What do you think?
Rate this book
Scenes from a Tragedy
If you hurt me, I'll hurt you. Not right away of course, because where's the fun in that?
When an empty passenger plane mysteriously crashes in the Lake District, journalist Carly Atherton is determined to get to the truth of what happened - the love of her life was one of the two pilots on board.
But when she contacts the family of the other pilot, the conflicting memories of his wife and his sister draw her into a story far darker than she could possibly have imagined.
As Carly delves into the dynamics of a seemingly ordinary family, she realises that the bonds that shape us can also tear us apart - and that sometimes there are monsters living among us, hiding in plain sight...
When an empty passenger plane mysteriously crashes in the Lake District, journalist Carly Atherton is determined to get to the truth of what happened - the love of her life was one of the two pilots on board.
But when she contacts the family of the other pilot, the conflicting memories of his wife and his sister draw her into a story far darker than she could possibly have imagined.
As Carly delves into the dynamics of a seemingly ordinary family, she realises that the bonds that shape us can also tear us apart - and that sometimes there are monsters living among us, hiding in plain sight...
- GenresThrillerMystery Thriller
480 pages, Hardcover
First published March 6, 2025
17 people are currently reading
479 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 86 reviews
March 9, 2025
I do love a novel that begins with the what and then plays out to give us the why, and the journey to the why was completely gripping, this was smart, dark, and interesting, my mind was played with a little by the book within a book- another love, it meant I kept reminding myself it was fiction.
From the outset, we know we are unfolding the story of how Danny came to crash his plane killing himself and his co pilot. Through the work of journalist Carly, we meet Danny’s nearest and dearest, Izzy his sister, and Grace his wife, through the three women we travel back through his life, his family and the ties between the three and their families. Whilst the content is serious, I found the author skilled at adding subtle dark and comedic elements sporadically and I really appreciated it, it always concerns me when I find the psychopath endearing for a time, but equally shows great depth and fabulous characterisation.
No complaints. I loved this.
The multiple narration from Eilidh Beaton, Louise Amos and Amy Noble was fantastic each portrayed their characters brilliantly.
Huge thanks to WF Howes LTD and NetGalley for the opportunity to review this audiobook 🎧
From the outset, we know we are unfolding the story of how Danny came to crash his plane killing himself and his co pilot. Through the work of journalist Carly, we meet Danny’s nearest and dearest, Izzy his sister, and Grace his wife, through the three women we travel back through his life, his family and the ties between the three and their families. Whilst the content is serious, I found the author skilled at adding subtle dark and comedic elements sporadically and I really appreciated it, it always concerns me when I find the psychopath endearing for a time, but equally shows great depth and fabulous characterisation.
No complaints. I loved this.
The multiple narration from Eilidh Beaton, Louise Amos and Amy Noble was fantastic each portrayed their characters brilliantly.
Huge thanks to WF Howes LTD and NetGalley for the opportunity to review this audiobook 🎧
March 13, 2025
Actual rating 4.5.
Another very bingeable read that had me absolutely hooked despite the fact it also probably sent my blood pressure through the roof with one of the most detestable characters EVER 🤣 This story wasn’t at all what I was expecting from the opening chapter, and I loved how it took me by surprise and went down a different direction, as we explored the buildup to a tragedy through the eyes of two people close to it. You will absolutely RAGE at one of our main narrators and the people who can’t see through her, but it sure makes for an engrossing read! Great on audio and I’ll definitely be picking up whatever Carole writes next!
Another very bingeable read that had me absolutely hooked despite the fact it also probably sent my blood pressure through the roof with one of the most detestable characters EVER 🤣 This story wasn’t at all what I was expecting from the opening chapter, and I loved how it took me by surprise and went down a different direction, as we explored the buildup to a tragedy through the eyes of two people close to it. You will absolutely RAGE at one of our main narrators and the people who can’t see through her, but it sure makes for an engrossing read! Great on audio and I’ll definitely be picking up whatever Carole writes next!
March 10, 2025
4.6 ⭐️🎧 Journalist Carly Atherton is investigating a mysterious plane crash in the Lake District that killed two pilots - one of them her ex-boyfriend, Luke. As she investigates, she becomes entangled with Daniel’s wife, Grace, and his controlling sister, Izzy.
I loved the book-within-a-book, true-crime-style account. Technically, it’s all from Carly’s POV, but through the interviews, we also get perspectives from Izzy and Grace.
This is undoubtedly a character-led story. It’s all about the relationship between these two women and their separate but linked lives. There’s no mystery - we know what happened right from the start - but there’s a creeping dread as the details are revealed.
I rarely love both the protagonist and antagonist - I’m a sucker for a good villain - but this time, I was obsessed with both women! Izzy is awful (you know I love a psychopath), and watching Grace come into her own was phenomenal!
I’m so glad I listened to the full-cast narration. The performances were unbelievably powerful, taking the book to the next level.
I guessed the final reveal early - but aside from that, this was a phenomenal, dark, and utterly gripping suspense novel.
Thanks to @Netgalley and
@wfhowes for access to this advanced readers copy
I loved the book-within-a-book, true-crime-style account. Technically, it’s all from Carly’s POV, but through the interviews, we also get perspectives from Izzy and Grace.
This is undoubtedly a character-led story. It’s all about the relationship between these two women and their separate but linked lives. There’s no mystery - we know what happened right from the start - but there’s a creeping dread as the details are revealed.
I rarely love both the protagonist and antagonist - I’m a sucker for a good villain - but this time, I was obsessed with both women! Izzy is awful (you know I love a psychopath), and watching Grace come into her own was phenomenal!
I’m so glad I listened to the full-cast narration. The performances were unbelievably powerful, taking the book to the next level.
I guessed the final reveal early - but aside from that, this was a phenomenal, dark, and utterly gripping suspense novel.
Thanks to @Netgalley and
@wfhowes for access to this advanced readers copy
August 13, 2025
Not really the book I was expecting it to be but a wild and compelling ride nonetheless! I especially enjoyed the audiobook narration.
February 24, 2025
Thanks to NetGalley and Corvus for the advanced copy of this title in return for an honest review.
I started this one night during a bout of insomnia and I've never been so glad to not be able to sleep; it was so captivating. It was compelling instantly. I don't know what I was expecting but it blew any expectations I did have out of the water, it was so good.
It's written in the form of...well, it looks like a plain prose, narrative book, but it also contains pieces of articles, transcripts, a book within a book. I reads as a standard novel would and so any formatting is not obvious as to put you off and so you're lost in it. And then you get a bit that reminds you what you're actually reading and that gives it another layer.
At 480 pages we're definitely pushing my general dislike for long books. 300-400 tends to be my favourite, and I have only read a handful of 500+ books worthy of that page length, and so I was concerned this would be similar. But I read it so quickly, like a shorter book, because it was so addictive.
It's a thriller but a quiet thriller. It's more about what people can do, what they think, how they trust, how they lie, how they love and lose. It's a really good character study too because you're not 100% sure about anyone. You almost forget that this plane crash has happened, so absorbed you are by the characters. For me, this isn't even about the plane crash, that's incidental. This is a character study and a bloody good one at that.
Carly is our struggling journalist who has a personal connection to the plane crash and sets out to find out what really happened. But she's really just there to tell the other characters' stories.
Danny is the main pilot in question, Grace is his wife, and Izzy his sister. We don't get to know Danny much, only through the accounts of the two women and they have differing memories. I felt a bit sorry for Grace. She's painted as this villain by Izzy, but I don't think she is. She's a bit of a wet weekend and I wish she would stand up for herself a bit more. And Izzy...well there's definitely something of a psychopath about her. I hated her so much (thanks to good writing), to the point that I'd get angry when it was her turn to talk. I won't spoil it and say why, but she got under my skin and I really didn't like it.
I read a lot of books. That shouldn't come as a surprise to those who have read my other reviews. We're talking 300-350 a year. Some of which are not good, others middling, and others fabulous, and this definitely goes into the latter category. It is just phenomenal writing. I can't quite explain why exactly. It's moving, it's so clever, so detailed, so rich. It's not an exaggeration to say that I think it could be studied in classes on how to write intelligent psychological thrillers.
I have got a copy of Carole's previous book - The Silence Project - but for whatever reason I haven't read it yet - it does look pretty on my shelf though. But after reading this, I'll definitely be moving it up my tbr list.
I started this one night during a bout of insomnia and I've never been so glad to not be able to sleep; it was so captivating. It was compelling instantly. I don't know what I was expecting but it blew any expectations I did have out of the water, it was so good.
It's written in the form of...well, it looks like a plain prose, narrative book, but it also contains pieces of articles, transcripts, a book within a book. I reads as a standard novel would and so any formatting is not obvious as to put you off and so you're lost in it. And then you get a bit that reminds you what you're actually reading and that gives it another layer.
At 480 pages we're definitely pushing my general dislike for long books. 300-400 tends to be my favourite, and I have only read a handful of 500+ books worthy of that page length, and so I was concerned this would be similar. But I read it so quickly, like a shorter book, because it was so addictive.
It's a thriller but a quiet thriller. It's more about what people can do, what they think, how they trust, how they lie, how they love and lose. It's a really good character study too because you're not 100% sure about anyone. You almost forget that this plane crash has happened, so absorbed you are by the characters. For me, this isn't even about the plane crash, that's incidental. This is a character study and a bloody good one at that.
Carly is our struggling journalist who has a personal connection to the plane crash and sets out to find out what really happened. But she's really just there to tell the other characters' stories.
Danny is the main pilot in question, Grace is his wife, and Izzy his sister. We don't get to know Danny much, only through the accounts of the two women and they have differing memories. I felt a bit sorry for Grace. She's painted as this villain by Izzy, but I don't think she is. She's a bit of a wet weekend and I wish she would stand up for herself a bit more. And Izzy...well there's definitely something of a psychopath about her. I hated her so much (thanks to good writing), to the point that I'd get angry when it was her turn to talk. I won't spoil it and say why, but she got under my skin and I really didn't like it.
I read a lot of books. That shouldn't come as a surprise to those who have read my other reviews. We're talking 300-350 a year. Some of which are not good, others middling, and others fabulous, and this definitely goes into the latter category. It is just phenomenal writing. I can't quite explain why exactly. It's moving, it's so clever, so detailed, so rich. It's not an exaggeration to say that I think it could be studied in classes on how to write intelligent psychological thrillers.
I have got a copy of Carole's previous book - The Silence Project - but for whatever reason I haven't read it yet - it does look pretty on my shelf though. But after reading this, I'll definitely be moving it up my tbr list.
March 10, 2025
4.25-4.5* overall
2 pilots are killed in a plane crash, we know immediately who caused the crash but not the why and the drive to uncover that truth sits at the heart of this story. To uncover the real story journalist Carly Atherton, (who's ex, Luke, was the other pilot) has to dig into the past of pilot Danny Taylor to figure out what caused him to fly the plane into the side of a mountain.
Along the way she meets Danny's narcissistic sister, Izzy and his wife, Grace and has to read between the lines to work out what the real truth of their family situation was all whilst being consistently beguiled by the charismatic and utterly unreliable Izzy.
Everything in this story keeps coming back to Izzy and I struggled so much with her character. It takes a lot for me to enjoy a book when a major character is utterly unlikeable but Carole Hailey has managed it with this one. The truth as it comes out explains so much why she is such a focal point and makes it all worthwhile but I really did struggle along the way. What helped a lot was the break in perspectives when we heard from Grace, from Carly herself and the journal articles which make up Carly's research work on ghost flights.
What also helped was the fantastic narration from the audiobook narrators. I felt that Eilidh Beaton; Louise Amos; Amy Noble did an amazing job with the shared narration. They were all completely distinctive and brought each different aspect of the book to life. The production quality is superb - high quality, clear, well edited and produced. I definitely felt that the aspects that bothered me most (namely Izzy's story) were mitigated by how well her perspective was brought to life in audio form.
Overall this is a fantastic, slow thriller that's highly character driven with a compelling story and structure. I loved the book within a book aspect with the interspersed journal articles and the switching narrative perspectives. It felt modern, fresh and was absolutely intriguing though felt a tad too long for me at points in the middle.
Thank you to NetGalley and Atlantic Books | Corvus Books for a digital review copy of "Scenes From a Tragedy" and W.F. Howes Ltd for a review copy of the Audiobook, both in exchange for my honest and voluntary review.
2 pilots are killed in a plane crash, we know immediately who caused the crash but not the why and the drive to uncover that truth sits at the heart of this story. To uncover the real story journalist Carly Atherton, (who's ex, Luke, was the other pilot) has to dig into the past of pilot Danny Taylor to figure out what caused him to fly the plane into the side of a mountain.
Along the way she meets Danny's narcissistic sister, Izzy and his wife, Grace and has to read between the lines to work out what the real truth of their family situation was all whilst being consistently beguiled by the charismatic and utterly unreliable Izzy.
Everything in this story keeps coming back to Izzy and I struggled so much with her character. It takes a lot for me to enjoy a book when a major character is utterly unlikeable but Carole Hailey has managed it with this one. The truth as it comes out explains so much why she is such a focal point and makes it all worthwhile but I really did struggle along the way. What helped a lot was the break in perspectives when we heard from Grace, from Carly herself and the journal articles which make up Carly's research work on ghost flights.
What also helped was the fantastic narration from the audiobook narrators. I felt that Eilidh Beaton; Louise Amos; Amy Noble did an amazing job with the shared narration. They were all completely distinctive and brought each different aspect of the book to life. The production quality is superb - high quality, clear, well edited and produced. I definitely felt that the aspects that bothered me most (namely Izzy's story) were mitigated by how well her perspective was brought to life in audio form.
Overall this is a fantastic, slow thriller that's highly character driven with a compelling story and structure. I loved the book within a book aspect with the interspersed journal articles and the switching narrative perspectives. It felt modern, fresh and was absolutely intriguing though felt a tad too long for me at points in the middle.
Thank you to NetGalley and Atlantic Books | Corvus Books for a digital review copy of "Scenes From a Tragedy" and W.F. Howes Ltd for a review copy of the Audiobook, both in exchange for my honest and voluntary review.
April 19, 2025
This book had me in an actual chokehold. I could not put it down and whenever I had to I was thinking about it - I even dreamt about it when I was forced to close it to go to sleep.
I thought ‘Scenes From A Tragedy’ was going to a be an investigative mystery into a plane crash, but it turned out to be a thriller-esque narrative on psychopathy and I LOVED it.
I think what particularly worked for me with this book was the way it was written and how the story grows into something else entirely - it was ADDICTIVE. It’s written ultimately as a book within a book - Carly is a journalist writing a book about a tragic plane crash and she presents us with chapters from her own POV about her research, excerpts from articles, transcripts, etc…but then tells us what ends up being the main ‘storyline’ through chapters written from the POV of 2 women she has been interviewing as part of her research. I don’t want to give any spoilers so all I will say is - if you like an unhinged female, this is an absolute must read!
Some of the story felt absolutely wild and potentially a bit OTT but it didn’t bother me in the slightest because I revelled in not knowing what was real, what was just a matter of opinion and what were downright lies - I was in a permanent state of intrigue throughout the entirety of this book.
I’ve seen a few reviewers say they were disappointed with the ending as they had ‘guessed the twist’ early on but I personally didn’t feel that the ‘twist’ was a twist at all. I felt like the ending was a climax we had been building up to from the very start. Again, I don’t want to say too much so I’ll leave it at this - for me, ‘Scenes From a Tragedy’ is entirely about the journey; the unravelling - we already knew the outcome from the beginning.
I thought ‘Scenes From A Tragedy’ was going to a be an investigative mystery into a plane crash, but it turned out to be a thriller-esque narrative on psychopathy and I LOVED it.
I think what particularly worked for me with this book was the way it was written and how the story grows into something else entirely - it was ADDICTIVE. It’s written ultimately as a book within a book - Carly is a journalist writing a book about a tragic plane crash and she presents us with chapters from her own POV about her research, excerpts from articles, transcripts, etc…but then tells us what ends up being the main ‘storyline’ through chapters written from the POV of 2 women she has been interviewing as part of her research. I don’t want to give any spoilers so all I will say is - if you like an unhinged female, this is an absolute must read!
Some of the story felt absolutely wild and potentially a bit OTT but it didn’t bother me in the slightest because I revelled in not knowing what was real, what was just a matter of opinion and what were downright lies - I was in a permanent state of intrigue throughout the entirety of this book.
I’ve seen a few reviewers say they were disappointed with the ending as they had ‘guessed the twist’ early on but I personally didn’t feel that the ‘twist’ was a twist at all. I felt like the ending was a climax we had been building up to from the very start. Again, I don’t want to say too much so I’ll leave it at this - for me, ‘Scenes From a Tragedy’ is entirely about the journey; the unravelling - we already knew the outcome from the beginning.
May 11, 2025
This was extraordinary and stands out as one of my absolute favourites of 2025 so far.
What makes this book so compelling is its unique structure. Carole blends intimate, biopic-style interviews with family members which are followed up with the reflective thoughts of our journalist narrator thereafter. This clever interplay allows for a rich layering of perspectives, giving each character a distinct voice while letting us into the psyche of the storyteller. It’s fresh, inventive, and it works brilliantly.
It’s brilliantly atmospherically whilst never being overly descriptive which I think is something rare. Each scene unfolded so clearly in my mind, yet the dialogue remained sharp and uninterrupted.
And the plot… all I can say is BRAVO. I was absolutely hooked from start to finish. With its dark undertones, tense domestic dynamics, and a chillingly wicked villain, this story grabbed me the entire time. The emotional and psychological tug-of-war between the characters is as gripping as it is heartbreaking. I really, really enjoyed these characters and their chaotic story - It really will leave you with your jaw dropped at so many moments. The storytelling is top-notch!
I can’t recommend it highly enough. Thank you Carole for the fantastic entertainment this story provided.
What makes this book so compelling is its unique structure. Carole blends intimate, biopic-style interviews with family members which are followed up with the reflective thoughts of our journalist narrator thereafter. This clever interplay allows for a rich layering of perspectives, giving each character a distinct voice while letting us into the psyche of the storyteller. It’s fresh, inventive, and it works brilliantly.
It’s brilliantly atmospherically whilst never being overly descriptive which I think is something rare. Each scene unfolded so clearly in my mind, yet the dialogue remained sharp and uninterrupted.
And the plot… all I can say is BRAVO. I was absolutely hooked from start to finish. With its dark undertones, tense domestic dynamics, and a chillingly wicked villain, this story grabbed me the entire time. The emotional and psychological tug-of-war between the characters is as gripping as it is heartbreaking. I really, really enjoyed these characters and their chaotic story - It really will leave you with your jaw dropped at so many moments. The storytelling is top-notch!
I can’t recommend it highly enough. Thank you Carole for the fantastic entertainment this story provided.
September 23, 2025
Intense, gripping psychological thriller that will have you hooked!
Never have I read a book with a more compelling and unhinged villain, who so perfectly masks her inherent psychopathy to get by in the world. SCENES FROM A TRAGEDY is an absolute masterclass in exploring how a psychopath manages to blend into their surroundings and get away with the most heinous things. Antagonist Izzy is the most disturbing kind of narcissist, managing to entwine her brother Danny and his sense of self entirely to her. Journalist Carly interviews Izzy and Danny’s wife, Beth, after his plane is deliberately flown into a mountain face, killing him and his copilot. It was absolutely gripping to discover the truth of Danny and Izzy’s childhood, as well as Beth’s insight into them both. What this leads to is the gradual painting of a portrait of a traumatised young man and a horrific young woman without any empathy or humility. I really enjoyed how all of these character revelations occur under the guise of getting to the bottom of why Danny’s plane was deliberately crashed, but in reality this is the McGuffin (as it’s the element we are probably least interested in by the end of the novel). This is very much a story of abuse, manipulation, narcissism, cruelty, and loss. However, it is utterly compelling and almost impossible to put down. It’s dark, bleak seeming at points, but it’s driven forward by this deep sense of mystery around the crash and the gradual unravelling of a truly despicable character.
I thought the way this story was told was ingenious too! Things are pinned together by Carly’s overarching narrative voice, with her notes punctuating the stories told from Izzy and Beth’s perspectives. Theatre narrative unfolds like a true crime documentary, which really adds a layer of plausibility and a sense of dread to the proceedings. It’s effortlessly readable and I was left wanting more from each perspective as I finished their latest chapter. It really works to stagger the revelations and packs a real punch as the truth comes to the surface.
I can’t recommend this book more, so I urge you to pick it up if you haven’t already!
Never have I read a book with a more compelling and unhinged villain, who so perfectly masks her inherent psychopathy to get by in the world. SCENES FROM A TRAGEDY is an absolute masterclass in exploring how a psychopath manages to blend into their surroundings and get away with the most heinous things. Antagonist Izzy is the most disturbing kind of narcissist, managing to entwine her brother Danny and his sense of self entirely to her. Journalist Carly interviews Izzy and Danny’s wife, Beth, after his plane is deliberately flown into a mountain face, killing him and his copilot. It was absolutely gripping to discover the truth of Danny and Izzy’s childhood, as well as Beth’s insight into them both. What this leads to is the gradual painting of a portrait of a traumatised young man and a horrific young woman without any empathy or humility. I really enjoyed how all of these character revelations occur under the guise of getting to the bottom of why Danny’s plane was deliberately crashed, but in reality this is the McGuffin (as it’s the element we are probably least interested in by the end of the novel). This is very much a story of abuse, manipulation, narcissism, cruelty, and loss. However, it is utterly compelling and almost impossible to put down. It’s dark, bleak seeming at points, but it’s driven forward by this deep sense of mystery around the crash and the gradual unravelling of a truly despicable character.
I thought the way this story was told was ingenious too! Things are pinned together by Carly’s overarching narrative voice, with her notes punctuating the stories told from Izzy and Beth’s perspectives. Theatre narrative unfolds like a true crime documentary, which really adds a layer of plausibility and a sense of dread to the proceedings. It’s effortlessly readable and I was left wanting more from each perspective as I finished their latest chapter. It really works to stagger the revelations and packs a real punch as the truth comes to the surface.
I can’t recommend this book more, so I urge you to pick it up if you haven’t already!
March 11, 2025
We know from the offset there has been an horrific tragedy - a plane, carrying just two pilots has crashed into a mountain side, and the circumstances of that crash are being investigated by Carly, a disgraced journalist, who just happens to be the ex-partner of one of the pilots, Alex. Consequently, in search for answers, Carly seeks out family members of Danny, the other pilot, and she speaks to both Danny’s sister and his wife in order to try understand the events prior to the that fateful day. What entails is rather disturbing!
Initially, I have to admit that I didn’t quite understand where the story was heading and I wasn’t terribly convinced by the format of interviews retelling the past; I found them a little contrived and unrealistic. I really had to push myself to persevere with the first 20% or so of the book, but then suddenly, once I was over the hump, I was hooked - the crumbs we’d been fed, led us to an unfolding plot, it picked up speed and became an enticing, rather unique thriller. I love a good character driven novel, and add to that the revelatory study of a psychopath, there’s plenty to keep us turning over those pages.
Thank you to NetGalley for an ARC.
Initially, I have to admit that I didn’t quite understand where the story was heading and I wasn’t terribly convinced by the format of interviews retelling the past; I found them a little contrived and unrealistic. I really had to push myself to persevere with the first 20% or so of the book, but then suddenly, once I was over the hump, I was hooked - the crumbs we’d been fed, led us to an unfolding plot, it picked up speed and became an enticing, rather unique thriller. I love a good character driven novel, and add to that the revelatory study of a psychopath, there’s plenty to keep us turning over those pages.
Thank you to NetGalley for an ARC.
April 18, 2025
4.5 ⭐️
This book was a wild ride!
For the first half I was completely hooked on the mystery of what had happened to the plane, but as it goes on it became more and more unsettling, almost edging on thriller territory.
Izzy was absolutely infuriating, but it was fascinating to be inside her head and I simultaneously despise her but also love her as a character. From the moment she opens her mouth you know something is off about her. While it is clear what is causing her behaviour, actually hearing her acknowledge it was eerie and unexpected.
Without giving spoilers, I really enjoyed the inclusion of the transcript at the end. It added a layer of understanding but was also absolutely chilling to see how deep rooted and complex the situation was, as well as just being really interesting.
I really enjoyed this, it was one of the most gripping books I’ve read in a while. It was a book club pick and I cannot wait to discuss it!
This book was a wild ride!
For the first half I was completely hooked on the mystery of what had happened to the plane, but as it goes on it became more and more unsettling, almost edging on thriller territory.
Izzy was absolutely infuriating, but it was fascinating to be inside her head and I simultaneously despise her but also love her as a character. From the moment she opens her mouth you know something is off about her. While it is clear what is causing her behaviour, actually hearing her acknowledge it was eerie and unexpected.
Without giving spoilers, I really enjoyed the inclusion of the transcript at the end. It added a layer of understanding but was also absolutely chilling to see how deep rooted and complex the situation was, as well as just being really interesting.
I really enjoyed this, it was one of the most gripping books I’ve read in a while. It was a book club pick and I cannot wait to discuss it!
August 29, 2025
This book had a very unique plot, it was really interesting. At points I was absolutely livid and just awestruck at the audacity of one of the characters. It was laid out very well and I really like the dual perspective of the story laid out. I would definitely recommend reading this book! 📕
Also - little side note, I was absolutely shook when the book is briefly set in Reading as that is where I’m from and did not expect that at all 🤣 Described Reading train station to a T 👌🏻
Also - little side note, I was absolutely shook when the book is briefly set in Reading as that is where I’m from and did not expect that at all 🤣 Described Reading train station to a T 👌🏻
March 15, 2025
This book wins the award for being the most unexpectedly different story from what I was expecting when reading the blurb and seeing the cover!
Gripping from the outset, the story moves along at pace giving different character POV's showing a past and present narrative, giving a well-rounded story. The characters were well done and it may even include one of the most dislikeable and infuriating character I have ever read about!
Recommended if you feel like a dark family mystery!
Gripping from the outset, the story moves along at pace giving different character POV's showing a past and present narrative, giving a well-rounded story. The characters were well done and it may even include one of the most dislikeable and infuriating character I have ever read about!
Recommended if you feel like a dark family mystery!
April 6, 2025
This was such an excellent read. The psychopathic character (you'll quickly work out which one that is!) was utterly fascinating and equally chilling. So hard to put this down - it kept me engrossed until he very end.
August 1, 2025
really enjoyed this book. i think it was so cleverly done and very addicting. i would love to have found out more about the characters after the event took place but i think it was purposefully ended where it was.
August 24, 2025
Honestly obsessed with this book. I don’t know how my sister discovered this but what a complete masterpiece. I was hooked from start to finish. BRB whilst I try and find the rest of the books this author has written 🥰
April 27, 2025
Wow, utterly brilliant.
August 15, 2025
I loved the way this was written. Even though I was sure of the way it was heading and ended, it was a compelling and enjoyable read, with good insight into psychopathy
March 13, 2025
Wow. This is a book that moved me and made an impact. The writing was phenomenal, I got completely sucked into the story. I was skeptical when the beginning of the book says that you’ll know who did it but not necessarily why because a lot of times thrillers make you wonder who did it and that’s where the twist happens to grip the reader. I couldn’t have been more wrong about my doubts. The author did such a good job with the villain that even knowing right away, I was completely invested in digging deeper and finding the meaning of it all. Emotionally, it was a rollercoaster. I felt anger, frustration, despair, and a feeling of anticipation throughout the entire book. I’ll try not to give any spoilers but the character you’re meant to hate is written in such a way that you will feel those emotions and want a sense of justice. The complexities of the plot make the story so realistic it almost feels like it could have been told from actual events. The combination of articles, interviews/transcriptions, and first person POV with the notes after each interview gave so much clarity to the characters and really made them feel real. You will be invested in this story and how everything unfolds. The author did mention in her acknowledgments that she conferred with experts in the aviation and psychology industries and you can tell. This is her second novel but I’m already anticipating many more from her and will definitely be reading her first novel.
Thank you NetGalley for giving me an ARC for this novel. I will be recommending this book to everyone I know who loves thrillers when it officially publishes in March!
Thank you NetGalley for giving me an ARC for this novel. I will be recommending this book to everyone I know who loves thrillers when it officially publishes in March!
April 18, 2025
I enjoyed the thriller grip of this book, and I must admit that I did read it fairly quickly however I feel disappointed with the ending. I felt that we were building up to some twists or new information due to the ongoing suspense but this book had told us all the juicy bits before they happened.
I enjoyed the characters and reading about Izzy and her escapades. The end chapter was incredibly predictable from the initial storytelling of that moment and therefore that felt unnecessary and maybe less is more in this situation.
As a book purely on psychopathy, I would have rated this higher. The who done it, plane crash, and narrators involvements all were boring and thats why my rating is 2/5.
I enjoyed the characters and reading about Izzy and her escapades. The end chapter was incredibly predictable from the initial storytelling of that moment and therefore that felt unnecessary and maybe less is more in this situation.
As a book purely on psychopathy, I would have rated this higher. The who done it, plane crash, and narrators involvements all were boring and thats why my rating is 2/5.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
March 31, 2025
My first 5 star review of the year!
Thanks to Net Galley for an ARC of this fabulous book.
Thanks to Net Galley for an ARC of this fabulous book.
August 18, 2025
One of my favourite things in any psychological thriller is a bat-sh*t crazy female with a narcissistic personality disorder and when they are also a completely delusional psychopath then I am in my element and I think Izzy gets my vote for the BEST character EVER.
This is Carole Hailey’s second novel, and I can confirm I have now downloaded her first book THE SILENCE PROJECT which is currently FREE on Kindle Unlimited.
Scenes From a Tragedy, is a masterclass in psychological storytelling. Set in the aftermath of a mysterious plane crash in the Lake District, the novel follows disgraced journalist Carly Atherton, whose lover was one of the two pilots killed. Determined to uncover the truth, Carly’s investigation leads her into the fractured lives of the other pilot’s family and IZZY, my new girl crush!
This book has so many elements to it that make it clever, original and more importantly impossible to put down. The author has blended fictional true-crime, medical note and reportage to create a completely new reading experience.
It’s emotional and hard-hitting in places. With themes of grief and obsession Scenes From a Tragedy is a very smart and unforgettable thriller which I completely and utterly recommend.
This is Carole Hailey’s second novel, and I can confirm I have now downloaded her first book THE SILENCE PROJECT which is currently FREE on Kindle Unlimited.
Scenes From a Tragedy, is a masterclass in psychological storytelling. Set in the aftermath of a mysterious plane crash in the Lake District, the novel follows disgraced journalist Carly Atherton, whose lover was one of the two pilots killed. Determined to uncover the truth, Carly’s investigation leads her into the fractured lives of the other pilot’s family and IZZY, my new girl crush!
This book has so many elements to it that make it clever, original and more importantly impossible to put down. The author has blended fictional true-crime, medical note and reportage to create a completely new reading experience.
It’s emotional and hard-hitting in places. With themes of grief and obsession Scenes From a Tragedy is a very smart and unforgettable thriller which I completely and utterly recommend.
January 7, 2025
When journalist Carly’s former boyfriend, who she still loves, is killed in a plane crash, she is devastated. Luke was one of two pilots on an othersise empty plane, and when investigations reveal that it was not an accident but a deliberate act by the other pilot, Carly is determined to find out what really happened. Through a series of interviews with the sister and widow of Daniel Taylor, the truth is slowly revealed, and it is darker and more horrifying than she could have ever imagined. I loved the author’s first novel, “The Silence Project”, which was very original and packed a huge punch, but this one left me a bit disappointed. Those who enjoy a well-plotted psychological thriller will probably lap it up, but I felt that the psychopath elements of the story have been well aired elsewhere recently, and it seemed very predictable from early on. I also felt that the narrative device of interviews by Carly with Izzy and Grace didn’t work very well- Carly was an unnecessary addition and the recounting of events from the past made them seem to have less immediacy. It will find a readership but was not a great read for me.
March 16, 2025
I found this very long and a little bit too obvious. The psychopathic sibling felt too much and too pushed.
May 6, 2025
*Provided by Atlantic Books and The Reading Agency *
Our reading group loved this book. We're still talking about it!
Ms Tayler
I really enjoyed reading this, an investigative journalist with a personal connection to a plane crash goes on a mission to find out what really happened. She delves into the lives of one of the pilots through a series of interviews with his sister and wife. The story that unfolds is not what you would expect and I read through the book very quickly keen to see how the story and characters would develop and what the conclusion was at the end.
Parts of this book reminded me of ‘We need to talk about Kevin’ and while I cringed at the antics of the sister I enjoyed reading how she was written as a character. I would look for more work by this author or books with a similar set of characters.
Dr Yeates
The book focuses on a journalist, Carly trying to get to the bottom of a plane crash in which her
Boyfriend was one of the pilots.
I enjoyed following the story through her narrative and interviews with the other pilots family.
The characters were well developed, believable and interesting.
I really liked how the story developed and how with each interview you gained an insight into what happened but also what Carly was thinking and feeling. I found as the reason for the tragedy unfolded, I became worried that those responsible would get away with it and was invested in Carly finding justice.
Despite the subject matter it's quite a light hearted read and would suit readers who like mystery without gore.
Ms Desavoye
"Scenes from a Tragedy is written in a format that I had never encountered before, it is cleverly done and I would not hesitate again to choose a novel written in this format. The author gives us insight into the brain of a psychopath which makes for a very chilling and suspenseful read. I thoroughly recommend it!"
Mrs Stephan
Scenes from a tragedy: Very compulsive read. Enjoyed reading this book and couldn’t put it down.
Ms Thom
“Scenes from a Tragedy” by Carole Hailey explores what happens when relationships are not quite what they seem and lead to sinister circumstances. The central character, journalist Carly Atherton, presents the story as her own, in a series of interviews with key characters to try to uncover what happened to the love of her life, a pilot who dies in a seemingly unexplained plane crash. While Carly, in an attempt to revive her career along the way, digs beneath the surface, Hailey pulls together a fast-paced kaleidoscope of varied perspectives showing the sometimes complex motivations of human interaction and relationships leading to a shocking conclusion.
This is a page-turning read for fans who might enjoy a twist on the usual “Who Dunit?” genre.
Ms Wilson
The style of this book is written differently to anything I have read before. The book focuses on journalist Carly, who is investigating a plane crash. The plane at the time of flight only had two pilots on board, one who is Carly’s ex-boyfriend. She takes it upon herself to speak to the other pilot’s family to investigate what or who made the plane crash. We meet the characters of Izzy and Grace through the book, who give conflicting stories as to past events in the life of one of the pilots on board. The chapters of the book are stories from different years of both Izzy’s and Grace’s point of view, where you really get lost in trying to figure out the truth. Reading the book was interesting as you begin to question both stories and try to figure out the truth. The author has written the book in a way that makes you second guess every story that Carly is being told and there are chapters which do make you feel uneasy and uncomfortable, just like you would be if you were in the situation. Overall I enjoyed the book, even though it wasn’t necessarily something I would usually read.
Mrs Üstün
While the cover may make you think it’s a lightweight airport novel to read while you’re lounging by the pool, this is not a bog-standard crime thriller. It is something more complex and satisfying that will stay with you long after you’ve put it down.
Disgraced journalist, Carly Atherton, has lost her job and split with her fiancée, Luke. She dreams of getting back with him and finding a big news exposé. When Luke is killed in a plane crash, her hopes of reconciliation are dashed but instead she finds her story. Her investigation into the plane crash sees her uncover an environmental scandal and brings her into contact with the family of the second pilot, Danny: his mother; his wife Grace; and his elder sister, Izzy.
This is written as a fictional true crime novel written by Carly, presenting psychological reports, and the conflicting narratives of Carly, Grace, and Izzy as evidence.
I listened to the audiobook and the use of different narrators for each character was very effective and brought the book to life.
It opens with a report on an unnamed woman with psychopathic tendencies, obviously the star of our story, but who is she? With this information, the reader knows more than the characters and this really ramps up the tension. You are constantly second guessing what you’re being told. Who is manipulating who? It is a fascinating look at the mind of a psychopath and the way the central character manipulates everyone around her.
The pace is unrelenting. At times I felt a sense of horror and dread, as she drew each unsuspecting person into her web. But despite the subject matter, it has moments of delicious dark humour, and you can’t help but be drawn to her. She’s someone who says and does whatever she wants without any qualms, and loves high fashion and the finer things in life, no matter the cost - a bit like Patsy from Ab Fab crossed with Villanelle from Killing Eve.
The sobering conclusion has certainly made me look at those around me with fresh eyes!
I’d highly recommend this book, and will follow this author with interest. I think it would be perfect for fans of Janice Hallett’s The Mysterious Case of the Alperton Angels, and Oyinkan Braithwaite’s My Sister, The Serial Killer.
Ms Cooper
The book 'Scenes from a Tragedy' is written as a journalists investigation into a plane crash. The book digs into the life of one of the pilots through his family, revealing a disturbing narrative, which compels you to read on.
I liked how the story was told as a chronicle of researching for another book and although I found it slow to get into, once you were deeper into the story it was difficult to put down.
The character Izzy was written as a likeable character which urged you to read on to discover more about her. Grace was portrayed initially as a weaker character and easily influenced however towards the end she showed a strength of character. Other characters were written with skill which created a real sense of empathy for them.
The structure initially took a little getting used to jumping between the stories and the reports, but once you got used to it acted as a tool to increase the pace and urge you on.
A few days after reading this book I found myself reflecting on the story and lives of all the characters, considering how it must have been to be in their position. I would recommend this book, but don't be fooled into thinking it is a light read.
Our reading group loved this book. We're still talking about it!
Ms Tayler
I really enjoyed reading this, an investigative journalist with a personal connection to a plane crash goes on a mission to find out what really happened. She delves into the lives of one of the pilots through a series of interviews with his sister and wife. The story that unfolds is not what you would expect and I read through the book very quickly keen to see how the story and characters would develop and what the conclusion was at the end.
Parts of this book reminded me of ‘We need to talk about Kevin’ and while I cringed at the antics of the sister I enjoyed reading how she was written as a character. I would look for more work by this author or books with a similar set of characters.
Dr Yeates
The book focuses on a journalist, Carly trying to get to the bottom of a plane crash in which her
Boyfriend was one of the pilots.
I enjoyed following the story through her narrative and interviews with the other pilots family.
The characters were well developed, believable and interesting.
I really liked how the story developed and how with each interview you gained an insight into what happened but also what Carly was thinking and feeling. I found as the reason for the tragedy unfolded, I became worried that those responsible would get away with it and was invested in Carly finding justice.
Despite the subject matter it's quite a light hearted read and would suit readers who like mystery without gore.
Ms Desavoye
"Scenes from a Tragedy is written in a format that I had never encountered before, it is cleverly done and I would not hesitate again to choose a novel written in this format. The author gives us insight into the brain of a psychopath which makes for a very chilling and suspenseful read. I thoroughly recommend it!"
Mrs Stephan
Scenes from a tragedy: Very compulsive read. Enjoyed reading this book and couldn’t put it down.
Ms Thom
“Scenes from a Tragedy” by Carole Hailey explores what happens when relationships are not quite what they seem and lead to sinister circumstances. The central character, journalist Carly Atherton, presents the story as her own, in a series of interviews with key characters to try to uncover what happened to the love of her life, a pilot who dies in a seemingly unexplained plane crash. While Carly, in an attempt to revive her career along the way, digs beneath the surface, Hailey pulls together a fast-paced kaleidoscope of varied perspectives showing the sometimes complex motivations of human interaction and relationships leading to a shocking conclusion.
This is a page-turning read for fans who might enjoy a twist on the usual “Who Dunit?” genre.
Ms Wilson
The style of this book is written differently to anything I have read before. The book focuses on journalist Carly, who is investigating a plane crash. The plane at the time of flight only had two pilots on board, one who is Carly’s ex-boyfriend. She takes it upon herself to speak to the other pilot’s family to investigate what or who made the plane crash. We meet the characters of Izzy and Grace through the book, who give conflicting stories as to past events in the life of one of the pilots on board. The chapters of the book are stories from different years of both Izzy’s and Grace’s point of view, where you really get lost in trying to figure out the truth. Reading the book was interesting as you begin to question both stories and try to figure out the truth. The author has written the book in a way that makes you second guess every story that Carly is being told and there are chapters which do make you feel uneasy and uncomfortable, just like you would be if you were in the situation. Overall I enjoyed the book, even though it wasn’t necessarily something I would usually read.
Mrs Üstün
While the cover may make you think it’s a lightweight airport novel to read while you’re lounging by the pool, this is not a bog-standard crime thriller. It is something more complex and satisfying that will stay with you long after you’ve put it down.
Disgraced journalist, Carly Atherton, has lost her job and split with her fiancée, Luke. She dreams of getting back with him and finding a big news exposé. When Luke is killed in a plane crash, her hopes of reconciliation are dashed but instead she finds her story. Her investigation into the plane crash sees her uncover an environmental scandal and brings her into contact with the family of the second pilot, Danny: his mother; his wife Grace; and his elder sister, Izzy.
This is written as a fictional true crime novel written by Carly, presenting psychological reports, and the conflicting narratives of Carly, Grace, and Izzy as evidence.
I listened to the audiobook and the use of different narrators for each character was very effective and brought the book to life.
It opens with a report on an unnamed woman with psychopathic tendencies, obviously the star of our story, but who is she? With this information, the reader knows more than the characters and this really ramps up the tension. You are constantly second guessing what you’re being told. Who is manipulating who? It is a fascinating look at the mind of a psychopath and the way the central character manipulates everyone around her.
The pace is unrelenting. At times I felt a sense of horror and dread, as she drew each unsuspecting person into her web. But despite the subject matter, it has moments of delicious dark humour, and you can’t help but be drawn to her. She’s someone who says and does whatever she wants without any qualms, and loves high fashion and the finer things in life, no matter the cost - a bit like Patsy from Ab Fab crossed with Villanelle from Killing Eve.
The sobering conclusion has certainly made me look at those around me with fresh eyes!
I’d highly recommend this book, and will follow this author with interest. I think it would be perfect for fans of Janice Hallett’s The Mysterious Case of the Alperton Angels, and Oyinkan Braithwaite’s My Sister, The Serial Killer.
Ms Cooper
The book 'Scenes from a Tragedy' is written as a journalists investigation into a plane crash. The book digs into the life of one of the pilots through his family, revealing a disturbing narrative, which compels you to read on.
I liked how the story was told as a chronicle of researching for another book and although I found it slow to get into, once you were deeper into the story it was difficult to put down.
The character Izzy was written as a likeable character which urged you to read on to discover more about her. Grace was portrayed initially as a weaker character and easily influenced however towards the end she showed a strength of character. Other characters were written with skill which created a real sense of empathy for them.
The structure initially took a little getting used to jumping between the stories and the reports, but once you got used to it acted as a tool to increase the pace and urge you on.
A few days after reading this book I found myself reflecting on the story and lives of all the characters, considering how it must have been to be in their position. I would recommend this book, but don't be fooled into thinking it is a light read.
March 5, 2025
Well... this book hit the ground (sorrynotsorry) running, sucked me in from the off, held me captive throughout, spitting me out at the end, exhausted but wholly satisfied. I also read it in a day, only stopping for the absolute necessary. Tbh it practically read itself to me, the words flying off the page...
So, we start with an empty passenger plane which is on a ghost flight with only the pilot and co-pilot aboard. Both die on impact and, when we first meet her, journalist Carly Atherton is desperately trying to get hold of her brother who flies for the airline. She does eventually get hold of him but subsequently learns that he was supposed to be on that flight but went sick. Only to be replaced by his best friend who was also Carly's ex-boyfriend Luke, as co-pilot.
Carly's journalistic instincts are piqued by the whole concept of ghost flights -which I will leave you to learn about from the author - as well as finding out what happened to cause the plane to crash. Especially when confirmed there was no mechanical reason. So she starts to try and interview the deceased pilot, Danny's, family. Build up a picture... Initially, only his sister, Izzy, will talk to her, but eventually his wife, Grace, agrees, reluctantly, as she feels Carly needs another side to the story... and boy what a story it all turns out to be. Quite uncomfortable reading in parts too...
Playing out in the present as Carly conducts her interviews, alongside the official investigation, we also, courtesy of these interviews, delve back to the past. To see how Grace met Danny, how the two families combined and, most importantly, the relationship between the sisters-in-law.
Oh My Days... what an uncomfortable and compelling read this was. As well as the crash, we also learn more about Carly and Luke's relationship and what happened there. Speaking mostly to Carly's motive and determination to get to the truth. We also learn about her own fall from grace and how she found herself in the position she is in when we first met her.
Again Oh My! What a character we have in Izzy... so uncomfortable reading about her. But again, you need to discover this as the author intends. Suffice to say she is hands down one of the best worst characters I have read in ages. Probably also top 10 overall, no mean feat considering the sheer volume of this genre book I read.
As well as a tough read in places, it's also quite emotional. I already said I devoured it in a day but I do have to admit that, on occasion, once or twice, I had to take a wee break from it. I was so angry...
So hats off to the author for a cracking piece of characterisation.
All in all a blooming cracking read that I wouldn't be surprised remains in my top ten of the year. I wonder what she will deliver up for me for next time. And... if you haven't already read The Silence Project, also by this author, I would also recommend that too.
My thanks go to the Publisher and Netgalley for the chance to read this book.
So, we start with an empty passenger plane which is on a ghost flight with only the pilot and co-pilot aboard. Both die on impact and, when we first meet her, journalist Carly Atherton is desperately trying to get hold of her brother who flies for the airline. She does eventually get hold of him but subsequently learns that he was supposed to be on that flight but went sick. Only to be replaced by his best friend who was also Carly's ex-boyfriend Luke, as co-pilot.
Carly's journalistic instincts are piqued by the whole concept of ghost flights -which I will leave you to learn about from the author - as well as finding out what happened to cause the plane to crash. Especially when confirmed there was no mechanical reason. So she starts to try and interview the deceased pilot, Danny's, family. Build up a picture... Initially, only his sister, Izzy, will talk to her, but eventually his wife, Grace, agrees, reluctantly, as she feels Carly needs another side to the story... and boy what a story it all turns out to be. Quite uncomfortable reading in parts too...
Playing out in the present as Carly conducts her interviews, alongside the official investigation, we also, courtesy of these interviews, delve back to the past. To see how Grace met Danny, how the two families combined and, most importantly, the relationship between the sisters-in-law.
Oh My Days... what an uncomfortable and compelling read this was. As well as the crash, we also learn more about Carly and Luke's relationship and what happened there. Speaking mostly to Carly's motive and determination to get to the truth. We also learn about her own fall from grace and how she found herself in the position she is in when we first met her.
Again Oh My! What a character we have in Izzy... so uncomfortable reading about her. But again, you need to discover this as the author intends. Suffice to say she is hands down one of the best worst characters I have read in ages. Probably also top 10 overall, no mean feat considering the sheer volume of this genre book I read.
As well as a tough read in places, it's also quite emotional. I already said I devoured it in a day but I do have to admit that, on occasion, once or twice, I had to take a wee break from it. I was so angry...
So hats off to the author for a cracking piece of characterisation.
All in all a blooming cracking read that I wouldn't be surprised remains in my top ten of the year. I wonder what she will deliver up for me for next time. And... if you haven't already read The Silence Project, also by this author, I would also recommend that too.
My thanks go to the Publisher and Netgalley for the chance to read this book.
February 12, 2025
"This is not a work of fiction, it is a cautionary tale. The story of a family that, on the face of it, could be yours. A story in which you may even recognise elements of yourself. But at its heart is a monster."
They say a tragedy has a way of bringing out the best in us; of pulling people together — but sometimes, tragedy just creates more tragedy.
A compelling, surprisingly dark story with a clever and engaging way of storytelling: Presenting itself as though it’s written by one of the characters like an autobiography, mixing up multiple perspective narration spanning different years, media snippets, testimonies and more to make it feel like we’re all a part of the investigation. At times certain sections lasted just a bit too long and broke the constant-jumping pace that was set out which made it a little jarring but it was generally a similar pacing throughout. Hailey definitely has a unique voice, I loved her last release and loved seeing how she experimented with bringing her own brand of storytelling to life again.
From the opening scene, we’re confronted with a psychological report letting us know we’re about to be up close and personal with narcissists and psychopaths— starting me off thinking I had no clue if I trust anyone we meet and that air of suspicion and threat creating a delightful kind of suspense.
Who appears at the start to be the “main character” almost acts like a curator of everyone’s stories rather than just a narrator - Carly, who lost her boyfriend and almost lost her brother in the crash is desperately trying to solve the mystery — her storytelling frantic, clawing and desperate, making me so curious about her even when she runs on tangents or shows us a messy side. Most other characters we meet are entirely unlikable, manipulative, deranged — an undeniably intriguing in a morbidly curious way.
We almost forget we’re solving a fatal mystery, getting caught up in the backstories and lives of the major players; and while it’s clear who the “monster” of the story is after a while, we’re left to keep reading through because if we already know that, what else is there still to find out?
A dark, highly disturbing but enigmatic story about control, trauma and real life monsters.
They say a tragedy has a way of bringing out the best in us; of pulling people together — but sometimes, tragedy just creates more tragedy.
A compelling, surprisingly dark story with a clever and engaging way of storytelling: Presenting itself as though it’s written by one of the characters like an autobiography, mixing up multiple perspective narration spanning different years, media snippets, testimonies and more to make it feel like we’re all a part of the investigation. At times certain sections lasted just a bit too long and broke the constant-jumping pace that was set out which made it a little jarring but it was generally a similar pacing throughout. Hailey definitely has a unique voice, I loved her last release and loved seeing how she experimented with bringing her own brand of storytelling to life again.
From the opening scene, we’re confronted with a psychological report letting us know we’re about to be up close and personal with narcissists and psychopaths— starting me off thinking I had no clue if I trust anyone we meet and that air of suspicion and threat creating a delightful kind of suspense.
Who appears at the start to be the “main character” almost acts like a curator of everyone’s stories rather than just a narrator - Carly, who lost her boyfriend and almost lost her brother in the crash is desperately trying to solve the mystery — her storytelling frantic, clawing and desperate, making me so curious about her even when she runs on tangents or shows us a messy side. Most other characters we meet are entirely unlikable, manipulative, deranged — an undeniably intriguing in a morbidly curious way.
We almost forget we’re solving a fatal mystery, getting caught up in the backstories and lives of the major players; and while it’s clear who the “monster” of the story is after a while, we’re left to keep reading through because if we already know that, what else is there still to find out?
A dark, highly disturbing but enigmatic story about control, trauma and real life monsters.
March 28, 2025
In February 2023 I read and reviewed Hailey's debut novel; The Silence Project. I adored it and recommended it to anyone that would listen to me. I'd wanted to get Scenes From A Tragedy read prior to publication but I became unwell over the New Year and was admitted to hospital. So, instead, the book came to Lanzarote with me a couple of weeks ago and I read it as I lay in the beautiful sunshine, under the gorgeous blue skies. It's quite ironic that we were staying just under the island's flight path, with planes coming and going all day as I read about the plane crash that is central to the story!
Carly Atherton is on a mission. She's a journalist and is determined to find out just how and why an empty passenger plane crashed into a mountain in the Lake District. The two pilots on board were both killed. One of the pilots; Luke, was Carly's ex boyfriend. They had a long and colourful history. Carly is also interested in looking into how many of these empty flights take place every year. It seems that airlines are forced to take them to ensure that they can keep their flight space. It all seems wasteful to Carly.
It becomes clear that it was pilot Danny Taylor who caused the crash. It appears that he aimed the plane straight at the mountain. Post accident investigations show that there was no attempt to stop the crash.
Carly begins to contact Danny's family. His wife Grace is at first loathe to speak, but Carly finds a willing participant in his sister Izzy, and then later on, Grace contacts her and tells her side of the story.
Cleverly structured, with an intriguing and unique narrative style, this novel is totally and utterly compelling. Although she's only written the two novels, Carole Hailey is most certainly one of my favourite authors. Her ability to create characters, especially female characters is stunning. Izzy is probably the most dislikable, yet perfectly formed character that I've come across for many years.
Captivating and compulsive, with hints of the darkest humour. This is a novel to savour and to enjoy. It is richly detailed and quite extraordinary. Highly recommended by me.
Carly Atherton is on a mission. She's a journalist and is determined to find out just how and why an empty passenger plane crashed into a mountain in the Lake District. The two pilots on board were both killed. One of the pilots; Luke, was Carly's ex boyfriend. They had a long and colourful history. Carly is also interested in looking into how many of these empty flights take place every year. It seems that airlines are forced to take them to ensure that they can keep their flight space. It all seems wasteful to Carly.
It becomes clear that it was pilot Danny Taylor who caused the crash. It appears that he aimed the plane straight at the mountain. Post accident investigations show that there was no attempt to stop the crash.
Carly begins to contact Danny's family. His wife Grace is at first loathe to speak, but Carly finds a willing participant in his sister Izzy, and then later on, Grace contacts her and tells her side of the story.
Cleverly structured, with an intriguing and unique narrative style, this novel is totally and utterly compelling. Although she's only written the two novels, Carole Hailey is most certainly one of my favourite authors. Her ability to create characters, especially female characters is stunning. Izzy is probably the most dislikable, yet perfectly formed character that I've come across for many years.
Captivating and compulsive, with hints of the darkest humour. This is a novel to savour and to enjoy. It is richly detailed and quite extraordinary. Highly recommended by me.
March 4, 2025
"If you hurt me, I'll hurt you. Not right away of course, because where's the fun in that?" This chilling sentiment sets the stage for a gripping thriller that delves into the shadowy corners of human nature. When a passenger jet plummets into the Lake District, claiming the life of her ex-boyfriend, journalist Carly Atherton embarks on a quest for answers. What begins as a search for truth soon spirals into a descent into a twisted family drama, blurring the lines between victim and perpetrator.
The author masterfully weaves a narrative of suspense, drawing Carly into the conflicting narratives of the co-pilot's widow and sister. These divergent accounts paint a portrait of a seemingly average family, yet beneath the surface lurks a darkness that Carly is compelled to uncover. As she probes deeper, she unearths the unsettling truth: the bonds that unite can also become instruments of destruction, and malevolence can reside in the most unexpected places.
One of the book's strengths lies in its meticulous portrayal of psychopathic tendencies. The author's evident research lends a chilling authenticity to the characters, making them both compelling and unsettling. This dedication to psychological realism elevates the narrative beyond a simple mystery, transforming it into a study of the human psyche's capacity for darkness.
The narrative is a masterclass in suspense, keeping the reader guessing until the very end. The author skillfully doles out clues, ensuring you'll identify the culprit, but the "why" remains shrouded in mystery until the final, devastating revelations. Emotionally, the journey is a turbulent one, a rollercoaster ride that leaves you breathless and pondering the depths of human depravity. Scenes from a Tragedy is a must-read for those who enjoy psychological thrillers that leave a lasting impact.
Thanks to NetGalley, the publisher, and the author of the ARC in exchange for my honest review.
The author masterfully weaves a narrative of suspense, drawing Carly into the conflicting narratives of the co-pilot's widow and sister. These divergent accounts paint a portrait of a seemingly average family, yet beneath the surface lurks a darkness that Carly is compelled to uncover. As she probes deeper, she unearths the unsettling truth: the bonds that unite can also become instruments of destruction, and malevolence can reside in the most unexpected places.
One of the book's strengths lies in its meticulous portrayal of psychopathic tendencies. The author's evident research lends a chilling authenticity to the characters, making them both compelling and unsettling. This dedication to psychological realism elevates the narrative beyond a simple mystery, transforming it into a study of the human psyche's capacity for darkness.
The narrative is a masterclass in suspense, keeping the reader guessing until the very end. The author skillfully doles out clues, ensuring you'll identify the culprit, but the "why" remains shrouded in mystery until the final, devastating revelations. Emotionally, the journey is a turbulent one, a rollercoaster ride that leaves you breathless and pondering the depths of human depravity. Scenes from a Tragedy is a must-read for those who enjoy psychological thrillers that leave a lasting impact.
Thanks to NetGalley, the publisher, and the author of the ARC in exchange for my honest review.
March 12, 2025
Rating: 3.5/5
Thanks to Atlantic Books for the ARC!
Scenes from a Tragedy by Carole Hailey is a psychological exploration into the devastating impact a psychopath can have on a family, and while it delivers some compelling moments, it didn't entirely hold my attention throughout.
One of the book's most intriguing elements is the structure of a book within a book. I found this narrative technique engaging, offering a sense of layered storytelling that helped maintain my curiosity at the beginning. That said, the pacing begins to falter around the halfway point. While I was initially hooked, the shift in rhythm became noticeable, and I started to lose interest as the story dragged on.
What did stand out to me, however, was how Hailey skillfully weaves the Covid pandemic into the narrative. It’s interesting—and, in many ways, unsettling—to see Covid emerging as a historical event in contemporary fiction. This grounding in a real-world crisis adds a layer of authenticity to the family’s struggles, highlighting how the pandemic can shape not just daily lives but the psyche of individuals as well.
While Scenes from a Tragedy might be marketed as a crime/thriller, I believe approaching it through that lens might lead to disappointment. The story isn’t focused on traditional thriller elements or whodunits. Instead, the real focus is on the chilling portrayal of how a psychopath can dismantle a family from the inside out. If you approach it with the mindset of a psychological warning or a deep dive into the toxic influence of a manipulative individual, the book has a lot to offer.
Overall, it’s a solid read. If you’re looking for a high-octane crime thriller, this is not the book for you. However, for those who enjoy psychological dramas that explore the darker sides of human nature, Scenes from a Tragedy provides a thoughtful, though at times slow, examination of the rippling effects one person’s malicious influence can have.
Thanks to Atlantic Books for the ARC!
Scenes from a Tragedy by Carole Hailey is a psychological exploration into the devastating impact a psychopath can have on a family, and while it delivers some compelling moments, it didn't entirely hold my attention throughout.
One of the book's most intriguing elements is the structure of a book within a book. I found this narrative technique engaging, offering a sense of layered storytelling that helped maintain my curiosity at the beginning. That said, the pacing begins to falter around the halfway point. While I was initially hooked, the shift in rhythm became noticeable, and I started to lose interest as the story dragged on.
What did stand out to me, however, was how Hailey skillfully weaves the Covid pandemic into the narrative. It’s interesting—and, in many ways, unsettling—to see Covid emerging as a historical event in contemporary fiction. This grounding in a real-world crisis adds a layer of authenticity to the family’s struggles, highlighting how the pandemic can shape not just daily lives but the psyche of individuals as well.
While Scenes from a Tragedy might be marketed as a crime/thriller, I believe approaching it through that lens might lead to disappointment. The story isn’t focused on traditional thriller elements or whodunits. Instead, the real focus is on the chilling portrayal of how a psychopath can dismantle a family from the inside out. If you approach it with the mindset of a psychological warning or a deep dive into the toxic influence of a manipulative individual, the book has a lot to offer.
Overall, it’s a solid read. If you’re looking for a high-octane crime thriller, this is not the book for you. However, for those who enjoy psychological dramas that explore the darker sides of human nature, Scenes from a Tragedy provides a thoughtful, though at times slow, examination of the rippling effects one person’s malicious influence can have.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 86 reviews