Note: Winter Duet is the second book in Echoes, a true series. The story starts in Shadowboxing, and the books are best read in order.
A true five-star read, Winter Duet by Anne Barwell exemplifies the best in historical romance. In addition to creating a love story that is heartwarming and heartrending by turns, the author deftly handles a difficult period in world history, and more specifically one of the most horrific eras in Germany—the reign of Hitler’s Third Reich, and World War II.
Wartime romance is a theme often explored in mainstream literature, and with good reason. People who confront mortality—their own and that of those close to them—live day by day or minute by minute. Emotions run high, as does the need for comfort and the affirmation of life. It’s no secret that war breeds a baby boom, but the need is more than sex drive; sex can only address a part of the desperation of living in a warzone, and people who are thrown together under such circumstances share an experience others can only guess or wonder at. It’s a door opener, allowing romance and love, and even true friendship to enter.
Leave it to Anne Barwell to tackle M/M romance in wartime. In the first novel in her Echoes series, Shadowboxing, main character Dr. Kristopher Lehrer painfully comes to face two important truths: First, he must face the fact that the project he is working on as a nuclear physicist is not going to be put to peaceful use by the Nazi party. And second, the love he has hoped for all his life will never blossom with any woman; he needs a man. He needs the right man. He is aided to escape the Nazi regime by Michel, a member of an international resistance team, and despite their always-imminent danger of discovery or death as the story unfolds, love takes root.
In Winter Duet the second book in the series, the author takes us through the second stage of their escape to safety. Tension runs even higher as the men are separated and find themselves in increasingly dangerous situations. Bombs are dropping, and the populace is in chaos. Injured and dead and orphaned are everywhere, the Reich continues its manhunt for the Doctor, and it’s impossible to know who to trust.
Barwell has woven this novel skillfully, interlacing important secondary characters, and the start-and-stop, agonizingly separate progress of Kristopher and Michel as well as other members of the resistance team. She’s made a tapestry of a bleak winter, bringing vividly to life the fears, hopes, loves, successes, failures, tears, and yes, even occasional laughter of her characters. She doesn’t slow the story for unimportant details, but doesn’t miss any of the important ones. She doesn’t break the suspense with meandering description, but gives us just what we need to “be there,” living the story. The romance is slow but strong, the sex infrequent but blazing hot. :) A detail that I love? Music. Kristopher is a violinist, and that becomes important.
I, like many in my generation, had parents who lived through this time in history. My mother was German, a young woman in the 1940s, and lived with the propaganda, the shortages, displacement, bombings, spiraling chaos, and loss of loved ones. Some writers have gone wrong in my estimation by depicting the German people as of one cloth—black as death. I appreciate that Anne has painted Germany with an honest brush, showing a country ravaged by war, where the leadership may have been demonic in character, but the people were no more or less evil than people in any place or time.
Often, even with a five-star review, I’ll mention something that didn’t quite suit, but I really don’t have anything like that to say about this novel. Barwell's prose style makes it easy to become fully involved in the story, and her characters are well-realized, with fears and flaws like any living person, and for whom life is difficult, but worth the effort. I recommend this book to readers who like to be immersed in another place and time, who enjoy romance that grows organically and becomes beautiful, who enjoy characters who don’t get stuck in any trope, and readers who are looking more for a good read than a light one.