I’ve been letting it sit for a while and I’ve changed my mind—I’m giving this 5🌟. Despite some of the issues that I did have, the way I felt about this book just outweighs that. I have not read a book that has kept me up all night reading and just so exhilarated in a while. The fact that it has been a couple of days and I still think about it… The fact that I even had trouble rating it… 5🌟, all of the stars.
———
4.5 4.75 ish 🌟 rounded up
Cassandra Clare’s writing shines brightest when depicting yearning, longing, and emotional turmoil in painstaking detail. Book 2 of The Chronicles of Castellane asks, “What would you do to protect the ones you love?”—and believe me, this book answers that question in the most gut-wrenching and tormenting way.
What a strong sequel—I’m happy to report that this book had everything I wished Sword Catcher had while also expanding on the foundations laid in the first installment. I wasn’t entirely sold by Sword Catcher; at times, it felt slow and could have been edited down. But with The Ragpicker King, I was sucked in immediately. The intricate world-building, the twists, the politics, the characters—everything felt fleshed out and more refined. The book picks up months after the events of Sword Catcher, and from the very first page, you’re thrown back into the power struggles and political intrigue of Castellane. My ARC has 563 pages, yet not once did I feel like it dragged. I was so immersed in the world and the story that putting the book down felt almost painful.
I’ve seen some people say this book was slow at times, but I didn’t feel that way at all. I get why, though—it does lean heavily into politics and it just isn’t for everyone. But the last hundred or so pages? Absolutely insane. I had to take a moment every now and then just to process everything. In true Cassandra Clare fashion, the ending never misses. The pacing becomes so propulsive that you’ll fly through the final stretch, as everything unravels in a whiplash-like sequence that will leave you gasping for air.
While I predicted some of the plot twists, they were still executed perfectly. Certain character revelations were handled masterfully. Cassie is an expert at weaving intricate details—down to the smallest, minute ones—and seamlessly intertwining storylines. There were moments when I had to just sit there and stare at the wall.
The romances develop further in this book, and they are oh so forbidden. The yearning increases tenfold compared to the first book, it was torturous. There were so many gut-wrenching moments that had me silently screaming at 2 a.m. for two nights straight. I felt every ounce of heartbreak and longing in my core. But beyond the romance, the friendships in this book take center stage. Kel and Conor’s dynamic often reminded me of Will and Jem—their brotherhood is both beautiful and devastating. The way this book explores the lengths one would go to protect the other was one of my favorite aspects. In fact, I loved their relationship even more than the romantic ones. It was equal parts painful and profound, and I need more of it. I also really enjoyed the newfound friendship between The Ragpicker King’s team of bandits, Kel, and Lin. Their interactions were a highlight for me, and I always love seeing more of their dynamic.
Cassie is one of the few authors who can capture raw, complex emotions so masterfully across multiple characters. You can’t help but love and grow attached to them, even though many are morally ambiguous. And morally ambiguous they are—so much scheming, secrecy, personal ambition, lies, betrayal, and revenge, yet their choices are deeply shaped by societal expectations, responsibilities, and internal conflict. They feel so real to me.
The world-building is stunning, and the different cultures are richly detailed. I especially loved learning more about Ashkar culture and the criminal underworld of Castellane. The societal commentary woven into the story was handled with care, and I appreciate that sensitivity readers were involved. You can feel the level of detail that went into making this world feel immersive and authentic. I do feel like we haven’t explored much of the magic system yet, but I assume that will come in the next book.
I had a few issues though—for a book called The Ragpicker King, we didn’t really see much of him as I’d like. While his story plays a role in the latter portion of the book, I still wish we had gotten more of him. Similarly, it was jarring how little we saw of Conor outside of other characters’ perspectives. His transformation is frequently mentioned rather than shown, and I feel like his arc was set aside in favor of Kel and Lin’s stories. The book includes short POV chapters from various characters aside from Kel and Lin, which I loved because it provided different angles to the story. However, none of them were from Conor, which disappointed me—I would have loved to get inside his head, especially after the events of Sword Catcher. This is also why I wish the book hadn’t skipped three months ahead. That said, without saying much, I look forward to seeing him take a more active role in the next one.
Overall, this was a rich, compelling, and utterly fascinating read—full of twists, revelations, and heartbreak. The stakes were higher, the romance more developed, the pacing faster. Just brilliant. I cannot wait to see how this story wraps up, and I hope we don’t have to wait too long for Book 3.
Thank you so much Macmillan for sending me an early copy. All thoughts are my own.
———
RATING & REVIEW TO COME!!!!!