So many thoughts! Overall, this lands at a 3.5 for me. It was a very easy to read story. There were some things that I liked, and a handful of things I'd have loved to see adjusted/places I found a little polishing may have been beneficial.
To start: Miller (MJ) Morgan suffers a devastating loss earlier in life, and spends the next decade-plus at a pause; unable to write, or truly move forward in almost any way. When she meets Grey, they have a very hard-to-explain connection and quickly become one another's person. She finds herself starting to become unstuck, and MJ wonders whether she can move forward and live a meaningful life with the memory of her loss intact.
Spoilers from this point on will be very minor as I'd like to respect Bianca's request to let everyone experience this for themselves, however I will offer some background on basic info in the story for the purpose of my critique/review. If you'd prefer to avoid that, please come back to this section once your read-through is complete. :)
Bianca does a good job of writing stories that are palatable. That may sound like a simple compliment, but it absolutely is not. How many times have you picked up a book from the shelf and been totally unable to engross yourself into the story? Bianca doesn't have that problem.
To the setting: Lovely! Who doesn't like the idea of a small, homey beach town? A small town was almost required for this story given MJ's fear of vehicles, which was, in my opinion, pretty severe.
The line, "Her dreams would always be pictures pinned to a wooden board." (IYKYK.) TOOK. ME. OUT. I loved it.
The way these two met didn't work for me. Grey nearly hits her with his car when she runs across the road. In my view, assuming MJ struggles with cars to this degree, it seems probable that this would REALLY scare her. But apart from a briefly increased heart rate, she appears largely unfazed, even winking at Grey a moment or two after. I did struggle to root for the couple afterward because this is the foundation they build off of. Insta-love can work, but I tend to find it best after a couple finds themselves spending some time together-even if it's only a couple of hours-and building from that. The quick 'almost hit and run, and now we're hooked' was so fast that it lost me a little bit.
Now, the idea of being frozen in place after a death is reasonable. Life-altering events shake you. We would never be able to appreciate the beautiful moments in life if we didn't live through bad ones, too. With that said, being frozen for eleven years was... Well, there's an element of grief which feels so terrible that eventually we all want to try. And MJ doesn't seem to do that. She is literally STUCK. I found this to be unrealistic, not because of the action, but because of how LONG she remains so.
I did enjoy the twist at the end of the story, and the epilogue!
A couple of other points:
I am a HOUND for grammar, and did locate a couple of errors in the text, which I documented.
Description, as well as dialogue, can be complicated to get right. There's an utter truth that speech requires which I found in certain lines, and was lacking in others. Some of it, though sweet, was repetitive. On description: There's a yin and yang with the number of descriptors to use, where and how to place them. There was too much for me in much of it-in one or two places, several pages worth. Often, a few well-chosen and correctly placed words will paint a stunning scene that allows you as the author to lean on one of the very best tools you have: The imagination of your reader. There were a couple places in which I'd have liked to have been able to rely on mine more.
When it boils down, writing is a craft, and Bianca is working her tail off at it. Any of us who love the field and strive to improve will achieve that goal if they continue to work at it. From the pieces of her debut, Diving In, that I read, she is certainly on the road to become more skilled as she goes. She has a very promising future as a writer and storyteller, and I hope like MAD that she continues, because this ride has been SO FUN.
Big thanks to Bianca for selecting me to be an ARC reader at no cost to her in exchange for a review. It was truly a pleasure. All opinions and thoughts are fully my own.