Once, it was thought, a scandal was the kiss of death for a political career. Today, however, surviving scandal seems to be the norm. Donald Trump has weathered―and even perhaps benefited from―controversies that would have been unimaginable for virtually any other candidate. Prominent figures in both parties have won elections and remained in office despite credible allegations of wrongdoing. Do scandals still matter? When and why do voters punish politicians or give them a free pass?
Charting the changes from Watergate to the present, this book is a rigorous and compelling investigation of the politics of scandals. Bringing together wide-ranging survey data, innovative experiment design, and historical analysis, Brandon Rottinghaus demonstrates how political polarization, affective partisanship, fading trust in media, and the spread of misinformation have diminished the resonance of controversies. Although scandals still fell many politicians, there is a clear trend over time for fewer voters to be swayed by them. In a polarized world, scandals take only a modest toll on politicians’ approval ratings, survival in office, ambitions, and legacies. In many cases, partisans accept―or even embrace―misbehavior from members of their own party and revel in scandals affecting the opposing party. Challenging conventional wisdom with extensive data, this book illuminates the declining significance of scandals and the consequences for democratic accountability.
Scandal; why politicians survive scandals in a bipartisan era by Dr.Brandon roddinghouse, if you love gossip and politics then you’ll absolutely love this book called scandal. Although I thought there was a lot of minutia in the beginning it turned out to be a very entertaining absolutely by partisan book about scandals. Whether they were national statewide and even our representatives I don’t think Doctor Roddin house missed much when accounting for the wrong doers and gave a fair balance of everyone’s miss steps. there’s some who won’t like this book because it mainly deals and facts and historical documents that I do believe the independent fair thinker will love this walk down histories lane I don’t think he missed anything. A definite recommendation! #NetGalley, #TheBlindReviewer, #MyHonestReview,
Brandon Rottinghaus, Scandal Why Politicians Survive Controversy in a Partisan Era, Columbia University Press, November 2025.
Thank you, NetGalley, for this uncorrected proof for review.
I was interested in this book as a way of discovering what an academic approach to political scandal would be, the way in which various types of scandal would or could be measured and the public response to scandal. Rottinghaus has fulfilled my quest for information. However, I am left with a concern that in an era when the mainstream media appears to be numbing public response to egregious political behaviour, an academic work would risk doing so. There is certainly a role for a history of scandalising political behaviour – after all why not? A valid argument can be made that political life is not immune to the forces that impact other areas of society where scandalous behaviour occurs. I would have liked the work to have made it clear that political life and behaviour is not necessarily more prone to scandal than other areas of power. I would also have appreciated an approach that undermined the prevailing view that various examples of scandalous behaviour are equal. The moral imperative might be similar, but the outcomes for supporting and ensuring that a democratic society remains democratic are markedly different depending on the nature of the behaviour seen as scandalous.
The publication features polling data that contributes to understanding definitions of political scandal, factors affecting perceptions of aversion, and the impact of partisanship. By using Watergate as a point of reference, it compares observer attitudes toward historic and more recent political events. An updated edition addressing commutations and Presidential pardons could offer further insight by contrasting current practices with those of the past, and there are additional topics relevant to contemporary politics that may warrant academic study.
Overall, the book provides valuable analysis of political behaviours considered scandalous in the United States and documents varying levels of aversion among observers. It serves as an introduction to studying scandal and its effects, appropriately framing itself as a study of American political behaviour. Including a comparative chapter on political scandals in other democratic countries during a similar timeframe could enhance the analysis by demonstrating notable differences.