A searing summer heatwave. A terrifying fire and a dead police officer. Not your typical north Wales summer for DS Charlie Rees. Social media is awash with lies about local holiday parks being requisitioned to house refugees. Sleepy Llanfair finds itself on the radar of the far right. Charlie is called out to a fire at an Asian-run business, and in the shattering aftermath, a body is discovered. To his horror, Charlie's straight-talking colleague Patsy Hargreaves is the number one suspect for the murder. In the centre of a media storm, Llanfair suffers another devastating fire and another body is discovered. Will Charlie find the evidence he needs before the whole town goes up in flames?
Lots of plot, great character development, and beautiful, concise writing. And a layered HEA—what’s not to love?!
The novel offers at least four major plot twists—both of the cops-and-robbers variety and in how the characters relate to each other. Emotionally, the main character experiences a first fight in his marriage stemming from rather subtle conflict, one victim’s surviving loved ones interact with multi-directional volatility, and even minor characters experience realistic love and heartbreak. These threads interweave through the storyline and dialogue, and opposing politics complicate it all.
Hayes’s writing evokes the setting and heatwave central to it with intimate descriptions like: “Most of the fields were yellow where the hay had been cut, contrasting with the deep, deep green of the trees overhanging the narrow roads. Every few miles, there would be the gift of a panorama: rolling hills and woods as far as the eye could see, all bathed in the unexpected heat.”
Hayes uses varied and layered methods to craft her characters quickly and effectively, such as:
- Marvelous detail, as when Charlie notices that one interview subject’s linen dress is fully lined while another’s is unlined (and shorter).
- Understated humor: “… and the claim that ‘Wales knows how to repel unwanted outsiders,’ which made Charlie snort with laughter. ‘These guys have a real grasp of Welsh history ….’”
- Even short bits of Hayes’s dialogue unveil truth about one larger-than-life character in just a few lines: “‘He’s definitely dead?’ Ravensbourne asked. Then, ‘Of course he is. My apologies, Charlie, I’m being a fool. It’s just the shock. I’m on my way.’”
My only disappointment is that the book isn’t longer. The characters experience so much action and so many feelings that I think Ripley Hayes sells herself short with the economy of her language. Precise and piercing language like Hayes’s is usually my favorite attribute of writing, but there’s enough substance in this novel that the reader could have more worthwhile time with her wonderful book.
Of course the good guys catch the bad guys and the lovers live happily ever after, but Hayes also builds a world where racism and hate are unequivocally wrong. We all deserve that kind of optimism in our fantasies, too.
“Charlie is having a bad day” should be the tag line for this book… if not the entire series. I have complained in the past that the character of Charlie Rees hasn’t been written in these books as the “fun cheeky chappie” we originally saw in the Daniel Owen series, but seeing what he has to deal with in this fourth book in the series, I’m not surprised! With murders, arson, two troublesome teenagers and problems with Tom, no wonder he’s feeling a little down in the dumps. But to have all these things happen in the middle of a heatwave when the police are so short staffed, then I’m not surprised Charlie can feel a headache coming on.
As someone who is always desperate to read a brand new Daniel Owen book, I’ve treated these Charlie Rees books more as a stop gap until Ripley Hayes decides to write a new Daniel Owen mystery. Not so much now though as I’m starting to see this series separate to its older sibling and more able to stand on its own two feet. With each book you see a clearer personality forming as the author fits more comfortably in to Charlie’s shoes and makes these books more independent from the others. With the wonderful side characters and the atmospheric setting, these books are becoming a real pleasure to read despite some of the weighty and unusual issues they deal with. However this one really felt like it needed a little more work, maybe another read through by the author, as some of the writing seemed a little odd. It almost felt like it had been written in haste and needed some more revisions before it was ready for publishing. This one definitely didn’t feel as polished as the others, and definitely lacked the depth we are use to seeing in the Daniel Owen series.
I also found this book to be very “case-heavy” with little time spent exploring the inter-relationships between the characters. Well not much outside the main murder investigation that is. I was desperate to know more about Eddy and Will’s burgeoning relationship, or to hear about Tom’s life following the incidents in New York. We got to hear that Mal attended Charlie’s wedding but didn’t get much more from the two of them outside what was demanded by the investigation. It’s these deeper insights that make Ripley Hayes’s books really interesting, and something that was lacking here. Even with Patsy, who is at the centre if all this, we didn’t get the depth I was hoping for. Well outside of her trying to convince everyone she was happy in a polyamorous relationship… though it sounded like it was just an open relationship to me. She has always been a character I never warmed to, particularly after her appearance in Doggone, and this book did little to change that.
The ending of the book was quite rushed too. The pacing seemed to suddenly changed from describing scenes in great detail to suddenly wrapping up the final scenes in a few short pages. And despite it being longer than the previous book it felt much shorter. There didn’t feel like there was enough character depth. In fact if you asked me what I have learn about Charlie from this book, I’d say it’s that he either got really hot from the intense sun or incredibly wet hobbling around on crutches in the rain. More time was spent describing this or his annoyance at the twins, than in learning about Charlie himself. And that’s a shame as I love when the author gives us that character insight. We did get snippets of it with Ravensbourne, particularly the hospital scene. Despite the tone of this review, I do like this series and really love this author, it’s just this book really missed the mark for me. I do recommend you read this book, but if you’ve seen the quality of her writing in “Dark Waters” and “A Man”, you might understand why I was a little disappointed.
Murder in Shades of Fire and Ash (DS Charlie Rees 4) By Ripley Hayes Published by the author, 2025 Five stars
The small Welsh town of Llanfair is a busy place. In the course of a single week, Detective Sergeant Charlie Rees’s world is rocked by two murders, two explosive arsonist events, and a wave of anti-immigrant misinformation. The question is: are all of these events somehow related?
On top of everything, Charlie’s had a row with his husband Tom, triggered by Tom’s having agreed to take his twin daughters into their home for the summer without consulting Charlie.
Once again, Ripley Hayes presents us with the quirky cast of characters that make up Llanfair’s police department, but ratchets up the angst and disorientation with a non-stop series of increasingly violent events that keep Charlie and his team constantly off-balance. It seems as if everything in Charlie’s world is at risk all at once.
Of course, anyone who knows this series knows that, in his own gentle, low-key way, Charlie is just the superhero to solve the problem. What we also know is that Charlie is willing to sacrifice almost anything for the good of others, both personally and professionally, including his own safety and peace of mind.
There’s a poetic (?) sort of parallel between the idyllic little green village of Llanfair going haywire and Charlie’s idyllic little gay marriage spiraling out of control at the same time. Romantic notions of home and family get tossed out the window in a world that is—literally—too hot. The unprecedented heat wave itself is a kind of broad metaphor for the larger ills of the United Kingdom in a post-Brexit world (not to mention the effects of climate change). All of it contributes to a marvelously claustrophobic atmosphere that keeps the reader as much on edge as it does the book’s main characters.
Ripley has become my go-to author when I want a bit of murder and mayhem, because I love her characters so much. Charlie Rees is Everyman, who’s had some hard knocks and struggles with self-doubt same as everyone, and is super relatable as a result. However, he has the heart of a true hero, though he would never say that about himself, and that’s really what makes him a great character.
The murder in this one is really personal for the staff at Llanfair, and I took it hard too. There is the usual array of suspects, compounded by threats of rioting and a wicked heat wave, plus some domestic discord to round out poor Charlie’s ‘fun’. DI Freya Ravensbourne continues to delight, and of course Mal Kent lends a hand too. I had a really hard time putting it down (same as with books 1-3) – it’s impossible not to take this one personally. I did feel the story wasn’t quite as tight as the others, with a few instances that felt more like plot holes than red herrings. In the end it doesn’t matter, though, because I love the whole Llanfair gang and needed, like them, to see it through to the end. And maybe it’s less neat but more lifelike that way. I’m already hoping for another.
Murder in Shades of Fire and Ash (DS Charlie Rees 4) sees Charlie having to cope with his husband’s teenage daughters coming to stay for the summer while having to solve a murder and arson case during a heat spell. Add misinformation spread over social media, hardly any clean clothes to change into, a lack of sleep, a lack of a good meal, getting blown up and there you have it. Well that’s not it all by a long shot so buckle up for one hell of a ride.
The whole series is a dream, sometimes really funny and at other times deadly serious. Murder in Shades of Fire and Ash is that with knobs on with the murder of a colleague and another under suspicion while anti-immigrant groups prowl the streets stirred up by false news and the hot weather. Charlie has a lot of responsibility on his shoulders and all he really wants is to have a cuddle with Tom, his husband, without his phone ringing or the girls demanding attention. A joy from start to finish.
I received an ARC and am reviewing this book of my free will and because it's just great!
For this latest story, MC Charlie is back in the fictional town of Llanfair in North Wales, struggling with both his domestic and professional responsibilities. The sense of growing tension is exacerbated by a rare heatwave (this is Wales!), online trouble making and arson, which is quite enough for the small rural team of police officers to be going on with. Let alone the murder of a colleague with another colleague in the frame as a suspect.
The story was fast-paced and relentless from the very start as Charlies deals with strained loyalties (both at home and in the police station) and an investigation that becomes increasingly convoluted and dangerous. A great plot and great pacing made this a enthralling read as Charlie doggedly keeps investigating despite all odds and his own self-doubt. That human element is so involving and I'm really enjoying how Charlie is developing as a character, police officer and husband in these stories.
Thanks to the author Ripley Hayes for providing me with an arc and apologies for my next couple of lines. I am hoping an editor did another look through before this went to press as there is a repeated paragragh at the end of the first chapter and a smaller one in the second or third. And a couple other formatting errors in the early third of the book.
That aside, the book was one fast, hard run race to the conclusion. The plotting was smooth with back to back action and an all mighty twist at the end that I didn't see coming. Ms. Hayes characters feel real, like people you'd want to hang out with - except for the unpleasant ones, of course - go to the pub with, and just general enjoy in your life. There was all sorts of character development for Charlie, Patsy, and surpringly DI Ravenbourne.
The quiet moments of Charlie and Tom working out their relationship and their relationship to Tom's daughters were lovely, if only real men could talk to each other so well!
I definitely enjoyed the mystery portion of this (as always), but I had some issues with the relationship aspect between Charlie and Tom. It's still a solid 4 stars -- because Hayes' writing is good -- but it wasn't as strong as I wanted it to be, LOL.
I love Charlie! He comes across as a sweet, somewhat insecure 'mild' being. Hiding a brain like a steel trap with a strong sense of ethics, integrity and right vs wrong. His move to this little Welsh town is bringing out the best of his hidden talents, or perhaps they are curmudgeoned out of him by his scruffy, nicotine inhaling boss. Current events at work and at home are challenging Charlie in new and not particularly welcome ways. He has several near misses (Tom is NOT impressed), he stays at the station more than he goes home (Tom is not impressed), and he is not impressed with Tom (Tom has some grovelling to do). I hope the stories keep on coming - I love Charlie (did i say that already?) and his work friends / colleagues and his gorgeous husband and the extended Charlie family have become firm favourites to read about. Loving this series - want more please
There are plenty of narrative twists and turns to make this story feel like quite the ride, and they’re nicely interspersed with more quotidian moments of domestic not-quite-bliss (Charlie has a lot going on, professionally and personally, and it’s a bit of a balancing act that allows him moments to really shine and others that provoke a deep sense of empathy). This is an easy-to-pick-up, hard-to-put-down kind of book, and it makes, overall, for a compelling read. (Note to readers that this is part of a series and is most rewarding when read in order).
*I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book.
An interesting murder and connected mystery. A fire in the high street leads to finding a body and as the story goes on we get more arson and another dead body. I enjoyed this but I thought the situation with Tom and Charlie was too easily resolved. I like to think they had a more in depth conversation then the paragraph or so in the book. I am glad the angst didn't go on forever but I think it was a deeper problem then the 'talk'. Glad to see Mal make a few appearances and will certainly read another book if there is one in the series.
The author’s ability/desire to kill off MAJOR side characters is kinda pissing me off.
It was a great mystery, lots of suspects, twists and turns BUT
I am Not A Fan of killing off side characters that are best friends, love interests, characters parents, etc of the main characters simply for Drama/Angst
It’s current 4:13 in the morning and I’m pissed enough that I’m writing this review two hours after I finished the book because There Were Other Options and HE WASN’T EVEN THE PERSON THE MURDERER WAS AFTER!!! Grrrrrrrrr
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I love Ripley Hayes' Daniel Owens and now Charlie Rees mystery series. The characters are nuanced and multidimensional, and I love that Wales plays such a prominent role and the strong sense of place. This new installment is a great continuation of the series with an interesting and engaging twisty mystery. I was glad to see Charlie and Tom's relationship dynamic evolve (though the lack of communication was a tad tiresome), and it seems there will be more exciting changes to come on the home front in the next installment.
I love everything about this series, and this story in particular : the writing, Charlie and the believable raft of supporting characters, the complex and detailed plot and the satisfying conclusion. If you haven’t read any of Ripley Hayes police procedurals, set in the beautiful Welsh countryside and with a strong gay relationship at the (warm) heart of them, you are missing a trick. I will read anything by her!
Despite the crimes in this story, I love the diverse community residents and characters. The scenes are nicely described, and the murder mystery is a puzzle to the end. Compared to other Charlie Rees stories I have read, the writing needs a few transitions better handled to give it a more realistic feel. A few rough patches on an otherwise good story. Look forward to more about Charlie, husband Tom and their lives.
Disappointing. Ridiculously over the top liberal crap takes up most of the space. The worst thing was that the entire “mystery” of Unwin’s death would have been solved in five minutes by looking at his phone records. Terrible police work and way too much virtue signaling wokeness. I’d heard the Brits were worse than us in the States, but over here the crazies are on the left, not the right. (I.e. burning Teslas). Would have been nice to just have a mystery without the BS.
One of the better books of the series - largely due to the many investigative streams being tackled by DS Rees and his small but intrepid band of law enforcers. Despite the multiple serious issues (arson, murder, racism, anti-immigration rhetoric, sexual exploitation, family discord etc etc etc) ... the author manages to keep them all woven together without overwhelming the procedural plot-lines. There are however quite a few editorial problems which did jarred my reading flow.
Such a great series. I have enjoyed every book so far and this was another great addition. Plenty of murder, mystery in this well written storyline keeping you completely captivated. Realistic characters helped as you really feel the angst and emotion leaving you avidly awaiting the outcome! Highly recommend I received a free arc copy and this is my honest review
I just love these books - great mystery/crime storytelling, human characters with complete normal feelings, making mistakes, learning, being uncomfortable, etc. etc. This time it really hits home, the story is complicated, some of the people involved are close to Charlie and on top of that - not everything at home is sunshine. Loved the book.
4.5/5* Another great outing for Charlie and his band of police officers, along with trouble and strife a bit with Tom and the girls. We Brits can't cope with the heat and this just, literally, adds fuel to the fire of events that happen in Llanfair - and happen they do! Fires, riots, murders, suspects that hit close to home - Charlie navigates through them, and we get to see Mal once again!
I’m not sure what to say about this other than that I really enjoyed it. A nice twisty-turny mystery. I’d have far less patience than Charlie did with those teenagers, but that’s no surprise. All in all, I highly recommend this series.
My thanks to the author for an advance copy of this book.
Another great book in this series. There wasn’t much Tom and Charlie in this one as it mainly focused on the cases at Charlie’s work. I figured out who committed the arsons pretty quickly. The murders were a different story. I really enjoyed this and look forward to the next book.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Not as strong as the others in the series, although still enjoyable. The multiple storylines just didn't hang together as well as in the other DS Charlie Rees novels, and the characters weren't as sharply drawn. Not bad, just not nearly as good.
Charlie Rees is back. I loved this story I thought the plot was really good and it kept me guessing. I really love this series and it hope to see more.