3.5 stars (rounded up) for this fast-paced and addictive debut novel!
Charlotte Morgan grew up in the shadow of her mother's repeated miscarriages, which eventually contributed to her parents' divorce. After the birth of her own baby, Alice, Charlotte decides to act as surrogate mother for a desperate couple. She posts on an unofficial surrogacy internet group, where she meets Brenda and Malcolm. She immediately hits it off with the latter. Charlotte's husband, Steve, is happy with her choice of intended parents, since Malcolm is willing to pay much more than the average amount for 'expenses'. The money will be a tremendous help: they live in a one-bedroom flat with Alice, and Steve has to buy out his business partner's share when the man is diagnosed with cancer.
Despite Charlotte's easy pregnancy with Alice, things do not go smoothly this time around. It takes three tries for her to conceive, only for the pregnancy to end in miscarriage. When she falls pregnant again, it is with twins. She feels unwell and bonds much more deeply with the babies - her (and Malcolm's) biological children - than she expected. Her mother strongly disapproves of the surrogacy: how can Charlotte give away 'her grandchildren'? Instead of bringing them closer, the surrogacy drives another wedge between them by bringing past trauma to the surface. To add insult to injury, Malcolm is acting weird. He has a temper and Charlotte wonders whether he might be abusing Brenda.
Despite these nagging doubts, Charlotte and Steve honours the agreement. They hand over the twins in exchange for the final cheque. Brenda promises to keep Charlotte involved in the twins' lives... but will she keep her word?
Of course not, otherwise there would be no story 😊. Charlotte has no legal ground to stand on, since 'contracts' between surrogate- and intended parents aren't worth the paper they're written on. Malcolm's cheque bounces and he and 'Brenda' disappear into thin air. Until Brenda turns up dead, that is. Who the hell did Charlotte give her babies to? Where are they? Will she ever find them again?
Somebody Else's Babies is a suspenseful tale which kept me reading until the not-so-early morning hours. Ms. Speechly's writing is skilled and her characters well-developed. The reader feels Charlotte's heartbreak when she surrenders her twins. Furthermore the book is an interesting exploration of the (substantial) flaws in British surrogacy laws.
I must admit, though, that I found Charlotte's naivety pretty unbelievable. What kind of mother would sign over her babies not only to complete strangers but to a man she suspects of spousal abuse? I know she is young and idealistic and strapped for cash, but honestly? Small inaccuracies also periodically broke the spell for me. To name one: directly after the birth Charlotte expresses breast milk with a pump so she can bottle-feed the twins. There is no way she'd have enough milk for this so early on, she would only be able to hand-express a few mililitres of colostrum to feed to the twins with a spoon or dropper (which would, of course, meet their nutritional needs perfectly). I all fairness, I am a lactation consultant, so mistakes like these will bother me more than most.
On the whole I enjoyed the book. I devoured it in a single sitting, after all. The topic is fascinating and I'll eagerly look out for the author's next book.
I received a complimentary copy through Netgalley in exchange for a honest review.