Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book
Rate this book
Brighton 1920. When the handsome Captain O'Harris invites Clara to dinner she doesn't expect to be asked to solve the mystery of his late uncle's disappearance. It seems a simple enough puzzle to unravel with an obvious suspect, but before long Clara is uncovering some very darks secrets in the O'Harris household. What does the death of a housemaid have to do with uncle Goddard's vanishing act? And could Captain O'Harris' late mother be involved in the crime? Before she knows it Brighton's first female private detective is heavily involved in a mystery that threatens to destroy the man she has grown to admire.

244 pages, Paperback

First published March 3, 2013

52 people are currently reading
36 people want to read

About the author

Evelyn James

65 books37 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
245 (42%)
4 stars
224 (39%)
3 stars
87 (15%)
2 stars
14 (2%)
1 star
3 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 20 of 20 reviews
Profile Image for Damaskcat.
1,782 reviews4 followers
October 31, 2015
Clara Fitzgerald, the only female private investigator in Brighton, meets the charismatic Captain O'Harris when he lands his plane - White Buzzard on the beach. Clara and her brother Tommy are invited to visit the Captain and he asks Clara if she will look into the mysterious death of his late uncle. Clara agrees somewhat reluctantly as she finds herself falling under the Captain's spell.

Almost as soon as she starts to investigate the case, she receives notes warning her not to look into the case. Needless to state these threats don't put her off and she is determined, once her curiosity is aroused, to find the solution to the mystery.

This is an interesting story with some well drawn characters and a convincing historical background. I like the relationship between Clara, Tommy and their less than conventional maid of all work - Annie - who is more of a friend to both of them than a servant. If you're looking for a new historical mystery series then you might be interested in this one. The books can be read as standalone novels or as part of a series. This book is the second one in the series.
Profile Image for Tony Hisgett.
2,996 reviews36 followers
December 20, 2020
In this book the murder mystery is actually a ‘cold case’, which was OK, but not as interesting as I hoped.
The thing that kept me interested during the first book was Clara’s relationship with her maid Annie and I hoped she might become more involved in Clara’s investigations, unfortunately that didn’t happen.
If possible I would have given 2.5 stars.
Profile Image for Amanda Jane.
1,337 reviews9 followers
September 1, 2019
Very good read, complex and surprising end

When Clara meets the dashing pilot Captain O'Hara, and he takes rather a shine to her, she finds herself intrigued by his family "mystery".

Some years earlier the Captain's Uncle Goddard died while smoking a cigar outside after dinner with his wife Florence and a friend Colonel Brandt. After finding his body lying prone on the grass Colonel Brandt rushes off to find a police officer while Florence goes to call their doctor. On their return the body has gone! Subsequent searches turn up nothing, there's no trace of either his body or . So who killed him and how? With two suspects and only one of the party still alive to fill in the blanks.. are they helping or hindering her investigation?

After Florence held a funeral with an empty casket and with no evidence at all the police had no choice but to close the case. Now Aunt Florence has also passed away, some time ago, leaving everything to Captain O'Hara much of which is still as Goddard and Florence left it. Will the house provide the missing links so Clara can fathom it out?

Clara is persuaded to look at the case with fresh eyes and see if she can determine who actually murdered Goddard and where his body lies. O'Hara's about to set of in his biplane to try and make a record breaking flight across the Atlantic and insists that Clara try her best to solve the mystery before he sets off.

A well written novel with plenty of twists and turns, false trails and even threatening letters trying to persuade Clara to stop digging into the past.. I didn't see the ending coming and it's certainly not the obvious conclusion.

Having read a huge number of books in this genre I commend Ms James's fresh ideas and for providing a new unexpected result.. so as not to spoil it for you all I will add is "it wasn't the butler!". I would give it more stars if I could!!
Profile Image for JJ.
406 reviews7 followers
April 7, 2018
I read the first Clara Fitzgerald book over a year ago and just thought it was ok and didn’t look out for another. However, I kept seeing that the series got favourable reviews and four or five star ratings so thought I’d try book two.
Well, I have just got book three so that should be some recommendation.
Clara and wheelchair-bound brother Tommy get involved with a dashing pilot.
He then asks Clara to see if she can find out who murdered his uncle ten years back. He has suspicions it was his aunt but sincerely hopes this was not the case, as he was quite fond of her.
Two things hinder Clara’s investigation; the passage of time and a paucity of suspects and witnesses.
She is a product of the years after WW1, when young women were modern, independent and a bit fearless, but always very polite.
Older brother Tommy suffers from PTSD, not that much was known about it in those early days. However, handicapped though he is, he is Clara’s ‘partner in crime’ and a sounding board for her ideas.
The book fairly moves along, even when Clara is unsure what direction to go in next and I found myself really interested to find out how she’d sort it all out.
Profile Image for Kerry Buchanan.
Author 16 books39 followers
September 13, 2018
Lovely, gentle, old-fashioned mystery

Thoroughly enjoyable story, but it dropped a star for the slightly erratic grammar and the habit the author has of slipping between points of view. The plot and most of the characters were sufficient, on the whole, to keep my attention but I did tsk to myself a number of times when errors distracted me from the story.
I began with a later book in the series (Ms James' grammar and tendency to head-hop is slightly better in later books), and now I'm reading the whole series from the beginning. Can't be that bad, then! I definitely intend to read on because Clara is adorable.
Profile Image for Clara Berge.
Author 4 books5 followers
August 18, 2020
This series is fun. The main characters are likable and interesting. I like the setting and window into history it gives in a fictional yet real way. Post war Britain with so many young men wounded and dead struck a chord with me in a way I've never felt it. Yet it is done so well through identifying with the characters. All in all light reading with a touch of real history.
Profile Image for Voirrey.
780 reviews8 followers
January 5, 2018
We see the characters from the first book developing further, and Clara tackling an old mystery - what happened to the uncle of their new friend and, even more mysterious, what happened to his body?

There are hints of romance, and of danger, for our central characters too.

306 reviews1 follower
December 28, 2019
The past

A past death, where the body has disappeared and the mystery never solved. A dashing pilot asks Clara to get to the bottom of the mystery and to remove suspicions about his Aunt being responsible. Another great story from the intrepid lady detective
Profile Image for Helen Miller.
72 reviews
August 5, 2020
The twenties in a nutshell

The Clara Fitzgerald mysteries are totally charming. The characters are well written. Even though I had worked out the answer well before the end I enjoyed the story.
Profile Image for Ruth.
4,698 reviews
September 11, 2020
A between the wars cozy mystery. I’m not quite sure if the author manages to convey the building relationships but apart from the odd since or two, it was an enjoyable and quick read. Recommended to the normal crew.
337 reviews1 follower
February 17, 2021
A cracking good read

This series is brilliant,the characters are really well written and enjoyable to read I would recommend this book to anyone who enjoys cosy mystery stories, can't wait for the next one.
129 reviews2 followers
November 21, 2022
Love it

This second book I read of the series and I am so pleased there is over 20 more still to read . I love the characters especially Clara she is one determined lady and for change she has the police helping her
1 review
June 26, 2018
Another great story I hope tuo get the full set.

Another great story .l hope to get the full set. We could with a few more ,Clara*s on this world
10 reviews
August 11, 2018
Interesting

Very good and enthralling story, I really enjoyed it. Interesting ending. And I am looking forward to reading the next ot
Profile Image for Claire Barker.
13 reviews4 followers
September 12, 2018
Couple of historical inaccuracies and some proof reading needed. I.e.missing commas and question marks, as well as 'conscience' being used for 'conscious.'

Overall a light and entertaining read.
788 reviews13 followers
April 7, 2025
Clara is hired by a former WW1 pilot to uncover what happened to his late uncle. The uncle had apparently died while smoking in his garden 10 years earlier but his body vanished.
164 reviews3 followers
May 26, 2025
Very enjoyable

This was much better than the first book! I actually felt myself back in the 1920s! I wonder how old Clara is though and what year the book was set in!
Profile Image for Paula.
609 reviews3 followers
January 17, 2022
Another mystery solved and I am SO enjoying these books!!

On to book number three as I cannot wait to delve into another mystery….

Will Clara EVER get it together with Oliver Bankes, the sweet photographer? Will Tommy EVER get it together with Annie? Will Tommy EVER realise his legs work and he CAN walk?? All these questions to be answered in this 23 book series….. I hope!!!

Fans of Agatha Christie will adore these 1920’s mysteries as they have a good plot, decent amount of characters and suspects, a smidge of “will they, won’t they?” romance, and a good old murder thrown in!! What’s not to like on these cold, winter evenings but a murder mystery and an ice cold Gin?!!
Profile Image for Johanna.
222 reviews26 followers
March 31, 2017
I enjoyed this one slightly less than the first book, mostly because the mystery just didn't gab me quite as much.
But the characters are still enjoyable and fun, their relationships are further developed and we learn new things about them.
A nice read for the holidays. ^^
Displaying 1 - 20 of 20 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.