Now: When Ruthie gets the part of one of Macbeth’s famous three witches she can’t wait to get started. Inspired by the beauty of the film’s Scottish locations and the camaraderie of the cast and crew, she can leave behind the expectations of her family and her lacklustre love life, at least for now. But as echoes from the past begin whispering in Ruthie’s ear and a restless spirit draws her further into its centuries-old secrets, it soon becomes clear that only she can uncover the truth of a terrible injustice.
1050 Scotland: Isobel and her two sisters have learnt about healing from their loving mother Sidheag, and she in turn has kept them safe. But without the protection of their late father, Sidheag knows that her daughters must find husbands or their futures are at risk.
Isobel believes in love over duty and when she catches sight of King Macbeth’s stepson Lulach she can picture a happiness she had hardly dare imagine. But as heir to a Scottish throne that is drenched in blood, Lulach’s destiny is to be a warrior. When Isobel’s actions leave her and her sisters vulnerable to accusations of witchcraft there may be nothing that can keep the three women safe, not even the great Macbeth himself.
As the calls from the past grow ever louder, Ruthie has no choice. Macbeth’s witches have a story that needs to be told and the truth can no longer stay hidden…
I admit, it took me a while to get into this book. I struggled with the unusual names and the dialect, finding it heavy-going and slow to start. Yet, I am so pleased I persevered, knowing that this writer does produce some cracking historical reads.
Knowing the Shakespeare play, Macbeth so very well, when I realised that this book uses the play as its backdrop, this grabbed my attention. In present day, Ruthie is cast as one of the witches from the play as part of a documentary focussing on the historical figure that Shakespeare’s play is based on. Whilst Ruthie is immersing herself in this role, she learns more about what the eleventh century consisted of. Thanks to unusual, cold feelings, a sense that something is “not quite right” and even seeing figures in the flames of fires, Ruthie begins to believe that the past is not as dead as one would think.
This feeds into the past narrative whereby we follow Isobel and her two sisters – the three witches of Macbeth – and what really happened to them. I found this element of the plot to be particularly fascinating, especially considering that Shakespeare’s portrayal was naturally to garner support from the King and his interest in the supernatural. However, as Ruthie observes, these “witches” were healers who knew how to use plants and nature in order to provide rudimentary medicines to the village they lived in. They weren’t casting spells and trying to cause chaos, but simply trying to make a living. Therefore, when the accusations of witchcraft begin to swirl, it became an opportunity for unjust persecution and, ultimately, the death of many innocent women.
Isobel’s story made me consider Shakespeare’s play in a new light. I loved how much research the writer has undertaken and it’s definitely introduced concepts that I had not considered before. Macbeth himself is not necessarily the brave warrior from Shakespeare’s works and I found it interesting how different Lady Macbeth was to the historical figure.
Isobel and her sisters try so hard to help others but eventually this works against them. The significance of the number three is explored in both the past and present, creating a synergy between the two timelines. As Ruthie films more of her documentary, I found I was most interested in what happened to Isobel. Thanks to the intriguing Prologue, the rest of the novel works as a countdown to these opening scenes, creating a sense of fate and inevitability to Isobel’s story. I think this added to the past narrative, building a nervous energy that swirled around the sisters – just like the rumours of witchcraft.
After adapting to the language and names, this book was thoroughly enjoyable. It’s a great take on a famous play and I enjoyed how Collins brings alive a known story and a lesser-known part of history.
With thanks to Boldwood books and NetGalley for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Another really entertaining read from Elena Collins - she is definitely the queen of witchy tales! Set in the highlands of Scotland this is a dual-timeline book with one foot in the 11th century and one in the present day. I loved how the two parts were knitted together and how the book came full circle. I learned a lot about the history of Macbeth. The main characters are all very believable & likeable (or deliciously dislikeable). I did struggle with the mediaeval sections, especially, for the first half of the book: the combination of old Scottish language plus hard to pronounce names (there is a guide but it’s hard to flip back to that when reading on kindle) I felt spoiled the flow of the book. Even the present day sections had some discombobulating names but is a lot faster moving. A great read all in all, I got very invested in Isobel’s story & I’m holding out for a sequel. We need to know more about Mercy!
What a triumph I thoroughly enjoyed this book. I devoured it in 2 sittings. It switches seamlessly between 11th century Scotland and the present day. It tells the story of the 3 witches in macbeth via the making of a TV documentary. Anyone interested in Scottish history or if you like books by barbara Erskine you will love this and while you are on check out the other books written by this very talented writer. I would like to thank the publishers for giving me the opportunity to read and review this book. I loved it!
Loved this one so much, can’t get enough of books about witches. Clearly I was one in a past life because I’m just fascinated by it all. I will be reading all of Elena’s books for sure.
About half way through, I couldn't help wondering if parts of this had been written by AI. Mostly dialogue sections that just had a weird rhythm. Those tell-tale short sentences, and like the characters weren't really speaking to each other--kinda more to themselves.
Frankly the back and forth timeline after each chapter became a little tedious and tiresome. I would have preferred perhaps parts instead of chapters, much easier to transition.
Overall, not particularly well written and sometimes bordered on YA style simplicity.
Once again Elena Collins has delivered another awe-inspiring paranormal dual timeline mystery romance. (I was drawn in too, by the gorgeously alluring cover!) The Three Witches is such a captivating read that once I started I could not stop until I finished it! And yes, I kept turning the pages into the wee hours of the night—even with our current heat wave here in Australia!
This well written timeslip moves effortlessly from past to present as it carries us back and forth in a pendulum swing fashion, with its flawless telling of two stories that are intertwined with each other. With a title like The Three Witches you know it is going to be atmospheric, and it definitely is! But it is also laced with intriguing culture, history and mystery that pulls you in even more. It is obvious the author has done a fair bit of research to make this a believable and yet still a magical story that raises questions. A lot has changed since the year 1050 but prejudice and misjudgement remain the same. I was deeply saddened by the horrible treatment of these women in the past. But other horrors exist today toward various minority groups that display the worst of humanity as well.
This novel centres around Macbeth and the three witches made famous by Shakespeare. His play is heavily fictionalised for dramatic and political purposes. But in The Three Witches during the present timeline, a documentary is being made that shows not only the stereotypes surrounding this piece of Scottish history but also the differences are explored (particularly off stage so to speak between fact and fiction—with the three sisters). And through the past timeline, we see what might have really happened to the three women labelled witches and Macbeth’s stepson who went down in history as being ‘foolish’. Understandable after knowing what happened. This information is brought forward into the present plot where we get a modern viewpoint through Ruth who is instrumental (along with a few others) in uncovering the truth.
In the present, we see actress Ruthie trying out for the part in the documentary and being chosen to play one of the three witches after she delivers a unique interpretation and modern performance. During their time in Scotland--all kinds of strange things happen on and off set. The three witches initially are presented in a more fictional light. But as Ruthie and friends begin to delve deeper into the true story of these three women. Of course, we also learn more about the real Macbeth, his wife and stepson.
We are transported to the past to learn about Isobel and her two sisters who learned about using herbs, etc to heal maladies from their mother. Of course back then, women were called witches who dabbled in such things but today, they would be known as herbalists. One thing about disturbing social behaviour that stood out is how quickly people can turn on their neighbour when things don’t go as planned. Many in the community drew upon and even expected the help of these women to offer remedies for them and their families but when patients did not follow directions and caused their own deaths, the first to get blamed was the healer/practitioner.
Another topic covered in the past is the seeking of a spouse. Women were expected to marry and have children. Many times love was not part of that but in Isobel’s case, she chose love over duty. But her beloved husband to be, chose duty even though he loved her. Everytime I think about her fate, I shudder. Without saying more, this part of the plot invoked a lot of emotion in me.
In the present, Ruthie has an interesting romantic journey, too. She must sort out who is friend and who is a romantic possibility. She is ambitious with her acting and her desire to understand more of what happened to the ladies known as witches and how to help in telling their real stories. Her sudden visionary gifts reveal her purpose to set things right by releasing the truth of this tragedy from the past. How the two timelines work and flow together is magnificent. I was totally engaged with the characters and plot in both timelines that were equally riveting.
The Three Witches is mesmerising and remarkable and has great depth. It was an honour to read. I loved it from cover to cover and definitely recommend it to Historical Fiction lovers around the world.
Thanks to Boldwood Books and Netgalley for the ARC.
This a really interesting, intriguing and wonderful tale about the three witches from Macbeth. In the present, an actress called Ruthie is given a job as one of the three witches in a documentary. It is being made in Scotland about Macbeth and the places and people it may have been based on. In the past in 1050 three Sisters live near the castle with their Mother who is teaching them healing and midwifery. Their story runs along side Ruthie’s and the Documentary cast and crew who arrive in Scotland to film on location. On location in Scotland Ruthie experiences sightings and visions of one of the witches named Isobel. It becomes apparent that Isobel wants the real story about the three sisters to come to light. Ruthie and the female members of the cast and crew soon realise that they need to uncover and tell the real story of the three women. Were they witches or were they three healing women wrongly accused of witchcraft like many other women across the country. A great read and page turner with themes of Sisterhood, Friendship, History, Misogyny, Witches, Healing, Love and Misfortune.
There are lots of things to enjoy about this wonderful dual timeline novel from Elena Collins. A take on the story of Macbeth but this time told from the witches point of view. The novel flows seamlessly from each storyline. I loved both timeliness, the injustices for the three sisters. The setting was perfect and well described. I loved it
3 star ⭐️ The premise of this book, exploring the three witches from Macbeth and their story, really appealed to me. Unfortunately, I found the execution rather clunky, and at times the Scottish elements felt a little shoehorned in to establish authenticity, which ironically made the story feel less authentic to me.
That said, it’s an easy read, and there were some genuinely interesting parts. I’d never really considered Macbeth as Mac Bethad mac Findláich in Gaelic, and I particularly enjoyed the explanation of “eye of newt” referring to things like flower seeds rather than anything sinister!
An interesting premise with some fascinating historical and linguistic details, but ultimately the storytelling didn’t quite work for me.
I have thoroughly enjoyed this novel. Set very close to home for me it was easy to visualise the settling and most of the language-albeit some of the names were hard work! Great characters and a very interesting story line about the 3 witches.
I enjoyed this book. It took me a little bit to get into it but when I did, I loved it. I know nothing about Macbeth or Lady Macbeth or the witches this story centers around.
I loved the historical parts of this book. The modern timeline was slow burn, picking up pace and emotion once it moved to Scotland.
Elena's historical works are always atmospheric and emotional, drawing you into the time period so that you can see, smell, and feel your surroundings.
I enjoyed learning about " The Scottish Play " and "The Scottish King," which I previously only had passing knowledge of.
This is another brilliant dual timeline from Elena Collins. Atmospheric, haunting and powerful the story of Isobel and her sisters is a wonderful one, and I was gripped from the very beginning. The links between Ruthie and Isobel’s timelines were so cleverly woven together and I loved how Ruthie was the one to tell Isobel’s compelling story. I’ve always been fascinated by the story of Macbeth’s witches - they’re always almost portrayed as hags, but it was wonderful seeing them here as women first and foremost - strong, loyal and compassionate women, with healing skills so valuable.
In the modern day, Ruthie gets the part of playing the third witch in a documentary about Macbeth and the potential existence of three witches in his history. Sent up to the Highlands of Scotland for filming, Ruthie discovers she may have her own ties to the individual whose character she plays. As her role set out to mimic the traditional characterisation of a witch, Ruthie starts seeing signs that a spirit may object to such demonisation, and have their own story they’d like to tell instead.
This modern day timeline is peppered with flashbacks of the lives of three sisters. Their mother was a healer and a pivotal part of the community. When their mother passes, the youngest sibling Isobel takes up this mantle. The three girls are well-known in their small community and do no end of good to support their fellows. However, it seems almost inevitable that dissenting male voices want to change the perception of these young women. The rest, is history.
Both timelines were excellent and engaging, complementing each other to form the well rounded story that is the three witches. I love watching each timeline unravel and to discover the ultimate fate of the young woman who are ill remembered. I neither favoured one nor the other – rather, switching between the two compelled me to read on. I was keen to discover how these two timelines were interlinked and to read about history as we know it. Then, consider the far more realistic story of who these women really were.
Characters
A wide variety of characters span the two timelines of The Three Witches. Each have their own story to tell, and are distinct voices I enjoyed hearing from. Naturally, Ruthie and Isobel as the main protagonist in each timeline are our leading ladies in this narrative. Yet, the supporting characters (for want of an expression to define them) don’t feel basic or ancillary. They provide a rich and detailed narrative that makes the story feel realistic.
There wasn’t really a character throughout this whole book that I didn’t like or feel that they didn’t fit in. Sure, there are less favourable characters in terms of their attitude - especially towards women. However, each individual has their place. All in all, I felt the three witches had a pretty accurate depiction of The variety of people in both societies and how they may have helped or hindered the lives of women who men felt intimidated by.
Setting
The location of Scotland was perfect for this tale. The wildness of its history, inhabitants and the elements makes for the perfect atmosphere for such a tale. Of course, it’s also historically accurate! In books like this, I enjoy when an author does their best to honour the true history and take as few liberties as possible. Naturally, historical records aren’t always complete or available. However, it’s clear the author has done as much as she could to make the book as historically accurate as possible with the information available, but also cleverly point out when it wasn’t. The character of Todd, the documentary director, is instrumental in conveying this information. It’s given organically throughout the narrative. At no point did I feel his role was to info-dump or fill in awkward gaps.
Narrative Style
The Three Witches is an incredibly easy read. If I’m entirely honest, I read most of the book in a single day. Yes, naturally having a deadline to review the book for the tour helped. However, I wanted to read on. I wanted to uncover the untold story. Consequently, the chapters flew by with ease an I was able to read this book for hours at a time!
What also really worked for me with this book is that I love a multiple timeline narrative. The way the three witches is written gives us time to explore each timeline in its own right, but each compliments the other in unravelling the underlying story.
Whilst we ultimately know what happens at the end of the earlier timeline (because of history, but also because the opening chapters start here), that doesn’t detract from the narrative. Rather, the exploration of the earlier timeline is about figuring out how the main characters got to this position rather than the ultimate ending itself. As I said, it’s well known how young women could be accused. What’s important to this earlier timeline is why…
Summary
The Three Witches is a perfect read for historical fiction fans eager to learn the truth of the lives of women falsely accused of witchcraft. It’s a heartbreaking tale that will tug at your heartstrings, cleverly packaged in an engaging, highly-readable mystery. If you want to read a novel that not only highlights the injustice and crimes committed against young women, but gives their voice back, the three witches is perfect for you.
I can only hope my review of The Three Witches has done the book justice!
I’ve read other novels inspired by Shakespeare’s Macbeth, but this is the first one that has focused specifically on the characters of the three witches. Although Shakespeare’s witches aren’t thought to have been based on any individual people (he took the idea from Holinshed’s Chronicles which refers to the ‘Weird Sisters’ or ‘nymphs or fairies’), Elena Collins imagines them here as three young women growing up in 11th century Scotland. They are the daughters of Sidheag, a wise woman or healer, and their names are Isobel, Ysenda and Merraid.
In modern day Bristol, Ruthie Reed is attending an audition for a new documentary about Macbeth and the historical Mac Bethad mac Findláech, King of Alba (Scotland), on whom the play is based. Acting is all Ruthie has ever wanted to do, but her career seems to be going nowhere and she’s desperate for a decent role. When she’s offered the part of one of the three witches in the documentary, she hopes this is the opportunity she’s been waiting for and will lead to bigger things. On arriving at Forres in the north of Scotland, however, things don’t go quite according to plan. The cast and crew are plagued with bad luck and disaster – and then Ruthie herself starts to catch glimpses of a mysterious young woman who seems to provide a link between past and present.
Ruthie’s story alternates with the story of Isobel and her sisters, left alone in the world after their mother’s death. Isobel, the youngest, has inherited her skills with herbs and potions, as well as her ability to see the future in the flames of the fire, but in a world where women who are different are viewed with suspicion, these talents could be a curse rather than a blessing. When Isobel falls in love with Lulach, Mac Bethad’s stepson, she believes she has found the security she needs, but Lulach’s mother, Gruoch, has other ideas…
As with most dual time period novels, there was one narrative that I enjoyed more than the other, and in this case it was the historical one. I liked the way the focus was on the fictional characters of Isobel, Ysenda and Merraid and their daily lives in the village rather than on the real historical figures such as Mac Bethad and Gruoch, who appear only occasionally. It was easy to see where Isobel’s story was heading, particularly as we get a hint of it in the Prologue, but that didn’t make it any less impactful. Although widespread witch trials and burnings peaked in Scotland in the 16th and 17th centuries, women were obviously being accused of witchcraft much earlier than that, so it’s not impossible that the historical Macbeth could have met women like Isobel and her two sisters – and this is something Ruthie and her friends in the modern day narrative begin to research, believing that the witches (both in the play and in history) deserve to be given more attention after centuries of being interpreted through the lens of misogyny.
I liked Ruthie and enjoyed following the filming of the documentary, but it did feel that her storyline was there mainly to add more context to the historical one and I didn’t become quite as invested in her chapters as I did in Isobel’s. The supernatural element of the book is well done – although it’s not a time travel or timeslip novel, there are moments where past and present seem to merge – but I wasn’t convinced that everyone else would have been so ready to believe Ruthie when she told them what she’d been experiencing! There’s also a romance for Ruthie which seemed to happen very suddenly and not with the person I’d expected it would be with.
Overall, I found this an interesting, engaging read. It’s the first I’ve read by Elena Collins, so I’m looking forward to reading some of her other books.
This was my first read by Elena Collins, and it will not be my last! 💓
My first degree in English Lit was heavily influenced by Shakespeare. I love all his writings- the comedies and the histories. When I read the blurb for this book, I immediately requested it- and I am so glad I did!
The blurb: Present Day: Drawn to the lure of the Scottish locations, and hoping for a wonderful cast experience, Ruthie is excited to get the part of one of Macbeth’s famous three witches. At home, she is dealing with family expectations and her love life seems to be going no where. However, as soon as she arrives, whispers from the past reach out to Ruthie, and a restless spirit reveals secrets from centuries past. She soon discovers that she is the only one to discover the terrible injustice from the past.
The Past: 1050 Scotland: Isobel and her two sisters are healers. They have learned their craft from their mother, Sidheag. Sidheag has kept the girls safe from the superstitions and suspicions of the community. However, with the loss of their father, they have also lost his protection. Sidheag realizes that her daughters must find husbands for security and safety.
Isobel believes in love. She catches sight of King Macbeth’s stepson Lulach and can see a happiness with him that she dared not dream about. As heir to a Scottish throne that has a bloody history, Lulach’s is slated to be a warrior. Isobel then takes action, but these actions leave she and her sisters vulnerable to accusations of witchcraft. Even the great MacBeth cannot protect them and keep them safe.
Ruthie has no choice to listen to the whispers of the past because Macbeth’s witches have a story that needs to be told and the truth can no longer stay hidden…
The way this story unfolds is mesmerizing. It switches from the present to the past seamlessly. The story from the past is told from the three witches point of view. They are woven together so that the reader is completely invested , and is able to see the connection between Ruthie and the witches. It is a fantastic blend of atmosphere, mystery and the culture/history of the time. Although the story revolves around Macbeth and the three witches which was fictionalized, in the present timeline they are making a documentary about the actual history of the play. We are also given quite a bit of information about women's roles, and what witchcraft was thought to be, and how it affected those accused. Most accused were women.
Supernatural things begin to happen on the set. As Ruthie begins to listen to the whispers, she feels the need to discover what really happened and seek the truth. There is also a subplot of a possible romance, but I felt this was a secondary plot. However, it was relative to the story and the growth of Ruthie in coming to accept the "gifts" she acquired.
There were times when I got emotional and uncomfortable with the story- in a good way because ut made me reflect on a past that I hope we never experience again. Collins conveys the treatment of "witches" and the fact that women had to rely on being "protected" by men very well (even though the women had strength of their own). They were at the mercy of the man they married, and often men chose "duty: over love. This was heartbreaking in the story of the past.
I was absolutely captivated by both storylines. I highly recommend this book to anyone who loves historical fiction, with information woven in, women's issues, and just a really good story that you can get lost in!!
Thank you to NetGalley and Boldwood Books for the ARC. This is my honest and voluntary review.
I really like this author; she has carved out a niche for herself in the realm of romantasy, time-slip, and dual-timeline novels—often infused with magical elements—and she is incredibly knowledgeable about history. Her historical storylines always offer a wonderful lesson on Britain’s past. Ms. Collins has thrilled me with her previous novels, so I was delighted to get my hands on her latest book. And I certainly wasn't disappointed! The blurb actually gives a pretty good summary of the plot. We have two distinct timelines: one set in the present day with Ruthie, an actress scraping by with a waitressing day job and occasional acting gigs, who receives an offer to appear in a TV documentary about Shakespeare’s Macbeth in Scotland. If you aren’t familiar with this Scottish play, don’t worry; suffice it to say that the Scottish king in question really did exist in the 11th century. Even though Shakespeare took plenty of creative liberties, most of the protagonists were real people. And—bordering on the realm of legend—there were said to be three sisters, three witches, who cursed the king, his wife, and his heir. Anyway, back to Ruthie: she lands the role of one of the three witches. So, it’s off to Scotland for filming! The second timeline is set in Scotland around the year 1050. Here, we follow Isobel and her two sisters, who live in a village community. Their father fell in battle when they were young; their mother was the village healer and midwife, and when she passes away, the sisters take over her duties. It’s easy to make the connection: naturally, Isobel and her sisters are the original three witches, and the three young women are destined for a heart-wrenching fate... while Isobel’s spirit finds no peace, even nearly a thousand years later... These two alternating storylines are linked by Isobel’s spirit—which has left traces in the Scottish village that persist to this day, and to which Ruthie, in particular, is highly attuned. The question is: can Ruthie help Isobel and uncover her story? My reading impression / conclusion: Let’s put it this way—Ms. Collins hasn’t reinvented the wheel with the basic plot here; this time-slip adventure infused with magical elements has worked well in many books (including her own previous novels), and it works here, too. No question about it. It’s not as if the general progression or the final resolution took me completely by surprise. But—and this is where her talent shines—she simply writes beautifully, and the historical settings are always distinctive and unique. I felt the history regarding Scotland and the royal bloodline was well-researched and portrayed, and I learned something new in the process. I found the female protagonists wonderful and relatable; the entire cast completely won me over. We experienced the full spectrum of powerful emotions—love, adventure, friendship, family, loss, despair—all set against the magnificent backdrop of a coastal Highland village. The two narrative strands are beautifully interwoven, and I found the story entirely convincing. It is superbly written—a fantastic, immersive read. What more could you ask for? I was thoroughly entertained. So, thank you to the author, the publisher, and NetGalley for a fantastic adventure and this review copy!
My thanks to NetGalley and Boldwood for an advance copy.
Elena Collins’ latest is best described as atmospheric with supernatural overtones. The three witches of the title are none other than the Wyrd Sisters conjured in Shakespeare’s ‘Macbeth,’ here called ‘the Scottish play’ in deference to the theatrical superstition that its true title invokes bad luck. This is a timeslip/dual timeline novel. One part takes place in 1095, and is about three actual sisters. Merraid, the eldest, is the quietest and most reflective; middle daughter Ysenda is bold and beautiful; the youngest, Isobel, seems to have inherited her mother’s gifts as a herbalist, healer and midwife. Folklore suggests that the third daughter—the third of three—has special powers. With both parents dead when they were barely out of childhood, the fate of many families in this dangerous time, they know how to take care of themselves and each other. Women of this time worked constantly, especially if they didn’t have husbands, and had to grow small crops in bad soil, keep chickens and cows, hunt, weave, bake, gathering herbs to make medicine. Many of these subsistence chores remained theirs after marriage too. Most bore many children in short order. And pregnancy and childbirth were frequently fatal.
Healing was largely a woman’s vocation, brings in coins and food and allowing a certain status. It also left women open to superstition and charges of witchcraft, for which a brutal public execution was considered just punishment.
Without giving too much away, I’ll say that Isobel’s gift, Ysenda’s ambitions for a wealthy husband, and Merraid’s radiant love for one of the king’s soldiers, lead them first to joy and then to horror.
The other, contemporary story is interwoven with the much darker 11th century episode. A group of actors, mostly English, are hired to perform on location in a tiny Northern Scottish village (Moray) with historic ties to Macbeth. They are filming a documentary, mostly in the woods and on the beach, filling in historic detail about what the play leaves out. They are constantly cold, wet and uncomfortable but mostly get along. Ruthie, who is the third of the three witches, begins to have visions about a young woman and fire. Soon it becomes clear that she has a special empathic connection to Isobel.
The author slowly builds up suspense, though the contemporary narrative seems to move much more quickly. This is likely due to the beautiful, immersive details about the landscape that she lays out in the historic part which don’t need repeating, and partly because the sisters’ story is much more dramatic. While 21st century Scotland is lovely, and the actors are keen to express their appreciation despite the weather, it doesn’t have the same feeling as the primitive barely-formed world of Macbeth’s time. The contemporary story’s conclusion, to my mind, seemed far less believable than that of the three sisters.
Thank you to NetGalley and Boldwood Books for providing me with an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.
I really love reading historical fiction, especially further back than history from the last two or three centuries. The fact that this book not only gets into a historical timeline in the 11th century, but also manages to tie it back to the events in Shakespeare’s Macbeth through the filming of a documentary.
I was immediately drawn into the 11th century timeline. It was easy to predict what the general outcome was going to be for three orphaned teenagers who practice healing and midwifery in a small village on the heath. However, I was engaged with Isobel and her sisters, and loved how each of their decisions and experiences all play a role in a coherent timeline of events. I will give the author credit for not including gratuitous violence, and dealing with witch hunts with sensitivity.
I started to enjoy the present day timeline more when filming of the documentary started and the author who started dropping bits and pieces of the story enough to put things together as they were being shaped. Ruthie read as a pretty flat character for me, especially since there didn’t seem to be much to her other than her love of acting and trying to find a positive aspect to everything. Instead, it felt to me like she was just there to be the person who the clues from the past are being revealed to, but there wasn’t a lot of personality there that I could see.
I’ve read some Shakespeare, including Macbeth, and had no idea about the factual basis behind the play. Macbeth, Lady Macbeth (Gruoch), Lulach, and others are documented historical figures, although the play was tailored to suit King James’ preferences. I love how the author overlaid modern day knowledge with the past timeline and the historical events, and it kept me engrossed with the story and learning more about this aspect of Scottish history.
Overall, this was a really enjoyable book. The pacing was steady, the jumps between timelines were clearly denoted, and the voices of Ruthie’s and Isobel’s chapters differed significantly so I was never confused about when and with whom the scene was set. There was a small romantic subplot that ran towards the end of the book, but I didn’t really feel like it felt organic. It didn’t add much to the story, and there wasn’t any tension or chemistry between them. However, I did love all the side characters and thought they were done really well. This is a great story.
Bottom line: The story is a wonderful homage to Macbeth, so if you like historical fiction, history, Shakespeare, or even just a book that features vividly beautiful scenery.
Let's start with the positives: I thoroughly enjoyed this story. It's an easy, quick read and I always love how Elena Collins pulls you into the narrative through her beautiful descriptions of the places she writes about. I really liked that the beginning of the story was set in Bristol (UK), where I lived for five years. I don't live far even now, and though I don't visit often, it's a city I love; it was lovely to see some of the places I know being mentioned. And of course, who doesn't like Scotland - the other location where the story is set?
However, there were some drawbacks: The book felt more like a YA story as it wasn't very deep. The modern characters - although pleasant - were not fully developed; you don't get a sense of intimate knowledge of them, while the characters from 1048 Scotland felt closer to me, and I really became fond of them.
It's still an enjoyable story, but I wish the modern characters were explored a bit better and that part of the story were a bit more realistic. For instance, the fact that ALL of them accept the presence of a ghost without questioning it, or even being too bothered by it, feels a bit forced.
That said, there is one thing I cannot get on board with: the historical inaccuracy, which isn't usual for Elena Collins. This is historical fantasy, of course, but that doesn't mean the author can completely rewrite history without a solid narrative justification.
In 1050 Scotland, the concept of a "witch hunt" is an absolute anachronism. At that time, the official position of the Church (governed by the Canon Episcopi) was that believing in "witchcraft" was a pagan illusion, not a physical reality.
Furthermore, the linguistic context is completely off. In 11th-century Scotland, the population would have spoken Gaelic (or Northumbrian in the south), and the modern word "witch" - let alone the concept of a woman having a "pact with the Devil"- simply did not exist. This framework only emerged centuries later, around the 1400s. In 1050, a woman with knowledge of herbs or the "second sight" would have been seen as a "wise woman" or a healer, and likely an integrated and respected member of her community. For a book that presents itself as historically accurate, shifting the Great Scottish Witch Hunt back by 500 years and using such modern concepts feels like a major oversight that breaks the immersion.
In the play Macbeth, the Wyrd Sisters are depicted as the stereotypical wart nosed, grotesque creatures who lead him to ruin. This historical fiction explores these Wyrd Sisters under a different lense. In all probability they were probably very human and aesthetically normal looking women who are simply healers.
The story is told through a split timeline (which I love): 1.) 11th century Scotland-The three sisters lead relatively normal lives taking care of their home, making remedies for themselves and their community, and as young girls do: dream of love and a happy ending. 2.) Present day Scotland- an actress gets a role starring as one of the three witches from Macbeth. As filming begins, she begins noticing supernatural occurrences which spark her to dig deeper into the history of these witches and what became of them.
I was totally invested in the lives of the three sisters, they are flawed but real. They made mistakes but were good women. The ending made me so mad though, it had nothing to do with the author or writing style- it was the events that took place that made me want to crawl into this book and start punching men. One single man in particular.
I also enjoyed the present day timeline but not as much, it added to the story but I thought there would be some climatic event there, so I left that timeline a little underwhelmed.
Also, I loved the Scottish accents and sayings (the audiobook reader was fantastic).
“M gate i m-muir, Am tond. Am fuaim mara, Am dam secht ndirend, Am seig I n-ail,l Am der grene.”
“I am Wind on Sea, I am Ocean-wave, I am Stag of Seven Tines, I am a Hawk on a Cliff, I am shining Tear of the Sun.”
“Have ye heard of the Wyrd Sisters, the fates who spin the thread of life? All’s measured and we can do nothing to change it.”
“As long as there are men, there will be battles”
“‘Words like “eye” just meant seeds, so eye of newt was the seeds of the mustard plant. They were old names. Lizard’s leg was ivy; toe of frog was the petal from a buttercup.’ ‘So there were no nasty ingredients in the witches spell?’ ‘No, they were just old remedies’”
"The entire play misrepresents all the characters. I love it as a piece of theatre, but. It's drama. Beneath it lies the real truth about real people, who lived and loved."
This is a brilliant dual timeline story set in Moray, Scotland, where Macbeth lived. You don't need to be familiar with the play or to be a Shakespeare fan to enjoy The Three Witches. But if you are, you are in for a real treat because the author has included obscure historical tidbits about Macbeth and King James VI. In the mid-11th-century timeline, we meet three sisters, all gifted healers in Moray. In the present day, we meet the film crew of a documentary about Shakespeare's Macbeth, including the three actresses who play the Weird Sisters in the play. The two realities connect through Isobel, the youngest of the healer sisters, and Ruthie, the actress playing the Third Witch, who is also the youngest of three sisters in her family. There is a mystical connection between the two women, and the reason for it is revealed slowly, chapter by chapter. "It's the magical number three: three daughters, three witches. 'Thrice to thine, and thrice to mine, And thrice again, to make up nine.'"
The author obviously researched healers and their remedies for common health issues, as well as how important these women were in their communities. I was fascinated by the old names of common herbs and plants, and why they used them. Everyone knows the witchy spells in Macbeth because they sound so creepy. Not so much when you learn that "lizard's leg" was ivy and "toe of frog" was the petal of a buttercup. Isobel's story was compelling and tragic, a tale of misogyny that continues today. I was so invested in the characters, both from a thousand years ago and the present day, that I hated for the story to end. But that's when you know you've read a terrific book, right? You won't want to miss The Three Witches, no matter how you feel about Shakespeare.
My thanks to NetGalley and Boldwood Books for the opportunity to read this ARC. The review and all opinions are entirely my own.
The Three Witches is a gorgeous blend of historical fiction, folklore, and time‑slip mystery — the kind of story that quietly wraps itself around you and lingers long after the final page. Elena Collins once again delivers a rich, emotionally layered novel that feels both intimate and sweeping.
The dual timeline works beautifully. In the present, Ruthie is instantly relatable: an actress thrilled to land a role that might finally let her break free from other people’s expectations. The camaraderie of the shoot, the Scottish landscape, and her own sense of possibility give those sections such warmth. But as whispers from the past begin to seep through, the tone shifts into something far more haunting, and I loved the way Ruthie’s modern life slowly intertwines with the fate of the women she’s portraying.
The historical storyline is simply stunning. Isobel and her sisters are written with such tenderness and strength that it’s impossible not to become completely invested in their lives. Their world — 1050 Scotland, harsh yet full of belief, beauty, and superstition — is vividly drawn. The looming threat of accusations, the vulnerability of women living at the mercy of power, and the heartbreak of love shaped by destiny all combine into something truly moving.
The connection between the timelines unfolds in a way that feels organic and evocative rather than forced. The supernatural elements are subtle but powerful, adding a shimmering, almost tragic magic to the narrative. And when Ruthie finally understands what the past has been asking of her, it lands with real emotional weight.
Atmospheric, immersive, and deeply compassionate, The Three Witches is a compelling reclaiming of voices too long silenced — a story about love, injustice, courage, and the ties that bind women across centuries.
A beautiful, unforgettable read for fans of Barbara Erskine, Outlander, and Weyward.
My thanks to Elena Collins, the publisher and netgalley for the ARC
"The Three Witches" by Elena Collins is a beautifully written and atmospheric dual-timeline novel that revitalizes Shakespeare’s most enigmatic characters.
The story seamlessly transitions between modern-day Scotland and the 11th century. In the present, actress Ruthie is cast as one of the witches in a film adaptation of "Macbeth." Surrounded by the rugged beauty of the Scottish landscape and the warmth of the cast and crew, she finds herself drawn into a narrative that is much older and darker than she anticipated. As whispers from the past begin to emerge, Ruthie’s journey evolves into one of reckoning, discovery, and justice.
The historical narrative is particularly compelling. Isobel and her sisters are taught healing by their mother and must navigate a world that swiftly fears what it does not understand. Collins vividly depicts medieval Scotland, emphasizing the dangers faced by women who dare to step outside society’s rigid expectations. The love story between Isobel and Lulach adds both tenderness and tension, set against a backdrop of political violence and superstition.
What makes this novel so powerful is its reclamation of the witches' story. Collins transforms them from symbols of menace into complex, compassionate women whose voices were silenced by fear and injustice. The themes of female agency, memory, and the enduring pull of the past are handled with grace and emotional depth, and the gradual convergence of both timelines is hauntingly effective.
"The Three Witches" is a captivating read for fans of historical fiction, feminist retellings, and stories inspired by Shakespeare. Emotional, immersive, and thought-provoking, it lingers long after the final page.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the advance copy. All opinions expressed are my own.
The Three Witches is a brilliantly imagined dual timeline novel that breathes new life into the often misunderstood healing women of old. In the present day, Ruthie an aspiring actress, finds herself drawn to the Scottish Highlands and to a story that seems to echo through the centuries. In the past three sisters - strong, intuitive and bound by loyalty - seem to live on the fringes of society, their knowledge of healing and the power of plants sets them apart. As the timelines unfold, their lives gradually intertwine across time, challenging the story of the so called 'weird sisters' from Macbeth. What emerges is an alternative, deeply human account of the three witches of ;The Scottish Play', one that is rooted in fear, prejudice and resilience rather than dark magic.
The use of a dual timeline is handled beautifully, cleverly weaving together past and present so that each chapter adds depth and resonance to the others; The atmosphere is wonderfully immersive. The historical detail so well researched that this re-imagining feels entirely believable. The author creates memorable characters who stay with you long after you turn the final page.
This is a story that is gloriously uplifting in places and breathtakingly sad in others. The portrayal of the three witches is compassionate and powerful, reclaiming their narrative in a way that feels both poignant and empowering.
If, like me; you initially struggle with the Gaelic names and vocabulary, stick with it - it is so worth the effort Once you settle into the rhythm it adds authenticity and richness to the story.
A fabulous read! If you are a fan of Barbara Erskine this is definitely one for you.
Many many thanks to NetGalley and Boldwood Books for my advance reader copy in return for my honest and unbiased review.
The Three Witches by Elena Collins, this is a dual timeline novel one is during the 1040s with the three witches from Macbeth and the present day is Ruthie who gets an acting job in the documentary about Macbeth as one of the witches. instead of witches at first they’re just three daughters Isabel Marad and Inthia. their mother is a great seer and healer and even reads the fire for the queen. When she passes away Isabel takes her place soon after the mom dies Ynthia gets married middle sister Marad is in love with the Queen‘s oldest son Oin who is a kad and a womanizer something she refuse to see. Isabel has her own secret Love who happens to be the youngest son of the queen and step son of King Macbeth. current day Ruthie lives in Bristol and works out a coffee shop while trying to become an actor and that’s how she becomes the third witch and the documentary of Macbeth. She flies to Scotland to Macbeth country where they’re soothing the documentary but soon after arriving there she not only start seeing messages in the fire she also sees the witches in the woods but this is nothing compared to the next strange thing and deadly thing that happens. she even becomes friends with Seth a local boy from Broom. what are the witches trying to tell her and will she figure it out before someone really gets hurt or dies? let me just say I am a humongous fan of Alayna Collins I love her riding style I love that she always has a romance wether big or small in her books I love the ghost I just love everything about her books this one was good but I didn’t find it was as good as some of her others I still enjoyed it and totally recommended and a lot of people do love it so do give it a try I just always expect my next favorite book with Elena Collins and although I was disappointed her book is still pretty good! #NetGalley, #TheBlindReviewer, #MyHonestReview,