Most companies fail to get the best out of “their” employees, making mistake after mistake along the way and possibly compounding issues by pretending to care. Sometimes they even do care, in their own special way, yet their behaviour is so clumsy and formulaic that it is working against itself.
This book looks at the apparent breakdown of the social contract between employees and employers. Many companies have fine words about how their people are “their greatest assets” and the author correctly notes that the rot has already set in with weasel words and patronising statements. You own assets. People are not assets or mere chattels for companies to buy, sell and exploit, wrapped up in meaningless, potentially offensive terms such as “human resources”, “human capital” or “full-time equivalents (FTEs)”.
Reading this book can make you angry, angry at how many companies don’t really treat their employees well. Those who sugar-coat their comments, peppering in words about partners, colleagues, co-workers or throwing in mere trinkets to the “compensation and workplace mix” - that are tax-deductible anyway - can feel as it is rubbing salt into the wound. “Polishing a turd,” as a slightly off-colour British English phrase may call it.
This was an enjoyable, focussed and gripping read yet a book like this shouldn’t be necessary if companies just got it. Take this extract from the book, which is something that should be printed out as a large poster and stuck liberally throughout the executive suite and a luminous copy within “human resources”: “Your people are not your greatest asset. They're not yours and they're not assets. Assets are property. You don't own your people. Many of them don't trust you. Some don't like you. Too many won't stick it out with you. And the ones you need most have the credentials to walk out fastest if you treat them poorly.”
Ah… but companies have carried out surveys, they engage their employees, they listen to the pulse of their resources and produce glowing statistics that would make a former political statistician in the USSR blush at their optimism. “We are all one big family, working together to a common goal,” they may cry (forgetting the little star and footnote that says “subject to shareholder and management whim or when dysfunctional management has a temper tantrum and makes an example of someone”).
Of course, not all employees are good. Many are bone idle, uncooperative and destructive. They are “as much use as a one-legged man in an arse kicking contest”, yet most employees actually do want to do a good job, no matter how high or low they are in an organisation. They want a fair day’s pay for a fair day’s work, be treated with respect and encouraged to develop. Most people know and understand that they can’t all be a CEO or sit on the top table, enjoying the financial benefits that these positions can bring. They can do their job though, playing their part.
Maybe some of the damage is self-inflicted out of a general, genuine fear of doing wrong. The cynic may say it is more fear of a lawsuit or bad press. If everyone is treated equally and fairly there wouldn’t be a problem. The author notes: “(this problem) is most painfully apparent when large firms pursue the admirable goal of eliminating racial and sexual discrimination. They count widgets by whether they are Latino, African American, Asian, or Native American; male or female; young or old. They become adept at categorisation rather than individualisation.”
Whether the companies who need to change the most would “get” this book is debatable. Many are too entrenched in their poor ways, buoyed by a faltering economy where people are often glad to have any job – yet when the good times start to roll again, maybe some companies will “reap what they sow”. Mind you, by then, they will be the first to start whinging about the difficulties in recruiting and retaining staff.
Widgets, written by Rodd Wagner and published by McGraw-Hill Professional. ISBN 9780071847780, 256 pages. YYYY