Wow! This series is so back! Heartbroken is my favorite Disney Villain novel in a long while! I had so much fun with this book! I will say that I have a previous love for the Alice in Wonderland film and the Queen of Hearts. I'd been wanting a Queen of Hearts novel for SOOOO long! However, with the release of the Gaston book, I became scared for Valentino to tackle a favorite villain. Now, all of the books before Fire and Fate were wonderful! I loved them so much! But, Fire and Fate along with Kill the Beast were so bad, and really brought out my issues with the other books, that I thought the series had lost its mojo... I was so wrong! Heartbroken actually covers the origins of the Queen of Hearts in a compelling and fun way! And, I can't believe I'm saying this, the Odd Sisters and their side of the world were not only cool, but I began to love those characters again! I never thought I'd say such a thing! They had consistently been my least favorite parts of the series, but now the sisters and the Many Kingdoms are showing GREAT PROMISE! Heartbroken not only makes the Queen of Hearts sympathetic, but it fleshes out Wonderland and the lore of the many kingdoms in a very cool, fun, and inventive way!
Firstly, the Queen of Hearts herself! I loved her storyline! It was so interesting how she appeared in Wonderland, and how she had to navigate it with the White Rabbit while tackling their fractured memories! I loved how Wonderland felt like it was ripped right out of the animated movie... But the addition of the Jabberwock was a very nice touch! The Queen goes through a lot, and I like how her journey kind of mirrors Alice in a dark way! Like Alice, the Queen becomes angry and perplexed by Wonderland, and eventually finds herself stranded and alone. However, the Queen can't escape the responsibility of her station. She tries her best to be kind, but she is angry by nature. The "how" of the Queen was so good! It literally made the travesty that was Fire and Fate worth it! They explained Wonderland and the Queen so well! The queen was sympathetic, and honestly I felt for her! This was an actual villain origin where we see her slow development into the villain! Unlike the horrible Gaston plot twist where he's cursed to be a villain. The White Rabbit in all of this is also very compelling! His love for the Queen is so sweet, and I honestly liked how he also wasn't perfect! The characters were very 3-dimensional, which isn't always true for this series.
The Odd Sisters/ Many Kingdoms stuff in this is absolutely amazing! Firstly, we get Chernobog and Bald Mountain! That was a wonderful surprise! And, the way that Wonderland and the Queen were created fits flawlessly into the narrative thus far! I really, really enjoyed the seamless connection. The Odd Sisters themselves were brilliantly used! They were funny, interesting, and dark. I also liked how we get some cameos from previously in the series.... I really liked how this book started tying everything together. Circe doesn't get as much to do, but she is set up for some big things in the future that I can't wait to see. But, yeah, this book sets up A LOT for the future! This book felt like the first act of Avengers: Infinity War... Setting up a HUGE overarching conflict. With three more books to go, I'm excited to see what we get! This book really made me excited for what's to come! I'm hoping for Madame Mim! I also want MORE than three more books! Keep this train moving! So, with Chernabog, we see a lot of the threads from previously in the series begin to become intertwined. We have the Dead woods, Wonderland, Hades, and Tulip all leading to the reemergence of this threat... I'm wondering if the next book will be the end of this arc like how the Odd Sisters was the end of the first arc.
Now, this book isn't a five star book for a reason... It did have some problems. Firstly, it has a very uneven tone. This book is technically a children's book, but it feels like the author wants it to be YA. Heck, I want it to be YA. So, sometimes it's really dark, and sometimes it's really childish. If we can get the next books in the YA section, that'd be great please... And that's it! That's all I didn't like! I LOVE THIS BOOK!
So, I've had my doubts about this series, but if we continue to have this quality, this could get back to its former glory with books like Mistress of Evil and Mother Knows Best! I'm so excited! I'm in love with this series again!