The Daughter of Shiloh

Enduring Hope #3

by Terri J. Haynes

A Stampede Tramples Hopes
 
Collect a series of six historical romances. When life seems weighed down by challenges, there are always pillars of enduring hope and love to be discovered.
 
Lealie Bevard, a determined Tuskegee Institute student, attends the Shiloh Baptist Church convention in Birmingham on September 19, 1902, to request a scholarship for continued education at Harvard. But a beautiful gathering turns tragic when a stampede breaks out and Lealie is injured. While convalescing at the home of fellow Tuskegee student Milton Rafferty, Lealie’s concerns for her future are set aside to help Milton uncover a mystery revolving around missing church funds and a possible murder. Perhaps a pause in Lealie’s well-laid plans can be used for good. . .and lead to love.
 
Other books in the Enduring Hope series
The Angel of Second Street by Barbara Tifft Blakey
The Undercover Heiress of Brockton by Kelly Goshorn
 

Genres: Historical Fiction, Historical, Inspirational, Romance, Christian, Christian Romance, Christian Historical Fiction

258 pages, Kindle Edition

First published October 1, 2025

About the author

Terri J. Haynes, a native Baltimorean, is a mom, prolific knitter, freelance graphic artist, and former Army wife (left the Army, not the husband). She is also the owner of AT Haynes House Yarns, a hand-dyed yarn business. She loves to read, so much that when she was in elementary school, she masterminded a plan to be locked in a public library armed with only a flashlight to read all the books and a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. As she grew, her love for writing grew as she tried her hand at poetry, articles, speeches, and fiction. She is a storyteller at heart. Her passion is to draw readers into the story world she has created and to bring laughter and joy to their lives.

Terri holds a Bachelor's Degree in Theology, a Master's degree in Theological Studies and a certificate in creative writing and graphic design.
Terri serves on Project Knitwell’s board of directors and is the chairwoman of DMV Fiber Friends. She lives in Fort Washington, MD, just outside Washington, DC with her husband and three adult children.

Visit her website, terrijhaynes.com.

Reviews

[Katja Labonté · Rating 4 out of 5]

4 stars. I didn't know what to expect from this novel, mainly because I didn't read the blurb. I know, I know. But I saw it was about Tuskegee and immediately requested it on Netgalley, because Booker T. Washington is my hero. He actually figures more than I expected, which was a pleasant surprise! I also appreciated getting to see his philosophy vs. W.E.B. DuBois's, and all that discussion, through the MCs.

I never got very close to Milton & Lealie, but I respected them, and enjoyed watching the enemies-to-lovers arc. I also really appreciate how both were emotionally & physically wounded in the stampede, and how anxiety, panic attacks, claustrophobia, etc., were approached. I felt like the villain was a bit of a cardboard cut-out, but I liked how that kept me from getting too freaked out by the suspense.

I enjoyed the mystery addition to the storyline, but mostly I appreciated getting to discover the Shiloh Baptist Church tragedy, which I never heard about before. And I really liked the theme of giving, healing, and handling bad reputations that people impute to you.

*I received a complimentary copy of this book for promotional purposes. I was not required to write a positive review. These are my honest thoughts and opinions.*

[linda hole · Rating 4 out of 5]

i read historical fiction first of all to be entertained, but also to know about the uknown disasters. accidents. and this was that kind of book, i learnt so much from it. thank you to netgalley for letting me read this e arc in exchange for an honest opinion

[aria ✧ · Rating 4 out of 5]

(thank you barbour publishing and netgalley for the arc in exchange for an honest review)

Joy comes, grief goes, we know not how;
Everything is happy now,
Everything is upward striving;
'Tis as easy now for the heart to be true
As for grass to be green or skies to be blue,

“Daughter of Shiloh” is the third title in the Enduring Hope series, a collection of standalone historical fiction novels. I was quick to request this as I am forever in the lookout for historical fiction books with black main characters. Add that it is Christian as well, and I was sold.

Lealia Bevard dreams of going to Howard (the summary says Harvard but the arc says Howard) University. She’s worked tirelessly at Tuskegee Institute to better her education, all with the hopes of easing her parents’ burdens. Members of the Shiloh Baptist Church have been kindly sponsoring her stay at the Institute but when she’s called back at Shiloh for a convention, to interview for a possible scholarship to Howard University, she’s overjoyed.

Milton Rafferty has been studying to be a nurse at Tuskegee Institute. He’s top of his class and dreams of becoming a doctor. He wants to help his community but mainly, he wants to move his mother away from the Shiloh community. Circumstances find him going back home to the community that hurt his family in the company of Lealia Bevard, someone he can’t help but feel drawn to.

‘Tis the natural way of living:
Who knows whither the clouds have fled?
In the unscarred heaven they leave no wake,
And the eyes forget the tears they have shed,
The heart forgets its sorrow and ache;
The soul partakes the season's youth,

The gathering, meant to be a moment of joy for the community, turns deadly when a stampede breaks out. The victims are numerous, some injured while others are found dead. Among the injured is Lealia, and she must now stay in Birmingham to heal. Still, she just can’t sit around while others are suffering. Once given the go-ahead from the doctor, she and Milton team up to help however they can— which leads to them getting involved in a mystery surrounding missing church funds and a possible murder.

This was a good time. There were some things that bothered me (how the scholarship situation resolved) but everything else that I loved made up for it (I adored the mental health rep). My first book by this author and I will definitely check out her others.

And the sulphurous rifts of passion and woe
Lie deep 'neath a silence pure and smooth,
Like burnt-out craters healed with snow.
What wonder if Sir Launfal now
Remembered the keeping of his vow?

[Melissa (christianbooksandcoffee) · Rating 5 out of 5]

This was my first read by this author and I absolutely loved it! I loved the writing style and the storytelling. Lealie and Milton are great characters. They both go back to Shiloh when tragedy strikes. Milton is scarred by it but does everything he can to help the town. Lealie is injured but also does what she can to help. I liked that even though they didn’t get off on the best foot in their relationship they were able to work together and of course find love. There is a sinister plot going on with a bad guy which was a great addition to the story. I also thought it was cool that Booker T. Washington was part of the story. Good Christian content. Overall, I really enjoyed this story and I definitely recommend!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Content: death, murder, stampede

I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from the author. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.

[DevotedToHope · Rating 4 out of 5]

Terri J. Haynes writes with a unique steadiness that never hides the depth of pain, despair, or ache. Every scene moves with quiet honesty, tracing how suffering and purpose can breathe within the same moment. The story holds people who keep showing up for one another even when it costs them, and that faithfulness becomes its own kind of redemption.

One of my favorite quotes from this story: “In his mind, he saw himself in the sanctuary that night, nearing his breaking point and feeling strength pour into him. Over and over again he had thought he had no more to give but then found a little more. Enough to help one more person. Again and again. God.”

That single passage carries the heartbeat of this book. Pain hurts. Agony steals our breath away. Yet God. Yet God.

This story honors perseverance, the daily kind that shows up with open hands and a willing heart. It holds the truth that love, service, and faith still matter infinitely.

Perfect for readers who value historical fiction that reflects purpose and God’s strength through those who surrender completely to Him.

I received a digital ARC of this book from the author and Celebrate Lit Publicity Group. I am not required to write a positive review nor paid to do so. This is my honest and unbiased review. My thoughts and opinions expressed in this book review are my own. My review focuses on the writing and story’s content, ensuring transparency and reliability.

[Sydney Schmied · Rating 5 out of 5]

The Daughter of Shiloh by Terri J. Haynes is a five-star read! Milton and Lealia were such vivid, relatable characters, and I loved watching their relationship and faith grow through the story. The ending was so sweet and really made the perfect closing scene for a story with such tragic history.
The book wove in the tragic history of the Shiloh stampede with grace and a tender heart. I didn’t know much about the history when I first began reading, but Haynes clearly did her research and handled it with so much care. It was written with respect, and it added weight and depth that made the story all the more powerful. This book had everything I enjoy in historical fiction: strong characters, a fascinating time period, real historical events, and a faith thread that felt genuine. It was touching in so many ways, with a little heartbreak and a little hope.
If you like historical fiction with romance, faith, and a well-researched backdrop, I highly recommend The Daughter of Shiloh. It’s one of those stories that lingers with you after you finish reading.
I received an early copy from NetGalley.

[Lisa M. · Rating 4 out of 5]

The Daughter of Shiloh is the next book in the Enduring Hope series. This series consists of several stand alone novels written by different authors. Each book focuses on a strong female/male character who made a difference and offered hope.

This installment is by the most excellent author Terri J. Haynes. She brings a lovely tale of two Tuskegee students who return to Birmingham and are caught in the middle of the horrible Shiloh Baptist Church stampede. Each of them deals with different aspects of the disaster: Lealie is forced to realize that her plans are not God's plans and she is in a waiting period as she tries to figure out what her future is going to look like. Milton is forced to come back to the town and church that rejected him based on his father's reputation years ago--and deal with having to take care of some of the very people who rejected him after the disaster. Both have to figure out what God is desiring for them.

Topics: panic attacks

I appreciated also learning a bit more about the difference in Booker T Washington's future for the Black community and WEB Dubois's vision during that time period.

4 STars

*Thank you to NetGAlley and the publishers for my ARC of this novel. All opinions are 100% my own.

[Tiffany Little · Rating 5 out of 5]

I enjoyed this book The Daughter of Shiloh very much. It tells the story of Leala Bevard and Milton Rafferty two college students from Tuskegee attend The Shiloh Baptist Church convention. Unfortunately, tragedy strikes during service at the convention. It causes Leala and Milton to examen what is important to their futures. Along the way they work to solve the mystery of a murder and other encounters. I really enjoyed their journey as the book went on with Leala and Milton. It is a lovely novel that weaves in historical characters, healing, strength and forgiveness with a touch of romance.

P.S. I read this book through NetGalley

[Parkland Mom · Rating 4 out of 5]

4.25 stars
Completed: Oct. 05th

Series: Enduring Hope, #3 (a collection by various authors, related by theme)
Format: e-ARC

Book #126 of 2025: This was my second book by this talented author. I was not familiar with the human stampede at Shiloh Baptist Church in Birmingham before this book.

I really appreciated the lead characters, Lealie and Milton. Both are ambitious, hard-working, family-oriented people. They are brought together on a trip with the Tuskegee Institute. Both are caught up in the stampede when people believed there was a fire. The depiction of the horror and fear of the stampede, as well as the difficult and challenging effects after, were very well done.

Lealie's scholarship hopes to attend Howard and Milton's past history with the Shiloh church make for interesting springboards into everything that happens next. Both work tirelessly to help with the aftermath of the stampede. They come across peculiar incidences, suspicions, and some mystery while also dealing with their own personal struggles and doubts. They find themselves drawn together in a romantic way on top of everything else. Lealie and Milton both grow to learn more about themselves and each other. Circumstances are such that it appears their futures could be adversely affected. Both also do not see a way for them to have a future together.

I also enjoyed several of the other characters in this book. The generosity of the church with the scholarships is incredible. Then there was the generosity from others toward the church after the devastation.

How people came together after such a tragedy was heartwarming to read, even in the face of all the struggles. I was immersed throughout the story and was encouraged by the strength of the human spirit, as given by God. The book collection theme of "enduring hope" is very apparent in this story.

*** My sincerest thanks to the publisher and Net Galley for providing me with an advanced reader copy of this book. My review is voluntary and completely my own.

[tre be · Rating 4 out of 5]

Daughter of Shiloh was such a richly coveted faith-based historical fiction that was both enlightening, and endearing. It was a fictional account of the September 19, 1902 stampede that occurred at the Shiloh Baptist Church in Birmingham, Alabama resulting in the deaths of 115. At the time of the crush, 3,000 people were gathered to hear Booker T. Washington address the National Convention of Negro Baptists.

I'd never heard about this devastating history, but I was quite intrigued to learn about it through the lens of these two fictional characters Lealia and Milton. These two were students at the Tuskegee Institute and were going to Birmingham to hear the speech, ask for scholarships to further their education, and/or to revisit their past. The stampede was brutal, and the fallout was so disheartening. 

Just imagine the toll of seeing so much death can bring a person?! Lealia suffered physically and Milton suffered mentally. But in the midst of suffering the two bonded and became closer, forging a beautiful new beginning.

I loved that this book was so compelling and had so much to offer - there was sadness, malice, and love. Yet, still, hope for a rainbow in the storm. 

Great, quick, beautiful and encompassing read that I would recommend for all!

[Mary Hake · Rating 4 out of 5]

This novel reads like authentic history (1902), and you feel like you’re right in the scenes with the credible characters living and suffering and hoping and thrown by surprising circumstances. The author based the dramatic story on an actual event and includes real people like Booker T. Washington and George Washington Carver, but incorporates fictional elements to flesh out the moving tale. The book also offers a clear perspective from the Black point of view, not told in a condescending or biased manner, and evokes understanding and sympathy for their plight. I admire the work ethic and character of the main characters. There is also surprising twists and some suspense within the heart-tugging story, with missing money and a murder. Most of all, this is an account of recovering from terrific events and serious injuries, both physical and mental. Come along with Milton and Lealia for an experience like none you’ve explored before. I received a copy from the publisher through NetGalley. All opinions are my own. #TheDaughterofShiloh #NetGalley

[Katie Tucker · Rating 4 out of 5]

I didn’t know what to expect from this book. My book club pick. It was very slow but interesting. It tells of a historical time in Birmingham Alabama about the stampede at the church of Shiloh. Milton was from Birmingham and his family went to Shiloh his father had been accused of starting a fire and his father ran away leaving Milton and his mother. His mother sent him to attend college in Tuskegee Alabama. He meets Lelia and they were chosen to attend the Baptist’s convention at Shiloh. While they attended the convention there was a fight that broke out and everyone thought it was a fire poor Milton thought of his father and what happened next was a lot more. The stampede hurt both Milton and Lelia. Life has a strange way of showing up this book had me thinking and looking back over my life and all the things I have been through I’m grateful and thankful.

[Wendy Andrus · Rating 5 out of 5]

My favorite kind of historical fiction is that based on true events. The Daughter of Shiloh is one such story, based on the tragic stampede at an African-American church in Birmingham, Alabama in September, 1902.

I like both Laelia and Milton, students of Tuskegee Institute. They're likable and relatable, and both suffer from PTSD after having experienced the Shiloh church stampede. Watching the growth of their faith after the tragedy is inspiring, and the growth of their friendship with each other is sweet.

If you enjoy Christian historical fiction based on true events, then I urge you to add this to your TBR list.

I received a complimentary copy. These opinions are my own.

[Emaleigh Nichelle · Rating 4 out of 5]

A little mystery, a little romance , a little history, a little crime. This book has everything. I enjoyed this book and all of its characters. I recommend this especially if you enjoy historical fiction.

[Sarah · Rating 5 out of 5]

Intriguing mystery with purpose

The story drew me in from the moment I opened it up. characters who were well written but also with history behind it.

[Courtney Pityer · Rating 5 out of 5]

The Daughter of Shiloh is the third book in the Enduring Hope series each book written by a different author. I've read the other two and they were really good. I will say that I was very impressed with this one as well. The author did an amazing job with all her research. I enjoyed it because our main heroine refused to give up even when it seemed like all hope was lost. However she persevered and managed to pull herself through.
We are introduced to Lealie Bevard who is a student at the Tuskegee Institute. She decides to go to a convention at the Shiloh Baptist Church in hope that she can obtain a scholarship to further her education at Harvard. Everything seems to go well until a stampede breaks out and Lealie ends up injured but is thankfully alright.
While recovering at the home of Milton Rafferty who is also a student. With her downtime she decides to look into some of the secrets of the church such as the missing funds. Eventually it becomes something much morw sinister. Will they be able to resolve the situation without falling victim to an attack?
I received an arc copy from Netgalley and all opinions are of my own.

[Maggie Boyd · Rating 5 out of 5]

Love born of tragedy is a common theme in romance. Terri J. Haynes’ The Daughter of Shiloh is an excellent example of this plot, examining the aftermath of a calamity and bringing to light a little-known piece of history.

Lealie Bevard is the crown princess of Shiloh Baptist Chruch in Birmingham, Alabama. A beautiful, passionate, and hard-working young woman, she was sent to the Tuskegee Institute on a scholarship from the church to train under Booker T. Washington. But Lealie has a secret. While she has loved her time at Tuskegee and excelled there, that is not where she believes her future lies. Mr. Washington is focused on upward mobility through outstanding labor. His students are trained in various industries, including carpentry, animal husbandry, nursing, and accounting. W.E.B. Du Bois, an educator in Boston, believes a classical education – the kind received at white universities – will “lead the race from poverty and ignorance.” Lealie admires what Mr. Washington is accomplishing, but her longing is to join her brother and others who are following Mr. Du Bois’ path at Howard University.

Determined to make her dream come true, Lealie plans to request a new scholarship when she attends the Negro Baptist Convention (NBC) being hosted by Shiloh. She’s so confident she’ll receive it that she cancels her fall semester schedule at Tuskegee and brags to her fellow students about her brilliant future. They mock her pride rather than offer congratulations or prayers for success.

Milton Rafferty has nothing but bad memories of Birmingham and has no intention of ever returning to Shiloh Baptist. Due to an incident between his father and the church, Milton has long been considered a black sheep in the congregation. His mother had to work two jobs to put him through Tuskegee, while other kids from the parish were offered scholarships. It’s therefore quite awkward when Mr. Washington insists that Milton join him in attending the NBC. Milton very reluctantly agrees, determined to have the bare minimum involvement with the church and spend all his free time with his mother, who still lives in the area.

When Lealie approaches Milton, he’s surprised. He only knows her in passing from around campus. However, Lealie needs his help. She hasn’t secured a place to stay and is wondering if he knows anyone in the congregation of Shiloh who would be willing to provide room and board for the small amount she can afford to pay. He connects her with a friend of his mother’s.

That would have been the end of their contact, but on September 19, 1902, when both are in attendance at the convention to hear Booker T. Washington speak, a tragedy occurs. Someone screams, shouting a word that sounds like fire, and people swarm toward the exit, causing a stampede. Lealie is caught at the center of a writhing mass of bodies, forced to the bottom of a pile of people. She can feel a painful twist take place in her ankle, a bump to the head, and then shortness of breath. Milton is more fortunate; strong and tall, he is able to help others to safety and is among those who rescue Laelie. With a rather severe concussion and no kindred in town to care for her, Milton and his mother make the decision to take Laelie home with them and slowly nurse her back to health. She’s among the fortunate. Many died of suffocation, smothered and crushed beneath those trying to avoid the non-existent fire that caused them to flee the church.

Once Laelie is back on her feet, she and Milton set aside plans to return to Tuskegee and agree to help at Shiloh until the injured have all been taken care of and the church is up and running again. Milton, just a few semesters from graduating from nursing school, helps the sick while Laelie, who excels in management, assists with accounting and handling the donations that come from all over the country to cover the expenses resulting from the tragedy. As they do their best to help Shiloh get back on its feet, they slowly grow closer, and Laelie starts to wonder if the path she first thought was right is in fact the one God wants her to take.

This is a charming Inspirational romance focusing on a terrific hero and heroine. https://allaboutromance.com/book-revi...

[Deana Dick · Rating 5 out of 5]

It is so interesting to read a fiction book that includes historical facts. I have never heard of The Shiloh Baptist Church stampede until I picked up this story. I appreciate how the author delivers an accurate account of this event while giving us realistic characters. I was excited to delve into the book and see where the author would take readers on this adventure mixed with tragedy, mystery and a bit of faith.

I recognized the name Booker T. Washington right away. Where I live we have a school named after this historic figure. He is known for several things such as founding the Tuskegee Institute for vocation and academics for African Americans. The story captures this person with confidence and compassion. The author introduces us to Lealia and her adventure that shapes this incredible story.

Lealia has worked very hard in her academics. It has not been easy but with her parents working hard and contributions from The Shiloh Church she is well on her way towards her dream. Now she has this plan to attend Harvard with the help of a scholarship from The Shiloh Baptist Church convention. All her dreams are waiting for her in Birmingham, Alabama on a day in 1902. She was not prepared for what was about to happen on this fateful day.

Milton is an intriguing character who made me think of him as a remarkably smart person. He makes excellent grades and strives to become known in the medical field. He doesn’t seem interested in going to see Mr. Washington at the convention like others are. There is something about going back to Birmingham he is trying to hide. I like the back story of Milton’s father which helped me understand his bitterness. Will he be able to let go of the past and find a way to forgive? When I discovered what Milton’s father had done, it broke my heart. No wonder Milton didn’t want to return home. He has carried his father’s sin all this time. Will he find a way to forgive and let his heart soften towards others?

This a very emotional story that not only shows us the struggles people faced during this time but reminds us how not letting go can have a lasting effect on you. After I finished the book, I decided to do more research on the tragic event from the story. I pray that readers will take time to study this historical event and strive to listen to our call on our life. We need to also remember that God has a plan for each of us. It may not be what we wanted, but God will place you where you are called to.

I received a copy of this book from Celebrate Lit. The review is my own opinion.

[Crystal · Rating 4 out of 5]

ARC Review
📚 Book Title: The Daughter of Shiloh
✍🏽Author: Terri J. Haynes

Format: eARC = 📱

⭐️ Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️


🕑Quick Take:
It's 1902, and Lealia Bevard is an admired student at Tuskegee Institute, aspiring to attend Howard University for further studies. Milton Rafferty, a fellow student at Tuskegee, is an advanced nursing trainee with plans to continue his education to become a doctor. Although Lealia and Milton were once childhood friends, the church perceives her as the "daughter of Shiloah" and him as a potential source of trouble.

The two attend the Shiloh Baptist Church convention in Birmingham to hear a lecture by Booker T. Washington and partner in caring for the injured following the historical stampede.

💕What I Loved:
In this historical fiction novel, we delve into the experiences of victims of the stampede that occurred on September 19, 1902, at the Shiloh Baptist Church in Birmingham, Alabama. The story also highlights the contrasting views of W.E.B. Du Bois’s concept of the “Talented Tenth,” which advocated for higher education to uplift the image of African Americans, and Booker T. Washington’s emphasis on industrial and vocational training. Additionally, the novel offers a glimpse into a budding romance between Lealia and Milton.

Themes:
- Historical Fiction
- Christian Fiction
- Elements of Slow Burn Romance
- Hope Against Odds

⚠️ Heads Up (Content Warning):
- Manmade Disaster/Crisis
- Physical Injury
- Mental Health Rep: Panic Attacks

💭Final Thoughts:
The Daughter of Shiloh is a beautifully written historical fiction novel that delves into the experiences of African Americans as they navigate education, personal growth, and the journey of coming of age. The story is engaging and includes elements of mystery and church drama. I thoroughly enjoyed this novel.

Thanks to Net Galley and Barbour Fiction for this advanced reader’s copy.

#TheDaughterOfShiloh #TerriJHaynes #ARCReview #NetGalley #BarbourFiction #bookstagram #ChristianFiction #HistoricalFiction #ChrysieZReads

[Cindy]

Tuskogee is a wonderful school and she’s learned so much there, but Lealie wants more. As a young black woman in the South in 1902, Lealie has dreams of becoming successful and moving her hard-working parents off their small sharecropper farm. But opportunities are scarce for girls like her. It all depends on the elusive scholarship to Howard College she has applied for. When the letter arrives saying the scholarship committee wants to meet with her in Birmingham, Lealie packs up her belongings and leaves Tuskogee, sure her dreams are all coming to fruition.
Milton, hopes to be a doctor and Tuskogee is providing him the basis for that education. His mother works hard to pay his way but she is alone and in Birmingham, the town Milton never wants to return to because of all the difficult memories it holds for him. When his teacher requests his presence in Birmingham for the Baptist Convention, Milton must return to the city and the very church that despised his family and sent him away in disgrace.
Tragedy strikes at the Shiloh Baptist Church during the convention and a stampede of people trying to exit the building leaves many dead and injures more. Lealie and Milton experience injuries, though each of a different nature, and find themselves thrown together to navigate the aftermath of the disaster and do what they can to aid in recovery efforts.
The tragedy seems to rip the dreams of the future away from them and set them on different paths than they ever thought they would take. Can Lealie and Milton find their way through the maze of obstacles set before them and will they allow the romance budding between them to grow even though their paths lead them in different directions?
This is not only a lesson in Black history that we all need to learn about, but an account of a true event and a story of the redemption and love available to all who would seek their Heavenly Father and His plan for their lives.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review

[Jalynn Patterson · Rating 5 out of 5]

About the Book:

Collect a series of six historical romances. When life seems weighed down by challenges, there are always pillars of enduring hope and love to be discovered.

Lealie Bevard, a determined Tuskegee Institute student, attends the Shiloh Baptist Church convention in Birmingham on September 19, 1902, to request a scholarship for continued education at Harvard. But a beautiful gathering turns tragic when a stampede breaks out and Lealie is injured. While convalescing at the home of fellow Tuskegee student Milton Rafferty, Lealie’s concerns for her future are set aside to help Milton uncover a mystery revolving around missing church funds and a possible murder. Perhaps a pause in Lealie’s well-laid plans can be used for good and lead to love.

My Review:

First of all, if there is a historical fiction book or story sign me up!. Love history and this one ranks up there with the top choices. I am not sure I was ever aware of the stampede that took place and I don't feel much has been said or written about it. I have lived in Alabama my whole life and the only story about any churches here is the story about the bombing in 1963 so this story was very interesting to me.

Lealie is a very determined young lady that has set her sights high but they aren't unreachable in her eyes. Maybe in the community and those around her but not in her own. She attends a gathering where Booker T Washington will be a speaker to reach out to the community for help, in getting a scholarship to Harvard in order to continue her education.

While there Lealie is caught in the middle of a disaster that no one saw coming. A stampede ensues and several people are hurt and some killed. All from a misunderstanding on words. While very sad Lealie and new friend Milton discover there is a huge mystery to uncover that will require the two of them to put their heads together to find resolution.

A really good read for a crisp afternoon!

**Disclosure**This book was sent to me free of charge for my honest review from the publisher. All opinions are my own.

[Becky · Rating 5 out of 5]

PLEASE READ THIS ON MY BLOG: https://bookreadingtic.com/2025/10/28... AND PLEASE FOLLOW ME, THANK YOU

A Story That Grabs Your Heart and Doesn't Let Go

From the very first chapter, this story is a gripping and deeply moving experience. It centers on Lealia, a student trying to redirect her path from Tuskegee Institute to Howard University, and Milton, a compassionate classmate, whose lives are changed at the Shiloh Baptist Convention.

This narrative immediately thrusts you into a terrifying and traumatic church stampede where panic breaks out. The author places you right in the middle of the confusion, making you feel the heartbreak and urgency.

Milton's quick action saves the badly injured Lealia, along with many others. His subsequent week-long dedication to helping the injured, sets the stage for a relationship built on shared trauma, and deep respect. The depiction of Milton's hidden PTSD adds a layer of struggle that is well-handled.

As Milton and Lealia spend weeks healing and helping, their story changes into a compelling mystery, with two major threads: the shooting of a beloved store owner, and the puzzle of the missing money at Shiloh. The blend of emotional recovery, budding romance, and clue-finding is great. As they grow closer, the looming question of their future--Lealia's move, and Milton finishing his degree--creates a heartbreaking situation.

I particularly loved the integration the character's faith in response to the tragedy, and to life. This isn't just a romance or a mystery; it's a story about finding purpose, love, and light after the worst kind of darkness. Do not miss this book; it's a five-star read that will keep you captivated from the first page to the last.

Thanks to Barbour Books for providing Tickmenot with a book to review. Opinions are my own.

[Debbie · Rating 5 out of 5]

"The Daughter of Shiloh" is a romance set in Alabama in 1902. Lealie is smart, and her home church (Shiloh Baptist Church) has paid for her to go to the Negro technical college, Tuskegee Institute. She's studying to be a nurse, but she applies for a scholarship to get a classical education at another college and become a lawyer. Milton's studying to be a doctor at Tuskegee Institute and is asked to attend the Baptist Church convention as an example of an excellent Tuskegee student. He's reluctant because the members of Shiloh Baptist Church blame him for his father's possible involvement in the arson that destroyed their first church. Both Lealie and Milton are present when someone cries "Fire!" in the crowded sanctuary and a panicked crowd trampled many to death.

Based on a true event, Lealie and Milton had to deal with their physical and mental injuries from the tragedy. They used their nursing knowledge to help the other injured, and then Lealie used her accounting skills to help deal with the incoming donations for the injured...and to uncover that someone's stealing from the donations. But how to prove it?

The main characters were likable and felt like real people, reacting realistically to events. Vivid historical and setting details were woven into the story, creating a distinct sense of the time and place. Lealie and Milton supported each other and found healing. Lealie felt arrogantly confident of her bright future only to have that threatened by outside events. She came to realize that her plans were not God's plans. There was no sex or bad language. Overall, I'd recommend this interesting, well-written story.

I received a free ebook review copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley.

[Lori Parrish · Rating 5 out of 5]

Even though this book is sad because of the terrible disaster and especially at a church, I learned a great deal from this story. I did watch a you tube documentary about it.
This author has done her research very well and I loved that she made her characters heartfelt and realistic. Their emotions made me cry at the tragedy of the situation. But, I also rejoiced too. This story definitely offers hope as well.
I finished this one in one evening.
This story is about forgiving, truth and Redemption.
Love is at the center of this book. Love is what makes this story.
I truly enjoyed this book and now wished I had grabbed the other two.
Milton is truly one of my favorite characters. He's like me and has to learn things the hard way. I was sad for him but I kept rooting for him.
Lealie is a wonderful character as well. She is headstrong, stubborn and always wanting to do things her way and not God's. I think this is one of the many things that I loved about her. She too has to learn that her ways sometimes doesn't always go with God's.
The supporting characters were awesome too. I felt they each got their fair share of the story too.
I highly recommend this story. It does teach some life lessons in here.
I wish I could give this one more than 5 stars! It was so good! So 5 stars it is!! I'd reread it again when it's in print.
I wished this book.didnt have to end.
My thanks for a copy of this book. I was NOT required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are mine.

[Becky Lewis · Rating 5 out of 5]

“you are their beloved daughter, and I am their troublesome son.”- Milton

The Daughter of Shiloh by Terri J. Haynes is a story of conflict, opposing opinions, and people uniting to work together despite their differences. Herein lies the hope of a story that recounts years of prejudice, discrimination, and a true tragedy of that occurred in a Birmingham church. I was somewhat uncomfortable reading of some of the prejudice that I cannot correct. Yet the story needs told, and I was thankful that the characters looked beyond their problems ( not denying them) to find Hope in following Jesus.

Lealia Bevard is highly intelligent, beautiful, and does exceptionally well at Tuskegee. She is on the fast track for a scholarship to Howard. She believes this is her and her family’s path out of poverty. She agrees to accompany Booker T. Washington to the Baptist convention in Birmingham at her former home church, Shiloh Baptist Church, because there she will be awarded the scholarship. A wise friend tells her, “I know you have hopes of how things will go in Birmingham, but remember, God may have other plans. His ways are not our ways, you know.”
Not if Lealia has anything to do with said plans!

Milton Rafferty, our other key player, is also a product of Shiloh Baptist Church. But his is not a love story. A continuously drunk father, an ill-timed event, and wagging tongues conspire to make Milton and his mother pariahs. The same people who are blessing Lealia are cursing Milton. As Lealia slowly gets to know Milton, she begins to see what a rock-steady nurse and man of character he is, because of his faith. Lealia is attracted to Milton, even as he hides his secret from her, and she becomes more and more involved in Shiloh Baptist Church.

What will it take for Lealia to shake off her arrogance and personal ambition to align with God’s will? What will it take for the members of Shiloh to accept Milton back into their midst? Can Lealia and Milton work together to help a hurting community and keep a church from being decimated in a totally different way?

One of my fave characters is Milton’s mom. She sloughs off insults like water off a duck’s back. She understands that
“People who are afraid can sometimes act in very cruel ways.” Mrs. Rafferty still speaks kindly of the Shiloh people and treats them with respect. “You can’t change other people’s fears, Milton. But you can change yours.” (However, she also recognizes a quack!)

I received a copy of the book from Celebrate Lit. I also bought my own copy. No positive review was required, and all opinions are my own.

Notable Quotables:

“That’s why it’s called faith. Sometimes
you don’t know if something is going to work or if you’re going in the right direction. You have to trust that God has a bigger plan for you than where you are right now.” -Mrs. Rafferty

“The Talented Tenth will show the way to the future.” -DuBois

“Going back to Shiloh was going to hurt. He could feel it.” - Milton

[Donna C · Rating 5 out of 5]

What I think you should know:
The Daughter of Shiloh by Terri J. Haynes is a Christian Historical Fiction. This book is set in Birmingham, Alabama in September of 1902. This book follows Tuskegee Institute students Lealie Bevard and Milton Rafferty as they attend the Baptist Convention at Shiloh Baptist Church. This book is part of the Enduring Hope Series, but can be read as a standalone as these stories are not connected.

What you might need to know:
Lealie and Milton are caught in the stampede at Shiloh and have both physical and mental injuries as a result.

What I think about this book:
I was enraptured with Lealie and Milton, both had such different attitudes about returning to Shiloh. Lealie had nothing but fond memories and affection for her home church, while Milton was left with anger and bitterness towards the church he grew up in. It was very interesting to see Shiloh through both of their eyes. I also enjoyed learning about Tuskegee and Mr. Booker T Washington. I had learned about it from a professor when I was in college, however I didn't realize that it was such a controversial school during that time. I loved reading about the mystery surrounding the donations. I love all of the history that the author brought into the story. Bravo!! The author did a magnificent job of bringing history to life. I will definitely look for more of her works.

I received a complimentary copy of this book from Celebrate Lit, this in no way influenced my review. All opinions are my own.

[Luminous Reads · Rating 4 out of 5]

This is a story where hope and love endure, even in difficult times.

About the Book:
When Tuskegee Institute students Lealia Bevard and Milton Rafferty attend the Shiloh Baptist Church convention in Birmingham, they find themselves caught in a terrifying stampede that leaves them both injured and uncertain about the future. As they recover from their injuries, they become involved in a mystery involving missing church funds and a suspicious death. These events shake their world and lead them to seek answers, healing, and perhaps even find love amidst the turmoil.

My Thoughts:
I'm still reeling from this powerful story! The descriptions of the 1902 Shiloh Baptist Stampede tragedy were rich with historical and emotional detail.
Lealia and Milton are wonderful characters! I truly appreciated how Terri depicted Lealia suffering a physical injury and Milton enduring emotional and mental trauma, highlighting that both forms of injury are significant and deserving of care. The way their healing journeys and struggles with trauma are portrayed was very heartfelt and compassionate.

The mystery element kept me engaged till the end and the final chapters were so thrilling!

This book illustrates the power of hope and resilience in moving forward through tragedy and uncertainty, showing that even in the darkest times, love and faith can prevail.


I received a complimentary review copy of this book from the publisher. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

[Kendra Neal · Rating 5 out of 5]

Christian Historical Fiction is a favorite genre to read. The Daughter of Shiloh by Terri J. Haynes is Book 3 in the Enduring Hope series. The series is written by various Authors and can be read as Stand Alone Books.

WOW, this storyline really was very intriguing and had a very recognized Historical Figure as part of the story. The setting is 1902 in Birmingham, Alabama The main characters are Lealie Bevard, and Milton Rafferty,. Lealie and Milton are both students at Tuskegee Institute. Leslie is attending the Shiloh Baptist Church Convention as she is requesting a Scholarship that would allow her to continue with her education. Lealie is injured in a Stampede and her fellow student, Milton, opens his home for her to recover from her injury. The pair work together to solve a mystery of missing funds from a church and a mysterious death. The students then have to exam their own future plans for life. I really LOVE that Booker T. Washington is a part of this book. Booker T. Washington is an integral part of History and of this time period of the book. The book is one of realizing that God can show us that sometimes tragedy can bring us close to God and another. Also, that Gods plans are greater than our own. The Historical research done by the Author is outstanding. I felt like I was right there as the story unfolds. I would recommend this book to those who enjoy Christian Historical Fiction. AMAZING BOOK!

[Emma · Rating 4 out of 5]

The Daughter of Shiloh by Terri J. Haynes

Book 3 of Enduring Hope
A Stampede Tramples Hopes

Collect a series of six historical romances. When life seems weighed down by challenges, there are always pillars of enduring hope and love to be discovered.

Lealie Bevard, a determined Tuskegee Institute student, attends the Shiloh Baptist Church convention in Birmingham on September 19, 1902, to request a scholarship for continued education at Harvard. But a beautiful gathering turns tragic when a stampede breaks out and Lealie is injured. While convalescing at the home of fellow Tuskegee student Milton Rafferty, Lealie’s concerns for her future are set aside to help Milton uncover a mystery revolving around missing church funds and a possible murder. Perhaps a pause in Lealie’s well-laid plans can be used for good. . .and lead to love.
Lealie Bevard dreams of going to Howard University.
Milton Rafferty is studying to be a nurse at Tuskegee Institute.
Historical fiction with romance, faith, mystery and forgiveness.
I recommend this book.
The Daughter of Shiloh by Terri J. Haynes
is a 4 -star book.
I am looking forward to reading more books by Terri J. Haynes.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced readers copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions shared here in this review are my own.

[Rebecca · Rating 3 out of 5]

3.5 stars
"We applaud your discipline and desire to further your education. Your accomplishements alone were enough to grant you a scholarship, but now that we have met you in person . . . "

Lealia Bevard was on the precipice of achieving her life's goal, to attend Howard University through a coveted scholarship bestowed by the Shiloh Baptist Church Convention. She had already proven herself a good student during her tenure at Tuskegee Institute and was looking forward to her interview with the Education Board. Traveling to Birmingham alongside fellow Tuskegee student Milton Rafferty, she never anticipated experiencing an historic tragedy, one that changed the trajectory of her future along multiple dimensions.

Recovering from a slightly slow start, this story glides along several interesting pathways, Lealia's recovery and time to self-reflect, Milton's opportunity to face the demons of his past, their combined efforts to serve a grieving community, and an unexpected mystery that threatens their tenuous peace of mind. However, it is the ending that is nothing short of providential! All in all, a very nice combination of history, mystery, and romance.

I voluntarily reviewed a copy of this book through Barbour Publications.