This was a nice book to listen to as I basically baked 1,000 cookies for a cookie exchange.
The narrator Mary Jane Wells -- man I love her voice.
The story it is a time travel where the heroine, Isabella, is a modern day lady who is at an 1800s re-enactment ball at an historic home courtesy of the museum where she works. During her present day ball she is mysteriously transported back to the same house during a ball in the 1800s.
I liked how this played out. Because everyone was in period dress during the present day ball and she only has a bit of wooziness during transport (which she chalks up to alcohol) Isabelle doesn't at first realize she's in a different time. She just believes the hard-core re-enactors have finally arrived. But her reactions where she starts to realize what happened, I thought were well done and ring true -- well as true as you could assume someone would act in the same situation.
Since this is a novel the worst that could happen to her, alone and bereft in a very strange place with no money and no one she knows, doesn't happen. She doesn't quite have the Clair Frasier experience. She happens to be the recipient of the kindness of strangers so she can get her bearings.
I did like how she outright convinced Ada, the young lady who comes to her rescue that she is from the future, courtesy of her cell phone that she still had handily on her person. So she is able to enlist Ada to her cause who also gives her a cover story, a place to stay and clothes. There is a bit of way too much convenience there, but I could hand-wave that for the sake of the story.
The rest of the story is Isabella trying to figure out a way to get back home while also falling in love with the hero, Phineas. And that morphs into the dilemma of how to reconcile the plot of who stays when?
There are some other subplots, mainly the hero is in his own revenge subplot that marginally dovetails with the time travel plot. For me the hero's plot was the weakest.
There are also imo, some rather contrived elements I felt that was piled on top to add obstacles to her getting back which I felt were unnecessary and just added extra ...stuff... to the plot.
But at the core this was a fun book with lots of humor. I did like Isabella's inner voice and her slips into modern colloquialisms and people's reactions to her speech patterns sometimes.
My biggest disappointment is toward the end I think Isabella turns a little uncharacteristically dumb. This is a woman who for all intents and purposes is trapped in a time when she has no relatives, no money, no means of support and she is supposedly a historian so she should be aware of the social issues she is facing, but decides to make a decision that is grounded too much in modern sensibility to make any sort of sense. She is supposed to be smarter than she comes off and I was very disappointed that it took someone else in the book to point that out to her, when she should have had enough sense to come to these conclusions herself. Also, I know this was a fairly light-hearted book, but there were places when I think Isabella could have benefited from a bit more panic about her situation.
Also there is an epilogue which, sigh, makes no sense but then you have the read the author's note to get an explanation for it. I get it, but really it opened more questions than it answered,
But like I said fun enough.