What do you think?
Rate this book
The Odds of You
Not yet published
Expected 6 Jan 26
Once is chance. Twice is fate.
Sage Collins knows a thing or two about odds. A year ago, she was a data analyst until she burned it all down to pursue her dream of becoming an author. One whirlwind bestseller and a struggling second book later, and Sage isn’t sure she’ll ever write a novel again.
But then an accidental encounter with an irritating passenger on the flight to Comic Con leaves Sage in an untested position. That passenger is Theo Sharpe: a breakout actor on the cusp of fame. And, unfortunately, the paparazzi have mistaken her for his girlfriend.
Armed with signature British charm and a smile that could tame oceans, Theo wears fame like a well-fit coat…though Sage can see there’s something deeper held in his eyes. But his fans are too involved in the drama, the pressure to deliver the next bestseller is on, and Sage and Theo both must agree there’s nothing between them. They don't have to acknowledge that saying it doesn't make it true.
When Sage decides to flee to Scotland to clear her head and write her novel, she expects to find fresh air and the stillness to think. What she doesn’t expect is Theo Sharpe to come back into her life…and how he may be her greatest miscalculation of all.
An emotionally-charged novel in the vein of Ashley Poston and Yulin Kuang, The Odds of You is a smart and sexy first contemporary novel from bestselling romantasy author Kate Dramis.
Sage Collins knows a thing or two about odds. A year ago, she was a data analyst until she burned it all down to pursue her dream of becoming an author. One whirlwind bestseller and a struggling second book later, and Sage isn’t sure she’ll ever write a novel again.
But then an accidental encounter with an irritating passenger on the flight to Comic Con leaves Sage in an untested position. That passenger is Theo Sharpe: a breakout actor on the cusp of fame. And, unfortunately, the paparazzi have mistaken her for his girlfriend.
Armed with signature British charm and a smile that could tame oceans, Theo wears fame like a well-fit coat…though Sage can see there’s something deeper held in his eyes. But his fans are too involved in the drama, the pressure to deliver the next bestseller is on, and Sage and Theo both must agree there’s nothing between them. They don't have to acknowledge that saying it doesn't make it true.
When Sage decides to flee to Scotland to clear her head and write her novel, she expects to find fresh air and the stillness to think. What she doesn’t expect is Theo Sharpe to come back into her life…and how he may be her greatest miscalculation of all.
An emotionally-charged novel in the vein of Ashley Poston and Yulin Kuang, The Odds of You is a smart and sexy first contemporary novel from bestselling romantasy author Kate Dramis.
345 pages, Kindle Edition
Expected publication January 6, 2026
19937 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 580 reviews
November 12, 2025
Some books slip quietly into your hands, and some completely sweep you off your feet. The Odds of You did the latter for me—it’s heartfelt, sparkling, and brimming with the kind of emotional depth that makes you believe in second chances, serendipity, and love that refuses to play by the rules.
We meet Sage Collins, a once-steady data analyst turned breakout author who now feels paralyzed by the fear of being a “one-hit wonder.” Enter Theo Sharpe—charming, golden-boy actor with that mix of vulnerability and confidence that makes you lean in closer. Their “accidental” meet-cute on a flight is the perfect spark, but what follows is more than a tropey celebrity-author romance. It’s a layered journey of self-discovery, grief, ambition, and the terrifyingly beautiful gamble of opening your heart again.
What struck me most about this book wasn’t just the romance (though, trust me, the chemistry between Sage and Theo is magnetic). It was how real and raw the characters felt. Sage’s anxiety and self-doubt weren’t glossed over—they pulsed on the page in ways that felt achingly relatable.
And Theo? Beneath his charisma lies a man carrying loss, responsibility, and the pressure of public scrutiny. Watching them slowly unravel their fears while leaning into each other was as tender as it was powerful.
And can we talk about the settings? From Comic Con chaos to the windswept beauty of Scotland, Kate Dramis paints backdrops that breathe life into every scene. The Scottish chapters especially felt like a balm—you could almost feel the mist, hear the crunch of gravel paths, and taste that fresh air Sage desperately needed.
Yes, this is a romance with sizzling tension and swoony banter, but it’s also a story about identity, creativity, and healing. It’s about learning that sometimes the bravest thing we can do is let ourselves be seen—not as the version we think the world wants, but as our truest selves.
Kate Dramis has given us a love story that’s equal parts witty, poignant, and soul-stirring. If you adore celebrity romances, fake dating gone wrong (or right), heartfelt character growth, or simply want to believe in the magic of unlikely encounters, this is a story worth betting on.
✨ A very huge thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press | St. Martin’s Griffin for sharing this beautiful romance’s digital reviewer copy with me in exchange for my honest thoughts—I feel lucky to have read it early!
medium.com
instagram
facebook
We meet Sage Collins, a once-steady data analyst turned breakout author who now feels paralyzed by the fear of being a “one-hit wonder.” Enter Theo Sharpe—charming, golden-boy actor with that mix of vulnerability and confidence that makes you lean in closer. Their “accidental” meet-cute on a flight is the perfect spark, but what follows is more than a tropey celebrity-author romance. It’s a layered journey of self-discovery, grief, ambition, and the terrifyingly beautiful gamble of opening your heart again.
What struck me most about this book wasn’t just the romance (though, trust me, the chemistry between Sage and Theo is magnetic). It was how real and raw the characters felt. Sage’s anxiety and self-doubt weren’t glossed over—they pulsed on the page in ways that felt achingly relatable.
And Theo? Beneath his charisma lies a man carrying loss, responsibility, and the pressure of public scrutiny. Watching them slowly unravel their fears while leaning into each other was as tender as it was powerful.
And can we talk about the settings? From Comic Con chaos to the windswept beauty of Scotland, Kate Dramis paints backdrops that breathe life into every scene. The Scottish chapters especially felt like a balm—you could almost feel the mist, hear the crunch of gravel paths, and taste that fresh air Sage desperately needed.
Yes, this is a romance with sizzling tension and swoony banter, but it’s also a story about identity, creativity, and healing. It’s about learning that sometimes the bravest thing we can do is let ourselves be seen—not as the version we think the world wants, but as our truest selves.
Kate Dramis has given us a love story that’s equal parts witty, poignant, and soul-stirring. If you adore celebrity romances, fake dating gone wrong (or right), heartfelt character growth, or simply want to believe in the magic of unlikely encounters, this is a story worth betting on.
✨ A very huge thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press | St. Martin’s Griffin for sharing this beautiful romance’s digital reviewer copy with me in exchange for my honest thoughts—I feel lucky to have read it early!
medium.com
November 2, 2025
DNF @ 24% 😭😭
First off, happy Halloween, everyone! 👻🎃 Hope y’all will have an amazing day! 🧡🖤
Okay, I want to start off by saying that I was super excited to read this book. When I come across a book that looks cute and sounds promising and see that it is a ‘Read Now’ book, I can’t help but check off those boxes and push that button! The NetGalley addiction is real, ladies and gentlemen. My brother says I need help; I think I need more books.😂 But, I should know by now that I should never, ever judge a book by its cover. Just because I like the cover doesn’t mean I’m going to like the story. And that is what happened with this book.
There is nothing wrong with the writing, but the characters felt a little distant and flat for me. At first, I found Sage relatable and her best friend Emerson funny, but by what, chapter 5 or something, I was already done with them. I just couldn’t get into the story, root for the main character, or even want to see how Theo and Sage end up together. I started this book on the 19th, and it is now the 31st. That proves to me that I could not and will not ever get into the story. I tried SO MANY TIMES to continue because it’s only 22 chapters, but I’m either in a slight reading slump or the book was boring and not worth my time and energy.
I’m honestly sad that it didn’t work out. I hate DNF’ing books, especially with how many I DNF’d this year, but I couldn’t persevere. You know it’s bad if you feel immediate relief once you slide that progress bar all the way to the end to get the book off your reading shelf. 😭 But who knows? Maybe in the future I’ll be able to pick this up and try to read it again, but for now, I’d rather not. 😅
Thank you to St. Martin’s Press and NetGalley for providing the arc in exchange for an honest review! All opinions and statements are my own.
Side note for those who might be uncomfortable with this, but the main character, Sage, is bi. If you don’t prefer to read about things like that, then this is your heads up! ☺
First off, happy Halloween, everyone! 👻🎃 Hope y’all will have an amazing day! 🧡🖤
Okay, I want to start off by saying that I was super excited to read this book. When I come across a book that looks cute and sounds promising and see that it is a ‘Read Now’ book, I can’t help but check off those boxes and push that button! The NetGalley addiction is real, ladies and gentlemen. My brother says I need help; I think I need more books.😂 But, I should know by now that I should never, ever judge a book by its cover. Just because I like the cover doesn’t mean I’m going to like the story. And that is what happened with this book.
There is nothing wrong with the writing, but the characters felt a little distant and flat for me. At first, I found Sage relatable and her best friend Emerson funny, but by what, chapter 5 or something, I was already done with them. I just couldn’t get into the story, root for the main character, or even want to see how Theo and Sage end up together. I started this book on the 19th, and it is now the 31st. That proves to me that I could not and will not ever get into the story. I tried SO MANY TIMES to continue because it’s only 22 chapters, but I’m either in a slight reading slump or the book was boring and not worth my time and energy.
I’m honestly sad that it didn’t work out. I hate DNF’ing books, especially with how many I DNF’d this year, but I couldn’t persevere. You know it’s bad if you feel immediate relief once you slide that progress bar all the way to the end to get the book off your reading shelf. 😭 But who knows? Maybe in the future I’ll be able to pick this up and try to read it again, but for now, I’d rather not. 😅
Thank you to St. Martin’s Press and NetGalley for providing the arc in exchange for an honest review! All opinions and statements are my own.
Side note for those who might be uncomfortable with this, but the main character, Sage, is bi. If you don’t prefer to read about things like that, then this is your heads up! ☺
November 28, 2025
Publication Date: 6th January 2026
⭐ 3.75 (rounded up) ⭐
🌷 Tropes and Themes 🌷
➵ Celebrity romance
➵ Actor X author
➵ Forced proximity
➵ He's British, She's American
➵ Golden retriever MMC (who also owns a cat)
➵ ADHD and Mental Health representation
⚠️ Trigger Warnings ⚠️
➵ Bereavement (loss of mother and brother)
📚 Summary 📚
When Sage Collins, a once data analyst now turned bestselling author, and Theo Sharpe, the next big movie star to come out of the UK, cross paths on the same flight, they hit it off straight away. The flight is filled with chitchat, British-American banter and comfortable company. That is, until paparazzi mistake Sage for Theo's girlfriend. With rumours circulating and hate comments galore, Sage soon becomes overwhelmed, which does nothing to help the major writer's block she's been battling.
In a hope to escape the drama and make progress with writing the sequel to her recent bestseller, Sage books a trip to the Isle of Skye, in Scotland. The odds of picturesque scenery, cosy evenings in front of her laptop, and the fresh air of the Scottish Hebrides are high. But the odds of a certain actor booking a retreat to the same town at the exact same time? Well, they are clearly not as slim as she would've thought.
💭 My Thoughts 💭
This book is written in third person present tense which isn't a combination I read very often as I sometimes feel that it can take away a bit of depth in regard to the characters' feelings. So, it did take me a little while to get into the swing of reading in this perspective, and I did occasionally find that some parts felt more "tell-y" than "show-y". However, I still found the story very enjoyable.
The dialogue between the characters was incredibly sweet, humorous and heart-warming. The banter between not only Sage and Theo, but also Sage and her friends was in my opinion what made the book so enjoyable and wholesome. I also really liked the side characters Margot and Emerson! If they were to get their own stories, I would absolutely read them!
I'm personally not too keen on the insta-love type relationships as it often feels kind of fanfiction-esque to me. I felt that the whole instant heart-eyes made Sage and Theo's relationship feel somewhat superficial. — My opinion on this is further solidified when I read the third act breakup that took four months to reconcile!! You're telling me that you both love each other but have made no effort to contact each other for FOUR FREAKING MONTHS?!? 🤔 To say I was frustrated with their acceptance of not seeing each other is an understatement. WHERE is the fight to win each other back?! WHERE IS THE YEARNING!? Nevertheless, I did still find their relationship cute.
I also feel like it's very important to give credit to how Kate Dramis represents mental health struggles and neurodivergence in this book. The Odds of You serves as a subtle reminder that anybody can face mental health struggles, even those who seem to "have it all". From anxiety and imposter syndrome, to ADHD, to bereavement and grief, this book is a reminder to people in similar situations that they're not alone.
💫 Overall 💫
This book was an easy and thoroughly enjoyable read filled with British X American banter, heart-warming confessions, and wholesome, cosy holiday season vibes.
Thank you to NetGalley, Kate Dramis and Bloomsbury Publishing UK for gifting this eBook in exchange for an honest and unbiased review. All opinions are my own.
❀ Tia ❀
⭐ 3.75 (rounded up) ⭐
🌷 Tropes and Themes 🌷
➵ Celebrity romance
➵ Actor X author
➵ Forced proximity
➵ He's British, She's American
➵ Golden retriever MMC (who also owns a cat)
➵ ADHD and Mental Health representation
⚠️ Trigger Warnings ⚠️
➵ Bereavement (loss of mother and brother)
📚 Summary 📚
When Sage Collins, a once data analyst now turned bestselling author, and Theo Sharpe, the next big movie star to come out of the UK, cross paths on the same flight, they hit it off straight away. The flight is filled with chitchat, British-American banter and comfortable company. That is, until paparazzi mistake Sage for Theo's girlfriend. With rumours circulating and hate comments galore, Sage soon becomes overwhelmed, which does nothing to help the major writer's block she's been battling.
In a hope to escape the drama and make progress with writing the sequel to her recent bestseller, Sage books a trip to the Isle of Skye, in Scotland. The odds of picturesque scenery, cosy evenings in front of her laptop, and the fresh air of the Scottish Hebrides are high. But the odds of a certain actor booking a retreat to the same town at the exact same time? Well, they are clearly not as slim as she would've thought.
💭 My Thoughts 💭
This book is written in third person present tense which isn't a combination I read very often as I sometimes feel that it can take away a bit of depth in regard to the characters' feelings. So, it did take me a little while to get into the swing of reading in this perspective, and I did occasionally find that some parts felt more "tell-y" than "show-y". However, I still found the story very enjoyable.
The dialogue between the characters was incredibly sweet, humorous and heart-warming. The banter between not only Sage and Theo, but also Sage and her friends was in my opinion what made the book so enjoyable and wholesome. I also really liked the side characters Margot and Emerson! If they were to get their own stories, I would absolutely read them!
I'm personally not too keen on the insta-love type relationships as it often feels kind of fanfiction-esque to me. I felt that the whole instant heart-eyes made Sage and Theo's relationship feel somewhat superficial. — My opinion on this is further solidified when I read the third act breakup that took four months to reconcile!! You're telling me that you both love each other but have made no effort to contact each other for FOUR FREAKING MONTHS?!? 🤔 To say I was frustrated with their acceptance of not seeing each other is an understatement. WHERE is the fight to win each other back?! WHERE IS THE YEARNING!? Nevertheless, I did still find their relationship cute.
I also feel like it's very important to give credit to how Kate Dramis represents mental health struggles and neurodivergence in this book. The Odds of You serves as a subtle reminder that anybody can face mental health struggles, even those who seem to "have it all". From anxiety and imposter syndrome, to ADHD, to bereavement and grief, this book is a reminder to people in similar situations that they're not alone.
💫 Overall 💫
This book was an easy and thoroughly enjoyable read filled with British X American banter, heart-warming confessions, and wholesome, cosy holiday season vibes.
Thank you to NetGalley, Kate Dramis and Bloomsbury Publishing UK for gifting this eBook in exchange for an honest and unbiased review. All opinions are my own.
❀ Tia ❀
December 15, 2025
This novel was such a heartfelt and emotional read for me! It is about second chances, love and chemistry. I really enjoyed the main characters! I think that the side characters stood out as well. I feel that this is a more character driven novel, where all of the characters were strongly developed and lovable. This was definitely more of a slow burn romance. What surprised me was that this book had spice in it! There was not a whole lot of spice in the novel, but there were a few spicy scenes. It is a celebrity and author romantic comedy, which I found to be unique and enjoyable.
This book overall was captivating, lighthearted, reflective and witty! It was well written, easy to follow and had all the cozy vibes in it! I really had a great time with this one! It gave me the movie “Notting Hill” vibes. Be sure to check out the content warnings. I give this book a 4.5 star rating out of 5! I do recommend reading this book when it comes out! It was really, really good!
Thank you to NetGalley, author Kate Dramis and St. Martin's Press | St. Martin's Griffin for this wonderful eARC in exchange for my honest review. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own.
This book is expected to be released on January 6, 2026!
This book overall was captivating, lighthearted, reflective and witty! It was well written, easy to follow and had all the cozy vibes in it! I really had a great time with this one! It gave me the movie “Notting Hill” vibes. Be sure to check out the content warnings. I give this book a 4.5 star rating out of 5! I do recommend reading this book when it comes out! It was really, really good!
Thank you to NetGalley, author Kate Dramis and St. Martin's Press | St. Martin's Griffin for this wonderful eARC in exchange for my honest review. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own.
This book is expected to be released on January 6, 2026!
November 6, 2025
another tortured hero named theo to add to my collection (as in put in my pocket and protect from harm)
i also feel the bones of red white and royal blue (in writing style/vibes) working its way through the narrative in a way i cannot explain
thank you to edelweiss for providing me an advance review copy. full review to come
Bookstagram | Blog
i also feel the bones of red white and royal blue (in writing style/vibes) working its way through the narrative in a way i cannot explain
thank you to edelweiss for providing me an advance review copy. full review to come
Bookstagram | Blog
December 17, 2025
It takes time to get used to third-person present tense. Dab isn’t sure, but it may have rewired her brain. Something’s been rearranged, she guesses 😵💫
Third-person present tense doesn’t always bother me, but it was distracting here, and it took me a moment to get into the story. I considered dnfing in the first 20–30%, but I’m glad I soldiered on, because it improved once I got invested.
Theo, a celebrity actor, and Sage, an upcoming author, meet on a plane and promptly get mistaken for a couple. Sage is terrified by the social media frenzy that follows, and despite mutual attraction, nothing comes of it. But then they bump into each other some time later and reconnect…
I really enjoyed their time together; the banter, the movies, and Christmas in snowy Scotland — all of that was very cozy and romantic. Their chemistry was great, and even though there were a lot of open-door scenes, I wouldn’t call this book spicy. It was never overly descriptive, and that worked well for me.
What I also appreciated was how both characters’ struggles with mental health, careers, families, and general life decisions were portrayed. They were both extremely relatable, and I very much appreciated the author’s take on those topics.
However.
I hate third-act breakups. They are unnecessary killjoys, and I’ve docked countless stars for them in the past. Imagine my wrath when this book served me two of those. There was a “breakup” in the first act, and I naively thought it would save us from another one later on, but no such luck. There was a full-on meltdown where dirty secrets were revealed, doors were slammed, and phone numbers were deleted. It took them months to get back together 😩
All in all, not a total flop, and I can see how this book might work for others, but I’m unfortunately not in love.
Thanks Bloomsbury Publishing and NetGalley for the arc, all opinions are my own.
Third-person present tense doesn’t always bother me, but it was distracting here, and it took me a moment to get into the story. I considered dnfing in the first 20–30%, but I’m glad I soldiered on, because it improved once I got invested.
Theo, a celebrity actor, and Sage, an upcoming author, meet on a plane and promptly get mistaken for a couple. Sage is terrified by the social media frenzy that follows, and despite mutual attraction, nothing comes of it. But then they bump into each other some time later and reconnect…
I really enjoyed their time together; the banter, the movies, and Christmas in snowy Scotland — all of that was very cozy and romantic. Their chemistry was great, and even though there were a lot of open-door scenes, I wouldn’t call this book spicy. It was never overly descriptive, and that worked well for me.
What I also appreciated was how both characters’ struggles with mental health, careers, families, and general life decisions were portrayed. They were both extremely relatable, and I very much appreciated the author’s take on those topics.
However.
I hate third-act breakups. They are unnecessary killjoys, and I’ve docked countless stars for them in the past. Imagine my wrath when this book served me two of those. There was a “breakup” in the first act, and I naively thought it would save us from another one later on, but no such luck. There was a full-on meltdown where dirty secrets were revealed, doors were slammed, and phone numbers were deleted. It took them months to get back together 😩
All in all, not a total flop, and I can see how this book might work for others, but I’m unfortunately not in love.
Thanks Bloomsbury Publishing and NetGalley for the arc, all opinions are my own.
November 16, 2025
To know him—truly know him.
What if.
What if.
What if.
Wow… just wow. If I could rate 6 stars I would in a heartbeat. 😭 This story reminded me why I love reading so much. 🥹🥹🥹 From the very first chapter, the writing is so vivid and beautifully crafted that it felt like I stepped right into the world alongside the characters. Every emotion, every setting, every quiet moment… they all came alive in the most effortless way. 🫶🏼🫶🏼
I fell completely in love with Sage. She’s the kind of girl you root for with your whole heart. She’s brave, stubborn in the best way, and determined to live a life that makes her happy, even when the pressure to be someone else is crushing. Watching her stand firm in her dreams, even while struggling, was powerful and honestly so inspiring. 💅🏼
And Theo… pure perfection. ✨ Charming without trying, gentle without being passive, and supportive in ways that feel rare in romance. Their connection starts off in the most unexpected way, but what follows is this slow, honest unraveling of walls and fears. The open communication between them (after the first rift in the beginning 🫣) was everything. No pointless arguments, no talking over each other—just two people learning to listen, to show up, and to be exactly what the other needs at exactly the right moments.
And one of my absolute favorite things? Nothing felt rushed. There’s tension, there’s longing, there are moments where you feel how close they are to falling (and moments where you hold your breath because you’re not sure if they’ll be brave enough to admit it). The story balances sweetness with emotional depth, and the quieter, heavier moments hit just as hard as the swoony ones.
The friendships and group chats? Hilarious. The family drama? So raw and realistic. The character growth? Chef’s kiss. 🤌🏼🤌🏼 Every piece of this book works together to create something warm, emotional, and unforgettable.
I genuinely can’t think of a single thing I didn’t like. It’s a story that sneaks up on you, wraps around you, and stays with you long after you close the last page. 🩵🩵🩵
If you’re craving a romance that’s beautifully written, emotionally grounded, and full of the kind of connection that feels both rare and real —add this to your TBR immediately‼️‼️
-♡-♡-♡-♡-♡-favorite quotes-♡-♡-♡-♡-♡-
"I write because one time I picked up a book and it made me feel less alone. And I think I can help others feel less alone, too," she murmurs.”
“His smile is soft, his eyes knowing. Something in Sage's chest swells. It feels a little bit like reading her favorite book for the very first time.”
“I don't consider myself a possessive man," he remarks, his voice like a rumble of distant thunder. "But seeing you in that shirt might be the thing to prove otherwise."
"You, Collins, are entirely missable."
-♡-♡-♡-♡-♡-♡-♡-♡-♡-♡-♡-♡-♡-♡-♡-♡-
things to know about the book ↓
📚 writer x actor
📚 small-town Scotland escape
📚 low drama between MCs
📚 second chance
📚 emotional healing
📚 third person POV
A huge thank you to Netgalley, St. Martin's Press, and Kate Dramis for allowing me to read this arc. These are all my honest opinions in this review.
What if.
What if.
What if.
Wow… just wow. If I could rate 6 stars I would in a heartbeat. 😭 This story reminded me why I love reading so much. 🥹🥹🥹 From the very first chapter, the writing is so vivid and beautifully crafted that it felt like I stepped right into the world alongside the characters. Every emotion, every setting, every quiet moment… they all came alive in the most effortless way. 🫶🏼🫶🏼
I fell completely in love with Sage. She’s the kind of girl you root for with your whole heart. She’s brave, stubborn in the best way, and determined to live a life that makes her happy, even when the pressure to be someone else is crushing. Watching her stand firm in her dreams, even while struggling, was powerful and honestly so inspiring. 💅🏼
And Theo… pure perfection. ✨ Charming without trying, gentle without being passive, and supportive in ways that feel rare in romance. Their connection starts off in the most unexpected way, but what follows is this slow, honest unraveling of walls and fears. The open communication between them (after the first rift in the beginning 🫣) was everything. No pointless arguments, no talking over each other—just two people learning to listen, to show up, and to be exactly what the other needs at exactly the right moments.
And one of my absolute favorite things? Nothing felt rushed. There’s tension, there’s longing, there are moments where you feel how close they are to falling (and moments where you hold your breath because you’re not sure if they’ll be brave enough to admit it). The story balances sweetness with emotional depth, and the quieter, heavier moments hit just as hard as the swoony ones.
The friendships and group chats? Hilarious. The family drama? So raw and realistic. The character growth? Chef’s kiss. 🤌🏼🤌🏼 Every piece of this book works together to create something warm, emotional, and unforgettable.
I genuinely can’t think of a single thing I didn’t like. It’s a story that sneaks up on you, wraps around you, and stays with you long after you close the last page. 🩵🩵🩵
If you’re craving a romance that’s beautifully written, emotionally grounded, and full of the kind of connection that feels both rare and real —add this to your TBR immediately‼️‼️
-♡-♡-♡-♡-♡-favorite quotes-♡-♡-♡-♡-♡-
"I write because one time I picked up a book and it made me feel less alone. And I think I can help others feel less alone, too," she murmurs.”
“His smile is soft, his eyes knowing. Something in Sage's chest swells. It feels a little bit like reading her favorite book for the very first time.”
“I don't consider myself a possessive man," he remarks, his voice like a rumble of distant thunder. "But seeing you in that shirt might be the thing to prove otherwise."
"You, Collins, are entirely missable."
-♡-♡-♡-♡-♡-♡-♡-♡-♡-♡-♡-♡-♡-♡-♡-♡-
things to know about the book ↓
📚 writer x actor
📚 small-town Scotland escape
📚 low drama between MCs
📚 second chance
📚 emotional healing
📚 third person POV
A huge thank you to Netgalley, St. Martin's Press, and Kate Dramis for allowing me to read this arc. These are all my honest opinions in this review.
August 29, 2025
THOUGHTS: Really loved this one! I didn't expect it to go so deep into mental health issues and family relationships - and if you were to ask me - I think this is more than a poolside romance and less than a serious read.
CHARACTER BUILDING: Sage's character was so refreshing to read because she was changing careers and finally setting some much-needed boundaries. That's REALLY hard to do but I love watching characters do it!
THE ‘MEH’ STUFF: None really!
FAVORITE QUOTE: 'dreams that were dismissed in the name of practicality and rationality' -- Gah. Plucked that feeling right out of my brain and put it into words.
- Tough family relationships
- International romantic relationships
- Changing careers
**Thank you to St. Martin's Griffin for the advanced reader copy. I received this book for free, but all thoughts are my own. – SLR🖤
Follow me on Instagram for honest reviews, bookish freebies & giveaways! 🖤 || href="https://www.youtube.com/@southernlady... ">Southern Lady Reads YouTube channel coming soon!!
CHARACTER BUILDING: Sage's character was so refreshing to read because she was changing careers and finally setting some much-needed boundaries. That's REALLY hard to do but I love watching characters do it!
THE ‘MEH’ STUFF: None really!
FAVORITE QUOTE: 'dreams that were dismissed in the name of practicality and rationality' -- Gah. Plucked that feeling right out of my brain and put it into words.
- Tough family relationships
- International romantic relationships
- Changing careers
**Thank you to St. Martin's Griffin for the advanced reader copy. I received this book for free, but all thoughts are my own. – SLR🖤
Follow me on Instagram for honest reviews, bookish freebies & giveaways! 🖤 || href="https://www.youtube.com/@southernlady... ">Southern Lady Reads YouTube channel coming soon!!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
3.75 / 5 Stars
Ugh, I am such an American pleb who is just easily charmed by a British man, fictional or not. I read this so it isn’t even that I could hear his accent, but the author just made him so damn charming. I am but a simple woman. “The Odds of You” is about Sage, a writer with horrible writer’s block (with a side of imposter syndrome). On a flight to Comic Con, she meets Theo, a handsome, British man, who happens to be an actor. Sage did not recognize him but the paparazzi sure did, creating havoc online and in Sage’s head. With her deadline approaching, she escaped to Scotland (it just looked so beautiful in the pictures that Theo showed her). What are the odds that Theo will also be there? And what are the odds that they will stop denying their electric connection? I don’t remember much from my stats class but the answer is PRETTY GOOD ODDS.
You will probably like this book if you like:
✒️ Celebrity romance
🎭 British Actor MMC x American Writer FMC
✒️ Books about books (she’s an author with writer’s block)
🎭 Scottish setting
✒️ Bisexual rep and ADHD rep (FMC)
🎭 Discussions of grief and loss
Sage was a really interesting character. Writer’s block sounds HORRIBLE and I feel like I got a full, in-depth look at what it feels like to go through. Sage also feels like she is both too much and not enough, balancing on that precarious precipice at all times and I related and appreciated those feelings.. My one complaint is that around the 30% mark, I started to feel like we were getting hit over the head with her internal back and forth and I just wanted to say “I am literally the target audience. I empathize. I relate. And I get it! I understand that it is multifaceted and pervasive and affects all aspects of her life. I truly, truly get it and would love to read something more.” And thankfully, there was more external action that broke up that internal dialogue because it was starting to feel heavy handed.
Beyond being charming, Theo had depth that made him flawed in a very believable way. And their banter was great. I love a man who loves to be teased by a witty woman. Their relationship was both effervescent and fun while being serious and I was on board fully until the third act conflict. Because man, oh man, would I not be able to forgive Theo as easily as Sage did for what happened. Yes, yes, she was also at fault and yes, she worked on herself and maybe I am just a grudge holder but I would need so much more groveling to be okay.
There were a few other great aspects to the book. I also LOVE texts in a book (epistolary if you’re fancy). And this had some great exchanges between Theo and Sage and Sage and her best friends. It was delightful. Sage’s issues with her parents and Theo’s issues with his dad were interesting and added some friction for both characters to deal with in a way that felt authentic.
This was written in third person present tense which I find distracting sometimes. Sometimes everything flowed and was easy to read and sometimes I found myself stumbling over sentences. Third person present just feels like an oxymoron sometimes -- we are in the present with the character but not in their brain because it is third person -- it is just challenging for me personally. You have been warned if that matters to you too.
Thank you St. Martin’s Press and NetGalley for providing this eARC! All opinions are my own.
Publication Date: January 6, 2026
_____________________
Pre-Read Thoughts: I keep thinking that this is a STEM romance because of the odds/math implication in the title but it is very much NOT that. It’s a celebrity romance and it’s giving “Notting Hill” vibes so I’m down.
Ugh, I am such an American pleb who is just easily charmed by a British man, fictional or not. I read this so it isn’t even that I could hear his accent, but the author just made him so damn charming. I am but a simple woman. “The Odds of You” is about Sage, a writer with horrible writer’s block (with a side of imposter syndrome). On a flight to Comic Con, she meets Theo, a handsome, British man, who happens to be an actor. Sage did not recognize him but the paparazzi sure did, creating havoc online and in Sage’s head. With her deadline approaching, she escaped to Scotland (it just looked so beautiful in the pictures that Theo showed her). What are the odds that Theo will also be there? And what are the odds that they will stop denying their electric connection? I don’t remember much from my stats class but the answer is PRETTY GOOD ODDS.
You will probably like this book if you like:
✒️ Celebrity romance
🎭 British Actor MMC x American Writer FMC
✒️ Books about books (she’s an author with writer’s block)
🎭 Scottish setting
✒️ Bisexual rep and ADHD rep (FMC)
🎭 Discussions of grief and loss
Sage was a really interesting character. Writer’s block sounds HORRIBLE and I feel like I got a full, in-depth look at what it feels like to go through. Sage also feels like she is both too much and not enough, balancing on that precarious precipice at all times and I related and appreciated those feelings.. My one complaint is that around the 30% mark, I started to feel like we were getting hit over the head with her internal back and forth and I just wanted to say “I am literally the target audience. I empathize. I relate. And I get it! I understand that it is multifaceted and pervasive and affects all aspects of her life. I truly, truly get it and would love to read something more.” And thankfully, there was more external action that broke up that internal dialogue because it was starting to feel heavy handed.
Beyond being charming, Theo had depth that made him flawed in a very believable way. And their banter was great. I love a man who loves to be teased by a witty woman. Their relationship was both effervescent and fun while being serious and I was on board fully until the third act conflict. Because man, oh man, would I not be able to forgive Theo as easily as Sage did for what happened. Yes, yes, she was also at fault and yes, she worked on herself and maybe I am just a grudge holder but I would need so much more groveling to be okay.
There were a few other great aspects to the book. I also LOVE texts in a book (epistolary if you’re fancy). And this had some great exchanges between Theo and Sage and Sage and her best friends. It was delightful. Sage’s issues with her parents and Theo’s issues with his dad were interesting and added some friction for both characters to deal with in a way that felt authentic.
This was written in third person present tense which I find distracting sometimes. Sometimes everything flowed and was easy to read and sometimes I found myself stumbling over sentences. Third person present just feels like an oxymoron sometimes -- we are in the present with the character but not in their brain because it is third person -- it is just challenging for me personally. You have been warned if that matters to you too.
Thank you St. Martin’s Press and NetGalley for providing this eARC! All opinions are my own.
Publication Date: January 6, 2026
_____________________
Pre-Read Thoughts: I keep thinking that this is a STEM romance because of the odds/math implication in the title but it is very much NOT that. It’s a celebrity romance and it’s giving “Notting Hill” vibes so I’m down.
September 17, 2025
I received a free copy of, The Odds of You, by Kate Dramis, from the publisher and Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. Sage Collins is a writer, or trying to be. I could not get into this book at all. I did not care for Sage or Theo, or the language.
December 17, 2025
A swoony romance for lovers of Carley Fortune and Christina Lauren. Celebrity-author romance, fake dating and a fun romp through la la land.
Sage was once a business data analyst and has become an author. Is she a one hit wonder or does she have a second book in her? Theo is the next it-guy in Hollywood. They meet on a flight and people think they are dating because the paparazzi picked up on the chemistry. He’s Scottish. They meet in the way to comicon then they meet again when Sage travels to Scotland for writing.
This was the perfect book on audio. It was easy to follow and the performance was excellent. I really enjoyed the Scottish accent and all of the banter. Even the internal dialogue was really engaging. I found it to be very romantic. Although parts of it were definitely a little unbelievable, overall I was able to suspend disbelief in the pursuit of a lovely story.
Thanks to NetGalley and Macmillan audio for the ALC. book to be published January 6, 2026.
Sage was once a business data analyst and has become an author. Is she a one hit wonder or does she have a second book in her? Theo is the next it-guy in Hollywood. They meet on a flight and people think they are dating because the paparazzi picked up on the chemistry. He’s Scottish. They meet in the way to comicon then they meet again when Sage travels to Scotland for writing.
This was the perfect book on audio. It was easy to follow and the performance was excellent. I really enjoyed the Scottish accent and all of the banter. Even the internal dialogue was really engaging. I found it to be very romantic. Although parts of it were definitely a little unbelievable, overall I was able to suspend disbelief in the pursuit of a lovely story.
Thanks to NetGalley and Macmillan audio for the ALC. book to be published January 6, 2026.
November 5, 2025
3⭐️
A thoroughly cute story! Sage is a once-published author who has escaped to the Scottish Highlands to finish her sophomore novel and get over a series case of writers block. Theo is a newly-hot actor in town to clean out his families vacation home- and also happens to be the man Sage met at Comic Con a few weeks prior.
This was a fun read, and I really enjoyed the Scottish atmosphere. Kate Dramis did a great job setting the scene on the Isle of Skye, I really felt like I could see it in my mind.
I will say, I didn't connect with the characters. Both as individuals and as a couple, they just didn't pull me in. And I can't quite put my finger on why? I just never cared much about them tbh, even though I think they both went through some solid growth here.
Thank you to Netgalley and the publishing team for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
A thoroughly cute story! Sage is a once-published author who has escaped to the Scottish Highlands to finish her sophomore novel and get over a series case of writers block. Theo is a newly-hot actor in town to clean out his families vacation home- and also happens to be the man Sage met at Comic Con a few weeks prior.
This was a fun read, and I really enjoyed the Scottish atmosphere. Kate Dramis did a great job setting the scene on the Isle of Skye, I really felt like I could see it in my mind.
I will say, I didn't connect with the characters. Both as individuals and as a couple, they just didn't pull me in. And I can't quite put my finger on why? I just never cared much about them tbh, even though I think they both went through some solid growth here.
Thank you to Netgalley and the publishing team for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
September 24, 2025
This one was a bit of a mixed bag for me. I couldn’t really connect with Sage—her constant overthinking and self-sabotage made it tough to root for her, and after a while I found myself skimming her inner struggles. On the flip side, Theo completely won me over. He’s charming, a little vulnerable under the surface, and honestly felt like the heart of the story whenever he showed up. I just wish we’d gotten more of his perspective, especially with the whole “celebrity” setup the blurb teases.
The pacing dragged in spots, and the third-person present tense narration didn’t always work for me. But there were still moments I enjoyed—especially the quiet chapters in Scotland and the sparks of chemistry between Theo and Sage when they finally slowed down enough to be real with each other.
Overall, this read less like a sweeping celebrity romance and more like a story about creative burnout and finding yourself again. Not a bad thing, just not what I was expecting. If you go in knowing it’s heavier on personal growth than on glitzy romance, you might enjoy it more than I did.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
The pacing dragged in spots, and the third-person present tense narration didn’t always work for me. But there were still moments I enjoyed—especially the quiet chapters in Scotland and the sparks of chemistry between Theo and Sage when they finally slowed down enough to be real with each other.
Overall, this read less like a sweeping celebrity romance and more like a story about creative burnout and finding yourself again. Not a bad thing, just not what I was expecting. If you go in knowing it’s heavier on personal growth than on glitzy romance, you might enjoy it more than I did.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
December 19, 2025
So, this was really good. It was slow to start and I was a little unsure if it was going to work but once it took hold it caught me and ran!
This started with all the expected nuances of a classic rom-com with a newly successful but relatively unknown young author having a chance meeting with an up-and-coming hot new actor on a cross country flight. Where it went from there, though, was a lot about the emotional trauma that comes from personal doubt and the pressure from ourselves, social media and our families to fit into certain roles and traditional definitions of success. It all set up a touching and emotional relationship journey between the two main characters - taking them from acquaintances to friends to casual lovers to partners.
The emotional journey that Sage, the FMC, goes through to deal with her stress responses, professional and familial pressures, all exacerbated by her ADHD, was pretty well done. Having to face harsh truths about her own self-sabotage at the cost of damage to her personal and professional lives until she could work it through was a realistic storyline.
Sage’s relationship with Theo, the MMC, was also a very nice surprise. Again, at first, I wasn’t sure how it would play. Started a lot like insta-love and suffered through more than one break but they had a palpable connection and great chemistry. Their story was quite romantic, actually. I really liked who they were when they were together and watching their relationship grow. They were just really good together.
The writing was also insightful and at times really lovely, especially as Sage and Theo grew to care for and understand each other.
Enjoyable, touching book!
Thank you to NetGalley, St. Martin’s Press and the author for the opportunity to read an advance copy and share my opinions!
This started with all the expected nuances of a classic rom-com with a newly successful but relatively unknown young author having a chance meeting with an up-and-coming hot new actor on a cross country flight. Where it went from there, though, was a lot about the emotional trauma that comes from personal doubt and the pressure from ourselves, social media and our families to fit into certain roles and traditional definitions of success. It all set up a touching and emotional relationship journey between the two main characters - taking them from acquaintances to friends to casual lovers to partners.
The emotional journey that Sage, the FMC, goes through to deal with her stress responses, professional and familial pressures, all exacerbated by her ADHD, was pretty well done. Having to face harsh truths about her own self-sabotage at the cost of damage to her personal and professional lives until she could work it through was a realistic storyline.
Sage’s relationship with Theo, the MMC, was also a very nice surprise. Again, at first, I wasn’t sure how it would play. Started a lot like insta-love and suffered through more than one break but they had a palpable connection and great chemistry. Their story was quite romantic, actually. I really liked who they were when they were together and watching their relationship grow. They were just really good together.
The writing was also insightful and at times really lovely, especially as Sage and Theo grew to care for and understand each other.
Enjoyable, touching book!
Thank you to NetGalley, St. Martin’s Press and the author for the opportunity to read an advance copy and share my opinions!
December 16, 2025
4.25 stars, loved this!
The Odds of You is a well-written dive into the world our main character, Sage, who is an up-and-coming author currently facing writer’s block on her second novel, which was due like, yesterday. She decides to clear her head and escape off to a small town in Ireland, where she happens to run into a famous actor (Theo) that she had once had a chance encounter with on a flight to NYC. What are the odds of running into this handsome guy, not once, but twice? Probably pretty low!
This meet-cute story is more than just that though; it delves into both Sage and Theo’s backstories and how they are still grappling with their past in their day-to-day. I enjoyed listening to this book, and was pretty invested in consuming it as quickly as possible haha. It was well narrated which is really important to me as a listener - I am a picky one, and if I find the narrator’s voice annoying, oddly paced, etc., it can just ruin the whole book for me. Not the case here! This was very well done. I can also be pretty particular about romance novels- they need to feel realistic, not contrived or sappy, and have depth to their characters - this one checked all those boxes! I recommend checking this story out for sure.
Thank you to NetGalley, the author and publisher for the opportunity to listen to an advance copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
The Odds of You is a well-written dive into the world our main character, Sage, who is an up-and-coming author currently facing writer’s block on her second novel, which was due like, yesterday. She decides to clear her head and escape off to a small town in Ireland, where she happens to run into a famous actor (Theo) that she had once had a chance encounter with on a flight to NYC. What are the odds of running into this handsome guy, not once, but twice? Probably pretty low!
This meet-cute story is more than just that though; it delves into both Sage and Theo’s backstories and how they are still grappling with their past in their day-to-day. I enjoyed listening to this book, and was pretty invested in consuming it as quickly as possible haha. It was well narrated which is really important to me as a listener - I am a picky one, and if I find the narrator’s voice annoying, oddly paced, etc., it can just ruin the whole book for me. Not the case here! This was very well done. I can also be pretty particular about romance novels- they need to feel realistic, not contrived or sappy, and have depth to their characters - this one checked all those boxes! I recommend checking this story out for sure.
Thank you to NetGalley, the author and publisher for the opportunity to listen to an advance copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
November 19, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley, Macmillan Audio and Kate Dramis for this advanced reader copy. The following is my honest review.
The Odds of You is a book with an undeniably fun premise: a writer, a charming British actor, a little serendipity, and a dash of celebrity romance. There are moments where the story delivers on that promise (particularly in its supporting cast and in small, sharply observed emotional beats) but for me, the execution didn’t always live up to the concept.
The novel’s choice of third-person narration was a big stumbling block for me. Third person can absolutely immerse a reader when it’s handled with a strong, consistent point of view but here, the perspective often felt like a weird move. As a result, I struggled to connect emotionally with her arc, even when I could see what the story wanted me to feel.
This narrative distance ended up magnifying some of my frustrations with Sage as a character. I think she’s meant to be endearingly neurotic, relatable, a little messy in that “rom-com heroine finding her footing” way. But the third-person lens made her quirks read less like natural personality traits and more like deliberately inserted “relatable moments.” Instead of feeling charming, they sometimes edged toward performative or overly self-consciously quirky, which created friction in scenes that were clearly aiming for heart or humor.
Ironically, the supporting cast felt more like the highlight of the book. Emerson, in particular, was a standout for me—funny without trying too hard, warm without being saintly, and voiced in a way that felt authentic. In the audiobook especially, her dialogue landed well and provided some of the book’s most natural moments.
Sage’s interactions with her friends, though, sometimes leaned toward exasperation or ungratefulness in ways I wasn’t sure were intentional. When the protagonist repeatedly reacts with frustration to the people who seem to be holding her up, it can shift reader sympathy without the story really interrogating that shift.
There’s a certain meta quality to the book where Sage is a writer grappling with writer’s block. And that combined with a few references sprinkled through the narrative, create the impression of autobiographical resonance, even if that’s not the author’s intention.
This isn’t inherently a problem; plenty of writers incorporate pieces of their own creative lives into fiction. But here, those parallels sometimes made the story feel less like fully imagined fiction and more like a self-insert romantic fantasy, the kind of dreamy, wish-fulfillment setup you’d expect from vintage Wattpad days. The book even nods to Wattpad explicitly, which reinforces that tonal connection.
And then there’s Theo as the blond, blue-eyed British actor whose gentle demeanor and celebrity aura are giving major Joe Alwyn vibes. Again, this isn’t inherently negative, but it adds to the overall feeling that the novel may be drawing more from personal fantasy structures than from fully developed character studies. The result is a romance that sometimes feels less crafted than imagined.
In the end, The Odds of You is a charming setup with some bright moments, but its narrative distance and character dynamics didn’t fully work for me. Readers who love celebrity romance, writer main characters, and a touch of wish-fulfillment will likely still enjoy the ride.
The Odds of You is a book with an undeniably fun premise: a writer, a charming British actor, a little serendipity, and a dash of celebrity romance. There are moments where the story delivers on that promise (particularly in its supporting cast and in small, sharply observed emotional beats) but for me, the execution didn’t always live up to the concept.
The novel’s choice of third-person narration was a big stumbling block for me. Third person can absolutely immerse a reader when it’s handled with a strong, consistent point of view but here, the perspective often felt like a weird move. As a result, I struggled to connect emotionally with her arc, even when I could see what the story wanted me to feel.
This narrative distance ended up magnifying some of my frustrations with Sage as a character. I think she’s meant to be endearingly neurotic, relatable, a little messy in that “rom-com heroine finding her footing” way. But the third-person lens made her quirks read less like natural personality traits and more like deliberately inserted “relatable moments.” Instead of feeling charming, they sometimes edged toward performative or overly self-consciously quirky, which created friction in scenes that were clearly aiming for heart or humor.
Ironically, the supporting cast felt more like the highlight of the book. Emerson, in particular, was a standout for me—funny without trying too hard, warm without being saintly, and voiced in a way that felt authentic. In the audiobook especially, her dialogue landed well and provided some of the book’s most natural moments.
Sage’s interactions with her friends, though, sometimes leaned toward exasperation or ungratefulness in ways I wasn’t sure were intentional. When the protagonist repeatedly reacts with frustration to the people who seem to be holding her up, it can shift reader sympathy without the story really interrogating that shift.
There’s a certain meta quality to the book where Sage is a writer grappling with writer’s block. And that combined with a few references sprinkled through the narrative, create the impression of autobiographical resonance, even if that’s not the author’s intention.
This isn’t inherently a problem; plenty of writers incorporate pieces of their own creative lives into fiction. But here, those parallels sometimes made the story feel less like fully imagined fiction and more like a self-insert romantic fantasy, the kind of dreamy, wish-fulfillment setup you’d expect from vintage Wattpad days. The book even nods to Wattpad explicitly, which reinforces that tonal connection.
And then there’s Theo as the blond, blue-eyed British actor whose gentle demeanor and celebrity aura are giving major Joe Alwyn vibes. Again, this isn’t inherently negative, but it adds to the overall feeling that the novel may be drawing more from personal fantasy structures than from fully developed character studies. The result is a romance that sometimes feels less crafted than imagined.
In the end, The Odds of You is a charming setup with some bright moments, but its narrative distance and character dynamics didn’t fully work for me. Readers who love celebrity romance, writer main characters, and a touch of wish-fulfillment will likely still enjoy the ride.
November 11, 2025
I had mixed feelings on this one, although they are more related to personal preference than the quality of the story.
I really liked the main character, Sage. She was a very relatable character, I enjoyed seeing her personal progress throughout the story and I also loved her friendship with Emerson and Margot and all of their group chat conversations. Theo was nice enough but felt a bit bland and him being a famous actor played a smaller role in the story than I hoped it would.
It was well written but I found the third person present tense narration incredibly distracting, especially in the first half.
Again, my expectations were likely the problem here rather than the book itself. The blurb compares it to Notting Hill and The Idea of You, so I went in expecting a fun, escapist, ‘one of us is famous’ storyline but while the MMC’s career and the romance are still central to the plot, the main focus here is Sage’s journey to quit people pleasing and find her confidence and self-worth, which isn’t what I look for in a romance.
Overall I think it’s a good book, so if you go into this one knowing what to expect and are looking for a romance with a focus on the FMC’s emotional journey, then you’ll probably really enjoy it. It just wasn’t the perfect book for me.
I really liked the main character, Sage. She was a very relatable character, I enjoyed seeing her personal progress throughout the story and I also loved her friendship with Emerson and Margot and all of their group chat conversations. Theo was nice enough but felt a bit bland and him being a famous actor played a smaller role in the story than I hoped it would.
It was well written but I found the third person present tense narration incredibly distracting, especially in the first half.
Again, my expectations were likely the problem here rather than the book itself. The blurb compares it to Notting Hill and The Idea of You, so I went in expecting a fun, escapist, ‘one of us is famous’ storyline but while the MMC’s career and the romance are still central to the plot, the main focus here is Sage’s journey to quit people pleasing and find her confidence and self-worth, which isn’t what I look for in a romance.
Overall I think it’s a good book, so if you go into this one knowing what to expect and are looking for a romance with a focus on the FMC’s emotional journey, then you’ll probably really enjoy it. It just wasn’t the perfect book for me.
November 21, 2025
This was a soft, sweet, and simple romance, and I really had a great time reading it.
I was interested in The Odds of You mainly because it takes place in Scotland on the Isle of Skye, which I have for many years suspected is my favorite place in the world even though I haven’t actually had a chance to visit yet. I thought that Kate Dramis did such a beautiful job of showing us around Skye, describing real locations in a vibrant and enchanting way that was so easy to visualize. She filled Portree with cozy pubs, football matches, and friendly locals (and yes, darkness and rain - but in a sexy way), and overall made Scotland even more of a dream destination for me.
However, even more captivating than the perfect setting were the characters. At first, I got off to a tentative start with Sage, but only because I found her almost too relatable. I spent the first chapter or so being bombarded with more than a few of my own anxieties and insecurities. It made me nervous, because… well, part of why I’m reading is to escape my own stress. However, I wound up really enjoying Sage’s journey. I liked how she specifically said that she wanted to write because she saw herself in a book and it helped her. I guess that was Kate Dramis’ intention as well, and I thought it was cool that I did, if fact, see myself in her book.
I also thought Theo was a perfect leading man. He was such an adorable sweetheart. If I started off a little tentatively with Sage, he and his flirty banter are what grabbed my attention and sold me on their relationship. I enjoyed every moment that he was on the page. The side characters were also very fun. I especially loved Sage’s friend group. If we were to get a spin off about one of them, I’d be first in line to check it out!
My only tiny personal issue is that I cannot stand the combination of present tense and third person point of view. However, it barely bothered me with The Odds of You, because I enjoyed the story so much. Again, that’s just a personal preference, and does not in any way take away from my strong recommendation that you read this book as soon as you can! It’s expected out on January 6th, 2026.
Audiobook Note - I was lucky enough to be gifted access to both the eARC and the ALC for The Odds of You, and I went back and forth between the two. I thought that the audio performance by Georgina Sadler was wonderful. Her narration was easy and fun to listen to, but I thought she especially did a great job with her accent work. When she was reading as Theo (or other Scottish/ English/ southern) characters, she was very believable - at least to me as an American! Each character had a distinct voice. It was well done!
Thank you so much to Kate Dramis, St. Martin’s Press, Macmillan Audio and NetGalley for allowing me to enjoy this book early in exchange for my review.
I was interested in The Odds of You mainly because it takes place in Scotland on the Isle of Skye, which I have for many years suspected is my favorite place in the world even though I haven’t actually had a chance to visit yet. I thought that Kate Dramis did such a beautiful job of showing us around Skye, describing real locations in a vibrant and enchanting way that was so easy to visualize. She filled Portree with cozy pubs, football matches, and friendly locals (and yes, darkness and rain - but in a sexy way), and overall made Scotland even more of a dream destination for me.
However, even more captivating than the perfect setting were the characters. At first, I got off to a tentative start with Sage, but only because I found her almost too relatable. I spent the first chapter or so being bombarded with more than a few of my own anxieties and insecurities. It made me nervous, because… well, part of why I’m reading is to escape my own stress. However, I wound up really enjoying Sage’s journey. I liked how she specifically said that she wanted to write because she saw herself in a book and it helped her. I guess that was Kate Dramis’ intention as well, and I thought it was cool that I did, if fact, see myself in her book.
I also thought Theo was a perfect leading man. He was such an adorable sweetheart. If I started off a little tentatively with Sage, he and his flirty banter are what grabbed my attention and sold me on their relationship. I enjoyed every moment that he was on the page. The side characters were also very fun. I especially loved Sage’s friend group. If we were to get a spin off about one of them, I’d be first in line to check it out!
My only tiny personal issue is that I cannot stand the combination of present tense and third person point of view. However, it barely bothered me with The Odds of You, because I enjoyed the story so much. Again, that’s just a personal preference, and does not in any way take away from my strong recommendation that you read this book as soon as you can! It’s expected out on January 6th, 2026.
Audiobook Note - I was lucky enough to be gifted access to both the eARC and the ALC for The Odds of You, and I went back and forth between the two. I thought that the audio performance by Georgina Sadler was wonderful. Her narration was easy and fun to listen to, but I thought she especially did a great job with her accent work. When she was reading as Theo (or other Scottish/ English/ southern) characters, she was very believable - at least to me as an American! Each character had a distinct voice. It was well done!
Thank you so much to Kate Dramis, St. Martin’s Press, Macmillan Audio and NetGalley for allowing me to enjoy this book early in exchange for my review.
November 28, 2025
⭐️⭐️⭐️
🌶️🌶️ mild
Sage was a data analyst until a year ago when she became a bestselling author. After a chance encounter with a devilishly handsome man on her flight to Comic Con, she soon discovers this mystery man is actually Theo Sharpe, a breakout British actor. Unfortunately, the paparazzi have mistaken them for a couple, which cues the fans online to start harassing Sage. She needs to clear her mind to make her book’s sequel deadline, and escapes to Scotland for fresh air. Except she totally miscalculated: she escaped to the one place Theo is hiding out. What are the odds?
The premise and execution of this book are cute; what’s not to love about an author meets movie star, American meets Brit, both full of family baggage, kind of romcom? It was a fun read, and honestly I loved some of the side characters as much as, if not more than, the two main characters. (Official petition for an Emerson spin-off!) The third-person present tense narration isn’t my favorite and the plot was a bit too nonlinear for me to enjoy it more, but one thing I LOVED was Georgina Sadler’s narration! She expertly transitioned from anxious American, queer Southern twang, British man, and Scottish elder and made each and everyone believable! The narration definitely added to the overall experience of the book, so I’d recommend listening if you can!
Reviewed as part of #ARC with NetGalley. Many thanks to Macmillan Audio for the #gifted copy in exchange for an honest review.
Read this book if you:
🎥 love books about authors and movie stars
💊 adore the very British pronunciation of “paracetamol”
❄️ swoon for Jude Law’s character in The Holiday
Follow me on Instagram for more book reviews!
🌶️🌶️ mild
Sage was a data analyst until a year ago when she became a bestselling author. After a chance encounter with a devilishly handsome man on her flight to Comic Con, she soon discovers this mystery man is actually Theo Sharpe, a breakout British actor. Unfortunately, the paparazzi have mistaken them for a couple, which cues the fans online to start harassing Sage. She needs to clear her mind to make her book’s sequel deadline, and escapes to Scotland for fresh air. Except she totally miscalculated: she escaped to the one place Theo is hiding out. What are the odds?
The premise and execution of this book are cute; what’s not to love about an author meets movie star, American meets Brit, both full of family baggage, kind of romcom? It was a fun read, and honestly I loved some of the side characters as much as, if not more than, the two main characters. (Official petition for an Emerson spin-off!) The third-person present tense narration isn’t my favorite and the plot was a bit too nonlinear for me to enjoy it more, but one thing I LOVED was Georgina Sadler’s narration! She expertly transitioned from anxious American, queer Southern twang, British man, and Scottish elder and made each and everyone believable! The narration definitely added to the overall experience of the book, so I’d recommend listening if you can!
Reviewed as part of #ARC with NetGalley. Many thanks to Macmillan Audio for the #gifted copy in exchange for an honest review.
Read this book if you:
🎥 love books about authors and movie stars
💊 adore the very British pronunciation of “paracetamol”
❄️ swoon for Jude Law’s character in The Holiday
Follow me on Instagram for more book reviews!
December 26, 2025
Thank you to Macmillan Audio for the opportunity to listen and review this book as an ALC.
This is my first book by Kate Dramis, but I have her Romantasy series on my shelves waiting to be read.
I liked the FMC, Sage. She is relatable and interesting, suffering from anxiety, imposter syndrome, and perfectionism. Her insecurities and family problems really resonated with me, and her character growth throughout the story was enjoyable. One issue for me is I feel the story suffered from the amount of rumination and internal monologuing associated to this character. I felt stuck in her head versus being immersed in the story.
The MMC was a grieving, also anxious/insecure, actor, Theo. He was sweet and understanding, while also struggling with his own family and career. I kept picturing Glen Powell as this MMC (only with a British accent).
Emerson and Margot were great side characters who brought comic relief to the story. I loved that Theo’s cat was named Toothless!
The plot was slow to medium paced throughout. I was frustrated with the lack/avoidance of communication between the FMC and MMC, which seemed to move the plot forward instead of actual action/event sequences. The anxieties and insecurities of the main characters gave this story a heavy quality.
This book had spice, I would say 2.5 🌶️
The audiobook narrator did a fantastic job on the voices for each character! She went from a southern accent seamlessly into a British accent, then to an American accent. I really enjoyed listening to her voice.
Overall, I liked the writing but wanted more from the story. I liked the characters and their growth, but I was not able to feel immersed in the story. I would try other books by this author.
This is my first book by Kate Dramis, but I have her Romantasy series on my shelves waiting to be read.
I liked the FMC, Sage. She is relatable and interesting, suffering from anxiety, imposter syndrome, and perfectionism. Her insecurities and family problems really resonated with me, and her character growth throughout the story was enjoyable. One issue for me is I feel the story suffered from the amount of rumination and internal monologuing associated to this character. I felt stuck in her head versus being immersed in the story.
The MMC was a grieving, also anxious/insecure, actor, Theo. He was sweet and understanding, while also struggling with his own family and career. I kept picturing Glen Powell as this MMC (only with a British accent).
Emerson and Margot were great side characters who brought comic relief to the story. I loved that Theo’s cat was named Toothless!
The plot was slow to medium paced throughout. I was frustrated with the lack/avoidance of communication between the FMC and MMC, which seemed to move the plot forward instead of actual action/event sequences. The anxieties and insecurities of the main characters gave this story a heavy quality.
This book had spice, I would say 2.5 🌶️
The audiobook narrator did a fantastic job on the voices for each character! She went from a southern accent seamlessly into a British accent, then to an American accent. I really enjoyed listening to her voice.
Overall, I liked the writing but wanted more from the story. I liked the characters and their growth, but I was not able to feel immersed in the story. I would try other books by this author.
August 31, 2025
This just wasn’t my cup of tea but i’m sure there are others that will enjoy it!
September 3, 2025
5/5 stars
It was super important to me that I gave this book a review. My love for Kate aside, this is truly my favorite thing she has written so far. (So far, because I am sure something else will win me over again eventually)
I am beyond thankful for the privilege that I have to experience this book again for the second time and I am forever grateful I got to reread it. This book is so special to me and holds so much of my love. I have sat with this story since early 2024 (April or May, I think) and it is on my mind often.
It is a celebrity romance, sure, but it is so much more than that. It holds such a great emotional depth that it never ceases to amaze me. This isn’t just a romance book, it is a book about personal and emotional growth and being loved despite our “inside wounds”. I cannot wait for the world to get to read this one and love Sage and Theo as much as I do. MWAH.
It was super important to me that I gave this book a review. My love for Kate aside, this is truly my favorite thing she has written so far. (So far, because I am sure something else will win me over again eventually)
I am beyond thankful for the privilege that I have to experience this book again for the second time and I am forever grateful I got to reread it. This book is so special to me and holds so much of my love. I have sat with this story since early 2024 (April or May, I think) and it is on my mind often.
It is a celebrity romance, sure, but it is so much more than that. It holds such a great emotional depth that it never ceases to amaze me. This isn’t just a romance book, it is a book about personal and emotional growth and being loved despite our “inside wounds”. I cannot wait for the world to get to read this one and love Sage and Theo as much as I do. MWAH.
December 17, 2025
I enjoyed this story. I feel like a lot of people can relate to our MCs. Our FMC just keeps getting hit after hit with bad news. Not only did her book to movie adaptation fall through she's suffering from writers block. Once her and Theo the MC reconnect in Skye you really get a feel for their chemistry. You see them both dive into their personal issues. A great read if you're looking for more than just a romance story. Also, the narration was great!
Thank you Macmillan audio for the gifted audiobook.
Thank you Macmillan audio for the gifted audiobook.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
The Odds of You by Kate Dramis
⭐️⭐️⭐️
🌶
I spent 80% of this book thinking, "girl, go to therapy already."
The premise was so promising and I desperately wanted to liked this. Unfortunately, this was a complete miss for me.
There were quite a few things I enjoyed, though. Initially, this book started off strong. I loved the beginning and the meet cute. Theo was an amazing character and I enjoyed every moment he was on the page. I truly wish he had a POV because this book would have been so much better, and more readable, if he had. The friendship between the FMC and Emerson was really fun, too. The group chats and texts were all highly entertaining and made me laugh a few times. The first couple of chapters had me anticipating a great read. Then the story slowly fell off.
While I tried to like and connect with the FMC, I came up empty everytime. It felt like that scene in The Office when Stanley tells Michael everything Michael does, Stanley would do a different way. I was frequently frustrated and exasperated by the FMC. She was battling writers block and instead of trying to resolve it, kept trying to force the writing. You know what they say, doing the same thing over and over and expecting a different result is the definition of insanity. And boy, did Sage damn near drive me insane. She was a very flat and static character. Not to mention, her internal monologue was extremely repetitive. If half of the repetitive internal monologue was cut, this book would be half the length. And honestly, it'd be better for it.
The romance was quite lackluster. The MCs were way too attached, much too quickly to be believable. It didn’t help that most of their initial bonding happened at the bar, yet most of it was cut. Then, the characters later referenced multiple conversations that happened after the bar scene ended. Why not just keep the full scene then?! And while the MCs had many cute scenes together later on, none of them gave me what I needed to ship them.
I also felt no chemistry between the MCs. I have no idea why Theo would remotely like Sage, either. Theo was such a great guy. He was sweet, caring, and kind. He constantly helped her and knew what she needed. Sage, on the other hand, was exhausting. What did she do for him besides ignore his texts and have him care for her like she was a child? Girl needed therapy, not a relationship. There was only one romantic moment that gave me mild butterflies. Unfortunately, there was no tension, yearning, or chemistry to be had for the majority of the novel. The characters just didn't make sense together. But maybe if this had been a dual POV with Theo, some of these issues could have been fixed.
Another big issue I had was the setting. Most of this took place in Scotland, but there was no sense of place. No exploration. There were only brief details and a lot of telling, not showing. I wanted to see Scotland through the FMC's eyes. I wanted to go with her on the trips. Instead, she spent most of her time moping and the times she did venture out, it was told in passing.
The antagonists for the novel were massively underdeveloped. Once again, Dramis failed to show the issues with Sage's parents. Dramis did well conveying the anxiety Sage felt. But because she had so few interactions with her parents, and most of it was told, not shown, Sage's reactions felt unwarranted. I was happy when Sage finally stuck up for herself, but her reaction felt overblown and unsatisfying because there was no proper build of tension for it.
I will say the ending was cute. I'm irritated at Theo for not bringing his cat to Scotland, because wtaf. If I'm going to spend 2 months away from home a couple hours away, bet your ass my cat would be with me. Also, no explanation of how his cat was cared for. But outside of that, the ending was decent.
Overall, I wish I'd connected to the FMC and loved this. I really wanted to. But her redundant internal monologues were a massive turn off for me. There was also so much telling and not showing that hindered the story. Plus, many details felt overlooked or were only there to push the story along/benefit the character. Like Theo's cat. As I've said, this had a great premise. It started off so strong. But the entire book boiled down to the FMC desperately needing therapy, and for unknown reasons, not seeking it. Instead, the FMC was static and insufferable. With all of that, for me, it was not a story worth reading.
Thank you to Netgalley and St. Martin's Press for this eARC in exchange for an honest review.
⭐️⭐️⭐️
🌶
I spent 80% of this book thinking, "girl, go to therapy already."
The premise was so promising and I desperately wanted to liked this. Unfortunately, this was a complete miss for me.
There were quite a few things I enjoyed, though. Initially, this book started off strong. I loved the beginning and the meet cute. Theo was an amazing character and I enjoyed every moment he was on the page. I truly wish he had a POV because this book would have been so much better, and more readable, if he had. The friendship between the FMC and Emerson was really fun, too. The group chats and texts were all highly entertaining and made me laugh a few times. The first couple of chapters had me anticipating a great read. Then the story slowly fell off.
While I tried to like and connect with the FMC, I came up empty everytime. It felt like that scene in The Office when Stanley tells Michael everything Michael does, Stanley would do a different way. I was frequently frustrated and exasperated by the FMC. She was battling writers block and instead of trying to resolve it, kept trying to force the writing. You know what they say, doing the same thing over and over and expecting a different result is the definition of insanity. And boy, did Sage damn near drive me insane. She was a very flat and static character. Not to mention, her internal monologue was extremely repetitive. If half of the repetitive internal monologue was cut, this book would be half the length. And honestly, it'd be better for it.
The romance was quite lackluster. The MCs were way too attached, much too quickly to be believable. It didn’t help that most of their initial bonding happened at the bar, yet most of it was cut. Then, the characters later referenced multiple conversations that happened after the bar scene ended. Why not just keep the full scene then?! And while the MCs had many cute scenes together later on, none of them gave me what I needed to ship them.
I also felt no chemistry between the MCs. I have no idea why Theo would remotely like Sage, either. Theo was such a great guy. He was sweet, caring, and kind. He constantly helped her and knew what she needed. Sage, on the other hand, was exhausting. What did she do for him besides ignore his texts and have him care for her like she was a child? Girl needed therapy, not a relationship. There was only one romantic moment that gave me mild butterflies. Unfortunately, there was no tension, yearning, or chemistry to be had for the majority of the novel. The characters just didn't make sense together. But maybe if this had been a dual POV with Theo, some of these issues could have been fixed.
Another big issue I had was the setting. Most of this took place in Scotland, but there was no sense of place. No exploration. There were only brief details and a lot of telling, not showing. I wanted to see Scotland through the FMC's eyes. I wanted to go with her on the trips. Instead, she spent most of her time moping and the times she did venture out, it was told in passing.
The antagonists for the novel were massively underdeveloped. Once again, Dramis failed to show the issues with Sage's parents. Dramis did well conveying the anxiety Sage felt. But because she had so few interactions with her parents, and most of it was told, not shown, Sage's reactions felt unwarranted. I was happy when Sage finally stuck up for herself, but her reaction felt overblown and unsatisfying because there was no proper build of tension for it.
I will say the ending was cute. I'm irritated at Theo for not bringing his cat to Scotland, because wtaf. If I'm going to spend 2 months away from home a couple hours away, bet your ass my cat would be with me. Also, no explanation of how his cat was cared for. But outside of that, the ending was decent.
Overall, I wish I'd connected to the FMC and loved this. I really wanted to. But her redundant internal monologues were a massive turn off for me. There was also so much telling and not showing that hindered the story. Plus, many details felt overlooked or were only there to push the story along/benefit the character. Like Theo's cat. As I've said, this had a great premise. It started off so strong. But the entire book boiled down to the FMC desperately needing therapy, and for unknown reasons, not seeking it. Instead, the FMC was static and insufferable. With all of that, for me, it was not a story worth reading.
Thank you to Netgalley and St. Martin's Press for this eARC in exchange for an honest review.
December 16, 2025
This was a sweet, different kind of romance…
Sage is an author. She had a great hit with her first novel, but is having a bit of a hard time with the follow up! She boards a plane to comic con and is seated. She wants nothing more than some peace and quiet on the plane! Maybe she can get some writing time in…
Theo is an actor. A relatively new one, but already pretty well known, and, dreamy…. He boards a plane to comic con and is seated… right next to a pretty woman. Although he tries and tries to get her to talk, she wants no part of it. Then, when the stewardess comes over and starts FLIRTING with him, well, she finally takes notice.
They do end up talking a bit, and before he leaves he asks her and her friend to join him at a club in a few days, with the promise of getting them in by giving his name. They’re not going…
Until they do…
And then everything changes…
He’s caught up in a world of paparazzi, stars, glamour, photographs, and everyone following him… and groupies falling for him!
She’s a private kind of person with no interest in any of this! But all you need is just one picture…
And life as you know it can change on a dime!
Scandals arise. Ties are broken. Families get involved… and is it all worth any of this??
She escapes to Scotland for a kind of personal retreat… to concentrate on herself and her writing.✍️
But, plans don’t always go the way you think…
I absolutely loved all the characters in this one! They each had their own qualities and faults… but, we are all human! And I just loved how the families and friends were there for Sage (and Theo!)
4 solid, sappy, sweet, sometimes scary…heartfelt stars for me!! 🌟🌟🌟🌟
#TheOddsOfYou by @KateDramis. Narrated beautifully by @GeorginaSadler. (Mind you, I had to go look at the NetGalley listing as I thought it was a mistake! I would’ve sworn there were MULTIPLE narrators in this one!!)
THIS ONE IS NOT BEING RELEASED UNTIL JANUARY 6TH... SO PLEASE KEEP YOUR EYES 👀 OPEN FOR ITS RELEASE, Next Month!!!
Thanks so much to #NetGalley and #MacmillanAudio for an ALC of the audiobook in exchange for an honest review.
You can also find my reviews on: Goodreads,
Instagram: @BookReviews_with_emsr and/or
My Facebook Book Club: Book Reviews With Elaine
Thanks so much for reading! And if you ‘liked’ my review, please share with your friends, & click ‘LIKE’ below… And, let me know YOUR thoughts if you read it!! 📚⭐️
Sage is an author. She had a great hit with her first novel, but is having a bit of a hard time with the follow up! She boards a plane to comic con and is seated. She wants nothing more than some peace and quiet on the plane! Maybe she can get some writing time in…
Theo is an actor. A relatively new one, but already pretty well known, and, dreamy…. He boards a plane to comic con and is seated… right next to a pretty woman. Although he tries and tries to get her to talk, she wants no part of it. Then, when the stewardess comes over and starts FLIRTING with him, well, she finally takes notice.
They do end up talking a bit, and before he leaves he asks her and her friend to join him at a club in a few days, with the promise of getting them in by giving his name. They’re not going…
Until they do…
And then everything changes…
He’s caught up in a world of paparazzi, stars, glamour, photographs, and everyone following him… and groupies falling for him!
She’s a private kind of person with no interest in any of this! But all you need is just one picture…
And life as you know it can change on a dime!
Scandals arise. Ties are broken. Families get involved… and is it all worth any of this??
She escapes to Scotland for a kind of personal retreat… to concentrate on herself and her writing.✍️
But, plans don’t always go the way you think…
I absolutely loved all the characters in this one! They each had their own qualities and faults… but, we are all human! And I just loved how the families and friends were there for Sage (and Theo!)
4 solid, sappy, sweet, sometimes scary…heartfelt stars for me!! 🌟🌟🌟🌟
#TheOddsOfYou by @KateDramis. Narrated beautifully by @GeorginaSadler. (Mind you, I had to go look at the NetGalley listing as I thought it was a mistake! I would’ve sworn there were MULTIPLE narrators in this one!!)
THIS ONE IS NOT BEING RELEASED UNTIL JANUARY 6TH... SO PLEASE KEEP YOUR EYES 👀 OPEN FOR ITS RELEASE, Next Month!!!
Thanks so much to #NetGalley and #MacmillanAudio for an ALC of the audiobook in exchange for an honest review.
You can also find my reviews on: Goodreads,
Instagram: @BookReviews_with_emsr and/or
My Facebook Book Club: Book Reviews With Elaine
Thanks so much for reading! And if you ‘liked’ my review, please share with your friends, & click ‘LIKE’ below… And, let me know YOUR thoughts if you read it!! 📚⭐️
December 5, 2025
Thank you to St. Martin’s Press and Macmillan Audio for my gifted ALC/eARC.
I need to start by saying this voice actor was phenomenal! The way she captured so many accents and gave each character their own distinct voice truly blew me away.
The story itself was also so beautiful. It starts with a little meet-cute: author Sage ends up sitting next to movie star Noah on a plane, having no idea who he is until the paparazzi show up at the airport. Despite Sage and Noah both having a degree of fame and seeming to have it all together, at the end of the day they’re just human.
Sage is struggling with writer’s block, anxiety, family drama, and a whole lot of very relatable chaos. Noah is recovering from a tragic loss and trying so hard to be the perfect son for his father. Somehow, they fit together so perfectly, seamlessly slotting into each other’s lives and caring for one another in all the right ways.
While I really loved the love, connection, and growth we see in both Sage and Noah, what really stood out to me in this one was the exploration of parasocial relationships. As a bookstagrammer with a meager following, I can somewhat relate. The internet is scary, and people don’t seem to have filters or grace anymore. I can’t even imagine what it must be like for actual public figures. I really appreciated this whole subplot because it felt all too real and incredibly relatable.
I need to start by saying this voice actor was phenomenal! The way she captured so many accents and gave each character their own distinct voice truly blew me away.
The story itself was also so beautiful. It starts with a little meet-cute: author Sage ends up sitting next to movie star Noah on a plane, having no idea who he is until the paparazzi show up at the airport. Despite Sage and Noah both having a degree of fame and seeming to have it all together, at the end of the day they’re just human.
Sage is struggling with writer’s block, anxiety, family drama, and a whole lot of very relatable chaos. Noah is recovering from a tragic loss and trying so hard to be the perfect son for his father. Somehow, they fit together so perfectly, seamlessly slotting into each other’s lives and caring for one another in all the right ways.
While I really loved the love, connection, and growth we see in both Sage and Noah, what really stood out to me in this one was the exploration of parasocial relationships. As a bookstagrammer with a meager following, I can somewhat relate. The internet is scary, and people don’t seem to have filters or grace anymore. I can’t even imagine what it must be like for actual public figures. I really appreciated this whole subplot because it felt all too real and incredibly relatable.
November 21, 2025
This was a perfectly sweet romcom. Where an anxiety riddled people pleasing author has a chance encounter with a hot actor with an adorable accent on a plane. And then author travels to actors favorite location (Scotland, of course) for a writing retreat, and what do you know?! Actor is there. 🥰 Georgina Sadler did such a great job narrating Sage and Theo. Her accent for Theo was fantastic, and she really brought out Sage’s anxious characteristic.
There were some very sweet moments in The Odds of You (the hospital scenes, the movie watching, etc), and some moments that felt so real (over analyzing parental conversations to the point of mania). These kept me engaged in a story that I felt was a little long. Parts were slow, and then parts were so fast. The way they just kept winding up in the same places immediately after conflict were hard to believe. And I just overall had a hard time connecting with either character. I don’t think it was the third person narrative like I’ve seen others suggest, but more that these characters are very unlike myself. I was obsessed with all the ao3 references and the Jake G red scarf moment!
Overall a good first contemporary romance from Kate Dramis!
There were some very sweet moments in The Odds of You (the hospital scenes, the movie watching, etc), and some moments that felt so real (over analyzing parental conversations to the point of mania). These kept me engaged in a story that I felt was a little long. Parts were slow, and then parts were so fast. The way they just kept winding up in the same places immediately after conflict were hard to believe. And I just overall had a hard time connecting with either character. I don’t think it was the third person narrative like I’ve seen others suggest, but more that these characters are very unlike myself. I was obsessed with all the ao3 references and the Jake G red scarf moment!
Overall a good first contemporary romance from Kate Dramis!
December 23, 2025
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.25/5
Spice: 🌶️🌶️/5
Thank you so much to St. Martin’s Press for the eARC and Macmillan Audio for the ALC!
This book was so sweet, heartwarming, emotional, and had some parts where I actually LOLed. Sage is an FMC who is very relatable and has her insecurities and self-doubt, don’t we all? Theo is the CUTEST MMC and is truly green flags only. And so hot likeeee??? I can’t
Sage’s friends, Margot and Emerson, were SOO much fun to read. Emerson is my favorite and I love their group chat so much. I love how supportive they are of Sage (and Theo!)
Sage and Theo both have real struggles in their lives and they’re portrayed beautifully in this book. I had such a great time getting to know them, and I loved their banter!!!
The narrator, Georgina Sadler, was wonderful. She did an excellent job with different accents and I really enjoyed listening to her!! Definitely would do more of her audiobooks.
Spice: 🌶️🌶️/5
Thank you so much to St. Martin’s Press for the eARC and Macmillan Audio for the ALC!
This book was so sweet, heartwarming, emotional, and had some parts where I actually LOLed. Sage is an FMC who is very relatable and has her insecurities and self-doubt, don’t we all? Theo is the CUTEST MMC and is truly green flags only. And so hot likeeee??? I can’t
Sage’s friends, Margot and Emerson, were SOO much fun to read. Emerson is my favorite and I love their group chat so much. I love how supportive they are of Sage (and Theo!)
Sage and Theo both have real struggles in their lives and they’re portrayed beautifully in this book. I had such a great time getting to know them, and I loved their banter!!!
The narrator, Georgina Sadler, was wonderful. She did an excellent job with different accents and I really enjoyed listening to her!! Definitely would do more of her audiobooks.
December 10, 2025
3.5 ⭐️
The Odds of You is just so cute. Theo is an absolute sweetheart, and the banter between him and Sage had me smiling the whole time.
It has a cozy, feel good romance vibe. I loved all the movie references throughout the book, it really pulled out some nostalgia. I also loved the holiday in Scotland atmosphere.
Beyond the cozy feels, the book thoughtfully handles mental health. Sage’s journey of self discovery and healing really added depth to the story.
There were a few times the pacing felt off, but overall, I had such a fun time with it. And the audio… wow. The narrator brought every character to life, handled all the accents flawlessly, and added so much charm and I honestly can’t imagine experiencing this one any other way. 🎧
The Odds of You is just so cute. Theo is an absolute sweetheart, and the banter between him and Sage had me smiling the whole time.
It has a cozy, feel good romance vibe. I loved all the movie references throughout the book, it really pulled out some nostalgia. I also loved the holiday in Scotland atmosphere.
Beyond the cozy feels, the book thoughtfully handles mental health. Sage’s journey of self discovery and healing really added depth to the story.
There were a few times the pacing felt off, but overall, I had such a fun time with it. And the audio… wow. The narrator brought every character to life, handled all the accents flawlessly, and added so much charm and I honestly can’t imagine experiencing this one any other way. 🎧
December 22, 2025
I loved listening to The Odds of You by Kate Dramis on audio — it’s the kind of celebrity romance that blends charm, heart, and emotional depth so seamlessly. Georgina Sadler is a seriously enjoyable narrator, bringing so much warmth and engagement to the story, and she does an especially great job with Theo’s British accent and the range of supporting voices. Sage and Theo’s connection feels genuine and deeply felt, with strong characterization and thoughtful mental health rep that adds weight beneath the swoony romance. Toss in a dreamy Scottish setting for a good chunk of the book, plus a story that’s charming, sweet, and quietly sexy, and I was completely sold from start to finish.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 580 reviews