“Fifty Fifty” is the second book in new series co-written by Patterson and Fox, featuring Harriet (“Harry”) Blue, a volatile female detective in Australia. I read the first book last year and didn’t really care for it as much as I wanted to. The premise wasn’t bad, but the delivery was sub-par in my opinion.
The second outing starts off with Harriet’s brother, Sam Blue, who was previously arrested and charged with killing several women, preparing for his defense in court. Sam claims his innocent and is determined to clear his name. Harry is right there fighting the good fight with him at the risk of her law enforcement career. However, after another uncontrolled outburst of her temper, Harry is reassigned to a remote town (again like the last book) to investigate a diary recently discovered on the roadside hinting at a large-scale murder plan. Shortly after Harry’s arrival, a killing occurs, and the town goes into a frenzy, leaving her to try and figure out what’s coming next.
Meanwhile, back home another woman is taken captive, and the real serial killer is not happy to find out Sam has been arrested and given credit for his work. Harry has her partner, Detective Whitt, and Tox, a shadowy investigator with a tainted reputation and close friend, following up on the possibility of another killer. Patterson and Fox bounce back and forth between these two plot lines – Harry’s hunting down a small town rage filled bomber and the search for the true killer that holds the key to Sam’s freedom – building to two violent and explosive climaxes.
The book was an easy read with a typical fast paced Patterson style plot line, superficial characters (for the most part), and (in my mind) a killer that started out with appeared to be a rather weak motivation for his murderous actions. However, the plot surprisingly tightened up in the last third of the book pretty well, and by the end, both plots and bad-guy motivations were tied out in ways that actually made sense. And I am going to give a few points of respect for one unexpected surprise twist at the end that I did not see coming and it delivered well.
Another thing to mention is that although the overall plotting followed Patterson’s usual formula, the writing style itself really felt more like Candace Fox. It felt like she really owned it and made it her own. I read six or more Patterson novels a year, and this one more than other collaboration that I can remember, seemed to reflect the authentic style of the collaborator and was not washed down in typical Patterson structured format. On the other hand, the farther I got into the book, the more overly melodramatic her style became in some key moments. I found some of the prose to be way too over the top and it grated on my reading, but that may just be me.
Overall, although this book was better than the first one, it was still not one of Patterson's better books. There were a few moments of suspense (but not a lot), and (just like the first book) Harry took on more physical suffering than most humans can handle, walked right out of the hospital after sustaining serious injuries, and was still physically strong enough to battle with the bomber at the end.
My score is 2.5 stars out of 5 stars.
If you read it, I hope you enjoy it more than I did. I really do…