What do you think?
Rate this book
The House of Promise
Victor’s world shatters when he’s lifted from Ignaçio’s farm and shifted hundreds of miles away. Nuria’s alliance dissolves when Ignaçio quits flamenco, leaves home, and defies her animal-rights campaign. A historic corrida veers their trajectories, merges their paths, and rebuilds the symbolic taurine city.
About the author: Indrajit lives in Paris with his family. The House of Promise is his fifth work of fiction.
About the author: Indrajit lives in Paris with his family. The House of Promise is his fifth work of fiction.
524 pages, Kindle Edition
First published April 19, 2025
1 person is currently reading
26 people want to read
About the author
Indrajit Garai
14 books17 followers"Indrajit Garai, an American citizen now, was born in India in 1965. After his Bachelors degree from Indian Institute of Technology and Masters from Harvard, he worked as a corporate strategy consultant and as an investment banker in America, Spain, and England, while studying parallelly Ayurveda (ancient medicine of India) for stress management. In 2001, after the birth of his daughter, he moved to Paris, opened his private practice of stress management, and then authored six books in this field (five in French and one in English).
Authoring these books on stress management gave him a deep love for writing. Since 2015, he has devoted himself full-time to creating literature."
Authoring these books on stress management gave him a deep love for writing. Since 2015, he has devoted himself full-time to creating literature."
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 18 of 18 reviews
May 8, 2025
LOVE, HONOR, FRIENDSHIP, NATIONAL AND COMMUNITY PRIDE, BATTLES TO THE DEATH, THIS BOOK HAS IT ALL.
☆☆☆☆☆
LOVE, HONOR, FRIENDSHIP, NATIONAL AND COMMUNITY PRIDE, BATTLES TO THE DEATH, THIS BOOK HAS IT ALL.
Indrajit GARAI writes with a voice that is pure poetry on the pages. It is clear that he is not only knowledgeable on this subjects he writes about but is very passionate about the stories he chooses, the characters, and the events inwhich brings his stories to life and his book "The House of Promise" is about as passionate as you can get when it comes to the relationships between family and friends, man and the animals we share our lifes with, our community, and are country.
This tell is about an orphaned boy who is taken in by a loving and supportive neighboring family who raise bulls and struggle with lifes challenges to support themselves in a country in the midst of a recession with not much choice to survive unless you work in an industry that goes against your very morals and believes even if by doing so breaks down your soul and makes you into the very thing you hate.
Once you cross the line that takes a little bit of your soul each and every minute of your day, you not only become what you despise but you give away a part of yourself that leaves you thinking that you are no longer the person you want or thought you were but a person that is beyond the ability to correct your life choices and return to the road in your life you were supposed to and wanted to travel all along.
This book is full of action, suspense, loss and love, joy and sadness, right and wrong. The right and wrong are the hardest to determine which is which even when you believe with every cell in your body that you are doing what you are doing for all the right reasons.
The characters are brought to these pages in a way which are not only easy to relate to but leaves you feeling you know what is in their hearts and minds. Don't be surprised when you find yourself shocked when what you thought was coming and it was not what you expected.
This story is told through the eyes of a young man named Ignacio who is a lover of animals, an inspiring veterinarian, a graceful flamenco dancer, and a professional bullfighter, an orphaned Bull named Victor who is gentle as a butterfly, Nuria who is more than his older sister of his adopted family. She's his friend, protector, and his confidant.
This book takes into the thoughts and relationships between man and the animals around us. The struggle to provide for yourself and your families in a recession and a pandemic brought them and their community to its knees. The clashes between what you were taught and what you know in your heart what is right and what is just plain wrong and should not have ever been from the get-go.
This is one of those books that will touch you all the way down to your soul and leave you looking not only to your past but looking and striving to truly be the person you not only want to be in the future.
Though this story is a piece of fiction, I find the dialog and the described events something of what the characters were going through to be truthful and real. Their feelings and strength to deal with the events life through at them were something that was very believable. I have no prior knowledge of Spain other than the little bit of knowledge I was taught while in grade school. And I have no prior knowledge to bullfighting, and to be honest, I have little desire to educate myself anymore on the subject.
I have never taken a stand against animal cruelty and have never taken part in it. I enjoy meat and fish and have no doubts or problems as to where my food comes from. But, to hurt an animal for entertainment is not something that I could ever stand by and watch, let alone do myself.
I have enjoyed this book and hope you too will find yourself not only enjoying it but find it up lifting and possibly life changing or at least kinda understanding life's processes with those lives around us both human and animal.
Quotes:
"Violence has it pull for the deprived."
"You can't accelerate your natural growth. Those who climb fast crash faster. Their rush doesn't prepare them for their success's weight. If you want to rise to the top and stay there for your due time, you pay with your patience. Diligence doesn't take any short-cuts."
"At times, against our will, we ride wild illusions and sail into destruction. There, moral storms rage our soul and punish our conscience. The menacing waves threaten our identity. We long for security, mourn for safety, yearn for warmth. That is humane. Believe me."
"The past isn't there to hold onto; it's there to draw lessons from and shape the future."
☆☆☆☆☆
LOVE, HONOR, FRIENDSHIP, NATIONAL AND COMMUNITY PRIDE, BATTLES TO THE DEATH, THIS BOOK HAS IT ALL.
Indrajit GARAI writes with a voice that is pure poetry on the pages. It is clear that he is not only knowledgeable on this subjects he writes about but is very passionate about the stories he chooses, the characters, and the events inwhich brings his stories to life and his book "The House of Promise" is about as passionate as you can get when it comes to the relationships between family and friends, man and the animals we share our lifes with, our community, and are country.
This tell is about an orphaned boy who is taken in by a loving and supportive neighboring family who raise bulls and struggle with lifes challenges to support themselves in a country in the midst of a recession with not much choice to survive unless you work in an industry that goes against your very morals and believes even if by doing so breaks down your soul and makes you into the very thing you hate.
Once you cross the line that takes a little bit of your soul each and every minute of your day, you not only become what you despise but you give away a part of yourself that leaves you thinking that you are no longer the person you want or thought you were but a person that is beyond the ability to correct your life choices and return to the road in your life you were supposed to and wanted to travel all along.
This book is full of action, suspense, loss and love, joy and sadness, right and wrong. The right and wrong are the hardest to determine which is which even when you believe with every cell in your body that you are doing what you are doing for all the right reasons.
The characters are brought to these pages in a way which are not only easy to relate to but leaves you feeling you know what is in their hearts and minds. Don't be surprised when you find yourself shocked when what you thought was coming and it was not what you expected.
This story is told through the eyes of a young man named Ignacio who is a lover of animals, an inspiring veterinarian, a graceful flamenco dancer, and a professional bullfighter, an orphaned Bull named Victor who is gentle as a butterfly, Nuria who is more than his older sister of his adopted family. She's his friend, protector, and his confidant.
This book takes into the thoughts and relationships between man and the animals around us. The struggle to provide for yourself and your families in a recession and a pandemic brought them and their community to its knees. The clashes between what you were taught and what you know in your heart what is right and what is just plain wrong and should not have ever been from the get-go.
This is one of those books that will touch you all the way down to your soul and leave you looking not only to your past but looking and striving to truly be the person you not only want to be in the future.
Though this story is a piece of fiction, I find the dialog and the described events something of what the characters were going through to be truthful and real. Their feelings and strength to deal with the events life through at them were something that was very believable. I have no prior knowledge of Spain other than the little bit of knowledge I was taught while in grade school. And I have no prior knowledge to bullfighting, and to be honest, I have little desire to educate myself anymore on the subject.
I have never taken a stand against animal cruelty and have never taken part in it. I enjoy meat and fish and have no doubts or problems as to where my food comes from. But, to hurt an animal for entertainment is not something that I could ever stand by and watch, let alone do myself.
I have enjoyed this book and hope you too will find yourself not only enjoying it but find it up lifting and possibly life changing or at least kinda understanding life's processes with those lives around us both human and animal.
Quotes:
"Violence has it pull for the deprived."
"You can't accelerate your natural growth. Those who climb fast crash faster. Their rush doesn't prepare them for their success's weight. If you want to rise to the top and stay there for your due time, you pay with your patience. Diligence doesn't take any short-cuts."
"At times, against our will, we ride wild illusions and sail into destruction. There, moral storms rage our soul and punish our conscience. The menacing waves threaten our identity. We long for security, mourn for safety, yearn for warmth. That is humane. Believe me."
"The past isn't there to hold onto; it's there to draw lessons from and shape the future."
May 23, 2025
What a great story that is written by a great author. A read that lingers long after the last page. Indrajit Garai's is deeply invested in the emotional lives of his characters. The story mainly follows Ignaçio, a farm owner, but also Nuria and their involvement with a bull named Victor. Victor's world shatters when he is lifted from Ignacio's farm and sent hundreds miles away. Nuria's alliance dissolves when Ignaçio quits and defies her animal-rights campaign. Ingaçio’s internal journey often ventures into a philosophical nature. The central plot is around the sport of bullfighting and how Ignacio struggles around the sport on a political and personal level. Highly recommend.
June 30, 2025
Books by Indrajit Garai are far better than entertaining. The themes take you out of the mainstream and cause you to think about issues and possibilities that you have not considered previously. The House of Promise delivers magnificently. The reader must understand that Garai’s works are self published, so he does not have the plethora of editors at his disposal, nor the marketing resources. So, there will be editorial errors.
I love a book that has a beautifully crafted and descriptive opening scene that leaves the reader wondering how it ties into the story. The author does a magnificent job of bringing the plotting full circle where the closing scene brings the two together.
The final scene between the matador and the bull was the best I have read in recent memory. The author captured the thoughts and emotions of both characters exceptionally well. For a writer to be able to communicate those things for an animal without coming across as pedantic or over the top is skillful writing.
The author has an advanced vocabulary which I found refreshing and a pleasant change from the over used descriptions used in literature.
If you want books that are highly processed like your food or candy, this may not be the choice for you. But if you like something you are going to have to work at and think about, I highly recommend The House of Promise.
I love a book that has a beautifully crafted and descriptive opening scene that leaves the reader wondering how it ties into the story. The author does a magnificent job of bringing the plotting full circle where the closing scene brings the two together.
The final scene between the matador and the bull was the best I have read in recent memory. The author captured the thoughts and emotions of both characters exceptionally well. For a writer to be able to communicate those things for an animal without coming across as pedantic or over the top is skillful writing.
The author has an advanced vocabulary which I found refreshing and a pleasant change from the over used descriptions used in literature.
If you want books that are highly processed like your food or candy, this may not be the choice for you. But if you like something you are going to have to work at and think about, I highly recommend The House of Promise.
August 23, 2025
“Victor’s world shatters when he’s lifted from Ignaçio’s farm and shifted hundreds of miles away. Nuria’s alliance dissolves when Ignaçio quits flamenco, leaves home, and defies her animal-rights campaign. A historic corrida veers their trajectories, merges their paths, and rebuilds the symbolic taurine city.
After reading The Man Without Shelter and The Bridge of Little Jeremy, I’ve come to recognize Indrajit Garai’s signature voice—quiet, thoughtful, and deeply invested in the emotional lives of his characters. The House of Promise continues in this vein, but for me, it stands out as his most grounded and hopeful work so far.”
Garai’s prose remains simple and sincere, with that same understated elegance that I’ve come to appreciate. He never over-explains. He just lets the characters breathe, and the story unfolds in its own time.
I believe The House of Promise is well worth your time. It’s a gentle, rewarding read that lingers long after the last page.
After reading The Man Without Shelter and The Bridge of Little Jeremy, I’ve come to recognize Indrajit Garai’s signature voice—quiet, thoughtful, and deeply invested in the emotional lives of his characters. The House of Promise continues in this vein, but for me, it stands out as his most grounded and hopeful work so far.”
Garai’s prose remains simple and sincere, with that same understated elegance that I’ve come to appreciate. He never over-explains. He just lets the characters breathe, and the story unfolds in its own time.
I believe The House of Promise is well worth your time. It’s a gentle, rewarding read that lingers long after the last page.
May 8, 2025
I’ve read a number of Indrajit Garai’s books by now and all of them have impressed me. The House of Promise, however, I found to be exceptional. Given the time gaps between each of the books I've read, I’m struggling to pinpoint exactly what the difference is, but it’s there, and I’m all for it.
The story mainly follows Ignaçio, a farm owner, but also Nuria and their involvement with a bull named Victor. In a way, I felt like the book was reminiscent of The Sun Also Rises as bullfighting is a central plot point, but this comparison is for extremely superficial reasons. The House of Promise takes a much deeper and a much more realistic look at this subject, particularly through the eyes of Ignaçio and his struggles surrounding the sport on personal and political levels.
Although I found the brutal depictions of what the animals go through upsetting, the way it was written was so well-crafted that it resonated in a way that it outweighed the visuals for me. I enjoyed watching Ingaçio’s internal journey, which often ventured into a philosophical nature.
I believe this is the longest novel this author has written, and it’s undoubtedly my favorite! I look forward to whatever comes next.
The story mainly follows Ignaçio, a farm owner, but also Nuria and their involvement with a bull named Victor. In a way, I felt like the book was reminiscent of The Sun Also Rises as bullfighting is a central plot point, but this comparison is for extremely superficial reasons. The House of Promise takes a much deeper and a much more realistic look at this subject, particularly through the eyes of Ignaçio and his struggles surrounding the sport on personal and political levels.
Although I found the brutal depictions of what the animals go through upsetting, the way it was written was so well-crafted that it resonated in a way that it outweighed the visuals for me. I enjoyed watching Ingaçio’s internal journey, which often ventured into a philosophical nature.
I believe this is the longest novel this author has written, and it’s undoubtedly my favorite! I look forward to whatever comes next.
December 17, 2025
4.5🌟what a hidden 💎 gem! The story, which is new and refreshing, is on bullfighting in Spain. It’s told in multiple perspectives, including the bull;( like Remarkably Bright Creatures). If you truly want to step into any perspective shoes in regard to this industry this story is truly eye opening. I highly encourage readers to pick this book up🌟.
August 15, 2025
⭐️⭐️
I read “The Man Without Shelter” by Indrajit Garai and really enjoyed it.
I was very much looking forward to reading “The House of Promise.” Unfortunately it just did not capture my interest. Perhaps it’s because I am not a fan of bullfighting and believe this sport should be stopped. I can only imagine the suffering these poor bulls must go through.
I read “The Man Without Shelter” by Indrajit Garai and really enjoyed it.
I was very much looking forward to reading “The House of Promise.” Unfortunately it just did not capture my interest. Perhaps it’s because I am not a fan of bullfighting and believe this sport should be stopped. I can only imagine the suffering these poor bulls must go through.
August 26, 2025
Eloquent but overly long
July 31, 2025
4.5 - This was a quiet, slow-starting book that explores human connection. Garai's ability to describe the natural world is subtle but beautiful. His words just make you feel very calm; it's definitely bedtime book reader approved!
The characters felt believable, but I did feel like the actual dialogue between them felt forced and inorganic. Overall, I very much enjoyed reading this! I'd say this book is great for people who enjoy character-driven stories.
Thank you EstelleLiterature for providing a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
The characters felt believable, but I did feel like the actual dialogue between them felt forced and inorganic. Overall, I very much enjoyed reading this! I'd say this book is great for people who enjoy character-driven stories.
Thank you EstelleLiterature for providing a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
May 24, 2025
A study of the bull-fighting industry in Spain from many perspectives: matador, breeder, political and economic, and even from the bull and his animal friends. At times, gruesome, at others, tender and funny.
The text could be improved by a good technical editor for grammar and choice of words.
Literally and figuratively there are some wonderfully colorful scenes worth experiencing. E.g., "The rising sun striated the sky's topaz-blue with violet and sprayed the fleeting fluffs with amber. The full moon resisted the sun, defended its place, and courted the cedars, cypresses, and junipers.”
The text could be improved by a good technical editor for grammar and choice of words.
Literally and figuratively there are some wonderfully colorful scenes worth experiencing. E.g., "The rising sun striated the sky's topaz-blue with violet and sprayed the fleeting fluffs with amber. The full moon resisted the sun, defended its place, and courted the cedars, cypresses, and junipers.”
October 15, 2025
A quiet journey that explores human connection and intertwines historical perspective of bull finding in Spain. I read it completely entrapped with the nuances and new information that I was learning. I also enjoyed the multiple POVS. I felt that the story progressed well and the ending really was impactful!
All the characters went through their own type of growth there was some bittersweet moments but I truly thought it was such a refreshing read!
All the characters went through their own type of growth there was some bittersweet moments but I truly thought it was such a refreshing read!
July 30, 2025
It's always such a special feeling to pick up a book by this wonderful author. Indrajit's works always makes me feel feelings I haven't expected to, while reading his books. His writing style is unique and beautiful and he has a special way to build a story you won't ever forget. A story where you can connect with the characters and feel all the deep emotions.
𝐓𝐡𝐞 𝐇𝐨𝐮𝐬𝐞 𝐨𝐟 𝐏𝐫𝐨𝐦𝐢𝐬𝐞 is his latest release. It's a heavy read including bull fighting with brutal honesty, which I have to admit was very hard for me to read about. It took me a lot longer than usual as I had to put the book down multiple times. But all the emotions and powerful story worth all the time and pain.
Indrajit Garai is a very talented author and I absolutely loved everything I've read by him so far. I highly recommend checking out his works to find out yourself how brilliant of an author he really is.
𝐓𝐡𝐞 𝐇𝐨𝐮𝐬𝐞 𝐨𝐟 𝐏𝐫𝐨𝐦𝐢𝐬𝐞 is his latest release. It's a heavy read including bull fighting with brutal honesty, which I have to admit was very hard for me to read about. It took me a lot longer than usual as I had to put the book down multiple times. But all the emotions and powerful story worth all the time and pain.
Indrajit Garai is a very talented author and I absolutely loved everything I've read by him so far. I highly recommend checking out his works to find out yourself how brilliant of an author he really is.
November 10, 2025
The House of Promise by Indrajit Garai
Thank you very much to @estelleliterature for the #gifted copy of this book.
The House of Promise is the third of Indrajit's novels that I've read. His writing is always thoughtful and his stories always have something to say as well as being entertaining.
I've taken a while to read this novel that came out earlier this year. Partly because it's longer but also because the subject matter and writing style suit a slow read.
The prose has an idiosyncratic feel as English is not the author's first language (he's multi-cultured and has also previously written in French). The choice of phrases and the way sentences are worded isn't the usual way of wording things but it's not grammatically wrong and the meaning is always clear. It just needs reading slowly to appreciate the rhythm of the language.
The House of Promise is set in Spain and follows a young man called Ignacio. He's a skilled flamenco dancer as well as a farmer and studying to be a veterinarian.
It's also about bullfighting. The corrida tradition in a taurine city. The novel doesn't glorify the bullfights but also doesn't shy away from the brutality of the situations.
The novel has deep levels of meaning, looking at countries traditions and how cultures change. It's a social commentary and also explores how the pandemic changed the corrida industry.
Ignacio has a lovely relationship with a young bull calf named Victor but when Victor is taken from the farm it appears to be the catalyst that sets Ignacio on the path to become one of the country's top matadors.
This career trajectory puts him at odds with friends and family and also with himself.
The novel follows various viewpoints and the best has to be the POV of Victor himself. The bull's thoughts, feelings, and relationships with other animals (particularly Santos the dog) and his 'playmate' Ignacio bring an unexpected emotional depth to the story.
The novel slows down a little too much at times with the politics but the conclusion is beautifully constructed.
A philosophical and meaningful entertainment.
Thank you very much to @estelleliterature for the #gifted copy of this book.
The House of Promise is the third of Indrajit's novels that I've read. His writing is always thoughtful and his stories always have something to say as well as being entertaining.
I've taken a while to read this novel that came out earlier this year. Partly because it's longer but also because the subject matter and writing style suit a slow read.
The prose has an idiosyncratic feel as English is not the author's first language (he's multi-cultured and has also previously written in French). The choice of phrases and the way sentences are worded isn't the usual way of wording things but it's not grammatically wrong and the meaning is always clear. It just needs reading slowly to appreciate the rhythm of the language.
The House of Promise is set in Spain and follows a young man called Ignacio. He's a skilled flamenco dancer as well as a farmer and studying to be a veterinarian.
It's also about bullfighting. The corrida tradition in a taurine city. The novel doesn't glorify the bullfights but also doesn't shy away from the brutality of the situations.
The novel has deep levels of meaning, looking at countries traditions and how cultures change. It's a social commentary and also explores how the pandemic changed the corrida industry.
Ignacio has a lovely relationship with a young bull calf named Victor but when Victor is taken from the farm it appears to be the catalyst that sets Ignacio on the path to become one of the country's top matadors.
This career trajectory puts him at odds with friends and family and also with himself.
The novel follows various viewpoints and the best has to be the POV of Victor himself. The bull's thoughts, feelings, and relationships with other animals (particularly Santos the dog) and his 'playmate' Ignacio bring an unexpected emotional depth to the story.
The novel slows down a little too much at times with the politics but the conclusion is beautifully constructed.
A philosophical and meaningful entertainment.
Read
September 19, 2025In lieu of a review, let me share the beautiful words the author sent to the Prime Minister of Spain on the topic of the cruelty of bull-fighting which was the subject of this novel.
"You are an honorable representative of Spain's citizens. With my due respect for you and for your country, please allow me to ask you the following questions, as a fellow human being:
1) Do you consider bloodshed in full public view, irrespective of who the blood comes from and for what reason, nonviolent and lawful?
2) Does a legal framework that permits public bloodshed fulfill its basic mission of maintaining law and order by preventing violence?
3) What can such public bloodshed do for children?
Thank you for your time.
Regards,
Indrajit"
"You are an honorable representative of Spain's citizens. With my due respect for you and for your country, please allow me to ask you the following questions, as a fellow human being:
1) Do you consider bloodshed in full public view, irrespective of who the blood comes from and for what reason, nonviolent and lawful?
2) Does a legal framework that permits public bloodshed fulfill its basic mission of maintaining law and order by preventing violence?
3) What can such public bloodshed do for children?
Thank you for your time.
Regards,
Indrajit"
November 6, 2025
A book about bullfighting is an ambitious undertaking, knowing how it is a tradition at the heart of Spain's culture. Passion, ceremony and performance are all wound up together in what is essentially organised animal cruelty and Garai, in this novel, attempts to tackle this rather conflicting set of issues through a vast array of characters who proffer, from their occupations and backgrounds, the vast plethora of views and circumstances that surround la corrida.
The story is really centred around three main characters. Firstly, Ignacio, a multi-talented man who we first meet as a flamenco dancer but who is also studying to be a vet whilst harbouring ambitions to be a matador. He loves Nuria who is his sister but not by blood or relation; Ignacio was brought up by Nuria's parents and so, they have grown side by side. However, as time passes, there is the danger of them growing apart, their views on bullfighting becoming more and more disparate, causing their relationship to fracture. Nuria becomes more involved in trying to change the culture, it becoming the passion she follows rather than love. And then, rather unusually, there is Victor, a bull as our third character.
Yes, a bull. And actually, I found the passages where we are inside Victor's head (or Mors as he's also known in the book) the most interesting and stimulating in the novel. Garai, by providing us with the perspective of the bull, offers an extra layer to the story, creating sympathy and awareness of a creature instead of a construct merely used in a fight for entertainment. Victor is intelligent and sensitive. Garai shows this through Victor's thought processes and his interactions with other animals and humans and this unusual approach works really well, over and above other aspects.
I liked this book and especially the debate that it prompts but at times, I found it confusing. It took a while for me to get all the characters clear in my head and there were parts where I had to reread paragraphs to be sure of their meaning. I also felt like there was a lot of telling - instead of being in the scenes, they were described more generally and lacked intensity despite the action that they presented and whilst I enjoyed the story and where it went, it was a trickier read than others by Garai.
All that said, it is still worth checking out.
The story is really centred around three main characters. Firstly, Ignacio, a multi-talented man who we first meet as a flamenco dancer but who is also studying to be a vet whilst harbouring ambitions to be a matador. He loves Nuria who is his sister but not by blood or relation; Ignacio was brought up by Nuria's parents and so, they have grown side by side. However, as time passes, there is the danger of them growing apart, their views on bullfighting becoming more and more disparate, causing their relationship to fracture. Nuria becomes more involved in trying to change the culture, it becoming the passion she follows rather than love. And then, rather unusually, there is Victor, a bull as our third character.
Yes, a bull. And actually, I found the passages where we are inside Victor's head (or Mors as he's also known in the book) the most interesting and stimulating in the novel. Garai, by providing us with the perspective of the bull, offers an extra layer to the story, creating sympathy and awareness of a creature instead of a construct merely used in a fight for entertainment. Victor is intelligent and sensitive. Garai shows this through Victor's thought processes and his interactions with other animals and humans and this unusual approach works really well, over and above other aspects.
I liked this book and especially the debate that it prompts but at times, I found it confusing. It took a while for me to get all the characters clear in my head and there were parts where I had to reread paragraphs to be sure of their meaning. I also felt like there was a lot of telling - instead of being in the scenes, they were described more generally and lacked intensity despite the action that they presented and whilst I enjoyed the story and where it went, it was a trickier read than others by Garai.
All that said, it is still worth checking out.
August 6, 2025
From the start of the book, I have no idea what is going on. None of it makes any sense to me. It seems like no one bothered to edit the book to make it more readable. That’s only my opinion and others may feel different.
A tough book to review, and its over 500 pages which made me anxious to finish it. This being the third book I’ve read by this author, I don’t really think that his writing has improved. He writes books that I don’t believe I would have normally been attracted to.
A brutal, slow and boring story about bullfighting and everything connected to it. I have no love for this story. If I had been able to persevere through the end of the book I may have given it 3 stars. Hard to say because I had decided to DNF it and then tried to browse through the next eighty pages or so and still could not get interested in it.
I was given a free copy of this book to read and review, and I am so sorry that I had to give it up.
A tough book to review, and its over 500 pages which made me anxious to finish it. This being the third book I’ve read by this author, I don’t really think that his writing has improved. He writes books that I don’t believe I would have normally been attracted to.
A brutal, slow and boring story about bullfighting and everything connected to it. I have no love for this story. If I had been able to persevere through the end of the book I may have given it 3 stars. Hard to say because I had decided to DNF it and then tried to browse through the next eighty pages or so and still could not get interested in it.
I was given a free copy of this book to read and review, and I am so sorry that I had to give it up.
December 2, 2025
The House of Promise by Indrajit Garai is a sweeping and emotionally intense novel that explores cruelty, compassion, and the complicated bonds between humans and animals. Like Jack London’s The Call of the Wild, where Buck is thrust into a world that reveals both the darkness and loyalty of mankind, Victor the bull undergoes a similar awakening. He learns early that many bipeds are capable of horrifying cruelty—but also, in time, that not all humans are monsters. Some fight for life, not against it.
What gives the novel even more depth is the human story running parallel to Victor’s—especially the journey of Ignacio. His transformation is one of the most striking arcs in the book: a gifted flamenco dancer of raw emotion and rhythm becomes a serious veterinary student devoted to care, then is pulled into the dangerous, bloody glamour of the matador’s world. Later, burdened by guilt and searching for redemption, he reinvents himself yet again as an artist. His life becomes a shifting mirror of creation and destruction, leaving readers wondering: Is Ignacio healer, performer, creator… or killer? The novel offers no simple labels, only the complexity of a man shaped by culture, expectation, and conscience.
Beyond the individual characters, Garai also paints a vivid portrait of a town forced to evolve over the years. Nuria and her family represent compassion, resistance, and the hope for a more humane future. They stand as a quiet but powerful counterweight to the forces that exploit both people and animals.
Then there is Willem, the antagonist whose rise to power is one of the most chilling elements of the story. During the pandemic, Willem is celebrated as a hero—charitable, helpful, seemingly invested in the community’s survival. But his kindness is a mask. Behind it, he carefully plots a grab for wealth and control. When the crisis passes, the truth emerges: Willem’s rule is not leadership but domination. Under his tightening grip, both the townspeople and the animals suffer, ground down by his greed, his manipulation, and his hunger for influence. The town becomes a symbol of how easily a community can be seduced, exploited, and reshaped by those with money and ambition.
This broader social struggle weaves seamlessly with Victor’s personal journey. Just as Buck must determine whom to trust in The Call of the Wild, Victor learns that some humans bring only pain, while others—like Nuria, Ignacio, and those who defy Willem—offer protection, loyalty, and love.
In the end, The House of Promise is not just a story about a bull, a matador, or a town—it is a meditation on choice, power, and moral courage. It shows how cruelty can shape a life, but how compassion can redefine it. Rich, lyrical, and emotionally unflinching, this novel lingers long after the final page, reminding us that even in a world of suffering, there are always those who choose to stand on the side of life.
In the end, The House of Promise is not just a story about a bull, a matador, or a town—it is a meditation on choice, power, and moral courage. It shows how cruelty can shape a life, but how compassion can redefine it. Rich, lyrical, and emotionally unflinching, this novel lingers long after the final page, reminding us that even in a world of suffering, there are always those who choose to stand on the side of life.
And as someone who has read it, I can say this: it’s the rare kind of story that doesn’t just stay in your mind—
it settles into your conscience, makes you question the world around you, and reminds you that even a single act of kindness can change the course of a life, human or animal.
What gives the novel even more depth is the human story running parallel to Victor’s—especially the journey of Ignacio. His transformation is one of the most striking arcs in the book: a gifted flamenco dancer of raw emotion and rhythm becomes a serious veterinary student devoted to care, then is pulled into the dangerous, bloody glamour of the matador’s world. Later, burdened by guilt and searching for redemption, he reinvents himself yet again as an artist. His life becomes a shifting mirror of creation and destruction, leaving readers wondering: Is Ignacio healer, performer, creator… or killer? The novel offers no simple labels, only the complexity of a man shaped by culture, expectation, and conscience.
Beyond the individual characters, Garai also paints a vivid portrait of a town forced to evolve over the years. Nuria and her family represent compassion, resistance, and the hope for a more humane future. They stand as a quiet but powerful counterweight to the forces that exploit both people and animals.
Then there is Willem, the antagonist whose rise to power is one of the most chilling elements of the story. During the pandemic, Willem is celebrated as a hero—charitable, helpful, seemingly invested in the community’s survival. But his kindness is a mask. Behind it, he carefully plots a grab for wealth and control. When the crisis passes, the truth emerges: Willem’s rule is not leadership but domination. Under his tightening grip, both the townspeople and the animals suffer, ground down by his greed, his manipulation, and his hunger for influence. The town becomes a symbol of how easily a community can be seduced, exploited, and reshaped by those with money and ambition.
This broader social struggle weaves seamlessly with Victor’s personal journey. Just as Buck must determine whom to trust in The Call of the Wild, Victor learns that some humans bring only pain, while others—like Nuria, Ignacio, and those who defy Willem—offer protection, loyalty, and love.
In the end, The House of Promise is not just a story about a bull, a matador, or a town—it is a meditation on choice, power, and moral courage. It shows how cruelty can shape a life, but how compassion can redefine it. Rich, lyrical, and emotionally unflinching, this novel lingers long after the final page, reminding us that even in a world of suffering, there are always those who choose to stand on the side of life.
In the end, The House of Promise is not just a story about a bull, a matador, or a town—it is a meditation on choice, power, and moral courage. It shows how cruelty can shape a life, but how compassion can redefine it. Rich, lyrical, and emotionally unflinching, this novel lingers long after the final page, reminding us that even in a world of suffering, there are always those who choose to stand on the side of life.
And as someone who has read it, I can say this: it’s the rare kind of story that doesn’t just stay in your mind—
it settles into your conscience, makes you question the world around you, and reminds you that even a single act of kindness can change the course of a life, human or animal.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
June 7, 2025
When bullfighting or bull runs come to mind, I think: exotic barbarism. I’m fascinated but I just want to stay out of the way! From the distant (for many of us) world of bullfighting, this novel, though, narrates a dignified human - moral - dilemma to which most any reader can delve into and resonate with.
In the late 1990s, Ignatio, orphaned, grows up with a farm family with whose daughter, Nuria, he becomes close. They diverge in adulthood. Nuria veers toward animal activism when Ignatio develops a corredo-flamenco with his beloved bull, Victor, into the fighting arena. The town’s economy, dominated by a tourist industry that ostracizes many of its citizens, reflects the wider scope of the family’s contentiousness. The town’s and the couple’s problems come to a head as the pandemic wraps up.
Told from Ignatio’s, Nuria’s, and Victor’s perspectives, the novel weaves many stories into one. Victor’s chapters are visceral and intuitive, with short declarative sentences. Ignatio’s are emotional and Nuria’s are more academic, as she navigates laws. Natural scenes on the farm, depicting Spain’s lush landscape contrast with urban grit and controversy. Spitty dialogue, between persons and in political debates, drives the story forward between descriptive passages. The developed characters work against a mafia-like figure’s attempts to exert his control over everyone. The novel’s varied elements work together to convey an irreducible complexity.
Dissenting sides’ friction culminates in an inferno: Ignatio’s final bullfight coincides with Nuria’s pivotal political debate on animal rights. No one’s outlook is taken for granted; all are considered. But the novel doesn’t end there. Calves and human babies populate the conclusion, a hopeful vision worth the book’s almost 500 pages.
In the late 1990s, Ignatio, orphaned, grows up with a farm family with whose daughter, Nuria, he becomes close. They diverge in adulthood. Nuria veers toward animal activism when Ignatio develops a corredo-flamenco with his beloved bull, Victor, into the fighting arena. The town’s economy, dominated by a tourist industry that ostracizes many of its citizens, reflects the wider scope of the family’s contentiousness. The town’s and the couple’s problems come to a head as the pandemic wraps up.
Told from Ignatio’s, Nuria’s, and Victor’s perspectives, the novel weaves many stories into one. Victor’s chapters are visceral and intuitive, with short declarative sentences. Ignatio’s are emotional and Nuria’s are more academic, as she navigates laws. Natural scenes on the farm, depicting Spain’s lush landscape contrast with urban grit and controversy. Spitty dialogue, between persons and in political debates, drives the story forward between descriptive passages. The developed characters work against a mafia-like figure’s attempts to exert his control over everyone. The novel’s varied elements work together to convey an irreducible complexity.
Dissenting sides’ friction culminates in an inferno: Ignatio’s final bullfight coincides with Nuria’s pivotal political debate on animal rights. No one’s outlook is taken for granted; all are considered. But the novel doesn’t end there. Calves and human babies populate the conclusion, a hopeful vision worth the book’s almost 500 pages.
Displaying 1 - 18 of 18 reviews