What do you think?
Rate this book
Bainbridge Island Mystery #1
An Amateur Sleuth's Guide to Murder
New York Times bestselling author Lynn Cahoon makes her hardcover debut with an irresistible new meta-mystery series about an amateur sleuth who doesn’t just solve crimes, she writes about how to do it . . .
TIP #1: WHAT DOESN’T KILL YOU COUNTS AS WORK EXPERIENCE
Meg Gates could use a guidebook for life. Indeed, she’s faced some challenges. She dropped out of college to work for a tech startup that failed—and her fiancé just took her bridesmaid to Italy on what was supposed to be Meg’s honeymoon.
Now, at twenty-six, Meg has taken the ferry ride of shame from Seattle back to Bainbridge Island to live with her family. At least she has her rescue cocker spaniel, Watson, by her side. But it’s Meg who could use a rescue—and she’s hoping it will come in the form of a part-time gig doing research for a bestselling mystery writer.
TIP #2: WRITE WHAT YOU KNOW – OR WHAT YOU WANT TO KNOW
That’s when the lightbulb goes Meg will write her own guidebook—a manual on criminal investigation. But before she can impress her new boss with her pet project, the author’s manager is found dead on the rocks beneath the author’s Gothic mansion.
Now it’s time to put her guide to the test, as Meg sets out to clear her employer of suspicion and solve the crime. But there’s one important caveat she’ll have to add to her guide—
TIP #3: BEWARE OF UNKNOWN DANGERS
TIP #1: WHAT DOESN’T KILL YOU COUNTS AS WORK EXPERIENCE
Meg Gates could use a guidebook for life. Indeed, she’s faced some challenges. She dropped out of college to work for a tech startup that failed—and her fiancé just took her bridesmaid to Italy on what was supposed to be Meg’s honeymoon.
Now, at twenty-six, Meg has taken the ferry ride of shame from Seattle back to Bainbridge Island to live with her family. At least she has her rescue cocker spaniel, Watson, by her side. But it’s Meg who could use a rescue—and she’s hoping it will come in the form of a part-time gig doing research for a bestselling mystery writer.
TIP #2: WRITE WHAT YOU KNOW – OR WHAT YOU WANT TO KNOW
That’s when the lightbulb goes Meg will write her own guidebook—a manual on criminal investigation. But before she can impress her new boss with her pet project, the author’s manager is found dead on the rocks beneath the author’s Gothic mansion.
Now it’s time to put her guide to the test, as Meg sets out to clear her employer of suspicion and solve the crime. But there’s one important caveat she’ll have to add to her guide—
TIP #3: BEWARE OF UNKNOWN DANGERS
1 pages, Audio CD
First published June 24, 2025
305 people are currently reading
6016 people want to read
About the author
Lynn Cahoon
103 books2,374 followersNYT and USA Today bestselling author, Lynn Cahoon, writes the Tourist Trap, Cat Latimer, Farm-to-Fork, Kitchen Witch, Survivors' Book Club, the Haunted Life, and the Bainbridge Island cozy mystery series. No matter where the mystery is set, readers can expect a fun ride Sign up for her newsletter at www.lynncahoon.com
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 225 reviews
June 15, 2025
Lynn Cahoon brings a new series to launch soon, and I was lucky enough to get an early copy. I've read nearly all the author's books, shy of the early ones before she switched to cozy mysteries. Always love seeing the new characters and setting. A lovely island off the coast of Seattle. A family with divorce and various relatives, all harboring some sort of hidden thoughts or secrets. An ex with an axe to grind. Sets up for a lot, and in this first installment, a literary agent is killed. Will the main character's new job as the author's research assistant go south shortly after taking off? Read on to learn more!
June 16, 2025
An Amateur Sleuth's Guide to Murder is the first of what looks to be a great new series. I love the setting of Bainbridge Island, WA and there are likable characters to get to know. Meg Gates is at a crossroads after her fiancé left her for one of her bridesmaids and she is between jobs. So, she moved home to the island from Seattle to work at her mom's bookstore and a second job helping a local author. She has a tight group of friends and family to support her. I enjoyed seeing Meg, her friends Dalton and Natasha work together to solve the murder of the author's obnoxious agent. He was not liked so there are many suspects to look at, including Natasha and others, but the answer was not what I expected. I look forward to reading more of the series. There may be some romance when Meg is ready.
I received a copy for the purpose of an honest review. These are my thoughts.
I received a copy for the purpose of an honest review. These are my thoughts.
January 17, 2026
2.5🌟
Mood/ Seasonal reading: late May but enough talk of beaches and boats to feel like summer
Oh boy. This was a let down for sure. I have many thoughts and opinions.
I was so excited for this book. Put it on my library holds immediately. Based on the description I was expecting a meta mystery similar to “Everyone in my Family Has Killed Someone”. Over the past year I have discovered my true love of these meta type books.
While the concept of her book was a bit of a red flag I decided it could be done in a very effective way and dove straight in.
It started out good. Meg was left by her cheating fiancé which always makes for a good future romance set up. The mystery author she worked for was interesting as well. Then, it just went down hill.
To start, one of my biggest issues was the chapter titles. I love chapter titles especially when they hint to what’s going to happen in the chapter. These were just her tips for sleuths and had no correlation to the story or her own experiences.
Meg was trying to write a non-fiction book coming from almost zero credibility. In fact, she frequently stated she hoped keeping her current job would give her credibility. That’s not how it works. Beyond a frequent mention of her childhood sleuthing she brought no background to the book she wanted to write. As well as her actual sleuthing was lacklustre at best.
The more I thought about the concept of her book the more I disliked it. Yes, I love a good amateur sleuth in a cozy but her “book” would’ve lead to a lot of issues in investigations.
The mystery was just bad. It had very few suspects with very little investigation beyond accusing her friends. In addition, the ending and reveal was so bad I don’t even want to talk about it. Just expect essentially a one line sentence in the lost anticlimactic reveal I think I’ve ever read. It honestly made me mad.
Her relationships were rough too. Her parents attempting to push her back to a cheating ex was hard to listen to. And Meg herself wasn’t a peach. When it came to her mother’s business she hoped it didn’t fail only so she wouldn’t lose her benefits.
In full transparency, the only reason this wasn’t a complete 2 star for me was the romance. I adored her friendship with Dalton and watching her explore her feelings for him. All other aspects of this failed for me.
Starting to think this author just isn’t for me.
Mood/ Seasonal reading: late May but enough talk of beaches and boats to feel like summer
Oh boy. This was a let down for sure. I have many thoughts and opinions.
I was so excited for this book. Put it on my library holds immediately. Based on the description I was expecting a meta mystery similar to “Everyone in my Family Has Killed Someone”. Over the past year I have discovered my true love of these meta type books.
While the concept of her book was a bit of a red flag I decided it could be done in a very effective way and dove straight in.
It started out good. Meg was left by her cheating fiancé which always makes for a good future romance set up. The mystery author she worked for was interesting as well. Then, it just went down hill.
To start, one of my biggest issues was the chapter titles. I love chapter titles especially when they hint to what’s going to happen in the chapter. These were just her tips for sleuths and had no correlation to the story or her own experiences.
Meg was trying to write a non-fiction book coming from almost zero credibility. In fact, she frequently stated she hoped keeping her current job would give her credibility. That’s not how it works. Beyond a frequent mention of her childhood sleuthing she brought no background to the book she wanted to write. As well as her actual sleuthing was lacklustre at best.
The more I thought about the concept of her book the more I disliked it. Yes, I love a good amateur sleuth in a cozy but her “book” would’ve lead to a lot of issues in investigations.
The mystery was just bad. It had very few suspects with very little investigation beyond accusing her friends. In addition, the ending and reveal was so bad I don’t even want to talk about it. Just expect essentially a one line sentence in the lost anticlimactic reveal I think I’ve ever read. It honestly made me mad.
Her relationships were rough too. Her parents attempting to push her back to a cheating ex was hard to listen to. And Meg herself wasn’t a peach. When it came to her mother’s business she hoped it didn’t fail only so she wouldn’t lose her benefits.
In full transparency, the only reason this wasn’t a complete 2 star for me was the romance. I adored her friendship with Dalton and watching her explore her feelings for him. All other aspects of this failed for me.
Starting to think this author just isn’t for me.
July 10, 2025
There are way too many mundane facts and not enough clues to puzzle through. I don't care that your dog "watered the tree" (yet the author mentions this SEVERAL TIMES throughout this book) and if you go to the trouble of mentioning that the MC is full and puts her leftover honey shrimp in the refrigerator, there damn well better be a reason the reader needs that information. There's not. Lastly, this is just one more book trying to use the trope of "He's just a friend/ wait ARE we dating?" and yet there's no conclusion to that, which makes me think the author's just trying to drag this out over several books. No thank you.
August 18, 2025
DNF. I just could not get into this book at all. I made it to 100 pages and then stopped. I didn't feel a connection with any of the characters. Very little sleuthing and that was up to 100 pages in! Boring(at times confusing) dialogue. Just wasn't for me.
August 7, 2025
Sorry if you’re a fan of Cahoon’s work, but critical review is forthcoming. While Cahoon is a good writer and gives us likable, relatable characters, there were some major flaws with this book.
1. At a slim 240 pages, there’s no room for fluff; everything in those pages must move the plot forward. Unfortunately there was a lot of repetition (we get it, Meg needed to grab her tote and the dog needed water) and needless detail (I could probably create a spreadsheet for all the meals they ate) that didn’t serve the story or character development in any real way.
2. For a truly good murder mystery, you need a solid villain. No spoilers, but this resolution fell flat and seemed rushed/anticlimactic. In fact, the entire murder storyline felt peripheral when it was the driving force for the story the whole time.
3. Probably the most grievous error was the structure. The book is set in present time, and the FMC is writing a non-fiction guidebook for amateur sleuths. Cute? Nostalgic? Sure, but not in any way realistic. Even in a small town law enforcement is not going to put up with well-meaning interference, so why create a book that will never sell? Lots of other options could have been explored here for a book idea that would have been feasible, even funnier. And the tips and tricks she offered? They were going for clever, but rang hollow.
Disappointed by this one… was really hoping for a series I couldn’t wait to read.
1. At a slim 240 pages, there’s no room for fluff; everything in those pages must move the plot forward. Unfortunately there was a lot of repetition (we get it, Meg needed to grab her tote and the dog needed water) and needless detail (I could probably create a spreadsheet for all the meals they ate) that didn’t serve the story or character development in any real way.
2. For a truly good murder mystery, you need a solid villain. No spoilers, but this resolution fell flat and seemed rushed/anticlimactic. In fact, the entire murder storyline felt peripheral when it was the driving force for the story the whole time.
3. Probably the most grievous error was the structure. The book is set in present time, and the FMC is writing a non-fiction guidebook for amateur sleuths. Cute? Nostalgic? Sure, but not in any way realistic. Even in a small town law enforcement is not going to put up with well-meaning interference, so why create a book that will never sell? Lots of other options could have been explored here for a book idea that would have been feasible, even funnier. And the tips and tricks she offered? They were going for clever, but rang hollow.
Disappointed by this one… was really hoping for a series I couldn’t wait to read.
April 18, 2025
A new series by a favourite author is always exciting, and the first book in the Bainbridge Island Mysteries doesn't disappoint! Meg Gates, not quite left at the altar but close enough, has returned home from Seattle to the small island she grew up on to reevaluate things. With part time jobs at her mom’s bookstore, and as an assistant for a bestselling mystery author, Meg is at least earning again but then a body is discovered and it looks like at least one job might be very short lived! In high school, Meg and best friends Natasha and Dalton had solved mysteries, so why not do it again? After all, Meg is writing a criminal investigation manual for would be sleuths so she knows what she's doing, doesn't she?
I was able to read an advanced copy of this thanks to NetGalley and the publishers, Kensington Publishing, Kensington Cosies, but the opinions expressed are my own. I thoroughly enjoyed this from start to finish. Meg, Natasha, and Dalton are great main protagonists, and it was an easy read with a very satisfying conclusion. I hope there will be more soon.
I was able to read an advanced copy of this thanks to NetGalley and the publishers, Kensington Publishing, Kensington Cosies, but the opinions expressed are my own. I thoroughly enjoyed this from start to finish. Meg, Natasha, and Dalton are great main protagonists, and it was an easy read with a very satisfying conclusion. I hope there will be more soon.
June 24, 2025
Happy publication day 🎉🥳🎧
This was really good fun, a little bit predictable, but i needed a little cozy distraction and it done its job.
Each chapter title is a sleuth’s tip, which was a nice touch and added to the overall fun feel of the novel, the setting was stunning, I wanted to beam myself there, without the murdery parts preferably. I warmed to our protagonist fairly early in, which is always a huge bonus. I always think that side characters really have the ability to make or break, and I’m pleased to say they were all really well written, and each either assists Meg in her sleuthing or comes under suspicion.
A great start to a new cozy mystery series, perfect for lazy days when you don’t want to have to think too much.
Great audio narration 🎧
Huge thanks to Tantor Audio and NetGalley for the opportunity to review this ALC 🎧
This was really good fun, a little bit predictable, but i needed a little cozy distraction and it done its job.
Each chapter title is a sleuth’s tip, which was a nice touch and added to the overall fun feel of the novel, the setting was stunning, I wanted to beam myself there, without the murdery parts preferably. I warmed to our protagonist fairly early in, which is always a huge bonus. I always think that side characters really have the ability to make or break, and I’m pleased to say they were all really well written, and each either assists Meg in her sleuthing or comes under suspicion.
A great start to a new cozy mystery series, perfect for lazy days when you don’t want to have to think too much.
Great audio narration 🎧
Huge thanks to Tantor Audio and NetGalley for the opportunity to review this ALC 🎧
July 13, 2025
This is the first book in a new series by the author. I like the premise & setting of the story. However, I felt it dragged in the middle and felt repetitive. The MC’s mother kept telling her that her fiancé would return to her. He was a cheater who ran off with her bridesmaid! Why would she want him back?! What mother would treat her daughter like she wasn’t good enough & should settle for a jerk? That tainted the whole story for me. Thank you to Goodreads, Kensington publishing & the author for this free book. I won it through a Goodreads giveaway.
June 17, 2025
“An Amateur Sleuth’s Guide to Murder” by Lynn Cahoon book one in A Bainbridge Island Mystery series. I found it to be just as enjoyable, entertaining and full of loveable characters as her other series.
Lynn Cahoon really knows how to craft a compelling cozy mystery series! The blend of mystery, humor, and character development is perfect for drawing readers in. Meg Gates, the protagonist, is relatable and endearing, navigating a recent breakup and new job as a writer's assistant. The discovery of a dead body at her workplace sets off a chain of events that draws Meg and her friends, Natasha and Dalton, into an amateur sleuthing adventure.
The characters are well-developed and likable, with natural dialogue that makes their relationships feel authentic. Meg's family, including her aunt and uncle (the police chief), add depth and warmth to the story. The Bainbridge Island setting is vividly described, providing a charming backdrop for the mystery.
The plot is engaging, with plenty of twists and suspects to keep readers guessing. Meg's determination to prove her new employer's innocence is admirable, and her restraint in the face of danger is refreshing. Overall, this is a delightful start to a new series, and I'm looking forward to seeing where Meg's journey takes her.
I highly recommend this cozy mystery series to all my friends who love a cozy with a strong support system of friends in it.
I requested and received an Advanced Readers Copy from Kensington Books and NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Lynn Cahoon really knows how to craft a compelling cozy mystery series! The blend of mystery, humor, and character development is perfect for drawing readers in. Meg Gates, the protagonist, is relatable and endearing, navigating a recent breakup and new job as a writer's assistant. The discovery of a dead body at her workplace sets off a chain of events that draws Meg and her friends, Natasha and Dalton, into an amateur sleuthing adventure.
The characters are well-developed and likable, with natural dialogue that makes their relationships feel authentic. Meg's family, including her aunt and uncle (the police chief), add depth and warmth to the story. The Bainbridge Island setting is vividly described, providing a charming backdrop for the mystery.
The plot is engaging, with plenty of twists and suspects to keep readers guessing. Meg's determination to prove her new employer's innocence is admirable, and her restraint in the face of danger is refreshing. Overall, this is a delightful start to a new series, and I'm looking forward to seeing where Meg's journey takes her.
I highly recommend this cozy mystery series to all my friends who love a cozy with a strong support system of friends in it.
I requested and received an Advanced Readers Copy from Kensington Books and NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
July 17, 2025
Two things almost made me stop reading within the first few chapters: the main character is in her mid-20s & streams something on Facebook live. As my 20-something kids have told me a hundred times, no one their age would be caught dead with a Facebook account (realistically it should have been TikTok or Instagram).
The second thing was when the main character was wearing flats to church and then changed into heels because her mom disapproved. You’re 26 and your mom is dictating what you wear? 🙄
The last straw was the casual usage of the phrase “slave driver”. Nope, the author should know better. DNF.
The second thing was when the main character was wearing flats to church and then changed into heels because her mom disapproved. You’re 26 and your mom is dictating what you wear? 🙄
The last straw was the casual usage of the phrase “slave driver”. Nope, the author should know better. DNF.
July 4, 2025
SBTB BINGO: Left at the altar
2.5 stars
This mashup of women's fiction and cozy mystery is light and pleasant (and yeah, I mean to damn it with faint praise). I thought the concept of her being a grownup Nancy Drew was done well, but the idea of the guide to amateur sleuthing was sort of half-hearted. I felt absolutely no chemistry between the intended love interests and the ending was more of a whimper than a bang.
2.5 stars
This mashup of women's fiction and cozy mystery is light and pleasant (and yeah, I mean to damn it with faint praise). I thought the concept of her being a grownup Nancy Drew was done well, but the idea of the guide to amateur sleuthing was sort of half-hearted. I felt absolutely no chemistry between the intended love interests and the ending was more of a whimper than a bang.
June 28, 2025
I was so happy to find a new series by Lynn Cahoon, she is absolutely a go-to for me when it comes to cozy mysteries. This new series has so many things I enjoy. First, there is the charming setting of Bainbridge Island, gorgeous scenery, beaches, and a bookstore. Second, we are introduced to some interesting characters, Meg has been through a lot, losing her job in a start up when it fails, discovering her fiance has taken off right before their wedding, with her bridesmaid and being forced to moved home. Fortunately, she has her close friends Natasha and Dalton, her Mom, her aunt Melody and uncle Troy, who is the town sheriff, an exciting part-time job with a well-known mystery author L. C. Aster and her loyal cocker spaniel Watson. Finally, we have a heroine who is willing to fight to get her life straightened out and back on track. She puts herself in new circumstances and looks for new paths to find her happiness and creative self, she takes on new responsibilities and oh yeah needs to figure out who killed her new author bosses recently fired agent before all her progress is destroyed. This looks like a series with lots of potential in a setting I would love to revisit and characters I want to spend more time with. Ms. Cahoon does it again!
July 12, 2025
Elder Gen-Z Meg has had a tough run, the career she dropped out of college for stalled out and her fiancé just left her at the altar for her bridesmaid. In desperate need of a fresh start, she and her dog, Watson, move back to her island hometown of Bainbridge, off the Seattle mainland. Since this is a cozy she is conveniently handed residence in a semi-private apartment and 2 part-time jobs that many would kill for. But what Meg really wants is to write her own amateur murder mystery guide. Her qualifications? She was famous on Bainbridge in high school for solving low-stakes mysteries. Luckily for her, one of her jobs is with a famous local mystery author, her uncle is the police chief, her aunt is a former literary agent who still has industry connections, and the mystery author’s agent is murdered while on the island. Along with her bff, bakery owner Natasha, and the guy who is very obviously in love with her, Dalton, she is determined to crack the case and in doing so write the ultimate amateur’s guide to solving a murder.
The mystery is solid enough (I did not guess the who or the why) and the island is a perfect backdrop but frankly I was bored. I think Meg has very relatable problems but I don’t feel super sympathetic towards her. Her fiance left her at the altar, but he sounds like a prick and she has a support system ready to pack her up, move her back to Bainbridge to a semi-private apartment and hand her 2 jobs. Also, like she just cuts up an expensive, designer wedding dress? In this economy?? I recognize that this ease is partially a staple of the genre but some stakes are needed for reader investment and Cahoon never develops immediate consequences for Meg. All of the cozies I have read start Book 1 with a personal reason for the FMC getting involved in solving the crime, usually they or a close family member is the primary suspect in a murder. Meg’s only reasons to solve the murder are so she can write a mystery solving guidebook with some semblance of real experience- which just feels shallow.
If Meg had a distinctive enough voice this alternatively could have made for a compelling read but she is an everygirl type of character.
5 stars for the cover though, I thought the composition hit the hallmarks of the cozy mystery cover but the style of illustration and color palette felt like a breath of fresh air.
The mystery is solid enough (I did not guess the who or the why) and the island is a perfect backdrop but frankly I was bored. I think Meg has very relatable problems but I don’t feel super sympathetic towards her. Her fiance left her at the altar, but he sounds like a prick and she has a support system ready to pack her up, move her back to Bainbridge to a semi-private apartment and hand her 2 jobs. Also, like she just cuts up an expensive, designer wedding dress? In this economy?? I recognize that this ease is partially a staple of the genre but some stakes are needed for reader investment and Cahoon never develops immediate consequences for Meg. All of the cozies I have read start Book 1 with a personal reason for the FMC getting involved in solving the crime, usually they or a close family member is the primary suspect in a murder. Meg’s only reasons to solve the murder are so she can write a mystery solving guidebook with some semblance of real experience- which just feels shallow.
If Meg had a distinctive enough voice this alternatively could have made for a compelling read but she is an everygirl type of character.
5 stars for the cover though, I thought the composition hit the hallmarks of the cozy mystery cover but the style of illustration and color palette felt like a breath of fresh air.
February 24, 2025
An Amateur Sleuth’s Guide To Murder, is the first book in the Bainbridge cozy mystery series by Lynn, cahoon, Meg was about to get married when her fiancé Romaine left her and went on their honeymoon with one of the bridesmaids. Meg is heartbroken and is returning home to Bainbridge Island to be closer to her family plus her mom is giving her a job at her bookstore, she’ll also be working for a very popular author named Lily. Meg always wanted to be an author. and loved solving mysteries. She even had a Nancy Drew club while growing up on the island. Little does Meg know that in moving home, she will get to do just that. because on her first day at work, Lilly‘s agent or ex agent rather is found dead in the sound behind her home. Unfortunately, he is a man with a plethora of great suspects that would’ve wanted him dead, but who did it? soon the Nancy Drew club is back together, and this will be the first case to Meg’s uncle, the Bainbridge sheriffs irritation. I absolutely was gaga for this cozy mystery. It was so good. I thought the storyline was intelligently done, a great mystery, lovable characters and a page turning narrative. except for the victim, I cannot think of any negative about this book. Having said that I will still be reading the next book I can’t wait to see what happens with Meg her relationship with Dalton and what the next mystery will be. I also want to say, I think it was brilliant that she made the titles of each chapter. The tips on how to solve a murder. This was an all-around perfect absolutely fabulous read! #NetGalley, #KensingtonBooks, #BlindReviewer, #LynnCalhoun, #AnAmateurLuteGuideToMurder,
June 23, 2025
Big Thanks to Netgalley and the Publisher for the advanced copy! I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own
'An Amateur Sleuth's Guide to murder' is a cozy mystery which takes place on an island and centers around a young woman who, after losing everything, moves back to her hometown and takes over as an amateur detective in order to solve a local murder case.
The book is about second chances, starting over, and, of course, solving mysteries. It also involves authors, bookstores, and, of course, a cute dog! The atmosphere is also very summer-y, and the moodis light and fun. The characters were, in addition, lovable and interesting, though most of them were moving stereotypes of the genre.
In addition, the mystery was thrilling and had many twists.
However, the book felt rushed and like the author was trying to put too many plotlines in such few chapters, thus ending up having all of them half-baked. For example, the sleuthing was few and sparse, as the main character did too little detective work for this book to have a smooth and engaging case-solving plot. Also, her relationship with the others around her, like her mom, her dad, and her friends, were all brushed off and never explored in depth, like her hurt over her parents' divorce.
Finally, the audiobook was well produced and the narrator did a good job with their performance.
'An Amateur Sleuth's Guide to murder' is a cozy mystery which takes place on an island and centers around a young woman who, after losing everything, moves back to her hometown and takes over as an amateur detective in order to solve a local murder case.
The book is about second chances, starting over, and, of course, solving mysteries. It also involves authors, bookstores, and, of course, a cute dog! The atmosphere is also very summer-y, and the moodis light and fun. The characters were, in addition, lovable and interesting, though most of them were moving stereotypes of the genre.
In addition, the mystery was thrilling and had many twists.
However, the book felt rushed and like the author was trying to put too many plotlines in such few chapters, thus ending up having all of them half-baked. For example, the sleuthing was few and sparse, as the main character did too little detective work for this book to have a smooth and engaging case-solving plot. Also, her relationship with the others around her, like her mom, her dad, and her friends, were all brushed off and never explored in depth, like her hurt over her parents' divorce.
Finally, the audiobook was well produced and the narrator did a good job with their performance.
August 1, 2025
So Boring
Unfortunately, this mystery missed the mark for me. The pacing was painfully slow, the plot felt recycled, and the characters were flat and unmemorable. I kept hoping for a twist or something to spark my interest, but it never came. It felt more like a chore than a thrill ride. Disappointing overall.
Unfortunately, this mystery missed the mark for me. The pacing was painfully slow, the plot felt recycled, and the characters were flat and unmemorable. I kept hoping for a twist or something to spark my interest, but it never came. It felt more like a chore than a thrill ride. Disappointing overall.
June 23, 2025
4 1/4 stars
This is the beginning of a new series which is set on Bainbridge Island, about a half-hour ferry ride from Seattle. When Meg Gates discovers her husband-to-be is cheating on her with one of her would-be bridesmaids, she moves to the island to help out at her family's bookstore. She also becomes a part-time research assistant to Lilly Aster, a successful author. Meg also has dreams of writing a book of her own - a how-to guide for aspiring amateur detectives. (The headings of Cahoon's book very cleverly correspond to the tips Meg is recording for her work-in-progress.) Meg has the chance to test out her advice when Lilly's manager is found dead and her new boss becomes one of the prime suspects.
Meg has help with her investigation from her best friend, Natasha, and her older brother's best friend, Dalton. The three make a great team and I'm rooting for a romance between Meg and Dalton. Another standout character is Meg's Aunt Melody. She tells it like it is, but in a kind and caring way. I liked Meg's relationship with her aunt much more than the one with her mom, who is a little too interfering for me. Meg's assignments for Lilly are fun to read about and I liked watching the cautious Lilly's trust of Meg grow. Overall, this is a light, fun read and a great start to a new series which I intend to follow.
Thank you to Kensington Books, Kensington Cozies, and NetGalley for the advance review copy. My review is voluntary and unbiased.
This is the beginning of a new series which is set on Bainbridge Island, about a half-hour ferry ride from Seattle. When Meg Gates discovers her husband-to-be is cheating on her with one of her would-be bridesmaids, she moves to the island to help out at her family's bookstore. She also becomes a part-time research assistant to Lilly Aster, a successful author. Meg also has dreams of writing a book of her own - a how-to guide for aspiring amateur detectives. (The headings of Cahoon's book very cleverly correspond to the tips Meg is recording for her work-in-progress.) Meg has the chance to test out her advice when Lilly's manager is found dead and her new boss becomes one of the prime suspects.
Meg has help with her investigation from her best friend, Natasha, and her older brother's best friend, Dalton. The three make a great team and I'm rooting for a romance between Meg and Dalton. Another standout character is Meg's Aunt Melody. She tells it like it is, but in a kind and caring way. I liked Meg's relationship with her aunt much more than the one with her mom, who is a little too interfering for me. Meg's assignments for Lilly are fun to read about and I liked watching the cautious Lilly's trust of Meg grow. Overall, this is a light, fun read and a great start to a new series which I intend to follow.
Thank you to Kensington Books, Kensington Cozies, and NetGalley for the advance review copy. My review is voluntary and unbiased.
June 28, 2025
As a cozy enthusiast. I was smitten to get my hands on a first in a new series by the cozy queen herself Lynn Cahoon…
An Amateur Sleuth’s Guide to Murder
The first Bainbridge Island Mystery intrioduces Meg Gates, who is returning to her hometown after a major betrayal. She gets a part time gig as a famous authors researcher as well as helps out at her mom’s local bookshop. A body turns up and Meg is here to sleuth the case, with her own manual on criminal investigation, and her rescue dog Watson.
A great start to a new series… it was fun to hear locations, events and other PNW locales mentioned. Tons of characters/community to become familiar with that has us set up for future books.
Thank you Kensington Cozies
Follow me on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/Lyon.brit.A...
An Amateur Sleuth’s Guide to Murder
The first Bainbridge Island Mystery intrioduces Meg Gates, who is returning to her hometown after a major betrayal. She gets a part time gig as a famous authors researcher as well as helps out at her mom’s local bookshop. A body turns up and Meg is here to sleuth the case, with her own manual on criminal investigation, and her rescue dog Watson.
A great start to a new series… it was fun to hear locations, events and other PNW locales mentioned. Tons of characters/community to become familiar with that has us set up for future books.
Thank you Kensington Cozies
Follow me on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/Lyon.brit.A...
June 25, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley and Tantor Audio for the ARC of this book!
I really wanted to like this book. I love a murder mystery, and this sounded like a lot of fun since the main character, Meg, was trying to write a "how to sleuth" novel at the same time she's investigating a murder. Throw in a little love interest and some good BFFs, and it's normally a winning combo for me. Sadly, I didn't ever feel invested in the story or characters.
What I did enjoy was the setting on Bainbridge Island. It gave a "locked room" vibe. I also liked the whole reader/writer/book seller aspect, for obvious reasons! And I thought the title was great.
What didn't work for me was the language the characters used. Meg and her friends are in the mid-20s. No guy I've ever met has said "terrific" about a dish of food or "lovely" about a view. Guys that age might say something is delicious, a view is awesome, but the language just didn't hit the right note. Also, Watson the dog was featured too much. We got a play by play of his every meal, walk, and bowel movement. I know the author was trying to show that Meg's a responsible dog owner, and remind us that she's living a normal life, but not once did we hear about Meg using the potty. I didn't need to be reminded of Watson's needs on every page... sorry! I didn't really buy into the romantic relationship either, and felt like we didn't get any kind of resolution.
This wasn't a bad book, but it's not one that I will be recommending.
I really wanted to like this book. I love a murder mystery, and this sounded like a lot of fun since the main character, Meg, was trying to write a "how to sleuth" novel at the same time she's investigating a murder. Throw in a little love interest and some good BFFs, and it's normally a winning combo for me. Sadly, I didn't ever feel invested in the story or characters.
What I did enjoy was the setting on Bainbridge Island. It gave a "locked room" vibe. I also liked the whole reader/writer/book seller aspect, for obvious reasons! And I thought the title was great.
What didn't work for me was the language the characters used. Meg and her friends are in the mid-20s. No guy I've ever met has said "terrific" about a dish of food or "lovely" about a view. Guys that age might say something is delicious, a view is awesome, but the language just didn't hit the right note. Also, Watson the dog was featured too much. We got a play by play of his every meal, walk, and bowel movement. I know the author was trying to show that Meg's a responsible dog owner, and remind us that she's living a normal life, but not once did we hear about Meg using the potty. I didn't need to be reminded of Watson's needs on every page... sorry! I didn't really buy into the romantic relationship either, and felt like we didn't get any kind of resolution.
This wasn't a bad book, but it's not one that I will be recommending.
June 24, 2025
Outstanding new cozy from a fan favorite author! Lynn Cahoon has hit it out of the park with this new series and I can't wait to see what she has in store for the characters in coming books! Meg, our curious main character, is back home after heartbreak or maybe not so much and reunited with her best friends and former school yard amateur sleuths! They're all adults now and each carrying their own baggage to work through, but that just makes them all the more realistic. While getting back in rhythm with each other, they also end up solving the island's newest mystery, a murder! Meg is learning that everyone must be looked at through the suspect lens, even those closest to you if you really want to find the truth! I absolutely loved the plot. It was entertaining, engaging, thoughtful and fun! I will definitely be watching for the next book to come out so I can get some more island time with Meg and crew!
If you are an audiobook fan, then get in line as this book was narrated well and added another dimension to the already well fleshed out characters! I can't wait to listen to more of the series!
If you are an audiobook fan, then get in line as this book was narrated well and added another dimension to the already well fleshed out characters! I can't wait to listen to more of the series!
June 25, 2025
I really enjoyed this fun trip to Bainbridge Island so if we ever get out west again, I might have a new bucket list place to visit. I liked Meg and her friends’ characters a lot, as well as the older generation especially Aunt Melody. Her sister Felicia who was Meg’s mom was just a little too uptight and eager for Meg to go back to a previous relationship that didn’t work out. I was proud of Meg for how she finally told the guy she was done. Would’ve loved to’ve seen the look on his face when she told him what she did with the ring!
I hadn’t guessed the correct killer at all and enjoyed that the arrest took place off page but it was after tons of sleuthing by Meg, Dalton and Natasha, aka the Mystery Crew. The ending was awesome since they all celebrated at the bookshop with food and fellowship—all provided by Meg’s new boss Lilly since Meg and her friends had worked tirelessly to prove Lilly for one was innocent. Natasha was another one being looked at, but the three friends weren’t having that, lol. I’m super eager to read the next book!
I voluntarily read and reviewed an ARC of this book provided by Kensington Cozies via NetGalley, and my opinions are my own.
I hadn’t guessed the correct killer at all and enjoyed that the arrest took place off page but it was after tons of sleuthing by Meg, Dalton and Natasha, aka the Mystery Crew. The ending was awesome since they all celebrated at the bookshop with food and fellowship—all provided by Meg’s new boss Lilly since Meg and her friends had worked tirelessly to prove Lilly for one was innocent. Natasha was another one being looked at, but the three friends weren’t having that, lol. I’m super eager to read the next book!
I voluntarily read and reviewed an ARC of this book provided by Kensington Cozies via NetGalley, and my opinions are my own.
August 23, 2025
DNF. At 47%, there was so much filler conversation, this audiobook did not need to be 8 hours.
Halfway in, there should be more accomplished. And there's been nothing. Considering Meg wants to be a mystery author, and is sorta, half-heartedly, kinda maybe thinking about the murdered agent, she is completely missing Dalton trying to woo her.
The writing was also...I'm not giving the author another chance with a different book, is all I'll say.
Halfway in, there should be more accomplished. And there's been nothing. Considering Meg wants to be a mystery author, and is sorta, half-heartedly, kinda maybe thinking about the murdered agent, she is completely missing Dalton trying to woo her.
The writing was also...I'm not giving the author another chance with a different book, is all I'll say.
June 30, 2025
I hate not finishing books, but here we are. I’ll start by saying that writing a book is an incredible achievement – truly. But this one…yikes. The characters were cardboard cutouts, the plot was downright silly, and the writing was beyond clunky. The dialogue sounded like it was generated by malfunctioning AI. I just couldn’t force myself to finish it.
March 26, 2025
This is the first book in the A Bainbridge Island Mystery.
Im loving Meg and her dog Watson! Meg is trying to solve a mystery with the help of her friends Natasha and Dalton . It had me guessing how the mystery was going to be solved up till the end! Can’t wait for more books in the series!
Im loving Meg and her dog Watson! Meg is trying to solve a mystery with the help of her friends Natasha and Dalton . It had me guessing how the mystery was going to be solved up till the end! Can’t wait for more books in the series!
July 23, 2025
This is a new cozy series from Lynn Cahoon set primarily on an island a ferry ride away from Seattle where Meg Gates was born. After her job ended and her fiancé takes one of her bridesmaids on her honeymoon trip, her family and friends help her along with her pet dog to return home. She lives in a small apartment over a garage next to her aunt’s house. Her uncle is the Police Chief.
Her mother hires her to work in the family bookstore and her aunt arranges for a part-time job for her with a famous mystery writer.
Meg also wants to write a how to solve a murder book. The chapters of this book are the tips she hopes to use in Meg’s book.
After the author’s fired agent is killed it’s up to Meg and her close friends, including one who seems romantically interested in Meg. He’s always there for her. Both her new author employer and her best friend are suspects in this murder.
The mystery was well developed and kept me engaged. I was surprised when the killer was revealed.
I enjoyed getting to know these new characters. I’m looking forward to seeing how they develop in future books in this series.
I listened to the audiobook and the narrator brought the story to life.
Her mother hires her to work in the family bookstore and her aunt arranges for a part-time job for her with a famous mystery writer.
Meg also wants to write a how to solve a murder book. The chapters of this book are the tips she hopes to use in Meg’s book.
After the author’s fired agent is killed it’s up to Meg and her close friends, including one who seems romantically interested in Meg. He’s always there for her. Both her new author employer and her best friend are suspects in this murder.
The mystery was well developed and kept me engaged. I was surprised when the killer was revealed.
I enjoyed getting to know these new characters. I’m looking forward to seeing how they develop in future books in this series.
I listened to the audiobook and the narrator brought the story to life.
July 4, 2025
I love the setting as my partner lived on Bainbridge when we started dating and I liked visiting him there. I will be honest I have a like dislike relationship with this author and this one was okay. I didn’t love the main character Meg and I felt like there was too much going on which led to very little investigating. And her uncle was assigned the case and seemed very capable so I don’t really understand why she involved herself or why he didn’t figure this out first. I was also confused about what side she was on a lot of you only pay if you’re in a car to Seattle and it sounded like these people were walk ups cause how can they see the passenger so easily or would they notice someone giving them a bad look when they aren’t paying?
I like the setting so I will probably check out the next one.
I like the setting so I will probably check out the next one.
June 23, 2025
What a delightful cozy mystery! An Amateur Sleuth’s Guide to Murder transports the reader to a charming island just outside Seattle. Meg Gates, our amateur sleuth, felt like a 26-year-old Nancy Drew—sharp, curious, and full of heart. In fact, the book gives several nods to the iconic teen detective, which made it even more enjoyable for fans of classic mysteries.
Lynn Cahoon’s writing is both witty and warm, perfectly capturing the tone of a modern cozy mystery while building a compelling plot. She created likable characters (and some not so likable - the ex-fiancé!), and kept me engaged, while trying to figure out who the perpetrator was.
Vanessa Daniels brought Meg and the rest of the cast to life beautifully. Her narration felt effortless and engaging, and her voice was a perfect match for the tone of the story. It complemented the author’s style so well that I often forgot I wasn’t there alongside Meg piecing clues together.
If you’re a fan of small-town charm, cozy mysteries, and relatable heroine, this audiobook is a must-listen!
Thank you NetGalley and Tantor Audio for sending this book for review consideration. All opinions are my own.
#AnAmateurSleuthsGuidetoMurder #NetGalley
Lynn Cahoon’s writing is both witty and warm, perfectly capturing the tone of a modern cozy mystery while building a compelling plot. She created likable characters (and some not so likable - the ex-fiancé!), and kept me engaged, while trying to figure out who the perpetrator was.
Vanessa Daniels brought Meg and the rest of the cast to life beautifully. Her narration felt effortless and engaging, and her voice was a perfect match for the tone of the story. It complemented the author’s style so well that I often forgot I wasn’t there alongside Meg piecing clues together.
If you’re a fan of small-town charm, cozy mysteries, and relatable heroine, this audiobook is a must-listen!
Thank you NetGalley and Tantor Audio for sending this book for review consideration. All opinions are my own.
#AnAmateurSleuthsGuidetoMurder #NetGalley
June 23, 2025
I've never read anything by this author before, but I do like her style. This is a good start to a new series, and you can read my full review here. https://tcl-bookreviews.com/2025/06/2...
September 22, 2025
4🌟 (Kindle). Fun read. Long chapter titles, but I understand why. Dalton is a sweetheart + I hope he gets his girl ;)
BONUS: lobster mac n cheese recipe at the end!!
BONUS: lobster mac n cheese recipe at the end!!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 225 reviews