I LOVED this story!
This was such an endearing and interesting sapphic romance, that I think tons of readers would enjoy.
Poppy is the publicist for famous football player, Cash. Rosaline is the publicist for famous musical artist, Lyric.
When Cash and Lyric start dating, Poppy and Rosaline must work together to navigate the challenges of representing their clients in their new relationship.
From the start, the two women aren’t exactly fond of each other. Rosaline is known for being intense, scary and cold- and Poppy is quite intimidated by her.
Eventually tensions rise, and feelings develop as the two women start spending more time together.
Shared red carpet and sporting events become something bigger- and they find themselves becoming increasingly infatuated with each other.
When problems arise with their clients, they must decide who and what is most important to them, and if their relationship can endure the conflict.
This was such a fun read! I hardly wanted to put it down.
The romance in it was great. I think Poppy and Rosaline are so cute together!
They have somewhat of a grumpy x sunshine dynamic, and it really comes through in a beautiful “opposites attract” kind of way.
I also really enjoyed that we get to see two romance stories play out here, since we are following Cash and Lyric as well.
It feels like reading two stories in one, which is quite unique.
I felt deeply sorry for Poppy throughout this entire story.
From her challenges with addiction, to her experience growing up with older parents who were “already done being parents” by the time she was born, she really did endure so much. These sorts of things add some heaviness to the story- but they also add realness and relatability.
Poppy truly came through as a very real person with real struggles- and I felt very connected to her for that. I think a lot of other readers would too.
The writing is fantastic, and very smooth.
It feels mature, while not being complicated or confusing.
I do think it would have been extra great if it was dual point-of-view, so that we could get some insight into both women’s individual thoughts and feelings, but honestly it is still fabulous the way it is.
Bravo to this author! This is my first book of hers, but it certainly won’t be my last!
Huge thank you to HarperCollins Publishing and author Alexandria Bellefleur for providing me with the eARC of “Playing for Keeps”, in exchange for my honest review!
Publication date: January 6th, 2026