What do you think?
Rate this book
4 ELEMENTS
The Earth - Vows of the Land
Amid the rolling hills of northern Thailand, two women from rival farms are drawn together by fate, bound by love, and threatened by the weight of generations-old conflict. Din Kasama, the resilient and fiercely loyal owner of Saenrak Farm, has vowed to protect Rose, the radiant heir of Chomjan Flower Farm. But when long-buried secrets and family pressures turn deadly, Din stands her ground—ready to fight for Rose, even if it means risking her own life.
As shadows from the past close in and the truth unravels, Din and Rose must confront the depth of their feelings and the dangers that surround them. Their families are locked in an unspoken war, and their love is a rebellion against forces greater than themselves. With trust tested, loyalties questioned, and a future hanging in the balance, they must will they defy the forces that seek to break them apart, or will their love be yet another sacrifice to the unforgiving land that binds them? In a world where every decision can tip the scale between life and death, they must ask themselves—can love truly conquer all, or will it be buried beneath the weight of the earth?
As shadows from the past close in and the truth unravels, Din and Rose must confront the depth of their feelings and the dangers that surround them. Their families are locked in an unspoken war, and their love is a rebellion against forces greater than themselves. With trust tested, loyalties questioned, and a future hanging in the balance, they must will they defy the forces that seek to break them apart, or will their love be yet another sacrifice to the unforgiving land that binds them? In a world where every decision can tip the scale between life and death, they must ask themselves—can love truly conquer all, or will it be buried beneath the weight of the earth?
405 pages, Kindle Edition
Published April 28, 2025
46 people are currently reading
163 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 23 of 23 reviews
February 20, 2026
They are so sweet!!
March 6, 2026
The translation I got was a bit confusing but nothing terrible. I actually liked this story. It was sweet and easy to read. I kinda wanted to give 4 stars but truly the quality of the book itself was not there. It felt a bit like reading fanfiction. I think I will give it a 3.5⭐️
—
2nd Read
I found a better translation than the first version. Still not perfect at all but it worked better than the first random version I found online. (I got the official kindle edition this time around hehe)
The reason why I decided to re read the story is because the adaptation is underway atm and I wanted to refresh my memory.
I still think the story was very light and even tho it has some dark themes it truly never gets too serious? Like you can tell everything will work out somehow. Kinda like a Disney movie. As long you are not the parents you are safe haha I do wish there were a bit more character development but in general it is a solid good read.
—
2nd Read
I found a better translation than the first version. Still not perfect at all but it worked better than the first random version I found online. (I got the official kindle edition this time around hehe)
The reason why I decided to re read the story is because the adaptation is underway atm and I wanted to refresh my memory.
I still think the story was very light and even tho it has some dark themes it truly never gets too serious? Like you can tell everything will work out somehow. Kinda like a Disney movie. As long you are not the parents you are safe haha I do wish there were a bit more character development but in general it is a solid good read.
December 16, 2025
Confusing translation.
This is the first book I bought and read from the 4 Elements novel series. I was curious about the story and how it would eventually be adapted into a series.
I rated this book 2 stars, mainly because of the confusing translation. Many characters are given two different names. I understand this for the main characters, Din and Rose (Kasima and Thipapa), but the same issue appears with the cousins, such as Lom and Wayo, whose names are written in multiple ways while referring to the same person. This made the story difficult to follow. At times, a character would be mentioned, only for it to turn out to be someone else entirely. It felt like frequent typographical or translation errors, which significantly affected my reading experience.
I’ve read many Thai novels that have been adapted into series, so I admit I had high expectations for this one. This is also my first time reading a work by this author, and honestly, I’m not sure if I’ll continue with the rest of the novels. I’ll most likely just watch the series adaptation instead.
As for the story itself, Rose comes across as very childish and overly jealous. I think this is largely due to how her inner monologue is written, but as a result, her character lacks depth. Din’s character, unfortunately, also feels quite flat and uninteresting.
I’ve read fanfiction with stronger character development than this. While other Thai GL novels aren’t perfect either, I think my disappointment stems from having such high expectations for this series, which ultimately made the let-down feel much greater.
This is the first book I bought and read from the 4 Elements novel series. I was curious about the story and how it would eventually be adapted into a series.
I rated this book 2 stars, mainly because of the confusing translation. Many characters are given two different names. I understand this for the main characters, Din and Rose (Kasima and Thipapa), but the same issue appears with the cousins, such as Lom and Wayo, whose names are written in multiple ways while referring to the same person. This made the story difficult to follow. At times, a character would be mentioned, only for it to turn out to be someone else entirely. It felt like frequent typographical or translation errors, which significantly affected my reading experience.
I’ve read many Thai novels that have been adapted into series, so I admit I had high expectations for this one. This is also my first time reading a work by this author, and honestly, I’m not sure if I’ll continue with the rest of the novels. I’ll most likely just watch the series adaptation instead.
As for the story itself, Rose comes across as very childish and overly jealous. I think this is largely due to how her inner monologue is written, but as a result, her character lacks depth. Din’s character, unfortunately, also feels quite flat and uninteresting.
I’ve read fanfiction with stronger character development than this. While other Thai GL novels aren’t perfect either, I think my disappointment stems from having such high expectations for this series, which ultimately made the let-down feel much greater.
February 25, 2026
4.5 stars.
My second Thai Gl novel and this was a world wind and my first finished book of 2026.
What did I love:
Din and Rose
The cousins,
What I didn’t love:
Wasu
Kawe
It follows Din and Rose, childhood friends who come up with a plan to stop Rose’s family farm from being taken over by a corrupt family ‘friend’. A fake marriage, but the fake marriage puts a target in Din’s back, cause not everyone is happy that Din had married N’Rose.
It’s got the fake marriage trope, chaotic cousins and a sweet falling in love story that made me smile so wide.
Wasu being a dick from the get go gave an edge to the story, you didn’t know what to expect from him and still ended up shocked by it when it happened. The twist of who the traitor was, I had a feeling from the start, and I was glad it went the way I thought it would.
I’ve also had the pleasure of watching the show as it’s come out week and seeing the scenes played out had been such a delight, but I couldn’t stop myself from reading on and finishing this, they’ve tweaked it enough that it adds a newness to the show while also keeps the foundation from the novel.
The translation seemed a bit all over the place at times and may have taken to read a line once or twice but that didn’t prevent me from reading and loving this.
All in all, a great start to the 4Elements series.
My second Thai Gl novel and this was a world wind and my first finished book of 2026.
What did I love:
Din and Rose
The cousins,
What I didn’t love:
Wasu
Kawe
It follows Din and Rose, childhood friends who come up with a plan to stop Rose’s family farm from being taken over by a corrupt family ‘friend’. A fake marriage, but the fake marriage puts a target in Din’s back, cause not everyone is happy that Din had married N’Rose.
It’s got the fake marriage trope, chaotic cousins and a sweet falling in love story that made me smile so wide.
Wasu being a dick from the get go gave an edge to the story, you didn’t know what to expect from him and still ended up shocked by it when it happened. The twist of who the traitor was, I had a feeling from the start, and I was glad it went the way I thought it would.
I’ve also had the pleasure of watching the show as it’s come out week and seeing the scenes played out had been such a delight, but I couldn’t stop myself from reading on and finishing this, they’ve tweaked it enough that it adds a newness to the show while also keeps the foundation from the novel.
The translation seemed a bit all over the place at times and may have taken to read a line once or twice but that didn’t prevent me from reading and loving this.
All in all, a great start to the 4Elements series.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
February 25, 2026
Earth – Salmon
Hay historias que hablan de amor. Y hay historias que hablan de pertenencia. Earth es ambas.
La novela nos presenta a Din y Rose, dos chicas que compartieron la infancia y que, como suele pasar, el tiempo y la distancia separaron. Años después, el destino las obliga a reencontrarse cuando el padre de Rose sufre un accidente y ella debe regresar a Tailandia. Pero lo que parecía un regreso temporal se convierte en una tormenta emocional.
Rose vuelve no solo para enfrentar la recuperación de su padre, sino también un compromiso ancestral: una promesa entre abuelos que la ata a un matrimonio arreglado. El vecino ambicioso que desea quedarse con sus tierras —y utilizarlas para fines oscuros como el tráfico de personas— presiona para que Rose cumpla con ese acuerdo y se case con su hijo.
La única salida es un matrimonio falso con Din.
La forma como se desarrolla la historia es ágil. Este libro es parte de una saga, pero no es necesario leer en orden. Pero si lo quisieran seria tierra, agua , aire y fuego.
Hay historias que hablan de amor. Y hay historias que hablan de pertenencia. Earth es ambas.
La novela nos presenta a Din y Rose, dos chicas que compartieron la infancia y que, como suele pasar, el tiempo y la distancia separaron. Años después, el destino las obliga a reencontrarse cuando el padre de Rose sufre un accidente y ella debe regresar a Tailandia. Pero lo que parecía un regreso temporal se convierte en una tormenta emocional.
Rose vuelve no solo para enfrentar la recuperación de su padre, sino también un compromiso ancestral: una promesa entre abuelos que la ata a un matrimonio arreglado. El vecino ambicioso que desea quedarse con sus tierras —y utilizarlas para fines oscuros como el tráfico de personas— presiona para que Rose cumpla con ese acuerdo y se case con su hijo.
La única salida es un matrimonio falso con Din.
La forma como se desarrolla la historia es ágil. Este libro es parte de una saga, pero no es necesario leer en orden. Pero si lo quisieran seria tierra, agua , aire y fuego.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 22, 2025
วิวาห์ปฐพี 🌏⛰️⚘️🌹 3.5/5
เรื่องราวของ กษมา วาทินวณิช (ดิน) เจ้าของไร่แสนรักจำเป็นต้องมาดูแล ทิพปภา อมรจินดา(โรส) ลูกสาวเจ้าของไร่ชมจันทร์ หลังเกิดอุบัติเหตุของบิดาขึ้น จึงเกิดการจัดฉากวิวาห์ลวงของกษมาและทิพปภาขึ้น เพื่อตบตาศัตรูอย่างครอบครัวมหัทธนากร เมื่อกษมาและทิพปภาต้องมาอยู่ด้วยกัน เกิดความผูกพันกัน กลายเป็นว่าความรักที่เกิดขึ้นระหว่างสองคนคือความจริงไม่ใช่ความลวงอีกต่อไป แต่ศัตรูที่อยู่รายรอบกลายเป็นอุปสรรคสำคัญ แต่ความหนักแน่น มั่นคง ไม่ยอมพ่ายแพ้ของทั้งสอง บวกกับความร่วมมือร่วมใจของพี่น้องวาทินวณิชก็สามารถเอาชนะ และก้าวข้ามเรื่องราวร้ายๆ ไปได้
สิ่งที่ชอบของเรื่องนี้คือตัวละครกษมา คือเป็นคนพูดน้อย สุขุม เข้มแข็ง แล้วก็พูดจาตรงไปตรงมาดี 555 แล้วก็ประเด็นการแต่งงานของเพศเดียวกัน ซึ่งในความเป็นจริงอาจจะฟังดูแปลก แต่นักเขียนถือว่ากล้าเขียน และทำให้เป็นเรื่องปกติที่ผู้หญิงจะแต่งงานกันได้
เนื้อหาจะแนวๆ บ้านไร่ (ฟีลตามรักคืนใจ, ดวงใจอัคนี ฯลฯ) มีไล่ยิงกัน บู๊หน่อยๆ ที่สำคัญคือการปรากฏตัวของพี่น้อง น้ำ ลม ไฟ ถือว่าทำให้เนื้อเรื่องสนุกขึ้น เพราะมาเมื่อไรแสดงว่าจะเกิดเรื่องแน่ๆ 555
เรื่องราวของ กษมา วาทินวณิช (ดิน) เจ้าของไร่แสนรักจำเป็นต้องมาดูแล ทิพปภา อมรจินดา(โรส) ลูกสาวเจ้าของไร่ชมจันทร์ หลังเกิดอุบัติเหตุของบิดาขึ้น จึงเกิดการจัดฉากวิวาห์ลวงของกษมาและทิพปภาขึ้น เพื่อตบตาศัตรูอย่างครอบครัวมหัทธนากร เมื่อกษมาและทิพปภาต้องมาอยู่ด้วยกัน เกิดความผูกพันกัน กลายเป็นว่าความรักที่เกิดขึ้นระหว่างสองคนคือความจริงไม่ใช่ความลวงอีกต่อไป แต่ศัตรูที่อยู่รายรอบกลายเป็นอุปสรรคสำคัญ แต่ความหนักแน่น มั่นคง ไม่ยอมพ่ายแพ้ของทั้งสอง บวกกับความร่วมมือร่วมใจของพี่น้องวาทินวณิชก็สามารถเอาชนะ และก้าวข้ามเรื่องราวร้ายๆ ไปได้
สิ่งที่ชอบของเรื่องนี้คือตัวละครกษมา คือเป็นคนพูดน้อย สุขุม เข้มแข็ง แล้วก็พูดจาตรงไปตรงมาดี 555 แล้วก็ประเด็นการแต่งงานของเพศเดียวกัน ซึ่งในความเป็นจริงอาจจะฟังดูแปลก แต่นักเขียนถือว่ากล้าเขียน และทำให้เป็นเรื่องปกติที่ผู้หญิงจะแต่งงานกันได้
เนื้อหาจะแนวๆ บ้านไร่ (ฟีลตามรักคืนใจ, ดวงใจอัคนี ฯลฯ) มีไล่ยิงกัน บู๊หน่อยๆ ที่สำคัญคือการปรากฏตัวของพี่น้อง น้ำ ลม ไฟ ถือว่าทำให้เนื้อเรื่องสนุกขึ้น เพราะมาเมื่อไรแสดงว่าจะเกิดเรื่องแน่ๆ 555
February 18, 2026
3.5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
This is the first Thai GL novel I’ve read. I mostly just watch GL series, but the 4 Elements collection seemed so interesting that I decided to try the English translation.
Honestly, I was gushing, completely giddy, through the first half of the book. It was fun to read, although a bit predictable, esp the conflict involving trafficking. I kinda wish that aspect had been explored more. Given the farmland setting, it also could have been interesting if the story touched on land issues, such as rights or farming concerns.
The latter part felt slower and somewhat dragging, particularly the misunderstanding between Rose and Din. I was kinda hoping also that Rose had more agency and was portrayed as a stronger character, considering she grew up abroad.
Still, it’s comforting to read wlw romance with a happy ending, no matter how predictable it may be. 555. I’ll probably read Water, Air, and Fire as well.
This is the first Thai GL novel I’ve read. I mostly just watch GL series, but the 4 Elements collection seemed so interesting that I decided to try the English translation.
Honestly, I was gushing, completely giddy, through the first half of the book. It was fun to read, although a bit predictable, esp the conflict involving trafficking. I kinda wish that aspect had been explored more. Given the farmland setting, it also could have been interesting if the story touched on land issues, such as rights or farming concerns.
The latter part felt slower and somewhat dragging, particularly the misunderstanding between Rose and Din. I was kinda hoping also that Rose had more agency and was portrayed as a stronger character, considering she grew up abroad.
Still, it’s comforting to read wlw romance with a happy ending, no matter how predictable it may be. 555. I’ll probably read Water, Air, and Fire as well.
March 4, 2026
Well, that was a ride. Not sure how all that's left in the book is fitting in the remaining two episodes. But this really needs a better translation. Considering I read the official translation there were still a lot of errors (wrong pronouns, wrong names) and sentences that just felt clunky. I think watching the series definitely helped me follow the flow of the conversation in spots that might otherwise not have been clear in translation. I also feel like Apple and Mim have done a great job really bringing out the personality of their characters where it sometimes didn't come through as well in the book. Overall a fun read if you've enjoyed the series. 4 stars for the book, less stars for the translation.
December 5, 2025
What a rollercoaster. This really had everything: action, adventure, love, betrayal, hijinks, and schemes. The translation could have been better and all of the nicknames were really confusing and hard to keep up with but I liked this as an introduction to the series and characters. I'm super excited to read about the rest of the series, namely Wayo and Apo's stories.
December 26, 2025
me gustó más de lo que creí
Son muy bonitas ellas, aunque no voy a negar que las primas se robaron un poco de mi atención JAJKAJAKA
Pero vale, Din y Rose son muy lindas juntas y realmente la forma en la que se demuestran su amor es muy bella; si acaso, mi única queja es el perro de Wasu, ya está
3.5
Son muy bonitas ellas, aunque no voy a negar que las primas se robaron un poco de mi atención JAJKAJAKA
Pero vale, Din y Rose son muy lindas juntas y realmente la forma en la que se demuestran su amor es muy bella; si acaso, mi única queja es el perro de Wasu, ya está
3.5
August 26, 2025
Me encanta como las dos sólitas se van dando cuenta que se están enamorando pero no quieren aceptarlo.
Estar leyendo e imaginandolo con las actrices que harán esta adaptación será muy cool esta serie.
Estar leyendo e imaginandolo con las actrices que harán esta adaptación será muy cool esta serie.
May 13, 2025
Muy heteronormativo para mi gusto pero los personajes están bien y la historia es mona
January 5, 2026
Este libro me tenia tan preocupada que no podia dejarlo de leer. Rose y P'Din son de lo mas tiernas ksjdj
January 15, 2026
พี่สาวคนโตสูตรสำเร็จวิวาห์ลวงสู่วิวาห์รัก รักหยอกสู่รักหรอก
January 28, 2026
3.5
Lovely story but nothing too special
Lovely story but nothing too special
February 1, 2026
se fosse pela experiência de leitura, seria 3 ⭐, mas como eu não sei ler tailandês, vou deixar 4 ⭐ e não culpar tanto a pessoa que traduziu, mas que me irritou, irritou
February 1, 2026
El primer libro de los 4 elementos, como surgió el amor entre Din y Rose fue tierno, probablemente esperaba más escenas románticas, pero fue lindo como se enamoraron.
February 2, 2026
Las acciones hablan más que las palabras. No voy a decir que alguien es malo sin pruebas y no voy a decir que soy mejor que nadie.
February 4, 2026
Mi favorito de los 4E series, lo disfruté mucho.
Din es todo lo que está bien, Moddang la amiga de Rose me hizo reír mucho
Din es todo lo que está bien, Moddang la amiga de Rose me hizo reír mucho
March 15, 2026
2.5 ⭐️
la traducción es absolutamente horrible y muchas veces me perdía en lo que estaba leyendo, pero la historia es bastante cute
la traducción es absolutamente horrible y muchas veces me perdía en lo que estaba leyendo, pero la historia es bastante cute
April 12, 2026
4.5 estrellas
Read
April 17, 2026⭐️3.5/5
May 8, 2026
Became fan of this author after watching the series. I love the storyline and you brought characters into real life. The pairing Apple and mimu looks cute.
Displaying 1 - 23 of 23 reviews