What a clever idea! Weinstein took the lyrics to The Plain White Tee’s hit, “Hey There, Delilah” and wove a complete story around those words. If you love music and enjoy a good love story, this book is for you.
In 1996, Cecelia James is a young reporter for Rolling Stone magazine based in Los Angeles, and one of the things she loves is delving into the backstory of popular songs’ lyrics. Her personal life is a bit of a mess, as she tends to push other commitments aside to follow a story. She has a strained/estranged relationship with her music-loving father, who has remarried and has two young daughters. While in Miami for a story (as well as to go on a cruise with her boyfriend), she stumbles over a hint to what might be the backstory for a huge hit (“What You Do To Me”). No one knows who the song was written for and the group broke up after an awful incident at one of their Miami concerts. The lead singer, Eddie, has virtually disappeared. Of course, in those days, before ubiquitous cell phones and internet, it was more possible to disappear out of the public eye. So everything about the song is a huge mystery.
The book hops around in time, starting and ending in 2023, with most of the story taking place in the late 1970s and mid-1990s. I confess it took me a little while to “get into” this book, with it bouncing between two seemingly unrelated stories and different timelines, but once I did, I was all in. Along the way, you’ll find chapters that each have a song title. Someone has even made a Spotify playlist to go along with the book. Fun!
We gradually get to know what happened in the late 1970s that led to the song and to Eddie’s vanishing. Sara Friedman’s extended family have a condo on Miami Beach (Surfside, technically) and they all head there for any and all holidays as well as summers. Sara’s mother, in particular, is overprotective. She’s been traumatized by something that happened to her sister (Sara’s aunt) when she was young, so it’ was kind of understandable but I still felt her protectiveness was over the top. Sara’s friendship with Eddie, the grandson of the condo building’s caretaker, was forbidden, even when they were kids. I realize this was a very insular Jewish family, but this ban struck me as being a bit of class-ism as well as about religious differences. It also had a little Romeo and Juliet vibe.
So what happened to Sara and Eddie? And Cecelia and her boyfriend? And her dad? You’ll have to read it to find out! Get your tissues ready, if you’re anything like me.