A villain’s origin story that had me checking the locks on my windows and doors, The First Hunt was everything I could want in a psychological thriller. A prequel to the other two novels in the Final Hunt series, it was just as packed with nostalgia as it was brimming over with dread and foreboding. You see, this evil coming-of-age tale brought me right back to the 80s and 90s. At the same time, though, I came face-to-face with a killer, whose very existence chilled me to the bone. With a great character arc, I shifted from feeling for a poor little boy to wanting to hide in the shadows from a cunning mastermind as he stepped out into the world.
As for the storyline, it was the definition of perfectly plotted. Told primarily via dual POVs, it was both fast-paced and propulsive, including two action-packed crescendos and a twist you couldn’t possibly see coming. The best piece of all, though? No matter how you read this unputdownable three-book series, you’ll come out with a win. Start with the prequel, or save it for last. Either way you approach it, you’ll fly through the pages just wanting to know what is coming around the next blind, deftly penned turn. After all, while you might have an inkling about what’s coming next, the fully fleshed out main characters will still keep you guessing for sure.
All said and done, I’m not surprised in the least that Ms. Cole’s newest thriller was yet another home run. Featuring a reporter-turned-true-crime-writer facing off against a killer, this game of cat-and-mouse ended with quite the shocking bang. In fact, the last few chapters of this novel made me want to reread the whole series all over again. All I know is that you should clear your schedule of any chores or appointments. After all, I read the whole thing from beginning to end in one very short binge. Thanks to multiple plot lines that come together with utter precision, there wasn’t a moment of downtime as I raced through this binge-worthy read. Rating of 5 stars.
SYNOPSIS:
When echoes of her sister's murder reignite the darkest of hunts, no one in Seattle is safe.
Seattle, 1985—Crime reporter Holly Sparks is driven to obsession by her sister's unsolved murder—a crime she's convinced was the work of the infamous Green River Killer. But her investigation takes a terrifying turn when she uncovers a chilling truth: There might be two killers stalking the city, and one wears a badge.
Five years later, her bestselling true crime novel can’t erase the pain of her sister’s unsolved case. But when Holly's violent ex-fiancé is let out of prison on parole, and murders mirroring the Green River Killer begin again, Holly fears the unthinkable: Is her ex-fiancé behind her sister's death and a string of others? As the line blurs between hunter and hunted, she faces a deadly choice—uncover the truth or become the next victim.
Only the hunt will tell.
Thank you to Audrey J. Cole for my complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.
PUB DATE: June 17, 2025
Content warning: domestic violence, stalking, hit-and-run, violence, murder