What do you think?
Rate this book
An Old Soul
Isaac André has always felt like a stranger in his own life, his memories slipping through his fingers in ways he can’t understand. Now, the world around him is whispering secrets—coincidences too sharp to dismiss. A fleeting glance from a stranger, a song that hits like a memory, a growing certainty he’s being guided—or shadowed.
In 1996 Chicago, Isaac scrapes by, working at a VHS rental store, saving for a computer, and tending to his warm-hearted grandmother. But the more he notices these eerie patterns, the more reality feels like it’s fraying at the edges. Then, in the glow of an early internet chatroom, he meets Noa Gayle—bold, magnetic, and inexplicably familiar. Their connection ignites like a match to dry tinder, drawing him in with the pull of destiny.
What starts as a fleeting chat spirals into a mystery that bends the rules of existence. Chasing the threads of his life, Isaac must unravel whether he’s hunting for answers—or being led straight to them.
Blending love, mystery, and the eerie pull of synchronicity, An Old Soul is a haunting tale that dances on the edge of reality and illusion. What begins as a chance encounter spirals into a journey that will leave you questioning the boundaries of fate, identity, and the shadows lurking in plain sight.
In 1996 Chicago, Isaac scrapes by, working at a VHS rental store, saving for a computer, and tending to his warm-hearted grandmother. But the more he notices these eerie patterns, the more reality feels like it’s fraying at the edges. Then, in the glow of an early internet chatroom, he meets Noa Gayle—bold, magnetic, and inexplicably familiar. Their connection ignites like a match to dry tinder, drawing him in with the pull of destiny.
What starts as a fleeting chat spirals into a mystery that bends the rules of existence. Chasing the threads of his life, Isaac must unravel whether he’s hunting for answers—or being led straight to them.
Blending love, mystery, and the eerie pull of synchronicity, An Old Soul is a haunting tale that dances on the edge of reality and illusion. What begins as a chance encounter spirals into a journey that will leave you questioning the boundaries of fate, identity, and the shadows lurking in plain sight.
252 pages, Kindle Edition
Published May 6, 2025
75 people are currently reading
14725 people want to read
About the author
M. Kevin Hayden
2 books155 followersM. Kevin Hayden is a novelist from the South Side of Chicago, where he grew up among storefront churches, corner stores, and the quiet echo of stories waiting to be told. His work blends emotional realism with speculative mystery, grounded in memory, place, and the uncanny moments that flicker through ordinary lives.
His debut, An Old Soul, is a slow-burn tale of love, memory, and unraveling reality set in 1996 Chicago. His second story, Willow Rose, leaves the city for the snowbound wilderness of northern Minnesota, where a weary doctor and a mysterious child confront a cosmic, ancient terror.
He writes for anyone who has ever felt out of step with the world, hoping his stories offer a sense of connection and wonder. He now lives somewhere quiet, surrounded by trees and the occasional flash of something just beyond the veil.
His debut, An Old Soul, is a slow-burn tale of love, memory, and unraveling reality set in 1996 Chicago. His second story, Willow Rose, leaves the city for the snowbound wilderness of northern Minnesota, where a weary doctor and a mysterious child confront a cosmic, ancient terror.
He writes for anyone who has ever felt out of step with the world, hoping his stories offer a sense of connection and wonder. He now lives somewhere quiet, surrounded by trees and the occasional flash of something just beyond the veil.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 67 reviews
May 2, 2025
An Old Soul by M. Kevin Hayden
Something is not quite right in Isaac’s life—the lingering feeling of not fitting in, a childhood filled with uncertainty. This is different, however; Isaac is an adult dealing with a sneaking hunch that he was born in the wrong era. Chicago, 1996: Isaac should be out picking up girls with his cousin in the summer heat. Should be…. Instead, he loves to paint, listen to jazz, and look after his elderly grandmother. Isaac might be better described as an introvert. Saving his pennies, he invests in his future and buys a computer. The chat rooms come calling upon firing up the PC, and soon he is chatting with a girl named Noa into the wee hours of the night. This is where M. Kevin Hayden, our author, drops readers into an interesting love story about future times and what a person is willing to do for love.
Futuristic love. Finding our person, that one single being who connects with us. Striking up an anonymous conversation with hopes of love and trepidations of a dreaded catfishing. An Old Soul is a standard affair in warmth and intimacy. Young people find love, like-mindedness, and security in a world where they might feel different. Passionate in its delivery, the book delivers a nostalgic feel as we visit a time where the internet is brand new and a VHS store becomes a destination. The author reminds the reader of dial-up connections and weekly visits to Blockbuster, certainly resonating with people who lived through the era.
I found myself thinking, where is the sci-fi element? The cover, in all its 16-bit glory, suggests as much. The blossoming relationship between Isaac and Noa seems perfect. Perhaps overly ideal. Isaac is left to wonder, what is Noa hiding? We are led down a journey of hoping Isaac has stumbled upon the woman he has been searching for, and yet there are so many questions as to how and why. Noa is mysterious and seems to know more about Isaac than he knows about himself. Of course, when one spends enough time with a significant other, this becomes natural, and yet in this case, it has happened so quickly.
As I rock-climbed the wall of passion, my feet dangled into the unknown. Looking down, I understood the magnitude of a misstep. I was over halfway up the rockface and yet to see the answers. Then it happened. A bombshell drops, leaving me stunned. The seeds had been planted and nurtured through my reading; I saw them, and yet I was unprepared for them to sprout and tell their truths. Connecting the proverbial dots, it all made sense. I had crafted my theories and double-checked my work. I was only partly correct. My ego dwindled, and with a solemn nod of my head, I saluted the author.
Steam rose from this volcanic relationship. Intensity oozed with reckless abandon, snaking its way down a fabricated landscape. Until reaching the bottom, where waves from the ocean cooled the fire and also my thoughts. As my hands clasped behind my head, I felt content. Not a perfect novel, as the love story is a bit drawn out for my liking. Nevertheless, it was entertaining, enigmatic, and had a compelling conclusion. I am giving this 4 out of 5 stars! Recommended for those who love a modern scientific love story.
Many thanks to Muse of the Moon Books for the ARC through Netgalley. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion.
Something is not quite right in Isaac’s life—the lingering feeling of not fitting in, a childhood filled with uncertainty. This is different, however; Isaac is an adult dealing with a sneaking hunch that he was born in the wrong era. Chicago, 1996: Isaac should be out picking up girls with his cousin in the summer heat. Should be…. Instead, he loves to paint, listen to jazz, and look after his elderly grandmother. Isaac might be better described as an introvert. Saving his pennies, he invests in his future and buys a computer. The chat rooms come calling upon firing up the PC, and soon he is chatting with a girl named Noa into the wee hours of the night. This is where M. Kevin Hayden, our author, drops readers into an interesting love story about future times and what a person is willing to do for love.
Futuristic love. Finding our person, that one single being who connects with us. Striking up an anonymous conversation with hopes of love and trepidations of a dreaded catfishing. An Old Soul is a standard affair in warmth and intimacy. Young people find love, like-mindedness, and security in a world where they might feel different. Passionate in its delivery, the book delivers a nostalgic feel as we visit a time where the internet is brand new and a VHS store becomes a destination. The author reminds the reader of dial-up connections and weekly visits to Blockbuster, certainly resonating with people who lived through the era.
I found myself thinking, where is the sci-fi element? The cover, in all its 16-bit glory, suggests as much. The blossoming relationship between Isaac and Noa seems perfect. Perhaps overly ideal. Isaac is left to wonder, what is Noa hiding? We are led down a journey of hoping Isaac has stumbled upon the woman he has been searching for, and yet there are so many questions as to how and why. Noa is mysterious and seems to know more about Isaac than he knows about himself. Of course, when one spends enough time with a significant other, this becomes natural, and yet in this case, it has happened so quickly.
As I rock-climbed the wall of passion, my feet dangled into the unknown. Looking down, I understood the magnitude of a misstep. I was over halfway up the rockface and yet to see the answers. Then it happened. A bombshell drops, leaving me stunned. The seeds had been planted and nurtured through my reading; I saw them, and yet I was unprepared for them to sprout and tell their truths. Connecting the proverbial dots, it all made sense. I had crafted my theories and double-checked my work. I was only partly correct. My ego dwindled, and with a solemn nod of my head, I saluted the author.
Steam rose from this volcanic relationship. Intensity oozed with reckless abandon, snaking its way down a fabricated landscape. Until reaching the bottom, where waves from the ocean cooled the fire and also my thoughts. As my hands clasped behind my head, I felt content. Not a perfect novel, as the love story is a bit drawn out for my liking. Nevertheless, it was entertaining, enigmatic, and had a compelling conclusion. I am giving this 4 out of 5 stars! Recommended for those who love a modern scientific love story.
Many thanks to Muse of the Moon Books for the ARC through Netgalley. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion.
April 20, 2025
Poetically captured, An Old Soul explores themes of existence, reality, and identity in a way that feels both intimate and mysterious. I really enjoyed the way the story opened—it immediately pulled me in with its atmospheric tone and sense of something deeper at play but I felt that Books 3 and 4 could have been given more time to develop. The world was so intriguing and full of unanswered questions, and while that ambiguity may be part of the novel’s charm, I was left wanting just a bit more from the final chapters.
May 30, 2025
Sci-fi based on rich characters
I enjoyed this book very much. This author spends the time to Devon the characters with rich detail and background so that you truly care about them as the science fiction aspects reveal themselves . Can’t wait for his next book!
I enjoyed this book very much. This author spends the time to Devon the characters with rich detail and background so that you truly care about them as the science fiction aspects reveal themselves . Can’t wait for his next book!
June 6, 2025
Captivating debut novel by masterful breakout author, M. Kevin Hayden!
Without giving too much away... Hayden has beautifully crafted this tale of science fiction, romance and philosophy in an impeccably imagined world, akin to The Matrix or Black Mirror - but with a deliciously hefty dose of 90s nostalgia.
Isaac and Noa, the star players of this fantastical tale, will entice you into their lives, their pasts, their minds, their hopes and their dreams, as they take you onto a journey of self-discovery, learning more about themselves, the world around them and human nature than they ever thought possible!
I can't wait to see what Hayden has in store for us in his next novel!
Without giving too much away... Hayden has beautifully crafted this tale of science fiction, romance and philosophy in an impeccably imagined world, akin to The Matrix or Black Mirror - but with a deliciously hefty dose of 90s nostalgia.
Isaac and Noa, the star players of this fantastical tale, will entice you into their lives, their pasts, their minds, their hopes and their dreams, as they take you onto a journey of self-discovery, learning more about themselves, the world around them and human nature than they ever thought possible!
I can't wait to see what Hayden has in store for us in his next novel!
April 16, 2025
(Arc Review) 4.5 ⭐️
Isaac André has always felt like something's off—his memories don’t quite stick, and the world seems full of strange coincidences that feel too intentional to ignore. It’s 1996 in Chicago, and while he's working at a VHS store, saving for a computer, and caring for his grandmother, reality begins to feel like it's unraveling.
Things take a turn when he meets Noa Gayle in an internet chatroom. She's magnetic and oddly familiar, and their connection is instant! As they grow closer, Isaac realizes he might not just be noticing patterns—he might be part of something much bigger. To uncover the truth, he’ll have to chase the mystery of his own life, even if it means confronting things he was never supposed to know.
This is definitely a slow burn . But it’s so interesting and I wanted to understand what was going on so bad that I read it in one sitting ! Definitely worth the read !
Isaac André has always felt like something's off—his memories don’t quite stick, and the world seems full of strange coincidences that feel too intentional to ignore. It’s 1996 in Chicago, and while he's working at a VHS store, saving for a computer, and caring for his grandmother, reality begins to feel like it's unraveling.
Things take a turn when he meets Noa Gayle in an internet chatroom. She's magnetic and oddly familiar, and their connection is instant! As they grow closer, Isaac realizes he might not just be noticing patterns—he might be part of something much bigger. To uncover the truth, he’ll have to chase the mystery of his own life, even if it means confronting things he was never supposed to know.
This is definitely a slow burn . But it’s so interesting and I wanted to understand what was going on so bad that I read it in one sitting ! Definitely worth the read !
June 5, 2025
Wow! This is THE most unique book I have ever read!
For starters it has a SOUNDTRACK! I have never in my life read a book that has a soundtrack (which has some great songs too!)
The story itself was amazing! And there were many plot twists but I was not expecting THE plot twist!
It was an amazing story and had me guessing the whole time!
I would highly recommend this book for pretty much anyone who wants a good read, or anyone who wants a very Chicago story! Or anyone who loves good music and pop-culture references from the 90s!
Loved the book!
Cannot wait to read whatever else M. Kevin Hayden comes up with!
For starters it has a SOUNDTRACK! I have never in my life read a book that has a soundtrack (which has some great songs too!)
The story itself was amazing! And there were many plot twists but I was not expecting THE plot twist!
It was an amazing story and had me guessing the whole time!
I would highly recommend this book for pretty much anyone who wants a good read, or anyone who wants a very Chicago story! Or anyone who loves good music and pop-culture references from the 90s!
Loved the book!
Cannot wait to read whatever else M. Kevin Hayden comes up with!
May 11, 2025
Book Review: An Old Soul by M. Kevin Hayden
M. Kevin Hayden’s An Old Soul is a contemplative and introspective debut novel that delves into existential questions of identity, purpose, and the search for meaning in an increasingly fragmented world. Blending elements of speculative fiction with literary introspection, Hayden crafts a narrative that is both philosophically rich and deeply personal, inviting readers to reflect on the nature of existence alongside its protagonist.
Narrative Structure and Style (4.5/5)
The novel follows a young man grappling with a profound sense of displacement, as if he exists out of sync with the world around him. Hayden’s prose is lyrical yet grounded, balancing abstract musings with vivid sensory details. The nonlinear structure—reminiscent of Slaughterhouse-Five’s temporal play—enhances the protagonist’s disorientation while gradually revealing the emotional core of his journey. Some readers may find the pacing deliberate, but the slow unraveling serves the novel’s meditative tone.
Characterization and Emotional Resonance (5/5)
The protagonist is a compelling study in alienation and yearning. Hayden avoids clichés of the “tortured soul” archetype by grounding his protagonist’s struggles in relatable human experiences: loneliness, the weight of memory, and the desire for connection. Secondary characters are sketched with economy, yet their interactions with the protagonist illuminate facets of his psyche. The novel’s speculative elements—hinted at in the title—subtly blur the line between metaphor and reality, leaving room for interpretation.
Themes and Philosophical Undercurrents (5/5)
An Old Soul excels in its exploration of:
Existential displacement: The protagonist’s feeling of being an “anomaly” in time and space.
The search for authenticity: How societal expectations clash with inner truth.
Memory and identity: Whether the self is shaped by past experiences or something more ineffable.
Hayden’s treatment of these themes avoids didacticism, instead inviting readers to sit with ambiguity. The novel’s speculative edge (e.g., hints of reincarnation or timeless consciousness) elevates it beyond a conventional coming-of-age story.
Critique and Considerations
While the novel’s ambiguity is a strength, some plot threads could benefit from tighter resolution. The introspective style, though beautiful, may alienate readers seeking faster-paced narratives. The speculative elements are understated; those expecting overt fantastical elements might desire more explicit worldbuilding.
Final Rating: 4.8/5
An Old Soul is a remarkable debut that lingers in the mind long after the final page. M. Kevin Hayden announces himself as a writer unafraid to tackle life’s big questions with nuance and grace. This novel will resonate deeply with readers who appreciate literary fiction that challenges as much as it comforts.
Acknowledgments: My heartfelt thanks to M. Kevin Hayden for generously providing a copy of An Old Soul for review. Engaging with such a thought-provoking and beautifully crafted work has been a privilege, and I eagerly anticipate Hayden’s future contributions to literature.
Note: This review focuses on thematic and stylistic analysis; plot specifics are omitted to preserve the reading experience.
M. Kevin Hayden’s An Old Soul is a contemplative and introspective debut novel that delves into existential questions of identity, purpose, and the search for meaning in an increasingly fragmented world. Blending elements of speculative fiction with literary introspection, Hayden crafts a narrative that is both philosophically rich and deeply personal, inviting readers to reflect on the nature of existence alongside its protagonist.
Narrative Structure and Style (4.5/5)
The novel follows a young man grappling with a profound sense of displacement, as if he exists out of sync with the world around him. Hayden’s prose is lyrical yet grounded, balancing abstract musings with vivid sensory details. The nonlinear structure—reminiscent of Slaughterhouse-Five’s temporal play—enhances the protagonist’s disorientation while gradually revealing the emotional core of his journey. Some readers may find the pacing deliberate, but the slow unraveling serves the novel’s meditative tone.
Characterization and Emotional Resonance (5/5)
The protagonist is a compelling study in alienation and yearning. Hayden avoids clichés of the “tortured soul” archetype by grounding his protagonist’s struggles in relatable human experiences: loneliness, the weight of memory, and the desire for connection. Secondary characters are sketched with economy, yet their interactions with the protagonist illuminate facets of his psyche. The novel’s speculative elements—hinted at in the title—subtly blur the line between metaphor and reality, leaving room for interpretation.
Themes and Philosophical Undercurrents (5/5)
An Old Soul excels in its exploration of:
Existential displacement: The protagonist’s feeling of being an “anomaly” in time and space.
The search for authenticity: How societal expectations clash with inner truth.
Memory and identity: Whether the self is shaped by past experiences or something more ineffable.
Hayden’s treatment of these themes avoids didacticism, instead inviting readers to sit with ambiguity. The novel’s speculative edge (e.g., hints of reincarnation or timeless consciousness) elevates it beyond a conventional coming-of-age story.
Critique and Considerations
While the novel’s ambiguity is a strength, some plot threads could benefit from tighter resolution. The introspective style, though beautiful, may alienate readers seeking faster-paced narratives. The speculative elements are understated; those expecting overt fantastical elements might desire more explicit worldbuilding.
Final Rating: 4.8/5
An Old Soul is a remarkable debut that lingers in the mind long after the final page. M. Kevin Hayden announces himself as a writer unafraid to tackle life’s big questions with nuance and grace. This novel will resonate deeply with readers who appreciate literary fiction that challenges as much as it comforts.
Acknowledgments: My heartfelt thanks to M. Kevin Hayden for generously providing a copy of An Old Soul for review. Engaging with such a thought-provoking and beautifully crafted work has been a privilege, and I eagerly anticipate Hayden’s future contributions to literature.
Note: This review focuses on thematic and stylistic analysis; plot specifics are omitted to preserve the reading experience.
Currently reading
October 11, 2025Happy to have gotten a copy of this book. I have heard good things about it, especially Reading my friend, Arielle Winters Review. Thanks for that.
It does sound different and one I want to try. Love Debut Authors. Just starting this Today :-)
It does sound different and one I want to try. Love Debut Authors. Just starting this Today :-)
May 12, 2025
This was an interesting one! From the very beginning, I found myself thinking, “What’s going on?” The direction of the story was unclear at first, and while that made me a little uncomfortable, I ultimately appreciated the ambiguity. It made this book a true mystery because there was never really a time when I could confidently say, “I know exactly what is going to happen.”
As I kept reading, the story kept my mind turning. I was constantly trying to pick up on clues to figure out what was going on, and I appreciated that sense of engagement. In addition, the songs mentioned throughout the book helped establish a mood for the story and, in a way, made me feel more connected to it.
That said, the beginning did feel a bit slow. However, I understand that in order to fully grasp the story, we needed to go through some detail-oriented world-building. I would have liked to see a more balanced approach to the character perspectives. While we did get some sprinkles of Noa’s point of view, the book felt a little unbalanced, with about 75 percent from Isaac’s perspective and only 25 percent from Noa’s. This imbalance made parts of the story feel a bit confusing and, at times, like two isolated events and not one central story.
On a positive note, the level of detail throughout the book was impressive. It helped me clearly visualize the scenes and almost placed me right in the world of Isaac and Noa.
Overall, I would recommend this book to fans of science fiction, mystery, romance, or anyone who is up for a fun and engaging read.
As I kept reading, the story kept my mind turning. I was constantly trying to pick up on clues to figure out what was going on, and I appreciated that sense of engagement. In addition, the songs mentioned throughout the book helped establish a mood for the story and, in a way, made me feel more connected to it.
That said, the beginning did feel a bit slow. However, I understand that in order to fully grasp the story, we needed to go through some detail-oriented world-building. I would have liked to see a more balanced approach to the character perspectives. While we did get some sprinkles of Noa’s point of view, the book felt a little unbalanced, with about 75 percent from Isaac’s perspective and only 25 percent from Noa’s. This imbalance made parts of the story feel a bit confusing and, at times, like two isolated events and not one central story.
On a positive note, the level of detail throughout the book was impressive. It helped me clearly visualize the scenes and almost placed me right in the world of Isaac and Noa.
Overall, I would recommend this book to fans of science fiction, mystery, romance, or anyone who is up for a fun and engaging read.
May 15, 2025
(ARC read. Thanking NetGalley and the Musw of The Moon Books for the opportunity to read and review this book)
An Old Soul by M. Kevin Hayden is a sweet and engaging short romance that's a promising debut. The writing is warm and inviting, and I loved the suggested music playlist - it helped set the mood.
My only critique is that the beginning was a bit slow to get going.
Overall, it's a charming read that I'm excited to see more from this author. I'd definitely recommend this book if you're looking for a nice, quick feel-good read.
An Old Soul by M. Kevin Hayden is a sweet and engaging short romance that's a promising debut. The writing is warm and inviting, and I loved the suggested music playlist - it helped set the mood.
My only critique is that the beginning was a bit slow to get going.
Overall, it's a charming read that I'm excited to see more from this author. I'd definitely recommend this book if you're looking for a nice, quick feel-good read.
October 6, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC, in exchange for an unbiased review.
3.5 stars, rounded up.
First, the good: The first half of this novel sucked me in. It was a literary version of an uncanny valley- it's written in the present tense, and the overly descriptive (almost technical) prose signals to the reader that something is...off. Essentially, the reader is as confused as the protagonist Isaac. I had so many theories, and none of them were right. Hats off to the author for the creativity, and for the authentic recreation of online life in the 1990s (yes, we did meet up with strangers we met in text-only BB chats! It was an amazing technological era to live through.).
But the bad: For as well written and atmospheric the first half was, the other half was a whiplash. The novel went from "slow-burn, curious mystery and character-driven" to "amateurishly written, rushed sci-fi romance with far too many adjectives." Several paragraphs were strangely repeated in one of the later chapters, but in different wording, as if the editors skipped that chapter. And the slow buildup (the first 70% of the book!) was suddenly shifted into overdrive, and the book's conclusion (just the last 7%) was so skimpy on details that it feels like the author just ran out of time or ink.
Also, the Afterword was...a bit much.
So for a debut effort, "An Old Soul" is good but not great. I do recommend, however, simply for the first half.
3.5 stars, rounded up.
First, the good: The first half of this novel sucked me in. It was a literary version of an uncanny valley- it's written in the present tense, and the overly descriptive (almost technical) prose signals to the reader that something is...off. Essentially, the reader is as confused as the protagonist Isaac. I had so many theories, and none of them were right. Hats off to the author for the creativity, and for the authentic recreation of online life in the 1990s (yes, we did meet up with strangers we met in text-only BB chats! It was an amazing technological era to live through.).
But the bad: For as well written and atmospheric the first half was, the other half was a whiplash. The novel went from "slow-burn, curious mystery and character-driven" to "amateurishly written, rushed sci-fi romance with far too many adjectives." Several paragraphs were strangely repeated in one of the later chapters, but in different wording, as if the editors skipped that chapter. And the slow buildup (the first 70% of the book!) was suddenly shifted into overdrive, and the book's conclusion (just the last 7%) was so skimpy on details that it feels like the author just ran out of time or ink.
Also, the Afterword was...a bit much.
So for a debut effort, "An Old Soul" is good but not great. I do recommend, however, simply for the first half.
October 5, 2025
3.75
Thank you NetGalley and Publishers for this eARC!!
This book follows 29 year old Isaac André who feels as if his world is not complete until he meets Noa Gayle via an online chatroom. From there romance buds and leads to Isaac finally feeling as if he is complete. Noa however disappears every now and again for extended periods of time with no communication while away. This leads to Isaac feeling unimportant and as if Noa is hiding something.
This book had me captivated from the very beginning as it was almost nostalgic for me and reminded me of how I grew up in the 90s with VHS tapes and dial up internet. As the story progressed I found myself able to piece the story together to understand the plot line. This was story that was nostalgic and mysterious with a touch of sci-fi. It touched on grief and how it can truly break a person. Sometimes it's not about how much time has passed when it comes to love.
Thank you NetGalley and Publishers for this eARC!!
This book follows 29 year old Isaac André who feels as if his world is not complete until he meets Noa Gayle via an online chatroom. From there romance buds and leads to Isaac finally feeling as if he is complete. Noa however disappears every now and again for extended periods of time with no communication while away. This leads to Isaac feeling unimportant and as if Noa is hiding something.
This book had me captivated from the very beginning as it was almost nostalgic for me and reminded me of how I grew up in the 90s with VHS tapes and dial up internet. As the story progressed I found myself able to piece the story together to understand the plot line. This was story that was nostalgic and mysterious with a touch of sci-fi. It touched on grief and how it can truly break a person. Sometimes it's not about how much time has passed when it comes to love.
September 24, 2025
An Old soul is a beautiful poignant tale that takes you on a journey ! It’s a love story with a twist. Isaac and Noa, the MCs are flawed but in a way that makes them relatable, in the best way. I was rooting for my Shaylas!! It is a very detailed story that made me feel like I was in1996 Chicago. There were a few time when things were repeated that I felt didn’t need to be, but it didn’t change my opinion on the story as a whole!
It’s romance, it’s sci fi , it’s human emotion wrapped into a beautiful story
M. Kevin Hayden has a gift for writing thought provoking stories that leave a lasting impression. To think that this is his debut book is mind blowing! Can’t wait to see what beautiful story comes next
Special Thanks to M. Kevin Hayden and Muse of the moon for the copy of An old soul. This review is my honest opinion of said book
It’s romance, it’s sci fi , it’s human emotion wrapped into a beautiful story
M. Kevin Hayden has a gift for writing thought provoking stories that leave a lasting impression. To think that this is his debut book is mind blowing! Can’t wait to see what beautiful story comes next
Special Thanks to M. Kevin Hayden and Muse of the moon for the copy of An old soul. This review is my honest opinion of said book
December 28, 2025
Isaac Andre is living a pretty ordinary life in 1997 Chicago working at a video store and taking care of his aging grandmother. One upside is that recently he feels like the universe is helping him out in the guise of busses arriving just as he approaches a stop and a musical soundtrack that seems to be fitting his life. As he seeks answers for this odd synchronicity online, he meets Noa, who he falls quickly in love with and who also seems to be able to continue his string of good luck. However, Noa hasn't opened up much about her past and could be hiding something mysterious or even miraculous.
In many ways, An Old Soul is almost a perfect story. It's relatively short (~250 pages) and elegantly developed. The budding romance between Isaac and Noa feels almost real (maybe a spoiler?) but also fresh and innocent. It's a great breakdown of 75% romance and 25% science fiction. I thought we were working towards a time travel twist ala Terminator, but instead found an interesting look at a Matrix-like dystopian future with a little hope. An Old Soul gives a little bit of hope for humanity.
In many ways, An Old Soul is almost a perfect story. It's relatively short (~250 pages) and elegantly developed. The budding romance between Isaac and Noa feels almost real (maybe a spoiler?) but also fresh and innocent. It's a great breakdown of 75% romance and 25% science fiction. I thought we were working towards a time travel twist ala Terminator, but instead found an interesting look at a Matrix-like dystopian future with a little hope. An Old Soul gives a little bit of hope for humanity.
October 13, 2025
Excellent book. Good storiy and characters you were really interested in. Wanted it to go well for the main characters and by the time it got to the end and the book really changed its tone, the science aspect of it comes into play, you will be well vested in what happens to them. Interesting and hopefully not a prophetic idea , but frighteningly sure could come to pass.
July 11, 2025
⭐️⭐️⭐️
ARC provided by NetGalley—a big thank you to them and the publisher for the opportunity to read this book.
An Old Soul by M. Kevin Hayden has a compelling concept that really drew me in, and for the most part, it delivered. I loved the 1990s nostalgia woven throughout the story, the incorporation of music, and the thoughtful nods to classic sci-fi books and authors. The love story at the heart of the book was another highlight—subtle but emotionally resonant.
However, the pacing was a bit uneven for me. The book took a while to get going, and while I initially appreciated the rich detail, it eventually became overwhelming and slowed the momentum. On the flip side, there were parts that felt too rushed or choppy, leaving me wanting more depth or smoother transitions. This imbalance made it a little hard to stay fully immersed.
That said, for a debut novel, this shows a lot of promise. Hayden clearly has an eye for story structure and a love for the genre. I’m curious to see where his writing goes next.
#netgalley #ARC
ARC provided by NetGalley—a big thank you to them and the publisher for the opportunity to read this book.
An Old Soul by M. Kevin Hayden has a compelling concept that really drew me in, and for the most part, it delivered. I loved the 1990s nostalgia woven throughout the story, the incorporation of music, and the thoughtful nods to classic sci-fi books and authors. The love story at the heart of the book was another highlight—subtle but emotionally resonant.
However, the pacing was a bit uneven for me. The book took a while to get going, and while I initially appreciated the rich detail, it eventually became overwhelming and slowed the momentum. On the flip side, there were parts that felt too rushed or choppy, leaving me wanting more depth or smoother transitions. This imbalance made it a little hard to stay fully immersed.
That said, for a debut novel, this shows a lot of promise. Hayden clearly has an eye for story structure and a love for the genre. I’m curious to see where his writing goes next.
#netgalley #ARC
January 11, 2026
Scientia Mater!
What a fabulous book! Absolutely loved reading this. Was not expecting the twist but it worked so well. A book to draw you in and make you think.
What a fabulous book! Absolutely loved reading this. Was not expecting the twist but it worked so well. A book to draw you in and make you think.
January 1, 2026
Soft black boy joy meets 90s nostalgia meets queer love meets Black Mirror, this book is a treat for the soul.
August 5, 2025
Thank you NetGalley for the DRC. The book had some problems with highlighting on my E-reader unfortunately.
I always like to mention the thing(s) I disliked first, so I can focus on all the things I loved afterwards. Approximately 50% of the book focuses on Isaac’s life and how he meets Noa. Noa is described as a 28/29-year old woman who is petite, but very curvy at the right places with perky cleavage. Her appearance is described as dainty and delicate. She behaves more or less the exact way I’ve heard men describing women behavior in my life. She tilts her head all the time, giggles instead of laughs and she does all this cutesy stuff that kind of infantalises this almost-30-year old woman. I 100% reckon I also see this the other way around in romance books written by women. I’ve never seen men snarl/growl, stroke their chin every time they think or have those stereotypical book boyfriend poses in doorways. I just really cringe at those descriptions, because it just doesn’t feel realistic to me. That being said. I think this book was a blast. The plot-twist was insane. Some things are repeated a lot, to which I’m not really sure whether it’s because the author thinks it’s otherwise unclear… or something else. But sometimes I thought: why is this repeated for the third time within the same chapter? I do think the author did a great job in writing beautiful sentences to describe the human experience. I see almost exclusively romantic stories written by women being promoted here, but this man is another example that shows that men are very good at describing love as well. I also enjoyed the nostalgic part and the fact that I was able to look through the eyes of a black young man living in Chicago in the 90s. It brought back memories of my walkman, VHS tapes and MSN. While it does give some attention to the ethical side of the things that happen it feels a bit rushed at the end. I wished the speculative aspect got more attention. I’d definitely recommend this if you love the romance or sci-fi genre. Though it was briefly mentioned I did love the conversation between Noa Gayle and Carolyn Faber. And the afterword is beautiful.
I always like to mention the thing(s) I disliked first, so I can focus on all the things I loved afterwards. Approximately 50% of the book focuses on Isaac’s life and how he meets Noa. Noa is described as a 28/29-year old woman who is petite, but very curvy at the right places with perky cleavage. Her appearance is described as dainty and delicate. She behaves more or less the exact way I’ve heard men describing women behavior in my life. She tilts her head all the time, giggles instead of laughs and she does all this cutesy stuff that kind of infantalises this almost-30-year old woman. I 100% reckon I also see this the other way around in romance books written by women. I’ve never seen men snarl/growl, stroke their chin every time they think or have those stereotypical book boyfriend poses in doorways. I just really cringe at those descriptions, because it just doesn’t feel realistic to me. That being said. I think this book was a blast. The plot-twist was insane. Some things are repeated a lot, to which I’m not really sure whether it’s because the author thinks it’s otherwise unclear… or something else. But sometimes I thought: why is this repeated for the third time within the same chapter? I do think the author did a great job in writing beautiful sentences to describe the human experience. I see almost exclusively romantic stories written by women being promoted here, but this man is another example that shows that men are very good at describing love as well. I also enjoyed the nostalgic part and the fact that I was able to look through the eyes of a black young man living in Chicago in the 90s. It brought back memories of my walkman, VHS tapes and MSN. While it does give some attention to the ethical side of the things that happen it feels a bit rushed at the end. I wished the speculative aspect got more attention. I’d definitely recommend this if you love the romance or sci-fi genre. Though it was briefly mentioned I did love the conversation between Noa Gayle and Carolyn Faber. And the afterword is beautiful.
November 1, 2025
wow! intriguing read
What an intriguing read. Suspenseful, surprising and thought provoking. Enjoyable with gripping moments which kept you reading and wanting to get the the bottom of the unfolding mystery.
What an intriguing read. Suspenseful, surprising and thought provoking. Enjoyable with gripping moments which kept you reading and wanting to get the the bottom of the unfolding mystery.
October 24, 2025
The book explores an interesting enough idea, but it takes way too much prose to do it. A short story would do the trick much better.
June 11, 2025
What a wonderful book! A great love story, and oh the plot twist! I highly recommend!
May 31, 2025
Kinda have mixed feelings about this book. I loved the concept of this book. That’s what drew me to read it. However, I think I would have enjoyed it more if it wasn’t for the following:
- The writing style. There was something about it that made it a little hard to enjoy reading
- The slow beginning.
- And there were sections of the book where the writer kept describing small moments in so many paragraphs (sometimes pages), and I wished he would just go straight to the point.
Wish I could enjoy this book more. Really has an interesting concept. Not bad for a debut novel though.
- The writing style. There was something about it that made it a little hard to enjoy reading
- The slow beginning.
- And there were sections of the book where the writer kept describing small moments in so many paragraphs (sometimes pages), and I wished he would just go straight to the point.
Wish I could enjoy this book more. Really has an interesting concept. Not bad for a debut novel though.
May 15, 2025
This was mildly interesting until I learned what Noa was doing (about 70% in), then it was mostly skim, skim, skim to the end. Apparently, all you need is love.
August 7, 2025
I want to thank Muse of the Moon Books and NetGalley for providing me an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.
An Old Soul drew me in immediately with its nostalgic premise. Set in the late 1990s — a time that holds a special place in my heart — the story follows a young protagonist who is saving up to buy his first computer. Along the way, he connects with a charming girl in a sci-fi chatroom, and the relationship that unfolds feels both innocent and emotionally resonant.
I absolutely loved how the author captured the era. The atmosphere, the cultural references, even the sound descriptions — everything felt immersive and authentic. It was as if I had been transported right back into that world.
That said, I did find the pacing quite slow for the first 60% of the book. There were several overly detailed passages, particularly regarding the artist’s animal rescue missions, that didn’t feel necessary to the story and occasionally pulled me out of the narrative.
Still, despite these criticisms, An Old Soul remains an interesting read — especially for readers who appreciate richly detailed descriptions and are fans of sci-fi themes. I’m genuinely curious to explore more of M. Kevin Hayden’s work in the future.
An Old Soul drew me in immediately with its nostalgic premise. Set in the late 1990s — a time that holds a special place in my heart — the story follows a young protagonist who is saving up to buy his first computer. Along the way, he connects with a charming girl in a sci-fi chatroom, and the relationship that unfolds feels both innocent and emotionally resonant.
I absolutely loved how the author captured the era. The atmosphere, the cultural references, even the sound descriptions — everything felt immersive and authentic. It was as if I had been transported right back into that world.
That said, I did find the pacing quite slow for the first 60% of the book. There were several overly detailed passages, particularly regarding the artist’s animal rescue missions, that didn’t feel necessary to the story and occasionally pulled me out of the narrative.
Still, despite these criticisms, An Old Soul remains an interesting read — especially for readers who appreciate richly detailed descriptions and are fans of sci-fi themes. I’m genuinely curious to explore more of M. Kevin Hayden’s work in the future.
January 7, 2026
I’m giving this one 4 stars and I really liked it overall!
An Old Soul is a compelling, emotional, and thought provoking read that blends speculative fiction, mystery, and romance in a way that kept me fully invested from the beginning.
The story of Isaac in 1996 Chicago immediately pulled me in, especially as the world begins to feel slightly off and starts whispering back to him in subtle but unsettling ways. The early internet chatroom setting was fascinating and added a strong sense of atmosphere and nostalgia. The connection between Isaac and Noa felt intense and fated, and I loved how their shared interests and conversations slowly deepened into something more meaningful.
As someone who was a teenager in the 90s, the technology really hit home for me! The pagers, the early days of the internet, chat rooms, massive desktop computers with huge CD rom towers, and even “AOL” cleverly disguised as another product in the book all felt incredibly authentic and added so much charm to the story.
One of my only real issues was the repeated phrase “It’s your world,” which felt a bit too cheesy for my taste and occasionally pulled me out of the story. Thankfully, that was a minor complaint in an otherwise excellent book.
I absolutely loved the twist and thought it was handled beautifully. Andre was an incredible character and easily one of my favorites. Isaac himself was so well written, and I truly loved the man he was throughout the story. His grandmother was a standout and I adored her! Tommy at the barbershop was another great touch that added warmth and humanity.
This is a great recommendation for readers who enjoy speculative fiction with emotional depth and romance woven throughout. The author did a wonderful job exploring themes of destiny, connection, and what it means to hold onto the people we love. I will definitely be reading more from this author in the future!
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this advanced readers copy in exchange for an honest review
An Old Soul is a compelling, emotional, and thought provoking read that blends speculative fiction, mystery, and romance in a way that kept me fully invested from the beginning.
The story of Isaac in 1996 Chicago immediately pulled me in, especially as the world begins to feel slightly off and starts whispering back to him in subtle but unsettling ways. The early internet chatroom setting was fascinating and added a strong sense of atmosphere and nostalgia. The connection between Isaac and Noa felt intense and fated, and I loved how their shared interests and conversations slowly deepened into something more meaningful.
As someone who was a teenager in the 90s, the technology really hit home for me! The pagers, the early days of the internet, chat rooms, massive desktop computers with huge CD rom towers, and even “AOL” cleverly disguised as another product in the book all felt incredibly authentic and added so much charm to the story.
One of my only real issues was the repeated phrase “It’s your world,” which felt a bit too cheesy for my taste and occasionally pulled me out of the story. Thankfully, that was a minor complaint in an otherwise excellent book.
I absolutely loved the twist and thought it was handled beautifully. Andre was an incredible character and easily one of my favorites. Isaac himself was so well written, and I truly loved the man he was throughout the story. His grandmother was a standout and I adored her! Tommy at the barbershop was another great touch that added warmth and humanity.
This is a great recommendation for readers who enjoy speculative fiction with emotional depth and romance woven throughout. The author did a wonderful job exploring themes of destiny, connection, and what it means to hold onto the people we love. I will definitely be reading more from this author in the future!
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this advanced readers copy in exchange for an honest review
July 11, 2025
A big thank you to Muse of the Moon Books and Netgalley for giving me an ARC of this book!
An Old Soul had me with the synopsis and premise. It's set in late 90s Chicago with our main character, Isaac, who saves up enough money to buy a computer and, on his first day, links up with a mysterious woman named Noa in a science fiction fan chat room. They quickly fall in love, but questions arise as Noa vanishes for weeks at a time, with no warning, and she is loathe to reply when asked.
I really liked the way M. Kevin Hayden describes 1990s Chicago, Illinois. He tells it with such warmth and realism that I couldn't help but be sucked in. There is also a lot of character and and earnestness with the way that Isaac interacts with his job, family, and his neighborhood. It feels lived in and charming, and I loved the beginning chapters for this reason. I wouldn't mind if this whole novella was about Isaac going about his day as a black 20-something nerdy male in 1990s Chicago.
I think where some of the issues lie for me is the pacing. Hayden's prose is great, and I love reading how he describes the world he creates, but I think there's some parts in the book that go on for way too long and are stuffed with detail, while cutting the more dramatic moments down to a page and a half. I also kind of wished there was more time dedicated to the early Internet Web 1.0 stuff - it was more relatable for me, and I think Noa and Isaac got together a little too quickly after talking a few times in a chat room. I was born in '95, so I can't speak entirely for that era, but the idea of meeting someone in real life after talking to them a handful of times in a sci-fi chatroom feels especially dangerous, ESPECIALLY if you're meeting up with a girl for a date.
However, the book won me back at the end with the last ten pages, as they were very touching, genuine and heartwarming. You can tell the author loves writing, and hopefully will continue to write more in the future!
In conclusion, and despite my criticisms, this is a solid debut novella. I will be reading more of this author's work in the future, and I'm glad I checked this book out!
An Old Soul had me with the synopsis and premise. It's set in late 90s Chicago with our main character, Isaac, who saves up enough money to buy a computer and, on his first day, links up with a mysterious woman named Noa in a science fiction fan chat room. They quickly fall in love, but questions arise as Noa vanishes for weeks at a time, with no warning, and she is loathe to reply when asked.
I really liked the way M. Kevin Hayden describes 1990s Chicago, Illinois. He tells it with such warmth and realism that I couldn't help but be sucked in. There is also a lot of character and and earnestness with the way that Isaac interacts with his job, family, and his neighborhood. It feels lived in and charming, and I loved the beginning chapters for this reason. I wouldn't mind if this whole novella was about Isaac going about his day as a black 20-something nerdy male in 1990s Chicago.
I think where some of the issues lie for me is the pacing. Hayden's prose is great, and I love reading how he describes the world he creates, but I think there's some parts in the book that go on for way too long and are stuffed with detail, while cutting the more dramatic moments down to a page and a half. I also kind of wished there was more time dedicated to the early Internet Web 1.0 stuff - it was more relatable for me, and I think Noa and Isaac got together a little too quickly after talking a few times in a chat room. I was born in '95, so I can't speak entirely for that era, but the idea of meeting someone in real life after talking to them a handful of times in a sci-fi chatroom feels especially dangerous, ESPECIALLY if you're meeting up with a girl for a date.
However, the book won me back at the end with the last ten pages, as they were very touching, genuine and heartwarming. You can tell the author loves writing, and hopefully will continue to write more in the future!
In conclusion, and despite my criticisms, this is a solid debut novella. I will be reading more of this author's work in the future, and I'm glad I checked this book out!
May 9, 2025
“People can be strange… but maybe this is all normal, and I’m the strange one.”
I love that this is titled An Old Soul because it has such an old, nostalgic feel. Reading this took me back to my childhood: when Blockbuster & Hollywood Video was a thing, VHS tapes, my first time using a computer, dial up internet, AOL chat rooms!! I felt completely immersed in the vividly drawn setting; Chicago, 1996…the sweltering heat of summer.
Twenty-five year old Isaac Andre feels like a stranger in his own life. His memories are slipping through his fingers in ways he can’t understand and the world seems full of strange coincidences that feel too intentional to ignore. Does Isaac have a string of good luck or is someone or something pulling the strings? After buying a computer with his hard earned money from the video store, Isaac logs into a chat room where he connects with the mysterious Noa Gayle, a girl that seems to get it. Noa is the only one that seems to get him. But why?
“Wherever your world is, so will mine be.”
In under 200 pages, Kevin Hayden explores themes of grief, human connection, identity, belonging, and the profound impact of love. I loved Isaac’s old soul and the relationships he had with the people in his world: Noa, his grandma, the guys at the barbershop, the people he worked with, and his cousin Pete. This is one of those books that you find more meaning in after you sit with it awhile. Isaac and Noa will sit with me awhile. Highly recommend!
Thank you to NetGalley, Kevin Hayden, and Muse of the Moon Books for the early opportunity to dive into Isaac’s world.
I love that this is titled An Old Soul because it has such an old, nostalgic feel. Reading this took me back to my childhood: when Blockbuster & Hollywood Video was a thing, VHS tapes, my first time using a computer, dial up internet, AOL chat rooms!! I felt completely immersed in the vividly drawn setting; Chicago, 1996…the sweltering heat of summer.
Twenty-five year old Isaac Andre feels like a stranger in his own life. His memories are slipping through his fingers in ways he can’t understand and the world seems full of strange coincidences that feel too intentional to ignore. Does Isaac have a string of good luck or is someone or something pulling the strings? After buying a computer with his hard earned money from the video store, Isaac logs into a chat room where he connects with the mysterious Noa Gayle, a girl that seems to get it. Noa is the only one that seems to get him. But why?
“Wherever your world is, so will mine be.”
In under 200 pages, Kevin Hayden explores themes of grief, human connection, identity, belonging, and the profound impact of love. I loved Isaac’s old soul and the relationships he had with the people in his world: Noa, his grandma, the guys at the barbershop, the people he worked with, and his cousin Pete. This is one of those books that you find more meaning in after you sit with it awhile. Isaac and Noa will sit with me awhile. Highly recommend!
Thank you to NetGalley, Kevin Hayden, and Muse of the Moon Books for the early opportunity to dive into Isaac’s world.
October 22, 2025
If I were able, I’d award this 3.5 stars. I’ll do my best to avoid spoilers, but there is a twist revealed about 100 pages in and it’s a decent one. Isaac, our main character, is a huge fan of Phillip K. Dick, but he might have been better serviced by throwing in some Lewis Carroll, specifically when Alice is asked if she’s dreaming or part of the dream. He lives in 1996 Chicago which the author beautifully captures, or perfectly constructs, more appropriately. He feels alone and is saving up for a computer that he hopes will open up his world. Anyone who grew up in that era is bound to feel the tingle of nostalgia for the endless possibilities we thought such technology would bring. Indeed, the twist includes some interesting commentary on one of the most debated technological developments happening today. An enjoyable read, overall.
May 5, 2025
After finally buying his first personal computer, Isaac André is pulled into the strange, buzzing world of dial-up internet—chat rooms, screeching modems, and early digital wonder. It’s in one of these chat rooms that he meets BirdGurl9—Noa Gayle. Their connection is immediate, deep, and uncanny. When they meet in person, it’s as if their bond was written in the stars. But something about Noa doesn’t quite add up. Or maybe... It’s Isaac. He’s always felt out of place in the world, unable to explain why.
What follows is a genre-bending blend of love story and metaphysical exploration. The writing is rich and immersive—I could feel the thick summer air of 1996 Chicago, hear the click of VHS tapes, and almost smell the static of old electronics. As someone who rarely reaches for sci-fi or fantasy, I was surprised by how deeply this story pulled me in. The emotional vulnerability of the characters, especially Isaac and Noa, is what kept me turning pages.
At its core, this is a romance, wrapped in the skin of sci-fi. Noa’s love for Isaac runs so deep it seems to bend time, space, and even reality. Their relationship is haunting, tender, and unlike anything I’ve read. There’s a haunting sweetness to their connection, one that kept me emotionally hooked even when some of the plot’s more complex layers (like all the GAIA, SOMA, NP, and AGI talk) became difficult to follow. I didn’t always fully grasp the technical framework, but the emotional resonance was clear and compelling.
Some moments dragged a bit, particularly for me, in the second act. A long scene involving a trash chute fall felt overly detailed and slowed the momentum. I also would’ve loved a bit more clarity on certain subplots—like the conflict between Carolyn and Jace Faber, which felt underdeveloped or unresolved.
Still, An Old Soul is a nostalgic, heartfelt, and genuinely original novel. It's romantic, strange, and soaked in 90s charm. At just over 200 pages, it’s a quick but memorable read—perfect for a weekend trip or a long flight. I’d recommend it to anyone looking for something different: a story that explores love, identity, and the uncanny way technology connects (and divides) us.
Read the full review: http://whitneydaniell.com/2025/04/29/...
What follows is a genre-bending blend of love story and metaphysical exploration. The writing is rich and immersive—I could feel the thick summer air of 1996 Chicago, hear the click of VHS tapes, and almost smell the static of old electronics. As someone who rarely reaches for sci-fi or fantasy, I was surprised by how deeply this story pulled me in. The emotional vulnerability of the characters, especially Isaac and Noa, is what kept me turning pages.
At its core, this is a romance, wrapped in the skin of sci-fi. Noa’s love for Isaac runs so deep it seems to bend time, space, and even reality. Their relationship is haunting, tender, and unlike anything I’ve read. There’s a haunting sweetness to their connection, one that kept me emotionally hooked even when some of the plot’s more complex layers (like all the GAIA, SOMA, NP, and AGI talk) became difficult to follow. I didn’t always fully grasp the technical framework, but the emotional resonance was clear and compelling.
Some moments dragged a bit, particularly for me, in the second act. A long scene involving a trash chute fall felt overly detailed and slowed the momentum. I also would’ve loved a bit more clarity on certain subplots—like the conflict between Carolyn and Jace Faber, which felt underdeveloped or unresolved.
Still, An Old Soul is a nostalgic, heartfelt, and genuinely original novel. It's romantic, strange, and soaked in 90s charm. At just over 200 pages, it’s a quick but memorable read—perfect for a weekend trip or a long flight. I’d recommend it to anyone looking for something different: a story that explores love, identity, and the uncanny way technology connects (and divides) us.
Read the full review: http://whitneydaniell.com/2025/04/29/...
Displaying 1 - 30 of 67 reviews