I love this book! I tend to be drawn toward the form of the graphic memoir, and this was not what I was expecting, but I appreciated the emotional honesty, humor and clear-eyed presence with devastating loss. There is something very simple about the book. Here is a writer who wants to hold onto time as her mother declines, knows that soon her mother will be gone, and the only way she can think to hold onto this 'time', these moments with her mother, is to keep a journal of their daily life.
The book is broken into parts, and then sections in a way that makes it a little less narratively connected and complex than some other graphic memoirs I've read. It's vignettish I suppose, without the kind of building, recursive reflection that often weaves through similar stories. And yet, Leavitt invites us into her world in a way that honors her experience, her relationship with her family, and her mothers' illness, and with tenderness and care, explores the complexity of family dynamics when a devastating illness hits.
I also really appreciated that this is a book in which the queer writer and her partner play a big role. It felt really good to read a book about a family in which people are emotionally connected, and queerness is not the tragic focus, but an accepted and appreciated part of life.
The opening scene -- the first section of the first part -- is called Nightmares, and I just finished reading "The Door" by Magda Szabo, which also opens up with a nightmare. And, as it turns out, last night I had a bit of a nightmare myself. Scary, but kind of cool, too. Very moody, a lot of noirish atmospheric pressure. I think it was in a kind of dramatic, night-time black and white in the rain dream (I often dream in color.) And I'm pretty sure part of it had to do with eating fast-food (eek!). And then, the usual anxieties my dreams are filled with. Don't need to go into that here, but often there is a kind of voicelessness in a time when the voice is most needed, and that is also something that happens in the opening of The Door. But not in the opening of Tangles. Sarah is young in this opening scene (and older reflecting back on this moment), living with her parents, and having a nightmare and she screams and waits for her mother to come in. This is her ritual. She calls out, then pretends to be sleeping when her mother comes in so she can hear her mother say, "It's okay honey. It was just a dream."
Only, of course, the illness her mother suffers from is a harsh reality, one she wishes she could wake up out of.
So, this is a graphic memoir in which Sarah's mother, who has always been provident, nurturing, a solid presence in the lives of her sisters (Sarah's aunts) and her husband and daughters (Sarah and her sister), and her students (she is a teacher) becomes more and more unraveled (untangled?) by Alzheimers. She does her best to find some continuous presence in her mother, and to remain compassionate though all of the challenges. One of the hardest things to tangle with emotionally in here, and perhaps intellectually, is the question of what it means to be human. Sarah's mother is able to articulate a feeling of no longer being a person as her illness progresses, and not only is this acutely painful to witness as a reader, but it brings up so many questions about the bonds that tie us together, and tie us to ourselves.
Some sections are one or two pages, some are much longer. They weave through time and offer just enough context to make sense of the present moment, and many of them start with quotes or transcribed conversations, often with some of the absurdity of language and thought that comes from dementia, and what Leavitt calls "poetic mistakes".
So, this book is a mixture of humor and anguish, with some travel through time and from place to place. Sometimes I wanted it to be a bit more intensely reflective, but as it is it is a beautiful book and one that I think will continue to have a lot of meaning for a lot of people. That said, I have a friend who has been going through a lot of hardship watching a family member die of early onset Alzheimers, and I am wondering if I should send it to her or not. It's hard to know.
I recommend this book and look forward to reading more of Leavitt's work!