I have had a number of customers request one or another SEAGULL READER. Finally, I noticed that the store was returning THE SEAGULL READER: STORIES. Thinking this was a shame, I decided to buy one. I'm glad I did. It is what it says it is: An anthology "lightly supplemented by editorial apparatus."
These are pretty famous stories, but the introduction, biographical sketches and glossary are unique in that they are to-the-point, informative and, somehow, fresh. His introduction concludes with a little arrow-pointing. He wants us to read Frank O'Connor's "Guests of the Nation." I read it today. I defy you not to be moved by it. Kelly has also included a masterful story by that other O'Connor whose first name begins with "F." It is one of the most memorable stories in all literature.
W. W. Norton publishes THE SEAGULL READER series. I think there's some idea at Norton that textbooks the size of the Manhattan phone book, with pages as thin as butterfly wings, are a bit forbidding. THE SEAGULL READER has thin pages, but they're no thicker than a composition notebook. The covers are, indeed, designed to look like composition notebooks. These are marketed toward students. When I was a student, Norton Anthologies were not only huge, they featured covers by Edward Hopper. Maybe the Hopper Estate is beginning to charge? So, Norton's gone thrifty. One thing, though. Norton should stop shrink-wrapping these. Let the people shopping at Barnes and Noble have a peek inside. READER is in the title, after all.