Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Mates #3

Penmates

Rate this book
Jenna Davis doesn’t lose. Ever. As New York’s top family attorney, she’s built her reputation on winning the unwinnable. And she’s not about to let one impossible case ruin it.

That’s when Colton King walks back into her life. NHL superstar. Single dad. And the same guy who made her teenage years miserable. He needs help securing full custody of his daughter. The case is high-profile, career-defining… and far from simple. Colton has already taken his child from her neglectful mother, and Jenna finds herself facing a case she might not be able to win.

So she does the unthinkable: right there in court, Jenna claims she and Colton are married. A bold, strategic lie meant to sway the judge and save a case she can’t afford to lose. A marriage of convenience that should mean nothing… and solve everything. Except now they have to live it.

Between forced proximity, lingering resentment, and undeniable chemistry, Jenna is starting to realize the one man she can’t control… might also be the one she can’t resist.

374 pages, Kindle Edition

Published June 1, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Nova Banks

6 books200 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
56 (30%)
4 stars
84 (46%)
3 stars
35 (19%)
2 stars
6 (3%)
1 star
1 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 108 reviews
Profile Image for cat.
463 reviews260 followers
June 4, 2026
“Maybe love isn’t grand declarations or perfect timing. Maybe it’s this. A warm shoulder. Shared popcorn. Someone making space for you before you even realize you need it. Someone who understands you and is there for you no matter what.”


on repeat 𝄞 ࿐♬ 𓍢ִ🎧ྀི ᯓ ‎♪ˎˊ˗
“ᴜɴᴡʀɪᴛᴛᴇɴ” x ɴᴀᴛᴀꜱʜᴀ ʙᴇᴅɪɴɢꜰɪᴇʟᴅ
0:46 ─♥───────── 4:19


WOOOO. This one surprised me in the best way.
First of all, can we talk about that cover? I was completely obsessed with the artwork and desperately hoping the story would live up to it. Thankfully it absolutely did 😌

What I wasn’t expecting was how much Jenna’s story would get to me. Watching the way she moved through life constantly trying to keep everyone happy was honestly heartbreaking. The people-pleasing tendencies she carried from such a young age explained so much, and every time Matthew showed up on page I wanted to personally escort that man out of her life. The frustration was REAL😭😭

One thing I really loved was that underneath the romance this was a story about learning to choose yourself. Jenna had spent so long shrinking herself, making excuses for people, and convincing herself she had to earn kindness. Watching her slowly break those patterns and reclaim her happiness felt incredibly satisfying. 🥺💖💖

And Colton? My heart hurt for him too. Seeing how fiercely protective he was of his daughter made so much of his character click for me. I’m not a parent, but I know what it’s like to want to protect someone you love, and some of those moments genuinely made me so emotional.🥹🥹

I do wish the romance had been given a little more room to breathe. Once they started spending time together, the shift felt very fast for me. I adored how supportive Colton was, but I wanted more buildup before the feelings and especially before the spicy scenes. A lot of those moments felt like they appeared out of nowhere when I was still waiting for the tension to simmer a little longer.

And then THAT unexpected moment near the end??? My jaw literally dropped because of how random it felt. I do think it could have benefited from more buildup and lengthened a bit, but at the same time it was sweet enough that I still finished the book smiling.

Overall this was deeper, more emotional, and more meaningful than I expected going in. It gave me a romance to root for, but it also gave me a heroine learning that her worth isn’t tied to what she can do for other people... and honestly, that ended up being my favorite part of the entire book 🫶🏼💖

(I will say if you're expecting a sports story, hockey definitely takes a back burner in this one. It's not really a huge part of the plot)

favorite quotes ↓

"No wonder cat ladies exist—twenty cats beat a clueless man any day."

“Sometimes the hardest person to be honest with is yourself.”

"Words have no power unless you give them space in your head.”

"Thirty-two freckles on her face. Yes, I counted them. All of them whenever I got lost in her beauty."

"They called him dangerous.
But Colton King might be my safe space."


things to know about the book ↓

🏒 single dad
🏒 hockey player x lawyer
🏒 her high school bully
🏒 enemies → lovers
🏒 marriage of convenience
🏒 dual POV
🏒 forced proximity
🏒 custody battle
🏒 learning to choose yourself

spice rating: 🌶️🌶️🌶️
→ chapters: 22, 24, 28, 31, 33,
swearing: yes

Thank you Love Notes PR, publisher & author for this arc in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

─────────
・❥・⁀➷ 💌🩷 𝕡𝕣𝕖-𝕣𝕖𝕒𝕕

trying so hard to catch up on arcs 😭🫠😔
SO EXCITED FOR THIS ONE THO!!
Profile Image for S {Semi-Hiatus} .
1,320 reviews1,782 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
May 20, 2026
4.5 out of 5 stars!

I still remember getting the first book in the Mates series by Nova Banks almost 2 years ago and instantly falling in love with it, so I was beyond excited to finally read Penmates and somehow it still exceeded my expectations.

I’ve been stuck in the worst reading slump for so long, but this book completely pulled me out of it. I finished it within a day because I genuinely could not stop reading. The tropes were exactly my thing: childhood history, enemies to strangers to teaming up to more , all the tension, the characters, plus the little one that kept me completely invested from start to finish.

I absolutely loved Jenna and Colton and the way they slowly grew on each other throughout the story. And seeing the main characters from the previous book have small roles in this one honestly made my day — I loved getting to read about them again.

Even though I adored book 1, I somehow fell just as hard for this one. And I genuinely can’t believe that even though it’s been over a week since I finished it, this book is still stuck in my head 24/7. Penmates reminded me why I love reading so much in the first place.

______________________
I still remember so vividly receiving the first book in the ‘Mates’ series by Nova Banks almost 2 years ago — I was absolutely over the moon. I immediately started reading it and completely fell in love with it.

And even though I still haven’t read book 2 yet 🫣, I’m beyond excited for book 3, ‘Penmates’. I can’t wait to dive into it and love it just as much as I loved the first book… if not even more. 👀
Profile Image for Christy.
131 reviews2 followers
June 1, 2026
What to expect:
💍 Marriage of Convenience
🥰 Enemies to Lovers
👀 Single Dad
⛅️ Grumpy x Sunshine
🔥 Slow Burn

Chemistry & banter is great! But I do feel like it was better in the beginning aka when they aren’t actually together. I kinda lost interest when they were together. And a lot of the chaos that happens in the last bit of the book felt unnecessary.
I do still think this is a cute read. I think it’s a great reminder for people who have or are stuck in toxic relationships that there is always a better alternative to staying. That you should have the confidence to live your life how you want to. And if people don’t fit that, then it’s okay to leave.
Profile Image for Alva Schwung.
718 reviews16 followers
May 19, 2026
✨✨ ARC review✨✨ well my ovaries are actually in pain?? because if my man doesn’t fight for his child like this then I simply do not want him 😭

absolutely incredible book in the form of a true daddy in every possible sense of the word. and EXCUSE ME but Jenna??? boss ass bitch energy. an actual power woman. I love strong women who refuse to back down. loved her nickname. loved the conversation between Jenna and Colton on the couch about why you don’t leave. how hard it is to even know what the right thing is. they’re just two broken souls finding each other and growing together through this shared love for Livy. INSANE😭🫶

and honestly you can never complain about a little ice hockey. I think I might actually be a hockey fan now?? or at the very least a fan of this book!!!! and now I obviously have to read the entire series because I loved every single character we got to meet.

also 😭😭 the way I SCREAMED at:

“I will never do anything you don’t want me to, Solnyshko… so you have to give me permission to eat you like the hungry dog I am…”

NO no no PLEASEEEEE I’m begging.

“Say it, Solnyshko. Tell me to eat you. Please do. Please let me, I beg you.”

dead and fucking deceased. buried. gone. ⚰️

and the way he handled his daughter?? no my heart. my uterus. I cannot deal with this. thank you very much.

incredible. all of it. recommend recommend recommend 🫡
Profile Image for Kaylyn Atkinson.
62 reviews1 follower
June 9, 2026
Thank you Love Notes PR for a chance to read this early.
This book wasn’t inherently bad. I just was left feeling like there was something missing. I felt their connection was more lust than love and it kinda took me out of the story. I really like the premise of the story but the execution needed a little more work.
Profile Image for ashlee ❤.
2,489 reviews139 followers
May 19, 2026
Jenna + Colton

-hockey romance
-enemies to lovers
-single dad
-lawyer x hockey star
-marriage of convenience
-slow burn

yall i got this & IMMEDIATELY dove in & then was so engrossed in it that i didn’t come up for air til i finished!! both colton & jennas past relationships were so traumatic i love that they found their way to each other with livy🥹🥹🥹
Profile Image for Shana .
492 reviews81 followers
June 3, 2026
3.5⭐️ | 3🌶
I was conflicted at the start of this one honestly. It was messy but at times sweet. Thank you to love notes pr for the arc
Profile Image for Amber is Always Reading.
653 reviews45 followers
May 21, 2026
This story was such a heartwarming and inspiring story of a father who will stop at nothing to protect his child,even if that results in his losing his career,fame, and reputation.
The single mindedness and drive that leads Colton to fight for his daughter,is the exact same approach he uses to devote himself to making Jenna’s life better. More fulfilling,and full of love and laughter.
This is the third book I’ve read and enjoyed in this series,and I look forward to revisiting these characters,and the fast-paced hockey filled world they live in.
Profile Image for Daniela Hernandez.
147 reviews4 followers
Review of advance copy
May 29, 2026
Penmates by Nova Banks 4⭐️ | 3.5 🌶️
Thanks to Love Notes PR and the author for the ARC!
• Marriage of convenience.
• Enemies to lovers.
• Single dad.
• Grumpy x Sunshine.
• Slow Burn.

“There isn’t a single woman on this planet I’d choose over her.”

Give me a single dad and I’ll read it VERY. SINGLE. TIME. Add a marriage of convenience and oh my, SOLD! I have to admit I haven’t read the two previous books, and I was a bit worried about getting into this one, but I didn’t have any issues.

Let’s talk about Colton, because that MAN. The love, the dedication he has for that little girl. The custody situation with his ex (who was a flipping bitch btw) was so complicated, and he was willing to go to whatever end to fix it. It didn’t matter if he had to risk his career, his reputation, NOTHING, His main concern was Livvy. Sometimes I’m a bit worried when in books, the relationship between the single dad and his ex or ONS, or whatever, is not always good, but I have to say, Nova really showed us a very realistic situation, if I can call like that. We know for a fact that in real life, kids go through these kind of situations, either with the mom or the dad. And it’s so annoying to think that sometimes they get away with it, because they have some influence, or relations that play in their favor, and the ones that end up suffering, are always the kids. But Colton said, NO FUCKING WAY, I’m getting my daughter away from you, you selfish rat!

Enters Jenna, my sassy legal queen! Jenna is such a badass, and I love how she managed at work and how it was proved she was one of the best, and that was the reason why Colton wanted. But as much as I was cheering for her because she was such a boss, I was dying for her to get out of that bloody relationship and kick out his LOSER boyfriend. But, as desperate as I was, I understood, and I kind of relate to her. Being in a toxic relationship is one of the worst things, and getting away from one is easier said than done. The mental exhaustion from it, the feeling that you’re never going to find something better, or what is worse, the feeling that we DON’T deserve better, is something terrible.

I was happy to know more about Colton and Jenna relationship, because yes, I was bit worried about the whole bullying situation, but I feel like they were both complicated and flawed characters during those years. During the book, and the more they work together we can see that slow burn, but THE CHEMISTRY WAS THERE! AND THE SPICE, GOD, MY OVARIES WERE GONE, GONE!
The last chapters of the book got me sweating and I felt like I wanted to get into the book, and moped the floor with Colton’s ex and her stupid lawyer, they were HORRIBLE, but that means that they worked, Nova gave us some goooood drama.

And this is where it comes the part why I didn’t give 5 stars. I loved the book, but I felt like the last chapters, were too rushed. After Nova wakes up, we jumped right to the epilogue. I would had love to see a bit more about Jenna’s recovery, and a much needed conversation between her and Colton. So I feel like we were needing maybe 2 or maybe 3 more chapters.

In general, Penmates was a lovely book, and it goes to my list of single dad romances. I’m definitely gonna be reading the previous two books.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Elena.
51 reviews
June 8, 2026
4⭐2,5🌶️

This book was such a good time guys! I loved how it focused more on the battle Colton and Jenna fought to regain control of their lives and get full costudy of Coltons daughter. I was pleasantly surprised to find that the plot moved slower than most, allowing the relationships and intimacy to build and build until the chemistry finally had them snap . I mean we didn't even get a spicy scene until like 70% if I remember correctly. What a breath of fresh air! 💕

Colton is an amazing character and father, the whole time I was rooting for him in all aspects. His daughter Livy broke my heart so much, it really goes to show how easy it is to traumatise a small child and a short amount of time. How easy she opened up and flourished in the company of Jenna and her father. I have a soft spot for these types of plot lines🥺

Jenna was also a badass and fierce lawyer and was actually so funny, I couldn't stop laughing at her inner monologue 😅🫣 She has such a soft heart but unfortunately she's a massive people pleaser. I'm glad she had the courage to call Colton when she needed him to help her! She finally got the chance to realise that love doesn't have to be transactional, and you don't have to keep proving yourself to receive it. It shouldn't be one sided.

Now on to the things I didn't particularly like.
Firstly, the original plot started off with Jenna and her abusive boyfriend of 7 years, who Colton forcibly removed from her apartment and ultimately her life. I kept waiting for him to come back at some point throughout the book, but he never did. I think it went against his character and kinda made his role in the book seem insignificant and just there for the jumpstart of the book.

Second, i didn't particularly like the dialogue in their first spicy scene. I think it felt forced and a little awkward so it took away from the scene. Besides that, I really enjoyed their intimate scenes.

Lastly, and *spoiler*, the drama at the end was a little unnecessary and didn't really make sense. It was so opposite to the other 92% of the book that it felt like it was done just for there to be a 3rd act breakup of sort so it could be followed by the accident and subsequently to their reconciliation. I think that if the author wanted to keep this "plot twist" it should have been followed by another 30-40 pages of Colton grovelling and regaining Jenna's trust. In the way it was written, it made me lose a bit of respect for both characters, because Colton changing up his act twice in 2 chapters had his behaviour look performative and lacking of substance and depth. And the fact that Jenna forgave him in literally 1 second also had me lose respect for the person she had managed to become.

For that, I will pretend that this part of the book didn't happen, and only keep the plot twist about his ex wife🤣 other than those things, I loved the book and definitely recommend it !!
✨💕🏒

*Thank you to the author and LoveNotes PR for this ARC*
Profile Image for Manuella.
469 reviews6 followers
June 4, 2026
Actual rating: 3.5/5
Thank you to Love Notes PR and Nova Banks for the opportunity to read this book early in exchange for an honest review!

This is my first book by Nova Banks – yes, I did the unthinkable and read the third book in a series first – but when I read the Love Notes' blurb for this one I was absolutely intrigued by this story and knew I had to read it. There is something about a single dad and a marriage of convenience that always pull me in – and a story with both? Basically made for me!

I was not a huge fan of the fact Colton used to bully Jenna in school and how hostile they were towards one another in the beginning, especially her. Considering she is now an adult, it felt a bit petty and childish – but honestly perhaps I should not be judging because I am not sure I would not do the same. I was thrilled when his kid managed to get her to change her mind, however. Kids often have the power to melt us.

I also absolutely loathed her boyfriend – or should I say the piece of garbage who yells at her, denigrates her and treats her like a maid (or, honestly, worse than that)? In full disclosure, I almost DNF'ed this book because of him. There was a lot of him and the verbal abuse was not my cup of tea. But I was intrigued enough about the custody battle and Colton to keep on reading – because yes, Colton was my favorite main character in this book.

Colton King is like the perfect blend of Ilya Rozanov and Cade Eaton, a grumpy and reserved hockey player with a very complicated background story who will stop at nothing to take care of his daughter. Jenna is more complicated, she holds grudges and is afraid of losing cases, relationships and admitting she is wrong. She is a survivor, but she is stubborn and guarded too. Together, they make an interesting duo, but not as interesting as I expected, unfortunately.

That is not to say I didn't have a good time with this book, I did! I loved our characters' development, their found family and how the plot unfolded. The side characters were also a gem. However, I felt as though Colton and Jenna's relationship was lacking something. Perhaps it was chemistry or more development, but it just did not quite as hard as I expected. Not to mention, the ending felt very rushed and I would have liked it to be better explored.

Overall it was a good time and it did make me intrigued enough to read the rest of the series.
Profile Image for Daphne.
314 reviews1 follower
June 8, 2026
Penmates had me hooked from the very first chapter, and by the end, I was completely in my feelings. Jenna and Colton's story was packed with tension, emotion, and some of my favorite romance tropes.

Jenna was such a standout character for me. I loved seeing a heroine who knew her worth and refused to let anyone intimidate her. Watching her absolutely own the courtroom and stand her ground made me admire her so much. She was strong without being perfect, and I found myself rooting for her every step of the way.

Colton completely stole my heart. As a single dad, he already had my attention, but seeing how hard and how fast he fell for Jenna made me love him even more. The marriage of convenience and forced proximity setup created so much delicious tension between them, especially with their complicated history. Their childhood connection wasn't exactly sunshine and rainbows, and the remnants of that past added another layer to their relationship that made everything feel more meaningful.

One thing Nova Banks consistently excels at is writing emotional scenes, and this book was no exception. There were moments that genuinely broke my heart. The story touches on some heavier topics, but I felt they were handled thoughtfully and added depth to both the characters and their journey.

My favorite part, though, was seeing the softer side of Colton that only Jenna seemed able to bring out. Their relationship growth felt authentic, and the family moments with Livy absolutely melted my heart. I adored their dynamic and loved watching them become a family.

The supporting cast was fantastic too. I always love when side characters enhance the story instead of distracting from it, and that was definitely the case here. That being said, Colton's ex-wife and her lawyer tested my patience every single time they appeared on page. I don't think I've rolled my eyes that much while reading in quite a while!

Overall, Penmates delivered everything I wanted: chemistry, angst, emotional depth, family feels, and a romance that felt worth every hurdle these characters faced. If you're a fan of sports romance, single dads, marriage of convenience, and heroes who fall first, this book deserves a spot on your TBR.
Profile Image for Shay Nicole.
205 reviews6 followers
May 21, 2026
Finally getting Colton and Jenna’s book after seeing them teased since book one was everything. Nova Banks does a great job using moments from past books to tie the storylines together.

Getting to learn the history between these two characters was great and getting both perspective gives a better understanding to their dynamic. I think this helps to make the “bully” aspect of their story a bit more understandable as well.

Watching their relationship unfold was really fun to see. The fact that even though everything moves so quickly with them because of the marriage in order to get Colton his daughter, the way it plays out is so entertaining. Banks does a great job at softening Jenna’s when it comes to Colton by using his daughter. The way that that little girl is both their sole focus throughout the book was so important to their story. It also adds depth to both their characters. Especially when we see Jenna’s internal thoughts after her past relationship and what that led to.

I also loved seeing Jenna become more open and vulnerable not only with Colton but with his friends as well. Even though they were in a marriage of convenience, they welcomed her in with open arms. I also liked how everyone was like “yeah, this isn’t going to be fake for long”, meanwhile both of them are like ‘pft, yeah it will’.

Colton’s character has been through so much and getting to learn more about him was amazing. The depth and complexity of him was written very well. Also his love for his little girl had me melting. His daughter is so important to him and I love how he will literally do anything for her. She stole so many scenes and had me laughing out loud constantly. This little family was so cute and watching them develop their own unit was precious.

Colton’s ex…and her lawyer…I was so angry every time they appeared on the page. The fact that there are actually people like this makes me so…I have no words. Banks did a great job creating some incredibly dislikable characters here.

Overall, Colton and Jenna’s story had so many layers woven throughout it, that helped create their dynamic and make it what it was. Seeing their vulnerability with each other and learning that love is sometimes unexpected.
Profile Image for Aja Soussi.
37 reviews
Review of advance copy
May 21, 2026
🧸🥀Penmates 𝒜ℛ𝒞 ℛℯ𝓋𝒾ℯ𝓌 🧸🥀

ℛ𝒶𝓉𝒾𝓃𝑔:
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5⭐️
𝒮𝓅𝒾𝒸ℯ ℛ𝒶𝓉𝒾𝓃𝑔
🌶️🌶️🌶️/5🌶️
Book 3 of the mates series🧸
————————
✨𝒯ℛ𝒪𝒫ℰ𝒮✨
🩷“ Fuck It” moment
🤍Single dad
🩷Marriage of Convience
🤍Lawyer X Hockey player
🩷He falls first
🤍Slowburn
🩷Dual pov
🤍Hopelessly inlove
🩷𝐏𝐫𝐨𝐭𝐞𝐜𝐭𝐢𝐯𝐞 𝐃𝐚𝐝𝐝𝐲
🤍𝐒𝐡𝐦𝐞𝐱𝐲 𝐚𝐧𝐠𝐫𝐲 𝐭𝐢𝐦𝐞
🩷Angry confession

ℳ𝓎 𝒯𝒽ℴ𝓊𝑔𝒽𝓉𝓈:

Wow. Yeah okay. Give me a minute thank you.
I just need a little minute🥲😭.
Imma say this once. If my future man does not fight for our daughter or me like colton then i simply do want that man😂😂, keep him away.

Now… im a 19yr old girl who dont know id she wants kids yet. But after this book? I wants a kid really badly, because oml how Livy got my heart. She’s the sweetest and cutest kid possible. She for sure got her sarcasm from me, trust😌. But no, all honestly. This book was amazing, i felt stressed as hell doin the stressed moments, i cried at the sad moments. I laughed at the good moments. I did every emotion possible. I feel so bad for both of them. Poor Colton, poor jenna💔. Fuck my heart died for Livy💔. ALSO THE RUSSIAN NICKNAME TO JENNA? I love it so much oml🥹🧸☀️.

And the annoyed confession, followed by a “ fuck it” moment. ( use ur imagination folks🤭). Holy shi, Nova. I love that shit🌶️. ALSO HE KNOWS THE COUNT OF FRECKLES ON HER FACE? MIND U GUYS. THEY WERE ENEMKES SO BADLY THEN. HE NOTICED IT FAST. Ugh. Colton ily🩷🌶️
I was DEEP into this, like deep. Its as if i never took a 1-2 yr break. Gosh. The chemistry, the betrayal Nova let me go trough. The ending. The hopeless love story, the “ i wanna hate u but i cant” moments. Gosh. Everything.
Love how we still gets visits from the main characters from Rinkmates & playmates ( go buy them hello, i mentioned them on purpose)😌😌😌.

I could talk abt this for hours and days. Btw i dont forgive u for yk what yet🥲💔.
@authornovabanks im ready for the next book, thank u🩷💋

✨PRE-ORDER NOW!!✨
❗️𝖱𝖤𝖫𝖤𝖠𝖲𝖤 𝖣𝖠𝖸 june 1st!!!!❗️
Profile Image for Ashy Khaira.
576 reviews51 followers
June 13, 2026
This book had me hooked from the very beginning and kept my attention all the way through. What initially drew me in was the premise, but what made me stay was the emotional depth behind the story and the way the characters' pasts continued to influence their present.

One of my favourite aspects of the book was how it explored the lasting impact of high school bullying and the regret that can follow people into adulthood. Watching the characters reconnect years later added an extra layer of complexity to their relationship, and I appreciated that the story didn't simply brush aside the hurt that had been caused in the past.

The lawyer storyline was another standout for me. Seeing a woman with a perfect win record initially refuse a case because of who the client was, only to be swayed by the circumstances surrounding a young child, genuinely tugged at my heart. It added an emotional element that made the story feel even more meaningful and showed a softer side to a character who initially appeared unshakable.

I also found the FMC's journey incredibly powerful. Watching everything she endured and seeing how long she put the needs of others before her own was heartbreaking at times. The moment a particular betrayal finally pushed her to choose herself and her own happiness felt both devastating and empowering. It was a reminder of how many women find themselves trapped in similar situations and how difficult it can be to finally put themselves first.

The fake marriage trope was surprisingly refreshing here as well. It is a trope that can sometimes feel repetitive or predictable, but I thought it was handled well in this story. The progression felt natural, and I found myself genuinely invested in watching the relationship evolve from something arranged into something real.

Overall, this was an emotional and engaging read that balanced romance, personal growth, and second chances in a way that kept me turning the pages.
Profile Image for Jerrika Romero.
78 reviews1 follower
June 3, 2026
I really enjoyed Pennmates by Nova Banks. I had been looking forward to Colton’s story since he first appeared—there was always something broody, mysterious, and undeniably compelling about him that made me want to know more.

After the events teased in Playmates, where we get a glimpse of Colton’s difficult custody situation and his strained relationship with his ex-wife, I was completely hooked and ready for his full story. In Pennmates, we meet Jenna, a lawyer who is stuck in an unhealthy relationship while taking on Colton’s custody case involving his neglectful ex-wife and his daughter.

As Jenna becomes more involved in the case, we learn she and Colton share history dating back to high school, and their connection isn’t exactly simple. Despite that, Jenna remains reluctantly takes his case and is committed to helping him and his daughter Livvy navigate a very painful situation. Along the way, Jenna begins to recognize her own worth and steps away from her toxic relationship, with Colton quietly supporting her growth just as she supports him and his daughter’s healing.

Their romance is a slow burn, even the heat isn't, but it’s emotionally rich and satisfying. Nova Banks does such a great job of writing characters who feel real—people who are self-aware, flawed, and clear about what they want. The dialogue feels natural, and the emotional pacing makes everything land so well.

This book is a strong addition to the series, which continues to deliver twisty, engaging storylines with characters you genuinely care about. I also loved catching up with familiar faces from previous books, which made the world feel even more connected.

Overall, Pennmates was an engaging, emotional and sexy read that’s hard to put down. You’ll be rooting for Jenna, Colton, and Livvg from beginning to end.
Profile Image for Sara-Catalina.
98 reviews
June 7, 2026
4/5

I have to say that I do not regret applying to get an eARC of this book. I loved this book, I loved Colton, regardless of my reluctance of reading sports romance. I looked past it, because papa bear Colton melted my heart.

Gimme a single dad romance and marriage of convenience on top of it and I will have the time of my life. Nova wrote Colton and the entire separation from his ex so realistically written that I had no complaints. He really focused on the wellbeing of his daughter, so in my eyes, he really went above and beyond to redeem himself. The man yearned and loved Jenna, so, in my eyes, what bullying? They were kids and they were different people too...

Now, Jenna is the character that broke my heart and put it back together. She's an absolute badass and she was a queen at work, so seeing her go through so much for that bloody relationship made me maaad. Her boyfriend was a toxic mf and I felt like their entire interaction was a ragebait. I could literally feel her mental exhaustion and I could almost taste her thoughts too, she felt like she didn't deserve any better. But rest assured, Colton loved her the way she deserved to be loved from the very beginning, so hear me cheering for them from the sidelines.

Their chemistry was off the charts and the spice was just hot, hot, hot. The heat was ramping up and I was giggling and kicking my legs like a schoolgirl.

The ending felt a bit rushed and Nova could have added two more chapters to develop the ending more, but I'm not complaining, she really served drama through Colton's bitchy and horrible ex, so I overlooked the sudden and abrupt ending.

All in all, I enjoyed this book as everyone can see from my rating. I definitely recommend this story. A huge thank you to Nova Banks and Love Notes PR for sending me this ARC.
Profile Image for yue.
239 reviews4 followers
June 8, 2026

Penmates is an absolute powerhouse of a contemporary sports romance. Nova Banks perfectly balances the fast-paced, high-pressure world of professional hockey with the intense, calculated environment of family law, giving readers a brilliant, high-angst story that is completely impossible to put down. It delivers exactly what hockey romance fans crave: blistering chemistry, a protective single dad, and a marriage-of-convenience trope executed with enough emotional weight to keep the pages turning.

Jenna Davis is an absolute standout protagonist for me. She was fiercely ambitious, highly professional, and easily one of my favorite female characters. The narrative doesn't waste any time establishing her deep, complicated history with NHL superstar Colton King, and the tension between them is immediate and palpable from the very first page they appeared together. Their sharp, competitive banter gives the dialogue incredible energy, making their transition from initial resentment to reluctant attraction feel entirely earned. Beyond the romance, Colton's unwavering devotion to his daughter and the high-stakes custody battle give the story profound emotional weight and a real sense of urgency.

While the story relies on a rapid succession of familiar romance tropes and requires a pretty significant suspension of disbelief regarding some of the legal ethics and courtroom drama, the execution is sharp, fresh, and addictive that I was completely hooked. It works beautifully as a standalone, features an incredibly strong slow-burn progression, and proves that Nova Banks knows exactly what her readers want.

For the full review : pagesofyue.com!

Many thanks to Nova Banks and LoveNotesPR for allowing me advance access to this book. I’m leaving this review voluntarily, and all thoughts are my honest reaction to the story.
Profile Image for Tanya.
321 reviews29 followers
June 1, 2026
Penmates was one of those books that completely won me over with the emotional side of the story just as much as the romance. 🥹🏒
Colton is the kind of MMC that immediately pulls at your heart. Beneath the hockey fame and reputation drama, everything he does comes back to one thing: protecting his daughter. The custody battle storyline added so much emotional weight, and honestly? Watching him put his entire life on the line for Livy made him impossible not to love.
And Livy absolutely stole every scene she was in. She felt like an actual six-year-old — funny, emotional, curious, chaotic in the cutest way — and her relationship with Jenna ended up being one of my favorite parts of the whole book. There’s just something about seeing someone slowly fall in love with both the parent and the child that gets me every time.
Jenna took a little longer for me to fully connect with, but once she stepped away from the toxic relationship she’d been stuck in, I really started rooting for her. I loved seeing her slowly regain confidence and stop shrinking herself for other people.
The chemistry between Jenna and Colton definitely delivered too 👀 The tension, the forced proximity, the emotional vulnerability mixed with the spice… it worked so well together. Their relationship develops in a way that feels messy at first but becomes genuinely sweet underneath all the chaos.
You definitely have to suspend disbelief a little with parts of the plot, but honestly? I didn’t even care because the emotional moments carried the story for me.
If you love:
🏒 Hockey romance
🤍 Single dad MMC
🏒 Marriage of convenience
🤍 Forced proximity
🏒 Protective hero energy
🤍 Emotional family dynamics
🏒 Hate to love vibes
…this one is worth picking up.
1,254 reviews11 followers
June 2, 2026
This book took me on such an intense entirely rollercoaster. I went through every single emotion known to mankind, and maybe a few more that I just discovered. I was shattered, put back together, broken again, then finally repaired in such a way I felt stronger. Jenna is an absolute beast of a character. She is truly a force to be reckoned with in the courtroom. But in her home is a different story. Honestly that poor excuse of man Matthew can go get bent. He’s the worst. Bye boy. The way he treated her angered me to no end. Colton is such an endearing character. My heart broke for him and everything he went through. He’s a dedicated father and a protector for all the people in his circle. And that extends to Jenna pretty early on. Their dynamic had me in stitches. It was so obvious that there was chemistry and deeper connection between Colton and Jenna but they refused to acknowledge it. The tension there was absolutely delicious though. These two truly support each other and are willing to make sacrifices for each other, and most importantly for Livy. This relationship was intense and so beautiful. There is vulnerability and heat and protection and sacrifice and support and devotion. Everything about them was swoon worthy and pulled on my heartstrings. The chemistry pulls you in, but it’s the deep and genuine connection they have that kept me invested. This book is layered with desire and devotion as well as friction and hurt. I absolutely could not out this book down until I knew what would happen for Colton and Jenna’s relationship and with Livy’s situation. I refused to not know she would be okay. And that ending gave me the resolution I needed along with everything I wanted.
Profile Image for Midnights Bookclub.
181 reviews
June 8, 2026
Penmates Review 📝⚖️

I received an ARC for this book, so I want to thank Nova Banks and Love Notes PR for sending me this amazing book!

If I had to take a few days to read the previous book from this series, with this one, it was the opposite. I devoured this book in one seating.

Here we have Colton, a Russian hockey player that kidnaped his own daughter because his ex-wife was neglecting her.

And Jenna, the badass lawyer that was bullied by Colton in High School, but had him begging her to take his case because she is the best in what she does.

Having to work together was not easy, for Jenna more than Colton, she didn’t forgot the things he has said and done to her. Colton wanted to fit in, so even not understanding the language, he was there while she was bullied, so now, having to earn her trust and her sympathy was not easy.

A few late nights woking together, a cheating and a shitty ex from both sides and a fake relationship later, this two are so attracted to each other, that we can feel the tension between them through the pages.

Jenna is not called the Iron Lady just in case, she really is the best family lawyer in NYC, she sees the bigger picture and she will do the impossible to win her cases.

Colton is a soft giant, he will do anything and everything for his daughter, he just wants her to be safe, and in the middle of a nasty custody battle, he finds himself falling for his lawyer.

This book showed me to never let until tomorrow the things we can say and do today! I fell in love with this two and Livy, though I will say I really need a extra chapter for them in the future with the tons of kids they wanted to have! I absolutely will give this a 5 ⭐️ review 📝⚖️
Profile Image for Becky.
361 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
May 25, 2026
I love a single dad, marraiage of convenience, hockey story.

I enjoyed reading Jenna and Colton’s story once they got to really interact with her. One thing I didn’t love was when he called her an F’N B, in his POV/inner monologue. Luckily this didn’t last long though.

You do have to suspend reality a little but for this story, as I think some of it is unrealistic. However, that’s the point of reading fiction - to lose yourself in a book and take yourself out of reality.

Things I loved:

Colton wanting to do anything for his daughter. This felt very realistic as with custody the mom is usually
Always chosen. I loved this take on this and how he would literally do anything for his daughter and to keep her safe. I also loved the dynamic he had with her.

Livy was written like an actual 6 year old. She wasn’t written to speak like a baby - but she also didn’t speak like she was 12. Her dynamic with Jenna was everything.

Jenna and Livy were precious. This is one of my favorite things about single parent romances is watching the character fall in love with the kid.

Jenna - She was way more likable once she was away from her ex. For such strong character she was definitely a doormat in her personal relationships outside of work.

Jenna and Colton - I really liked they’re dynamic and how their relationship went from hate (she hates him) to love. The spice was 🥵.

Read if you like -
Past bully
Hate to love
Single parent
Marriage is convenience

Check your trigger warnings
Child endangerment not by main characters
Verbal and emotional abuse (not by main characters)

295 reviews
June 5, 2026
We had already gotten a glimpse of Colton and Jenna's dynamic in the last book, and i couldn't wait to find out what their story was. I was really happy to learn more about them, because they have such an interesting story. They go way back, to their high school days, were Colton was kind of a douchebag and was also Jenna's bully. Now, his faith is in her hands.

Their banter is so good, especially when Jenna is in her lawyer mode. I was so glad when she finally left her terrible boyfriend. It made her so much stronger, and I liked how it made her see how much better Colton is, even if they had a rocky start.

And when they do start their relationship, it's not under the best circumstances. It had me pulling out hairs, the way Colton would misspeak and totally say the wrong thing. He really isn't good with his words. But he makes up for it with his actions, especially with how he handles his daughter. She is the sweetest and absolutely deserved him as her father. She's also a little meddler and I think she made sure that Colton made his move on Jenna, even if he didn't know she had planned it.

Colton has a very difficult background, and I could understand why he was such a jerk in the past. I would also have trouble moving to a country where I didn't understand the language, especially at that age. It's so easy to get bullied for a variety of reasons and if you bully first, you can't get bullied yourself. Not that I condone bullying, but I get where he was coming from. I liked how he took responsibility for it and apologized. He really saw the error of his ways.

Thank you Nova Banks and LoveNotes PR for the e-ARC. All thoughts are my own.
Profile Image for Emmi (bookish_redpanda).
993 reviews48 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
May 27, 2026
Format: 📱 eBook 📱 (ARC)
Check CWs before reading

Really enjoyed coming back to Banks' world with Jenna and Colton - and I love that we still get to see characters from the previous two books in the series.

My heart broke in this one, for Jenna and the situation she's in, and for Livy and all she's been going through. You really feel the range of emotions with this one, really connecting with the characters on so many levels - one of the many reasons I enjoy Banks' writing so much.

I loved the enemies-to-lovers aspect of the beginning of Jenna and Colton's relationship, but I do love when the truth about it all starts to come out as we learn more of Colton and his past. It could not have been easy, and the poor guy just wanted to fit in at a brand-new school, in a new country, with a language he did not understand in the slightest.

What I also loved about this one is that one of the major plot points actually happens quite late compared to other stories featuring that trope - and it definitely works to the book's advantage. You learn to really fall for and understand the characters, and that this decision, whilst rushed and in the moment for the characters, has been so carefully plotted out by the author that it works perfectly in the moment. I genuinely think if the timeline for that moment had been quicker, it wouldn't have had such an impact on not only the story, but on the readers, too.

I absolutely ADORE Livy, especially her interactions with Jenna once she warms up to her. Such a sweet little girl, and I hope if Banks continues to add to this series, we see her (and Colton and Jenna) appear in future books.

I also have to mention that I am an absolute SUCKER for Russian pet names, so applause to Banks for adding that in, too.

Loved this one, and so excited to see where Banks' writing takes her next!

Thank you to the author for the eARC opportunity. These are my honest thoughts that I have provided voluntarily.
Profile Image for Annette Megaughin-Helder.
180 reviews3 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
May 22, 2026
A lawyer in an abusive relationship and a Russian hockey star trying to win custody of his daughter.

A happy ever after?

Penmates is the 3rd book in Nova Banks series about fictional NHL team the New York Falcons. I haven’t read the first two, but it’s stand alone so that’s not a problem.

The story is predictable. The grumpy hockey God hires his old schoolmate to help him win custody of his cute little girl. Only he was her high school bully so she hates him. But it is love at first sight with his daughter so she decides to represent him.

They fall for each other, and even before admitting that they get hitched so they have a better chance of winning. Once they admit their feelings, the book gets spicy. I didn’t care much for the s@x scenes but that’s just because I’ve read so many and it’s gets quite same same after time.

Of course there is a fall out, a making up and a real wedding at the end.

First of, the story is well written and an easy read.

There are some issues with reality. Once married, she should not have been allowed to continue being his lawyer as this is a major conflict of interest. Also, after the accident and coma it’s unlikely she remembers the event (having been in a similar situation I know most victims have memory loss of the time around when it happened), nor would she be as coherent as she is, being able to read all notes.

The wedding at the end is nice, but comes quick as a closer.

I did enjoy the book.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
3 reviews
June 1, 2026
ARC review

well. my standards have once again been set at an absolutely unreasonable level because WHAT do you mean this man exists??? if my future husband doesn’t worship me, obsess over me, and make me question every life choice that led me to reading this book then i genuinely do not want him 😭

Nova Banks, count your days because I was NOT emotionally prepared for this.

the tension??? INSANE. the chemistry??? CRIMINAL. every single message had me kicking my feet, giggling, screaming into my pillow and then immediately needing to continue because there was physically no way I could stop reading.

and can we PLEASE talk about the way these two fell for each other??? not me sitting there smiling at my kindle like an absolute idiot. the banter. the longing. the emotional connection. inject it directly into my veins immediately.

also the way I was convinced I knew what was coming and then BOOM. humbled. destroyed. emotionally compromised.

😭😭 the amount of times I had to put my book down and stare into space because I couldn’t cope???

dead. deceased. buried. gone. ⚰️

and don’t even get me started on HIM because I fear I have become unbearable. every time he opened his mouth I was like yes king that’s exactly right.

I laughed. I cried. I screamed. I fell in love with every character we met and now I’m left with the overwhelming urge to immediately reread it because apparently I enjoy emotional suffering.

incredible. all of it. recommend recommend recommend 🫶📚✨
Profile Image for Jade .
70 reviews7 followers
June 4, 2026
Penmates was an interesting read. I'm a big fan of the enemies to lovers trope, and love a reformed bully who becomes a good guy. So this ticked both boxes thanks to Colton and Jenna.

Colton is a big old softie underneath the formidable ice hockey player shell, and one hell of a father.

Jenna is a clever lawyer known as The Iron Lady by her peers. She's stuck in a relationship with Matthew, an absolute pig of a man. I think a lot of us have known a Matthew or two in our time.

Jenna's past comes back to haunt her when her former bully needs legal representation in his fight for custody of his adorable daughter.

Although an enjoyable read, what stops me rating this higher was just too many inconsistencies, as though scenes had been rewritten and those details then forgotten further into the story, creating a story that didn't always line up properly.

That said, it is still worth a read, and the writer has a good sense of humour, giving me some giggles along the way.

You might enjoy this book if you love:
- Open door romance (spicy)
- Enemies to lovers
- Marriage of convenience
- Hockey player x lawyer
- Single dad
- Ice Hockey
- Dual POV

Penmates is now available, including on KU. It is not the first in the series, but can be easily read as a stand alone.

Thank you to Nova Banks and Love Notes PR for the complimentary copy of this book. The views and opinions expressed in this review are my own.
Profile Image for Eloïse van Deutekom.
254 reviews1 follower
June 8, 2026
ARC REVIEW

I loved every second of reading this book!! This is the third book of the series and I haven't read the other two, but you actually don't have to. I have the first book at home and I'm going to start it really soon because this book was so freakishly good.

Colton was basically her high school bully. Normally I would not like that as a trope, but it actually has a good backstory. He is Russian and he just came to the USA so he couldn't speak or understand English. When they were calling her names he actually thought that was her name, because he didn't know what it meant. The other reason is that he did his best to fit in, even though he knew that he didn't.

Now he needs Jenna's help because he has a custody case against his ex-wife to get his daughter back. His ex doesn't let him see her and abuses her. So he is doing everything in his power to get sole custody over their daughter. Jenna is known as the Iron Lady in family court because she never loses a case. Now he needs her to be his lawyer and help him and his daughter out. I loved his daughter so freaking much. The kid is so cute and really smart too.

This book was sweet, spicy and with a lot of tension. It also broke and healed my heart because Jenna gets abused by her ex and Colton also had to go through that with his ex.


My favorite quotes:
"You aren't romantic Dad. I think Ineed tpo help you. Jenna is nice and good for you."
'The thirty-two freckles on her face. Yes, I counted them. All of them whenever I got lost in her beauty.'

My rating:
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.5
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
132 reviews
June 3, 2026
Jenna Davis is a powerhouse attorney who never loses, while Colton King is an NHL superstar and devoted single dad fighting for custody of his daughter. Throw in a fake marriage, forced proximity, unresolved history, and plenty of chemistry, and I was hooked from the very first chapter.

I absolutely loved the dynamic between Jenna and Colton. Their history added so much depth to every interaction, and watching resentment slowly turn into trust, friendship, and something much deeper made this story impossible to put down.

One of my favorite parts of this story was Jenna's personal journey. After enduring a toxic and emotionally abusive seven-year relationship, watching her rediscover her confidence, recognize her worth, and learn what a healthy, supportive relationship looks like was incredibly rewarding. Nova Banks handled her healing journey with care, adding an emotional depth that made me connect with Jenna even more.

Colton was such a standout character. Beneath the fame and confidence was a father willing to do absolutely anything for his daughter, and those moments completely stole my heart. The way he supported Jenna, respected her boundaries, and showed her what real love looks like made me fall for him right alongside her.

The emotional moments hit just as hard as the romantic ones, creating a story that was equal parts heartwarming and swoon-worthy.
Profile Image for lia ♡.
203 reviews18 followers
June 11, 2026
3.75 ⭐️ | arc review

”i remember they called him dangerous. but colton king might be my safe space.”

first, thank you to love notes pr for the arc 💌! i had fun reading this one !

honestly, this may be my favorite in the series, and i really did like book two a lot. idk something about a single dad with a smart mouthed daughter will do it every time 🤭 i loved livy so much, she was so sassy & honestly such an icon, okay i adored her comments all too much when it came to jenna & her daddy 🤣

i loved the pacing of this, it didn’t feel too dragged out, and yet it felt like the spice came at the right time, so i wasn’t even mad that they were giving in to their attraction to one another so late in the book because i was so invested in the custody case. a lot of books, i feel, either have the mc’s give in too early, or DRAG the story along to the point where i’m just not even into it anymore, so with this making me feel the way i did, i really appreciated it.

anyways, i think you’d like this if you like romances where the mmc IS in fact an athlete but it’s not the entire book.. like every other chapter isn’t a hockey—or football or basketball or whatever sport they play—game. it’s known, it’s mentioned, but it isn’t the entire book.

again thank you to love notes pr for the arc 💕
Displaying 1 - 30 of 108 reviews