What do you think?
Rate this book
A Rip Through Time #4
Death at a Highland Wedding: A Rip Through Time Novel
Not yet published
Expected 21 Apr 26Death at a Highland Wedding is the fourth installment in New York Times bestselling author Kelley Armstrong's gripping Rip Through Time Novels.
After slipping 150 years into the past, modern-day homicide detective Mallory Atkinson has embraced her new life in Victorian Scotland as housemaid Catriona Mitchel. Although it isn’t what she expected, she's developed real, meaningful relationships with the people around her and has come to love her role as assistant to undertaker Dr. Duncan Gray and Detective Hugh McCreadie.
Mallory, Gray, and McCreadie are on their way to the Scottish Highlands for McCreadie's younger sister's wedding. The McCreadies and the groom’s family, the Cranstons, have a complicated history which has made the weekend quite uncomfortable. But the Cranston estate is beautiful so Gray and Mallory decide to escape the stifling company and set off to explore the castle and surrounding wilderness. They discover that the groom, Archie Cranston, a slightly pompous and prickly man, has set up deadly traps in the woods for the endangered Scottish wildcats, and they soon come across a cat who's been caught and severely injured. Oddly, Mallory notices the cat's injuries don't match up with the intricacies of the trap. These strange irregularities, combined with the secretive and erratic behavior of the groom, put Mallory and Duncan on edge. And then when one of the guests is murdered, they must work fast to uncover the murderer before another life is lost.
New York Times bestselling author Kelley Armstrong’s unique time travel mystery series continues to entertain as Mallory adjusts to life in the 1870s.
After slipping 150 years into the past, modern-day homicide detective Mallory Atkinson has embraced her new life in Victorian Scotland as housemaid Catriona Mitchel. Although it isn’t what she expected, she's developed real, meaningful relationships with the people around her and has come to love her role as assistant to undertaker Dr. Duncan Gray and Detective Hugh McCreadie.
Mallory, Gray, and McCreadie are on their way to the Scottish Highlands for McCreadie's younger sister's wedding. The McCreadies and the groom’s family, the Cranstons, have a complicated history which has made the weekend quite uncomfortable. But the Cranston estate is beautiful so Gray and Mallory decide to escape the stifling company and set off to explore the castle and surrounding wilderness. They discover that the groom, Archie Cranston, a slightly pompous and prickly man, has set up deadly traps in the woods for the endangered Scottish wildcats, and they soon come across a cat who's been caught and severely injured. Oddly, Mallory notices the cat's injuries don't match up with the intricacies of the trap. These strange irregularities, combined with the secretive and erratic behavior of the groom, put Mallory and Duncan on edge. And then when one of the guests is murdered, they must work fast to uncover the murderer before another life is lost.
New York Times bestselling author Kelley Armstrong’s unique time travel mystery series continues to entertain as Mallory adjusts to life in the 1870s.
352 pages, Paperback
First published May 20, 2025
267 people are currently reading
11586 people want to read
About the author
Kelley Armstrong
302 books33.5k followersKelley Armstrong has been telling stories since before she could write. Her earliest written efforts were disastrous. If asked for a story about girls and dolls, hers would invariably feature undead girls and evil dolls, much to her teachers' dismay. All efforts to make her produce "normal" stories failed.
Today, she continues to spin tales of ghosts and demons and werewolves, while safely locked away in her basement writing dungeon. She's the author of the NYT-bestselling "Women of the Otherworld" paranormal suspense series and "Darkest Powers" young adult urban fantasy trilogy, as well as the Nadia Stafford crime series. Armstrong lives in southwestern Ontario with her husband, kids and far too many pets.
Today, she continues to spin tales of ghosts and demons and werewolves, while safely locked away in her basement writing dungeon. She's the author of the NYT-bestselling "Women of the Otherworld" paranormal suspense series and "Darkest Powers" young adult urban fantasy trilogy, as well as the Nadia Stafford crime series. Armstrong lives in southwestern Ontario with her husband, kids and far too many pets.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 788 reviews
May 10, 2025
Modern-day thirty-one year-old Vancouver, Canada homicide detective Mallory Atkinson is back. She’s still 150 years in the past in Scotland and still in the body of twenty-year old maid Catriona Mitchel. Mallory is enjoying her job as assistant to undertaker and medical examiner Dr. Duncan Gray and assisting him and Detective Hugh McCreadie in a variety of cases. In this fourth book of the A Rip Through Time series, Mallory along with Duncan, his sister Isla Ballantine, and Hugh travel to the Scottish Highlands for Hugh’s younger sister Fiona’s wedding to Archie Cranston. The weekend is uncomfortable due to some family history. However, the Cranston estate is beautiful. Duncan and Mallory go for a walk and find traps have been set out to prevent poaching and to capture a Scottish wildcat. They discover irregularities when one is caught, but even more when one of the wedding guests is murdered.
Mallory is a character with plenty of depth. She’s logical, kind, relatable, and empathetic. She’s good at seeing clues and connections in people’s speech, mannerisms, and expressions and is protective of her friends. While she makes for a strong female protagonist that readers can cheer on, she flouts convention and is sarcastic as well as being an independent thinker unafraid to speak her mind, which isn’t normal for women in Victorian times. Gray is passionate about his work, enthusiastic, confident, caring, occasionally relaxed and teasing. He’s a pioneer in the field of forensics, has an eye for detail, and has a scientific curiosity. He reads and interprets evidence well, but can be obtuse when it comes to evaluating emotional situations. Isla is a chemist who is brilliant, strong-willed, and kindhearted. She’s also been a widow for two years and is well-respected by those who work for her. McCreadie is clever, good-natured, and a bit of an adventure hound. The remaining supporting cast of characters are well-developed and provide insight into individuals in various roles in a Victorian household as well as those they interact with.
The introduction catches readers up if it’s been a while since they read the last book. It also provides a summary for new readers jumping into the series with book four. Kelley Armstrong has a fluid writing style that quickly brings readers into the well-paced story. They also get insight into the state of police forensics during this early era as well as how the local constable approaches a murder investigation. My biggest quibble is the lack of progress in one of the potential romances.
There are some twists and surprises as the story progresses with an ending that is full of action. There are some dark aspects that are uncovered during the investigation. Two things that stand out are the world-building that transported this reader to the Scottish Highlands and the humor that is sprinkled throughout the tale. Themes include endangered wildlife, weddings, family, arranged marriages, relationship, friendship, how servants are treated, and changing laws regarding estate land, as well as attitudes toward, expectations of, and limitations on women.
Overall, this is a well-written, suspenseful, gripping, and entertaining novel with great characterization as well as some pivotal stressful and emotional moments. Readers of historical mysteries will likely enjoy this novel. It captured the characters, attitudes, and lifestyles of the times and brought them to life. I can’t wait to see what will happen in the next book in the series.
St. Martin’s Press – Minotaur Books and Kelley Armstrong provided a complimentary digital ARC of this novel via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions expressed in this review are my own. Publication date is currently set for May 20, 2025. This review was originally posted at Mystery and Suspense Magazine.
----------------------------------------
My 4.48 rounded to 4 stars review is coming soon.
Mallory is a character with plenty of depth. She’s logical, kind, relatable, and empathetic. She’s good at seeing clues and connections in people’s speech, mannerisms, and expressions and is protective of her friends. While she makes for a strong female protagonist that readers can cheer on, she flouts convention and is sarcastic as well as being an independent thinker unafraid to speak her mind, which isn’t normal for women in Victorian times. Gray is passionate about his work, enthusiastic, confident, caring, occasionally relaxed and teasing. He’s a pioneer in the field of forensics, has an eye for detail, and has a scientific curiosity. He reads and interprets evidence well, but can be obtuse when it comes to evaluating emotional situations. Isla is a chemist who is brilliant, strong-willed, and kindhearted. She’s also been a widow for two years and is well-respected by those who work for her. McCreadie is clever, good-natured, and a bit of an adventure hound. The remaining supporting cast of characters are well-developed and provide insight into individuals in various roles in a Victorian household as well as those they interact with.
The introduction catches readers up if it’s been a while since they read the last book. It also provides a summary for new readers jumping into the series with book four. Kelley Armstrong has a fluid writing style that quickly brings readers into the well-paced story. They also get insight into the state of police forensics during this early era as well as how the local constable approaches a murder investigation. My biggest quibble is the lack of progress in one of the potential romances.
There are some twists and surprises as the story progresses with an ending that is full of action. There are some dark aspects that are uncovered during the investigation. Two things that stand out are the world-building that transported this reader to the Scottish Highlands and the humor that is sprinkled throughout the tale. Themes include endangered wildlife, weddings, family, arranged marriages, relationship, friendship, how servants are treated, and changing laws regarding estate land, as well as attitudes toward, expectations of, and limitations on women.
Overall, this is a well-written, suspenseful, gripping, and entertaining novel with great characterization as well as some pivotal stressful and emotional moments. Readers of historical mysteries will likely enjoy this novel. It captured the characters, attitudes, and lifestyles of the times and brought them to life. I can’t wait to see what will happen in the next book in the series.
St. Martin’s Press – Minotaur Books and Kelley Armstrong provided a complimentary digital ARC of this novel via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions expressed in this review are my own. Publication date is currently set for May 20, 2025. This review was originally posted at Mystery and Suspense Magazine.
----------------------------------------
My 4.48 rounded to 4 stars review is coming soon.
July 8, 2025
Now Available!
I was excited to dive back into the intriguing world of the “A Rip Through Time” series as we reunite with Mallory Atkinson, a modern homicide detective from Vancouver, now navigating life in the 19th-century Scottish Highlands—still in the body of 20-year-old maid Catriona Mitchel. In this compelling fourth installment, Mallory embraces her role as assistant to the passionate Dr. Duncan Gray, the village undertaker and medical examiner, collaborating with him and the charming Detective Hugh McCreadie on a series of captivating cases.
As they head to the picturesque Cranston estate for Hugh’s sister Fiona’s wedding to Archie Cranston, the weekend is marred by family tension. While the haunting beauty of the Highlands offers a breathtaking backdrop, while working the estate grounds, Mallory and Duncan stumble upon disturbing signs of illegal poaching. Just when the wedding festivities seem idyllic, tragedy strikes—one of the guests is found murdered.
Mallory is a character brimming with depth and complexity. Her logical yet empathetic nature makes her relatable and fiercely protective of those she cares for. She defies the era's norms with a sharp wit and a penchant for sarcasm, proving that strong female protagonists can be independent thinkers unafraid to voice their opinions. Joining her in this gripping narrative are Duncan, whose enthusiasm for forensic science shines through; Isla, a brilliant chemist and widow with a heart of gold; and the adventurous McCreadie, whose clever antics add a bit of lightheartedness to the mix.
Kelley Armstrong’s fluid writing envelops readers in a richly crafted story, seamlessly summarizing previous events for those returning to the series while welcoming newcomers embarking on this thrilling journey. The insightful exploration of early police forensics and the local constable's investigative methods adds a fascinating layer to the murder mystery.
Expect unexpected twists and shocking revelations as the plot unfolds, leading to a heart-pounding finale filled with revelations that had me on the edge of my seat. Amidst the suspense, the story tackles darker themes that resonate deeply, offering a glimpse into the treatment of servants and changing societal expectations for women. The vivid world-building transports readers to the enchanting Scottish Highlands, augmented by clever humour that lightens the narrative beautifully.
With its well-drawn characters, gripping tension, and moments that tug at your heartstrings, this novel is a must-read for fans of historical mysteries. Get ready to immerse yourself in a tale that captures the essence of the past while leaving you eagerly anticipating what lies ahead in the next chapter of Mallory’s journey! It was hard to say goodbye to the characters I have come to adore, and I can’t wait to see what adventure awaits them in the next series installment.
Kate Handford's narration is exceptional, highlighting her impressive vocal range and skill. She skillfully switches between various character voices, including Mallory's distinct "Canadian" voice and Catriona’s Victorian accent, while effectively capturing other characters' Scottish brogue. Her engaging and natural delivery allows the story to unfold beautifully, making her performance a joy to listen to. I wholeheartedly recommend the audio format of this series as it offers an excellent way to immerse oneself in the captivating tale.
Thank you, St. Martin's Press, Macmillan Audio, and NetGalley for providing an ALC and ARC in exchange for an honest review. All opinions expressed are my own. I was under no obligation to provide a review.
I was excited to dive back into the intriguing world of the “A Rip Through Time” series as we reunite with Mallory Atkinson, a modern homicide detective from Vancouver, now navigating life in the 19th-century Scottish Highlands—still in the body of 20-year-old maid Catriona Mitchel. In this compelling fourth installment, Mallory embraces her role as assistant to the passionate Dr. Duncan Gray, the village undertaker and medical examiner, collaborating with him and the charming Detective Hugh McCreadie on a series of captivating cases.
As they head to the picturesque Cranston estate for Hugh’s sister Fiona’s wedding to Archie Cranston, the weekend is marred by family tension. While the haunting beauty of the Highlands offers a breathtaking backdrop, while working the estate grounds, Mallory and Duncan stumble upon disturbing signs of illegal poaching. Just when the wedding festivities seem idyllic, tragedy strikes—one of the guests is found murdered.
Mallory is a character brimming with depth and complexity. Her logical yet empathetic nature makes her relatable and fiercely protective of those she cares for. She defies the era's norms with a sharp wit and a penchant for sarcasm, proving that strong female protagonists can be independent thinkers unafraid to voice their opinions. Joining her in this gripping narrative are Duncan, whose enthusiasm for forensic science shines through; Isla, a brilliant chemist and widow with a heart of gold; and the adventurous McCreadie, whose clever antics add a bit of lightheartedness to the mix.
Kelley Armstrong’s fluid writing envelops readers in a richly crafted story, seamlessly summarizing previous events for those returning to the series while welcoming newcomers embarking on this thrilling journey. The insightful exploration of early police forensics and the local constable's investigative methods adds a fascinating layer to the murder mystery.
Expect unexpected twists and shocking revelations as the plot unfolds, leading to a heart-pounding finale filled with revelations that had me on the edge of my seat. Amidst the suspense, the story tackles darker themes that resonate deeply, offering a glimpse into the treatment of servants and changing societal expectations for women. The vivid world-building transports readers to the enchanting Scottish Highlands, augmented by clever humour that lightens the narrative beautifully.
With its well-drawn characters, gripping tension, and moments that tug at your heartstrings, this novel is a must-read for fans of historical mysteries. Get ready to immerse yourself in a tale that captures the essence of the past while leaving you eagerly anticipating what lies ahead in the next chapter of Mallory’s journey! It was hard to say goodbye to the characters I have come to adore, and I can’t wait to see what adventure awaits them in the next series installment.
Kate Handford's narration is exceptional, highlighting her impressive vocal range and skill. She skillfully switches between various character voices, including Mallory's distinct "Canadian" voice and Catriona’s Victorian accent, while effectively capturing other characters' Scottish brogue. Her engaging and natural delivery allows the story to unfold beautifully, making her performance a joy to listen to. I wholeheartedly recommend the audio format of this series as it offers an excellent way to immerse oneself in the captivating tale.
Thank you, St. Martin's Press, Macmillan Audio, and NetGalley for providing an ALC and ARC in exchange for an honest review. All opinions expressed are my own. I was under no obligation to provide a review.
March 31, 2025
Gripping, interesting, chilling, shocking and hard to put down! I fell in love with the characters of Mallory Atkinson and Dr. Duncan Gray in the first book in the series, A Rip Through Time! I continue to adore them and the supporting characters in this book. If you have not read that book or this series, I highly recommend it. I find not only this book but the other books in the series to be captivating, wonderfully written, atmospheric, thrilling and mysterious.
A brief background on the characters - Mallory Atkinson was a detective in Vancouver in modern times but found herself being transported 150 years into the past to Victorian Scotland and into the body of Catriona Mitchel, a housemaid for Dr. Duncan Gray. Lucky for her she found herself being transported into Duncan's home as he is an undertaker and works closely with Detective Hugh McCreadie. She was able to confide in them and utilize her modern-day detective skills to assist them in solving crimes.
In Death at a Highland Wedding, sees Mallory/Catriona, Gray, and McCreadie traveling to the highlands for a wedding at the Cranston estate. The grounds are beautiful but immediately Mallory senses something isn't right when a cat found in a trap has injuries that do not match up with the trap. Something is afoot and the groom is acting in strange and odd fashion. When a dead body is found, the trio must work fast to kind the killer!
As with the other books, I loved the setting. I also loved the atmosphere that oozed from this book. The Scottish Highlands, the forest at night, the tension in the air, and the mystery surrounding the cat's injuries and the murdered guest, made for a gripping mystery. I also love the dynamic between the characters. Mallory continues to try to behave and fit in as a woman would in Victorian times. Plus, her interactions with Gray have me wanting to shove them together and say 'come on already' as their chemistry is off the charts!
I love Kelley Armstrong's writing and her use of place and time in this series. She nails the Victorian settings and feel of the book. I also love the dialogue and how Mallory can utilize her current detective skills with the skills of the investigators of that time. The mystery was intriguing and had me wondering whodunit the entire book. The final reveal was nicely done and well played out. While I enjoy the mysteries and crimes that are investigated in this series, it is the relationships and characters that keep me coming back. Kelley Armstrong has created characters that I care about and root for.
Riveting, chilling, atmospheric, gripping and hard to put down!
*I had the pleasure of having the physical book (Thank you to Kat White at St. Martin's Press), the e-book and the audiobook which made for a lovely and completely enjoyable reading experience. The narration of the audiobook was wonderful and so well done.
Thank you to Kat White, St. Martin's Press | Minotaur Books, Macmillan Audio and NetGalley who provided me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All the thoughts and opinions are my own.
Read more of my reviews at www.openbookposts.com 📖
A brief background on the characters - Mallory Atkinson was a detective in Vancouver in modern times but found herself being transported 150 years into the past to Victorian Scotland and into the body of Catriona Mitchel, a housemaid for Dr. Duncan Gray. Lucky for her she found herself being transported into Duncan's home as he is an undertaker and works closely with Detective Hugh McCreadie. She was able to confide in them and utilize her modern-day detective skills to assist them in solving crimes.
In Death at a Highland Wedding, sees Mallory/Catriona, Gray, and McCreadie traveling to the highlands for a wedding at the Cranston estate. The grounds are beautiful but immediately Mallory senses something isn't right when a cat found in a trap has injuries that do not match up with the trap. Something is afoot and the groom is acting in strange and odd fashion. When a dead body is found, the trio must work fast to kind the killer!
As with the other books, I loved the setting. I also loved the atmosphere that oozed from this book. The Scottish Highlands, the forest at night, the tension in the air, and the mystery surrounding the cat's injuries and the murdered guest, made for a gripping mystery. I also love the dynamic between the characters. Mallory continues to try to behave and fit in as a woman would in Victorian times. Plus, her interactions with Gray have me wanting to shove them together and say 'come on already' as their chemistry is off the charts!
I love Kelley Armstrong's writing and her use of place and time in this series. She nails the Victorian settings and feel of the book. I also love the dialogue and how Mallory can utilize her current detective skills with the skills of the investigators of that time. The mystery was intriguing and had me wondering whodunit the entire book. The final reveal was nicely done and well played out. While I enjoy the mysteries and crimes that are investigated in this series, it is the relationships and characters that keep me coming back. Kelley Armstrong has created characters that I care about and root for.
Riveting, chilling, atmospheric, gripping and hard to put down!
*I had the pleasure of having the physical book (Thank you to Kat White at St. Martin's Press), the e-book and the audiobook which made for a lovely and completely enjoyable reading experience. The narration of the audiobook was wonderful and so well done.
Thank you to Kat White, St. Martin's Press | Minotaur Books, Macmillan Audio and NetGalley who provided me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All the thoughts and opinions are my own.
Read more of my reviews at www.openbookposts.com 📖
April 20, 2025
4.0 Stars
I obsessively binged the first few books in this series and then had to wait impatiently for this next installments. This one started a little slow, but once the mystery started, I was fully invested. The murder investigation was quite enjoyable with some interesting leads. I equally enjoy the internal personal relationships which arguably is the biggest draw of this series. I love a “person out of time” series and this one has helped to fill the void of Outlander.
I would highly recommend to anyone who enjoys a mystery thriller with a touch of romance. However, you will want to start at the beginning to appreciate the full character development.
Disclaimer I received a copy of this book from the publisher.
I obsessively binged the first few books in this series and then had to wait impatiently for this next installments. This one started a little slow, but once the mystery started, I was fully invested. The murder investigation was quite enjoyable with some interesting leads. I equally enjoy the internal personal relationships which arguably is the biggest draw of this series. I love a “person out of time” series and this one has helped to fill the void of Outlander.
I would highly recommend to anyone who enjoys a mystery thriller with a touch of romance. However, you will want to start at the beginning to appreciate the full character development.
Disclaimer I received a copy of this book from the publisher.
March 15, 2025
Kelley Armstrong is one of those authors that consistently delivers books that are exactly to my taste, across genres. In her Rip Through Time series, Mallory Atkinson is a modern day detective visiting family in Edinburgh when she’s violently attacked in an alley. When she wakes up, she’s in Victorian Scotland in the body of a young housemaid, working for the local undertaker/medical examiner Dr. Gray. Hijinks ensue.
This is the 4th book in the series, so we’ve had time to settle in with these characters. Oh, they’re all going to a country house for a wedding? They’ll be staying at the estate? Look, I’ve read plenty of regency romance, I know what happens at these house parties! Ok, maybe it’s not usually MURDER, but what more could you ask for? Mallory and Gray at a beautiful country estate, a wedding, a body to examine together and a murder to solve, come on.
There’s definitely progression on the romance front for several couples, but this is a slow burn –and thank GOD, why aren’t there more slow burn romances lately, I need a serious break from insta-love. Look y’all, the slower the burn, the hotter the fire, ok? The payoff is going to be so worth it.
As far as the murder mystery goes, I was engaged and surprised by several of the reveals. (I do want to be upfront about this, a trigger warning for SA.) I feel like Armstrong’s mysteries are always well done, never over the top and always believable, but still well constructed and a complete surprise.
You should really start at the beginning of this series to get the full effect, but if time-travel-romance, fish-out-of-water, Sherlock-esque characters appeals to you, then I think you’ll like this one. It’s not out till May so you’ve got some time, but make sure to put it on the TBR!
As always, thank you NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for the ARC! My opinions are, for better or for worse, my own.
This is the 4th book in the series, so we’ve had time to settle in with these characters. Oh, they’re all going to a country house for a wedding? They’ll be staying at the estate? Look, I’ve read plenty of regency romance, I know what happens at these house parties! Ok, maybe it’s not usually MURDER, but what more could you ask for? Mallory and Gray at a beautiful country estate, a wedding, a body to examine together and a murder to solve, come on.
There’s definitely progression on the romance front for several couples, but this is a slow burn –and thank GOD, why aren’t there more slow burn romances lately, I need a serious break from insta-love. Look y’all, the slower the burn, the hotter the fire, ok? The payoff is going to be so worth it.
As far as the murder mystery goes, I was engaged and surprised by several of the reveals. (I do want to be upfront about this, a trigger warning for SA.) I feel like Armstrong’s mysteries are always well done, never over the top and always believable, but still well constructed and a complete surprise.
You should really start at the beginning of this series to get the full effect, but if time-travel-romance, fish-out-of-water, Sherlock-esque characters appeals to you, then I think you’ll like this one. It’s not out till May so you’ve got some time, but make sure to put it on the TBR!
As always, thank you NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for the ARC! My opinions are, for better or for worse, my own.
April 22, 2025
The fourth installment in the Rip Through Time series, Death at a Highland Wedding follows Mallory and Duncan as they leave the city behind for the Scottish Highlands for the wedding of a family friend. Once they arrive at the countryside, Mallory finds herself in the middle of Detective Hugh McCreadie's family drama and soon, a murder takes place.
Kelley Armstrong is one of my favorite authors and this series is one of her strongest of her most recent works. After book 3, we got partial closure on some subjects, but still get to see Mallory living in Scotland 150 in the past. It's great how most of the characters who know about Mallory's time travel embrace it, where they make jokes and comparisons. The romance between Mallory and Duncan is the slowest of the slow burns, and taking forever to happen.
For some reason I didn't love this one as much as the first 3 books in the series. I can't place my finger on it just this second why, but this is still a very great series and one that I jump at the chance to read with every new book. Excited to see where this story and these characters finally land someday.
An ALC was provided by libro.fm as a part of their Librarian ALC program
Kelley Armstrong is one of my favorite authors and this series is one of her strongest of her most recent works. After book 3, we got partial closure on some subjects, but still get to see Mallory living in Scotland 150 in the past. It's great how most of the characters who know about Mallory's time travel embrace it, where they make jokes and comparisons. The romance between Mallory and Duncan is the slowest of the slow burns, and taking forever to happen.
For some reason I didn't love this one as much as the first 3 books in the series. I can't place my finger on it just this second why, but this is still a very great series and one that I jump at the chance to read with every new book. Excited to see where this story and these characters finally land someday.
An ALC was provided by libro.fm as a part of their Librarian ALC program
April 5, 2025
Kelley Armstrong is one of my favorite authors and across so many genres everything she writes just works for me. This is one of my favorite series (and not just because I share a name with the protagonist), but it is fun and full of excellent murder mysteries, what more could a girl ask for? Mallory and friends go to McCreadie’s sister’s wedding in the highlands, but things are set off course when the groom’s best friend is found dead. Despite not officially being on the case when it is clear there will be no other real investigation Mallory, Duncan, and Hugh all work hard to try to track the real killer. I liked that Mallory and Duncan both got closer to something and further as some real barriers/drawbacks were considered in other ways and of course some miscommunication hindered them. I am beyond ready for them to realize how much they care for each other, but I can wait a little longer I suppose. I listened to the audiobook for the first third of this one before I became too impatient and had to just binge the rest with kindle. The narrator was awesome and I really enjoyed the audiobook, I just read faster than I listen.
February 12, 2025
3.5 rounded to 4
This is the 4th book in a series. I have not read the other books in this series.
I appreciate that the author gave a brief summary in the beginning of the book to familiarize readers of the characters.
Mallory is a modern day detective who is transported in time to the 1870’s.
This story brings the reader to the beautiful Scottish Highlands to attend a wedding.
One of the guests is murdered. There is a lot of speculation who commuted this crime. But Mallory and Duncan are on the case.
We have a lovely hunting lodge full of people who are suspects. Each with their own secrets.
It was a delightful read. I felt you could read it as a standalone but pay careful attention to the names first and last. I become confused at times with the names, who was who? I would recommend reading the first just to get a feel for the characters.
Thank you to NetGalley and Minotaur Books for this advanced readers copy.
This is the 4th book in a series. I have not read the other books in this series.
I appreciate that the author gave a brief summary in the beginning of the book to familiarize readers of the characters.
Mallory is a modern day detective who is transported in time to the 1870’s.
This story brings the reader to the beautiful Scottish Highlands to attend a wedding.
One of the guests is murdered. There is a lot of speculation who commuted this crime. But Mallory and Duncan are on the case.
We have a lovely hunting lodge full of people who are suspects. Each with their own secrets.
It was a delightful read. I felt you could read it as a standalone but pay careful attention to the names first and last. I become confused at times with the names, who was who? I would recommend reading the first just to get a feel for the characters.
Thank you to NetGalley and Minotaur Books for this advanced readers copy.
March 11, 2025
First and foremost, a large thank you to NetGalley, Kelley Armstrong, St. Martin’s Press, and Minotaur Books for providing me with a copy of this publication, which allows me to provide you with an unbiased review.
Kelley Armstrong is back with another of her great thriller that spans over a century and a half. Mallory Atkinson continues to settle in 19th century Scotland with her secret of time travel. She and her close friends are on their way to a wedding in the Scottish Highlands, a great break from the busyness of the every day. However, during their time there, a man is murdered on the estate and other oddities begin to surface. The family secrets come to the surface and what was supposed to be a celebratory affair is soon covered with an alarming pall. Mallory and her group will have to solve things to bring some closure to a baffling murder. Armstrong delivers a great story that kept me hooked until the final pages.
While it has been a while since Mallory Atkinson slipped back in time, the former Vancouver Police detective has made the most of her life in Victorian Scotland. Malory overcame some significant bumps along the way and has created meaningful friendships with those she shares a home, including Dr. Duncan Gray. She’s also found a niche to hone her forensic skills as she works alongside Dr. Gray and Detective Hugh McCreadie of the local police constabulary.
While the work is enjoyable, the idea of getting away for a bit is equally alluring. When Mallory, Gray, and McCreadie travel with a handful of others to the Scottish Highlands, the adventure commences. The wedding of McCreadie’s younger sister is the occasion, though family histories could create some concerns. The groom, Archie Cranston, proves to be a prickly fellow, whose estate is beautiful, though scattered with many animal traps. When Mallory and Gray discover a wildcat that has been found in a trap, the injuries baffle them, as nothing seems to make sense.
After the body of a wedding guest turns up, Mallory, Gray, and McCreadie begin investigating. What they discover leaves the trio concerned that someone is hiding something important. The body appears to have been struck by something, while one of the estate managers is acting quite oddly. The more they probe, the fewer answers come to the surface. Soon, a missing child is added to the mix and more confusion ensues. With the wedding now on the back burner, Mallory and Gray will have to slyly get answers, reporting to McCreadie so that an arrest can be made. Kelley Armstrong delivers a chilling story that mixes ideas of both Victorian Scotland with police work in the 21st century.
I discovered the work of Kelley Armstrong and cannot get enough. While it was another series that pulled me in, when I sought to expand my reading base, this time travel series seemed intriguing. The series has kept a solid narrative foundation and provides the reader with a clear pathway to see how events will transpire. As things gain speed, the handful of core characters develop effectively, keeping the reader curious. This is complemented by a strong plot that weaves its way throughout and provides multiple surprises on which the reader can feast. I am eager to see where things are headed with this series and how Kelley Armstrong will keep appealing to her reading base!
Kudos, Madam Armstrong, for another strong piece in this time-travel collection.
Love/hate the review? An ever-growing collection of others appears at: http://pecheyponderings.wordpress.com/
Kelley Armstrong is back with another of her great thriller that spans over a century and a half. Mallory Atkinson continues to settle in 19th century Scotland with her secret of time travel. She and her close friends are on their way to a wedding in the Scottish Highlands, a great break from the busyness of the every day. However, during their time there, a man is murdered on the estate and other oddities begin to surface. The family secrets come to the surface and what was supposed to be a celebratory affair is soon covered with an alarming pall. Mallory and her group will have to solve things to bring some closure to a baffling murder. Armstrong delivers a great story that kept me hooked until the final pages.
While it has been a while since Mallory Atkinson slipped back in time, the former Vancouver Police detective has made the most of her life in Victorian Scotland. Malory overcame some significant bumps along the way and has created meaningful friendships with those she shares a home, including Dr. Duncan Gray. She’s also found a niche to hone her forensic skills as she works alongside Dr. Gray and Detective Hugh McCreadie of the local police constabulary.
While the work is enjoyable, the idea of getting away for a bit is equally alluring. When Mallory, Gray, and McCreadie travel with a handful of others to the Scottish Highlands, the adventure commences. The wedding of McCreadie’s younger sister is the occasion, though family histories could create some concerns. The groom, Archie Cranston, proves to be a prickly fellow, whose estate is beautiful, though scattered with many animal traps. When Mallory and Gray discover a wildcat that has been found in a trap, the injuries baffle them, as nothing seems to make sense.
After the body of a wedding guest turns up, Mallory, Gray, and McCreadie begin investigating. What they discover leaves the trio concerned that someone is hiding something important. The body appears to have been struck by something, while one of the estate managers is acting quite oddly. The more they probe, the fewer answers come to the surface. Soon, a missing child is added to the mix and more confusion ensues. With the wedding now on the back burner, Mallory and Gray will have to slyly get answers, reporting to McCreadie so that an arrest can be made. Kelley Armstrong delivers a chilling story that mixes ideas of both Victorian Scotland with police work in the 21st century.
I discovered the work of Kelley Armstrong and cannot get enough. While it was another series that pulled me in, when I sought to expand my reading base, this time travel series seemed intriguing. The series has kept a solid narrative foundation and provides the reader with a clear pathway to see how events will transpire. As things gain speed, the handful of core characters develop effectively, keeping the reader curious. This is complemented by a strong plot that weaves its way throughout and provides multiple surprises on which the reader can feast. I am eager to see where things are headed with this series and how Kelley Armstrong will keep appealing to her reading base!
Kudos, Madam Armstrong, for another strong piece in this time-travel collection.
Love/hate the review? An ever-growing collection of others appears at: http://pecheyponderings.wordpress.com/
November 29, 2025
This is a well-written, entertaining, murder mystery novel. It has a likeable, intelligent, strong and capable female protagonist who has traveled through time to the past, wit, intrigue, suspense, a slow burn romance, twists and turns, and a satisfying conclusion. This is the fourth entry in Ms. Armstrong's outstanding A Rip Through Time series, and it is best when read in order. The introduction provides prominent details from the previous novels to refresh the loyal reader's memory, or as background for those new to the series. I am looking forward to reading the next entry with great anticipation. Ms. Kate Handford does a wonderful job voicing the characters.
May 17, 2025
Finished Reading
Pre-Read notes
I'm really excited for this one because it's a wild concept– a contemporary detective slides in time and ends up in the Highlands of Scotland in the late nineteenth century. If that isn't cool enough, she's there to solve a crime.
I really like time travel stories that don't get tangled in themselves. To this end, I really appreciated the introduction in which the author catches the reader up on what has gone before in the series. I found this very useful, as I am dropping into this series. I wish more series writers did something like this!
Final Review
“The law is a uniform entity,” I say. “The police are not.”“But does Constable Ross know that?” Isla says, looking crafty..p124
Review summary and recommendations
For me, this one was okay. I get distracted easily if an author creates too many side-quests, sub-plots, or even character through-lines. There was a lot of extraneous detail that distracted from the plot. It was good enough to keep me entertained and reading though!
I recommend this book to fans of accidental time travel, mysteries, and nineteenth century romances. Another time-traveling romance I really liked was Maybe Once, Maybe Twice and another mystery that spans two different timelines that I enjoyed was The Book Spy
Except that never happens because, being a romance . . . ?” I trail off with a shrug. “It all works out in the end.” p270
Reading Notes
Five things I loved:
1. I love that the author included an introduction that catches new readers up on the series.
2. I am such a fan of fish-out-of-water stories and this is a good one. A lot of humor originates from the detective feeling so out of place.
3. ...Gray teased me for flinching at the handling of evidence or the treatment of crime scenes, and I realize it wasn’t just teasing. They’re genuinely amused by my struggle to work in less than ideal circumstances. For them, that’s the norm. p136 Characters pointing out ableism in other characters is great disability rep!
4. “I am disturbingly fond of Macbeth, as my father always said.” p167 I adore the dark humor here!
5. I really love the setting details Armstrong provides about the setting, like the size and compositions of typical dwellings of late nineteenth century Scottish Highlands.
6. I really liked the ending and the solution to the mystery, but it's honestly a little long. The last chapter is quite good and clarifies a few shadowy spots in the story.
Three quibbles:
1. This one took a bit to get going, but once the mystery started unfolding, I was in.
2. I think the author retreads material quite a bit, usually setting and character details, which slows down the pace and convolutes the plot somewhat. This book could honestly have been shorter if it had been better organized.
Notes
1. Content warnings: veterinary surgery, injury to an animal, murder,
2. Contemporary forensic science in a late 19th century setting is a great mashup!
Rating: 🗻🗻🗻.5 /5 mountains in Scotland
Recommend? yes
Finished: Apr 29 '25
Format: accessible digital arc, NetGalley
Read this book if you like:
🔪 murder mysteries
🏞️ stories set in Scotland / the mountains
🐠 fish-out-of-water stories
👩🏼❤️👩🏽 romance
Thank you to the author Kelley Armstrong, publishers Minotaur Books, and NetGalley for an accessible digital arc of DEATH AT A HIGHLAND WEDDING. All views are mine.
--------------
Pre-Read notes
I'm really excited for this one because it's a wild concept– a contemporary detective slides in time and ends up in the Highlands of Scotland in the late nineteenth century. If that isn't cool enough, she's there to solve a crime.
I really like time travel stories that don't get tangled in themselves. To this end, I really appreciated the introduction in which the author catches the reader up on what has gone before in the series. I found this very useful, as I am dropping into this series. I wish more series writers did something like this!
Final Review
“The law is a uniform entity,” I say. “The police are not.”“But does Constable Ross know that?” Isla says, looking crafty..p124
Review summary and recommendations
For me, this one was okay. I get distracted easily if an author creates too many side-quests, sub-plots, or even character through-lines. There was a lot of extraneous detail that distracted from the plot. It was good enough to keep me entertained and reading though!
I recommend this book to fans of accidental time travel, mysteries, and nineteenth century romances. Another time-traveling romance I really liked was Maybe Once, Maybe Twice and another mystery that spans two different timelines that I enjoyed was The Book Spy
Except that never happens because, being a romance . . . ?” I trail off with a shrug. “It all works out in the end.” p270
Reading Notes
Five things I loved:
1. I love that the author included an introduction that catches new readers up on the series.
2. I am such a fan of fish-out-of-water stories and this is a good one. A lot of humor originates from the detective feeling so out of place.
3. ...Gray teased me for flinching at the handling of evidence or the treatment of crime scenes, and I realize it wasn’t just teasing. They’re genuinely amused by my struggle to work in less than ideal circumstances. For them, that’s the norm. p136 Characters pointing out ableism in other characters is great disability rep!
4. “I am disturbingly fond of Macbeth, as my father always said.” p167 I adore the dark humor here!
5. I really love the setting details Armstrong provides about the setting, like the size and compositions of typical dwellings of late nineteenth century Scottish Highlands.
6. I really liked the ending and the solution to the mystery, but it's honestly a little long. The last chapter is quite good and clarifies a few shadowy spots in the story.
Three quibbles:
1. This one took a bit to get going, but once the mystery started unfolding, I was in.
2. I think the author retreads material quite a bit, usually setting and character details, which slows down the pace and convolutes the plot somewhat. This book could honestly have been shorter if it had been better organized.
Notes
1. Content warnings: veterinary surgery, injury to an animal, murder,
2. Contemporary forensic science in a late 19th century setting is a great mashup!
Rating: 🗻🗻🗻.5 /5 mountains in Scotland
Recommend? yes
Finished: Apr 29 '25
Format: accessible digital arc, NetGalley
Read this book if you like:
🔪 murder mysteries
🏞️ stories set in Scotland / the mountains
🐠 fish-out-of-water stories
👩🏼❤️👩🏽 romance
Thank you to the author Kelley Armstrong, publishers Minotaur Books, and NetGalley for an accessible digital arc of DEATH AT A HIGHLAND WEDDING. All views are mine.
--------------
June 15, 2025
(4.25 stars)
Hooray for being back in 1870 Scotland with Mallory/Catriona, Duncan, Isla and Hugh. Kelley Armstrong’s A Rip Through Time series has become one of my favorites and I always look forward to the next book in the series. For those who have no idea what I’m talking about, here’s a quick orientation for you - Mallory is a 21st century detective from Canada who found herself transported to 1869 (now 1870 in book 4 of the series) Scotland, and not as herself. She lives in the body of a younger woman, Catriona, who was a maid in the Gray household. Dr. Duncan Gray and his sister Isla both know who Mallory is at this point and she’s serving as Dr. Gray’s assistant, helping investigate cases with Duncan and Hugh McCreadie, their detective friend, who also knows about Mallory now.
Mallory is the ultimate “fish out of water,” having to get used to 19th century clothing and customs, and with this being the fourth book, she’s doing a pretty good job of it. And it seems that she has decided that she wants to stay right where/when she is.
This time the group finds themselves outside of Edinburgh, to attend the wedding of Hugh’s sister, Fiona. I missed Edinburgh but enjoyed the countryside atmosphere, including the hunting lodge/mansion where the wedding is to take place.
There’s a creepy gamekeeper, dangerous traps on the estate grounds, villagers who don’t trust the new owner (the groom), and more. And of course, a death, as the title says. And an inexperienced local constable. I enjoyed the mystery and the progress in relationships among our regulars.
If you haven’t read any of this series, you could pick this up as a standalone, but you’d lack all the backstory. However, the author has provided a short summary before the beginning of the book, aimed at both new readers and returning readers who might appreciate a bit of a refresher.
I bounced between the audiobook and the ebook for this title, which was very convenient. The audiobook was beautifully narrated by Kate Handford once again.
Thank you to Minotaur Books and NetGalley for the opportunity to read an advance reader copy of this book and to Macmillan Audio and NetGalley for the opportunity to listen to an advance copy of this audiobook. All opinions are my own.
Hooray for being back in 1870 Scotland with Mallory/Catriona, Duncan, Isla and Hugh. Kelley Armstrong’s A Rip Through Time series has become one of my favorites and I always look forward to the next book in the series. For those who have no idea what I’m talking about, here’s a quick orientation for you - Mallory is a 21st century detective from Canada who found herself transported to 1869 (now 1870 in book 4 of the series) Scotland, and not as herself. She lives in the body of a younger woman, Catriona, who was a maid in the Gray household. Dr. Duncan Gray and his sister Isla both know who Mallory is at this point and she’s serving as Dr. Gray’s assistant, helping investigate cases with Duncan and Hugh McCreadie, their detective friend, who also knows about Mallory now.
Mallory is the ultimate “fish out of water,” having to get used to 19th century clothing and customs, and with this being the fourth book, she’s doing a pretty good job of it. And it seems that she has decided that she wants to stay right where/when she is.
This time the group finds themselves outside of Edinburgh, to attend the wedding of Hugh’s sister, Fiona. I missed Edinburgh but enjoyed the countryside atmosphere, including the hunting lodge/mansion where the wedding is to take place.
There’s a creepy gamekeeper, dangerous traps on the estate grounds, villagers who don’t trust the new owner (the groom), and more. And of course, a death, as the title says. And an inexperienced local constable. I enjoyed the mystery and the progress in relationships among our regulars.
If you haven’t read any of this series, you could pick this up as a standalone, but you’d lack all the backstory. However, the author has provided a short summary before the beginning of the book, aimed at both new readers and returning readers who might appreciate a bit of a refresher.
I bounced between the audiobook and the ebook for this title, which was very convenient. The audiobook was beautifully narrated by Kate Handford once again.
Thank you to Minotaur Books and NetGalley for the opportunity to read an advance reader copy of this book and to Macmillan Audio and NetGalley for the opportunity to listen to an advance copy of this audiobook. All opinions are my own.
May 10, 2025
I have become obsessed with catching up on this time travel/historical fiction series! One of the things that I have been enjoying about this series are the interactions between Mallory, with her 21st century memories and experiences, and her 19th century friends and associates, especially Duncan. I love the friendship that they have developed and the camaraderie that they engage in when they’re working together on a case. With Duncan as the Dr and his education and knowledge of what can and cannot be done in 19th century and Mallory with her 21st century detective skills and experiences, some of their interactions are hilarious.
”I believe we require a demonstration. Stand right there, face the window and let me club you in the back of the head. Then we can see which clubs line up correctly.” - Duncan Gray
🤣🤣🤣 I’m still cracking up over that scene, even now as I write this. I was walking my dog as I was listening to the audiobook and when I started cracking up, one of my neighbors came over to see if I was ok because I was bending over in hysterical laughter (I can be easily amused at times). Suffice it to say that there are so many hilarious moments like that in this series, which is indicative of both the series’ characters and Armstrong’s wacky sense of humor. I love a good story that can make me laugh and cry and that will grab my attention from the get-go and never let up until the end. This is classic Kelley Armstrong and why after 21 books spanning three series as well as including several standalones, I remain a huge fan of her work.
Anyway, the book summary pretty much lays out the primary storyline of the murder of Ezra, the best man for Archie, who is marrying McCreadie’s little sister, Fiona, because 10yrs ago, McCreadie broke of the engagement with Archie’s sister, Violet. It’s no spoiler that McCreadie is in love with Isla, Duncan’s sister, and probably has been since he was a teenager. Both McCreadie’s thwarted marriage, and Fiona’s impending marriage are, for the most part, transactional and arranged for the purposes of the bride and groom’s family merger for business reasons. This was quite common back then and still very much alive and well today in some countries and families. None of this is a spoiler since it’s basically how the story started.
However, there is kind of a secondary storyline of the local country folks despising the previous owner of the country home, that the Cranston family has recently purchased. The previous owner had kicked all of the tenants off the property and had forbidden them from hunting on the property (that the former owner before that had allowed them to do for generations). The Cranston family has now set traps to catch poachers. There are other dramas going on, actually a whole lot of drama that keeps the story moving at a very steady pace, basically never letting the storyline drag – at all!
Much of the story revolves around Mallory, Duncan and McCreadie investigating the murder while at the same time avoiding the local, country constable, Petey, who is a young, inexperienced and kind of a pompous idiot, who hasn’t a clue what he is doing. Petey has taken offense to McCreadie, the older, wiser, and MUCH more experienced Edinburgh Homicide Detective, advising Petey on what he needs to do. Suffice it to say, that there is a lot going on for Mallory and the rest of the wedding guests. It’s deep into the second half, that I begin to suspect who the killer was and was kind of shocked when the real killer was revealed.
The continuing character development for Mallory, the Grays and McCreadie as well as the bride and groom was well done. The pacing was steady and the storyline very interesting. The writing was, again, classic Armstrong. I can’t say it enough; I am really enjoying the evolving relationships between the MC’s that is such a vital component to the series. There were some potential changes in the dynamic between Mallory, the Grays and McCreadie that I look forward to seeing where Armstrong goes with those changes. I’m looking at an overall rating of 4.5 that I will be rounding up to a 5star review. I want to thank NetGalley and Macmillan Audio for sending me this eARC in exchange for my honest review.
#NetGalley #MacmillanAudio #DeathataHighlandWedding
”I believe we require a demonstration. Stand right there, face the window and let me club you in the back of the head. Then we can see which clubs line up correctly.” - Duncan Gray
🤣🤣🤣 I’m still cracking up over that scene, even now as I write this. I was walking my dog as I was listening to the audiobook and when I started cracking up, one of my neighbors came over to see if I was ok because I was bending over in hysterical laughter (I can be easily amused at times). Suffice it to say that there are so many hilarious moments like that in this series, which is indicative of both the series’ characters and Armstrong’s wacky sense of humor. I love a good story that can make me laugh and cry and that will grab my attention from the get-go and never let up until the end. This is classic Kelley Armstrong and why after 21 books spanning three series as well as including several standalones, I remain a huge fan of her work.
Anyway, the book summary pretty much lays out the primary storyline of the murder of Ezra, the best man for Archie, who is marrying McCreadie’s little sister, Fiona, because 10yrs ago, McCreadie broke of the engagement with Archie’s sister, Violet. It’s no spoiler that McCreadie is in love with Isla, Duncan’s sister, and probably has been since he was a teenager. Both McCreadie’s thwarted marriage, and Fiona’s impending marriage are, for the most part, transactional and arranged for the purposes of the bride and groom’s family merger for business reasons. This was quite common back then and still very much alive and well today in some countries and families. None of this is a spoiler since it’s basically how the story started.
However, there is kind of a secondary storyline of the local country folks despising the previous owner of the country home, that the Cranston family has recently purchased. The previous owner had kicked all of the tenants off the property and had forbidden them from hunting on the property (that the former owner before that had allowed them to do for generations). The Cranston family has now set traps to catch poachers. There are other dramas going on, actually a whole lot of drama that keeps the story moving at a very steady pace, basically never letting the storyline drag – at all!
Much of the story revolves around Mallory, Duncan and McCreadie investigating the murder while at the same time avoiding the local, country constable, Petey, who is a young, inexperienced and kind of a pompous idiot, who hasn’t a clue what he is doing. Petey has taken offense to McCreadie, the older, wiser, and MUCH more experienced Edinburgh Homicide Detective, advising Petey on what he needs to do. Suffice it to say, that there is a lot going on for Mallory and the rest of the wedding guests. It’s deep into the second half, that I begin to suspect who the killer was and was kind of shocked when the real killer was revealed.
The continuing character development for Mallory, the Grays and McCreadie as well as the bride and groom was well done. The pacing was steady and the storyline very interesting. The writing was, again, classic Armstrong. I can’t say it enough; I am really enjoying the evolving relationships between the MC’s that is such a vital component to the series. There were some potential changes in the dynamic between Mallory, the Grays and McCreadie that I look forward to seeing where Armstrong goes with those changes. I’m looking at an overall rating of 4.5 that I will be rounding up to a 5star review. I want to thank NetGalley and Macmillan Audio for sending me this eARC in exchange for my honest review.
#NetGalley #MacmillanAudio #DeathataHighlandWedding
November 10, 2025
★★★★
I continue to really enjoy this very readable and entertaining series by Kelley Armstrong. The setting in Edinburgh (and in this installment, the Scottish Highlands) is wonderful and the concept of a police detective from 2019 travelling back 150 years in time to Victorian Edinburgh makes for entertaining and interesting reading.
This is the fourth book in the series and we travel with Mallory, Duncan, Isla and Hugh to the Highlands to attend the wedding of Hugh's sister. The social dynamics are tense as Hugh, although close to his younger sister, had a falling out with his parents over breaking off an arranged engagement years before. When a murder occurs on the grounds of the country estate that everyone is staying in, Mallory and her gang investigate.
There is romance throughout this series but it is such a slow burn (which I enjoy), the plot never feels like it's sacrificing story to further the romance. I like all the characters and enjoy seeing the friendship and found family vibes continue to grow as the series progresses.
I will definitely be picking up the next one in the series!
I continue to really enjoy this very readable and entertaining series by Kelley Armstrong. The setting in Edinburgh (and in this installment, the Scottish Highlands) is wonderful and the concept of a police detective from 2019 travelling back 150 years in time to Victorian Edinburgh makes for entertaining and interesting reading.
This is the fourth book in the series and we travel with Mallory, Duncan, Isla and Hugh to the Highlands to attend the wedding of Hugh's sister. The social dynamics are tense as Hugh, although close to his younger sister, had a falling out with his parents over breaking off an arranged engagement years before. When a murder occurs on the grounds of the country estate that everyone is staying in, Mallory and her gang investigate.
There is romance throughout this series but it is such a slow burn (which I enjoy), the plot never feels like it's sacrificing story to further the romance. I like all the characters and enjoy seeing the friendship and found family vibes continue to grow as the series progresses.
I will definitely be picking up the next one in the series!
March 11, 2025
It's no secret that I adore this series. It just truly, gets better with each new installment. I want to devour each new book and yet also take my time, soak it all in, and savor it. Sadly, I almost always devour it and then am left sad that it is over because I want more.
I love how much more we get in this installment. So much more history, so much more mystery, so much more Mallory and Gray, Isla and Hugh. *happy sigh* Armstrong writes so beautifully that I want to step into the pages and experience it all myself, well, minus the murder, of course.
It's another great book in the series, and I'm on edge for the next because so much happens in it. So many feels. So many potential feels on the horizon.
*ARC provided by the publisher in exchange for an honest review.*
I love how much more we get in this installment. So much more history, so much more mystery, so much more Mallory and Gray, Isla and Hugh. *happy sigh* Armstrong writes so beautifully that I want to step into the pages and experience it all myself, well, minus the murder, of course.
It's another great book in the series, and I'm on edge for the next because so much happens in it. So many feels. So many potential feels on the horizon.
*ARC provided by the publisher in exchange for an honest review.*
May 22, 2025
This is book #4 in Kelley Armstrong's A Rip Through Time series, which combines detective fiction, historical fiction and time travel. The author begins the story with a little review of how a modern day Vancouver detective ended up in 1870 Scotland, so it is possible to jump into the series here. But do start with book one so you don't miss all the fun.
This outing takes place in June, 1870, in the Scottish Highlands. The friends have gathered at the hunting lodge of Archie Cranston, who is marrying Detective McCreadie's sister Fiona. Unfortunately before the ceremony can take place, someone is found murdered. The local policeman is inexperienced and seems inept but McCreadie cannot take over the case. However he and his friends can do some unofficial investigating of their own.
This series is always lots of fun, especially since we keep hoping we'll see romance blossom soon for some of our favorite characters. This story has an interesting conclusion--see if you agree whether justice was served.
Many thanks to the author and publisher for providing me with an arc of this new novel via NetGalley.
My review is voluntary and the opinions expressed are my own.
This outing takes place in June, 1870, in the Scottish Highlands. The friends have gathered at the hunting lodge of Archie Cranston, who is marrying Detective McCreadie's sister Fiona. Unfortunately before the ceremony can take place, someone is found murdered. The local policeman is inexperienced and seems inept but McCreadie cannot take over the case. However he and his friends can do some unofficial investigating of their own.
This series is always lots of fun, especially since we keep hoping we'll see romance blossom soon for some of our favorite characters. This story has an interesting conclusion--see if you agree whether justice was served.
Many thanks to the author and publisher for providing me with an arc of this new novel via NetGalley.
My review is voluntary and the opinions expressed are my own.
April 23, 2025
Special thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for a free, electronic ARC of this novel received in exchange for an honest review.
Expected publication date: May 20, 2025
Mallory Atkinson is beginning to adjust to her new life after slipping through time and becoming a housemaid in Victorian Scotland. Working for undertaker Dr. Duncan Grey, she also uses her police experience to assist Grey and his friend, Hugh McCreadie, in investigating and solving local crimes. In this installment, Mallory, Grey and McCreadie are on their way to the Scottish Highlands for McCreadie’s youngest sister’s wedding but, as is to be expected, Mallory and her friends end up investigating a murder when the best man is found dead.
“Death at a Highland Wedding” is the fourth installment in Kelly Armstrong’s “A Rip Through Time” series. Think “Outlander” with a police investigation, murder mystery component, and you have Armstrong’s time travel series.
Although I have read the first three novels in this series, it had been a while so I appreciated Armstrong’s recap at the beginning of the novel. This would also be helpful for anyone who jumped into book four without reading the previous three, although I wouldn’t recommend it. Although it is easy to follow either way, Armstrong’s “Time” series is definitely one of those that should be read consecutively, as it is most definitely worth the time and effort to get the full experience.
Mallory is just starting to come to terms with her feelings for Grey, so expect slow, creeping romantic tension. “Wedding” has a few of these secret romances, as well as some adorable kittens, and some very disturbing secrets that are treated very differently in Victorian Scotland than they would be today. Combined, Armstrong’s novel creates non-stop, page-turning drama and action from the first page.
I love Mallory as a protagonist as she is sharp, sassy and relatable. In “Wedding”, there is a small glimpse (and I mean a sentence or two) of Mallory’s former life and some mystery about how she transported back and forth is hinted at, although I’m glad she chose to remain in the past. Duncan continues to be completely socially awkward but brilliant and I love that Armstrong brought back McCreadie and Isla for book four, as they have slowly started to develop their own plotline, which I completely support.
I love books that take place in Scotland, regardless of the era, and I’m almost as big of a fan of time travel novels, so Armstrong’s “Wedding” was a no-brainer for me. Armstrong has numerous other novels, both stand-alones and series, but I have only had the pleasure of reading her “A Rip Through Time” novels, though I continue to be curious about her other stories. I’m definitely going to be looking for more Mallory and Grey, but I might just check out some of Armstrong’s other novels in the interim.
Expected publication date: May 20, 2025
Mallory Atkinson is beginning to adjust to her new life after slipping through time and becoming a housemaid in Victorian Scotland. Working for undertaker Dr. Duncan Grey, she also uses her police experience to assist Grey and his friend, Hugh McCreadie, in investigating and solving local crimes. In this installment, Mallory, Grey and McCreadie are on their way to the Scottish Highlands for McCreadie’s youngest sister’s wedding but, as is to be expected, Mallory and her friends end up investigating a murder when the best man is found dead.
“Death at a Highland Wedding” is the fourth installment in Kelly Armstrong’s “A Rip Through Time” series. Think “Outlander” with a police investigation, murder mystery component, and you have Armstrong’s time travel series.
Although I have read the first three novels in this series, it had been a while so I appreciated Armstrong’s recap at the beginning of the novel. This would also be helpful for anyone who jumped into book four without reading the previous three, although I wouldn’t recommend it. Although it is easy to follow either way, Armstrong’s “Time” series is definitely one of those that should be read consecutively, as it is most definitely worth the time and effort to get the full experience.
Mallory is just starting to come to terms with her feelings for Grey, so expect slow, creeping romantic tension. “Wedding” has a few of these secret romances, as well as some adorable kittens, and some very disturbing secrets that are treated very differently in Victorian Scotland than they would be today. Combined, Armstrong’s novel creates non-stop, page-turning drama and action from the first page.
I love Mallory as a protagonist as she is sharp, sassy and relatable. In “Wedding”, there is a small glimpse (and I mean a sentence or two) of Mallory’s former life and some mystery about how she transported back and forth is hinted at, although I’m glad she chose to remain in the past. Duncan continues to be completely socially awkward but brilliant and I love that Armstrong brought back McCreadie and Isla for book four, as they have slowly started to develop their own plotline, which I completely support.
I love books that take place in Scotland, regardless of the era, and I’m almost as big of a fan of time travel novels, so Armstrong’s “Wedding” was a no-brainer for me. Armstrong has numerous other novels, both stand-alones and series, but I have only had the pleasure of reading her “A Rip Through Time” novels, though I continue to be curious about her other stories. I’m definitely going to be looking for more Mallory and Grey, but I might just check out some of Armstrong’s other novels in the interim.
June 1, 2025
Story 4.5 stars rounded up. Narration 4.5 stars
I’m such a fan of this series and I was really happy when my turn came to receive it from my library. A one day listen for me.
Mallory is a homicide detective in Canada and through a twist she’s thrown back to 1870 Scotland. She finds herself in the body of a younger buxom housemaid in a doctor’s house. The doctor is an undertaker and skilled investigator of cause of death among other death findings. He works with a Detective solving crimes. The perfect household for Mallory except for cleaning the chamber pots. She no longer has to do that thankfully! The doctor and detective know her story and welcome her skills as a detective. This is the fourth book in this series. This one begins with a coach trip to a wedding for the detective’s sister to a friend of both gentlemen. There’s a houseful of guests and when someone gets murdered it’s up to them to solve it.
The plot was quite intricate with several twists. I usually figure things out before the end of a lot of mysteries, but not this time. I love it when that happens! As with all of these books, I enjoyed the characters and by now I feel like I know them all. This was well written as usual and narrated as well. I am already wanting to read the next one. Highly recommended!
I’m such a fan of this series and I was really happy when my turn came to receive it from my library. A one day listen for me.
Mallory is a homicide detective in Canada and through a twist she’s thrown back to 1870 Scotland. She finds herself in the body of a younger buxom housemaid in a doctor’s house. The doctor is an undertaker and skilled investigator of cause of death among other death findings. He works with a Detective solving crimes. The perfect household for Mallory except for cleaning the chamber pots. She no longer has to do that thankfully! The doctor and detective know her story and welcome her skills as a detective. This is the fourth book in this series. This one begins with a coach trip to a wedding for the detective’s sister to a friend of both gentlemen. There’s a houseful of guests and when someone gets murdered it’s up to them to solve it.
The plot was quite intricate with several twists. I usually figure things out before the end of a lot of mysteries, but not this time. I love it when that happens! As with all of these books, I enjoyed the characters and by now I feel like I know them all. This was well written as usual and narrated as well. I am already wanting to read the next one. Highly recommended!
March 22, 2025
This was another great addition to this series. This time everyone is in the Scottish Highlands for a wedding. The groom has set up traps for wild cats along his estate and one was found dead with its kittens nearby. It turns out that it is not so much the groom who did it but his newly hired game keeper. There is something odd and suspicious about the gamekeeper. It also comes to light that it wasn't the trap that killed the wild cat but the cat was poisoned. Soon after that someone is murdered. It turns out to be a very tangled web and a great mystery!
Mallory is a great character and I love that she is a modern woman in a Victorian woman's body. She absolutely makes this series. I love historical fiction and a good mystery. The fact that you add a strong modern woman to the mix makes this series stand out. My only complaint would be that I wish something more would happen with Gray. This is the fourth book and I am really hoping something happens soon. I highly recommend especially if you love mysteries, historical fiction, and time travel!!
Thank you to Minotaur Books and NetGalley for this ARC.
Mallory is a great character and I love that she is a modern woman in a Victorian woman's body. She absolutely makes this series. I love historical fiction and a good mystery. The fact that you add a strong modern woman to the mix makes this series stand out. My only complaint would be that I wish something more would happen with Gray. This is the fourth book and I am really hoping something happens soon. I highly recommend especially if you love mysteries, historical fiction, and time travel!!
Thank you to Minotaur Books and NetGalley for this ARC.
January 26, 2025
Oh, Kelly Armstrong, you cruel, briliant mastermind. I can't believe you teased us like that and almost let THAT happen again! 😭😭😭 Talk about angst!
This is one of my go to series now, as it has a bit of everything, satisfies my curious brain and brings something different than the usual fantasy or historical or crime or romance books. It actually is a blend of all that in perfect doses. (Well, except the Romance, which as I get more invested in these characters's lives, the more I want of it. Even if it's super slow burn and just a minor subplot).
I loved the new setting in the Highlands, the new characters (especially Hugh's sister), all the mystery puzzles, secret meetings and discoveries. This one also touched on some sensitive topics and I appreciate how it was handled.
The full cast of characters, murder and various mysteries and technical descriptions did make my head spin a little and my brain hurt, but overall, it was amazing.
I'll just go sulk in a corner now for all those "almost" moments and lost letters. 🥹
Thank you St Martin Press for the ARC
4- 4.5⭐️, RTC
This is one of my go to series now, as it has a bit of everything, satisfies my curious brain and brings something different than the usual fantasy or historical or crime or romance books. It actually is a blend of all that in perfect doses. (Well, except the Romance, which as I get more invested in these characters's lives, the more I want of it. Even if it's super slow burn and just a minor subplot).
I loved the new setting in the Highlands, the new characters (especially Hugh's sister), all the mystery puzzles, secret meetings and discoveries. This one also touched on some sensitive topics and I appreciate how it was handled.
The full cast of characters, murder and various mysteries and technical descriptions did make my head spin a little and my brain hurt, but overall, it was amazing.
I'll just go sulk in a corner now for all those "almost" moments and lost letters. 🥹
Thank you St Martin Press for the ARC
4- 4.5⭐️, RTC
May 21, 2025
Disappointing
I’ve been reading this series for years and I’m so invested in these characters that a new book release was like Christmas for me! Unfortunately, the story felt like it should’ve been a novella, a 1/2 way point between the last book and the next book. After all the build up and forward movement of the primary relationship in the book from the previous books, this one feels like a step backward. Why on earth would the author do that?!? Creating random blocks to try to extend the tension is a cheap move and frustrates dedicated readers. When the next book comes out, if it’s more of the same, this series might be done for me.
I’ve been reading this series for years and I’m so invested in these characters that a new book release was like Christmas for me! Unfortunately, the story felt like it should’ve been a novella, a 1/2 way point between the last book and the next book. After all the build up and forward movement of the primary relationship in the book from the previous books, this one feels like a step backward. Why on earth would the author do that?!? Creating random blocks to try to extend the tension is a cheap move and frustrates dedicated readers. When the next book comes out, if it’s more of the same, this series might be done for me.
February 21, 2025
The lastest instalment in the “A Rip Through Time” series brings the same energy that I loved from its predecessors; Victorian murder & mystery, mixed with the slowest of slow-burn (maybe, eventually) romances.
In this newest addition to the series, we see familiar characters return, as well as a cast of new ones - some pompous, some misguided, and all full of their own secrets.
I loved the setting & premise, heading out into the countryside for an estate wedding, only to wind up stuck there solving a murder. Just like the rest of the series, “Death at a Highland Wedding” delivers historical Victorian setting and values alongside our main character’s 21st century mentalities and wit.
*Disclaimer: I was generously provided with an advanced copy of this book from the publisher via Netgalley. However, all thoughts expressed above are my own!
In this newest addition to the series, we see familiar characters return, as well as a cast of new ones - some pompous, some misguided, and all full of their own secrets.
I loved the setting & premise, heading out into the countryside for an estate wedding, only to wind up stuck there solving a murder. Just like the rest of the series, “Death at a Highland Wedding” delivers historical Victorian setting and values alongside our main character’s 21st century mentalities and wit.
*Disclaimer: I was generously provided with an advanced copy of this book from the publisher via Netgalley. However, all thoughts expressed above are my own!
January 5, 2025
Going back in time 150 Years.
The Wedding in the Scottish Highlands at an Estate owned by the Cranston's.
While walking in the woods a kitten is discovered in a fiendish trap and injured badly. The mother cat placed by the trap was poisoned, not death by the trap.
Everything is not right, especially with the groom.
A guest at the wedding is murdered and time is getting short to uncover the murderer before another life is taken.
This was "A Rip Through time novel"
I want to thank Minotaur Books for send me this book.
The Wedding in the Scottish Highlands at an Estate owned by the Cranston's.
While walking in the woods a kitten is discovered in a fiendish trap and injured badly. The mother cat placed by the trap was poisoned, not death by the trap.
Everything is not right, especially with the groom.
A guest at the wedding is murdered and time is getting short to uncover the murderer before another life is taken.
This was "A Rip Through time novel"
I want to thank Minotaur Books for send me this book.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 26, 2025
Death at a Highland Wedding by Kelley Armstrong
A Rip Through Time series #4. Historical mystery, timeslip. Diverse. Best read in series order.
Detective Hugh Mcacreadie’s sister is getting married in the Scottish highlands and Hugh has invited his friends, Dr Duncan Graham and his assistant Catriona, aka Mallory to the week in the country. The Cranstons estate and castle are beautiful, but when traps are discovered in the surrounding wooded paths, Gray and Mallory feel something isn’t quite right. Their unease is proved correct when one of the guests is found dead.
Gray, Mallory and Hugh use their expertise to determine what’s hidden in the woods and why.
🎧 I alternated between an ebook and audiobook copy which narrated by Kate Handford who does the full series. The performance is incredible with characters coming to life over the storytelling. Emotions are clear and distinct as a death is investigated and the traps cause an uneasy background to the estate owner. Mallory can’t help investigating and it’s amusing when she stumbles between her true police background vs. her young assistant persona. Tense situations lead to a bit of an emotional reveal that had me paying close attention to what came next.
I listened to this at 1.5 and slightly higher to more closely match my reading and conversation speed. I love being able to read the two formats together. It deepens both the visual and emotional for me.
I love this series for the grand storytelling, the mysteries, and mostly the characters that are uniquely themselves. Mallory’s occasional lapses in conversation about her timeline and a piece of science or machinery gives us an inside scoop into how she has to adjust her thinking and knowledge back to 1870. We also mourn that Duncan can’t know the world she lived in. He would love the science advances of the times.
Complex, compelling, intelligent and intriguing. It’s an absolute thrill to read this series.
I received a copy of this from NetGalley and publisher Macmillan Audio. I also purchased a copy to keep and reread.
A Rip Through Time series #4. Historical mystery, timeslip. Diverse. Best read in series order.
Detective Hugh Mcacreadie’s sister is getting married in the Scottish highlands and Hugh has invited his friends, Dr Duncan Graham and his assistant Catriona, aka Mallory to the week in the country. The Cranstons estate and castle are beautiful, but when traps are discovered in the surrounding wooded paths, Gray and Mallory feel something isn’t quite right. Their unease is proved correct when one of the guests is found dead.
Gray, Mallory and Hugh use their expertise to determine what’s hidden in the woods and why.
🎧 I alternated between an ebook and audiobook copy which narrated by Kate Handford who does the full series. The performance is incredible with characters coming to life over the storytelling. Emotions are clear and distinct as a death is investigated and the traps cause an uneasy background to the estate owner. Mallory can’t help investigating and it’s amusing when she stumbles between her true police background vs. her young assistant persona. Tense situations lead to a bit of an emotional reveal that had me paying close attention to what came next.
I listened to this at 1.5 and slightly higher to more closely match my reading and conversation speed. I love being able to read the two formats together. It deepens both the visual and emotional for me.
I love this series for the grand storytelling, the mysteries, and mostly the characters that are uniquely themselves. Mallory’s occasional lapses in conversation about her timeline and a piece of science or machinery gives us an inside scoop into how she has to adjust her thinking and knowledge back to 1870. We also mourn that Duncan can’t know the world she lived in. He would love the science advances of the times.
Complex, compelling, intelligent and intriguing. It’s an absolute thrill to read this series.
I received a copy of this from NetGalley and publisher Macmillan Audio. I also purchased a copy to keep and reread.
June 9, 2025
Death and more!
Catriona Mitchel (really Detective Mallory Atkinson 150 years from the future) is now an assistant to Dr. Duncan Gray of Edinburgh.
Let’s just say this has been quite the journey for Mallory. A different more well rounded body does get in the way sometimes as does the clothing of Victorian Edinburgh.
To the outside world Catriona is a rather untrustworthy maid.
Inside her small circle her friends (sort of) know Mallory chafes at the restrictions.
However the household including Detective Hugh McCreadie are off to the wedding of Hugh’s niece to Archie Cranston.
A mess of folks, of poachers, of an ugly gamekeeper, and of village folk denied entrance to Cranston’s newly purchased property, topped off by a murder has everyone on their toes, including me.
Just love this series!
A St Martin’s Press ARC via NetGalley.
Many thanks to the author and publisher.
Catriona Mitchel (really Detective Mallory Atkinson 150 years from the future) is now an assistant to Dr. Duncan Gray of Edinburgh.
Let’s just say this has been quite the journey for Mallory. A different more well rounded body does get in the way sometimes as does the clothing of Victorian Edinburgh.
To the outside world Catriona is a rather untrustworthy maid.
Inside her small circle her friends (sort of) know Mallory chafes at the restrictions.
However the household including Detective Hugh McCreadie are off to the wedding of Hugh’s niece to Archie Cranston.
A mess of folks, of poachers, of an ugly gamekeeper, and of village folk denied entrance to Cranston’s newly purchased property, topped off by a murder has everyone on their toes, including me.
Just love this series!
A St Martin’s Press ARC via NetGalley.
Many thanks to the author and publisher.
May 4, 2025
Book 4 in the A Rip Through Time series was every bit as devourable as the first 3. I do recommend at least reading Book 1 first, because of important background information (though if you do, I'm pretty sure you'll want to read 2&3 as well because this series is addictive!).
I love the Victorian era setting. The lack of DNA, technology, proper evidence and hiring procedures make solving mysteries far more difficult. Heck, the era even makes it difficult for our main characters, Mallory and Duncan, to have a private conversation without worrying about how it will appear to everyone because what a scandal it would be for an unwed man and woman to meet unsupervised. (Can I just say how thankful I am that I wasn't born back then!)
The murder mystery was fast paced and unpredictable. There were several viable suspects, but I had no idea who did it until the very end.
Some characters made progress in their love lives while others at least shed some light on the insecurities preventing progress. Hopefully they can work it out soon as I've been rooting for them since Book 1!
I would love to see this series turned into a TV show!
I love the Victorian era setting. The lack of DNA, technology, proper evidence and hiring procedures make solving mysteries far more difficult. Heck, the era even makes it difficult for our main characters, Mallory and Duncan, to have a private conversation without worrying about how it will appear to everyone because what a scandal it would be for an unwed man and woman to meet unsupervised. (Can I just say how thankful I am that I wasn't born back then!)
The murder mystery was fast paced and unpredictable. There were several viable suspects, but I had no idea who did it until the very end.
Some characters made progress in their love lives while others at least shed some light on the insecurities preventing progress. Hopefully they can work it out soon as I've been rooting for them since Book 1!
I would love to see this series turned into a TV show!
December 21, 2025
we're getting there 👀
June 21, 2025
There’s no getting away with murder when Mallory and Gray are on the case, in yet another excellent and thrilling adventure.
The estate that played host to the wedding provided plenty of secrets, suspicious events, and even more dubious people. There were also intricate familial connections to navigate. As usual, our intrepid investigators played to their strengths and worked together as a well-oiled team, with plenty of lighthearted banter.
Mallory and Gray were still engaged in their dance of will they, won’t they, with things taking an unexpected turn. They were facing a whole host of obstacles, combined with personal reservations, that made things complex. This book is not a romance, per se, but more the hope and possibility of one.
The plot flowed really well through the highs and lows of the investigation, cleverly revealing pertinent details about the way of life from the past and the prevailing detective methods of that time. I believed that Mallory was now in exactly the right place, where she belonged. Before, the whole concept of her living in a different body felt alien and a bit uncomfortable to me.
I can highly recommend this entire series if you like time travel and historical murder mysteries. I think it’s better to read the books in order, as there are a lot of character and relationship development happening.
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for providing me with a copy. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
This review is also on Hooked By That Book.
The estate that played host to the wedding provided plenty of secrets, suspicious events, and even more dubious people. There were also intricate familial connections to navigate. As usual, our intrepid investigators played to their strengths and worked together as a well-oiled team, with plenty of lighthearted banter.
Mallory and Gray were still engaged in their dance of will they, won’t they, with things taking an unexpected turn. They were facing a whole host of obstacles, combined with personal reservations, that made things complex. This book is not a romance, per se, but more the hope and possibility of one.
The plot flowed really well through the highs and lows of the investigation, cleverly revealing pertinent details about the way of life from the past and the prevailing detective methods of that time. I believed that Mallory was now in exactly the right place, where she belonged. Before, the whole concept of her living in a different body felt alien and a bit uncomfortable to me.
I can highly recommend this entire series if you like time travel and historical murder mysteries. I think it’s better to read the books in order, as there are a lot of character and relationship development happening.
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for providing me with a copy. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
This review is also on Hooked By That Book.
May 8, 2025
When I was invited to read/review this by the publisher, I had never heard of these books, much less the author. I went and looked them up, found there were only three books [and 2 novellas] and that this one would be #4 and they looked interesting and very intriguing [this is a real twist I have not read before], and as they were on KU and the audio was readily available at my libraries, I decided why not; the worse that could happen was that I hated them and I would do a "will not review" for this one. So I jumped in with book one and WHOOSH, here we are.
This is one excellent series. Twisty, turny, and a real reminder of what life was like in 1860's Scotland. Seeing that time-frame from someone who is from MY time is...well, there is a lot of laughter, cringe and EW. LOL The four main characters [I have to include everyone; even though technically these are Mallory's stories, Duncan, Isla, and Hugh are SO much a part of these stories that they too are close enough to main characters themselves] are just fantastic, very real, and very aware of just how weird and often precarious their situation is. If you like historical fantasy, this series just might be for you.
In this book, the whole crew is heading to the Highlands [Mallory telling them that it would take only an hour and a half or so in her time as opposed to the EIGHT hours it is taking them by carriage is hilarious and makes for some interesting conversation] for a wedding [Hugh's sister is getting married in an arranged marriage - EEK!] and of course all sorts of shenanigans occur, including a particularly grizzly murder of someone that everyone but Mallory knows well. There are suspects galore and plenty of excellent red herrings and when the nail-biting reveal happens and you learn the whole truth [and y'all, this was...ergh], well, I was in shock and really felt for the characters as they have to absorb some seriously ick knowledge and then move on from it.
Excellent writing and research, really great story and mystery, and fantastic pacing - this one was just what I was hoping for and I can only hope that we get at least a couple more books!! ;-)
Kate Handford is one excellent narrator. She handles all the voices really well, flips between Mallory's "Canadian" voice, her "Catriona" voice and the Scottish brogues of all the other characters like she talks that way on a regular basis and also delivers the story in the very best way and I'm never wishing that there was a different narrator. I highly recommend listening to this series; it is a great way to experience this awesome series.
I was invited to read/review this by the publisher [St. Martin's Press/Minotaur Books] and I thank them, Kelley Armstrong, Kate Handford - Narrator, Macmillan Audio and NetGalley for providing the eBook and audiobook ARC's in exchange for an honest review.
This is one excellent series. Twisty, turny, and a real reminder of what life was like in 1860's Scotland. Seeing that time-frame from someone who is from MY time is...well, there is a lot of laughter, cringe and EW. LOL The four main characters [I have to include everyone; even though technically these are Mallory's stories, Duncan, Isla, and Hugh are SO much a part of these stories that they too are close enough to main characters themselves] are just fantastic, very real, and very aware of just how weird and often precarious their situation is. If you like historical fantasy, this series just might be for you.
In this book, the whole crew is heading to the Highlands [Mallory telling them that it would take only an hour and a half or so in her time as opposed to the EIGHT hours it is taking them by carriage is hilarious and makes for some interesting conversation] for a wedding [Hugh's sister is getting married in an arranged marriage - EEK!] and of course all sorts of shenanigans occur, including a particularly grizzly murder of someone that everyone but Mallory knows well. There are suspects galore and plenty of excellent red herrings and when the nail-biting reveal happens and you learn the whole truth [and y'all, this was...ergh], well, I was in shock and really felt for the characters as they have to absorb some seriously ick knowledge and then move on from it.
Excellent writing and research, really great story and mystery, and fantastic pacing - this one was just what I was hoping for and I can only hope that we get at least a couple more books!! ;-)
Kate Handford is one excellent narrator. She handles all the voices really well, flips between Mallory's "Canadian" voice, her "Catriona" voice and the Scottish brogues of all the other characters like she talks that way on a regular basis and also delivers the story in the very best way and I'm never wishing that there was a different narrator. I highly recommend listening to this series; it is a great way to experience this awesome series.
I was invited to read/review this by the publisher [St. Martin's Press/Minotaur Books] and I thank them, Kelley Armstrong, Kate Handford - Narrator, Macmillan Audio and NetGalley for providing the eBook and audiobook ARC's in exchange for an honest review.
March 16, 2025
I love this series. This installment is more of a McCreadie and Mallory investigation than Duncan and Mallory, but the supporting cast is great and it was fun to see them in a closed door mystery and outside of Edinburgh. Some parts were convenient and rushed, but I’m so entertained I don’t care.
I don’t usually mind Duncan’s abrasive manner because we see his charm through his single-mindedness. But here he was so obtuse it was disappointing. The slow burn is now frustratingly glacial. I’m glad for Hugh and Isla’s progress, though and am ready to devour the next one.
I received an arc from NetGalley
I don’t usually mind Duncan’s abrasive manner because we see his charm through his single-mindedness. But here he was so obtuse it was disappointing. The slow burn is now frustratingly glacial. I’m glad for Hugh and Isla’s progress, though and am ready to devour the next one.
I received an arc from NetGalley
Displaying 1 - 30 of 788 reviews