Exposing the ableism underlying medical innovation
As medical advancements continue to shape the detection, diagnosis, and treatment of disability and illness, technology is often presented as a pathway to autonomy. Challenging this assumption, Rebecca Monteleone shows how medical technologies contribute to a cruel double bind, forcing disabled people to be accountable for adapting to a world built by and for nondisabled people while dismissing their lived experiences in favor of medical expertise. Far more complex than simple progress, these technologies are more oppressive than liberating when they place the burden of care on individuals and perpetuate societal ableism that demands that bodies look, move, and function in certain ways. The Double Bind of Disability examines the complex relationship between medical technologies and their users, highlighting tensions between personal responsibility and medical authority. Sharing the perspectives and experiences of users of three medical technologies (prenatal genetic screening, deep brain stimulation, and do-it-yourself artificial pancreas systems), Monteleone analyzes how users navigate the constraints of these systems and also imagine a new, more liberatory approach to healthcare. Asserting a bold vision, Monteleone describes a future where medical interventions take seriously the lived expertise of disabled people to address ableist infrastructures rather than require the modification of nonnormative bodyminds. She calls for a radical reimagining of medical technology that moves beyond individualistic frameworks to embrace collective experience and embodied knowing. Retail e-book files for this title are screen-reader friendly.
In The Double Bind of Disability, Monteleone uses three case studies of medical technology to compare and contrast the experiences of people with disabilities in their interactions with medical technology. The Double Bind refers to contradictions built into the situation/ treatment, most typically where medical professionals demand users demonstrate personal responsibility yet the agency, knowledge, and perspective of users are undermined. This diminishes the success of the technology in improving the everyday lives of its users. The Intro and chapter one are written in an academic style and may be difficult for non-academics to follow. The three case study chapters have important contributions to scholarship, but are written in a more accessible style, including many compelling quotes from the users of medical technology. I will keep this review short as it will be reviewed in many journals. I highly recommend for academics interested in disability, medicine, health, and technology.