What do you think?
Rate this book
Shepherd Sisters Mysteries #4
A Brush with Murder
Can Savanna Shepherd and her sisters unravel a deadly web of art and betrayal before the final brushstroke paints their doom?
When Savanna Shepherd’s father, Harlan, and artist friend Sebastian Alexander vanish during a sailing regatta along Michigan’s west coast, the Shepherd family is plunged into turmoil. As the Coast Guard scours the Great Lake, Savanna sets aside her work on Sebastian’s art show to join her sisters in comforting their mother and aiding in the search.
When Sebastian’s assistant is found dead—Savanna’s keen eye as an art authenticator turns to a darker decoding the secrets of Sebastian’s bitter family. Days later, the missing yacht drifts ashore, with Harlan gravely injured, Sebastian missing, and a sinister bloodstain on the bow.
In this compelling mystery brimming with small-town charm, loyal pets, and family ties, Savanna must piece together the clues to uncover who cut the lines, spilled the blood, and nearly tore her world apart.
When Savanna Shepherd’s father, Harlan, and artist friend Sebastian Alexander vanish during a sailing regatta along Michigan’s west coast, the Shepherd family is plunged into turmoil. As the Coast Guard scours the Great Lake, Savanna sets aside her work on Sebastian’s art show to join her sisters in comforting their mother and aiding in the search.
When Sebastian’s assistant is found dead—Savanna’s keen eye as an art authenticator turns to a darker decoding the secrets of Sebastian’s bitter family. Days later, the missing yacht drifts ashore, with Harlan gravely injured, Sebastian missing, and a sinister bloodstain on the bow.
In this compelling mystery brimming with small-town charm, loyal pets, and family ties, Savanna must piece together the clues to uncover who cut the lines, spilled the blood, and nearly tore her world apart.
- GenresCozy MysteryMystery
346 pages, Kindle Edition
Published August 20, 2025
11 people are currently reading
36 people want to read
About the author
Tracy Gardner
9 books273 followersTracy Gardner is a multi-award winning mystery and women's fiction author and Edgar Award nominee. Under pseudonym Jess Sinclair, the author's book club fiction book What We Could Have Been won the 2024 Storytrade Women's Fiction Award and USA Southeast Fiction award.
Currently, Gardner's five book Shepherd Sisters Mysteries series is rapid-releasing through Tule Publishing in 2025.
A Detroit native and mother of three, Tracy is the daughter of two teachers. She lives with her husband and best friend of thirty years and a menagerie of spoiled rescue dogs and cats, and is a strong believer in the power of baked goods, live music, and girlfriend therapy as staples to a happy life.
Currently, Gardner's five book Shepherd Sisters Mysteries series is rapid-releasing through Tule Publishing in 2025.
A Detroit native and mother of three, Tracy is the daughter of two teachers. She lives with her husband and best friend of thirty years and a menagerie of spoiled rescue dogs and cats, and is a strong believer in the power of baked goods, live music, and girlfriend therapy as staples to a happy life.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 40 reviews
August 20, 2025
Thank you very much to Tracy Gardner for my complimentary copy of A Brush with Murder.
All thoughts and opinions are my own.
This installment of the Shepherd Sisters Mysteries was a bit darker than the previous books and I loved it ! And by darker I mean so much family drama.
The family is preparing for a wedding but something strange is going on and Savannah is basking in all the joys of being in love.
But……
When Savannah’s dad goes missing during the annual regatta it’s all hands on deck.
This is my favorite installment of the Shepherd Sisters. This time the stakes are very high because it’s personal. The character emotions are raw and unfiltered.
Looking forward to the next installment!
All thoughts and opinions are my own.
This installment of the Shepherd Sisters Mysteries was a bit darker than the previous books and I loved it ! And by darker I mean so much family drama.
The family is preparing for a wedding but something strange is going on and Savannah is basking in all the joys of being in love.
But……
When Savannah’s dad goes missing during the annual regatta it’s all hands on deck.
This is my favorite installment of the Shepherd Sisters. This time the stakes are very high because it’s personal. The character emotions are raw and unfiltered.
Looking forward to the next installment!
September 26, 2025
I listened to the first three books in this series in audio and I really like this series, so I was super excited when I heard the author was re-publishing the first 3 books with a new publisher and adding 2 new books to the series. I bought this one on release day and didn't wait long to start reading it.
A Brush with Murder is the fourth book in this series and continues the story of The Shepherd Sisters with a new mystery in each book. I really enjoyed being back in this world and reading about the Shepherd Sisters again. Sydney is getting married soon, while Skylar is having some troubles she isn't sharing yet. Savanna meanwhile gets involved in another mystery as her father and one of his best friends go missing while participating in a regatta.
It took me some time to get into this book, as I listened to the other 3 and reading one felt different somehow. I also struggled a bit when someone close to Savannah lands in the hospital as I just recently had visited my sick mother in the hospital, so that hit a bit too close to home. The mystery was a bit slow to start and I just had these moments were it wasn't fully working for me. Luckily the mystery picked up, the family member got out of the hospital and I got used to reading instead of listening and it got easier for me to enjoy the book. Not my favorite book in the series, but I still enjoyed it.
The mystery didn't fully grip me, it was very slow to start. Looking back I can see how this lead up was part of the mystery, but in the moment it was hard to connect the pieces and it felt like there was this stretch were they were just waiting and nothign much was happening. I got a bit more itnerested when Savannah got more actively involved after finding a dead body, but I still didn't get fully invested. There were some possible suspects and some interesting clues. I didn't feel the Shepherd Sisters were as instrumental in solving this one as some of the earlier books, but they do find a big clue the police missed which leads to them solving the case. And the way it came together at the end was great and I liked how it all made sense and how some clues from earlier on tied back in the wrap up.
One of my favorite parts of this series is reading about Savannah and her sisters. they all have some things going on in their life and it's fun to read about them and see them interact with each other. They are a very close knit family and there are some heartwarming scenes with them being there for each other. Then there is Aidan, Savannah's fiancé and his daughter Mollie who are fun to read about. As well as some pet characters who make fun additions to the story.
To summarize: I was excited to hear this series gets two more books and quickly got this fourth book after it released. It was so fun to be back in this world and reading about the Shepherd Sisters and their lives. All three sisters have things going on and there is a new mystery. I had a few moments I struggled a bit with this one due to having listened to the first 3 books and reading this one, the mystery being a bit slow to start and the injured family member which hit a bit close to home as I recently visited my mom in the hospital. The mystery picked up later and I liked seeing it all play out and fall on it's place. I enjoyed reading more about the Shepherd Sisters, their loved ones and pets. I look forward to the next book!
A Brush with Murder is the fourth book in this series and continues the story of The Shepherd Sisters with a new mystery in each book. I really enjoyed being back in this world and reading about the Shepherd Sisters again. Sydney is getting married soon, while Skylar is having some troubles she isn't sharing yet. Savanna meanwhile gets involved in another mystery as her father and one of his best friends go missing while participating in a regatta.
It took me some time to get into this book, as I listened to the other 3 and reading one felt different somehow. I also struggled a bit when someone close to Savannah lands in the hospital as I just recently had visited my sick mother in the hospital, so that hit a bit too close to home. The mystery was a bit slow to start and I just had these moments were it wasn't fully working for me. Luckily the mystery picked up, the family member got out of the hospital and I got used to reading instead of listening and it got easier for me to enjoy the book. Not my favorite book in the series, but I still enjoyed it.
The mystery didn't fully grip me, it was very slow to start. Looking back I can see how this lead up was part of the mystery, but in the moment it was hard to connect the pieces and it felt like there was this stretch were they were just waiting and nothign much was happening. I got a bit more itnerested when Savannah got more actively involved after finding a dead body, but I still didn't get fully invested. There were some possible suspects and some interesting clues. I didn't feel the Shepherd Sisters were as instrumental in solving this one as some of the earlier books, but they do find a big clue the police missed which leads to them solving the case. And the way it came together at the end was great and I liked how it all made sense and how some clues from earlier on tied back in the wrap up.
One of my favorite parts of this series is reading about Savannah and her sisters. they all have some things going on in their life and it's fun to read about them and see them interact with each other. They are a very close knit family and there are some heartwarming scenes with them being there for each other. Then there is Aidan, Savannah's fiancé and his daughter Mollie who are fun to read about. As well as some pet characters who make fun additions to the story.
To summarize: I was excited to hear this series gets two more books and quickly got this fourth book after it released. It was so fun to be back in this world and reading about the Shepherd Sisters and their lives. All three sisters have things going on and there is a new mystery. I had a few moments I struggled a bit with this one due to having listened to the first 3 books and reading this one, the mystery being a bit slow to start and the injured family member which hit a bit close to home as I recently visited my mom in the hospital. The mystery picked up later and I liked seeing it all play out and fall on it's place. I enjoyed reading more about the Shepherd Sisters, their loved ones and pets. I look forward to the next book!
August 19, 2025
This Savannah Shepherd mystery might just be my favorite yet!
Savannah’s dad, the unflappable and dependable Harlan, sets sail for his yearly sailing regatta competition with his artist friend Sebastian. It’s a tradition they’ve done together for years, and no one expects this year to be too different from the previous years- that is, until their boat disappears and Harlan and Sebastian are nowhere to be found. The Shepherd family is in shambles as they try to hold on to hope that everything will be okay for their dad and friend. As the ugly truths behind the men’s disappearance come to light, the family starts to untangled a web of lies and deceit surrounded the mysterious artist Sebastian. Can Savannah once again use her sleuthing skills to find the truth of his disappearance- before it’s too late?
I loved the mystery and suspense in this one! I found myself frantically reading, trying to figure out if Harlan was going to be okay. The intricacies of the case were fun to follow, complex without being overly confusing! The double missing person aspect was a fresh take and very engaging, and I enjoyed the amateur sleuthing aspects in this one.
Of course, we also got plenty of Shepherd family charm as we continue to get pieces of the Shepherd sisters’ stories. Skylar faced some martial challenges in this book that also had me reading frantically for the resolution- I just love her little family! Savannah’s uncles also make their appearance, as well as plenty of furry friends from the previous book. Savannah and Aidan and Finn and Sydney continue to be the power couples of the year. The Finn and Sydney highlights were especially swoony! Finally, I loved all the furry friends in this book and especially the way a dog helped collect clues to pin down the murderer (read to find out how!)
Yup, this one was definitely my favorite, and can’t wait for more to come!
Savannah’s dad, the unflappable and dependable Harlan, sets sail for his yearly sailing regatta competition with his artist friend Sebastian. It’s a tradition they’ve done together for years, and no one expects this year to be too different from the previous years- that is, until their boat disappears and Harlan and Sebastian are nowhere to be found. The Shepherd family is in shambles as they try to hold on to hope that everything will be okay for their dad and friend. As the ugly truths behind the men’s disappearance come to light, the family starts to untangled a web of lies and deceit surrounded the mysterious artist Sebastian. Can Savannah once again use her sleuthing skills to find the truth of his disappearance- before it’s too late?
I loved the mystery and suspense in this one! I found myself frantically reading, trying to figure out if Harlan was going to be okay. The intricacies of the case were fun to follow, complex without being overly confusing! The double missing person aspect was a fresh take and very engaging, and I enjoyed the amateur sleuthing aspects in this one.
Of course, we also got plenty of Shepherd family charm as we continue to get pieces of the Shepherd sisters’ stories. Skylar faced some martial challenges in this book that also had me reading frantically for the resolution- I just love her little family! Savannah’s uncles also make their appearance, as well as plenty of furry friends from the previous book. Savannah and Aidan and Finn and Sydney continue to be the power couples of the year. The Finn and Sydney highlights were especially swoony! Finally, I loved all the furry friends in this book and especially the way a dog helped collect clues to pin down the murderer (read to find out how!)
Yup, this one was definitely my favorite, and can’t wait for more to come!
September 6, 2025
I had read the first three books in this series when the author originally released them under Hallmark. I was quite happy to see that there were going to be a couple more added to the series. While there are definitely mysteries in this series, I honestly feel like this is more of a women's fiction book than a mystery. It was great to catch up with Skyler, Savanna and Sydney, the Shepherd sisters, their businesses, and relationships. I love seeing Savanna use her art skills to authenticate the paintings of a local famous artist who is also a sailing buddy of her dad's. When Harlan and his friend, artist Sebastian Alexander, participate in a local sailing regatta, something they have done numerous times, no one anticipates any issues, so when the yacht disappear no one knows what to think. While everyone tries to figure out what happened to the yacht and its occupants and Savanna works on moving the collection onto the scheduled show, many family issues are raised in both families. At this point in the book, I did feel that there was some drama overload. This was way more about relationships and their problems than actual mystery solving, but Savanna does make a couple of discoveries that finally lead to a few answers. I felt that this book had definitely more drama than those in the past, and I would have preferred a bit more mystery.
August 28, 2025
A sailing trip Savanna’s dad and friend Sebastian make goes off the rails and they go missing. Caught up in a complex and convoluted situation fueled by anger and resentment. While the families wait for news there’s still so much going on. Sydney is two weeks from her wedding, Skylar is having issues and Savanna is neck deep in prep for a showing and investigating. Hoping for the best but scared of the worst the family waits and tries to go about their normal lives.
I thought this was a clever and unexpected puzzle. At first I thought that Griffin’s theory was right, then I was convinced otherwise all to find out he had the right idea but the wrong culprits. Really enjoyed reading through and seeing the string bonds and love this family has. Loved the wedding the sweet ending. Can’t wait for what’s next for these sisters and this family!.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
I thought this was a clever and unexpected puzzle. At first I thought that Griffin’s theory was right, then I was convinced otherwise all to find out he had the right idea but the wrong culprits. Really enjoyed reading through and seeing the string bonds and love this family has. Loved the wedding the sweet ending. Can’t wait for what’s next for these sisters and this family!.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
July 26, 2025
I enjoyed this book. Despite the slow start I think it is my favourite book so far. It only seemed like a slow start because Harlan and his friend going missing, so a lot of time is spent looking and worrying about them before the real investigation and murder take place. This actually worked well because you got to know the characters, built up the motive and kept you guessing over what the out come would be. There was also a number of suspects to keep you guessing and the story entertaining. I think it is the characters that make it such a good series and by getting a number of there perspectives throughout the story you really get to know and care about them. There was a lot going on in this story with a missing boat, a murder, an art exhibit, a wedding, a marriage in crisis and unlike choppy waters the book flowed along nice until you reached the end of the book. I can't wait for the next book to see what is in-store for the Sheperd sister's next.
Savanna and her sister's were brought up sailing me she has no fear of the water. Until her dad and his friend Sebastian fail to reach the finish line for the annual sailing regatta. Some time during the night there boat has gone missing and already down a man the family don't want to contemplate the worse. Sebastian was returning to the art world, with Savanna authenticating his work but with him missing shoulder carry on? But if she doesn't does that mean she has given up hope of ever finding them alive? Then the worst happens and the boat is found with only one body on board. Elated to have there father home and alive, Savanna turns her skills to finding out what happened to Sebastian and in the process finds his assistant dead. Can she find the killer?
I was given this free review copy book at my request and have voluntarily left this review.
Savanna and her sister's were brought up sailing me she has no fear of the water. Until her dad and his friend Sebastian fail to reach the finish line for the annual sailing regatta. Some time during the night there boat has gone missing and already down a man the family don't want to contemplate the worse. Sebastian was returning to the art world, with Savanna authenticating his work but with him missing shoulder carry on? But if she doesn't does that mean she has given up hope of ever finding them alive? Then the worst happens and the boat is found with only one body on board. Elated to have there father home and alive, Savanna turns her skills to finding out what happened to Sebastian and in the process finds his assistant dead. Can she find the killer?
I was given this free review copy book at my request and have voluntarily left this review.
August 29, 2025
This is book 4 in The Shepherd Sisters Mysteries. I think this is the best one yet. The story kept you guessing as to who did what, what happened to Savanna’s dad, what happened to the artist Sebastian, who killed Sebastian’s assistant, what is happening in Savanna’s sister Skylar’s life, and so on. Underlying the story is love of family and community. I can’t wait for the next one. I voluntarily read an advance copy from the publisher. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
July 29, 2025
So happy to have received an advanced copy of this book! This is the fourth in the series, and while it can absolutely be read as a standalone, I think it’s my favorite installment so far.
In this book, the Shepherd Sisters’ father joins his friend Sebastian in a local boating competition. Sebastian, once a famous artist, gave up painting years ago to live a quieter life in Carson with his wife. But on the first night of the competition, their boat goes missing—and no one knows where the two men are.
I was completely hooked and flew through this story. I don’t know much about sailing or art, but the details were fascinating and clearly well researched. The writing made me feel like I was right there on the dock. If I weren’t a non-swimmer, I’d be inspired to learn how to sail!
This was such a great cozy mystery, full of charm and suspense, with lovable dog personalities woven throughout. The series just keeps getting better, and I can’t wait for the next one.
Heartfelt, atmospheric, and full of small-town warmth—this is exactly the kind of cozy mystery I love to get lost in. Highly recommend!
In this book, the Shepherd Sisters’ father joins his friend Sebastian in a local boating competition. Sebastian, once a famous artist, gave up painting years ago to live a quieter life in Carson with his wife. But on the first night of the competition, their boat goes missing—and no one knows where the two men are.
I was completely hooked and flew through this story. I don’t know much about sailing or art, but the details were fascinating and clearly well researched. The writing made me feel like I was right there on the dock. If I weren’t a non-swimmer, I’d be inspired to learn how to sail!
This was such a great cozy mystery, full of charm and suspense, with lovable dog personalities woven throughout. The series just keeps getting better, and I can’t wait for the next one.
Heartfelt, atmospheric, and full of small-town warmth—this is exactly the kind of cozy mystery I love to get lost in. Highly recommend!
August 28, 2025
Savanna Shepherd is thrilled to be authenticating the works of the legendary and reclusive artist, Sebastian Alexander, thanks partly to his friendship with her dad, Harlan. The men are preparing for the annual regatta on Lake Michigan, although Sebastian claims it will be his last. Savanna gets a glimpse at some family strife when Sebastian’s son drops out as deckhand. As the men are experienced, no one is too concerned about them setting off alone. Unfortunately, the yacht doesn’t check in when expected and contact lost. The Shepherd family is thrown into turmoil as the fate of the men is up in the air. When an injured Harlan is found without Sebastian, more questions arise. What actually happened on the yacht; accident, sabotage, murder, or misdirection? When Sebastian’s assistant is also found dead, things get even murkier.
The intricately layered plot and character relationships drive this family centered story. Fear for Harlan’s safety has everyone on edge. The drama in Sebastian’s family also plays in as his children and wife fall under suspicion as well. Add in tension in Skylar’s marriage and the upcoming wedding of Sydney and Finn, to keep the pages turning. While it’s fourth book in the series, it is still accessible to those without prior knowledge. The family’s bonds are written so well that it’s easy to feel the connection between the sisters and their respective significant others. Small touches like eldest Skylar trying to handle everything on her own or Savanna giving grace to Aidan for the realities of his job commitment, add to the relatability of the characters.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
The intricately layered plot and character relationships drive this family centered story. Fear for Harlan’s safety has everyone on edge. The drama in Sebastian’s family also plays in as his children and wife fall under suspicion as well. Add in tension in Skylar’s marriage and the upcoming wedding of Sydney and Finn, to keep the pages turning. While it’s fourth book in the series, it is still accessible to those without prior knowledge. The family’s bonds are written so well that it’s easy to feel the connection between the sisters and their respective significant others. Small touches like eldest Skylar trying to handle everything on her own or Savanna giving grace to Aidan for the realities of his job commitment, add to the relatability of the characters.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
August 25, 2025
I love cozy mysteries and am always looking for a new series to read. It's just like me to jump into the 4th book of a series so I really wasn't vested in all the family drama-which there is a lot of. I did love the dynamic of the Sheperd sisters and will definitely go back to read the beginning of the series (the author also provided enough background so I was not lost). I loved the setting-having lived in Michigan the spirit of the state is well captured (the reference to the daredevil deer at night made me chuckle although every Michigander knows they are no joke). The mysterious disappearance of Harlan Sheperd and his artist friend Sebastian during a sailing regatta made for a compelling story. I enjoyed how Savanna pieced together the clues unravelling the intricacies of Sebastian's life. A little slow at times with all the Sheperd family exploits but the mystery itself makes for a great read. I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
August 28, 2025
What a crazy story! Savanna’s dad and Sebastian, a family friend, are participating in a regatta. When the boat goes missing, it’s all hands on deck to find them. Savanna and Sydney head out to identify a body that isn’t their dad. When he does turn up, he’s banged up, but thankfully alive. But Sebastian is still missing. Griffin, Sebastian’s son, thinks his dad faked his death. He did change his will, removing his wife. When Savanna finds his assistant dead at his house while she’s working on his paintings for an upcoming exhibit, things get scary. All evidence points toward the assistant, but why did he do it?
The twists and turns in this one keep you on the edge of your seat. Such a fun read!
The twists and turns in this one keep you on the edge of your seat. Such a fun read!
August 19, 2025
I am just in love with this cozy mystery series. With each new book in this series, I just love it even more.
A Brush With Murder is the 4th in the series. These books can definitely be read as stand-alones, but I would highly recommend reading the entire series.
This one was intense. I couldn't put it down by the end, I needed to know how it was going to resolve.
This series focuses on the Shepherd family, mainly the sisters, with the middle sister, Savannah being our lead and primary amateur sleuther. The entire Shepherd family are amazing characters. So, this one definitely felt so much more shocking and intense when the sisters dad goes missing.
The mystery in this one had me on the edge of the seat. There were a few twists in this one. So, while at first I thought I knew where the story was going, I was very wrong.
The other thing I really enjoy about these books is that the characters are so real. Besides the mystery, we also get a glimpse into the characters' lives and different struggles and challenges that we can all face at times in our lives. I don't want to give spoilers. This one has left me on a bit of a cliffhanger with a challenge that Savannah and her fiance, Aiden, are facing, and now I am not so patiently waiting for the next 🤣
This book definitely made me gasp in shock, groan in frustration, and then swoon at the beautiful romances! I love it when a book gives me so many feels.
A Brush With Murder is the 4th in the series. These books can definitely be read as stand-alones, but I would highly recommend reading the entire series.
This one was intense. I couldn't put it down by the end, I needed to know how it was going to resolve.
This series focuses on the Shepherd family, mainly the sisters, with the middle sister, Savannah being our lead and primary amateur sleuther. The entire Shepherd family are amazing characters. So, this one definitely felt so much more shocking and intense when the sisters dad goes missing.
The mystery in this one had me on the edge of the seat. There were a few twists in this one. So, while at first I thought I knew where the story was going, I was very wrong.
The other thing I really enjoy about these books is that the characters are so real. Besides the mystery, we also get a glimpse into the characters' lives and different struggles and challenges that we can all face at times in our lives. I don't want to give spoilers. This one has left me on a bit of a cliffhanger with a challenge that Savannah and her fiance, Aiden, are facing, and now I am not so patiently waiting for the next 🤣
This book definitely made me gasp in shock, groan in frustration, and then swoon at the beautiful romances! I love it when a book gives me so many feels.
August 22, 2025
A Brush with Murder, the fourth of the Shepherd Sisters stories by Tracy Gardner is the twisty of the series so far. The Shepherds father goes missing along with his artist friend. It takes a while for this to be solved then the big murder investigation takes over. Even with the small-town personality, sweet pets and supporting family it is clear something more sinister is going on there. Everyone is on hand to find the ones responsible even though several have issues of their own. If art and sailing are your thing, by the time you finish reading this book you will want them to be. While the family stories have developed from the first, this book could still be read on its own.
August 24, 2025
I enjoy this series. This is book 4 in the Sheppard Sisters series. Savannah’s dad disappears during the sailing regatta. When he’s found he’s in a coma and his sailing partner is dead. Savanna and her sisters can figure out why but as they investigate she discovers some forgeries at the local art gallery. A good cozy with clues that keep you guessing and on the right track.
August 30, 2025
Savanna's father Harlan and artist friend Sebastian are sailing off the coast of Michigan. When the yacht disappears with Harlan and Sebastian on board, Savanna and her sisters team up to help with the search. When the yacht is found, Harlan is critically injured and Sebastian is missing. What happened on that yacht and where is Sebastian? In the midst of all that, the sisters are facing their own struggles in their personal lives. A full-blown mystery with plenty of twists combined with challenging family dynamics and lovable pets will keep you on the edge of your seat waiting to see what happens next!
August 20, 2025
A Brush with Murder is a spell binding, fascinating, small town, familycentric, cozy mystery. The Shepherd sisters are always fascinating to me. I love their close family dynamic - and Ms. Garner really ratcheted up the family drama in this one. The blurb really summarizes the plot well. I was so caught up with the missing men, and then the artist's assistant's murder that I got very little sleep that night! I love visiting with the extended Shepherd family - the significant others, the uncles and the dogs. This well plotted book held me attention completely from beginning to end!
September 7, 2025
A Brush With Murder is the fourth book in the Shepherd Sisters Mystery series by Tracy Gardner. The amateur sleuth is Savanna Shepherd, an art authenticator with a keen eye for detail.
A Brush With Murder is a delightful family-centric mystery with great sister relationships, a cozy lakeside setting, and a light touch of clean, closed-door romance.
In this book, Savanna Shepherd’s father, Harlan, and artist friend Sebastian Alexander vanish during a sailing regatta along Michigan's west coast. Their boat later drifts to shore with a sinister blood stain on the bow. Savanna and her family investigate to try to find out what happened to their patriarch and his missing friend.
One of my favorite things about this series is the setting of Carson, a small town on Lake Michigan. It provides the perfect location for this particular installment, which features a fun sailing regatta, missing sailors, and a mysterious event out on the lake.
The mystery is really good! Author Tracy Gardner masterfully paces the story, layering revelations with red herrings that build to a satisfying climax. The integration of art heists, betrayal, and personal stakes make A Brush With Murder exciting and suspenseful.
As usual, I really enjoyed the unbreakable sister bond in this story. The heartfelt, homespun family element is what really makes this series shine.
Thanks to Tule Publishing for an advance reader copy of this story. Getting an ARC did not influence this voluntary review.
A Brush With Murder is a delightful family-centric mystery with great sister relationships, a cozy lakeside setting, and a light touch of clean, closed-door romance.
In this book, Savanna Shepherd’s father, Harlan, and artist friend Sebastian Alexander vanish during a sailing regatta along Michigan's west coast. Their boat later drifts to shore with a sinister blood stain on the bow. Savanna and her family investigate to try to find out what happened to their patriarch and his missing friend.
One of my favorite things about this series is the setting of Carson, a small town on Lake Michigan. It provides the perfect location for this particular installment, which features a fun sailing regatta, missing sailors, and a mysterious event out on the lake.
The mystery is really good! Author Tracy Gardner masterfully paces the story, layering revelations with red herrings that build to a satisfying climax. The integration of art heists, betrayal, and personal stakes make A Brush With Murder exciting and suspenseful.
As usual, I really enjoyed the unbreakable sister bond in this story. The heartfelt, homespun family element is what really makes this series shine.
Thanks to Tule Publishing for an advance reader copy of this story. Getting an ARC did not influence this voluntary review.
September 19, 2025
This mystery hit a little closer to home for the Shepard sisters than the previous ones but also was a very different mystery at the start. It allowed the reader to get to know the family even more whether you have read the others in the series or not. Once certain details were uncovered Savannah went into sleuth mode very quickly. I enjoyed the way she looks at the clues analytically and tries not to form conclusions based on personal ties or emotional opinions. I learned a couple fun facts about dogs, and I like how much the business and Savannah's dog is mentioned. I love the setting and the small-town vibes. I liked that we got to see more of Skylar’s personal life and the family dynamic.
September 2, 2025
Another Savanna Shepherd mystery, the 4th book in the series. There is always drama and mystery when it comes to the Shepherd family. This book has it all, the drama and the mystery. Savannah's dad and his artist friend, Sebastian,disappear during the regatta, and the search begins when they are not heard from. Everyone is shocked as they are both seasoned sailors. So the shock of them missing is rough for both families. Then Sebastian's assistant ends up dead. So now another mystery needs to be solved on who did it and why. There are many twists and turns. You will want to get the book to find out the rest.
August 21, 2025
A Brush with Murder is the fourth book in Tracy Gardner’s fabulous series, The Shepherd Sisters Mysteries. We return to Carson, Michigan where Harlan, the girl’s father is getting ready to leave for a regatta with his friend Sebastian Alexander. Sebastian is a renowned artist who had been away from his work for many years until recently. His family convinced him to do another show and Savanna Shepherd was hired to authenticate his paintings. Sebastian’s assistant has been working with Savanna so she could get everything done.
After the boat the men are on veers off course, the families are notified that the boat is missing. After a couple days of searching, the boat is finally located and only Harlan is on board. He has been attacked and is in bad shape. The Shepherd family heads to Wisconsin where he was taken to a hospital. Harlan is unable to remember a lot as he was unconscious for awhile. The search continues for Sebastian. It is unclear if he attacked Harlan or if it was someone else. Savanna starts investigating the different people in Sebastian’s life and motives and means. Harlan continues to improve and returns home.
Savanna continues her work for the art show as it is uncertain what will happen. At the same time, wedding preparations are continuing for Sydney and her fiancé Finn in two weeks. The oldest sister Skylar has a secret that is causing her much unhappiness. She and her husband are fighting over something and it’s not clear what is going on. The sisters are very worried and want to help her. Savanna and her fiancé are working on setting a date for their own wedding.
Tracy has given us another terrific and well written story. I loved the plot and the various characters’ interactions. The inclusion of each of the sisters individual romances makes their book even more compelling to read. I am a huge fan of angsty romances and mystery and combining them is genius. It is fun to read about the changes in everyone’s lives too. I appreciate learning about sailing and regattas as well as the art authentication process. I am looking forward to the next book in this series. This is another five star book that I highly recommend.
I was fortunate to receive this ARC from Tule Publishing in exchange for my honest review.
After the boat the men are on veers off course, the families are notified that the boat is missing. After a couple days of searching, the boat is finally located and only Harlan is on board. He has been attacked and is in bad shape. The Shepherd family heads to Wisconsin where he was taken to a hospital. Harlan is unable to remember a lot as he was unconscious for awhile. The search continues for Sebastian. It is unclear if he attacked Harlan or if it was someone else. Savanna starts investigating the different people in Sebastian’s life and motives and means. Harlan continues to improve and returns home.
Savanna continues her work for the art show as it is uncertain what will happen. At the same time, wedding preparations are continuing for Sydney and her fiancé Finn in two weeks. The oldest sister Skylar has a secret that is causing her much unhappiness. She and her husband are fighting over something and it’s not clear what is going on. The sisters are very worried and want to help her. Savanna and her fiancé are working on setting a date for their own wedding.
Tracy has given us another terrific and well written story. I loved the plot and the various characters’ interactions. The inclusion of each of the sisters individual romances makes their book even more compelling to read. I am a huge fan of angsty romances and mystery and combining them is genius. It is fun to read about the changes in everyone’s lives too. I appreciate learning about sailing and regattas as well as the art authentication process. I am looking forward to the next book in this series. This is another five star book that I highly recommend.
I was fortunate to receive this ARC from Tule Publishing in exchange for my honest review.
September 5, 2025
Let me tell you, diving into A Brush with Murder felt like catching up with old friends—ones who just happen to stumble into deadly chaos with alarming regularity. Book 4 in The Shepherd Sisters Mysteries hits a little deeper, cuts a little sharper, and had me flipping pages like my sanity depended on it.
From the second I found out Savanna’s dad and Sebastian were missing during that regatta, my heart was in my throat. Like, how dare Tracy Gardner threaten Harlan?! That man is the backbone of this family, and you better believe I was just as emotionally wrecked as the sisters when that yacht came ashore—Harlan barely clinging to life, and Sebastian just… gone. The dread? Real. The questions? Endless. The emotional investment? Off the charts.
Savanna continues to shine as this grounded, observant, fiercely loyal heroine. I love that she doesn’t play detective for the thrill of it—it’s always about family, loyalty, and justice. When Sebastian’s assistant turns up dead and that bloodstain on the boat won’t stop screaming for answers, Savanna’s art expertise becomes her greatest weapon. I live for the way she pieces together clues like a pro—using details others overlook and her ability to read between the brushstrokes.
What really got me this time, though, was the emotional layering. Watching the sisters rally around their mom? The way fear and love pushed them all forward, even when the truth started getting twisted and dangerous? It just hit different. The art world tension, the family secrets, and yes—more than a few gasp-worthy reveals—had me clenching my cozy mystery-loving fists in suspense.
Oh, and the pets! Still loyal. Still adorable. Still giving the perfect touch of comfort in all the mayhem.
This one felt personal. Like the stakes were raised not just in the mystery, but in the heart of the Shepherd family. If you love smart sleuthing, art-world intrigue, and sisterly bonds stronger than any alibi, A Brush with Murder delivers. Hard.
Five stars. A must-read for every cozy mystery lover who likes their whodunits with a splash of heart and a bold brushstroke of danger.
From the second I found out Savanna’s dad and Sebastian were missing during that regatta, my heart was in my throat. Like, how dare Tracy Gardner threaten Harlan?! That man is the backbone of this family, and you better believe I was just as emotionally wrecked as the sisters when that yacht came ashore—Harlan barely clinging to life, and Sebastian just… gone. The dread? Real. The questions? Endless. The emotional investment? Off the charts.
Savanna continues to shine as this grounded, observant, fiercely loyal heroine. I love that she doesn’t play detective for the thrill of it—it’s always about family, loyalty, and justice. When Sebastian’s assistant turns up dead and that bloodstain on the boat won’t stop screaming for answers, Savanna’s art expertise becomes her greatest weapon. I live for the way she pieces together clues like a pro—using details others overlook and her ability to read between the brushstrokes.
What really got me this time, though, was the emotional layering. Watching the sisters rally around their mom? The way fear and love pushed them all forward, even when the truth started getting twisted and dangerous? It just hit different. The art world tension, the family secrets, and yes—more than a few gasp-worthy reveals—had me clenching my cozy mystery-loving fists in suspense.
Oh, and the pets! Still loyal. Still adorable. Still giving the perfect touch of comfort in all the mayhem.
This one felt personal. Like the stakes were raised not just in the mystery, but in the heart of the Shepherd family. If you love smart sleuthing, art-world intrigue, and sisterly bonds stronger than any alibi, A Brush with Murder delivers. Hard.
Five stars. A must-read for every cozy mystery lover who likes their whodunits with a splash of heart and a bold brushstroke of danger.
July 8, 2025
🥰 My favourite of the series so far!
I absolutely loved this one because I got to know the Shepherd sisters better as they dealt with real-life personal and professional issues, family dynamics, sibling rivalry, a murder, and a missing person. Gardner’s implementation of the family theme tied this mystery together very well. Her examination of the parent-child, sibling, and extended family relationships made me feel part of the family. When difficulties arose, I noted the role of family in providing emotional and psychological support. The marital issues, generational conflicts, and sibling rivalry added to the sense of belonging that the Shepherds represent and made this a more authentic-sounding story.
Connecting with Sebastian’s character early in the book meant that I felt the loss later. I love this blended family and their genuine love for one another. I hope you smile when you reach the bracelet scene! Not only are the children’s ages represented well, but Sebastian’s adopted dog will pull on your heartstrings. Ringo is a Bouvier des Flandres. You’ll see him on the right side of the cover. If I were a dog person, I’d love this breed. Yes, Savanna’s Boston Terrier, Fonzie, makes an appearance in this story.
Sebastian heads off on the 198 nautical mile sailboat race to Mackinac City, but before he gets too far into the 54h round trip, his sailboat goes off course and the men are unaccounted for. Gardner makes sure her characters feel the same sense of dread that is echoed throughout the Shepherd family. I couldn’t put the book down until I knew the outcome of the tragedy.
Great cover, too. Love that it reflects Sebastian’s postimpressionist painting style.
This fantastic cozy mystery examining art and betrayal is one you won’t want to miss!
I was gifted this copy and was under no obligation to provide a review.
I absolutely loved this one because I got to know the Shepherd sisters better as they dealt with real-life personal and professional issues, family dynamics, sibling rivalry, a murder, and a missing person. Gardner’s implementation of the family theme tied this mystery together very well. Her examination of the parent-child, sibling, and extended family relationships made me feel part of the family. When difficulties arose, I noted the role of family in providing emotional and psychological support. The marital issues, generational conflicts, and sibling rivalry added to the sense of belonging that the Shepherds represent and made this a more authentic-sounding story.
Connecting with Sebastian’s character early in the book meant that I felt the loss later. I love this blended family and their genuine love for one another. I hope you smile when you reach the bracelet scene! Not only are the children’s ages represented well, but Sebastian’s adopted dog will pull on your heartstrings. Ringo is a Bouvier des Flandres. You’ll see him on the right side of the cover. If I were a dog person, I’d love this breed. Yes, Savanna’s Boston Terrier, Fonzie, makes an appearance in this story.
Sebastian heads off on the 198 nautical mile sailboat race to Mackinac City, but before he gets too far into the 54h round trip, his sailboat goes off course and the men are unaccounted for. Gardner makes sure her characters feel the same sense of dread that is echoed throughout the Shepherd family. I couldn’t put the book down until I knew the outcome of the tragedy.
Great cover, too. Love that it reflects Sebastian’s postimpressionist painting style.
This fantastic cozy mystery examining art and betrayal is one you won’t want to miss!
I was gifted this copy and was under no obligation to provide a review.
August 7, 2025
Wonderful!
I was so delighted to see that this series is continuing. I think the first 3 books were rewrites of earlier books, but the author has, fortunately, continued the story, and I hope to see much more!!
In this book, Harlan (dad to Savanna, Skylar & Sydney) and an artist friend disappear during a sailing regatta. There is an all out effort to find them, and the girls and their mom are simply beside themselves.
Though Harlan is found, he's badly injured. Sebastian, his friend, is still missing, and Savanna finds Sebastian's assistant dead in the artist's home.
Will Sebastian be found? Will Harlan recover? Who did this? Savanna helps figure out what happened, as she balances the rest of her life.
What is wonderful about this series is the excellent writing, which doesn't rely on catch phrases to tell the story. There is a compelling mystery, a lovely setting, great character, and some romance.
The relationships between all the characters are so lovely, and very touching at times, touching my heart.
I really look forward to the next book to see what happens and what new adventures will take place!!!.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
I was so delighted to see that this series is continuing. I think the first 3 books were rewrites of earlier books, but the author has, fortunately, continued the story, and I hope to see much more!!
In this book, Harlan (dad to Savanna, Skylar & Sydney) and an artist friend disappear during a sailing regatta. There is an all out effort to find them, and the girls and their mom are simply beside themselves.
Though Harlan is found, he's badly injured. Sebastian, his friend, is still missing, and Savanna finds Sebastian's assistant dead in the artist's home.
Will Sebastian be found? Will Harlan recover? Who did this? Savanna helps figure out what happened, as she balances the rest of her life.
What is wonderful about this series is the excellent writing, which doesn't rely on catch phrases to tell the story. There is a compelling mystery, a lovely setting, great character, and some romance.
The relationships between all the characters are so lovely, and very touching at times, touching my heart.
I really look forward to the next book to see what happens and what new adventures will take place!!!.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
August 14, 2025
The Shepherd sisters are an interesting crew, and I am really enjoying getting to know this entire family, warts and all. The author does a great job of showing every side of the family, even when the picture may not be pretty. This makes a character more realistic and much more likable. The closeness of their family shines through the pages. These family members and their friends would do anything for each other.
This one was a little slower getting started, but the foundation had to be built with getting lost and sea and all that followed. I was never worried, and with good reason, because once it picked up steam, it never stopped rolling as the author expertly tied everything up with a nice, neat bow.
Lost at sea will have a different ring to it after reading this book. The cover alone gives this the necessary edge of perfection with the beautiful colors and adorable dogs. This series just keeps getting better.
Thank you to the author for this ARC. I am leaving this review voluntarily.
This one was a little slower getting started, but the foundation had to be built with getting lost and sea and all that followed. I was never worried, and with good reason, because once it picked up steam, it never stopped rolling as the author expertly tied everything up with a nice, neat bow.
Lost at sea will have a different ring to it after reading this book. The cover alone gives this the necessary edge of perfection with the beautiful colors and adorable dogs. This series just keeps getting better.
Thank you to the author for this ARC. I am leaving this review voluntarily.
August 13, 2025
Lost at sea!
When Harlan Shepherd and his friend, artist Sebastian Alexander, disappear during a sailing regatta, the Shepherd family hopes for the best and fears the worst. Savanna and her sisters join ranks to support their mother and search for their father. Savanna is authenticating Sebastian’s paintings for an upcoming event. When his assistant is found dead, she begins searching for links between his death and the disappearance. Secrets and family turmoil are revealed as danger mounts.
This is an intriguing mystery. I like how the story entangles the disappearance with the Shepherd family drama. I received a free copy, but my review is honest and voluntary.
When Harlan Shepherd and his friend, artist Sebastian Alexander, disappear during a sailing regatta, the Shepherd family hopes for the best and fears the worst. Savanna and her sisters join ranks to support their mother and search for their father. Savanna is authenticating Sebastian’s paintings for an upcoming event. When his assistant is found dead, she begins searching for links between his death and the disappearance. Secrets and family turmoil are revealed as danger mounts.
This is an intriguing mystery. I like how the story entangles the disappearance with the Shepherd family drama. I received a free copy, but my review is honest and voluntary.
August 27, 2025
Is Sebastian still alive or was he murdered?
This is an exciting book filled with sailing and races and art. While billed as a standalone, I really feel I missed quite a bit by not having read the previous books in the Shepherd Sisters Mysteries series. It would have been helpful to have some background on the main characters. However, that being said, I did enjoy this story. The plot was tight, it was well-written and the characters are all engaging. Big bonus, there’s even a wedding in this one.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
This is an exciting book filled with sailing and races and art. While billed as a standalone, I really feel I missed quite a bit by not having read the previous books in the Shepherd Sisters Mysteries series. It would have been helpful to have some background on the main characters. However, that being said, I did enjoy this story. The plot was tight, it was well-written and the characters are all engaging. Big bonus, there’s even a wedding in this one.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
August 5, 2025
A fast-paced cozy mystery.
While Savanna, an art authenticator, is busy preparing for a friend’s art show and her sister’s wedding. Savanna’s father and his best friend turn up missing during a sailing regatta. Soon after that, she stumbles upon a dead body, her artist friend’s assistant. Savanna will do everything possible to solve the crimes. While reading this book (and the rest of the series) I struggled finding a stopping point. The books are that good. This is a fast paced and I predictable story.
While Savanna, an art authenticator, is busy preparing for a friend’s art show and her sister’s wedding. Savanna’s father and his best friend turn up missing during a sailing regatta. Soon after that, she stumbles upon a dead body, her artist friend’s assistant. Savanna will do everything possible to solve the crimes. While reading this book (and the rest of the series) I struggled finding a stopping point. The books are that good. This is a fast paced and I predictable story.
September 5, 2025
This is the fourth book in the series and deals with Savannah in the middle of everything going on with missing artists, injured father, sisters having their own issues; keeping Savannah hopping from one thing to another. I love all the tie-ins from the family and the hundreds of things always going on there, along with the mystery and it makes it seem more real. Very good series so I'm going to have to check out any other books this author has written!.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
August 27, 2025
The books in this series just keep getting better and better. They can all be read standalone, but you will want to read them all. Wonderful characters that feel like you know them, family dogs, and mysteries make this just a wonderful read. This one will keep you on the edge of your seat until the end. So many surprises along the way. Great to read.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
September 15, 2025
Savanna and her 2 sisters are busy. Savanna is spending her fall teaching and preparing for a major art exhibition. Sydney is finishing the final plans for her wedding. Skylar-well we’re not really sure what is going on with Skylar’s family. Harlan and Sebastian are going on an overnight sailing regatta. Unfortunately the yacht disappears along with the two men. This is another enjoyable read in this series.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 40 reviews