews
September 16, 2025
Another wonderfully engaging read by my favourite author, Fiona McIntosh.
The Soldier’s Daughter is an historical novel that looks at family, legacy, and wartime secrets.
Violet Nash the protagonist and her father Charlie, a veteran from WWI, leave the safety of their home in Scotland for a new life in Tasmania. They are looking to build a whisky distillery. Charlie’s past in France resurfaces as WWII looms and he returns to France to assist in the war effort. Violet is left alone in Tasmania to continue their dream of having their own whiskey distillery.

This book is rich in atmosphere and emotion, it’s a story of resilience, identity, and sacrifice. A compelling, heartfelt read for fans of epic historical fiction.
115 reviews3 followers
October 10, 2025
This was a deep and intense read for me. A Father and Daughter on a journey to make whiskey during a time of War. The love Charles had for Violet was sweet but when he leaves Violet to fight for the cause, things drastically change for Violet and her future.

Great read and I really enjoy this Author.
59 reviews
December 19, 2025
I didn’t realise this book was a follow-on from Champagne Wars. When I picked it up, it was simply because I love Fiona McIntosh and historical fiction. Once I realised the story continued Charlie and Sophie’s journey, I was absolutely delighted.
18 reviews
January 8, 2026
Moving, inspiring and educational. I was gifted this book for Christmas and although not I would normally buy for myself I loved it! The strength and gumption of Violet as a character had me hooked from the start and the relationship between Violet and her Dad, Charlie was moving. I appreciated learning more about the intricacies of how whisky is made and found the portrayal of life leading into World War II fascinating. I loved travelling to the different settings throughout the book and seeing how the characters react and evolve in these different locations. Only downside for me was the ending which I found a little too convenient for the sake of tying everything in a neat bow.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Chris Richardson.
53 reviews2 followers
January 4, 2026
Loved this book and story line. Love whisky too. Recommend to my friends. Of course some of the whisky treatments are not correct but it does not distract the story.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
216 reviews12 followers
January 8, 2026
This book is worth reading. Fiona McIntosh created a believable historical novel on the making of whisky and champagne. Even the soldier and the daughter were relatable to the war and the post-war situation. If you are interested in whiskey making, this is a book you might appreciate.
Profile Image for Debbie Lamb.
356 reviews23 followers
November 9, 2025
Another solid offering from the pen of Ms McIntosh. Loved learning about Whisky making too. Recommended.
Profile Image for Rachel.
207 reviews
October 17, 2025
This book is *kind of* a sequel to 'The Champagne War'. Upon learning this, I decided to read that first. While it wasn't necessary to be able to read and enjoy this one, it gave some nice, rich insight into Charlie and Sophie as characters from WWI.

This story follows Violet Nash, Charlie's daughter who is a very smart and independent girl looking to follow in her father's footsteps of distilling whisky. After being pushed out of Scotland in The Great Depression and being somewhat outcasts due to being English, they decide to move to Tasmania and work on a farm growing barley and move on to making whisky there. WWII beckons Charlie back to France as a spy, while Violet is forced to continue the family business alone.

The relationship between Violet and Charlie was beautiful. I loved seeing the depth of love and understanding between them as father and daughter. I loved thinking about how brave they were being pioneers of whisky making in Tasmania and enjoyed further researching this.

Overall, I enjoyed this more than 'The Champagne War'. The entire middle of the book is set in Richmond, Tasmania and it was really nice to be able to read about a place I'm familiar with and imagine it almost 100 years ago.

It was an emotional and informative story about identity, love and sacrifice. I thoroughly enjoyed it, but felt the ending was wrapped up a little too quickly and would have preferred a little bit more from the ending.

Thank you to Penguin Random House Australia for providing me with this ARC through Netgalley in exchange for my honest review.
Profile Image for Cathy Jacobs.
61 reviews2 followers
Read
September 23, 2025
Violet Nash's story was beautiful and I loved it! No doubts about that, she was the main character in the story.

This books takes you through a series of stages of life through the eyes of Violet.
● Beginning with childhood
● The making of whiskey and champagne (which reminded me of my own Great Grandfather who use to brew whiskey)
● The unique geographical locations (the way they were described them had made me with I could visit these places, and see them for myself)

I had sad tears throughout this book while also having happy tears, it broke me completely just like Rebecca Yarros 'The Last Letter' and 'The Things We Leave Unfinished'. Books that remind me of the war stories that my Great Grandparents use to tell me about with the lollie jars on their tables (my favourite part of memories) to also the letters I would receive as well with the stories being told, these are where I have a soft spot and will always love remembering and seeing more ways into the Wars.

Would I recommend this book? Yes! Would I want to own a trophy version (special edition or signed would be even better)? Yes!

Thank you for giving me this opportunity to read this arc, I really did enjoy the story line.
Profile Image for Kimberly.
1,044 reviews40 followers
October 1, 2025
The Soldier’s Daughter by Fiona McIntosh. Storm Publishing—thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for my gifted ARC. I opened this book thinking I’d dip into a few chapters, and instead I wound up ignoring my to-do list, my laundry, and possibly my sanity because I absolutely refused to put it down. Historical fiction is my weakness, but Fiona McIntosh has this knack for taking the expected (war, family, love, sacrifice) and layering it with flavors so rich it’s like tasting a whisky you thought you knew, only to realize it has hidden notes of smoke, honey, and heartbreak. We start with Violet Nash, who I immediately rooted for, mostly because she doesn’t fit neatly into anyone’s expectations. Her father, Charlie, is a WWI sniper-turned-whisky-maker who carries trauma like it’s an accessory he can’t quite put down. He’s the kind of man who thinks starting over on the other side of the world will magically fix his shattered dreams. Spoiler alert: trauma packs itself neatly into your carry-on and always clears customs. Tasmania may be beautiful and fertile for barley, but it isn’t exactly a balm for the scars left by war. Violet grows up in this world of whisky, science, and silence, learning not just her father’s craft but also his tendency to keep secrets locked tighter than a distillery vault. The magic of Violet’s story is that she’s not content to be the dutiful daughter who inherits a business. No, she wants to change the game. In an era when women were told to pour whisky but not dare to craft it, Violet has the audacity (and brilliance) to step into the distilling world with her own ideas. She’s innovative, bold, and stubborn in ways that make her deeply relatable. Who among us hasn’t wanted to smash the glass ceiling—or in this case, the whisky cask—and leave our mark on something traditionally male-dominated? Violet is more than just a daughter clinging to her father’s coattails; she’s a pioneer, and I loved watching her fight for recognition in a space that wasn’t ready to welcome her. Meanwhile, Charlie can’t resist the gravitational pull of his past. When WWII erupts, he feels duty-bound to return to occupied France, not just because of unfinished business with the resistance but also because of Sophie, the woman who once held his heart in those Champagne caves. This dual narrative—Violet forging ahead in Tasmania while Charlie disappears into the shadowy, dangerous world of espionage—creates a rhythm that’s both heartbreaking and thrilling. The whisky distillery and the French vineyards become symbolic battlegrounds, places where legacy and memory ferment alongside courage and sacrifice. One of the book’s greatest strengths is how vividly McIntosh paints the settings. You can smell the earthy sweetness of barley in Tasmania, feel the damp chill of the Champagne caves, and hear the crack of tension as resistance fighters whisper plans in war-torn France. These aren’t just backdrops—they’re living, breathing elements of the story that make you feel transported. I’ve read enough historical fiction to know when an author skimps on atmosphere, and let me tell you, McIntosh does not skimp. She pours it generously, like a host who insists you have “just one more” dram. The emotional weight of the novel lies squarely on Violet’s shoulders, and she carries it beautifully. She’s grieving, raging, creating, and surviving all at once, and somehow she never becomes a caricature of “strong woman in history.” She feels real—messy, brilliant, and determined. There’s a line in the book that perfectly encapsulates her journey: “She inherited his gift. She carried his secrets. She’ll fight to claim his legacy.” It’s not just marketing copy—it’s the spine of the novel, and McIntosh never lets us forget that Violet is equal parts inheritor and innovator, burdened and free. What really elevates this book is how seamlessly it blends the personal with the political, the intimate with the epic. You’re reading about whisky-making techniques one minute, and the next you’re plunged into the tension of the French Resistance, and somehow it all works. It’s not just a story about war, or whisky, or family—it’s about resilience. About what we carry, what we inherit, and what we decide to build for ourselves. By the end, I wasn’t just invested in Violet’s success; I was cheering for her like she was a friend who’d finally proven everyone wrong. McIntosh has been called a master storyteller before, but this book cements it. She knows exactly how to balance lush, immersive detail with fast-moving plotlines. She gives us heartbreak and action, intimacy and suspense, without ever tipping too far in one direction. And she makes whisky-making—something I thought I understood—feel like a metaphor for life itself. Complex, patient, sometimes bitter, often sweet, but always worth savoring. If you’re a fan of historical fiction that doesn’t just replay history but reimagines it through the lens of ordinary people doing extraordinary things, The Soldier’s Daughter belongs on your shelf. Fans of Kristin Hannah, Rhys Bowen, and anyone who likes their novels equal parts grit and grace will find plenty to love here. I’m giving this book ★★★★★ without hesitation, because rating it lower would feel like committing the literary equivalent of mixing top-shelf whisky with diet cola, and honestly, I’d rather be arrested. #TheSoldiersDaughter #NetGalley #FionaMcIntosh #HistoricalFiction #BookReview #StormPublishing #ReadersOfInstagram #Bookstagram #WomensFiction #WWIIFiction #WhiskyAndWar #HistoricalReads
61 reviews1 follower
September 28, 2025
THE SOLDIERS DAUGHTER by Fiona McIntosh is published by Penguin Random House September 2025
Review by Lorraine Parker
The Soldier’s Daughter is an historical fiction, eloquent and intriguing. The setting from 1935 to WWII, spans from Scotland, to Australia, England and France and back again. McIntosh’s attention to detail and evocative descriptions of time and place transport the reader visually and emotionally. An added incentive, (or not) to read, is if you have read her previous best seller The Champagne Wars.
The prologue set in 1930, introduces 10 year old Violet Nash, in a school yard setting, immersed in a squabble. Violet’s strong character is portrayed in the headmistress’s office and especially when her quietly spoken father, Charlie Nash enters. Violets mother Ellen died 3 years ago and Violet always outspoken, declares that her behaviour has nothing to do with this. Violet so close to her father has watched him blend whiskey and wants nothing more than to follow in her father’s footsteps, even at this young age.
Chapter 1 opens in 1935. Violet, now 15 is working along-side her father in their struggling whiskey distillery (Scotland) Occasionally, Charlie talks reluctantly about his experience in WWI. Wounded behind enemy lines, he was hidden and cared for in a private vineyard in Epernay, France. Here was fortunate to learn about champagne production from one of the best, Sophie Delancré. His background knowledge as a chemist made him an understanding contributor. He left France with his heart broken but found love with Violet’s mother, (Ellen). Charlie continued his chemist skills to make and blend whisky and Violet has progressed in her blending skills.

In Scotland, the English were considered to be Sassenach. The Nash’s found it more and more difficult to survive. Violet (now 18), convinces her father to visit London, to her grandparents. In London Violet uses her own initiative. Through her father’s connections from his time in the Great War, she is able to sell enough whiskey to continue. At this time Australia was calling and welcoming new immigrants, with grants of land and assistance. Tasmania, beckoned with its weather which was very similar to Scotland’s. Charlie’s new dream was to grow malt barley and re-establish ‘Glen Corbie’ as a whiskey of distinction. They agree to a new start and adventure. Violet is now a talented blender and distiller in her own right. She wants to be the first female to change and refine the whisky industry.
However, when WWII breaks out Charlie becomes restless and returns to England to be of service. An unhappy but courageous, understanding Violet is left behind.
Violet is unaware that once again Charlie, with his skills is sent behind enemy lines. He finds himself in Epernay and once again Sophie Delancré a fifth generation champenoise, is thrust into his life.
Sophie now has a son Raphael. Charlie must face the regrets and ghosts of his youth. Trust has to be built and really is a fragile component in wartime France.
Violet’s story continues. Violet’s tenacity and talent in the male-dominated world of whisky distilling highlight the determination, strength and resilience of women navigating adversity. You must read to find out more.
A powerful and compelling read that lingered with me, long after the final page.
Profile Image for betweenthecoverswithdanielle Danielle Robinson.
43 reviews1 follower
November 13, 2025
The Soldier’s Daughter is a beautifully told, emotionally grounded historical novel that left me really invested in its characters, especially Violet Nash. Fiona McIntosh has a gift for writing stories that feel both sweeping and intimate, and this one definitely hits that sweet spot.

The novel follows Violet, daughter of WWI veteran Charlie Nash, as she grows up in the shadow of her father’s trauma. Charlie, still scarred by his time in the Champagne region of France, uproots their lives to Tasmania to start a whisky distillery — a dream that feels like a fresh start for him and, unexpectedly, a whole new identity for Violet. I loved how naturally Violet steps into the world of distilling. It never feels forced or gimmicky; it’s just who she is. Quietly capable, deeply observant, and far more talented than the people around her realise. Her journey feels real, grounded, and easy to cheer for.

McIntosh’s sense of place is one of the highlights here. The contrast between the wild beauty of Tasmania and the tension of wartime France is vivid without feeling overdone. You can practically smell the peat, feel the shift in seasons, and sense that low hum of anxiety that comes when the world edges toward conflict again. The historical backdrop is well-researched but never heavy-handed — just textured enough to pull you in.

Charlie’s storyline, especially his pull back to France as WWII looms, adds emotional weight without tipping into melodrama. I liked him as a character: flawed, hurting, full of pride and regret. And the father–daughter relationship at the heart of the book feels authentic. Not sentimental, not overly dramatic — just a steady, believable bond shaped by love, loss and unspoken understanding.

If I’m being honest, the pacing dips in a few places, and there were moments where I wanted a deeper look at some side characters. The story is strong, but a couple of threads felt like they could have been explored just a touch more. Still, none of that pulled me out of the book — it just kept this from being a full five stars for me.

Overall, The Soldier’s Daughter is an engaging, heartfelt read with a memorable heroine and a rich historical setting. It’s warm, cinematic, emotional in the right places, and perfect for anyone who loves character-driven historical fiction with a strong sense of place. I really enjoyed it, and Violet is a character who’ll stay with me for a while.
Profile Image for Meg Pearson.
464 reviews10 followers
September 22, 2025
The Soldier’s Daughter by Fiona McIntosh is a sweeping and emotional historical novel that transports readers from the whisky distilleries of Scotland to the vineyards of France and the rugged beauty of Tasmania. It is as much a story of craft and legacy as it is of love, loss, and resilience.

At its heart, this is a father–daughter story. Violet Nash grows up in the long shadow of her father Charlie—a WWI hero, brilliant chemist, and whisky distiller haunted by secrets of the Champagne caves and the woman he left behind. As Violet masters the alchemy of whisky-making, she becomes both Charlie’s pride and his vulnerability. When war once again calls him back to France and into the peril of the Resistance, Violet must summon her own strength and carve her own path, determined to honor and protect the legacy they built together.

McIntosh’s ability to weave meticulous historical research with deeply human storytelling shines here. The whisky-making details are fascinating, adding richness and authenticity without ever weighing down the narrative. Likewise, the depiction of wartime France—its vineyards, its dangers, and its quiet acts of resistance—is vivid and moving. The shifting settings across three countries never feel disjointed; instead, they underscore the global impact of war and the deeply personal choices made within it.

What resonated most for me was Violet herself. Strong-willed, innovative, and unwilling to settle for less than she deserves, she is a heroine who lingers long after the final page. Her devotion to her father, her courage in stepping into a male-dominated world, and her fierce independence make her both relatable and inspiring.

Fans of Kristin Hannah, Rhys Bowen, and Fiona McIntosh’s earlier The Champagne War will find much to love here. The Soldier’s Daughter is a heartfelt, immersive, and beautifully told novel about the bonds between fathers and daughters, the cost of sacrifice, and the power of legacy.

Highly recommended for readers of historical fiction who enjoy stories that balance emotional depth with meticulous detail.
Profile Image for Joan.
574 reviews
December 10, 2025
Another excellent historic fiction from Fiona McIntosh. A story based on the production of whisky, starting from Scotland then through to Tasmania and back to Scotland. Add to this a side interest in the making of champagne.

As a child Violet learned about the different aspects of making whisky while following her father Charlie around his small distillery in Scotland. As he had originally come from England his whisky was in competition with the better known ones made at the Scottish distilleries. His wife Ellen whom he adored had died earlier ,but he had always fondly remembered Sophie who had nursed him to health after being injured in Epernay in France during WWI.

He was unable to find contentment in Scotland and as Violet grew up it was evident she would be a champion distiller. She had no desire to excel at school and when Charles decided they should take a break from the distillery she suggested a move to Australia which was looking for new settlers.

They moved to Tasmania where they again started a distillery and seemed well settled. Violet was strong in her self belief and many man who were attracted to her beauty found it difficult to accept her character and she was not prepared to settle for any man who didn’t set her heart on fire.

WWII came and eventually Charlie offered his services to Britain and with his knowledge of the French regions, was accepted and trained as a spy. He promised Violet his work would be safe and on his return they would establish their brand of whisky and compete with those of Scotland. He found himself in France and eventually he once again saw Sophie, whose husband was imprisoned by the Germans. She was helped on her farm where she made champagne, by her son Raphael, her other son having been killed in action.

There is more sadness but eventually there is a happy ending.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 116 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.