What do you think?
Rate this book
Monster Hunter #4
Monster in the Moonlight
Do werewolves exist? That’s the question skeptical cryptozoologist Morgan Carter has to answer in the latest entry in this USA Today bestselling mystery series.
The discovery of a dead body along Bray Road in Wisconsin sparks rumors of The Beast of Bray Road, a werewolf-like creature that is said to inhabit the area.
The dead woman has been mutilated by some kind of large animal. The community is convinced that the legendary beast is not only real but responsible for this brutal killing. In an effort to prove them wrong, the police bring in cryptozoologist Morgan Carter, who soon finds that the mystery runs considerably deeper than whether or not one mythical predator is on the prowl.
The discovery of a dead body along Bray Road in Wisconsin sparks rumors of The Beast of Bray Road, a werewolf-like creature that is said to inhabit the area.
The dead woman has been mutilated by some kind of large animal. The community is convinced that the legendary beast is not only real but responsible for this brutal killing. In an effort to prove them wrong, the police bring in cryptozoologist Morgan Carter, who soon finds that the mystery runs considerably deeper than whether or not one mythical predator is on the prowl.
336 pages, Hardcover
Published January 27, 2026
77 people are currently reading
8359 people want to read
About the author
Annelise Ryan
19 books1,160 followersAnnelise Ryan is a pseudonym for Beth Amos, the USA Today bestselling author of 30 novels, including the Monster Hunter Mysteries featuring cryptozoologist and bookstore owner, Morgan Carter, the Mattie Winston mystery series, featuring a wryly cynical nurse-turned-coroner, and the Helping Hands Mysteries featuring social worker Hildy Schneider.
In addition, she is the author of the Mack's Bar Mystery series written as Allyson K. Abbott and five standalone paranormal thrillers written as Beth Amos.
She is a retired emergency room nurse living in Wisconsin. There are several reasons why she decided to use pseudonyms, not the least of which was that her ER patients might not have been comfortable knowing she spent her spare time thinking up clever ways to kill people.
In addition, she is the author of the Mack's Bar Mystery series written as Allyson K. Abbott and five standalone paranormal thrillers written as Beth Amos.
She is a retired emergency room nurse living in Wisconsin. There are several reasons why she decided to use pseudonyms, not the least of which was that her ER patients might not have been comfortable knowing she spent her spare time thinking up clever ways to kill people.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 43 reviews
September 26, 2025
Monster in the Moonlight is another entertaining installment in the Monster Hunter series. And, I mean, these novels are rather formulaic — if you've read the previous books, you have a pretty good idea of how this one is going to play out. There's a murder and a cryptid hunt (this time for the Beast of Bray Road, a werewolf-like creature supposedly stalking the town of Elkhorn, Wisconsin) and drama with ol' Flatfoot Sanders. All of the usual characters make an appearance, including Rita, Devon, and the bestest boy Newt. Newt, as always, is the real MVP of the story and he deserves all of the cheeseburgers. (Trigger warning: dog abuse. At one point Morgan promises Newt a cheeseburger and doesn't deliver UNTIL THE FOLLOWING DAY!)
Previous Monster Hunter books have been light and fluffy reads, and this one is no exception. But the mystery is solid (as long as you're willing to suspend some disbelief) and the characters likeable, and I enjoyed learning about the Beast of Bray Road (a cryptid I'd never heard of before). I did guess who or what was responsible for the murders well before Morgan did, but the way she goes about solving the case is definitely creative. It's not fine literature, but it's fun.
I do think, however, that this book kind of misrepresents Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder. At one point Morgan states that “OCD isn't necessarily a bad thing” and then the characters go on to discuss how organized the “OCD”-afflicted person is. OCD is washing your hands over and over until they bleed or not being able to leave the house because you're terrified that you'll leave the stove on; it's not liking your living space clean and being really good at making lists. Sigh.
But, still, this is an enjoyable read and it's full of Newt the Good Boy and cryptids and werewolf talk and a cop who moonlights as a romance novel writer, and I can't complain too much. I'm already looking forward to the next installment — it sounds like some pretty big changes are coming to Morgan's cryptid-hunting operation!
3.75 stars, rounded up.
Many thanks to NetGalley and Berkley for providing me with an advance copy of this book to review. Its expected publication date is January 27, 2026.
Previous Monster Hunter books have been light and fluffy reads, and this one is no exception. But the mystery is solid (as long as you're willing to suspend some disbelief) and the characters likeable, and I enjoyed learning about the Beast of Bray Road (a cryptid I'd never heard of before). I did guess who or what was responsible for the murders well before Morgan did, but the way she goes about solving the case is definitely creative. It's not fine literature, but it's fun.
I do think, however, that this book kind of misrepresents Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder. At one point Morgan states that “OCD isn't necessarily a bad thing” and then the characters go on to discuss how organized the “OCD”-afflicted person is. OCD is washing your hands over and over until they bleed or not being able to leave the house because you're terrified that you'll leave the stove on; it's not liking your living space clean and being really good at making lists. Sigh.
But, still, this is an enjoyable read and it's full of Newt the Good Boy and cryptids and werewolf talk and a cop who moonlights as a romance novel writer, and I can't complain too much. I'm already looking forward to the next installment — it sounds like some pretty big changes are coming to Morgan's cryptid-hunting operation!
3.75 stars, rounded up.
Many thanks to NetGalley and Berkley for providing me with an advance copy of this book to review. Its expected publication date is January 27, 2026.
October 20, 2025
Monster in the Moonlight
by Annelise Ryan
I thought this was going to be a mystery with some paranormal aspects but it was just a great mystery that teased me about the supernatural bit. I loved it anyway. A very good mystery with buried treasure, an unknown creature, a killer on the loose, and interesting side stories, too.
I enjoyed the characters, plot, and world-building. The clues and investigations were even suspenseful at times. The main character, Morgan, is an expert on cryptids. Some in this town believed the "Monster" on Bray Rd was a werewolf so she was consulted. She also has a big lovable dog named Newt.
I think he is my favorite character. I am certainly going to get this author's earlier books in this series and catch up!
I want to thank the publisher and NetGalley for letting me read this terrific book!
by Annelise Ryan
I thought this was going to be a mystery with some paranormal aspects but it was just a great mystery that teased me about the supernatural bit. I loved it anyway. A very good mystery with buried treasure, an unknown creature, a killer on the loose, and interesting side stories, too.
I enjoyed the characters, plot, and world-building. The clues and investigations were even suspenseful at times. The main character, Morgan, is an expert on cryptids. Some in this town believed the "Monster" on Bray Rd was a werewolf so she was consulted. She also has a big lovable dog named Newt.
I think he is my favorite character. I am certainly going to get this author's earlier books in this series and catch up!
I want to thank the publisher and NetGalley for letting me read this terrific book!
Read
December 30, 2025Is there a werewolf out in the woods near Elkhorn, Wisconsin? Is Al Capone’s treasure hidden nearby? Cryptozoologist and cult bookstore owner, Morgan Carter, gets called in once again to investigate a death where a legendary creature might be involved.
Monster in the Moonlight is the fourth of the Monster Hunter Mysteries series. Though the mysteries are standalone, there is an ongoing development of characters and relationships so it works best read in order.
My full review will post at The Reading Frenzy TBA.
Monster in the Moonlight is the fourth of the Monster Hunter Mysteries series. Though the mysteries are standalone, there is an ongoing development of characters and relationships so it works best read in order.
My full review will post at The Reading Frenzy TBA.
Currently reading
January 21, 2026ARC received! Thank you, Berkley!
I think this series is so fun and cozy. I've enjoyed them all, so def looking forward to this latest installment, which I've gotta say is my favorite cover thus far!
I think this series is so fun and cozy. I've enjoyed them all, so def looking forward to this latest installment, which I've gotta say is my favorite cover thus far!
January 14, 2026
Another fun installment in the Monster Hunter series. The werewolf storyline was great, and the mystery was genuinely fun to watch unfold. I’ve loved every book in this series so far, and this one kept the momentum going with its mix of humor, heart, and supernatural intrigue. I can’t wait for book 5.
January 27, 2026
Morgan and her trusted sidekick Newt are back investigating a mysterious death linked to the infamous Beast of Bray Road. Locals blame a werewolf-like creature is responsible for the killing. Not entirely convinced, Morgan joins forces with the local detective as strange artifacts and shady characters have her staking out the Monster in the Moonlight.
Now fourth book in, I’m a huge fan of this cozy monster hunting mystery. The author creates very intriguing puzzles that are super fun to solve. I love the balance between historical and paranormal themes, as well as the Midwest setting. It’s a great mix of investigative procedural storytelling with imaginative cryptid lore, I’m a bit of a sucker for!
I greatly appreciated Morgan’s growth in this book, her and Jon finally have their heart-to-heart. The possibilities and new revelations in her parents’ deaths has me looking forward to the next installment! And lastly, Newt was the goodest best boy in the world.
Huge thanks to Berkley and Netgalley for the advance review copy.
Now fourth book in, I’m a huge fan of this cozy monster hunting mystery. The author creates very intriguing puzzles that are super fun to solve. I love the balance between historical and paranormal themes, as well as the Midwest setting. It’s a great mix of investigative procedural storytelling with imaginative cryptid lore, I’m a bit of a sucker for!
I greatly appreciated Morgan’s growth in this book, her and Jon finally have their heart-to-heart. The possibilities and new revelations in her parents’ deaths has me looking forward to the next installment! And lastly, Newt was the goodest best boy in the world.
Huge thanks to Berkley and Netgalley for the advance review copy.
November 30, 2025
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for this ARC!
Full disclosure - when I requested this I wasn’t aware this was fourth in a series. But thankfully enough backstory was provided that the story and characters made perfect sense without having read them.
Overall this was a fun little whodunnit with a side of the paranormal. Morgan is a cryptozoologist who is approached by a detective to help with a possible werewolf case. A woman has been killed in an area famous for werewolf sightings. However, Morgan’s investigation might point toward something more sinister.
I thought this was enjoyable yet simple. The pacing was a bit slow to start and the climax/resolution rushed. Also it was a lot of tell not show which is not my favorite form of writing. Overall, I’d recommend this series if you like paranormal creatures as well as good ol’ detective stories.
Full disclosure - when I requested this I wasn’t aware this was fourth in a series. But thankfully enough backstory was provided that the story and characters made perfect sense without having read them.
Overall this was a fun little whodunnit with a side of the paranormal. Morgan is a cryptozoologist who is approached by a detective to help with a possible werewolf case. A woman has been killed in an area famous for werewolf sightings. However, Morgan’s investigation might point toward something more sinister.
I thought this was enjoyable yet simple. The pacing was a bit slow to start and the climax/resolution rushed. Also it was a lot of tell not show which is not my favorite form of writing. Overall, I’d recommend this series if you like paranormal creatures as well as good ol’ detective stories.
November 29, 2025
I’ve really enjoyed my binge of this whole series. Cryptids make me so happy and these books have become comfort reads for me. This newest addition is no exception! Morgan is such a fun and quirky character and I love how she dives headfirst into her cases. Newt continues to be a main character and I love him so much! He’s such a great companion to Morgan. This particular installment focuses on The Beast of Bray Road aka …. A werewolf? Vicious and deadly attacks have left locals scared and there have been recent sightings of a werewolf-like creature. If you want to know what Morgan uncovers in this case you’ll just have to read it and find out!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This is the first of the Monster Hunter series that I physically read and it kept me engaged and entertained just as the previous audiobooks have! This was a big relief! I truly enjoy this series and Monster in the Moonlight not only introduces a new cryptid, Morgan's scientific and reasonable approach to Plausable Existability, as well as a continuation in her own personal saga.
This author's writing is approachable and cozy yet analytical and intriguing. The Cozy Cryptid Mystery sub genre is one of the best additions to the reading world.
This author's writing is approachable and cozy yet analytical and intriguing. The Cozy Cryptid Mystery sub genre is one of the best additions to the reading world.
January 25, 2026
My ARC was provided by the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. The author has really hit her stride in this installment of the series. We have the short arc of the immediate investigation as well as the long arc of her trauma following the murder if her parents as well as her struggling relationship with local lawman, Jon. We see a new wrench thrown into the mix here and can’t wait to see where that takes them!
January 27, 2026
Synopsis: Cryptozoologist Morgan Carter is called to assist in a murder investigation in a small town where the locals are convinced the culprit is The Beast of Bray Road.
Thoughts: Though this is book four, it can be read as a standalone. There’s a bit of backstory you’ll be missing out on with some character relationships, but the mystery plot is fully standalone. These books are all cozy mysteries, and this one is cozy while still having a very solid murder mystery case. The characters are likable and fun, and the cryptozoologist spin makes for a unique read.
Read this if you like:
🐺 cryptids
🐺 murder mystery
🐺 werewolves
🐺 dog sidekick
🐺 quirky characters
Thoughts: Though this is book four, it can be read as a standalone. There’s a bit of backstory you’ll be missing out on with some character relationships, but the mystery plot is fully standalone. These books are all cozy mysteries, and this one is cozy while still having a very solid murder mystery case. The characters are likable and fun, and the cryptozoologist spin makes for a unique read.
Read this if you like:
🐺 cryptids
🐺 murder mystery
🐺 werewolves
🐺 dog sidekick
🐺 quirky characters
October 6, 2025
I'm really disappointed in my response to this one, but I think I may be done with this series... I really enjoyed the first and third books; the second was not my favorite, but I still found it a positive reading experience. This time around though, I felt like I was reading a rehash of the first books, albeit with a different creature and a different location. The interpersonal relationships also felt like I'd experienced them before, over and over again. The arguments over recklessness. The struggle to trust. The potential-love-triangle with the local law. The slobbering dog. The creature-that-isn't-a-creature. It's formulaic - and while that doesn't have to be a problem in a cozy series, here it was for me. I just couldn't generate much interest in seeing it all play out this time around... I skimmed, because I'd seen other reviewers mention a new direction that comes about at the end. There is something to that, but ultimately I'm not sure how much it'll really change things - and I'm not sure how interested I am in finding out...
This series may have played itself out for me. I just don't know how many more times I can watch Morgan throw herself in harm's way with no one but her dog for backup, or how many more cryptid-or-no Midwestern quests I can take. I was hoping to see more develop in the David/dead parents mystery storyline here, so if the next book offered up more in that direction I *might* be willing to give it another go - otherwise, I might be done.
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for my obligation-free review copy.
This series may have played itself out for me. I just don't know how many more times I can watch Morgan throw herself in harm's way with no one but her dog for backup, or how many more cryptid-or-no Midwestern quests I can take. I was hoping to see more develop in the David/dead parents mystery storyline here, so if the next book offered up more in that direction I *might* be willing to give it another go - otherwise, I might be done.
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for my obligation-free review copy.
January 28, 2026
Morgan Carter has spent her life looking for bigfoot. For all cryptids, actually. Her parents were fascinated by cryptids, and she traveled with them when they were on a case. So she grew up and became a cryptozoologist herself, and now she gets called in to consult on cases that police find hard to understand.
In Elkhorn, Wisconsin, a woman was found brutally beaten. She had been alone in the woods, close to where a local man had seen something unusual in the fields just days before. He’d been alone, dumped in the woods by coworkers who thought it would be funny, and he’d been drinking. But after realizing his friends had left him alone and cold in the woods, and then stumbling and hurting his ankle, he sobered up pretty quickly. So he was certain that what he had seen, a hairy creature on two feet, had been real. It just wasn’t anything he could readily identify. He had heard a howling just after seeing the beast, so he thought it was the local cryptid, the Beast of Bray Road. A werewolf.
Local police detective Wyatt Moorhead asks Morgan for help. It doesn’t help anyone to stir up the rumors about the Beast of Bray Road, but he can’t explain the scratches they found on the woman’s body or her car. So Morgan packs up a few essentials and her dog Newt and heads for Elkhorn. And while everyone is focused on the wounds on the woman’s body and what kind of creature could have made them, Morgan is focused on another question completely. What was this woman doing in the woods all alone in the middle of the night?
Morgan learns that the woman had been widowed by a car accident that had left her grown son in a wheelchair. She wanted to move somewhere that would be better for her son, but selling her house wouldn’t get her the kind of money she needed. So she was looking into potential income sources, including possible buried treasure that could be associated with notorious Chicago gangsters. Could that have been what she’d been doing in the woods that day? Morgan is trying to figure that out when she is startled to look up and see the creature for herself.
Could the woman’s murder really be the work of the Beast of Bray Road? Is it really a werewolf? Or will the killer turn out to be a creature even more deadly than that?
Monster in the Moonlight is the fourth book in Annalise Ryan’s Monster Hunter mysteries. Each of these books center on a different cryptid and a murder mystery, with lots of smart plotting and intriguing surprises along the way. This one is about the possibility of a werewolf in Wisconsin, and it goes to crazy places to find the answers.
I am a fan of these mysteries. I find cryptozoology fascinating, and I love the way Ryan approaches these mysteries, with skepticism instead of conspiracy. These are smart novels, with twists all the way through and a comforting dog to pet in case it gets a little intense. I loved how this mystery came together, and I can’t wait for the next one in the series. I will be sitting here waiting, with my fingers crossed that we finally get to my favorite cryptid, Mothman. But if we don’t get there yet, I’ll still be reading because these books are such fun.
Egalleys for Monster in the Moonlight were provided by Berkley through NetGalley, with many thanks, but the opinions are mine.
In Elkhorn, Wisconsin, a woman was found brutally beaten. She had been alone in the woods, close to where a local man had seen something unusual in the fields just days before. He’d been alone, dumped in the woods by coworkers who thought it would be funny, and he’d been drinking. But after realizing his friends had left him alone and cold in the woods, and then stumbling and hurting his ankle, he sobered up pretty quickly. So he was certain that what he had seen, a hairy creature on two feet, had been real. It just wasn’t anything he could readily identify. He had heard a howling just after seeing the beast, so he thought it was the local cryptid, the Beast of Bray Road. A werewolf.
Local police detective Wyatt Moorhead asks Morgan for help. It doesn’t help anyone to stir up the rumors about the Beast of Bray Road, but he can’t explain the scratches they found on the woman’s body or her car. So Morgan packs up a few essentials and her dog Newt and heads for Elkhorn. And while everyone is focused on the wounds on the woman’s body and what kind of creature could have made them, Morgan is focused on another question completely. What was this woman doing in the woods all alone in the middle of the night?
Morgan learns that the woman had been widowed by a car accident that had left her grown son in a wheelchair. She wanted to move somewhere that would be better for her son, but selling her house wouldn’t get her the kind of money she needed. So she was looking into potential income sources, including possible buried treasure that could be associated with notorious Chicago gangsters. Could that have been what she’d been doing in the woods that day? Morgan is trying to figure that out when she is startled to look up and see the creature for herself.
Could the woman’s murder really be the work of the Beast of Bray Road? Is it really a werewolf? Or will the killer turn out to be a creature even more deadly than that?
Monster in the Moonlight is the fourth book in Annalise Ryan’s Monster Hunter mysteries. Each of these books center on a different cryptid and a murder mystery, with lots of smart plotting and intriguing surprises along the way. This one is about the possibility of a werewolf in Wisconsin, and it goes to crazy places to find the answers.
I am a fan of these mysteries. I find cryptozoology fascinating, and I love the way Ryan approaches these mysteries, with skepticism instead of conspiracy. These are smart novels, with twists all the way through and a comforting dog to pet in case it gets a little intense. I loved how this mystery came together, and I can’t wait for the next one in the series. I will be sitting here waiting, with my fingers crossed that we finally get to my favorite cryptid, Mothman. But if we don’t get there yet, I’ll still be reading because these books are such fun.
Egalleys for Monster in the Moonlight were provided by Berkley through NetGalley, with many thanks, but the opinions are mine.
October 29, 2025
A visitor from Elkhorn, Wisconsin, comes to Morgan's store with an interesting story. A woman was killed on Bray Road - home of the infamous Bray Road Beast - and the circumstances of her death are more than a little mysterious. Local authorities are quick to dismiss the death as nothing more than an unfortunate meeting between man and wild animal but Wyatt isn't so sure. What will Morgan find when she arrives? Evidence to prove the theory of bear attack? Or something far more menacing?
I am kind of obsessed with cryptozoological creatures and the investigations into their existence. Spending a night sitting out in the woods like Morgan has been known to do, waiting for a creature to show its face, is not on my bucket list, but I definitely enjoy hearing and reading about people who do that. Another thing I'm kind of obsessed with is my cozy mysteries. This author has combined the two and (not surprise) I love it!
In this book Morgan goes to investigate the Bray Road Beast and a murder potentially caused by it. But right away there are discrepancies she just can't get past. We have a devoted (perhaps too much so) mother, a son with a variety of challenges who is more than happy to be doted upon by said devoted mother (what child was ever unhappy to be doted on by a loving parent?), a forlorn unrequited love, a super sus caretaker, a police officer who is actually possibly the fishiest one of all of them. So what on earth is actually going on here? I had an inkling, but was still surprised at how it all came together in the end. Oh and things shake out with Jon and you're not going to believe how that ends!
Another thing I love about this series is the covers. The designs remind me of old school movie posters or travel posters. Though the cover of the first book was completely different, I actually really like it too. I know they say you shouldn't judge a book by its cover but I do. A nice cover, quality paper, a legible font, they make for a great reading experience and though I read this as an ebook, I still have to rave about the cover.
I realize this review sounds like it was written by the author's mom LOL! But I think this series is great and I think you'll agree.
Thank you to the author, publisher, and NetGalley for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest (and in this case, glowing) review.
I am kind of obsessed with cryptozoological creatures and the investigations into their existence. Spending a night sitting out in the woods like Morgan has been known to do, waiting for a creature to show its face, is not on my bucket list, but I definitely enjoy hearing and reading about people who do that. Another thing I'm kind of obsessed with is my cozy mysteries. This author has combined the two and (not surprise) I love it!
In this book Morgan goes to investigate the Bray Road Beast and a murder potentially caused by it. But right away there are discrepancies she just can't get past. We have a devoted (perhaps too much so) mother, a son with a variety of challenges who is more than happy to be doted upon by said devoted mother (what child was ever unhappy to be doted on by a loving parent?), a forlorn unrequited love, a super sus caretaker, a police officer who is actually possibly the fishiest one of all of them. So what on earth is actually going on here? I had an inkling, but was still surprised at how it all came together in the end. Oh and things shake out with Jon and you're not going to believe how that ends!
Another thing I love about this series is the covers. The designs remind me of old school movie posters or travel posters. Though the cover of the first book was completely different, I actually really like it too. I know they say you shouldn't judge a book by its cover but I do. A nice cover, quality paper, a legible font, they make for a great reading experience and though I read this as an ebook, I still have to rave about the cover.
I realize this review sounds like it was written by the author's mom LOL! But I think this series is great and I think you'll agree.
Thank you to the author, publisher, and NetGalley for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest (and in this case, glowing) review.
January 4, 2026
Monster In The Moonlight is the fourth book in the monster Hunter mysteries by Annalise Ryan, in the book we meet Morgan who is supposed to be a professional crypto zoologist and have been studying the mythical beast ever since she was a little girl with her parents. In this book a local woman is found dead in the woods with strange marks on her and her vehicle and it doesn’t help that there’s been sightings of the monster of Bray Road in recent days. The monster of Bray Road has been talked about since the early 20th century and width the death of Lydia is ramping up. While Morgan is working with a detective from Elks Creek Wyatt she worries about her relationship with local policeman John they’ve recently broken up and she misses him but when she sees him she doesn’t get clear messages whether he misses her or even wants to still be friends. As it that’s not enough she gets a call from David the man she blames for her parents death but learns he may not have killed them at all. I found this was a very good mystery but here is where the problem lies I thought this book would have a touch of magical realism with crypto zoological animals and I don’t wanna give any spoilers away so I will just say I didn’t like the ending and having read the first book which I also really liked except for the ending I’m starting to sense a theme here and don’t know if I will continue reading these books. chances are I probably will though because as I said the mystery was really good and thought it was clever I like how the investigations go when you could follow the clues but I do find some of the things Morgan does is ridiculous and wasn’t a big fan of hers but Love Newt, mostly love the story and would still definitely recommend this to those who love a good mystery and one as I said where you can follow the clue because some mysteries are just solved out of nowhere and that wasn’t the case with this book. I also found there were no inconsistencies with this book there were no unanswered questions and that is rare everything brought up in the book was known at the end well everything except with her mom and dad‘s murder but that is an ongoing story as far as I can tell. So yes I guess I definitely recommend this book it really was a great mystery. #NetGalley, #TheBlindReviewer, #MyHonestReview,
January 21, 2026
My foray into the Monster Hunter Series was Beast of the North Woods, which was new to me at the time. I admit I didn't even know a cryptozoologist was a thing. What I enjoy most about the series is the pairing of mystery and cryptids.
Monster in the Moonlight was fun to read and listen to. Knowing Morgan Carter, I was looking forward to her next cryptid. In this case, as the title suggests, a werewolf.
What stood out: Getting more clarity on Morgan's backstory, specifically about her parents' murders. I liked how beyond the current mystery, there was a cohesion connecting to her personal life. The romance, while only a side element, was quite dramatic. I was rooting for Morgan and Jon to find middle ground - he wants her safe, she won't give up cryptid hunting. Morgan felt like a person to me, not just a hired consultant for folklore beings that may or may not have anything to do with a murder investigation.
The mystery around the werewolf was what I expected after reading Beast of the North Woods. I loved the explanation of the werewolf sightings though. Is it a werewolf? You'll have to read it to find out.
As for the murder mystery, I figured out who it was around page 116. Yet it didn't stop me from enjoying following along with Morgan putting the pieces together. There were a few suspenseful scenes where I didn't realize I was holding my breath. The danger was palpable and I couldn't look away, just like Morgan.
Audio experience: I love pairing print with audiobooks for a more heightened experience. Susan Bennett brought Morgan to life — her inquisitiveness, deductive skills, frustrations. She nailed it all in her performance. Voicing the other characters with nuance was a bonus.
Similar vibes: The Anomaly by Michael Rutger for investigative work with cryptid elements.
You'll love this if: You want paranormal mysteries with legendary beings and investigative work.
Series note: This is book 4 of 4 in the Monster Hunter series. You can jump in for the current mystery, but if you want Morgan's full backstory, best to start from book 1.
Thank you to Penguin Random House Audio for my early audio access and to Berkley for my gifted print copy for review. All opinions are my own.
Monster in the Moonlight was fun to read and listen to. Knowing Morgan Carter, I was looking forward to her next cryptid. In this case, as the title suggests, a werewolf.
What stood out: Getting more clarity on Morgan's backstory, specifically about her parents' murders. I liked how beyond the current mystery, there was a cohesion connecting to her personal life. The romance, while only a side element, was quite dramatic. I was rooting for Morgan and Jon to find middle ground - he wants her safe, she won't give up cryptid hunting. Morgan felt like a person to me, not just a hired consultant for folklore beings that may or may not have anything to do with a murder investigation.
The mystery around the werewolf was what I expected after reading Beast of the North Woods. I loved the explanation of the werewolf sightings though. Is it a werewolf? You'll have to read it to find out.
As for the murder mystery, I figured out who it was around page 116. Yet it didn't stop me from enjoying following along with Morgan putting the pieces together. There were a few suspenseful scenes where I didn't realize I was holding my breath. The danger was palpable and I couldn't look away, just like Morgan.
Audio experience: I love pairing print with audiobooks for a more heightened experience. Susan Bennett brought Morgan to life — her inquisitiveness, deductive skills, frustrations. She nailed it all in her performance. Voicing the other characters with nuance was a bonus.
Similar vibes: The Anomaly by Michael Rutger for investigative work with cryptid elements.
You'll love this if: You want paranormal mysteries with legendary beings and investigative work.
Series note: This is book 4 of 4 in the Monster Hunter series. You can jump in for the current mystery, but if you want Morgan's full backstory, best to start from book 1.
Thank you to Penguin Random House Audio for my early audio access and to Berkley for my gifted print copy for review. All opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
** “In fact, werewolves are one of the oldest monsters we human beings have managed to dream up. Symbolically, they are thought to represent a basic duality of human nature: the inability to overcome our basic desires and primal instincts in much the same way a werewolf is unable to control its conversion into a savage beast.” **
Annelise Ryan once again offers a fun murder mystery with a cryptozoology twist — this time centering around Elkhorn, Wisconsin’s Beast of Bray Road — in “Monster in the Moonlight.”
Cryptozoologist Morgan Carter is called on to investigate some unusual occurrences, including a murder, in Elkhorn. With a series of four scratches down the side of her car, Lydia Palmer is found dead with similar marks to her body. Many in the town believe the legendary Beast of Bray Road, a werewolf, is responsible. So a friend of her boyfriend, Washington Island Police Chief Jon Flanders, brings her in for assistance.
As Morgan digs into the case and the happenings surrounding it, can she determine if a werewolf is truly the villain? And if not, who is, and why?
Once again, Ryan offers a fun and zany tale filled with twists and turns. She creates great characters, including Elkhorn Detective Wyatt Moorhead, who once wanted to be a psychologist and helps Morgan through some of her issues, a delightful rescue dog named Newt and a mummified corpse named Henry.
Fans of cozy mysteries and stories about cryptic creatures will love “Monster in the Moonlight,” which is due out Jan. 27.
Five stars out of five.
Berkley Publishing Group provided this complimentary copy through NetGalley for my honest, unbiased review.
Annelise Ryan once again offers a fun murder mystery with a cryptozoology twist — this time centering around Elkhorn, Wisconsin’s Beast of Bray Road — in “Monster in the Moonlight.”
Cryptozoologist Morgan Carter is called on to investigate some unusual occurrences, including a murder, in Elkhorn. With a series of four scratches down the side of her car, Lydia Palmer is found dead with similar marks to her body. Many in the town believe the legendary Beast of Bray Road, a werewolf, is responsible. So a friend of her boyfriend, Washington Island Police Chief Jon Flanders, brings her in for assistance.
As Morgan digs into the case and the happenings surrounding it, can she determine if a werewolf is truly the villain? And if not, who is, and why?
Once again, Ryan offers a fun and zany tale filled with twists and turns. She creates great characters, including Elkhorn Detective Wyatt Moorhead, who once wanted to be a psychologist and helps Morgan through some of her issues, a delightful rescue dog named Newt and a mummified corpse named Henry.
Fans of cozy mysteries and stories about cryptic creatures will love “Monster in the Moonlight,” which is due out Jan. 27.
Five stars out of five.
Berkley Publishing Group provided this complimentary copy through NetGalley for my honest, unbiased review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Morgan Carter is a Cryptozoologist who inherited her parents’ oddities shop and also their love of investigating cryptids. Morgan fearlessly investigates Bigfoot, the Loch Ness monster, and in this one the Beast of Bray Road.
Morgan is introduced to Wyatt, a detective in Wisconsin who is investigating the death of a woman in the woods off of Bray Rd on the edge of a small town.
Morgan is always a skeptic but while interviewing locals, she finds out that many believe they have seen the creature.
The victim’s death does make it look like she’d been killed by an animal.
In the meantime, Morgan’s love life has taken a nose dive when Jon, her love interest, is giving her the cold shoulder. She is aware that he doesn’t like that she puts herself in dangerous situations. She interprets it as that he wants her to give up her investigations and she isn’t ready to do so.
Morgan doesn’t tackle the task alone, she has a large dog who accompanies her everywhere.
This is a great cozy mystery series with a paranormal twist. I have enjoyed this series and look forward to what she will come up with next.
I have read several books in this series and I recently found another book by this author while weeding through my book shelves. That book is “Dead in the Water”. It is an older book that has nothing to do with this series. Since reading the Monster Hunter series, I am curious about reading this stand alone. Hopefully I will get to it soon.
The publish date is January 27th.
Thanks to NetGalley and Berkley for this advanced reader copy for my review. All opinions are my own.
Morgan is introduced to Wyatt, a detective in Wisconsin who is investigating the death of a woman in the woods off of Bray Rd on the edge of a small town.
Morgan is always a skeptic but while interviewing locals, she finds out that many believe they have seen the creature.
The victim’s death does make it look like she’d been killed by an animal.
In the meantime, Morgan’s love life has taken a nose dive when Jon, her love interest, is giving her the cold shoulder. She is aware that he doesn’t like that she puts herself in dangerous situations. She interprets it as that he wants her to give up her investigations and she isn’t ready to do so.
Morgan doesn’t tackle the task alone, she has a large dog who accompanies her everywhere.
This is a great cozy mystery series with a paranormal twist. I have enjoyed this series and look forward to what she will come up with next.
I have read several books in this series and I recently found another book by this author while weeding through my book shelves. That book is “Dead in the Water”. It is an older book that has nothing to do with this series. Since reading the Monster Hunter series, I am curious about reading this stand alone. Hopefully I will get to it soon.
The publish date is January 27th.
Thanks to NetGalley and Berkley for this advanced reader copy for my review. All opinions are my own.
November 16, 2025
Monster in the Moonlight is a mystery that sneaks up on you—not just with its tension and eerie atmosphere, but with the emotional depth woven underneath the suspense. Annelise Ryan blends small-town secrets, folklore, and a touch of the uncanny into a story that feels both grounded and ghostly at the same time.
The book shines in its setting: misty woods, moonlit nights, and that simmering sense that something is watching from just out of sight. Ryan’s writing captures that mood perfectly, making this a great read for anyone who loves mysteries with a supernatural edge.
The protagonist is easy to root for—flawed, persistent, and genuinely human. Her journey feels realistic, with just enough vulnerability to make the stakes land. The supporting cast adds color and tension, though some characters feel more developed than others.
The plot moves steadily, with a few stretches that slow down, but the payoff is worth it. The twists are satisfying without feeling over-engineered, and the final reveal strikes a strong balance between myth and reality.
Overall, a great atmospheric monster hunter mystery with a supernatural tilt—dark, engaging, and perfect for a chilly night. If you enjoy folklore-tinged thrillers with emotional undercurrents, this one is absolutely worth picking up.
Thank you NetGalley and Berkley Publishing for this eARC!
The book shines in its setting: misty woods, moonlit nights, and that simmering sense that something is watching from just out of sight. Ryan’s writing captures that mood perfectly, making this a great read for anyone who loves mysteries with a supernatural edge.
The protagonist is easy to root for—flawed, persistent, and genuinely human. Her journey feels realistic, with just enough vulnerability to make the stakes land. The supporting cast adds color and tension, though some characters feel more developed than others.
The plot moves steadily, with a few stretches that slow down, but the payoff is worth it. The twists are satisfying without feeling over-engineered, and the final reveal strikes a strong balance between myth and reality.
Overall, a great atmospheric monster hunter mystery with a supernatural tilt—dark, engaging, and perfect for a chilly night. If you enjoy folklore-tinged thrillers with emotional undercurrents, this one is absolutely worth picking up.
Thank you NetGalley and Berkley Publishing for this eARC!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
MF
Single POV
Mystery
Mature MC
Cryptids
Doggy sidekick
Rating: 3.5/5 - this isn't a book that I will reread but I really enjoyed it
🌶️: 0/5 - not a romance
TLDR: Such a cool way to learn about Wisconsin
My absolute favorite thing about this series is the local history. I love learning about Wisconsin's lore. Living in a fly over state, I never really expect a book to take place in an area I know. Also who knew Wisconsin had so many cryptid legends?! The "whodunnit" aspect of the story is also very enjoyable. I was hooked and wanted an explanation. I was not disappointed. The subplot of the romance isn't great. It just isn't convincing and I think the story could be without it entirely but it isn't necessarily bad either. Just seemingly unnecessary. You don't have to read the entire series. This book can be read as a standalone but the overreaching plot and the side characters will make more sense if you've read the entire series.
Ultimately, I'd recommend this book to anyone who enjoys a mystery.
Thank you to the author, Berkley, and NetGalley for the advanced review copy of this book. My opinions are my own.
Single POV
Mystery
Mature MC
Cryptids
Doggy sidekick
Rating: 3.5/5 - this isn't a book that I will reread but I really enjoyed it
🌶️: 0/5 - not a romance
TLDR: Such a cool way to learn about Wisconsin
My absolute favorite thing about this series is the local history. I love learning about Wisconsin's lore. Living in a fly over state, I never really expect a book to take place in an area I know. Also who knew Wisconsin had so many cryptid legends?! The "whodunnit" aspect of the story is also very enjoyable. I was hooked and wanted an explanation. I was not disappointed. The subplot of the romance isn't great. It just isn't convincing and I think the story could be without it entirely but it isn't necessarily bad either. Just seemingly unnecessary. You don't have to read the entire series. This book can be read as a standalone but the overreaching plot and the side characters will make more sense if you've read the entire series.
Ultimately, I'd recommend this book to anyone who enjoys a mystery.
Thank you to the author, Berkley, and NetGalley for the advanced review copy of this book. My opinions are my own.
October 4, 2025
I flew through this one. This is the 4th in the series. Morgan has grown so much as a character since the beginning. She has started realizing things about herself and dealing with her parents murder.
Morgan receives a visit from Jon and his friend, Wyatt, who is a detective in a rural Wisconsin town, asking for help. A werewolf is terrorizing Elkhorn, WI, killing one woman and going after farm animals. Jon delivers Wyatt to Morgan and takes off in a hurry, leaving a devastated Morgan behind. Morgan agrees to help look for the Beast of Bray Road and she and Newt pack up and head for Elkhorn.
I do love how Morgan is so thorough in her investigation and although she doesn't outright deny it could be a criptid, she also leaves that option open. As always, Newt stole the show, being his usual charming and lovable self.
We see a little bit of Rita and Devon, who are two of my favorites. Overall, great read. I love Annelise's books and I look forward to more.
Thank you to NetGalley and Berkley for an ARC of this book.
Morgan receives a visit from Jon and his friend, Wyatt, who is a detective in a rural Wisconsin town, asking for help. A werewolf is terrorizing Elkhorn, WI, killing one woman and going after farm animals. Jon delivers Wyatt to Morgan and takes off in a hurry, leaving a devastated Morgan behind. Morgan agrees to help look for the Beast of Bray Road and she and Newt pack up and head for Elkhorn.
I do love how Morgan is so thorough in her investigation and although she doesn't outright deny it could be a criptid, she also leaves that option open. As always, Newt stole the show, being his usual charming and lovable self.
We see a little bit of Rita and Devon, who are two of my favorites. Overall, great read. I love Annelise's books and I look forward to more.
Thank you to NetGalley and Berkley for an ARC of this book.
January 26, 2026
First I would like the thank NetGalley and the Publisher for sending me an arc of this book!
Monster in the Moonlight is a mystery thriller about a the Beast of Bray Road and an alleged killing it is involved in. I originally requested this arc because of my interest in paranormal mysteries and was very much excited to read this book. I was very early let down and not engaged with the plot or characters . While the mystery element was good with the twist at the end, I felt like I was forcing this read. I did not care for the characters and was not even interested by the sprinkle of romance. Their trauma where it played a part felt forced and honestly felt like it was just thrown in there. It was not my favorite style of writing. I felt like the author was jumping around a lot and had whole chapters that just felt not needed. This book just did not do it for me personally but if you like the series and/or paranormal mysteries definitely give it a shot.
Monster in the Moonlight is a mystery thriller about a the Beast of Bray Road and an alleged killing it is involved in. I originally requested this arc because of my interest in paranormal mysteries and was very much excited to read this book. I was very early let down and not engaged with the plot or characters . While the mystery element was good with the twist at the end, I felt like I was forcing this read. I did not care for the characters and was not even interested by the sprinkle of romance. Their trauma where it played a part felt forced and honestly felt like it was just thrown in there. It was not my favorite style of writing. I felt like the author was jumping around a lot and had whole chapters that just felt not needed. This book just did not do it for me personally but if you like the series and/or paranormal mysteries definitely give it a shot.
January 29, 2026
I LOVE this series!!
From the covers and the titles, which is what first drew me in, Annelise Ryan writes a mystery and characters that suck you in and won't let you go until the mystery is solved!
Morgan is a Cryptozoologist, and along with her Newfoundland dog, Newt, and her employees at her oddities shop, she helps investigate when it seems like a Cryptid is behind the mystery. In this one, Morgan is invited to the death of a woman thought to have been killed by the Beast of Bray Road. Morgan doesn't automatically believe the beast is real, and she uses all of her sleuthing abilities to uncover the truth of the beast, and if it, or something else, was behind the woman's death.
The plot is solid, and the characters are ones you want to root for. The mystery kept me guessing until the very end, when everything was revealed. I thoroughly enjoy everything about this series and can't wait to see where it's going to go next!
From the covers and the titles, which is what first drew me in, Annelise Ryan writes a mystery and characters that suck you in and won't let you go until the mystery is solved!
Morgan is a Cryptozoologist, and along with her Newfoundland dog, Newt, and her employees at her oddities shop, she helps investigate when it seems like a Cryptid is behind the mystery. In this one, Morgan is invited to the death of a woman thought to have been killed by the Beast of Bray Road. Morgan doesn't automatically believe the beast is real, and she uses all of her sleuthing abilities to uncover the truth of the beast, and if it, or something else, was behind the woman's death.
The plot is solid, and the characters are ones you want to root for. The mystery kept me guessing until the very end, when everything was revealed. I thoroughly enjoy everything about this series and can't wait to see where it's going to go next!
September 7, 2025
I read this book as a standalone and I still really enjoyed it. I love a good murder mystery and this one was well done, with a touch of paranormal. Morgan Carter, a cryptozoologist is called to investigate the Beast of Bray road, who is suspected to have killed a woman. From there, the investigation took place and it was really interesting to read. It did get a bit long in the middle as I usually like a bit more action, but the ending definitely made up for it. I was definitely surprised by the reveal of the killer which I enjoyed. Looking back, there was a lot of foreshadowing that I missed, so that was very clever from the author. I think I’ll go back and read the previous book because I got attached to Morgan. I hope there are more books in the series!
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for an arc of this book. Opinions are my own.
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for an arc of this book. Opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
The Beast of Bray Road is real - and it's just killed a woman. At least, that's what the residents of a small Wisconsin town believe. Enter cryptozoologist Morgan Carter, who's called in to investigate what may be a cryptid...or something far more complicated.
This is book 4 in the Monster Hunter series, which has quickly become one of my favorites. If you're already a fan like I am, you pretty much know what you're getting here: a murder, a mysterious cryptid, and plenty of drama as Morgan works to unravel the truth. And of course, Newt remains the goodest boy and is still my favorite character.
Fans of monster lore and cozy mysteries - especially those who enjoy a familiar formula done well - will absolutely enjoy this installment.
*Thank you to Berkley & NetGalley for the free ARC in exchange for an honest and voluntary review.
This is book 4 in the Monster Hunter series, which has quickly become one of my favorites. If you're already a fan like I am, you pretty much know what you're getting here: a murder, a mysterious cryptid, and plenty of drama as Morgan works to unravel the truth. And of course, Newt remains the goodest boy and is still my favorite character.
Fans of monster lore and cozy mysteries - especially those who enjoy a familiar formula done well - will absolutely enjoy this installment.
*Thank you to Berkley & NetGalley for the free ARC in exchange for an honest and voluntary review.
September 14, 2025
Monster in the Moonlight is the third Monster Hunter mystery by Annelise Ryan. I really enjoy this series and this book was no different. It was a great, complicated mystery with a resolution that was surprising and really was a challenge to figure out. I enjoy reading about the cryptids and how the mystery surrounding them can develop. It’s really fascinating. I really like the characters of Morgan and Jon and I loved the character development in this book. I don’t want to spoil anything, but I loved the ending and can’t wait for the next book! I recommend this book for a fun read that draws you in from the very first page!
Thank you to NetGalley for allowing me to read this book. All opinions are my own.
Thank you to NetGalley for allowing me to read this book. All opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Fascinating topic but this was very slow in spots, making it difficult to get through. I always enjoy learning about cryptids and I get that it’s tough to get proof of their existence, thus the mystique, but the books have the same overall formula: Morgan gets called in for a possible cryptid sighting, she tromps around, putting herself in danger with no regard for anyone else, she ultimately finds out it isn’t a cryptid after all. This one did give some resolution on her relationship and hints are more in the series. Hoping that these issues are fixed in the next one.
I received a copy from #NetGalley for an honest review.
I received a copy from #NetGalley for an honest review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Annelise Ryan is my favorite mystery author. She has a knack for complex puzzles that leave you guessing until the very end. I get the impression from this fourth installment in her series that there will be more to come and I am thrilled. This book was a bit of a character builder in that it set up some personal development that will likely shape the series moving forward. As usual, I loved the characters she paints in the small towns she visits. I look forward to seeing what other cryptids she will pursue next.
Thank you NetGalley and Berkley Publishing Group for providing me with an ARC!
Thank you NetGalley and Berkley Publishing Group for providing me with an ARC!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This was my first Monster Hunter Mystery but I think I'm going to read the others - as a native Wisconsinite, obviously I need these stories. As someone who grew up knowing about the Beast of Bray Road (and has made many silly drives down it hoping to see a creature) this was really fun for me and was why I requested the book in the first place.
Morgan and her dog Newt are referred to an Elkhorn police officer after a strange murder shows signs of a cryptid. We get to follow along as Morgan both explores information about the Beast and the potential evidence of the cryptid's existence, as well as the human elements that might be using the Beast as a cover.
There's lots of interesting perspectives on cryptids, nature, animal conservancy, and investigation, although I can't lie, her not cooperating with the police was annoying as hell. Morgan is at time an inconsistent character, but I appreciate her dedication to getting it right, and knowing that people can make terrible choices for all kinds of reasons.
A cozy mystery with a unique premise that you can read quickly and enjoyably.
I'll be spending some time in Rhinelander in a few weeks, and picked up the previous book about the hodag!
Morgan and her dog Newt are referred to an Elkhorn police officer after a strange murder shows signs of a cryptid. We get to follow along as Morgan both explores information about the Beast and the potential evidence of the cryptid's existence, as well as the human elements that might be using the Beast as a cover.
There's lots of interesting perspectives on cryptids, nature, animal conservancy, and investigation, although I can't lie, her not cooperating with the police was annoying as hell. Morgan is at time an inconsistent character, but I appreciate her dedication to getting it right, and knowing that people can make terrible choices for all kinds of reasons.
A cozy mystery with a unique premise that you can read quickly and enjoyably.
I'll be spending some time in Rhinelander in a few weeks, and picked up the previous book about the hodag!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Thanks to the publisher, via Netgalley, for an advance e-galley for honest review.
I've lived in Wisconsin for the majority of my life, and yet Annelise Ryan has introduced me to several cryptids I haven't ever heard of with this series, including in this one with the Beast of Bray Road of Elkhorn, WI. I appreciated that this one really did further the series along, with information appearing about the death of Morgan's parents, some tough conversations and decisions about her relationship with Jon, and still readers get a solid mystery. It's atmospheric and creative.
I've lived in Wisconsin for the majority of my life, and yet Annelise Ryan has introduced me to several cryptids I haven't ever heard of with this series, including in this one with the Beast of Bray Road of Elkhorn, WI. I appreciated that this one really did further the series along, with information appearing about the death of Morgan's parents, some tough conversations and decisions about her relationship with Jon, and still readers get a solid mystery. It's atmospheric and creative.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 43 reviews