Nature is filled with lessons.
One of the bright spots involved the tale of how Mr. Connell started off with twelve sheep to begin with. It’s shared early on and was filled with amusing details about some of the possible problems one can encounter when searching for this type of animal in a world where not every seller is honest or has the buyer’s best interests in mind. Honestly, it reminded me a little of pitfalls of online dating as far as needing to vet everything carefully goes.
I was surprised to find so much religious content in a book that was marketed as a memoir about sheep husbandry. My expectation was that the majority of the content would be directly related to the care and keeping of sheep, so it was disappointing to see how often the text veered away from that to discuss his faith instead. Yes, these two topics theoretically could be combined into the same story, but I’d expect the blurb to represent that accurately and for the author to spend much more time explaining why they are so intimately connected in his mind. It’s like writing the first few chapters of a sweet historical romance novel only for zombies to suddenly show up in chapter four and start biting everyone. Authors, please don’t obscure your genres or mislead your audience! It’s not good writing and it is frustrating for people who are specifically looking for the sort of stuff you write as well as for those who have excellent and sometimes even traumatic reasons for avoiding certain genres. There are readers out there who would love a theological farming book, so it only does a disservice to the rest of us to suddenly be pulled into a completely unrelated genre without warning instead of letting everyone know upfront what to expect.
With that being said, I did enjoy the descriptions of what it means to be emotionally attached to a piece of land. That was an off-topic detail that ended up feeling related to the main storyline, and it helped to explain why someone would persevere through the difficult aspects of farming when it would be so easy to sell everything off, move to the city, and no longer have to worry about animal hijinks or sudden illnesses. A little more of this would have been appropriate in my opinion.
The inclusion of so much theology and philosophy also meant that there wasn’t much space left for sheep stories which, to be honest, is the entire reason I picked up this book in the first place. As someone who has only ever interacted with sheep briefly and with a sturdy wooden fence planted firmly between us in real life, there was so much I didn’t know about this species that this book barely skimmed over. The author had a wonderful opportunity here to paint a vivid picture in his readers’ minds of how sheep behave, what it’s like to interact with them, and maybe even a little bit about what they think about the world around them. To see it squandered made me sad as I would have happily read something twice this length if it had genuinely been about the lives of sheep.
I did appreciate how short most of the chapters were. They were almost like a series of very short stories that followed the same themes, so this could be a good thing to read for people who only want to dive in for a few pages at a time. This also made the occasional longer chapters, such as the one on rural decay and the downside of encouraging young people in rural places to seek higher educations and then jobs in other places, more meaningful.
I’d recommend The Lambing Season to readers who love the inspirational genre and know in advance that this is what they’re signing up for.