Intriguing noir that is fighting for its own voice
Mixed Bag, the first collection of short stories by Tajammul Kothari, does indeed have a lot of different treats within its covers, from morality tales for the young to the most noirish mix of chancers, small-time crooks, crime bosses and double-crossing dames.
It starts on a touching story for kids, The Video Game, where a young boy learns to do the right thing at the cost of something he though he could not live without, the latest video game. After that, the characters get older, from high school swimming rivals to business schemers, and the tone gets darker, reminiscent of the Hollywood noir of crooks and hard-nosed ladies, and shady dealings and mixed identities at every turn.
Kothari has a good eye for pace, and his stories keep the reader engaged, though some of the plot twists do come out of nowhere. The settings are also sometimes too generically American to give the stories much flavour – I feel like Kothari is missing the chance to inject something of himself, perhaps something that would make them distinctive. After all, we’ve got Outback noir, disturbed lives in picture-perfect Australian country towns, and Kiwi noir, many of the books that come from my own country, Aotearoa New Zealand. Perhaps Kothari could be the one who gives us Bahrain noir and lifts the lid on strange goings on in his idyllic land?
Another intriguing aspect is the supernatural: two stories, The Resurrection, and Retribution, centre around ghostly possession and how spirits can get their just desserts from beyond the grave. These were the most satisfying of the stories, because of the feeling of wrongs being righted, even after death. There is also a strong sense of morality and the cost of keeping promises to the dead, that makes stories like The Guardian stand out: the burden of selfless love and responsibility stays with you after you’ve finished reading.
I look forward to more from this author, and hope he stays closer to home with his next collection: I’d like to see how hard-boiled anti-heroes transported to a more real setting.
I received a free copy of this book, in exchange for an honest review.