What do you think?
Rate this book
North Bay #3
Way Off Base
Asking for help is hard enough, but when the problem is this embarrassing, reaching out for advice couldn't possibly be any more humiliating. Or so I thought until I accidentally forwarded the most awkward voicemail of my life to my brother's best friend. Now North Bay's gorgeous first baseman knows way more about me than he bargained for, and this situation is getting entirely out of hand.
Way Off Base is Book 3 in the North Bay Series. This is a standalone with interconnected characters. It contains mild-to-medium open door spice.
Way Off Base is Book 3 in the North Bay Series. This is a standalone with interconnected characters. It contains mild-to-medium open door spice.
- GenresRomance
243 pages, Kindle Edition
Published January 13, 2026
6 people are currently reading
1558 people want to read
About the author
Stephanie Giese
9 books85 followersStephanie Giese specializes in creating cozy chaos. Since we know you're wondering, her last name rhymes with "rice." If you like small-town romance and tropes like found family, you're in the right place! Stephanie writes lightly spicy love stories and classic romantic comedies intended to make you laugh out loud while also addressing more serious concerns like mental health, treatment, and consent. Originally from Maryland, she now lives in Florida with her large family and one very naughty beagle.
In addition to her contemporary romance books, Stephanie's writing has appeared in newspapers, magazines, and three humor anthologies, including the New York Times best-selling I JUST WANT TO PEE ALONE. In 2021, she worked in collaboration with her oldest son, Nicholas, on the memoir ALL I NEVER KNOWED, which addresses the children's mental health crisis in America. Her parenting articles have been featured on HuffPost, Good Morning America, Parents Magazine, and the Today Show. She has also worked for multiple non-profit organizations as a parenting "expert" (which she thinks is hilarious, as she never claimed to know what she was doing).
After a fifteen-year career creating parenting content and working as a children's mental health advocate, Stephanie decided to focus on something new that made her smile. At the top of the list? Romance novels. She is now the author of the North Bay romantic comedy series, which begins with OUT OF LEFT FIELD.
Follow her author journey on TikTok or Instagram @stephaniegieseauthor
Visit her website & sign up for the newsletter to receive free bonus scenes: https://www.stephaniegiese.com/
Purchase signed copies and book boxes: https://www.etsy.com/shop/stephaniegiese
In addition to her contemporary romance books, Stephanie's writing has appeared in newspapers, magazines, and three humor anthologies, including the New York Times best-selling I JUST WANT TO PEE ALONE. In 2021, she worked in collaboration with her oldest son, Nicholas, on the memoir ALL I NEVER KNOWED, which addresses the children's mental health crisis in America. Her parenting articles have been featured on HuffPost, Good Morning America, Parents Magazine, and the Today Show. She has also worked for multiple non-profit organizations as a parenting "expert" (which she thinks is hilarious, as she never claimed to know what she was doing).
After a fifteen-year career creating parenting content and working as a children's mental health advocate, Stephanie decided to focus on something new that made her smile. At the top of the list? Romance novels. She is now the author of the North Bay romantic comedy series, which begins with OUT OF LEFT FIELD.
Follow her author journey on TikTok or Instagram @stephaniegieseauthor
Visit her website & sign up for the newsletter to receive free bonus scenes: https://www.stephaniegiese.com/
Purchase signed copies and book boxes: https://www.etsy.com/shop/stephaniegiese
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 62 reviews
January 2, 2026
5/5
Way off base is the third book in the North Bay series featuring Shelly (Mike's sister) and Jordan (Mike's best friend and former roommate). It all starts when Shelly mistakenly sends a personal voice memo meant for her friend to Jordan. Jordan and Shelly have always felt an attraction to each other, but were afraid to act upon it due to their personal struggles and fear of Mike's disapproval. Throughout the story, we learn more about their personal struggles (Shelly's ADHD and side effects of her medications; Jordan's elbow injury, future in baseball, troubled past, and struggle with labeling his sexuality) and how it affects their daily lives and their relationship with each other.
As with the rest of the North Bay series, I loved this book, the way the author creates the characters is phenomenal. Although these books are considered interconnected standalone, it is recommended to read the books in order as key events and information from the previous books are mentioned.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Way off base is the third book in the North Bay series featuring Shelly (Mike's sister) and Jordan (Mike's best friend and former roommate). It all starts when Shelly mistakenly sends a personal voice memo meant for her friend to Jordan. Jordan and Shelly have always felt an attraction to each other, but were afraid to act upon it due to their personal struggles and fear of Mike's disapproval. Throughout the story, we learn more about their personal struggles (Shelly's ADHD and side effects of her medications; Jordan's elbow injury, future in baseball, troubled past, and struggle with labeling his sexuality) and how it affects their daily lives and their relationship with each other.
As with the rest of the North Bay series, I loved this book, the way the author creates the characters is phenomenal. Although these books are considered interconnected standalone, it is recommended to read the books in order as key events and information from the previous books are mentioned.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
January 13, 2026
Way Off Base was the perfect cozy read--with a lot of heart and reality too. Very real issues were explored and given space--all wrapped up in a sweet romance! 😍
January 2, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
🌶️.5/5
That’s a wrap on North Bay. I am sad to see this series end. Stephanie has a way of writing that I absolutely love and enjoy every time. She handled this story with care and knowledge and I believe this story will benefit many people and many will be able to relate to this story and the struggles the characters are facing.
Shelly is Mike’s brother (from Out Of Left Field) and she has a bit of resentment towards Mike due to his past struggles. She felt she could never step out of line, she had to be perfect. Because their parents were always focused on Mike and making sure he didn’t relapse. But, she struggles to share this with Mike because of how far he’s come. She’s also facing problems of her own struggling to reach her climax and feeling like her body is betraying her.
One voice memo gone wrong ended up in Mike’s best friend Jordan’s text vs who Shelly meant for it to go. Which makes for a very awkward and uncomfortable situation regardless of the fact that Shelly has a crush on Jordan. It actually leads to Shelly being comfortable enough to speak with a guy she can trust about her situation.
Jordan had some hardships growing up as well. He didn’t have it easy. He’s also facing some struggles of dealing with an injury and facing retirement from baseball as well as struggling with what to label his sexuality. He finds comfort in sharing this with Shelly as they begin to open up to one another.
Jordan only wants to be a friend to Shelly because he knows this is wrong as Mike is his best friend. He can’t cross that line. Sisters are off limits.
Jordan and Shelly have a fun banter and back and forth. Their relationship of trusting each other and opening up to each other is beautiful to watch unfold. I don’t want to spoil anything that happens. They face their challenges an ups and downs personally and together but ultimately wind up with a happily ever after.
Stephanie handled the story with care and you can tell she definitely did her research on the topics she spoke about throughout Shelly and Jordan’s story. I’ve saw some say they feel like the issues drug out, for me that wasn’t the case because you can’t determine that with this topic. I did at points feel the story as whole drug out but not the topic. Stephanie did a fantastic job wrapping up The North Bay Series!
🌶️.5/5
That’s a wrap on North Bay. I am sad to see this series end. Stephanie has a way of writing that I absolutely love and enjoy every time. She handled this story with care and knowledge and I believe this story will benefit many people and many will be able to relate to this story and the struggles the characters are facing.
Shelly is Mike’s brother (from Out Of Left Field) and she has a bit of resentment towards Mike due to his past struggles. She felt she could never step out of line, she had to be perfect. Because their parents were always focused on Mike and making sure he didn’t relapse. But, she struggles to share this with Mike because of how far he’s come. She’s also facing problems of her own struggling to reach her climax and feeling like her body is betraying her.
One voice memo gone wrong ended up in Mike’s best friend Jordan’s text vs who Shelly meant for it to go. Which makes for a very awkward and uncomfortable situation regardless of the fact that Shelly has a crush on Jordan. It actually leads to Shelly being comfortable enough to speak with a guy she can trust about her situation.
Jordan had some hardships growing up as well. He didn’t have it easy. He’s also facing some struggles of dealing with an injury and facing retirement from baseball as well as struggling with what to label his sexuality. He finds comfort in sharing this with Shelly as they begin to open up to one another.
Jordan only wants to be a friend to Shelly because he knows this is wrong as Mike is his best friend. He can’t cross that line. Sisters are off limits.
Jordan and Shelly have a fun banter and back and forth. Their relationship of trusting each other and opening up to each other is beautiful to watch unfold. I don’t want to spoil anything that happens. They face their challenges an ups and downs personally and together but ultimately wind up with a happily ever after.
Stephanie handled the story with care and you can tell she definitely did her research on the topics she spoke about throughout Shelly and Jordan’s story. I’ve saw some say they feel like the issues drug out, for me that wasn’t the case because you can’t determine that with this topic. I did at points feel the story as whole drug out but not the topic. Stephanie did a fantastic job wrapping up The North Bay Series!
November 11, 2025
I first came across Stephanie’s books a few months ago when I walked into my local B&N where she was promoting Out of Left Field and Right as Rain. I walked up to her table and spoke to her for a bit and I bought both of her books which she kindly signed. I came home and read them back to back in the matter of days. I fell in love with the town of North Bay.
So when i saw she was looking for ARC readers for Way off Base I knew I had to sign up. So here we are. I finished Shelly and Jordan’s story and I can honestly say it was so beautiful reading the development of their relationship. I loved how it touches on how relationships don’t always have to be physical and that the emotional connection is just as important. Stephanie’s books are well written and keep you interested during the whole book. I love North Bay and I hope we can some more of it.
So when i saw she was looking for ARC readers for Way off Base I knew I had to sign up. So here we are. I finished Shelly and Jordan’s story and I can honestly say it was so beautiful reading the development of their relationship. I loved how it touches on how relationships don’t always have to be physical and that the emotional connection is just as important. Stephanie’s books are well written and keep you interested during the whole book. I love North Bay and I hope we can some more of it.
November 8, 2025
This was my first ever ARC read and I was very nervous about it. What if I hate the book? What if I have to write a bad review (because I won't be anything but honest) and I hurt the author's feelings?
So imagine my relief to find the FMC very relatable in that way. Adult ADHD and obvious OCD causing extreme overthinking. I loved the representation of neurodiversity that wasn't viewed as negative. I loved the personal and relationship growth between Shelley and Jordan. Pacing was done well and made for a quick read. I would have loved for the final chapter to be a little longer though. IYKYK
I look forward to reading more from Stephanie Giese!
So imagine my relief to find the FMC very relatable in that way. Adult ADHD and obvious OCD causing extreme overthinking. I loved the representation of neurodiversity that wasn't viewed as negative. I loved the personal and relationship growth between Shelley and Jordan. Pacing was done well and made for a quick read. I would have loved for the final chapter to be a little longer though. IYKYK
I look forward to reading more from Stephanie Giese!
November 13, 2025
What a rollercoaster of emotions. Shelley has every woman’s nightmare an intimate voicemail sent to the wrong person but turns out to be the right person in the end.
Shelly and Jordan are really made for each other, both drowning under emotional baggage. You feel so sorry for Shelley and her problem but Jordan can help if only she’d let him.
A charming story of two people overcoming life’s challenges to get their HEA
I received a free copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Shelly and Jordan are really made for each other, both drowning under emotional baggage. You feel so sorry for Shelley and her problem but Jordan can help if only she’d let him.
A charming story of two people overcoming life’s challenges to get their HEA
I received a free copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review.
November 26, 2025
4.5⭐️ Shelley is a law student and Jordan is a minor league baseball player and Shelley’s brother’s best friend. Shelley accidentally sends Jordan a personal text meant for someone else and it starts their friendship which evolves into more. Aside from not wanting to hurt her brother, Shelley is also neurodivergent and has had problems in the past with intimacy. Jordan has his own insecurities about his sexuality so they bond quickly. This story has funny parts, but also has emotional family dynamics. It can be read as a standalone, but is the third book in the North Bay Series. Thank you to Stephanie Giese for the opportunity to ARC read this.
December 6, 2025
Such a sweet story about two people overcoming life's challenges in a very different way
Shelly accidentally sends Jordan (her brothers best friend) a very embarrassingly personal text meant for someone else luckily Jordan is a sweetie who helps her in more ways than she could imagine and in turn they help each other overcome a few big issues
There's great character development and interesting topics covered, its funny and emotional and an enjoyable read
Thank you Stephanie Giese for the ARC opportunity
Shelly accidentally sends Jordan (her brothers best friend) a very embarrassingly personal text meant for someone else luckily Jordan is a sweetie who helps her in more ways than she could imagine and in turn they help each other overcome a few big issues
There's great character development and interesting topics covered, its funny and emotional and an enjoyable read
Thank you Stephanie Giese for the ARC opportunity
December 10, 2025
This was such a fun and heartwarming read! North Bay feels like a town you could live in, and the characters make it even better.
Shelly is so relatable. Her ADHD and overthinking lead to some super awkward situations...like that accidentally forwarded voicemail that kicks off the story. Totally cringe, but also hilarious! Jordan, her brother’s best friend, is patient, kind, and just the right amount of swoony. Watching them figure out their feelings while helping each other grow was really sweet.
What I loved most is that their romance isn’t just about the physical stuff. They talk about sex. They know what is going on. They understand each other, but it obviously isn't the center of their relationship...it’s about their emotional connection, and it felt so real and earned. The book also does a great job showing neurodiversity in a positive way.
Thanks so much to Stephanie Giese and NetGalley for the ARC.
Shelly is so relatable. Her ADHD and overthinking lead to some super awkward situations...like that accidentally forwarded voicemail that kicks off the story. Totally cringe, but also hilarious! Jordan, her brother’s best friend, is patient, kind, and just the right amount of swoony. Watching them figure out their feelings while helping each other grow was really sweet.
What I loved most is that their romance isn’t just about the physical stuff. They talk about sex. They know what is going on. They understand each other, but it obviously isn't the center of their relationship...it’s about their emotional connection, and it felt so real and earned. The book also does a great job showing neurodiversity in a positive way.
Thanks so much to Stephanie Giese and NetGalley for the ARC.
January 15, 2026
*Review of advanced copy provided by the author. All opinions are my own.
I really loved this book! I found it a little bit hard to get into at first, but then I got really into it and finished it in a day!
As someone who also struggles with something similar as the FMC, I loved the representation this book brought, it wasn't just a fun read, it was important to read and I appreciated how it was brought.
It was the first book of Stephanie that I read, and I'm so excited to start reading her other ones! Definitely recommend!
I really loved this book! I found it a little bit hard to get into at first, but then I got really into it and finished it in a day!
As someone who also struggles with something similar as the FMC, I loved the representation this book brought, it wasn't just a fun read, it was important to read and I appreciated how it was brought.
It was the first book of Stephanie that I read, and I'm so excited to start reading her other ones! Definitely recommend!
Review of advance copy
arc Book Review
This is the third installment in Stephanie Giese's North Bay series, continues to deliver the smalltown charm and heartwarming romance that fans have come to love. Giese's writing effortlessly draws you back into the lives of the North Bay community, making you feel like you're catching up with old friends.
The story focuses on new characters, each grappling with their own personal challenges and dreams. The author skillfully weaves their individual stories together, creating a cohesive and engaging narrative. The chemistry between the main characters is palpable, and their journey is filled with both sweet moments and relatable struggles.
This is the third installment in Stephanie Giese's North Bay series, continues to deliver the smalltown charm and heartwarming romance that fans have come to love. Giese's writing effortlessly draws you back into the lives of the North Bay community, making you feel like you're catching up with old friends.
The story focuses on new characters, each grappling with their own personal challenges and dreams. The author skillfully weaves their individual stories together, creating a cohesive and engaging narrative. The chemistry between the main characters is palpable, and their journey is filled with both sweet moments and relatable struggles.
November 13, 2025
I absolutely am honored that I was given this advanced readers copy to read. I do now know that I definitely need to read the first 2 books in this series. I love Jordan like is he not the best man ever? I feel if I write too much I will spoil this book for others!
November 2, 2025
This was something different for me I usually read thriller or dark romance or fantasy but I can honestly say I loved every second of this book
January 14, 2026
Stephanie is so good at writing books that speak to your soul! Way Off Base is such a fine example of finding your person and growing a relationship the right way! Women are often shamed when our bodies don’t work the way we want them too, and Stephanie reminded us that with the right person by our side, we can be loved!
I love the character development, the way Jordan and Shelley develop their relationship through their words and their emotions. Their story is a good reminder that we are all different in our own ways and being accepted for who we are is truly what being loved is all about.
I did receive a copy of this book for review, but my views are my own!
I love the character development, the way Jordan and Shelley develop their relationship through their words and their emotions. Their story is a good reminder that we are all different in our own ways and being accepted for who we are is truly what being loved is all about.
I did receive a copy of this book for review, but my views are my own!
December 11, 2025
Star rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.25
Way off Base is a brothers best friend romance and is the third book in the North Bay series. It follows Jordan the first baseman for the professional North Bay baseball team and Shelley, the younger sister of another North Bay player Mike, Jordan’s best friend.
Starting with Shelley, I really liked how the author wrote her. She’s a twenty something woman who is struggling with her libido and can’t figure out why. The depiction of the doctors appointments and the internal battle Shelley wages with herself on if it’s her fault and if she’s broken are so relatable to so many women dealing with the same problems. She also has ADHD and I felt like this was represented well in the book
Jordan struggles with his feelings for Shelley and how her brother might react to them getting together. Jordan is also trying to figure out his sexuality and gets a lot of support from different people along the way which was really refreshing to read about
I think the dynamic between Shelley and Jordan as they start to get closer was perfect. As they each get more vulnerable, you see support from both sides and just a sweetness that I don’t see in a lot of brothers best friend romances. I also love how Jordan and Shelley both learn more about themselves as they open themselves up to one another and it’s very authentic feeling
Now my one critique had to do with the third act breakup (which I’m generally not the biggest fan of but it made sense in this story the way it happened). Shelley is an adult but had her brother get involved which I felt was really immature and then instead of helping defend Jordan, she really didn’t do much to keep Mike from being angry with Jordan for going behind his back with his sister. Shelley has some resentment toward Mike too and yet relies on him to clean up her messes and come to her rescue all the time. I did like that Shelley was able to confront Mike and get their sibling relationship back on track and I thought the author did a good job with this scene.
Overall, I really enjoyed this book and felt it was different than other romance books on the market. I’ve come to love this series and hope to go back and read book 2!
Thank you to the author for having me as an ARC reader for this book. I’m leaving this review voluntarily ☺️
Way off Base is a brothers best friend romance and is the third book in the North Bay series. It follows Jordan the first baseman for the professional North Bay baseball team and Shelley, the younger sister of another North Bay player Mike, Jordan’s best friend.
Starting with Shelley, I really liked how the author wrote her. She’s a twenty something woman who is struggling with her libido and can’t figure out why. The depiction of the doctors appointments and the internal battle Shelley wages with herself on if it’s her fault and if she’s broken are so relatable to so many women dealing with the same problems. She also has ADHD and I felt like this was represented well in the book
Jordan struggles with his feelings for Shelley and how her brother might react to them getting together. Jordan is also trying to figure out his sexuality and gets a lot of support from different people along the way which was really refreshing to read about
I think the dynamic between Shelley and Jordan as they start to get closer was perfect. As they each get more vulnerable, you see support from both sides and just a sweetness that I don’t see in a lot of brothers best friend romances. I also love how Jordan and Shelley both learn more about themselves as they open themselves up to one another and it’s very authentic feeling
Now my one critique had to do with the third act breakup (which I’m generally not the biggest fan of but it made sense in this story the way it happened). Shelley is an adult but had her brother get involved which I felt was really immature and then instead of helping defend Jordan, she really didn’t do much to keep Mike from being angry with Jordan for going behind his back with his sister. Shelley has some resentment toward Mike too and yet relies on him to clean up her messes and come to her rescue all the time. I did like that Shelley was able to confront Mike and get their sibling relationship back on track and I thought the author did a good job with this scene.
Overall, I really enjoyed this book and felt it was different than other romance books on the market. I’ve come to love this series and hope to go back and read book 2!
Thank you to the author for having me as an ARC reader for this book. I’m leaving this review voluntarily ☺️
January 13, 2026
📚Way off Base
✍🏻Stephanie Giese
Blurb:
Looking for a small-town brother's best friend romance with tropes like found family? Are you here for responsible physical and mental health representation? Then you'll love Jordan and Shelley!
Shelley: Asking for help is hard enough, but when the problem is this embarrassing, reaching out for advice couldn't possibly be any more humiliating. Or so I thought until I accidentally forwarded the most awkward voicemail of my life to my brother's best friend. Now North Bay's gorgeous first baseman knows way more about my body than he bargained for, and this situation is getting entirely out of hand.
Way Off Base is Book 3 in the North Bay Series. This is a dual POV standalone with interconnected characters. It contains mild-to-medium open door spice and features neurodivergent and LGBTQ+ main characters in a M/F relationship.
My Thoughts:
Woy off Base follows Shelley and Jordan. This is book #3 in a series, I will be reading the ones I have missed. Shelly (Mike's sister) and Jordan (Mike's best friend and former roommate). It all starts when Shelly mistakenly sends a personal voice memo meant for her friend to Jordan. Jordan and Shelly have always felt an attraction to each other.They are afraid to act on their feelings. Due to personal struggles, Shelly's ADHD and the side effects of her medication. Jordan's elbow injury, future in baseball, troubled past, and struggle with labeling his sexuality) and how it affects their daily lives and their relationship with each other. I really enjoyed this book and looking forward to reading more from this Author.
Thanks Stephanie Giese, Binkies and Briefcases LLC for the advanced copy of "Way off Base" I am leaving my voluntary review in appreciation.
#StephanieGiese
#BinkiesandBriefcasesLLC
#WayoffBase
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
✍🏻Stephanie Giese
Blurb:
Looking for a small-town brother's best friend romance with tropes like found family? Are you here for responsible physical and mental health representation? Then you'll love Jordan and Shelley!
Shelley: Asking for help is hard enough, but when the problem is this embarrassing, reaching out for advice couldn't possibly be any more humiliating. Or so I thought until I accidentally forwarded the most awkward voicemail of my life to my brother's best friend. Now North Bay's gorgeous first baseman knows way more about my body than he bargained for, and this situation is getting entirely out of hand.
Way Off Base is Book 3 in the North Bay Series. This is a dual POV standalone with interconnected characters. It contains mild-to-medium open door spice and features neurodivergent and LGBTQ+ main characters in a M/F relationship.
My Thoughts:
Woy off Base follows Shelley and Jordan. This is book #3 in a series, I will be reading the ones I have missed. Shelly (Mike's sister) and Jordan (Mike's best friend and former roommate). It all starts when Shelly mistakenly sends a personal voice memo meant for her friend to Jordan. Jordan and Shelly have always felt an attraction to each other.They are afraid to act on their feelings. Due to personal struggles, Shelly's ADHD and the side effects of her medication. Jordan's elbow injury, future in baseball, troubled past, and struggle with labeling his sexuality) and how it affects their daily lives and their relationship with each other. I really enjoyed this book and looking forward to reading more from this Author.
Thanks Stephanie Giese, Binkies and Briefcases LLC for the advanced copy of "Way off Base" I am leaving my voluntary review in appreciation.
#StephanieGiese
#BinkiesandBriefcasesLLC
#WayoffBase
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
November 27, 2025
⚾✨ ARC Book Review: Way Off Base by Stephanie Giese ✨⚾
If you’re looking for a small-town, brother’s best friend romance packed with heart, humor, and all your favourite tropes—including found family—Way Off Base delivers big time. Stephanie Giese blends laugh-out-loud awkward moments with genuine emotional depth, creating a story that’s both swoony and meaningful.
Shelley is just trying to ask for help… but when the problem is this embarrassing, the last thing she expects is to accidentally forward the world’s most mortifying voicemail to her brother’s best friend. Suddenly, North Bay’s gorgeous first baseman knows way more about her body than anyone ever should—and things quickly spiral from uncomfortable to undeniably electric.
What makes this story shine is its responsible physical and mental health representation, paired with characters who feel warm, real, and wonderfully human. Jordan and Shelley’s dynamic is tender, funny, and absolutely addictive.
⚾ What I loved:
✨ Sharp, playful banter and off-the-charts chemistry
✨ A brother’s-best-friend setup done so right
✨ Neurodivergent and LGBTQ+ representation woven respectfully and naturally
✨ Dual POV that makes you fall for both characters
✨ A perfect balance of heart, humor, and mild-to-medium open-door spice
Way Off Base is Book 3 in the North Bay Series, but works as a dual-POV standalone with interconnected characters—and it’s easily a new favorite.
Added the first two to my TBR. Loved it. 😍📚
If you’re looking for a small-town, brother’s best friend romance packed with heart, humor, and all your favourite tropes—including found family—Way Off Base delivers big time. Stephanie Giese blends laugh-out-loud awkward moments with genuine emotional depth, creating a story that’s both swoony and meaningful.
Shelley is just trying to ask for help… but when the problem is this embarrassing, the last thing she expects is to accidentally forward the world’s most mortifying voicemail to her brother’s best friend. Suddenly, North Bay’s gorgeous first baseman knows way more about her body than anyone ever should—and things quickly spiral from uncomfortable to undeniably electric.
What makes this story shine is its responsible physical and mental health representation, paired with characters who feel warm, real, and wonderfully human. Jordan and Shelley’s dynamic is tender, funny, and absolutely addictive.
⚾ What I loved:
✨ Sharp, playful banter and off-the-charts chemistry
✨ A brother’s-best-friend setup done so right
✨ Neurodivergent and LGBTQ+ representation woven respectfully and naturally
✨ Dual POV that makes you fall for both characters
✨ A perfect balance of heart, humor, and mild-to-medium open-door spice
Way Off Base is Book 3 in the North Bay Series, but works as a dual-POV standalone with interconnected characters—and it’s easily a new favorite.
Added the first two to my TBR. Loved it. 😍📚
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
December 31, 2025
This is the third book in the North Bay series, but it can be read as standalone. It is the first book I have read by Stephanie Giese, and it will not be the last. The story is not what I expected, but I liked it so much that I am planning to read the first two books in the series.
In addition to having ADHD and being a neurodivergent, Shelley has an intimate personal problem. She accidentally sends a text about it to her brother’s best friend Jordan. She is extremely embarrassed because she has crushed on Jordan in the past. She also feels that her body is defective and she can’t connect with people.
Jordan is a minor league baseball player, and Shelley’s brother Mike’s best friend. Mike is moving up to the major leagues, so Jordan is feeling a tremendous loss in his life. Jordan feels his life has been stagnant the past few years, and he is currently struggling with his own sexuality.
There are many reasons why Shelley and Jordan feel they can be friends only. As they get to know each other and the relationship grows at a slow pace, they determine they want the relationship to be more. They have a strong connection that allows them to help each other deal with their struggles. Having a son on the spectrum, I like that their “differences” are shown in such a positive light. A wonderful, emotional story that the world needs more of!
I received an advance review copy from BookSirens, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
In addition to having ADHD and being a neurodivergent, Shelley has an intimate personal problem. She accidentally sends a text about it to her brother’s best friend Jordan. She is extremely embarrassed because she has crushed on Jordan in the past. She also feels that her body is defective and she can’t connect with people.
Jordan is a minor league baseball player, and Shelley’s brother Mike’s best friend. Mike is moving up to the major leagues, so Jordan is feeling a tremendous loss in his life. Jordan feels his life has been stagnant the past few years, and he is currently struggling with his own sexuality.
There are many reasons why Shelley and Jordan feel they can be friends only. As they get to know each other and the relationship grows at a slow pace, they determine they want the relationship to be more. They have a strong connection that allows them to help each other deal with their struggles. Having a son on the spectrum, I like that their “differences” are shown in such a positive light. A wonderful, emotional story that the world needs more of!
I received an advance review copy from BookSirens, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
November 19, 2025
Rating: 5/5
A must read for all ✨
Plot: A young adult romance with brother's best friend while being strongly present for herself and the things that matter.
Genre: Young Adult Romance, Sports Romance, Small Town Romance
Highlight:
+Sensitivity to mental health terminologies
+Acknowledgement of LGBTQIA+
+Respect to Consent
+Acknowledging the conflict with family
+Character description
+Dual POV
My experience: The plot is very simple to understand, however the way it caters to the challenges, curiosity and exploration that are a significant part of young adulthood is brilliant. It clearly gives strong space and voice to how sexual concerns and consent require a genuine space among relationships without being considered as a taboo. It easily transitions to all the conversation between FL and ML regarding their perceived flaws, insecurities and the need for a safe space to communicate it all is truly the biggest highlight. I truly loved that ✨
Although, I really did find the epilogue section a bit rushed but all the other things were so good that I won't be reducing the rating for it. It deserves to be read by all readers and authors to understand the depth and intensity of safe communication space in any relationship.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
A must read for all ✨
Plot: A young adult romance with brother's best friend while being strongly present for herself and the things that matter.
Genre: Young Adult Romance, Sports Romance, Small Town Romance
Highlight:
+Sensitivity to mental health terminologies
+Acknowledgement of LGBTQIA+
+Respect to Consent
+Acknowledging the conflict with family
+Character description
+Dual POV
My experience: The plot is very simple to understand, however the way it caters to the challenges, curiosity and exploration that are a significant part of young adulthood is brilliant. It clearly gives strong space and voice to how sexual concerns and consent require a genuine space among relationships without being considered as a taboo. It easily transitions to all the conversation between FL and ML regarding their perceived flaws, insecurities and the need for a safe space to communicate it all is truly the biggest highlight. I truly loved that ✨
Although, I really did find the epilogue section a bit rushed but all the other things were so good that I won't be reducing the rating for it. It deserves to be read by all readers and authors to understand the depth and intensity of safe communication space in any relationship.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
November 28, 2025
ARC REVIEW | ⭐️ 4 | 🌶️ 0.5
From page one, I knew this book was going to deliver on representation and wow, did it. A neurodivergent FMC, LGBTQIA+ exploration, and the realities of addiction within families… this story had depth, honesty, and real heart.
Shelly is one of the most authentic neurodivergent heroines I’ve read. The way the author captured an ADHD brain, Spot. On! Every high, every crash, every “why isn’t the world built for me?” moment felt raw and incredibly real. It was refreshing, validating, and beautifully written.
Jordan’s journey in understanding and expressing his sexuality was just as compelling. His open conversations with Shelly were soft, vulnerable, and some of the best moments in the book.
Their relationship unfolds slowly, naturally, and with intention. Jordan giving Shelly the time and space her brain needs. That was a highlight gentle, patient, and deeply respectful.
If I had one issue, it’s that Mikey’s reaction dipped a little too far into alpha-male territory, and I wished for a bit more connection with the side characters. But honestly the representation steals the show here thoughtful, layered, and done with genuine care.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
From page one, I knew this book was going to deliver on representation and wow, did it. A neurodivergent FMC, LGBTQIA+ exploration, and the realities of addiction within families… this story had depth, honesty, and real heart.
Shelly is one of the most authentic neurodivergent heroines I’ve read. The way the author captured an ADHD brain, Spot. On! Every high, every crash, every “why isn’t the world built for me?” moment felt raw and incredibly real. It was refreshing, validating, and beautifully written.
Jordan’s journey in understanding and expressing his sexuality was just as compelling. His open conversations with Shelly were soft, vulnerable, and some of the best moments in the book.
Their relationship unfolds slowly, naturally, and with intention. Jordan giving Shelly the time and space her brain needs. That was a highlight gentle, patient, and deeply respectful.
If I had one issue, it’s that Mikey’s reaction dipped a little too far into alpha-male territory, and I wished for a bit more connection with the side characters. But honestly the representation steals the show here thoughtful, layered, and done with genuine care.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
December 2, 2025
I received this book as an eARC from BookSirens and am leaving this review voluntarily
I was surprised by how much I truly enjoyed reading this book, and following Shelley and Jordan! I have read some hockey romances recently but I am a baseball girly at heart. While you don’t need to know much about baseball to understand and follow along, you do want to be open to the mind of people who may be different from the majority of others. I related to Shelley in several ways and appreciated the vulnerability we got from her and Jordan. Though I am not part of the LGBTQA+ community, I am an ally and getting a glimpse of their reality also made me more invested in the characters.
This is book #3 in a series but I do not feel like I missed out on anything since I have not read the other two. In fact, I have added the other two to my tbr! This was a refreshing read and I highly recommend!
I was surprised by how much I truly enjoyed reading this book, and following Shelley and Jordan! I have read some hockey romances recently but I am a baseball girly at heart. While you don’t need to know much about baseball to understand and follow along, you do want to be open to the mind of people who may be different from the majority of others. I related to Shelley in several ways and appreciated the vulnerability we got from her and Jordan. Though I am not part of the LGBTQA+ community, I am an ally and getting a glimpse of their reality also made me more invested in the characters.
This is book #3 in a series but I do not feel like I missed out on anything since I have not read the other two. In fact, I have added the other two to my tbr! This was a refreshing read and I highly recommend!
December 6, 2025
Shelly is having difficulty with arriving at the finish line ( sorry amazon will be picky i just know it so have to word it like this) So she decides to be proactive but accidentally instead of asking her friend she sent a voicemail to Jordan he big brothers best friend and strictly off limits but the chemistry between the two is off the charts can they resist while he helps her with her problems. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily I loved that it didn't shy away from her problems and made it very clear this is normal and not something to be ashamed of, to be honest there was a lot of things i didnt even realize.
But not her but him as well and i found it interesting to read and how it was from a guys perspective. How this relationship builds up and i really enjoyed it.
But not her but him as well and i found it interesting to read and how it was from a guys perspective. How this relationship builds up and i really enjoyed it.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Seeing yourself through someone else’s eyes
This is the 3rd book in the North Bay series and features Shelley and Jordan.
Shelley has crushed on her brother’s best friend for a while and knew it would go no further. Bro code and all.
Until the day she accidentally sends him a rather detailed voice message that wasn’t meant for his ears.
This starts a friendship that eventually leads to more between two people that have their own set of personal issues that need to be resolved.
This emotional at times story beautifully describes their sometimes crooked path to building a life together.
A really enjoyable story with wonderfully diverse characters not afraid to discuss some hard topics.
Thank you Stephanie Giese, NetGalley and Victory Editing NetGalley Co-op for the opportunity to read this story.
This is the 3rd book in the North Bay series and features Shelley and Jordan.
Shelley has crushed on her brother’s best friend for a while and knew it would go no further. Bro code and all.
Until the day she accidentally sends him a rather detailed voice message that wasn’t meant for his ears.
This starts a friendship that eventually leads to more between two people that have their own set of personal issues that need to be resolved.
This emotional at times story beautifully describes their sometimes crooked path to building a life together.
A really enjoyable story with wonderfully diverse characters not afraid to discuss some hard topics.
Thank you Stephanie Giese, NetGalley and Victory Editing NetGalley Co-op for the opportunity to read this story.
Review of advance copy received from Author
I think is one is my favorite from this series! I have fallen in love with Shelley and Jordan!
This story dives more into real life issues that people are afraid to talk about and the stress and anxiety of dealing with them. Jordan is a huge cinnamon roll and I love him. He gave Shelley the love and attention she needed and took his time with her.
Shelley has so much anxiety and stress dealing with all
Of her health issues and past trauma that she still doesn’t know how to deal with or what to do about it. When she accidentally sends a text to the wrong person that ends up being the best thing that cld have ever happened to her.
We get to see some characters from the other two books in this series, make appearances also, which I love, esp the scene with Honey, that cracked me up. Just shows your never too old to let loose and have a little fun!
This story dives more into real life issues that people are afraid to talk about and the stress and anxiety of dealing with them. Jordan is a huge cinnamon roll and I love him. He gave Shelley the love and attention she needed and took his time with her.
Shelley has so much anxiety and stress dealing with all
Of her health issues and past trauma that she still doesn’t know how to deal with or what to do about it. When she accidentally sends a text to the wrong person that ends up being the best thing that cld have ever happened to her.
We get to see some characters from the other two books in this series, make appearances also, which I love, esp the scene with Honey, that cracked me up. Just shows your never too old to let loose and have a little fun!
Review of advance copy received from Author
I absolutely love the North Bay series so much and this book is no different. This is book three in the series of interconnected standalones. what a beautiful way to showcase a relationship that is not considered the norm. bringing about the importance of bodily autonomy and a trusting caring partner who respects every part of you. we have a brother's best friend almost forbidden relationship situation, bodies that just don't cooperate the way that most do, and genuine love. there are a couple of hard hit topics such as referencing addiction that at is covered mostly in the first book of the series, as well as growing up in a difficult home life and having a found family that far too often is there for you more than your blood family. i will forever recommend this series to people because it is just so good.
November 20, 2025
I’ve been waiting to read about Jordan and Shelly since the first book in the North Bay series. I knew their story was going to be amazing but honestly I was not prepared for the emotional journey this was going to take me on.
The author did such an amazing job with describing the aspects of Shelly’s mental health and even Jordan’s struggles that it had me tearing up.
I’m so sad that this is the last book but I’ve thoroughly enjoyed reading this series.
Favorite moment: learning that Jordan crochets. Like come on, did we need even more reasons to fall in love with him.
I did receive an ARC of the novel but this review is my honest opinion after having read the series and falling in love with the characters.
The author did such an amazing job with describing the aspects of Shelly’s mental health and even Jordan’s struggles that it had me tearing up.
I’m so sad that this is the last book but I’ve thoroughly enjoyed reading this series.
Favorite moment: learning that Jordan crochets. Like come on, did we need even more reasons to fall in love with him.
I did receive an ARC of the novel but this review is my honest opinion after having read the series and falling in love with the characters.
Review of advance copy received from Author
I loved Way Off Base so much! It had the perfect balance of seriousness and humor. When Shelley is having a personal issue, she sends a message to an old friend for advice…or so she thought. It turns out she accidentally sent the message to North Bay’s cute first baseman, Jordan, who also happens to be her brother’s best friend.
I appreciate how Stephanie writes about common issues people experience that maybe they don’t feel comfortable talking about. For women, we don’t get taken seriously when it comes to our emotions and bodies. We get shamed for it. For men, I imagine there’s intense pressure on being confident in your sexuality. In Way Off Base, Stephanie addresses both these issues, highlighting that it’s okay to be different and that you deserve to be loved no matter what.
I appreciate how Stephanie writes about common issues people experience that maybe they don’t feel comfortable talking about. For women, we don’t get taken seriously when it comes to our emotions and bodies. We get shamed for it. For men, I imagine there’s intense pressure on being confident in your sexuality. In Way Off Base, Stephanie addresses both these issues, highlighting that it’s okay to be different and that you deserve to be loved no matter what.
Review of advance copy received from Author
This is a gorgeous love story between Jordan and Shelly, his best friends sister.
When Shelly accidently sends Jordan a deeply personal message meant for someone else, it opens the door to honest conversations she's never felt safe having before. Jordan - someone she has quietly had feelings for - responds with unexpected kindness, patience and understanding.
What makes this story especially powerful is its portrayal of a woman living with ADHD and navigating the effect her medication has on her body and her confidence. Shelly believes that loving her - and waiting until she feels truly comfortable with intimacy - is too much to ask of anyone, especially Jordan.
At its heart, this is a story about trust, vulnerability, and learning that the right kind of love is never a burden.
When Shelly accidently sends Jordan a deeply personal message meant for someone else, it opens the door to honest conversations she's never felt safe having before. Jordan - someone she has quietly had feelings for - responds with unexpected kindness, patience and understanding.
What makes this story especially powerful is its portrayal of a woman living with ADHD and navigating the effect her medication has on her body and her confidence. Shelly believes that loving her - and waiting until she feels truly comfortable with intimacy - is too much to ask of anyone, especially Jordan.
At its heart, this is a story about trust, vulnerability, and learning that the right kind of love is never a burden.
November 27, 2025
I’ve officially found my new book boyfriend!
Jordan is everything a person would want in a partner. Patience, kind, caring, loving, understanding and of course good looking, specially with the glasses! I love that Stephanie’s books are close door romance but this one felt like the door cracked open a bit and gave us a mild level of spice (if you read it, you know what I’m talking about). I would’ve loved to know if Shelly found her big “O” but by that epilogue I’m guessing YES!
I think this is the last one in the series? I am sad it’s over but so glad I read them and was part of their love story. I think the person I will miss the most is Honey but I know we’ll all miss her!
Jordan is everything a person would want in a partner. Patience, kind, caring, loving, understanding and of course good looking, specially with the glasses! I love that Stephanie’s books are close door romance but this one felt like the door cracked open a bit and gave us a mild level of spice (if you read it, you know what I’m talking about). I would’ve loved to know if Shelly found her big “O” but by that epilogue I’m guessing YES!
I think this is the last one in the series? I am sad it’s over but so glad I read them and was part of their love story. I think the person I will miss the most is Honey but I know we’ll all miss her!
January 4, 2026
ARC REVIEW
This was a short quick read that had me captivated right from the beginning. I love a brother’s best friend trope so I was all in.
Now the topics in this book were heavy, but discussed in detail and felt like researched.
This was book 3 in the series and I hadn’t read the other 2, but didn’t feel like I was missing anything from not reading them first.
I loved that even though they had a hard time communicating, but it was difficult to express they still kept trying and working through things together.
My only critique is that I felt like it ended quick. The epilogue was good, but I wanted more for the ending.
This was a short quick read that had me captivated right from the beginning. I love a brother’s best friend trope so I was all in.
Now the topics in this book were heavy, but discussed in detail and felt like researched.
This was book 3 in the series and I hadn’t read the other 2, but didn’t feel like I was missing anything from not reading them first.
I loved that even though they had a hard time communicating, but it was difficult to express they still kept trying and working through things together.
My only critique is that I felt like it ended quick. The epilogue was good, but I wanted more for the ending.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 62 reviews