* I received this book in exchange for my honest review *
Divided is a fine book. It had ups and downs, but that's the gist of it. If you want a more detailed review, here are the things I saw as ups and downs:
Let me say this: Eloise Dyson writes well, the flow of the story is pleasant, it has action and heart. But there are some flaws that stopped me from enjoying it completely.
The premiss is interesting, even if it is confusing. I really like dystopian worlds, and this one has tribes that were forced into a more primitive living, government compounds that train teens, and brain enhancements. Fun, right? Yes, but too bad it doesn't hold up that well as a cohesive world. It isn't one of those stories where you don't get answers. There are a lot of things that are explained, and that is satisfying. But that is it: they are explained. Always explained, never discovered, or unveiled. Also, things seem to fall perfectly into place so the main chatacters find out what they need to find out in order for the story to move along.
The characters were something else I had trouble with. The book is writen in the first person perspective, from Arys', Kai's, Kayra's and Phillip's points of view, thus giving us a chance to get to know their voices. But even with that, I wasn't able to relate to them. They were "likable" enough, smart enough, flawed enough. They were Ok. But they didn't speak to me. No personality traits they have really stood out, "good" or "bad". They weren't particularly true to the slight traits they seem to have, either. Not that people are cohesive all the time, but at least for the most part, right? It also annoyed me how trusting Arys and Kayra are. Especially Arys, who was raised in the tribes. She should know better than to let people she barely knows have experiments done to her, or to tell her biggest secrets to people she just met. And the worst part is, they miraculously are all thrustworthy (or are they?).
I couldn't understand the motivation behind the bad guys either. Sure, I understood what happened. But why did they do it? That was the other confusing part, and where it crashed with the cohisiveness of the world that was being built.
What I did like about it is that it makes you think about what you have and what you don't in your life. The issue of freedom, especially. Freedom is relative: It's a feeling and a belief, rather than an absolute truth. There's freedom in the Compound, and there's freedom within the tribes. And there's imprisonment there too, in both situations. But is there freedom in a Hunter's life? Could there be freedom in lies and obscurity? It reminded me of a Nelson Mandela quote: "for to be free is not merely to cast off one's chains, but to live in a way that respects and enhances the freedom of others". And how often is that possible? How often are we strong enough to do that? Those are questions raised by this book, and I liked it that much more for it.
This book might not be the best dystopian I've ever read, but I do believe fans of dystopian urban fantasy will enjoy it.
My rating: 3.5/5
Would I read it again? Probably not...
Will I read the next one in the series? Maybe, we'll see when it comes out.
Do I recommend it? Yes, but to big fans of YA dystopian stories only.