What do you think?
Rate this book
Bakeshop Mystery #22
The Whisking Hour
Another delicious installment in the Bakeshop Series set in Ashland, OR!
Fall is in full flush in the charming hamlet of Ashland, Oregon, where theater director Lance’s production of Perfect Crime has been met with rave reviews. As with everything, Lance has put his own spin on the long-running Broadway classic, opting for an intimate staging and drawing the audience into a cozy New York apartment on a stormy fall night where a nefarious set of suspects pulls off the perfect murder. Jules and the team at Torte are eagerly whipping up a murderous crime scene feast for the cast party, baking a bevy of treats like panna cotta eyeballs with blood orange coulis, deviled eggs, and savory cheese fingers with pumpkin dipping sauce.
Life seems to imitate art when a storm rolls over the Siskiyou Mountains on the day of the soirée, ushering in gusty winds and unrelenting rain. But Jules and Lance are not to be deterred. After all, the show must go on. The audience buzzes with electric energy as the lights flicker and the actors take the stage. Once the actors take their final bow, the cast trickles into Carpenter Hall, ready for a night of frivolity, but when the lead actor stumbles in with a fatal stab wound, Jules wonders if she’s just witnessed the perfect murder.
Fall is in full flush in the charming hamlet of Ashland, Oregon, where theater director Lance’s production of Perfect Crime has been met with rave reviews. As with everything, Lance has put his own spin on the long-running Broadway classic, opting for an intimate staging and drawing the audience into a cozy New York apartment on a stormy fall night where a nefarious set of suspects pulls off the perfect murder. Jules and the team at Torte are eagerly whipping up a murderous crime scene feast for the cast party, baking a bevy of treats like panna cotta eyeballs with blood orange coulis, deviled eggs, and savory cheese fingers with pumpkin dipping sauce.
Life seems to imitate art when a storm rolls over the Siskiyou Mountains on the day of the soirée, ushering in gusty winds and unrelenting rain. But Jules and Lance are not to be deterred. After all, the show must go on. The audience buzzes with electric energy as the lights flicker and the actors take the stage. Once the actors take their final bow, the cast trickles into Carpenter Hall, ready for a night of frivolity, but when the lead actor stumbles in with a fatal stab wound, Jules wonders if she’s just witnessed the perfect murder.
320 pages, Mass Market Paperback
First published February 24, 2026
174 people are currently reading
6117 people want to read
About the author
Ellie Alexander
85 books3,141 followersEllie is a voracious storyteller and a lover of words and all things bookish. She believes that stories have the ability to transport and transform us. With over forty published novels and counting, her goal is to tell stories that provide points of connection, escape, and understanding.
She loves inhabiting someone else’s skin through the pages of a book and is passionate about helping writers find their unique storytelling lens. As a writing teacher and coach, she guides writers in crafting the story they’ve always wanted to tell while navigating the path to publication that’s right for them.
Find out more about Ellie and her books by visiting her website at: http://www.elliealexander.co/ or following her on social media—
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/ellie_alexa...
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@elliealexande...
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/elliealexande...
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/elliealexand...
Pinterest:
https://www.pinterest.com/elliealexan...
She loves inhabiting someone else’s skin through the pages of a book and is passionate about helping writers find their unique storytelling lens. As a writing teacher and coach, she guides writers in crafting the story they’ve always wanted to tell while navigating the path to publication that’s right for them.
Find out more about Ellie and her books by visiting her website at: http://www.elliealexander.co/ or following her on social media—
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/ellie_alexa...
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@elliealexande...
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/elliealexande...
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/elliealexand...
Pinterest:
https://www.pinterest.com/elliealexan...
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 168 reviews
April 25, 2026
I had requested this book from the library. There are only 2 in the library system and I had to wait over a month. It was worth the wait. I love this series and I hope it continues. Quite a few twists in this one. A lot of suspects in the murder mystery. A very unliked producer of plays ends up dead. He treated many of his actors as well as others, poorly. I wish there had been more of the main character's, Jules', employees at Torte in the book. I really like reading their work scenes. They were there but not as much as the other books. Marty is my favorite. Since a couple employees left 2 or 3 books ago, there's talk about the younger, newer employees for the past couple of books but they are never introduced. I find that odd. They've been there a little while now but only vaguely mentioned they exist. At least they all wink a lot less at each other in this one, haha. I always found that weird but I still love these books. They give me a cozy feeling and I look forward to them. I hope Ellie Alexander writes more for the series! Jules has to give birth sometime! Happy reading! 🎭🤰
April 6, 2026
I love the characters and they keep bringing me back to this series, but it seems like we spend more time catching up with them than solving mysteries. There’s also a ton of filler in this one with the step-by-step of Jules’ baking in the kitchen. The mystery, while interesting, was lost in the everyday of Jules’ life. There were also a few places where her being involved in the mystery didn’t make sense and why people constantly seek her out, this hugely pregnant soon-to-be mom, to talk to and/or stalk. I enjoyed this but felt that the series has lost some of its shine.
Thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for the review copy.
Thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for the review copy.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This is a great cozy mystery perfect for those who enjoy baking and/or the theatre. The main character runs a bakery, and she and her husband are theatre patrons as well. The mystery of "who done it" is enough to keep you guessing for a while, and the conclusion was most satisfying. Thank you, NetGalley and St. Martin's Press, for the ARC, and the opportunity to provide an honest review.
February 24, 2026
The Whisking Hour by Ellie Alexander is the twenty second installment in a truly beloved cozy mystery series, and while you can technically hop in anywhere, this is absolutely one of those series that rewards long term reading. I binged the entire series over December and January, and at this point, returning to Ashland feels like catching up with family. Jules Capshaw and the Torte crew have become such comfort characters for me, and every visit back to Oregon is layered with warmth, growth, and history that longtime readers will especially appreciate.
This installment leans beautifully into fall vibes—stormy skies over the Siskiyou Mountains, a theatrical production of Perfect Crime, and a cast party catered by Torte featuring delightfully macabre treats (panna cotta “eyeballs,” anyone?). When life imitates art and a lead actor stumbles in with a fatal stab wound, the mystery kicks into gear with all the classic whodunnit fun the series does so well. It’s a solid, engaging case wrapped in atmosphere, community, and of course, mouthwatering descriptions that once again made me wish Torte was a real place I could visit for just one bite of whatever Jules is baking.
One element I especially appreciated was Jules being in her final trimester of pregnancy. Instead of diving headfirst into danger like she often does, she pulls back and allows others to take on more of the sleuthing. It felt realistic and refreshing, she’s still involved and sharp as ever, but not recklessly putting herself in harm’s way. That balance gave the story a slightly different energy while maintaining the strong sense of coziness and community that keeps this series so special. It’s always a joy to be back in Ashland.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
It is always fun to visit Jules, Torte, and the gang. I still love the setting, the theater, and the characters. Being a foodie, I always enjoy the food descriptions, the recipes, and processes involved and whatever the themed food event is going to be. I do think the mysteries are starting to get a little stale, Lance and or Richard will often get on my last nerve, although I have to say Richard added a little levity and a strangely fun mini twist in this one, and I wonder how the author will handle the changes that dual pregnancies will bring to the series. The mystery here was very blah a character involved in one of Lance's shows is murdered after it has been established that everyone connected to the show hates him. There are some supposed stage tricks and traps set, but it just wasn't very compelling, maybe because all the potential murderers were just as unlikable as the victim! Thanks to #Netgally, #MinatourBooks, and the author for an opportunity to read. #TheWhiskingHour #TheBakeShopMysteries #bookreview #bookideas #retiredreader
May 2, 2026
This one felt a little slow to the others in the series. The mystery was okay but there were a lot of unlikable characters and the ending seemed off. The killer was stalking Jules…but actually wasn’t? Hmm…missed opportunity maybe!
Still ready for the next book in this series!
Still ready for the next book in this series!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This was my first book by this author and I really enjoyed it. The cozy mystery based around food and the theater was a nice change from heavier fiction. I really enjoyed the extensive descriptions of the settings, the food and the characters.
Once the murder occurred in the theater, there were any number of possible suspects. The person I thought was guilty changed many times. It ws fun being proven wrong over and over again!
Thanks to Minotaur Books for the digital copy via NetGalley. All thoughts are my own.
Once the murder occurred in the theater, there were any number of possible suspects. The person I thought was guilty changed many times. It ws fun being proven wrong over and over again!
Thanks to Minotaur Books for the digital copy via NetGalley. All thoughts are my own.
February 10, 2026
"The Whisking Hour (A Bakeshop Mystery Book 22)" by Ellie Alexander has Juliet still pregnant with twins. Seriously, still pregnant. How long is this plot line going to go. It's the fourth book now I think. She better have those babies at the very beginning of book 23. It's just crazy considering how much they've had going on.
The other thing for me is that I was thinking they were getting this one solved pretty quick with less Juliet involvement because the babies would be born. When the director of Lance's current play is found dead there's a lot going on. Fingers can be pointed at several people. However, my first suspect was right on target. I did get bounced around a bit though before the final reveal. Still no babies though.
The other thing for me is that I was thinking they were getting this one solved pretty quick with less Juliet involvement because the babies would be born. When the director of Lance's current play is found dead there's a lot going on. Fingers can be pointed at several people. However, my first suspect was right on target. I did get bounced around a bit though before the final reveal. Still no babies though.
February 24, 2026
It’s hard to believe this is the 22nd installment of this series! I started with the first book and have enjoyed all of them. Although you don’t have to have read the previous books but you would definitely miss out on the development of the wonderful characters if you don’t. Over time, the relationships have evolved and it is so integral to the stories.
This time around Lance, Juliet’s BFF and the Artistic Director of the local Shakespearean theater is at the center of the murder mystery. I always love when Lance is around because I love his over the top personality and his sense of humor. The murder victim is one of the actors and there is a long list of suspects that kept me guessing until the end. Because Juliet is very pregnant,she takes a back seat with the investigation, though she is still helping from afar while her friends at the police department take the lead. This crime hits close to home so she is very invested in the outcome.
Coming back to Ashland,Oregon and this tight knit community is like visiting old friends and I look forward to each new book. Torte, the Juliet’s bake shop is always at the core of the stories and I also love that.The recipes featured are included at the end of the book which is a plus if you love to bake.
With the impending birth of Juliet’s twins, there is no doubt the stories will be changing and I’m on board with that and excited to see how motherhood changes Jule’s life in and around the bake shop. This is one of my favorite cozy mystery series and I appreciate having them to read between other books I read with darker, heavier content. The always leave me with the warm and fuzzies!
Special thanks to #MinotaurBooks for my advance reader copy through #NetGalley in exchange for my fair and honest opinion. #cozymystery #newbook #thewhiskinghour
This time around Lance, Juliet’s BFF and the Artistic Director of the local Shakespearean theater is at the center of the murder mystery. I always love when Lance is around because I love his over the top personality and his sense of humor. The murder victim is one of the actors and there is a long list of suspects that kept me guessing until the end. Because Juliet is very pregnant,she takes a back seat with the investigation, though she is still helping from afar while her friends at the police department take the lead. This crime hits close to home so she is very invested in the outcome.
Coming back to Ashland,Oregon and this tight knit community is like visiting old friends and I look forward to each new book. Torte, the Juliet’s bake shop is always at the core of the stories and I also love that.The recipes featured are included at the end of the book which is a plus if you love to bake.
With the impending birth of Juliet’s twins, there is no doubt the stories will be changing and I’m on board with that and excited to see how motherhood changes Jule’s life in and around the bake shop. This is one of my favorite cozy mystery series and I appreciate having them to read between other books I read with darker, heavier content. The always leave me with the warm and fuzzies!
Special thanks to #MinotaurBooks for my advance reader copy through #NetGalley in exchange for my fair and honest opinion. #cozymystery #newbook #thewhiskinghour
January 25, 2026
Thank you to Netgalley and St Martins Press for sending me an advanced copy of this book. I feel honored to have recieved it. I have never read any of this authors books before, but funny enough, I picked up one at the thrift over the summer that is on my list to read. I had to give this book 3 stars. It was fine. Was not the worst book I have ever read and was not the best
Book I have ever read. It was a cozy mysetery. I did like the characters a lot. And i love a good bake shop. The ending was just nothing super exciting as in most like this style. The chapters were a bit long for me in my prefrence of them. I finished it so fast because I skimmed a lot that was extra details. I will still read the other book I have from this author, and I am hoping that it includes these same
Characters.
Book I have ever read. It was a cozy mysetery. I did like the characters a lot. And i love a good bake shop. The ending was just nothing super exciting as in most like this style. The chapters were a bit long for me in my prefrence of them. I finished it so fast because I skimmed a lot that was extra details. I will still read the other book I have from this author, and I am hoping that it includes these same
Characters.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
A Whisking Hour is filled with delicious food being prepared at Torte bakery. The words and food are coming off the page and will make you drool. The Bakeshop mysteries are like visiting friends because I have grown to love all the characters, especially Lance my favorite. Lance has delivered a great new show for the OSF once again. However, these actors might be taking their roles too seriously. She is very pregnant, and Jules is surrounded by her friends and family - including Lance and her fellow bakers. Behind the scenes of this murder-themed play, there is a real murder taking place. As soon as I thought I knew who did it and why there was someone who had the real killing instinct, I realized I was wrong but that did not stop me from enjoying this book.
Thank you Netgalley and the publisher for the advanced copy of this book. This is an honest review.
Thank you Netgalley and the publisher for the advanced copy of this book. This is an honest review.
March 18, 2026
Another Great Cozy Mystery by Ellie ..But is Jules ever having her Twins ??
March 28, 2026
Another great book in this series!
March 12, 2026
This is a long running series that I have enjoyed thoroughly. One of the treats is experiencing the ups and downs and growth of the characters. This one does not disappoint. Juliette is in her last trimester and trying to keep busy while arranging for her upcoming mat leave. The various events that Torte offers are always fun but Lance throw a challenge at her. He wants a themed meal for the cast of his latest production. In three days. And he wants it to help relieve some of the tension amongst the cast and crew.
It only takes moments to discover the source of the problems is the director who has been allowed to run roughshod over everyone. That is until someone decides to put a stop to him. Permanently.
Like so many cozies, there is no shortage of suspects from his ex-wife to the property manager to the actors. One of the things I like about this series is there is no confrontation between Juliette and the local police. In fact, they are rather close and appreciate her insights. There are a number of false starts and twists to the story but it is going to require Jules to have a calm head when she and the killer come face to face. The suspense is high and I half expected labour to start. I won’t tell but there is lots more to discover about our favourite characters. Probably best read as part of the series and in order. Five purrs and two paws up.
It only takes moments to discover the source of the problems is the director who has been allowed to run roughshod over everyone. That is until someone decides to put a stop to him. Permanently.
Like so many cozies, there is no shortage of suspects from his ex-wife to the property manager to the actors. One of the things I like about this series is there is no confrontation between Juliette and the local police. In fact, they are rather close and appreciate her insights. There are a number of false starts and twists to the story but it is going to require Jules to have a calm head when she and the killer come face to face. The suspense is high and I half expected labour to start. I won’t tell but there is lots more to discover about our favourite characters. Probably best read as part of the series and in order. Five purrs and two paws up.
March 16, 2026
I thoroughly enjoyed the 22nd book in this long-running cozy series. It is escapist entertainment wrapped in a warm hug. I ❤️ the setting and all of the characters feel like old friends that I look forward to catching up with. I enjoy all of the descriptions of baking and cooking. I care more about the characters than the mystery, and some readers seem disappointed that the mystery takes a backseat to the story. I think that this is just because Jules, the sleuth, is pregnant and entering a different stage of life, with her priorities shifting.
February 27, 2026
The Whisking Hours is book #22 in the Bakeshop Mystery series by Ellie Alexander. As usual, one can pick up this book out of order because the author does a great job of giving the backstory without sounding too tedious to those who have followed the series for a long time.
This mystery seems a bit darker than the rest and is perfect reading for a dark and stormy night. Our heroine, Juliet, is very pregnant with twins and finalizing her plans for the bakeshop before her maternity leave begins.
At the local theater, there is a Broadway show being performed called A Perfect Crime. When planning a cast party with a murder theme (which was fantastic btw!), an actual murder takes place in the dressing rooms. With Jules and her best friend, Lance, the clues keep coming but the suspects keep changing!
This truly was one that keeps the reader engaged and excited to see what happens next!
I do want to add a personal comment, which I normally do not do in a book review. As someone who has been pregnant with twins, I am wondering the the author talked to moms prior to developing this story line. I had an exceptionally healthy pregnancy with my twins, but even so, I thought the author's perspective on things was a bit uninformed. That said, I think the author did a fantastic job of describing a doting husband and I am glad Jules had someone like Carlos to help her (much like I had my wonderful husband!)
Thank you to Netgalley for an advanced copy of this book!
This mystery seems a bit darker than the rest and is perfect reading for a dark and stormy night. Our heroine, Juliet, is very pregnant with twins and finalizing her plans for the bakeshop before her maternity leave begins.
At the local theater, there is a Broadway show being performed called A Perfect Crime. When planning a cast party with a murder theme (which was fantastic btw!), an actual murder takes place in the dressing rooms. With Jules and her best friend, Lance, the clues keep coming but the suspects keep changing!
This truly was one that keeps the reader engaged and excited to see what happens next!
I do want to add a personal comment, which I normally do not do in a book review. As someone who has been pregnant with twins, I am wondering the the author talked to moms prior to developing this story line. I had an exceptionally healthy pregnancy with my twins, but even so, I thought the author's perspective on things was a bit uninformed. That said, I think the author did a fantastic job of describing a doting husband and I am glad Jules had someone like Carlos to help her (much like I had my wonderful husband!)
Thank you to Netgalley for an advanced copy of this book!
March 11, 2026
This was another great installment in The Bakeshop series by Ellie Alexander. I always love reconnecting with the characters in this series. I feel like I know them and am eager to find out what is happening with each one. It is fun that the mystery took place at the Shakespeare theater in Ashland, Oregon. I was invested in the mystery and in the sub-plots. It kept me turning the pages to find out what was going to happen next. I loved the inclusion of a character from another one of her series. It was a great read and I am eagerly awaiting the next book in the series.
February 24, 2026
Clever Author #EllieAlexander for the title of her latest book of A Bakeshop Mystery. Owner of Torte, Juliet Capshaw, and her capable staff have been whisking up all types of baked goods, breads; roasting coffee for delectable drinks; and arranging and staging Sunday night dinners for family and townspeople of picturesque Ashland, Oregon. Theater director, Lance, and close friend of the soon-to-be mother of Twins Jules, persuades her to cater a feast for the cast of the current murder mystery play complete with all the bloody and gruesome spins one could image for food. The food is ready and just as the first of the crew arrives, a scream rings out as the director of the play, Kean, has been found dead in a dressing room. The suspects could include anyone connected to the play as Kean was not a likable person. Jules manages to talk with (interview) all suspects and passes along vital information to the police. This book is as delightful in all the scents of a kitchen as well as a stirring up a complicated twist of clues to the murder. Thanks to #NetGalley and #StMartinsPress for a digital ARC of this book; this review is wholly my opinion of this book.
February 25, 2026
***I received an ARC from Net Galley in exchange for my honest review
This is the 22nd bakeshop mystery. In this one, it is fall in Ashland, Oregon, and Juliet Capshaw & the rest of the staff at Torte are asked to cater a murderous feast for the cast party, production of the Broadway classic Perfect Crime. They baked up a bevy of creepy concoctions ; panna cotta eyeballs with blood orange coulis, deviled eggs, and savory cheese fingers with pumpkin dipping sauce. On the day of the soirée, a storm rolls through, bringing high winds and heavy rain. The lights are flickering as the actors take the stage, but fortunately they don't lose power. After the final curtain call, as the cast trickles into Carpenter Hall ready to party, an actor is discovered dead in his dressing room.
This book was a lot of fun. I loved the descriptions of all of the food & drinks.....very mouthwatering. Don't read on an empty stomach! There is a great mystery that kept me guessing,, as well. If you enjoy cozy mysteries, especially food & recipe themed, you should definitely check it out.
This is the 22nd bakeshop mystery. In this one, it is fall in Ashland, Oregon, and Juliet Capshaw & the rest of the staff at Torte are asked to cater a murderous feast for the cast party, production of the Broadway classic Perfect Crime. They baked up a bevy of creepy concoctions ; panna cotta eyeballs with blood orange coulis, deviled eggs, and savory cheese fingers with pumpkin dipping sauce. On the day of the soirée, a storm rolls through, bringing high winds and heavy rain. The lights are flickering as the actors take the stage, but fortunately they don't lose power. After the final curtain call, as the cast trickles into Carpenter Hall ready to party, an actor is discovered dead in his dressing room.
This book was a lot of fun. I loved the descriptions of all of the food & drinks.....very mouthwatering. Don't read on an empty stomach! There is a great mystery that kept me guessing,, as well. If you enjoy cozy mysteries, especially food & recipe themed, you should definitely check it out.
March 10, 2026
This is one of my favorite series and the fact that there are TWENTY TWO books?!? I love how she has kept this story going - and growing! I adore the characters and if someone offered me a house in Ashland, I would move tomorrow! I can’t wait for book 23!!
March 12, 2026
When the new play brings in a new cast, things get weird. Method acting taken to far, lies, and podcasts. This was another great adventure. Looking forward to more stories about Torte!
February 20, 2026
My first bakeshop mystery, not my last! This book had a whole cast of characters each with their own motive for the crime that happens! I would definitely classify this as a cozy mystery and I loved the whole vibe of the book. As a person who loves being in the kitchen, I loved the detail and recipes included in the book! It was so fun to try to figure out the purp as the book continued, but it definitely kept me guessing. Mainly since everyone 1. Had a motive and 2. Kept acting so suspect!!! Thank you St Martin’s for sending me this copy!
March 3, 2026
Jules Capshaw is back, this time with twins in her belly. It’s not quite time for the birth, but she is having to cut back on some of her duties at her bakery Torte. But when her best friend Lance wants Torte to create a crime scene dinner for the cast and crew of his latest production, Jules can’t help but say yes.
Lance Rousseau is celebrating the popularity of his latest play, Perfect Crime, a change of pace from his usual Shakespeare. However, the cast is struggling against the director and he is somewhat distracted trying to plan his wedding. But he knows that Jules and Torte can come up with a beautiful spread for the party, even on short notice.
Jules puts her head together with her bakers and cooks, and they prepare some appetizers, a meal, and desserts for Lance’s party. It’s to follow one of the performances. As Jules takes in the space they will have for cooking and for serving, she overhears some of the things happening with the cast. Apparently the director, Kean Armitage, has insisted that his actors use the Method style of acting, staying in character on the stage and off.
So lead actor Roman is skulking around acting menacing at all times, and Blake has felt like someone was following her, causing her to feel increasingly anxious as the days have gone by. Kean’s ex-wife is also in town, as a sketchy theater reviewer and party planner for Lance’s last-minute cast party. And Casey, in charge of the props for the play, is incensed because Kean told Roman to take the prop gun with him outside of the theater, which is just asking for trouble.
And trouble comes, when Kean is shot in the head the evening of the big cast party.
Jules and her crew decide to go ahead and serve the meal they prepared, but instead of a fun cast party, they are serving a serious-minded cast and police officers as they take breaks from gathering evidence and questioning suspects. Lance is taking this murder personally, as it happened in the middle of his perfect murder mystery play, so he enlists Jules to help him investigate. But Jules is now especially vulnerable, so she needs to stay alert to stay out of danger herself.
The Whisking Hour is book 22 in Ellie Alexander’s popular Bakeshop Mystery Series based in Ashland, Oregon. You don’t have to have read the previous books to dive into this one, but there are a lot of recurring characters and much of the activity that’s not about solving the murder is about the bakery and family, which is more meaningful the more of these books you read.
There is a lot of food talk, brownies and meatballs and coffee, so I always have to make sure I have snacks on hand before reading her books. And if you’re a fan of all of Alexander’s books, then there is a truly lovely surprise from her Sloan Krause brewery mystery series. But I do love reading these Bookshop mysteries. They feel make me feel like I’m taking a trip to see friends, getting caught up on all the changes to the town and what everyone is up to (and eating!). I was surprised that the babies weren’t here yet, as this is not the only book where Jules has been pregnant, but otherwise, I had a lot of fun visiting Torte and the gang in Ashland, and I look forward to those babies being born.
Egalleys for The Whishing Hour were provided by Minotaur Books through NetGalley, with many thanks, but the opinions are mine.
Lance Rousseau is celebrating the popularity of his latest play, Perfect Crime, a change of pace from his usual Shakespeare. However, the cast is struggling against the director and he is somewhat distracted trying to plan his wedding. But he knows that Jules and Torte can come up with a beautiful spread for the party, even on short notice.
Jules puts her head together with her bakers and cooks, and they prepare some appetizers, a meal, and desserts for Lance’s party. It’s to follow one of the performances. As Jules takes in the space they will have for cooking and for serving, she overhears some of the things happening with the cast. Apparently the director, Kean Armitage, has insisted that his actors use the Method style of acting, staying in character on the stage and off.
So lead actor Roman is skulking around acting menacing at all times, and Blake has felt like someone was following her, causing her to feel increasingly anxious as the days have gone by. Kean’s ex-wife is also in town, as a sketchy theater reviewer and party planner for Lance’s last-minute cast party. And Casey, in charge of the props for the play, is incensed because Kean told Roman to take the prop gun with him outside of the theater, which is just asking for trouble.
And trouble comes, when Kean is shot in the head the evening of the big cast party.
Jules and her crew decide to go ahead and serve the meal they prepared, but instead of a fun cast party, they are serving a serious-minded cast and police officers as they take breaks from gathering evidence and questioning suspects. Lance is taking this murder personally, as it happened in the middle of his perfect murder mystery play, so he enlists Jules to help him investigate. But Jules is now especially vulnerable, so she needs to stay alert to stay out of danger herself.
The Whisking Hour is book 22 in Ellie Alexander’s popular Bakeshop Mystery Series based in Ashland, Oregon. You don’t have to have read the previous books to dive into this one, but there are a lot of recurring characters and much of the activity that’s not about solving the murder is about the bakery and family, which is more meaningful the more of these books you read.
There is a lot of food talk, brownies and meatballs and coffee, so I always have to make sure I have snacks on hand before reading her books. And if you’re a fan of all of Alexander’s books, then there is a truly lovely surprise from her Sloan Krause brewery mystery series. But I do love reading these Bookshop mysteries. They feel make me feel like I’m taking a trip to see friends, getting caught up on all the changes to the town and what everyone is up to (and eating!). I was surprised that the babies weren’t here yet, as this is not the only book where Jules has been pregnant, but otherwise, I had a lot of fun visiting Torte and the gang in Ashland, and I look forward to those babies being born.
Egalleys for The Whishing Hour were provided by Minotaur Books through NetGalley, with many thanks, but the opinions are mine.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
I always feel a bit like I've overeaten at a scrumptious meal and shared lots of hugs, laughs, and good times with wonderful friends by the time I finish a book in this series. Seriously, don't even think of sitting down to read while you're hungry. I'm not even remotely a foodie but you'll almost feel like the aromas and tastes of the meals and treats being prepared throughout almost seep out of the pages. Given that my usual move is to stick something in the microwave and be done with it, that's high praise from this not-even-pretending-to-be-a-cook reader. It's been a delight to follow the saga of Juliet Capshaw over this series and I've come to think of the characters as old friends. Even those physically missing, such as Carlos' son Ramiro, who was a fun ingredient over the last few books but has returned to Spain for his final school year before college, gets space. Of course, it's always extra fun with the way over the top Lance Rousseau gets to share the spotlight with Juliet/Jules. Oh, boy, wait till you hear some of Lance's ideas for his upcoming wedding. Then there's Jules' mother, Helen, and Shakespeare quoting step-dad Doug, hardly what one expects when contacting the police, as well as officers Thomas and Kelly. And, of course, the entire crew at Torte, Jules' family's amazing bakery. Again, if you weren't hungry when you started the book, you'll be by the time you finish.
So, while I'd say it's the characters that keep me coming back book after book, but Ellie Alexander always offers up an interesting mystery to be solved, too. It was actually quite refreshing to see Jules not rushing off to confront potential murderers or putting herself deliberately in harms' way, something that we can't always say of many amateur sleuths. Maybe that has something to do with the fact Jules' is pregnant with twins and has become more aware of the need to take care of herself. Thus, while wildly curious about the "perfect murder" at the end of a performance of a Lance produced play, we get to see several others take the lead in chasing down not just the clues but suspects. Well, sorta. Nope, not telling. Let's just say that murder party had an unexpected ending and the cast is, well, let's say, all rather weirdly suspicious. True crime podcasts and even AI get their moments, as does some weird method acting. I never quite settled on my choice for whodunit, I have to admit, though. One of those where my best guess kept changing until the end, nearly the very end, in fact.
Bottom line, it's surely obvious I'm a fan of the series and loved the maturity Jules showed in not being the proverbial "too stupid to live". Thanks #StMartin'sPress - #MintaurBooks for the early peek at how Jules' pregnancy and life is going, not to mention whether Lance has driven them all crazy with his impulsive ideas for his wedding. You'll also learn that running a bakery isn't all about bakery. Planning and being able to go with the flow of events, even bad ones, not to mention all the paperwork. Ugh, paperwork doesn't sound at all appetizing. The ending is a delight, too, highlighting the sense of community and family. I'm already ready for the next in the series.
So, while I'd say it's the characters that keep me coming back book after book, but Ellie Alexander always offers up an interesting mystery to be solved, too. It was actually quite refreshing to see Jules not rushing off to confront potential murderers or putting herself deliberately in harms' way, something that we can't always say of many amateur sleuths. Maybe that has something to do with the fact Jules' is pregnant with twins and has become more aware of the need to take care of herself. Thus, while wildly curious about the "perfect murder" at the end of a performance of a Lance produced play, we get to see several others take the lead in chasing down not just the clues but suspects. Well, sorta. Nope, not telling. Let's just say that murder party had an unexpected ending and the cast is, well, let's say, all rather weirdly suspicious. True crime podcasts and even AI get their moments, as does some weird method acting. I never quite settled on my choice for whodunit, I have to admit, though. One of those where my best guess kept changing until the end, nearly the very end, in fact.
Bottom line, it's surely obvious I'm a fan of the series and loved the maturity Jules showed in not being the proverbial "too stupid to live". Thanks #StMartin'sPress - #MintaurBooks for the early peek at how Jules' pregnancy and life is going, not to mention whether Lance has driven them all crazy with his impulsive ideas for his wedding. You'll also learn that running a bakery isn't all about bakery. Planning and being able to go with the flow of events, even bad ones, not to mention all the paperwork. Ugh, paperwork doesn't sound at all appetizing. The ending is a delight, too, highlighting the sense of community and family. I'm already ready for the next in the series.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Dollycas’s Thoughts
Oregon Shakespeare Festival’s theater artistic director extraordinaire, Lance Rousseau, has brought a Broadway classic to Ashland, Oregon. He has put his own spin on Perfect Crime, and performances are selling out. The performers are getting a little weary with only a few shows left, so Lance hires his BFF Jules and the Torte crew to cater a cast party. With tasty treats ready to serve and a storm coming over the Siskiyou Mountains, Jules learns there has been an actual murder at the theatre. The play director is dead, and the entire cast and crew are now playing the real suspects. Lance quickly decides he and Jules will don their sleuthing caps to be sure this killer didn’t commit a “Perfect” murder.
The characters Ms. Alexander has created for this series are well-crafted and continue to evolve with each new story. Jules and Carlos are excited as the birth of their twins draws near. Her mom, Helen, will be stepping in to cover at Torte, but the team at Torte is well-qualified and the best in the business, so there is no worry there. Lance is turning into a bit of a Bridezilla with his crazy wedding ideas. Arlo is a wonderful man with the patience of a saint who loves Lance to the moon and back. Thomas and Kerry are also awaiting a new arrival. I love how these characters come together for each other, no matter what; it is a real family atmosphere.
The murder mystery was very intriguing. Director Kean Armitage was a horrible man with even crazier ideas than Lance. He was most unlikeable and abhorred by anyone forced to work with him. His death was not going to be solved easily with a cast full of suspects. The Professor, Thomas, and Kerry had their hands full. They, along with Lance and Jules, did their best to eliminate people and try to gain focus on the killer, but were still stymied. Don’t worry, Lance had a plan! Oh dear, that usually brings more trouble. Jules did her best to stay out of the fray, protecting herself and her babies. Carlos, still worried. I was on the fence about the guilty party until the very end, but had pared it down to two. The takedown was very satisfying.
To quote the Professor who quoted Rosalind from As You Like It, where she teases Orlando, “I like this place and willingly could waste my time in it.” He reframes what it means to waste our time. I agree, there is nothing better than spending time with family and friends.
The Whisking Hour was another fun visit with Jules and all her friends and family. The mystery had a passel of suspects, twists, and turns, along with entertaining subplots. Foodies will love the recipes included in the story. I would willingly waste my time reading anything written by Ellie Alexander. She is an awesome storyteller. This was another Perfect Escape!
Stay tuned! The Pumpkin Vice Cafe is coming September 29, 2026!
I voluntarily reviewed an Advance Reader Copy. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review. Thank you to Minotaur Books and NetGalley for providing me with an ARC.
Oregon Shakespeare Festival’s theater artistic director extraordinaire, Lance Rousseau, has brought a Broadway classic to Ashland, Oregon. He has put his own spin on Perfect Crime, and performances are selling out. The performers are getting a little weary with only a few shows left, so Lance hires his BFF Jules and the Torte crew to cater a cast party. With tasty treats ready to serve and a storm coming over the Siskiyou Mountains, Jules learns there has been an actual murder at the theatre. The play director is dead, and the entire cast and crew are now playing the real suspects. Lance quickly decides he and Jules will don their sleuthing caps to be sure this killer didn’t commit a “Perfect” murder.
The characters Ms. Alexander has created for this series are well-crafted and continue to evolve with each new story. Jules and Carlos are excited as the birth of their twins draws near. Her mom, Helen, will be stepping in to cover at Torte, but the team at Torte is well-qualified and the best in the business, so there is no worry there. Lance is turning into a bit of a Bridezilla with his crazy wedding ideas. Arlo is a wonderful man with the patience of a saint who loves Lance to the moon and back. Thomas and Kerry are also awaiting a new arrival. I love how these characters come together for each other, no matter what; it is a real family atmosphere.
The murder mystery was very intriguing. Director Kean Armitage was a horrible man with even crazier ideas than Lance. He was most unlikeable and abhorred by anyone forced to work with him. His death was not going to be solved easily with a cast full of suspects. The Professor, Thomas, and Kerry had their hands full. They, along with Lance and Jules, did their best to eliminate people and try to gain focus on the killer, but were still stymied. Don’t worry, Lance had a plan! Oh dear, that usually brings more trouble. Jules did her best to stay out of the fray, protecting herself and her babies. Carlos, still worried. I was on the fence about the guilty party until the very end, but had pared it down to two. The takedown was very satisfying.
To quote the Professor who quoted Rosalind from As You Like It, where she teases Orlando, “I like this place and willingly could waste my time in it.” He reframes what it means to waste our time. I agree, there is nothing better than spending time with family and friends.
The Whisking Hour was another fun visit with Jules and all her friends and family. The mystery had a passel of suspects, twists, and turns, along with entertaining subplots. Foodies will love the recipes included in the story. I would willingly waste my time reading anything written by Ellie Alexander. She is an awesome storyteller. This was another Perfect Escape!
Stay tuned! The Pumpkin Vice Cafe is coming September 29, 2026!
I voluntarily reviewed an Advance Reader Copy. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review. Thank you to Minotaur Books and NetGalley for providing me with an ARC.
February 25, 2026
Many thanks to NetGalley and Minotaur Books for an ARC of this novel.
Incredibly, this is the 22nd book in Ellie Alexander’s Bakeshop series, their very number testifying to the popularity of this cosy mystery set in the pretty little town of Ashland, Oregon. In this volume, we have a very pregnant Juliet Montague Capshaw (Jules). Despite the undoubted physical discomfort and fatigue of carrying twins, Jules is as active as ever in running Torte, the bakery started by her parents. I found myself actually worrying at the way she was running up and down the stairs carrying trays of baked goods and supplies. The food in these books is so lovingly described it practically becomes its own cast of supporting characters.
As always, Jules has her wonderful and infinitely helpful husband Carlos by her side. Everyone is looking forward to the forthcoming babies. She has an efficient, capable, and loyal staff ready to take up extra duties as she gets closer to her due date. All is well. Except that, as this story begins, everyone’s favourite local thespian, actually theatre director/her best friend Lance, asks for ‘a favour.’ He wants her to prepare a dinner for 30 guests on the theme of murder, in keeping with the very popular murder mystery he is staging. She has only 3 days’ notice, but the combined efforts of the Torte team quickly put together an appropriately gory menu.
Naturally, life then imitates art. The director, Kean, that Lance has hired is famous for his theatre skills, but also despised for his arrogance and the pressure he puts on his actors. One of them, Roman, is practically unhinged because Kean insists that he stay in character all the time, and even follows him around to make sure. Kean’s ex-wife, Vera, has also shown up. She is supposed to be a crime podcaster, but her story is flimsy. Why is she really there? She clearly despises Kean as well. Then there are the female actors, whom he did not hesitate to harass in other ways. So, when Kean is found dead of a gunshot wound just before the play opens, there are a number of suspects and some fairly straightforward motivations. The question seems to be not why he was murdered, but who most wanted him dead.
Basically, there is a murder mystery behind a play that is a murder mystery. Jules is obliged to take a somewhat more distanced role than usual, letting her friends in the local police force take the lead. But Jules is nothing if not a mastermind clue collector, and if she does more thinking than active solving, she still does a lot to uncover who did it.
This no. 22 is as much fun as the ones that preceded it, but the same things that make the books fun also, after all this time, make the plot a bit predictable. I do enjoy the food prep but it gets heavy handed. New characters are introduced but the ‘old’ ones don’t seem to change much over time. This is especially true about the lovely but histrionic Lance. Nonetheless, even if this is your introduction to the series, there’s enough detail to fill in what’s needed, and enough suspense to make it a lively mystery.
Incredibly, this is the 22nd book in Ellie Alexander’s Bakeshop series, their very number testifying to the popularity of this cosy mystery set in the pretty little town of Ashland, Oregon. In this volume, we have a very pregnant Juliet Montague Capshaw (Jules). Despite the undoubted physical discomfort and fatigue of carrying twins, Jules is as active as ever in running Torte, the bakery started by her parents. I found myself actually worrying at the way she was running up and down the stairs carrying trays of baked goods and supplies. The food in these books is so lovingly described it practically becomes its own cast of supporting characters.
As always, Jules has her wonderful and infinitely helpful husband Carlos by her side. Everyone is looking forward to the forthcoming babies. She has an efficient, capable, and loyal staff ready to take up extra duties as she gets closer to her due date. All is well. Except that, as this story begins, everyone’s favourite local thespian, actually theatre director/her best friend Lance, asks for ‘a favour.’ He wants her to prepare a dinner for 30 guests on the theme of murder, in keeping with the very popular murder mystery he is staging. She has only 3 days’ notice, but the combined efforts of the Torte team quickly put together an appropriately gory menu.
Naturally, life then imitates art. The director, Kean, that Lance has hired is famous for his theatre skills, but also despised for his arrogance and the pressure he puts on his actors. One of them, Roman, is practically unhinged because Kean insists that he stay in character all the time, and even follows him around to make sure. Kean’s ex-wife, Vera, has also shown up. She is supposed to be a crime podcaster, but her story is flimsy. Why is she really there? She clearly despises Kean as well. Then there are the female actors, whom he did not hesitate to harass in other ways. So, when Kean is found dead of a gunshot wound just before the play opens, there are a number of suspects and some fairly straightforward motivations. The question seems to be not why he was murdered, but who most wanted him dead.
Basically, there is a murder mystery behind a play that is a murder mystery. Jules is obliged to take a somewhat more distanced role than usual, letting her friends in the local police force take the lead. But Jules is nothing if not a mastermind clue collector, and if she does more thinking than active solving, she still does a lot to uncover who did it.
This no. 22 is as much fun as the ones that preceded it, but the same things that make the books fun also, after all this time, make the plot a bit predictable. I do enjoy the food prep but it gets heavy handed. New characters are introduced but the ‘old’ ones don’t seem to change much over time. This is especially true about the lovely but histrionic Lance. Nonetheless, even if this is your introduction to the series, there’s enough detail to fill in what’s needed, and enough suspense to make it a lively mystery.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Special thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for a free, electronic ARC of this novel received in exchange for an honest review.
Expected publication date: Feb. 24, 2026
“The Whisking Hour” is the twenty-second book in “The Bakeshop Mysteries” series by author Ellie Alexander.
Bakery owner, and head baker, Juliet Capshaw is preparing for a murder-themed party, celebrating a new theatre production, with Juliet’s best friend, Lance, as the theatre director. But what she doesn’t expect is the tension between the actors, and most of it is directed toward the show’s director, Kean, and it takes everything Juliet has to just try and stay out of the drama for the party. Of course, this doesn’t work out so well when Kean’s body is found, thrusting all of the actors and stage crew in a different kind of spotlight. Although Juliet knows the police are doing all they can, she can’t help but look into herself, and what she discovers is not at all what she expected.
“Hour” was my first book by Alexander, and my first foray into this series in general. The characters were all new to me, but I was still able to keep up and remain engaged throughout. It is obvious that character relationships have developed throughout the series, and the details of those were shared in other books, but this particular storyline was focused on a stand-alone mystery, and less on the character relationships, which made it easier for a newbie like me to keep up with.
Juliet is a baker, so expect lots of sweet treats, as well as how she crafts them, to show up often and regularly. She continues to run her bakery, even though her pregnancy will soon have her leaving the bake shop to take maternity leave, but she seems to have a decent set of workers to support her, as the funny and quirky backup characters were a perfect complement to Juliet.
The mystery itself was well developed, but I was slightly underwhelmed by the ending. The final pages revealed the suspect, but it seemed forced and rushed, and the explanation around this discovery was brushed over. I would’ve liked to have known more of the specific details on how this particular suspect committed the crime, but at least the ending provided an answer to most of the questions.
“Hour” is a murder mystery that takes place while a murder mystery is being performed on stage, with a delicious and delectable backdrop of absolutely mouth-watering treats and delicacies. I enjoyed the fast-paced storyline and Juliet was a relatable and likable protagonist. The ending was satisfying, even if I wanted a bit more detail, and I’m invested enough in Juliet and her crew to pick up the next novel in the series.
Expected publication date: Feb. 24, 2026
“The Whisking Hour” is the twenty-second book in “The Bakeshop Mysteries” series by author Ellie Alexander.
Bakery owner, and head baker, Juliet Capshaw is preparing for a murder-themed party, celebrating a new theatre production, with Juliet’s best friend, Lance, as the theatre director. But what she doesn’t expect is the tension between the actors, and most of it is directed toward the show’s director, Kean, and it takes everything Juliet has to just try and stay out of the drama for the party. Of course, this doesn’t work out so well when Kean’s body is found, thrusting all of the actors and stage crew in a different kind of spotlight. Although Juliet knows the police are doing all they can, she can’t help but look into herself, and what she discovers is not at all what she expected.
“Hour” was my first book by Alexander, and my first foray into this series in general. The characters were all new to me, but I was still able to keep up and remain engaged throughout. It is obvious that character relationships have developed throughout the series, and the details of those were shared in other books, but this particular storyline was focused on a stand-alone mystery, and less on the character relationships, which made it easier for a newbie like me to keep up with.
Juliet is a baker, so expect lots of sweet treats, as well as how she crafts them, to show up often and regularly. She continues to run her bakery, even though her pregnancy will soon have her leaving the bake shop to take maternity leave, but she seems to have a decent set of workers to support her, as the funny and quirky backup characters were a perfect complement to Juliet.
The mystery itself was well developed, but I was slightly underwhelmed by the ending. The final pages revealed the suspect, but it seemed forced and rushed, and the explanation around this discovery was brushed over. I would’ve liked to have known more of the specific details on how this particular suspect committed the crime, but at least the ending provided an answer to most of the questions.
“Hour” is a murder mystery that takes place while a murder mystery is being performed on stage, with a delicious and delectable backdrop of absolutely mouth-watering treats and delicacies. I enjoyed the fast-paced storyline and Juliet was a relatable and likable protagonist. The ending was satisfying, even if I wanted a bit more detail, and I’m invested enough in Juliet and her crew to pick up the next novel in the series.
December 21, 2025
Ellie Alexander’s The Whisking Hour is the literary equivalent of wrapping yourself in a soft sweater while chaos politely unfolds nearby and someone, inevitably, ends up dead.
St. Martin’s Press / Minotaur Books, thank you so much for my gifted ARC via NetGalley, which I happily devoured with zero crumbs left behind.
This installment drops us straight into peak fall in Ashland, Oregon, and I could practically hear the rain tapping the windows while I read. There’s theatre drama, literal stage drama, and the kind of stormy atmosphere that makes you feel like something terrible is not only possible but scheduled. Jules is gearing up to cater a murder-themed cast party for a production of Perfect Crime, which is already flirting with irony before the body even drops. Add flickering lights, theatrical egos, and a cast full of secrets, and you’ve got a setup that feels both cozy and ominous in the best possible way.
Let’s talk about the food, because wow. If you read this book hungry, that’s on you. The descriptions of baked goods and savory treats are borderline aggressive, and I mean that as a compliment. Panna cotta eyeballs, cheese fingers, pumpkin sauces, comfort food layered with just enough macabre flair to fit the theme. The kitchen scenes are some of my favorites, not just because they made me crave carbs, but because they highlight how much Jules trusts her team now. There’s a real sense of growth and stability here that longtime readers will appreciate.
Jules herself is heavily pregnant in this book, and I loved that this actually mattered. She’s not sprinting into danger or ignoring common sense. She’s thoughtful, cautious, and aware of her limits, which was honestly refreshing. The mystery unfolds around her rather than because of reckless choices, and it made the story feel grounded without losing momentum.
The theatre setting adds an extra layer of fun. Everyone is already pretending to be someone else, so figuring out who’s lying feels like part of the performance. The suspect pool is solid, motives are layered, and just when I thought I had it figured out, the story nudged me sideways again. It’s not wildly shocking, but it doesn’t need to be. This is comfort reading with a pulse.
What really got me, though, was the emotional payoff. Beneath the murder and the pastries, this book is about community, friendship, and showing up for one another when it counts. The ending leans into that theme hard, and yes, it absolutely got me misty. I blame hormones. And good writing.
“Autumn comes with pumpkin spice, cinnamon rolls, and a heaping tablespoon of murder.”
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5 stars
#TheWhiskingHour #EllieAlexander #ABakeshopMystery #CozyMystery #BookReview #NetGalley #ARCReview #MysteryBooks #CozyReads #FallReads
St. Martin’s Press / Minotaur Books, thank you so much for my gifted ARC via NetGalley, which I happily devoured with zero crumbs left behind.
This installment drops us straight into peak fall in Ashland, Oregon, and I could practically hear the rain tapping the windows while I read. There’s theatre drama, literal stage drama, and the kind of stormy atmosphere that makes you feel like something terrible is not only possible but scheduled. Jules is gearing up to cater a murder-themed cast party for a production of Perfect Crime, which is already flirting with irony before the body even drops. Add flickering lights, theatrical egos, and a cast full of secrets, and you’ve got a setup that feels both cozy and ominous in the best possible way.
Let’s talk about the food, because wow. If you read this book hungry, that’s on you. The descriptions of baked goods and savory treats are borderline aggressive, and I mean that as a compliment. Panna cotta eyeballs, cheese fingers, pumpkin sauces, comfort food layered with just enough macabre flair to fit the theme. The kitchen scenes are some of my favorites, not just because they made me crave carbs, but because they highlight how much Jules trusts her team now. There’s a real sense of growth and stability here that longtime readers will appreciate.
Jules herself is heavily pregnant in this book, and I loved that this actually mattered. She’s not sprinting into danger or ignoring common sense. She’s thoughtful, cautious, and aware of her limits, which was honestly refreshing. The mystery unfolds around her rather than because of reckless choices, and it made the story feel grounded without losing momentum.
The theatre setting adds an extra layer of fun. Everyone is already pretending to be someone else, so figuring out who’s lying feels like part of the performance. The suspect pool is solid, motives are layered, and just when I thought I had it figured out, the story nudged me sideways again. It’s not wildly shocking, but it doesn’t need to be. This is comfort reading with a pulse.
What really got me, though, was the emotional payoff. Beneath the murder and the pastries, this book is about community, friendship, and showing up for one another when it counts. The ending leans into that theme hard, and yes, it absolutely got me misty. I blame hormones. And good writing.
“Autumn comes with pumpkin spice, cinnamon rolls, and a heaping tablespoon of murder.”
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5 stars
#TheWhiskingHour #EllieAlexander #ABakeshopMystery #CozyMystery #BookReview #NetGalley #ARCReview #MysteryBooks #CozyReads #FallReads
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Jules is expecting! Ashland is a hub of activity as usual with an exciting new play at OSF, lots of catering events at Torte, and Lance deep into planning the wedding of the century to fiancé Arlo but Juliet is trying to take it easy as she prepares for maternity leave. Though Juliet knows she shouldn't be digging into any crimes with not one but two buns in the oven, she can't help herself when her murder-themed after party becomes a bit more true to theme than anyone planned.
This series is a favorite of mine. In general I read cozies in the order of release but this series I started with book 17, Catch Me If You Candy, then read book 18, A Smoking Bun, before going back to the beginning and binge-reading the first books. I was supposed to be reading them as part of a group series read but I couldn't pace myself and read them one after another long before I was supposed to read them. I might have gotten a bit more out of the later books if I'd read the series in order and seen the evolution of the characters in real-time but I don't think I enjoyed the books any less. The setting it so perfect, the characters so lovely, every visit to Ashland is a true pleasure.
There were some bittersweet things in this book, as can happen with a series you get really invested in. Ramiro has gone back to Spain and Jules misses him terribly. She's excited to welcome her two babies but their impending birth is also bittersweet because her own father won't be there to meet his new grandbabies. But while there was a hint of sadness there was also so much love. The entire community is reaching out to support Jules and Carlos and Torte, helping them make sure Torte stays up and running while Jules is on maternity leave and Jules and Lance even go so far as to attend Richard Lord's viewing of his new reality show to show their support for a man who's done nothing but cause them headaches. Because that's what you do in Ashland.
The mystery in this book was also really interesting, centering around the cast of a new play. All the actors are sus and Jules can't help but allow Lance to pull her into things, though everyone is keeping a very close eye on their favorite baker and her precious cargo. The only thing I will say about the mystery is that it all came together... until Thomas was explaining to Jules what had happened. And it didn't make any sense. As the truth was revealed previously I was on board and everything was clear but when Thomas started explaining things he added some details that didn't fit in with anything else. But easy enough to shrug off and move on.
This is definitely a series that any cozy fan needs to read!
Thank you to the author, publisher, and NetGalley for providing me with an ARC.
This series is a favorite of mine. In general I read cozies in the order of release but this series I started with book 17, Catch Me If You Candy, then read book 18, A Smoking Bun, before going back to the beginning and binge-reading the first books. I was supposed to be reading them as part of a group series read but I couldn't pace myself and read them one after another long before I was supposed to read them. I might have gotten a bit more out of the later books if I'd read the series in order and seen the evolution of the characters in real-time but I don't think I enjoyed the books any less. The setting it so perfect, the characters so lovely, every visit to Ashland is a true pleasure.
There were some bittersweet things in this book, as can happen with a series you get really invested in. Ramiro has gone back to Spain and Jules misses him terribly. She's excited to welcome her two babies but their impending birth is also bittersweet because her own father won't be there to meet his new grandbabies. But while there was a hint of sadness there was also so much love. The entire community is reaching out to support Jules and Carlos and Torte, helping them make sure Torte stays up and running while Jules is on maternity leave and Jules and Lance even go so far as to attend Richard Lord's viewing of his new reality show to show their support for a man who's done nothing but cause them headaches. Because that's what you do in Ashland.
The mystery in this book was also really interesting, centering around the cast of a new play. All the actors are sus and Jules can't help but allow Lance to pull her into things, though everyone is keeping a very close eye on their favorite baker and her precious cargo. The only thing I will say about the mystery is that it all came together... until Thomas was explaining to Jules what had happened. And it didn't make any sense. As the truth was revealed previously I was on board and everything was clear but when Thomas started explaining things he added some details that didn't fit in with anything else. But easy enough to shrug off and move on.
This is definitely a series that any cozy fan needs to read!
Thank you to the author, publisher, and NetGalley for providing me with an ARC.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
The Whisking Hour
is the twenty-second book in the Bakeshop Mystery series by Ellie Alexander. This cozy mystery is set in Ashland, Oregon and features Jules Capshaw, her husband Carlos, best friend Lance, his significant other, Arlo, and the team at Torte. Torte is the bakery started by Jules’s parents.
This story is centered around theater artistic director Lance’s production of a murder mystery that has been getting terrific reviews. The play is about a group of suspects and the so-called perfect murder. Jules and her team have been asked to cater a cast party with a murder theme. Unfortunately, a member of the crew is found murdered.
Jules is expecting twins in a few weeks. She’s a great mentor to the staff and has recently promoted some of them as she prepares for maternity leave. Carlos is a supportive and loving husband. He runs their winery. Lance is some-what over-the-top, but a dedicated artistic director. He’s tenderhearted, but has an inclination for theatrics. His ideas for his and Arlo’s wedding and reception are hilarious. The early chapters allow readers to catch up with repeat characters.
The story starts at Torte with readers being introduced to many of the staff, but it takes until chapter eight before the mystery gets fully underway. There are plenty of twists and turns and several suspects. The cozy small-town atmosphere and worldbuilding is great. A big positive for this book is the relationships. However, there are long segments with talk about food, Jules’s pregnancy, and her family, friends, and neighbors. This makes the murder take a back seat when it should have been the focus.
Overall, this is an entertaining and fun small-town cozy mystery that focuses more on food, friendship, family, community, and helping others than the mystery itself.
St. Martin’s Press – Minotaur Books and Ellie Alexander provided a complimentary digital ARC of this novel via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions expressed in this review are my own. Publication date is currently set for February 24, 2026.
-----------------------------------
My 3.27 rounded to 3 stars review is coming soon.
This story is centered around theater artistic director Lance’s production of a murder mystery that has been getting terrific reviews. The play is about a group of suspects and the so-called perfect murder. Jules and her team have been asked to cater a cast party with a murder theme. Unfortunately, a member of the crew is found murdered.
Jules is expecting twins in a few weeks. She’s a great mentor to the staff and has recently promoted some of them as she prepares for maternity leave. Carlos is a supportive and loving husband. He runs their winery. Lance is some-what over-the-top, but a dedicated artistic director. He’s tenderhearted, but has an inclination for theatrics. His ideas for his and Arlo’s wedding and reception are hilarious. The early chapters allow readers to catch up with repeat characters.
The story starts at Torte with readers being introduced to many of the staff, but it takes until chapter eight before the mystery gets fully underway. There are plenty of twists and turns and several suspects. The cozy small-town atmosphere and worldbuilding is great. A big positive for this book is the relationships. However, there are long segments with talk about food, Jules’s pregnancy, and her family, friends, and neighbors. This makes the murder take a back seat when it should have been the focus.
Overall, this is an entertaining and fun small-town cozy mystery that focuses more on food, friendship, family, community, and helping others than the mystery itself.
St. Martin’s Press – Minotaur Books and Ellie Alexander provided a complimentary digital ARC of this novel via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions expressed in this review are my own. Publication date is currently set for February 24, 2026.
-----------------------------------
My 3.27 rounded to 3 stars review is coming soon.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 168 reviews