When in Rockland, Maine, I often splurge on a book that I wouldn't otherwise buy. Hello, Hello Books is the cutest little bookstore with a groovy vibe and lots of books personally recommended by the owner. Plus I'm always there on vacation, so why wouldn't I be feeling good?
I saw "Rock, Meet Window" at Hello Hello earlier this month, hardcover, but on sale. I opened and read the first page. In my house we call this the first page test. My wife will often take 8-10 books off the shelf at home and just read the first page of each one to see which is most promising. Sometimes we read them aloud together. (Then again, sometimes we don't.) So, I read the first page and it was fun, funny, easy. Then it was time to go. I didn't buy the book, but tucked it in the back of my mind. Later, I checked the library website - not available. I also poked around for it online. It was similarly priced. I decided to go back and buy it at Hello, Hello. Duh. I shoulda done that in the first place.
My daughter and I read the first section out loud, about how the author's father force-fed him a beet when he was a kid. We were in a grand mood, we both laughed, looked funny while laughing, noticed each other's funny looking faces, and laughed some more. Worth the price right there.
Over the past week or so, I read the rest. Jason Good tells the emotional story of his father's battle with leukemia alongside many trips to his childhood, visits to his favorite parenting moments, and a forthright look at a grown-man's relationship with his father. Man to man relationships are funny and not in a good way. Mostly I've found them awkward and hard to negotiate. This one is no different.
Still, there isn't enough story here and there's too much thinking aloud. I wasn't amused by the inevitable medical marijuana section (I'm a stick in the mud, I guess), and I thought the funny parenting moments were all-right, but I wouldn't have included most in a book. Jason Good's writing feels honest and courageous, though. That's pretty cool.
And, the end was good. Maybe I'll read that section to my daughter, too, and see if we can laugh some more.
It appears Jason Good came up with a great opening bit, and nice closing piece, and figured following along with his feelings during his dad's struggle would be enough to satisfy in the middle. It wasn't enough, at least not for me. I'm a tough critic, though. Maybe you'll like it better.