What do you think?
Rate this book
Clay Hawkins #1
Liar's Creek
From New York Times bestselling author and Emmy Award-winner Matt Goldman comes Liar's Creek, which asks how far we'll go to protect the people we love.
The small town of Riverwood, Minnesota is true to its name, brimming with beautiful scenes of nature. Its rural landscape is threaded with scenic trout streams, which carve their way through limestone bluffs. But beneath its picturesque facade, danger runs rampant.
Clay Hawkins isn’t a stranger to the secrets of his hometown. After twenty years away, Clay has recently returned home from abroad with his twelve-year-old son Braedon, and his relationship with his father Judd, the recently replaced sheriff, is as strained as ever.
Trouble immediately brews for Clay when his beloved uncle, Teddy, disappears. Together, the three generations of Hawkinses must overturn every stone in Riverwood and confront deep familial wounds to find the one person who brings them together. As danger looms, Clay worries that it might be too late to save Teddy—and that the rest of the family might be next.
The small town of Riverwood, Minnesota is true to its name, brimming with beautiful scenes of nature. Its rural landscape is threaded with scenic trout streams, which carve their way through limestone bluffs. But beneath its picturesque facade, danger runs rampant.
Clay Hawkins isn’t a stranger to the secrets of his hometown. After twenty years away, Clay has recently returned home from abroad with his twelve-year-old son Braedon, and his relationship with his father Judd, the recently replaced sheriff, is as strained as ever.
Trouble immediately brews for Clay when his beloved uncle, Teddy, disappears. Together, the three generations of Hawkinses must overturn every stone in Riverwood and confront deep familial wounds to find the one person who brings them together. As danger looms, Clay worries that it might be too late to save Teddy—and that the rest of the family might be next.
336 pages, Paperback
Published May 5, 2026
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 29 of 237 reviews
February 23, 2026
2 stars
Not for me!
A man returns to his childhood hometown with his preteen son after being away for twenty years. He has a difficult relationship with his father who is the retired Chief of police in their small town. Upon his arrival, the man’s uncle goes missing and he finds himself wrapped up in the missing persons investigation.
The premise of this story held high appeal to me, especially with the vivid nature setting descriptions, but the execution failed to draw me in. I enjoyed the small town vibe, where everyone knows everyone. There are some nature focused scenes that I liked, but I had hoped for more palpable atmosphere. I wanted to feel the setting more vividly.
One of my issues causing my lack of investment was the characters. I didn’t connect with any of them. Some were cliches, others were simply uninteresting. There is a love triangle in the story that was cringey and cheesy. I had zero investment in any of the relationships. I also found the pace quite slow.
The storyline itself was nothing new. Small town citizens investigating a crime alongside local police. After the first quarter, I became bored and indifferent. The plot had several implausible elements and many character interactions had me rolling my eyes.
Bottom line, I am not the right reader for this book. Please check out the other reviews that show more favourable opinions before deciding on this one.
Audio rating: 4 stars! The narrator did a great job and kept me listening. Although I wasn’t engrossed in the story, I did enjoy the way the audio narrator presented it. He uses an Irish accent for some of the characters that worked well for me. The audio narrator is what kept me from DNF’ing this one.
Thank you to the publisher for my advanced listening copy!
Not for me!
A man returns to his childhood hometown with his preteen son after being away for twenty years. He has a difficult relationship with his father who is the retired Chief of police in their small town. Upon his arrival, the man’s uncle goes missing and he finds himself wrapped up in the missing persons investigation.
The premise of this story held high appeal to me, especially with the vivid nature setting descriptions, but the execution failed to draw me in. I enjoyed the small town vibe, where everyone knows everyone. There are some nature focused scenes that I liked, but I had hoped for more palpable atmosphere. I wanted to feel the setting more vividly.
One of my issues causing my lack of investment was the characters. I didn’t connect with any of them. Some were cliches, others were simply uninteresting. There is a love triangle in the story that was cringey and cheesy. I had zero investment in any of the relationships. I also found the pace quite slow.
The storyline itself was nothing new. Small town citizens investigating a crime alongside local police. After the first quarter, I became bored and indifferent. The plot had several implausible elements and many character interactions had me rolling my eyes.
Bottom line, I am not the right reader for this book. Please check out the other reviews that show more favourable opinions before deciding on this one.
Audio rating: 4 stars! The narrator did a great job and kept me listening. Although I wasn’t engrossed in the story, I did enjoy the way the audio narrator presented it. He uses an Irish accent for some of the characters that worked well for me. The audio narrator is what kept me from DNF’ing this one.
Thank you to the publisher for my advanced listening copy!
May 6, 2026
A novel about 3 generations of men in the Hawkins family. It begins when Clay returns home to his small town Riverwood, MN with his twelve year old son, Braedon. Clay’s reception by his father, Judd is icy even after twenty years. It’s the tension between father and son and years of no communication. Judd is also feeling resentful after being let go from the police department.
It’s slow in that there isn’t a lot of suspense, but that’s made up by character development and the landscape descriptions. The narrative does move along well when it’s revealed Clay’s favorite uncle, which is Judd’s twin brother Teddy is missing. What unfolds is a fulfilling mystery with familial relationships uncovered.
Matthew Goldman is a new author to me and I look forward to the next book in this series. I recommend for those who appreciate character development in a mystery.
Thanks to NetGalley and Minotaur Books for early access.
It’s slow in that there isn’t a lot of suspense, but that’s made up by character development and the landscape descriptions. The narrative does move along well when it’s revealed Clay’s favorite uncle, which is Judd’s twin brother Teddy is missing. What unfolds is a fulfilling mystery with familial relationships uncovered.
Matthew Goldman is a new author to me and I look forward to the next book in this series. I recommend for those who appreciate character development in a mystery.
Thanks to NetGalley and Minotaur Books for early access.
May 28, 2026
With a setting in the tiny and friendly rural town of Riverwood, Minnesota, Matt Goldman has weaved together a novel that not only includes mystery and suspense….but also a strong dose of love, loss, romance, redemption, and complicated family dynamics. When Clay Hawkins returns home after spending many years in Europe as a professional soccer player, the tension and estrangement between he and his father, Judd, is fully palpable. Even though the central plot focuses around the search for Clay’s beloved uncle, who has gone missing, nearly all the central characters in the novel seems to have deep and personal secrets…which leads to one heck of roller coaster ride filled with unexpected twists and turns.
On more than one occasion, I thought I had things pretty well figured out…only to discover that I was far off-base. In any event, Goldman tied things together for a very satisfying ending, as well as the possibility of a second book to follow Liar’s Creek. Better yet, this was definitely a 5-star read!
On more than one occasion, I thought I had things pretty well figured out…only to discover that I was far off-base. In any event, Goldman tied things together for a very satisfying ending, as well as the possibility of a second book to follow Liar’s Creek. Better yet, this was definitely a 5-star read!
May 11, 2026
(4.25 stars)
Thank you to Minotaur Books and Macmillan Audio for the opportunity to read and listen to an advance copy of Liar’s Creek by Matt Goldman. This was my first book by this author and now I’m going to check out his backlist.
Liar’s Creek is the first book in a new series that focuses on Clay Hawkins and is set in a small town in southern Minnesota, Riverwood. Clay is quite an interesting character - he grew up in that town, went off to West Point and then became a professional soccer player in Europe. Now he’s back in Minnesota, to coach for his alma mater, a local private high school. He’s had a very difficult relationship with his father for years (estranged, is probably the best word for this) and now he’s brought his 12-year-old son Braedon with him, who hits it off fabulously with his new-to-him grandfather. This puts Clay in the middle, struggling to establish a decent relationship with his dad, Judd, the town’s former police chief.
Clay’s uncle Teddy (Judd’s twin brother, a bit of a character) is missing, which forms the narrative arc of the book, but I really enjoyed the relationship building aspects of the story, along with the mystery of what happened to Teddy. Clay displays a lot of “smarts” as they try to figure out where Teddy went and what happened to him, smarts that you wouldn’t think a pro soccer player has. And so we guess there’s more to Clay than meets the eye.
The local townspeople were great and quite varied. The new police chief, Zoey, is partly Native American, for example. Clay’s mother died when he was young and Judd’s new “girlfriend”, Mai, is a doctor at the famed Mayo Clinic, which isn’t too far away. I appreciated the inclusion of strong women characters, along with the male relationships. Braedon is a charming 12-year-old, trying to figure out life in the US (he was living in Ireland prior to this). The descriptions of the area landscape and tidbits about fly fishing were lovely to read.
The audiobook was well narrated by Fred Berman.
I’m looking forward to the next book in this series.
Thank you to Minotaur Books and Macmillan Audio for the opportunity to read and listen to an advance copy of Liar’s Creek by Matt Goldman. This was my first book by this author and now I’m going to check out his backlist.
Liar’s Creek is the first book in a new series that focuses on Clay Hawkins and is set in a small town in southern Minnesota, Riverwood. Clay is quite an interesting character - he grew up in that town, went off to West Point and then became a professional soccer player in Europe. Now he’s back in Minnesota, to coach for his alma mater, a local private high school. He’s had a very difficult relationship with his father for years (estranged, is probably the best word for this) and now he’s brought his 12-year-old son Braedon with him, who hits it off fabulously with his new-to-him grandfather. This puts Clay in the middle, struggling to establish a decent relationship with his dad, Judd, the town’s former police chief.
Clay’s uncle Teddy (Judd’s twin brother, a bit of a character) is missing, which forms the narrative arc of the book, but I really enjoyed the relationship building aspects of the story, along with the mystery of what happened to Teddy. Clay displays a lot of “smarts” as they try to figure out where Teddy went and what happened to him, smarts that you wouldn’t think a pro soccer player has. And so we guess there’s more to Clay than meets the eye.
The local townspeople were great and quite varied. The new police chief, Zoey, is partly Native American, for example. Clay’s mother died when he was young and Judd’s new “girlfriend”, Mai, is a doctor at the famed Mayo Clinic, which isn’t too far away. I appreciated the inclusion of strong women characters, along with the male relationships. Braedon is a charming 12-year-old, trying to figure out life in the US (he was living in Ireland prior to this). The descriptions of the area landscape and tidbits about fly fishing were lovely to read.
The audiobook was well narrated by Fred Berman.
I’m looking forward to the next book in this series.
June 18, 2026
Early thoughts: This book reminds me of my highschool boyfriends back when I loved grunge rock and trouble.
Feeling: atmospheric and gritty
I’m curious about: nothing yet
Final thoughts: I'm not always a fan of mysteries because I feel that the mystery at the heart of the book isn't accessible enough for me to connect. I still want a good plot and compelling characters, too. I felt immediately connected to the story, here. MMC returns to small home town to raise his son and gets involved in a car part theft ring. I buy into that because I know this is the kind of story that rivets an entire small town.
For me though, the pace is choppy. An interesting beginning sort of devolves into a cat and mouse, if the cats all carried guns. The story progression becomes uneven. The arc is anticlimactic. In my opinion, the ending of a mystery should not only solve the mystery, but offer closure for the story and character arcs. This story was a little soft here, I thought.
I don't know. I wanted to like it, even did like it at one point. But it didn't keep my interest.
What worked:
🔎 Well-constructed, compelling mystery
🌎 The characters and I didn't share a worldview, but the author didn't make it didactic. There was no kind of political statement being made here, or at least it wasn't smacking the reader in the face.
What didn’t:
🧳 I found this story a little claustrophobic after a while.
Who this is for: fans of small town mystery thrillers
Rating: ⭐⭐.5
Thank you NetGalley and publisher for the arc!📚
Content Notes:
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
loss of a parent, moving house, tiny towns, patriotism, animal suffering, animal cruelty, animal death, hunting, fishing, small town politics, guns, kids with guns,
Feeling: atmospheric and gritty
I’m curious about: nothing yet
Final thoughts: I'm not always a fan of mysteries because I feel that the mystery at the heart of the book isn't accessible enough for me to connect. I still want a good plot and compelling characters, too. I felt immediately connected to the story, here. MMC returns to small home town to raise his son and gets involved in a car part theft ring. I buy into that because I know this is the kind of story that rivets an entire small town.
For me though, the pace is choppy. An interesting beginning sort of devolves into a cat and mouse, if the cats all carried guns. The story progression becomes uneven. The arc is anticlimactic. In my opinion, the ending of a mystery should not only solve the mystery, but offer closure for the story and character arcs. This story was a little soft here, I thought.
I don't know. I wanted to like it, even did like it at one point. But it didn't keep my interest.
What worked:
🔎 Well-constructed, compelling mystery
🌎 The characters and I didn't share a worldview, but the author didn't make it didactic. There was no kind of political statement being made here, or at least it wasn't smacking the reader in the face.
What didn’t:
🧳 I found this story a little claustrophobic after a while.
Who this is for: fans of small town mystery thrillers
Rating: ⭐⭐.5
Thank you NetGalley and publisher for the arc!📚
Content Notes:
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
loss of a parent, moving house, tiny towns, patriotism, animal suffering, animal cruelty, animal death, hunting, fishing, small town politics, guns, kids with guns,
June 19, 2026
I went into this book blindly and it was my first time reading anything by Matt Goldman. I ended up really enjoying this book - it's a good example to readers to explore new authors and stories because you'll find new gems like Liar's Creek!
Fred Berman does a wonderful job narrating this story. He paces himself and savours every word, which is something I really appreciate in a narrator - when they're enjoying the story as much as you and the author!
The reason I gave this book 4 stars instead of 5 is because I found the plot slowed down too much in certain places.
Thank you MacMillan Audio for the gifted ALC of Liar's Creek in exchange for my honest review!
Fred Berman does a wonderful job narrating this story. He paces himself and savours every word, which is something I really appreciate in a narrator - when they're enjoying the story as much as you and the author!
The reason I gave this book 4 stars instead of 5 is because I found the plot slowed down too much in certain places.
Thank you MacMillan Audio for the gifted ALC of Liar's Creek in exchange for my honest review!
March 9, 2026
I listened to this on audiobook and really enjoyed the narration by Fred Berman. I loved Matt Goldmans last book so was keen to read this one. It wasn’t as fast paced as ai expected, and was more of a character story than anything but with a mystery at the centre.
I did like the characters of Clay Hawkins, a former soccer superstar in Ireland, and his young son Braedon . Both trying to find their feet on a different continent. Clays uncle has gone missing and he is trying to find out what happened. His father is the former sheriff and they have a strained relationship.
I feel there is more to come for these characters with the way this one ended, I look forward to reading it.
Thanks to Macmillan Audio for my early copy to listen to on NetGalley. Out on April 21st.
I did like the characters of Clay Hawkins, a former soccer superstar in Ireland, and his young son Braedon . Both trying to find their feet on a different continent. Clays uncle has gone missing and he is trying to find out what happened. His father is the former sheriff and they have a strained relationship.
I feel there is more to come for these characters with the way this one ended, I look forward to reading it.
Thanks to Macmillan Audio for my early copy to listen to on NetGalley. Out on April 21st.
April 24, 2026
Fathers, sons, and small-town secrets.
Riverwood, located in southeast Minnesota, is a picturesque town where the scenery is beautiful and the community is tight-knit. When Clay Hawkins, son of the former chief of police turned international soccer star, returns home with his young son after twenty years away, he's pulled straight back into old tensions - especially with his father, Judd, the recently retired lawman. But when Clay's uncle - Teddy, Judd's twin brother - disappears, three generations of Hawkins men are forced to dig into the past to uncover what's really going on.
Matt Goldman's Liar's Creek isn't a nail-biter, but more of a slow unraveling - less about shocking twists and more about peeling back layers, both of the central mystery and of the Hawkins family itself (and it's all the better for it). The suspense is there, but it builds gradually, and while most of the reveals aren't particularly surprising, they're still satisfying in how they bring everything together. (One notable exception: a certain reveal about Clay that finally makes a few things click into place.)
What really stood out to me were the expertly drawn family dynamics. The relationships between fathers and sons, and the weight of history in a small town, all feel grounded and thoughtfully developed. The Hawkins' backstory, in particular, adds depth and gives the mystery real emotional stakes. Zoey, the new chief of police, is a another standout, and the cast overall feels strong enough to carry a series.
Appropriately, the pacing is slow and steady at first, taking its time to establish characters and setting, before picking up momentum toward the end. It works, especially if you go in expecting something more character-driven than plot-twist-heavy.
The audiobook, expertly narrated by Fred Berman, is a great match for the story. His delivery is steady and engaging, and he does a great job differentiating between characters. His narration definitely enhanced the overall experience for me.
Overall, Liar’s Creek is a character-driven, quietly engaging mystery - less about shocking you and more about drawing you in. A solid, atmospheric start to the Clay Hawkins series - I wouldn't mind spending more time with this group in the future.
Many thanks to Macmillan Audio for providing me with an ALC of the audiobook via NetGalley in exchange for my honest review.
"Liar's Creek" was published on April 21, 2026, and is available now.
Riverwood, located in southeast Minnesota, is a picturesque town where the scenery is beautiful and the community is tight-knit. When Clay Hawkins, son of the former chief of police turned international soccer star, returns home with his young son after twenty years away, he's pulled straight back into old tensions - especially with his father, Judd, the recently retired lawman. But when Clay's uncle - Teddy, Judd's twin brother - disappears, three generations of Hawkins men are forced to dig into the past to uncover what's really going on.
Matt Goldman's Liar's Creek isn't a nail-biter, but more of a slow unraveling - less about shocking twists and more about peeling back layers, both of the central mystery and of the Hawkins family itself (and it's all the better for it). The suspense is there, but it builds gradually, and while most of the reveals aren't particularly surprising, they're still satisfying in how they bring everything together. (One notable exception: a certain reveal about Clay that finally makes a few things click into place.)
What really stood out to me were the expertly drawn family dynamics. The relationships between fathers and sons, and the weight of history in a small town, all feel grounded and thoughtfully developed. The Hawkins' backstory, in particular, adds depth and gives the mystery real emotional stakes. Zoey, the new chief of police, is a another standout, and the cast overall feels strong enough to carry a series.
Appropriately, the pacing is slow and steady at first, taking its time to establish characters and setting, before picking up momentum toward the end. It works, especially if you go in expecting something more character-driven than plot-twist-heavy.
The audiobook, expertly narrated by Fred Berman, is a great match for the story. His delivery is steady and engaging, and he does a great job differentiating between characters. His narration definitely enhanced the overall experience for me.
Overall, Liar’s Creek is a character-driven, quietly engaging mystery - less about shocking you and more about drawing you in. A solid, atmospheric start to the Clay Hawkins series - I wouldn't mind spending more time with this group in the future.
Many thanks to Macmillan Audio for providing me with an ALC of the audiobook via NetGalley in exchange for my honest review.
"Liar's Creek" was published on April 21, 2026, and is available now.
April 17, 2026
Wow! This was stressful… and riveting… and sweet… and tied to family, and friendships, and tough times, and good times , and, basically life in general in a small town…
Three generations of Hawkins men are featured in this one.
Judd…the Father/Grandfather… who’s also the ex chief of police. He’s tough and fair.
Teddy… the sweet, beloved guy in town who always seems to be getting himself in trouble, but at the same time is happy to help any and everyone. (He’s Judd’s twin.)
Clay… Judd’s son who just returned back from England after many years. He was a professional soccer player and coach, but has now returned home with his 12 year old son. (Braeden). And, he has many great memories with his Uncle Teddy from when he was young, but not so much with his Dad… being chief of police and all…
They each carry their own crosses for separate reasons… but, Clay wants to try to work things out with his Dad for his son’s sake…
So, when his beloved Uncle Teddy goes missing, an all out search for him is prompted… and no-one will rest until they are able to get to the bottom of it!
BUT…things don’t always go as planned, and each time some new evidence shows up, it seems to get crushed, and they’re back to square one.
And… some old secrets are stirred up, as well as rivalries and more. Plus, add in a new chief of police who’s a woman (Zoe) … and well, there’s a lot going on!
Terrific story. Wonderful revelations. And… peeling back the layers on each character was amazing!
Of note, this looks to be book #1 in a new series! (Yay!!).
Looking forward to reading more from this very talented author!
#LiarsCreek by @MattGoldman and narrated wonderfully by @FredBerman.
THIS ONE HAS NOT BEEN RELEASED YET! Please look 👀 for it on 4/21/26 (perNetGalley, although Goodreads has a May date… so, not really sure.)
4 1/2 whopping, scary, breath-holding, family-working-through-their-problems stars for me! 🌟🌟🌟🌟💫…. Happily rounded up to 5!!!!
Thanks so much to #NetGalley and @MacmillanAudio for an ALC of the audiobook in exchange for an honest review.
You can also find my reviews on: Goodreads,
Instagram: @BookReviews_with_emsr and/or
My Facebook Book Club: Book Reviews With Elaine
Thanks so much for reading! And if you ‘liked’ my review, please share with your friends, & click ‘LIKE’ below… And, let me know YOUR thoughts if you read it!!
And as always, thanks for reading along with me! 📚⭐️📖🩷
Three generations of Hawkins men are featured in this one.
Judd…the Father/Grandfather… who’s also the ex chief of police. He’s tough and fair.
Teddy… the sweet, beloved guy in town who always seems to be getting himself in trouble, but at the same time is happy to help any and everyone. (He’s Judd’s twin.)
Clay… Judd’s son who just returned back from England after many years. He was a professional soccer player and coach, but has now returned home with his 12 year old son. (Braeden). And, he has many great memories with his Uncle Teddy from when he was young, but not so much with his Dad… being chief of police and all…
They each carry their own crosses for separate reasons… but, Clay wants to try to work things out with his Dad for his son’s sake…
So, when his beloved Uncle Teddy goes missing, an all out search for him is prompted… and no-one will rest until they are able to get to the bottom of it!
BUT…things don’t always go as planned, and each time some new evidence shows up, it seems to get crushed, and they’re back to square one.
And… some old secrets are stirred up, as well as rivalries and more. Plus, add in a new chief of police who’s a woman (Zoe) … and well, there’s a lot going on!
Terrific story. Wonderful revelations. And… peeling back the layers on each character was amazing!
Of note, this looks to be book #1 in a new series! (Yay!!).
Looking forward to reading more from this very talented author!
#LiarsCreek by @MattGoldman and narrated wonderfully by @FredBerman.
THIS ONE HAS NOT BEEN RELEASED YET! Please look 👀 for it on 4/21/26 (perNetGalley, although Goodreads has a May date… so, not really sure.)
4 1/2 whopping, scary, breath-holding, family-working-through-their-problems stars for me! 🌟🌟🌟🌟💫…. Happily rounded up to 5!!!!
Thanks so much to #NetGalley and @MacmillanAudio for an ALC of the audiobook in exchange for an honest review.
You can also find my reviews on: Goodreads,
Instagram: @BookReviews_with_emsr and/or
My Facebook Book Club: Book Reviews With Elaine
Thanks so much for reading! And if you ‘liked’ my review, please share with your friends, & click ‘LIKE’ below… And, let me know YOUR thoughts if you read it!!
And as always, thanks for reading along with me! 📚⭐️📖🩷
June 8, 2026
A small town with a murder at the center. This one is fun because of the setting and the history of the town being woven in, but ultimately it was another small town murder where the citizens investigate and solve the case, even if Clay is not an ordinary citizen.
There were lots of little sprinkles of things that I think will evolve as the series continues that would be fun to follow up on.
Thank you to NetGalley, the author Matt Goldman, and Macmillan audio for my copy of this audiobook.
There were lots of little sprinkles of things that I think will evolve as the series continues that would be fun to follow up on.
Thank you to NetGalley, the author Matt Goldman, and Macmillan audio for my copy of this audiobook.
June 9, 2026
3.5 stars. Slow burn family drama mystery. Looking forward to a book #2
Review of advance copy received from Goodreads Giveaways
I received Liar's Creek through a goodreads giveaway. It was my first Matt Goldman book and I appreciated the author's adept handling of a small-town narrative infused with family trauma and mystery. I enjoyed the author's writing style and was kept captivated by the plot twists and turns.
May 13, 2026
Character-Rich Crime Fiction
In crime fiction, you hear a lot about propulsive twists and heart-thudding suspense and adrenaline-jacking thrills … but you don’t often hear about a story in which all of those things are subordinated to surprising character depth, and is better off for it. This is a story about people above all who have toughness and courage but sometimes can’t get out of their own way — or their own pasts — to see those strengths within themselves until prodded to do so by someone else in a not-dissimilar state of being. The plot just happens to be the conveyance that gets them to this infinitely satisfying place. LIAR’S CREEK is one of my top reads of 2026.
In crime fiction, you hear a lot about propulsive twists and heart-thudding suspense and adrenaline-jacking thrills … but you don’t often hear about a story in which all of those things are subordinated to surprising character depth, and is better off for it. This is a story about people above all who have toughness and courage but sometimes can’t get out of their own way — or their own pasts — to see those strengths within themselves until prodded to do so by someone else in a not-dissimilar state of being. The plot just happens to be the conveyance that gets them to this infinitely satisfying place. LIAR’S CREEK is one of my top reads of 2026.
May 20, 2026
Small towns seem appeal to readers of fiction for various reasons. After being away from his hometown in Minnesota for two decades, Clay Hawkins returns with his twelve year old son in tow. Clay has had a lucrative career in Ireland as a professional footballer (soccer player).
Clay and his Dad have never had a good relationship, though Clay's son Braedon seems to immediately form a strong bond with his grandfather. Clay's father, Judd, was the sheriff of Riverwood, but now he has retired, the position has been taken by a woman, an attractive, strong woman named Zoey Jensen. A woman whom Clay finds very appealing...
Shortly after Clay's return to Riverwood, his uncle Teddy goes missing. Teddy is a likeable rascal, who has been known to be no stranger to trouble of his own making. Teddy's nephew Clay and his brother Judd, put aside their differences to search for him.
Though essentially a mystery as to what happened to Uncle Teddy, this novel also broaches some other narrative threads. Estranged family, inter-generational relationships, parenting, family dynamics, and re-connection.
This is a slow paced, multi-layered story. The protagonist was a likeable man with a past that proves more intriguing than one might first have assumed. The descriptions were well written, and the peripheral characters well delineated. All good for a first novel of a proposed series. That being said, I don't think I was the right reader for this book, and I probably will not pursue the Clay Hawkins' series. In my personal opinion, this is a mystery novel that will appeal more strongly to male readers. There is much talk about fishing and other manly pursuits and the male viewpoint is prevalent.
I listened to the story on audiobook, and I'm very glad I did. Fred Berman's narration brought an interest and authenticity to the narrative that kept me engaged in a story that I might otherwise have skimmed through. I do think the audiobook might have been improved though, if a female narrator did the female voices.
In summation, a slow paced family drama with a mystery on the side.
Clay and his Dad have never had a good relationship, though Clay's son Braedon seems to immediately form a strong bond with his grandfather. Clay's father, Judd, was the sheriff of Riverwood, but now he has retired, the position has been taken by a woman, an attractive, strong woman named Zoey Jensen. A woman whom Clay finds very appealing...
Shortly after Clay's return to Riverwood, his uncle Teddy goes missing. Teddy is a likeable rascal, who has been known to be no stranger to trouble of his own making. Teddy's nephew Clay and his brother Judd, put aside their differences to search for him.
Though essentially a mystery as to what happened to Uncle Teddy, this novel also broaches some other narrative threads. Estranged family, inter-generational relationships, parenting, family dynamics, and re-connection.
This is a slow paced, multi-layered story. The protagonist was a likeable man with a past that proves more intriguing than one might first have assumed. The descriptions were well written, and the peripheral characters well delineated. All good for a first novel of a proposed series. That being said, I don't think I was the right reader for this book, and I probably will not pursue the Clay Hawkins' series. In my personal opinion, this is a mystery novel that will appeal more strongly to male readers. There is much talk about fishing and other manly pursuits and the male viewpoint is prevalent.
I listened to the story on audiobook, and I'm very glad I did. Fred Berman's narration brought an interest and authenticity to the narrative that kept me engaged in a story that I might otherwise have skimmed through. I do think the audiobook might have been improved though, if a female narrator did the female voices.
In summation, a slow paced family drama with a mystery on the side.
May 20, 2026
***ARC received from Minotaur Books and NetGalley, opinions are all my own. Thank you!***
How far would you go to protect the people you love? The book sets up an interesting concept, what would be willing to do for the people that we love and while at times it gets close it ultimately didn’t work out for me.
This book should be at its strongest when it is exploring the relationships between father figures and sons and sometimes it gets there but unfortunately it really struggled with it at time. Clay and Judd are struggling to rebuild their relationship after Clay leaves to go play football in Europe and the strain in the relationship was handled well, there is clear rift between the pair and it was really believable. It had built over years since the death of Clay’s mother as they took different paths. Sadly for how well the strain was handled the resolution felt so forced it never felt like they earned their bond back which was a shame. I also liked the relationship between grandfather and grandson that despite the strain with father and son Clay never wants to have his son not build a bond with his grandfather which was really great to see.
For me the writing just doesn’t work, it was far to much telling and so little showing. There are hints about the setting, the creek and daily activity of the area but it gets lost in the, we did this, then this and now this. It makes it hard to connect with the characters and really get into the depth of the story telling. Which made for me the heart of the story which is the missing uncle just not that interesting. I felt no investment in wanting him to return, or that the characters missed him. We know they do because the book tells us but at the resolution to his disappearance there feels like so little of an emotional impact.
The book is also just doing too much, setting up too many characters, too many potential story lines that have an impact on the story that just felt forced. I can’t tell if this is setting up for a series but it doesn’t need to shove everything into the first book when you just wanting to dip your toes into the world and want more.
There is so much potential here but it gets bogged down in the writing and just wanting to do too much.
How far would you go to protect the people you love? The book sets up an interesting concept, what would be willing to do for the people that we love and while at times it gets close it ultimately didn’t work out for me.
This book should be at its strongest when it is exploring the relationships between father figures and sons and sometimes it gets there but unfortunately it really struggled with it at time. Clay and Judd are struggling to rebuild their relationship after Clay leaves to go play football in Europe and the strain in the relationship was handled well, there is clear rift between the pair and it was really believable. It had built over years since the death of Clay’s mother as they took different paths. Sadly for how well the strain was handled the resolution felt so forced it never felt like they earned their bond back which was a shame. I also liked the relationship between grandfather and grandson that despite the strain with father and son Clay never wants to have his son not build a bond with his grandfather which was really great to see.
For me the writing just doesn’t work, it was far to much telling and so little showing. There are hints about the setting, the creek and daily activity of the area but it gets lost in the, we did this, then this and now this. It makes it hard to connect with the characters and really get into the depth of the story telling. Which made for me the heart of the story which is the missing uncle just not that interesting. I felt no investment in wanting him to return, or that the characters missed him. We know they do because the book tells us but at the resolution to his disappearance there feels like so little of an emotional impact.
The book is also just doing too much, setting up too many characters, too many potential story lines that have an impact on the story that just felt forced. I can’t tell if this is setting up for a series but it doesn’t need to shove everything into the first book when you just wanting to dip your toes into the world and want more.
There is so much potential here but it gets bogged down in the writing and just wanting to do too much.
June 10, 2026
This was an excellent mystery that kept me hooked from beginning to end. Riverwood, Minnesota was brought to life so vividly that it felt like a character in its own right. The scenic trout streams, limestone bluffs, and small-town atmosphere created the perfect backdrop for a story filled with secrets, tension, and danger lurking beneath the surface.
What really made this book stand out for me was the family dynamic. The relationship between Clay, his son, and his father added an emotional depth that elevated the story beyond a typical missing-person mystery. The author did a fantastic job exploring generational wounds, complicated family relationships, and the ways people come together when everything is on the line.
The mystery itself was compelling and well-paced. As Clay searches for his missing uncle, the stakes continue to rise, and I found myself constantly wanting to read just one more chapter. There were enough twists and surprises to keep me guessing without feeling unrealistic or overdone.
I especially appreciated how the story balanced suspense with heartfelt moments. The emotional connections between the characters made me genuinely care about what happened to them, which made the danger feel even more real.
Thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press | Minotaur Books for a digital ARC.
What really made this book stand out for me was the family dynamic. The relationship between Clay, his son, and his father added an emotional depth that elevated the story beyond a typical missing-person mystery. The author did a fantastic job exploring generational wounds, complicated family relationships, and the ways people come together when everything is on the line.
The mystery itself was compelling and well-paced. As Clay searches for his missing uncle, the stakes continue to rise, and I found myself constantly wanting to read just one more chapter. There were enough twists and surprises to keep me guessing without feeling unrealistic or overdone.
I especially appreciated how the story balanced suspense with heartfelt moments. The emotional connections between the characters made me genuinely care about what happened to them, which made the danger feel even more real.
Thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press | Minotaur Books for a digital ARC.
May 3, 2026
I was really excited to read this book, but unfortunately it fell short for me. Part of that was I think the narrator, Fred Berman, I think he did absolutely terrible female voices. The male voices were fine, and in fact he had some very diverse voices for different characters (although I'm not sure they remained consistent throughout the audiobook, especially the Irish). But the female voices were just, in my opinion, quite terrible. I also do not think the characters were well-developed. Certain twists were just thrown in there, which honestly just felt so unbelievable. And even the ending was a bit anti-climactic. I'm sure there is an audience for this book, it was unfortunately just not me.
Thank you to NetGalley and Macmillan Audio for the eARC Aubiobook!!
Thank you to NetGalley and Macmillan Audio for the eARC Aubiobook!!
May 7, 2026
This is more of a family and small town drama rather than a thriller. Yes there is the mystery of Teddy Hawkins disappearance, but in many ways that disappearance takes a backseat to the relationship dynamics between the other characters. It’s a good story, but I honestly found it to be slow and not all that suspenseful. Those who like character driven stories with family and small town drama may really enjoy this book, but it missed the mark for me.
June 23, 2026
A fun mystery about a missing person and a family’s quest to find him. I feel we had some different side stories also going on here and some of the beginning was extra information to fill the space (I now know a lot about fly fishing) but overall the last 50% kept me interested!
May 15, 2026
After being away for 20 years playing soccer & traveling the world, Clay Hawkins (with his 12 year old son Braeden) move back to Clay’s small Minnesota hometown and estranged father Judd, who is also the former police chief. Judd’s twin brother Teddy goes missing & the Hawkins men have to put aside family conflicts & work together to find him.
I thought this was an enjoyable small town crime thriller with a solid mystery & interesting characters. The setting of Riverwood, MN is vivid & atmospheric … but not in a Mayberry “aww shucks” kind of way … more in a “secrets run deep here & ain’t nobody talkin’ about it” kind of way!
I’ll admit, it took me a hot minute to settle into the scene but once I got into the groove I was heavily invested to find out what happened to poor Uncle Teddy. I had several guesses of what I thought went down, but I didn’t get it right in the end. Nice little twist.
This story surprised me with not only an engaging plot, but also characters that won me over & amused me. The banter between Clay & Zoey is great & I loved them together. The author left us with a little bit of an open ending on some of the storylines and I’m happy to spend more time with these folks & see where this new series goes!
Thank you to St Martins Press & Minotaur for the gifted arc!
I thought this was an enjoyable small town crime thriller with a solid mystery & interesting characters. The setting of Riverwood, MN is vivid & atmospheric … but not in a Mayberry “aww shucks” kind of way … more in a “secrets run deep here & ain’t nobody talkin’ about it” kind of way!
I’ll admit, it took me a hot minute to settle into the scene but once I got into the groove I was heavily invested to find out what happened to poor Uncle Teddy. I had several guesses of what I thought went down, but I didn’t get it right in the end. Nice little twist.
This story surprised me with not only an engaging plot, but also characters that won me over & amused me. The banter between Clay & Zoey is great & I loved them together. The author left us with a little bit of an open ending on some of the storylines and I’m happy to spend more time with these folks & see where this new series goes!
Thank you to St Martins Press & Minotaur for the gifted arc!
April 30, 2026
This review was originally posted on Books of My Heart
Review copy was received from NetGalley. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
I have read other books by Matt Goldman and a series. Initially, I was drawn to the Minnesota settings. Liar's Creek has a Minnesota setting but for me, it's more about the character developments than the plot.
We have the father, Judd who was the sheriff in their smaller town, while his son Clay was growing up. After his wife died, his grief was huge and he wasn't the best father. Clay made his own way with his skills in soccer and music, attending a private school and then West Point based on his scholarship. He became a soccer star in college and after leaving West Point.
Clay is now home with his son Braedon, to coach at his alma mater private high school. His father, has been replaced as sheriff. His uncle Teddy, Judd's twin is missing. They both work on trying to find him. Judd using his contacts on the force. Clay though talks to the new sheriff.
Clay is adjusting to being back in his home town for the first time since high school and after years living and working in Europe. It's Braedon's first US experience. But Clay wanted him to have family. The story is just full of these relationships and their various personal developments.
I loved the mystery and the police procedural aspects of the investigation. I loved the various romantic connections of each of the three generations of men. I am beyond thrilled this is the first in the Clay Hawkins series . I look forward to more in this small town of Riverwood, MN which tries to take care of its own.
Narration:
I have listened to Fred Berman in another series but don't recall anything specific. The voices for the different characters were distinct and well performed. It was easy to recognize who was speaking. Both male and female voices, as well as a few accents felt appropriate. I listened at my newer 1.75x speed
Listen to a clip: HERE
Review copy was received from NetGalley. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
I have read other books by Matt Goldman and a series. Initially, I was drawn to the Minnesota settings. Liar's Creek has a Minnesota setting but for me, it's more about the character developments than the plot.
We have the father, Judd who was the sheriff in their smaller town, while his son Clay was growing up. After his wife died, his grief was huge and he wasn't the best father. Clay made his own way with his skills in soccer and music, attending a private school and then West Point based on his scholarship. He became a soccer star in college and after leaving West Point.
Clay is now home with his son Braedon, to coach at his alma mater private high school. His father, has been replaced as sheriff. His uncle Teddy, Judd's twin is missing. They both work on trying to find him. Judd using his contacts on the force. Clay though talks to the new sheriff.
Clay is adjusting to being back in his home town for the first time since high school and after years living and working in Europe. It's Braedon's first US experience. But Clay wanted him to have family. The story is just full of these relationships and their various personal developments.
I loved the mystery and the police procedural aspects of the investigation. I loved the various romantic connections of each of the three generations of men. I am beyond thrilled this is the first in the Clay Hawkins series . I look forward to more in this small town of Riverwood, MN which tries to take care of its own.
Narration:
I have listened to Fred Berman in another series but don't recall anything specific. The voices for the different characters were distinct and well performed. It was easy to recognize who was speaking. Both male and female voices, as well as a few accents felt appropriate. I listened at my newer 1.75x speed
Listen to a clip: HERE
May 17, 2026
Matt Goldman's LIAR’S CREEK strikes us emotionally in ways that mystery novels rarely aim for or achieve. As a matter of fact, its genre may be accurately described as “family novel” or “unusual love story,” as well as “mystery.” The characters are, indeed, filled with love for each other. While they recognize each other's flaws, they're often able to overlook them because of their very touching and warm relationships.
The protagonist is Clay Hawkins, a man in his 30s who has lived through a most unusual set of adventures and experiences. He lost his mom, Pam, to cancer when he was 13, which has haunted him --- and his father, Judd --- for the rest of their lives.
Although Clay and Judd share those powerful emotions, they do not like each other. Their problems had begun long before Pam's death. When Clay was an unhappy infant in his crib, he stopped crying when Pam hugged him. When Judd picked him up, the crying got louder and nastier. And things went downhill from there. Clay was a bright, sensitive, talented boy. He became a promising violinist and lover of music, a fine student, and an outstanding athlete whose sport of choice was soccer. Tough and unyielding, Judd was the chief of police in their tiny hometown of Riverwood, Minnesota. He had dreams for his son, none of which apparently would ever be fulfilled. The older both of them got, the more they grew apart.
However, as compelling as the conflicts between that father and son are, even more fascinating is the story of Clay and his son, Braedon. That relationship began with an event that draws us directly into an emotional storm. At this point, an explanation of how the pair came to “meet” is necessary. But we must begin that story with a bit more information about Clay's young life.
Clay managed to enroll in an exclusive private high school to which he earned entry because of his many talents --- and without telling his father. He was a star on the school's soccer team and received offers from many colleges but quite surprisingly picked West Point, where his soccer stardom continued. And Judd once again had no input in his son's decisions. After West Point, he chose European professional soccer as his life's occupation. Again, he was a star.
Then, one night after a game, Clay went to a bar and met a lovely young lady with whom he immediately became enchanted. And she apparently returned the feeling. They spent the night together, and he tried repeatedly to call her the next day, but she refused to respond. He saw her only one more time, and that resulted in a shocking development. Months later, he was alone at home when his doorbell rang. When he opened the door, she was standing there, holding an infant in her arms. She told him that he was the baby's father, and she was offering him the opportunity to keep the child --- because she would not. Ultimately, he decided to raise the baby and named him Braedon.
The relationship between this father and son is in every way the opposite of Clay and Judd's. It does become complicated at this point but remains logical and understandable. Clay and Braedon represent a virtually perfect father-son bond, sharing wonderful ideals and times together. When Clay decides to quit his life as a traveling soccer star, he chooses to go back home with his son to live in the town in which he grew up. Braedon meets Judd, and their relationship is special and entirely positive. Braedon is almost like the son Judd never had, despite the ongoing difficulties between Judd and Clay.
But now we are introduced to the character whose fate becomes the primary plot thread for the rest of the novel. That's Teddy Hawkins, a truly fascinating guy whose personality defies consistency, logic or even accurate description.
Teddy has been a favorite of everyone who has ever known him. He's a ne'er-do-well who has never been able to hold a job, plan a realistic future, or be proven reliable in any way or in any circumstance. Yet above all, he's lovable and loving. He's Judd's younger brother, and Judd has spent most of his life protecting the “kid.” He's also, of course, Clay's uncle and Braedon's great-uncle, and he's been married for years to a patient and ultra-thoughtful woman named Deb.
The rest of the novel's cast includes several people who are significant contributors to Teddy's story. Among them are Zoey, the new chief of the Riverwood police force since Judd was fired because the town was allegedly looking for new blood. But despite the awkwardness of the situation, Judd did a more than respectable job of training her for her new position. Zoey and Clay are immediately attracted to each other. We also meet Stephanie, the owner of a beauty shop and Clay's girlfriend when the two were teenagers. Clay is the only male who is a regular customer at Steph's place. Then there are three teenage juvenile delinquents who give Braedon and his friend, Daniel, a very rough time and pull some disgusting and dangerous stunts. One of those kids is Steph's unruly son, who was born when she was married to an adult delinquent named Wags.
Teddy has disappeared and for a frighteningly long time has not reappeared. The search for him features the individuals above, all of whom like and/or love him. The unfolding of this most important plot thread includes a kidnapping threat; some surprising revelations about Clay's life and career; and deeds that are both heroic and villainous, performed by unexpectedly heroic characters. But the big questions that remain regard Teddy's disappearance. Did he just decide to take a trip without telling anyone or preparing anyone for it? (He's done that kind of thing before.) Was he kidnapped? Is his life endangered? Was he murdered? Did he die by suicide? Did he commit a crime and decide to just run away rather than face the consequences? Had he fallen in with some dangerous, maybe even evil characters? Will his loved ones ever see him again?
These questions are answered via a semi-happy but certainly melancholy climax and denouement. The climax itself revolves around a subtle and gentle twist that's worthy of any fine mystery novel. Matt Goldman has done a magnificent job of presenting a series of knotty plot threads and then cleverly untying those knots. Along the way, he has given us well-rounded characters who communicate some valuable lessons about the power of close relationships, the nobility of forgiveness, and the overwhelming beauty of familial love.
LIAR’S CREEK is altogether a brilliantly conceived and effectively executed novel of love and suspense. I highly recommend it.
Reviewed by Jack Kramer
The protagonist is Clay Hawkins, a man in his 30s who has lived through a most unusual set of adventures and experiences. He lost his mom, Pam, to cancer when he was 13, which has haunted him --- and his father, Judd --- for the rest of their lives.
Although Clay and Judd share those powerful emotions, they do not like each other. Their problems had begun long before Pam's death. When Clay was an unhappy infant in his crib, he stopped crying when Pam hugged him. When Judd picked him up, the crying got louder and nastier. And things went downhill from there. Clay was a bright, sensitive, talented boy. He became a promising violinist and lover of music, a fine student, and an outstanding athlete whose sport of choice was soccer. Tough and unyielding, Judd was the chief of police in their tiny hometown of Riverwood, Minnesota. He had dreams for his son, none of which apparently would ever be fulfilled. The older both of them got, the more they grew apart.
However, as compelling as the conflicts between that father and son are, even more fascinating is the story of Clay and his son, Braedon. That relationship began with an event that draws us directly into an emotional storm. At this point, an explanation of how the pair came to “meet” is necessary. But we must begin that story with a bit more information about Clay's young life.
Clay managed to enroll in an exclusive private high school to which he earned entry because of his many talents --- and without telling his father. He was a star on the school's soccer team and received offers from many colleges but quite surprisingly picked West Point, where his soccer stardom continued. And Judd once again had no input in his son's decisions. After West Point, he chose European professional soccer as his life's occupation. Again, he was a star.
Then, one night after a game, Clay went to a bar and met a lovely young lady with whom he immediately became enchanted. And she apparently returned the feeling. They spent the night together, and he tried repeatedly to call her the next day, but she refused to respond. He saw her only one more time, and that resulted in a shocking development. Months later, he was alone at home when his doorbell rang. When he opened the door, she was standing there, holding an infant in her arms. She told him that he was the baby's father, and she was offering him the opportunity to keep the child --- because she would not. Ultimately, he decided to raise the baby and named him Braedon.
The relationship between this father and son is in every way the opposite of Clay and Judd's. It does become complicated at this point but remains logical and understandable. Clay and Braedon represent a virtually perfect father-son bond, sharing wonderful ideals and times together. When Clay decides to quit his life as a traveling soccer star, he chooses to go back home with his son to live in the town in which he grew up. Braedon meets Judd, and their relationship is special and entirely positive. Braedon is almost like the son Judd never had, despite the ongoing difficulties between Judd and Clay.
But now we are introduced to the character whose fate becomes the primary plot thread for the rest of the novel. That's Teddy Hawkins, a truly fascinating guy whose personality defies consistency, logic or even accurate description.
Teddy has been a favorite of everyone who has ever known him. He's a ne'er-do-well who has never been able to hold a job, plan a realistic future, or be proven reliable in any way or in any circumstance. Yet above all, he's lovable and loving. He's Judd's younger brother, and Judd has spent most of his life protecting the “kid.” He's also, of course, Clay's uncle and Braedon's great-uncle, and he's been married for years to a patient and ultra-thoughtful woman named Deb.
The rest of the novel's cast includes several people who are significant contributors to Teddy's story. Among them are Zoey, the new chief of the Riverwood police force since Judd was fired because the town was allegedly looking for new blood. But despite the awkwardness of the situation, Judd did a more than respectable job of training her for her new position. Zoey and Clay are immediately attracted to each other. We also meet Stephanie, the owner of a beauty shop and Clay's girlfriend when the two were teenagers. Clay is the only male who is a regular customer at Steph's place. Then there are three teenage juvenile delinquents who give Braedon and his friend, Daniel, a very rough time and pull some disgusting and dangerous stunts. One of those kids is Steph's unruly son, who was born when she was married to an adult delinquent named Wags.
Teddy has disappeared and for a frighteningly long time has not reappeared. The search for him features the individuals above, all of whom like and/or love him. The unfolding of this most important plot thread includes a kidnapping threat; some surprising revelations about Clay's life and career; and deeds that are both heroic and villainous, performed by unexpectedly heroic characters. But the big questions that remain regard Teddy's disappearance. Did he just decide to take a trip without telling anyone or preparing anyone for it? (He's done that kind of thing before.) Was he kidnapped? Is his life endangered? Was he murdered? Did he die by suicide? Did he commit a crime and decide to just run away rather than face the consequences? Had he fallen in with some dangerous, maybe even evil characters? Will his loved ones ever see him again?
These questions are answered via a semi-happy but certainly melancholy climax and denouement. The climax itself revolves around a subtle and gentle twist that's worthy of any fine mystery novel. Matt Goldman has done a magnificent job of presenting a series of knotty plot threads and then cleverly untying those knots. Along the way, he has given us well-rounded characters who communicate some valuable lessons about the power of close relationships, the nobility of forgiveness, and the overwhelming beauty of familial love.
LIAR’S CREEK is altogether a brilliantly conceived and effectively executed novel of love and suspense. I highly recommend it.
Reviewed by Jack Kramer
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
When a disgraced sheriff, a violinist ex-soccer-pro single dad, and a mysteriously vanishing uncle walk into a small Minnesotan town, you’d think we were gearing up for something juicy. And to be fair, Liar’s Creek absolutely flirts with the potential for juicy. It just never quite commits. This book is like a simmering pot of family secrets and trout streams that someone forgot to turn all the way up to boil.
Clay Hawkins returns to Riverwood after two decades abroad with his emotionally advanced twelve-year-old son Braedon (who I would die for, btw), only to immediately be pulled into a missing-persons case when his uncle Teddy ghosts harder than my last Hinge match. Also, Clay’s dad Judd just got ousted as sheriff, and their dynamic is a Hallmark card that someone set on fire. So. That’s the tension. You’ve got generational trauma, a town full of suspiciously closed mouths, and an ex-soldier turned reluctant investigator with a secret stash of dad guilt. Let’s go!
Now, I love a slow burn as much as the next emotionally unstable reader, but this is less slow burn and more slow simmer while your tea goes cold and you forget what you’re waiting for. The emotional arcs? Solid. The mystery? There. The pacing? Like being stuck behind a tractor on a two-lane road in February. The good news is, Goldman’s writing has a warm, lived-in quality that really nails the small-town atmosphere. You believe this place exists, even if you’re screaming into the void because every man in this town talks like he was raised by an REI catalog and a roll of duct tape.
Clay, for better or worse, is a very male protagonist. He’s quiet, angsty, deeply repressed, and casually checking out every woman he meets like he’s been starved of estrogen for twenty years. It doesn’t ruin the book, but it does make you go, “Sir… I beg you to journal.” His relationship with Braedon is the standout here. Genuinely sweet and layered, especially as Braedon starts asking questions about his absent mother and starts developing opinions about his grandfather’s entire deal (spoiler: Judd’s vibe is “emotionally constipated military dad,” and I say that with affection).
Uncle Teddy’s disappearance drives the plot, but it’s really just an excuse to trap these emotionally illiterate men in a metaphorical (and sometimes literal) cabin together until they start processing feelings like adults. And by “like adults,” I mean through poorly timed confessions, light violence, and aggressive fishing metaphors. Throw in a suspicious ransom note, some low-key corruption, and the hint of a romantic subplot with the new sheriff Zoey (love her, she deserves a better man and at least one nap), and you’ve got all the ingredients for a very moody, very Midwestern stew.
Unfortunately, the big reveal lands with more of a soft shrug than a gasp. It’s not bad, but it’s giving “we had to wrap this up before Braedon aged out of his precocious phase.” There are too many red herrings and not enough actual payoff, which left me feeling like I’d just opened a can of LaCroix expecting champagne.
All that said, I would read the sequel. Not because I’m dying for more mystery, but because I need to know if Clay ever learns how to emote without brooding in the woods. Also, if Zoey doesn’t get a bigger arc where she takes down some institutional corruption and maybe adopts a dog, I will riot.
I’m giving this one 3.5 stars for strong vibes, complicated dad energy, and a town full of secrets that almost slaps. It's like prestige TV that skipped one too many therapy sessions.
Whodunity Award: For Most Emotionally Repressed Men in a Canoe
Big thanks to St. Martin’s Press and NetGalley for the ARC. You really said, “Here, have a small town full of daddy issues and suppressed emotions,” and I devoured it like emotionally stunted literary comfort food.
Clay Hawkins returns to Riverwood after two decades abroad with his emotionally advanced twelve-year-old son Braedon (who I would die for, btw), only to immediately be pulled into a missing-persons case when his uncle Teddy ghosts harder than my last Hinge match. Also, Clay’s dad Judd just got ousted as sheriff, and their dynamic is a Hallmark card that someone set on fire. So. That’s the tension. You’ve got generational trauma, a town full of suspiciously closed mouths, and an ex-soldier turned reluctant investigator with a secret stash of dad guilt. Let’s go!
Now, I love a slow burn as much as the next emotionally unstable reader, but this is less slow burn and more slow simmer while your tea goes cold and you forget what you’re waiting for. The emotional arcs? Solid. The mystery? There. The pacing? Like being stuck behind a tractor on a two-lane road in February. The good news is, Goldman’s writing has a warm, lived-in quality that really nails the small-town atmosphere. You believe this place exists, even if you’re screaming into the void because every man in this town talks like he was raised by an REI catalog and a roll of duct tape.
Clay, for better or worse, is a very male protagonist. He’s quiet, angsty, deeply repressed, and casually checking out every woman he meets like he’s been starved of estrogen for twenty years. It doesn’t ruin the book, but it does make you go, “Sir… I beg you to journal.” His relationship with Braedon is the standout here. Genuinely sweet and layered, especially as Braedon starts asking questions about his absent mother and starts developing opinions about his grandfather’s entire deal (spoiler: Judd’s vibe is “emotionally constipated military dad,” and I say that with affection).
Uncle Teddy’s disappearance drives the plot, but it’s really just an excuse to trap these emotionally illiterate men in a metaphorical (and sometimes literal) cabin together until they start processing feelings like adults. And by “like adults,” I mean through poorly timed confessions, light violence, and aggressive fishing metaphors. Throw in a suspicious ransom note, some low-key corruption, and the hint of a romantic subplot with the new sheriff Zoey (love her, she deserves a better man and at least one nap), and you’ve got all the ingredients for a very moody, very Midwestern stew.
Unfortunately, the big reveal lands with more of a soft shrug than a gasp. It’s not bad, but it’s giving “we had to wrap this up before Braedon aged out of his precocious phase.” There are too many red herrings and not enough actual payoff, which left me feeling like I’d just opened a can of LaCroix expecting champagne.
All that said, I would read the sequel. Not because I’m dying for more mystery, but because I need to know if Clay ever learns how to emote without brooding in the woods. Also, if Zoey doesn’t get a bigger arc where she takes down some institutional corruption and maybe adopts a dog, I will riot.
I’m giving this one 3.5 stars for strong vibes, complicated dad energy, and a town full of secrets that almost slaps. It's like prestige TV that skipped one too many therapy sessions.
Whodunity Award: For Most Emotionally Repressed Men in a Canoe
Big thanks to St. Martin’s Press and NetGalley for the ARC. You really said, “Here, have a small town full of daddy issues and suppressed emotions,” and I devoured it like emotionally stunted literary comfort food.
May 7, 2026
"In Liar’s Creek, Matt Goldman delivers a gritty, atmospheric PI mystery that proves small towns have the longest memories. When a private investigator returns to a community defined by its secrets, he’s forced to navigate a web of deception where the truth is as elusive as the shoreline.
A "Picturesque Facade": The setting of Riverwood, Minnesota, feels "picture-perfect" and scenic, but beneath this beauty, there is a pervasive "undercurrent of unease" and the sense that the entire community is "in on a secret".
Vivid and atmospheric, painted with sharp, sensory details of the rural Minnesota landscape, the author skillfully captures the small-town feel that is both beautiful and slightly eerie.
LIAR’S CREEK by Matt Goldman
My thoughts:
~A gritty, atmospheric PI mystery where the past is as murky as the Minnesota shoreline.
~Verdict: 4⭐Stars. The vibe of Liar's Creek is a "slow-burn" blend of small-town intrigue and deeply felt family drama. It is a more character-driven, quietly engaging mystery that prioritizes authentic emotional weight over rapid-fire plot twists.
~"Reliable, atmospheric, a snappy mystery for fans of the genre." It’s a classic "sins of the past" story set against a well-realized, atmospheric backdrop. The central themes focus heavily on the complexities of family and the secrets hidden within a small town's "picturesque facade."
~A solid, character-driven, compelling procedural that hits the right notes. It’s well-constructed and moves fast, but it stays within the lanes of a traditional mystery without reinventing the wheel. Goldman’s writing feels like it’s built for the screen—it's punchier and less "heavy" than the deep-dive investigations you get with Bosch or Ballard.
Special thanks to Minotaur Books and NetGalley for providing an advanced reading copy in exchange for my honest thoughts.
blog review posted @
JudithDCollins.com
@JudithDCollins | #JDCMustReadBooks
My Rating: 4 Stars
Pub Date: May 5, 2026
May Newsletter
May 2026 Must-Read Books
A "Picturesque Facade": The setting of Riverwood, Minnesota, feels "picture-perfect" and scenic, but beneath this beauty, there is a pervasive "undercurrent of unease" and the sense that the entire community is "in on a secret".
Vivid and atmospheric, painted with sharp, sensory details of the rural Minnesota landscape, the author skillfully captures the small-town feel that is both beautiful and slightly eerie.
LIAR’S CREEK by Matt Goldman
~Intro:
A gritty but witty private investigator mystery that pulls a detective back into a small-town web of old grudges and fresh lies.
~Setting:
Riverwood, Minnesota. Atmospheric, while visually beautiful, the town is portrayed as having a "picturesque facade" that hides deep secrets and underlying danger.
~The Vibe:
Grit with Heart.
~Themes:
The burden of hometown secrets; the path to redemption; small-town justice.
~Mood:
"Classic Noir with a Modern Pulse."
~Characters:
The three generations of Hawkins men (Judd, Clay, and Braedon) investigate the town's secrets, facing dangers that threaten their family.
~Highlights:
A strong sense of place and a protagonist who feels grounded.
~Standout:
Goldman’s background in TV writing shows in the sharp, fast-paced dialogue.
~Narrative:
The healing of generational trauma and addressing past abandonment.
~Author Writing:
The dialogue is sharp, snappy, and carries a lot of the book’s personality. The pacing is tight, making it a quick, satisfying weekend read.
~Protagonist:
A protagonist who feels "real"—flawed, persistent, and a bit world-weary.
~Takeaway:
You can leave your past, but you can’t make it stay buried.
~Recs:
For readers who enjoy authors John Hart, Greg Isles, CJ Box, Linwood Barclay, and Harlan Coben.
~Audio Note:
Fred Berman brings that perfect "noir-adjacent" gravel to the narration.
My thoughts:
~A gritty, atmospheric PI mystery where the past is as murky as the Minnesota shoreline.
~Verdict: 4⭐Stars. The vibe of Liar's Creek is a "slow-burn" blend of small-town intrigue and deeply felt family drama. It is a more character-driven, quietly engaging mystery that prioritizes authentic emotional weight over rapid-fire plot twists.
~"Reliable, atmospheric, a snappy mystery for fans of the genre." It’s a classic "sins of the past" story set against a well-realized, atmospheric backdrop. The central themes focus heavily on the complexities of family and the secrets hidden within a small town's "picturesque facade."
~A solid, character-driven, compelling procedural that hits the right notes. It’s well-constructed and moves fast, but it stays within the lanes of a traditional mystery without reinventing the wheel. Goldman’s writing feels like it’s built for the screen—it's punchier and less "heavy" than the deep-dive investigations you get with Bosch or Ballard.
Special thanks to Minotaur Books and NetGalley for providing an advanced reading copy in exchange for my honest thoughts.
blog review posted @
JudithDCollins.com
@JudithDCollins | #JDCMustReadBooks
My Rating: 4 Stars
Pub Date: May 5, 2026
May Newsletter
May 2026 Must-Read Books
May 14, 2026
Real Rating: 3.75* of five
The Publisher Says: From New York Times bestselling author and Emmy Award-winner Matt Goldman comes Liar's Creek, which asks how far we'll go to protect the people we love.
The small town of Riverwood, Minnesota is true to its name, brimming with beautiful scenes of nature. Its rural landscape is threaded with scenic trout streams, which carve their way through limestone bluffs. But beneath its picturesque facade, danger runs rampant.
Clay Hawkins isn’t a stranger to the secrets of his hometown. After twenty years away, Clay has recently returned home from abroad with his twelve-year-old son Braedon, and his relationship with his father Judd, the recently replaced sheriff, is as strained as ever.
Trouble immediately brews for Clay when his beloved uncle, Teddy, disappears. Together, the three generations of Hawkinses must overturn every stone in Riverwood and confront deep familial wounds to find the one person who brings them together. As danger looms, Clay worries that it might be too late to save Teddy—and that the rest of the family might be next.
I RECEIVED A DRC FROM THE PUBLISHER VIA NETGALLEY. THANK YOU.
My Review: Author Goldman clearly invested a lot of mental energy in Clay Hawkins' life trajectory. It's all here: dead mother, grouchy prickly father, adolescent son with all that implies and entails, escapr from then return to Home after a fun, fascinating adulthood elsewhere...it's all here. Coming home has its rewards, these aren't skimped, and its risks. Uncle Teddy, who vanishes without explanation, is going to be found, by Clay, and damned if his family's ugly secrets they do NOT want splashed around will stop Clay from doing it.
Perch that determination on top of his...estranged, unliked...father making a friend of Clay's son, and the differing ways to be a father between the generations add a load of tension between them, among all three of them. The women in the story are all strong, competent people, with their own careers and concerns. They're not little ladies, nor are they ball-busting viragos, they're presented as flawed and imperfect like the stiff-necked men they choose to hang around with.
The mystery's resolved. Copious trout-fishing is done. Football/soccer is discussed. The manly men (and one about to start being a man) all do man-stuff like pointedly not talk, like ignore feelings (their own of course, but each others' too), not talk, lust after women, and not talk. It takes extreme measures to goad them into speech not about sports. When they do talk, shit gets done and in a hurry.
I'm afraid I was not surprised by the big reveal. I really seldom am, and this was not one of those times. I don't fault Author Goldman for that. I fault him a little for apparently losing track of some red-herrings that will stink up the furniture in future installments of the series. There will be future installments because no publisher works this hard to drop a promising premise. I hope the team will make some serious effort to answer young Braedon's quite reasonable questions about his past that he's too young to remember on his own.
A promising debut series that needs a bit of finesse applied as it matures.
The Publisher Says: From New York Times bestselling author and Emmy Award-winner Matt Goldman comes Liar's Creek, which asks how far we'll go to protect the people we love.
The small town of Riverwood, Minnesota is true to its name, brimming with beautiful scenes of nature. Its rural landscape is threaded with scenic trout streams, which carve their way through limestone bluffs. But beneath its picturesque facade, danger runs rampant.
Clay Hawkins isn’t a stranger to the secrets of his hometown. After twenty years away, Clay has recently returned home from abroad with his twelve-year-old son Braedon, and his relationship with his father Judd, the recently replaced sheriff, is as strained as ever.
Trouble immediately brews for Clay when his beloved uncle, Teddy, disappears. Together, the three generations of Hawkinses must overturn every stone in Riverwood and confront deep familial wounds to find the one person who brings them together. As danger looms, Clay worries that it might be too late to save Teddy—and that the rest of the family might be next.
I RECEIVED A DRC FROM THE PUBLISHER VIA NETGALLEY. THANK YOU.
My Review: Author Goldman clearly invested a lot of mental energy in Clay Hawkins' life trajectory. It's all here: dead mother, grouchy prickly father, adolescent son with all that implies and entails, escapr from then return to Home after a fun, fascinating adulthood elsewhere...it's all here. Coming home has its rewards, these aren't skimped, and its risks. Uncle Teddy, who vanishes without explanation, is going to be found, by Clay, and damned if his family's ugly secrets they do NOT want splashed around will stop Clay from doing it.
Perch that determination on top of his...estranged, unliked...father making a friend of Clay's son, and the differing ways to be a father between the generations add a load of tension between them, among all three of them. The women in the story are all strong, competent people, with their own careers and concerns. They're not little ladies, nor are they ball-busting viragos, they're presented as flawed and imperfect like the stiff-necked men they choose to hang around with.
The mystery's resolved. Copious trout-fishing is done. Football/soccer is discussed. The manly men (and one about to start being a man) all do man-stuff like pointedly not talk, like ignore feelings (their own of course, but each others' too), not talk, lust after women, and not talk. It takes extreme measures to goad them into speech not about sports. When they do talk, shit gets done and in a hurry.
I'm afraid I was not surprised by the big reveal. I really seldom am, and this was not one of those times. I don't fault Author Goldman for that. I fault him a little for apparently losing track of some red-herrings that will stink up the furniture in future installments of the series. There will be future installments because no publisher works this hard to drop a promising premise. I hope the team will make some serious effort to answer young Braedon's quite reasonable questions about his past that he's too young to remember on his own.
A promising debut series that needs a bit of finesse applied as it matures.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Special thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for a free, electronic ARC of this novel received in exchange for an honest review.
Expected publication date: April 21, 2026
After twenty years playing soccer professionally overseas, Clay Hawkins has returned to his hometown of Riverwood, Minnesota, with his twelve-year-old son in tow. Soon after his arrival, Clay’s beloved uncle, Teddy, disappears and Clay, along with his estranged father, Judd, are willing to pull out all the stops to find him. With the help of the new police chief and a few of Clay’s childhood friends, Clay and Judd set out to locate Teddy, rebuilding their bond along the way.
“Liar's Creek” is the first novel in a series by author Matt Goldman. Clay is the protagonist, a former professional footballer and single father who returns to his hometown where he reconnects with his estranged father, the former police chief. Of course, there is more to Clay than meets the eye and his secrets are revealed to a select few as he investigates the disappearance of his uncle.
The story is primarily narrated by Clay, although there are several others who readers will hear from, including Clay’s son, Braeden and Clay’s father, Judd, which provide unique perspectives on not only Clay himself, but on the family dynamic as a whole. Braeden is particularly likable, for a twelve-year-old, as a motherless child who has had his whole life uprooted to move to another country, and Clay does an admirable job parenting him, considering his own upbringing. There is a strong emotional component that hides under the surface in Goldman’s novel, which only increased my enjoyment.
“Creek” was engaging and, although there were plenty of characters, each one was unique and easily recognizable, making the story easy to follow. I was immediately invested in what happened to Teddy, and I loved meeting Clay’s family and friends, both old and new, as they were all eccentric and fun. There are a few side plots as well that Goldman connected smoothly, and everything converged into an unexpected and satisfying ending.
Clay is a unique protagonist, as normally novels like this feature police officers, rangers or some other form of law enforcement, so a former footballer investigating a disappearance is a clever turn. Add to that the single father angle and you have a relatable, likable main character who only adds to the novel’s page-turning story line and picturesque setting.
“Liar's Creek” is an entertaining first installment, and I’m looking forward to seeing more from Clay.
Expected publication date: April 21, 2026
After twenty years playing soccer professionally overseas, Clay Hawkins has returned to his hometown of Riverwood, Minnesota, with his twelve-year-old son in tow. Soon after his arrival, Clay’s beloved uncle, Teddy, disappears and Clay, along with his estranged father, Judd, are willing to pull out all the stops to find him. With the help of the new police chief and a few of Clay’s childhood friends, Clay and Judd set out to locate Teddy, rebuilding their bond along the way.
“Liar's Creek” is the first novel in a series by author Matt Goldman. Clay is the protagonist, a former professional footballer and single father who returns to his hometown where he reconnects with his estranged father, the former police chief. Of course, there is more to Clay than meets the eye and his secrets are revealed to a select few as he investigates the disappearance of his uncle.
The story is primarily narrated by Clay, although there are several others who readers will hear from, including Clay’s son, Braeden and Clay’s father, Judd, which provide unique perspectives on not only Clay himself, but on the family dynamic as a whole. Braeden is particularly likable, for a twelve-year-old, as a motherless child who has had his whole life uprooted to move to another country, and Clay does an admirable job parenting him, considering his own upbringing. There is a strong emotional component that hides under the surface in Goldman’s novel, which only increased my enjoyment.
“Creek” was engaging and, although there were plenty of characters, each one was unique and easily recognizable, making the story easy to follow. I was immediately invested in what happened to Teddy, and I loved meeting Clay’s family and friends, both old and new, as they were all eccentric and fun. There are a few side plots as well that Goldman connected smoothly, and everything converged into an unexpected and satisfying ending.
Clay is a unique protagonist, as normally novels like this feature police officers, rangers or some other form of law enforcement, so a former footballer investigating a disappearance is a clever turn. Add to that the single father angle and you have a relatable, likable main character who only adds to the novel’s page-turning story line and picturesque setting.
“Liar's Creek” is an entertaining first installment, and I’m looking forward to seeing more from Clay.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Pleasant light reading, perfect for the beach.
"Liar's Creek", Clay Hawkins #1 by Matt Goldman (2026)
Review based on an advance review copy courtesy of St. Martin's Press, Minotaur Books & NetGalley.
(See book details below.)
━━━━━━━
Riverwood, MN
Small Town USA, Midwestern style. Trout streams and limestone bluffs, four stoplights, two beauty salons, nine bars. One barber shop, seven restaurants, two hardware stores. One bakery, one police station, three auto repair shops.
And, at this particular moment, one missing person.
Liar's Creek.
Riverwood is also home to "Liar's Creek", named in 1887 after a two-timing cobbler who'd originally named the small waterway "Miller's Creek" after himself. But the name christened by townsfolk following his indiscretion, Liar's Creek, stuck.
The town's "salmon".
Term coined for its residents who leave Riverwood only to return years later.
Enter The Prodigal Son.
One such "salmon" is Clay Hawkins. Back in town after 24 years in the Army. Then abroad in Europe as a professional soccer player and coach. He brings home his 12-year-old son, Braedon, who speaks with a fading Irish brogue. Along with investigative skills he'd honed in the Army, plus in some jobs clandestinely working for the government, skills which he puts to good use in the investigation of the disappearance of his beloved Uncle Teddy, the aforementioned missing person.
_____
// _____Review Spotlight: Written by Matt Goldman, Emmy Award-winning television writer for the Seinfeld, Ellen show, et al. His wit comes across in his stories, primarily staged in the Midwest /Twin Cities area, terrific scenery along with glimpses of the so-called "Midwest nice" . //
_____
Daddy Hawkins.
None other than ex-Riverwood Police Chief, Judd Hawkins. Tough, fair, and fired by the town council who wanted new blood. Judd takes an instant liking to his grandson, Braedon, with whom he develops a tight bond, and acts a mentor, teaching him the Minnesotan ways, i.e. trout fishing, ━and gun safety too. Which balances out a long-standing, estranged relationship with his son, Clay, the main reason why his son had stayed away in Europe.
Braedon.
12-year-old, precocious. Eager to learn from his grandpa. He still regularly calls a friend back in Ireland. His longing to finally meet his mom, whom he googles and discovers lives in Ireland with a family and kids of her own, provides an emotional subplot to the story.
New Police Chief.
Zoel Jensen brings in fresh perspectives to policing in the generally peaceful town. She assumes a key role in the investigation of the disappearance of Teddy Hawkins. And takes a liking to the new guy back from Europe. Unexpectedly, she adds comic relief, laced with double entendres, to the narrative.
And finally, Teddy Hawkins.
Happy go lucky, unreliable, married, childless, jobless. Which wasn't always the case, it would appear. A good uncle to Clay who loves him unconditionally. A handyman to anyone who'd pay. He gets involved in the dregs of commerce, buying and selling whatever he can lay his hands on. He gets himself caught stripping copper from power lines said to be no longer in use.
Then, Teddy goes missing.
And the entire Midwest town gets caught in a quandary.
tgw━━━━════════
Recommendation:
Pleasant light reading, perfect for the beach, or perhaps, on a breezy summer day. Character and location driven story, not unlike a well-written sitcom, infused with those "Midwest nice" traits of politeness, neighborliness and compassion. In a town where everybody knows everyone else.
Brings to mind those catchy lines, ━"Sometimes you want to go, where everybody knows your name. And they’re always glad you came. You want to be, where you can see. Our troubles are all the same..."
Book details:
"Liar's Creek", Clay Hawkins #1 by Matt Goldman
Published by St. Martin's Press, Minotaur Books
Book launch date: May 5, 2026
Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.25 Stars!)
"Liar's Creek", Clay Hawkins #1 by Matt Goldman (2026)
Review based on an advance review copy courtesy of St. Martin's Press, Minotaur Books & NetGalley.
(See book details below.)
━━━━━━━
Riverwood, MN
Small Town USA, Midwestern style. Trout streams and limestone bluffs, four stoplights, two beauty salons, nine bars. One barber shop, seven restaurants, two hardware stores. One bakery, one police station, three auto repair shops.
And, at this particular moment, one missing person.
Liar's Creek.
Riverwood is also home to "Liar's Creek", named in 1887 after a two-timing cobbler who'd originally named the small waterway "Miller's Creek" after himself. But the name christened by townsfolk following his indiscretion, Liar's Creek, stuck.
The town's "salmon".
Term coined for its residents who leave Riverwood only to return years later.
Enter The Prodigal Son.
One such "salmon" is Clay Hawkins. Back in town after 24 years in the Army. Then abroad in Europe as a professional soccer player and coach. He brings home his 12-year-old son, Braedon, who speaks with a fading Irish brogue. Along with investigative skills he'd honed in the Army, plus in some jobs clandestinely working for the government, skills which he puts to good use in the investigation of the disappearance of his beloved Uncle Teddy, the aforementioned missing person.
_____
// _____Review Spotlight: Written by Matt Goldman, Emmy Award-winning television writer for the Seinfeld, Ellen show, et al. His wit comes across in his stories, primarily staged in the Midwest /Twin Cities area, terrific scenery along with glimpses of the so-called "Midwest nice" . //
_____
Daddy Hawkins.
None other than ex-Riverwood Police Chief, Judd Hawkins. Tough, fair, and fired by the town council who wanted new blood. Judd takes an instant liking to his grandson, Braedon, with whom he develops a tight bond, and acts a mentor, teaching him the Minnesotan ways, i.e. trout fishing, ━and gun safety too. Which balances out a long-standing, estranged relationship with his son, Clay, the main reason why his son had stayed away in Europe.
Braedon.
12-year-old, precocious. Eager to learn from his grandpa. He still regularly calls a friend back in Ireland. His longing to finally meet his mom, whom he googles and discovers lives in Ireland with a family and kids of her own, provides an emotional subplot to the story.
New Police Chief.
Zoel Jensen brings in fresh perspectives to policing in the generally peaceful town. She assumes a key role in the investigation of the disappearance of Teddy Hawkins. And takes a liking to the new guy back from Europe. Unexpectedly, she adds comic relief, laced with double entendres, to the narrative.
And finally, Teddy Hawkins.
Happy go lucky, unreliable, married, childless, jobless. Which wasn't always the case, it would appear. A good uncle to Clay who loves him unconditionally. A handyman to anyone who'd pay. He gets involved in the dregs of commerce, buying and selling whatever he can lay his hands on. He gets himself caught stripping copper from power lines said to be no longer in use.
Then, Teddy goes missing.
And the entire Midwest town gets caught in a quandary.
tgw━━━━════════
Recommendation:
Pleasant light reading, perfect for the beach, or perhaps, on a breezy summer day. Character and location driven story, not unlike a well-written sitcom, infused with those "Midwest nice" traits of politeness, neighborliness and compassion. In a town where everybody knows everyone else.
Brings to mind those catchy lines, ━"Sometimes you want to go, where everybody knows your name. And they’re always glad you came. You want to be, where you can see. Our troubles are all the same..."
Book details:
"Liar's Creek", Clay Hawkins #1 by Matt Goldman
Published by St. Martin's Press, Minotaur Books
Book launch date: May 5, 2026
Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.25 Stars!)
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I love small town crime thrillers and mysteries. I always have, even though I was born and raised and lived most of my life in Los Angeles. Having finally relocated to a small, rural town in NoCA two years ago, most days I am truly living with some story of small-town life and its small-town crimes as it were where. Anyway, this story sounded like my kind of story.
The book summary basically just introduces one of the storylines of Clay coming home after 24yrs to the small town of Riverwood, MN after ending his 20yr soccer career, abroad for an Irish team, to a coaching position at his former high school. Clay, now a single father to 12yr old son, Braden, after Braden’s mother (a one-night stand Clay had the year before) abandoned Braden with Clay when Braden was just months old. Clay and his father, Judd, are as estranged as they ever would, since the death of Clay’s mother when he was just a kid. His mother was diagnosed with cancer that was discovered right after she gave birth to Clay, and that Judd always blamed Clay for.
There is the secondary storyline of Clay’s uncle Teddy and Judd’s twin brother suddenly going missing. Teddy is the beloved one of the family, the one that everyone loves and adores and kind of the glue of the family, the one denominator that brings everyone together, even Braden came to adore Uncle Teddy. However, Teddy has always had a bit of a rebel streak in him and it’s not long before Judd and Clay start to wonder what he’s gotten himself into now.
It’s right around the halfway point that a major reveal about why Clay came home adds a bit of intrigue to the story that I’m not going to spoil. The second half begins to reveal a lot more about what’s been going on in Riverwood and all the secrets under the surface. LOVE ZOEY!!! The new, female, Sheriff in Riverwood, who replaced Judd when the city council fired him. Omg, she is hilarious! She adds so much entertainment value to every scene she is in. What a great character!
The character development was well done, especially for characters like Clay, Zoey, and Braden and a few others. The pacing was pretty steady in the first half and picked up a bit in the second half. The storyline was interesting, with its small-town crime thriller and a bit of intrigue. The writing was well done too; I liked a lot of the world building that Goldman provided to make the town of Riverwood and its residents come to life, even the kookie ones. I’m looking at an overall rating of 4.1 that I will be rounding down to a 4star review. I want to thank NetGalley and Macmillan Audio for sending me this eARC in exchange for my honest review.
#NetGalley #MacmillanAudio #LiarsCreek
The book summary basically just introduces one of the storylines of Clay coming home after 24yrs to the small town of Riverwood, MN after ending his 20yr soccer career, abroad for an Irish team, to a coaching position at his former high school. Clay, now a single father to 12yr old son, Braden, after Braden’s mother (a one-night stand Clay had the year before) abandoned Braden with Clay when Braden was just months old. Clay and his father, Judd, are as estranged as they ever would, since the death of Clay’s mother when he was just a kid. His mother was diagnosed with cancer that was discovered right after she gave birth to Clay, and that Judd always blamed Clay for.
There is the secondary storyline of Clay’s uncle Teddy and Judd’s twin brother suddenly going missing. Teddy is the beloved one of the family, the one that everyone loves and adores and kind of the glue of the family, the one denominator that brings everyone together, even Braden came to adore Uncle Teddy. However, Teddy has always had a bit of a rebel streak in him and it’s not long before Judd and Clay start to wonder what he’s gotten himself into now.
It’s right around the halfway point that a major reveal about why Clay came home adds a bit of intrigue to the story that I’m not going to spoil. The second half begins to reveal a lot more about what’s been going on in Riverwood and all the secrets under the surface. LOVE ZOEY!!! The new, female, Sheriff in Riverwood, who replaced Judd when the city council fired him. Omg, she is hilarious! She adds so much entertainment value to every scene she is in. What a great character!
The character development was well done, especially for characters like Clay, Zoey, and Braden and a few others. The pacing was pretty steady in the first half and picked up a bit in the second half. The storyline was interesting, with its small-town crime thriller and a bit of intrigue. The writing was well done too; I liked a lot of the world building that Goldman provided to make the town of Riverwood and its residents come to life, even the kookie ones. I’m looking at an overall rating of 4.1 that I will be rounding down to a 4star review. I want to thank NetGalley and Macmillan Audio for sending me this eARC in exchange for my honest review.
#NetGalley #MacmillanAudio #LiarsCreek
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Liar's Creek by Matt Goldman is a highly recommended character-driven mystery. This is the first book in the Clay Hawkins' Series, set in the small town of Riverwood, Minnesota.
Clay Hawkins, a professional footballer in England for twenty years, has return to his small hometown of Riverwood, MN, with his twelve-year-old son, Braedon. His relationship with his father and former sheriff, Judd, is as strained as ever, but Judd and Braedon have quickly formed a tight bond. Clay's beloved uncle Teddy has disappeared and Clay, Judd, and now the new sheriff are investigating, but as the days pass they all fear the worst may have happened.
This is a well-written, character-driven investigative mystery that has a strong sense of place, which is essential to the plot. It is a small town where everyone knows everyone else, but where they can all have secrets. Teddy is a well known figure around town as someone who is likable but frequently skirts the law and seemingly courts trouble. Even with their tense relationship, Clay and Judd are both looking for Teddy. While Judd turns to his contacts within the sheriff's office, Clay defies his father and talks directly to the new sheriff, Zoey Jensen. The father and son do set aside their grievances and work together.
While the main concern is the search for Teddy, there are several other narrative threads also developing, which serve to add tension and drama. The pace is even as various characters are introduced and brought to life. There is also another story line involving Braedon, his new friend, and some older teens in town (which, as it's a small town, everyone should have known who the teens were while privately keeping an eye on them, looking for trouble.) There is a lot of talk about fishing too.
The character development is excellent as they are all portrayed as complicated, fully realized individuals. Even Braedon is brought to life, along with the minor characters around town. Their interpersonal relationships are realistic and believable. It is revealed along the way that there is more to Clay than meets the eye.
Liar's Creek is a good choice for those who enjoy character-driven investigative mysteries and want to get in at the start of a new series. Thanks to St. Martin's Press for providing me with an advance reader's copy via NetGalley. My review is voluntary and expresses my honest opinion.
http://www.shetreadssoftly.com/2026/0...
Clay Hawkins, a professional footballer in England for twenty years, has return to his small hometown of Riverwood, MN, with his twelve-year-old son, Braedon. His relationship with his father and former sheriff, Judd, is as strained as ever, but Judd and Braedon have quickly formed a tight bond. Clay's beloved uncle Teddy has disappeared and Clay, Judd, and now the new sheriff are investigating, but as the days pass they all fear the worst may have happened.
This is a well-written, character-driven investigative mystery that has a strong sense of place, which is essential to the plot. It is a small town where everyone knows everyone else, but where they can all have secrets. Teddy is a well known figure around town as someone who is likable but frequently skirts the law and seemingly courts trouble. Even with their tense relationship, Clay and Judd are both looking for Teddy. While Judd turns to his contacts within the sheriff's office, Clay defies his father and talks directly to the new sheriff, Zoey Jensen. The father and son do set aside their grievances and work together.
While the main concern is the search for Teddy, there are several other narrative threads also developing, which serve to add tension and drama. The pace is even as various characters are introduced and brought to life. There is also another story line involving Braedon, his new friend, and some older teens in town (which, as it's a small town, everyone should have known who the teens were while privately keeping an eye on them, looking for trouble.) There is a lot of talk about fishing too.
The character development is excellent as they are all portrayed as complicated, fully realized individuals. Even Braedon is brought to life, along with the minor characters around town. Their interpersonal relationships are realistic and believable. It is revealed along the way that there is more to Clay than meets the eye.
Liar's Creek is a good choice for those who enjoy character-driven investigative mysteries and want to get in at the start of a new series. Thanks to St. Martin's Press for providing me with an advance reader's copy via NetGalley. My review is voluntary and expresses my honest opinion.
http://www.shetreadssoftly.com/2026/0...
Displaying 1 - 29 of 237 reviews