eARC gifted by author in exchange for an honest review. Thank you!
2/5 🌟
2/5 🌶
So. As a self-proclaimed Mimi Grace stan account, I feel I should explain myself...
Ever since I first read Mimi Grace's Lovestuck series, I've been absolutely obsessed with anything she has ever written. That's why I was so beyond excited when I saw the announcement that a new book was coming out in July and when I saw that ARC sign ups were open, I immediately JUMPED on it. Before I go into my review, I want to make one thing clear: just because I didn't necessarily love this book, it does not mean that this book (or any of Mimi Grace's other books) are not worth reading. I absolutely adore all her backlog, so I very much see my lack of enjoyment while reading this book as a blip. I will still very patiently wait until Mimi Grace's next release and read that as soon as it is released, like always. Now, for the review.
The premise of this story is super fun: it follows a professional matchmaker, Mary, who has to take on disgruntled (and frankly pretty cynical) journalist and radio host, Ruben, as a client after a fairly unpleasant radio interview where he disparages matchmaking after it generates a buzz for both their companies. Mary is now in charge of trying to find Ruben his perfect match in order to impress her boss while Ruben has to do his best to navigate the matchmaking scene to film a feature to also appease his own boss. Of course, as one can expect, things don't go totally to plan. I was obsessed with this set up!
I didn't realise how much I needed something fluffy to read until I read this! I feel lately a lot of romances have been delving into more intense topics, which its fine, but at times it is good to have a break. In fact, I am happy to announce that this book doesn't only have dual POV but also doesn't have a third act break up!!!!! It's been a while that I've read a romance where this was the case, so this was also a very welcome change. I'm very much a sucker for stories where the book is just the main characters coming to terms with their true feelings for each other (and we are in both their heads), so I was happy that this was the case here too. Even if at times he was a bit of a blank slate, I really liked Ruben by the end. At first, I found him a bit boring because I felt he didn't really have much going for him as a character; he kind of just did things but his motivations were not always clear and felt a bit too overly convenient for the plot. However, by the end, I kind of just saw him as a going-with-the-flow kind of dude which was refreshing. I find that authors are typically not really able to write a character like that without making them seem immature, but I was happy that this was not the case here! Also, like all Mimi Grace books, the spicy scene was excellent!
Despite this book having all the ingredients for me to become totally obsessed with, it missed on the most important aspect of a love story: the romance. I just didn't believe in Mary and Ruben's romance at all. It's not even that it was bad, boring, or cringy, but more that it was non-existent. When Ruben came out saying that he loved Mary, I kept questioning how??? I felt they barely knew each other and hadn't really built any foundation for why they would love each other. I also sadly felt their chemistry was just not there. The book kept inferring that they had this tension between them but I did not feel it. There's instances where we are told that Mary and Ruben are interacting with each other, but that's it. We are told, not shown. Of course I could tell that there was an attraction there and it made sense they would want to explore it, but I was not that sure about the claim that they were in love by the end. It is hard to fully sell a love story if we are rarely privy to them actually building their relationship with each other. I think this skirting around the relationship also exacerbated another issue I had with this book: the at times unnatural interactions, behaviours and dialogue characters had with one another. It was really hard (and still is, if I am honest) to know if this was an issue with the writing or us missing some vital information that made how the characters interacted make sense. I am typically pretty forgiving when it comes to this when reviewing an indie book, but there were definitely a good amount of times that I just could not understand the logic behind so many decisions that it would feel weird not to mention it.
Overall, would I recommend this book? It pains me to say this, but it depends. I personally think that Mimi Grace has many other books which are much better than this one that I would recommend instead. Although this has the building blocks of a great story, I think the narrative and characters are a bit too flat. It was not necessarily a 'bad book', so I would still tell people to test it out for themselves.