What do you think?
Rate this book
Frost Lake High #2
Playing with Forever
From USA Today bestselling author Rebecca Jenshak comes the next in a brand new YA romance series that follows Frost Lake High School's state champion soccer team.
Tutoring the captain of Frost Lake High's soccer team isn't on her bucket list. And neither is falling for him.
Seventeen-year-old Lacey Kerr is a lot of head cheerleader, an A+ student, vice president of student council, a loyal friend, and beloved by her classmates.
What she isn't is a fan of star soccer player Vaughn Collins.
And he knows it.
Unfortunately for him, he needs her.
With his grades on the line, he'll do anything to turn it around and keep his spot on the soccer team. Even if it means winning over his ex-girlfriend's best friend and convincing her to tutor him.
They're different. She's sunshine and he's…not. She has a bucket list of fun things to do before high school is over and he's allergic to fun.
But as they spend more time together, studying and crossing things off Lacey's list, they realize they're more alike than either of them wants to admit.
She doesn't want to fall for him, and he doesn't want to fall for anyone. They're both good at playing the game, but maybe this time it could be forever.
Tutoring the captain of Frost Lake High's soccer team isn't on her bucket list. And neither is falling for him.
Seventeen-year-old Lacey Kerr is a lot of head cheerleader, an A+ student, vice president of student council, a loyal friend, and beloved by her classmates.
What she isn't is a fan of star soccer player Vaughn Collins.
And he knows it.
Unfortunately for him, he needs her.
With his grades on the line, he'll do anything to turn it around and keep his spot on the soccer team. Even if it means winning over his ex-girlfriend's best friend and convincing her to tutor him.
They're different. She's sunshine and he's…not. She has a bucket list of fun things to do before high school is over and he's allergic to fun.
But as they spend more time together, studying and crossing things off Lacey's list, they realize they're more alike than either of them wants to admit.
She doesn't want to fall for him, and he doesn't want to fall for anyone. They're both good at playing the game, but maybe this time it could be forever.
368 pages, Paperback
Published January 20, 2026
125 people are currently reading
5994 people want to read
About the author
Rebecca Jenshak
50 books7,079 followersRebecca Jenshak is a new adult romance author.
Sign up for her newsletter: https://www.subscribepage.com/rebecca...
Amazon: https://goo.gl/6VtdGu
Facebook: https://goo.gl/ix1kB2
Instagram: https://goo.gl/MQw2FW
Sign up for her newsletter: https://www.subscribepage.com/rebecca...
Amazon: https://goo.gl/6VtdGu
Facebook: https://goo.gl/ix1kB2
Instagram: https://goo.gl/MQw2FW
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 134 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This is a classic sports romance. Team captain x tutor. Though in this case the athlete was the fmc bestfirends ex, which I found a little off putting because the author made us hate him in the last book, (or atleast I did) I found Lacey and Vaughns relationship very dense, and I felt like they did'nt really have any tension or passion between them. I also jst could not get past how Lacey was dating her bestfriends ex that did her so dirty, even though she has a new boyfriend.
January 29, 2026
4.5⭐️
This one was so cute! It was the epitome of a high school romance. The FMC is the head cheerleader and is made of sunshine and rainbows and the MMC is the captain of the soccer team and always brooding (clearly a match made in heaven). I love a tutoring trope and I’m also a sucker for a blond MMC. I’m super excited for whatever comes next in the series (I’m REALLY hoping it’s Rowan).
This one was so cute! It was the epitome of a high school romance. The FMC is the head cheerleader and is made of sunshine and rainbows and the MMC is the captain of the soccer team and always brooding (clearly a match made in heaven). I love a tutoring trope and I’m also a sucker for a blond MMC. I’m super excited for whatever comes next in the series (I’m REALLY hoping it’s Rowan).
December 23, 2025
4.0 ⭐
[2:38am — 23/12/2025]
I want to start off by thanking NetGalley, Rebecca Jenshak & Bloom Books for sending me this book. I am most grateful, and I will provide an honest review. Everything I’ll say is formed of my opinion only.
Review time!!
Are Vaughn and Lacey better than Claire and Austin? One thousand percent. There’s something about the tutor and the captain of a team trope that will always get me. I’m a sucker for that and it kinda being grumpy x sunshine too? Adorable.
In the beginning, I was a little off putted considering this is Claire’s ex that Lacey was getting with, but given their age, I think it’s fine. I thought a second chance romance would be better for Claire and Vaughn but come to think of it, they never really made sense romantically.
They benefited off of each other in the sense of having the same goals. That’s all really. What Vaughn did (leaving Claire in the first book) will always be shitty but it’s one of those leeway moments you can have for some characters.
If they were in their late twenties acting like this, I’d obviously be like ‘erm no’ BUT they’re teens here so high school ‘drama/relationships’ makes sense. I do believe though, however, that Vaughn could have had a better character development.
In a way, it didn’t feel as if his character got much justice from the first book, but towards the end, I really liked his character. Do I think Vaughn could be a bit more yearn-y/pathetically down bad? Yes. But, I mostly wish that every time.
I liked Lacey’s character though actually. More than I expected to. I do, however, hoped we could have gotten more interactions of her dad and his dad. It feels important to me that it happens. Regardless, I enjoyed it.
The football (soccer) moments? Freaking everything to me. I would have liked more in depth football moments but I’ll take it. Also, the mention of Arsenal was off putting. I’m saying that because I hate the club with everything in me. I am an Arsenal hater, so naturally, when they came up, I side eyed.
Pick a better team, girl. My Liverpool heart is breaking every time that stupid Arse club is mentioned. Anyone but them. Well that’s not true, I hate every club that’s not mine. Okay, I’m getting distracted.
My favourite scene was probably when the two of them kissed underneath the stars (bucket list check). It was such a soft and sweet scene, it’s pure romantic softness moments that I love to read about.
Overall, I enjoyed this book but I believe it could be improved in other aspects [as listed above] and possibly a little longer by giving us scenes of them travelling internationally.
Like for instance, incorporating a school field to go abroad and in a way, Lacey does that list. And other stuff on the list gets completed. But, yeah, nonetheless, an adorable, sweet, heartfelt book.
I hope we get Rowan’s book next. Rowan and Austin’s sister (maybe). I’m excited either way!
[3:01am — 23/12/2025]
[2:38am — 23/12/2025]
I want to start off by thanking NetGalley, Rebecca Jenshak & Bloom Books for sending me this book. I am most grateful, and I will provide an honest review. Everything I’ll say is formed of my opinion only.
Review time!!
Are Vaughn and Lacey better than Claire and Austin? One thousand percent. There’s something about the tutor and the captain of a team trope that will always get me. I’m a sucker for that and it kinda being grumpy x sunshine too? Adorable.
In the beginning, I was a little off putted considering this is Claire’s ex that Lacey was getting with, but given their age, I think it’s fine. I thought a second chance romance would be better for Claire and Vaughn but come to think of it, they never really made sense romantically.
They benefited off of each other in the sense of having the same goals. That’s all really. What Vaughn did (leaving Claire in the first book) will always be shitty but it’s one of those leeway moments you can have for some characters.
If they were in their late twenties acting like this, I’d obviously be like ‘erm no’ BUT they’re teens here so high school ‘drama/relationships’ makes sense. I do believe though, however, that Vaughn could have had a better character development.
In a way, it didn’t feel as if his character got much justice from the first book, but towards the end, I really liked his character. Do I think Vaughn could be a bit more yearn-y/pathetically down bad? Yes. But, I mostly wish that every time.
I liked Lacey’s character though actually. More than I expected to. I do, however, hoped we could have gotten more interactions of her dad and his dad. It feels important to me that it happens. Regardless, I enjoyed it.
The football (soccer) moments? Freaking everything to me. I would have liked more in depth football moments but I’ll take it. Also, the mention of Arsenal was off putting. I’m saying that because I hate the club with everything in me. I am an Arsenal hater, so naturally, when they came up, I side eyed.
Pick a better team, girl. My Liverpool heart is breaking every time that stupid Arse club is mentioned. Anyone but them. Well that’s not true, I hate every club that’s not mine. Okay, I’m getting distracted.
My favourite scene was probably when the two of them kissed underneath the stars (bucket list check). It was such a soft and sweet scene, it’s pure romantic softness moments that I love to read about.
Overall, I enjoyed this book but I believe it could be improved in other aspects [as listed above] and possibly a little longer by giving us scenes of them travelling internationally.
Like for instance, incorporating a school field to go abroad and in a way, Lacey does that list. And other stuff on the list gets completed. But, yeah, nonetheless, an adorable, sweet, heartfelt book.
I hope we get Rowan’s book next. Rowan and Austin’s sister (maybe). I’m excited either way!
[3:01am — 23/12/2025]
January 27, 2026
this was so much better than book 1! 🫶🏼🎉
the development of Vaughn, his relationship with Lacey, the friendship group 👍🏼
very cute HS soccer romance!
the development of Vaughn, his relationship with Lacey, the friendship group 👍🏼
very cute HS soccer romance!
January 25, 2026
I don't read a lot of YA romance but if Rebecca writes it I will read it and I am so glad I did! This was such a sweet story with all the high school nostalgia! LOVED IT!
Vaughn's sole focus is Soccer and is failing math. He turns to the smartest girl in his grade to tutor him which so happens to be his ex's best friend. Lacey is the peppiest person in school and so full of sunshine so she isn't thrilled to help Vaughn who is serious all the time and doesn't know how to let loose. The more time they spend together the more they realize that they may have judged each other too harshly. They begin to push each other out of their comfort zones and come together to complete Lacey's high school bucket list is the sweetest way.
Vaughn stepped up in the biggest way! The way he wanted to help Lacey check off every single line on her bucket list was so dang cute. Lacey helped Vaughn realize there is more to life than just soccer. The character growth between them was so incredible! The connection was perfectly done for a high school couple. I didn't feel like it was too unrealistic or too much. And Vaughn's grand gesture at the end had me so giddy! I can't wait to read more from this series!!
AUDIO: This was narrated by Jesse Vilinsky and Andrew Eiden. I enjoyed this one a lot! They both embodied the high school setting and gave into all the highs and lows that come with that age.
-YA Romance
-Soccer Captain x Cheerleading Captain
-Grumpy x Sunshine
-She tutors him
-Opposites Attract
-Best Friends Ex
-Bucket List
Vaughn's sole focus is Soccer and is failing math. He turns to the smartest girl in his grade to tutor him which so happens to be his ex's best friend. Lacey is the peppiest person in school and so full of sunshine so she isn't thrilled to help Vaughn who is serious all the time and doesn't know how to let loose. The more time they spend together the more they realize that they may have judged each other too harshly. They begin to push each other out of their comfort zones and come together to complete Lacey's high school bucket list is the sweetest way.
Vaughn stepped up in the biggest way! The way he wanted to help Lacey check off every single line on her bucket list was so dang cute. Lacey helped Vaughn realize there is more to life than just soccer. The character growth between them was so incredible! The connection was perfectly done for a high school couple. I didn't feel like it was too unrealistic or too much. And Vaughn's grand gesture at the end had me so giddy! I can't wait to read more from this series!!
AUDIO: This was narrated by Jesse Vilinsky and Andrew Eiden. I enjoyed this one a lot! They both embodied the high school setting and gave into all the highs and lows that come with that age.
-YA Romance
-Soccer Captain x Cheerleading Captain
-Grumpy x Sunshine
-She tutors him
-Opposites Attract
-Best Friends Ex
-Bucket List
February 5, 2026
I hadn’t read the first book when I received this one, but I had no trouble picking this up and reading it as a standalone. The backstory of the characters is explained well enough, though probably could have been more fleshed out if you read them in order!
I’m such a sucker for the tutor x athlete trope and Playing With Forever didn’t disappoint! Vaughn and Lacey were opposites but Lacey brought out the best in Vaughn, he really needed her sunshine. I was a little uncomfortable with the best friend’s ex trope but that’s more of a personal taste issue, even though the characters talked about it and there was no bad blood between them. I liked how Vaughn helped Lacey work on her late mother’s highschool bucket list, that was a super cute way to bring them closer together!
Because I’ve read other RJ books I found myself aging the characters up to college in my mind a lot, until she’d write something highschool specific that reminded me of their age. For young adults who haven’t read anything like this before I think this could easily become their new favourite, and open them up to the wonderful world of sports romance🥰
**Thank you to Bloom Books for providing me an advanced copy! All opinions are my own.**
I’m such a sucker for the tutor x athlete trope and Playing With Forever didn’t disappoint! Vaughn and Lacey were opposites but Lacey brought out the best in Vaughn, he really needed her sunshine. I was a little uncomfortable with the best friend’s ex trope but that’s more of a personal taste issue, even though the characters talked about it and there was no bad blood between them. I liked how Vaughn helped Lacey work on her late mother’s highschool bucket list, that was a super cute way to bring them closer together!
Because I’ve read other RJ books I found myself aging the characters up to college in my mind a lot, until she’d write something highschool specific that reminded me of their age. For young adults who haven’t read anything like this before I think this could easily become their new favourite, and open them up to the wonderful world of sports romance🥰
**Thank you to Bloom Books for providing me an advanced copy! All opinions are my own.**
January 15, 2026
First of all, Thank you Rebecca & NetGalley for gifting me this early reading opportunity!!!
This is my second book by Rebecca Jenshak and she just has a way of pulling me in! I can’t wait to read more by her.
This was a cute, heartfelt, high school romance, with mild spice & lots of great characters! At first I was a little put off by the whole best friend’s ex trope, however the way this was written makes it impossible not to pull for these two!! I was so drawn into their characters and all they were dealing with in their personal lives, but also really enjoyed the relationship and bonding between them & the side characters as well.
Lacey is the cheerleader who is good at math & Vaughn is the captain of the soccer team who needs to pass this algebra test! This was a fun tutor x team captain story, with some added emotional aspect. A great story about finding what makes you happy and getting out of your comfort zone! These two were so perfect together & Lacey was just this optimistic ray of sunshine that Vaughn absolutely needed in his life! I loved these two and this story!
This is my second book by Rebecca Jenshak and she just has a way of pulling me in! I can’t wait to read more by her.
This was a cute, heartfelt, high school romance, with mild spice & lots of great characters! At first I was a little put off by the whole best friend’s ex trope, however the way this was written makes it impossible not to pull for these two!! I was so drawn into their characters and all they were dealing with in their personal lives, but also really enjoyed the relationship and bonding between them & the side characters as well.
Lacey is the cheerleader who is good at math & Vaughn is the captain of the soccer team who needs to pass this algebra test! This was a fun tutor x team captain story, with some added emotional aspect. A great story about finding what makes you happy and getting out of your comfort zone! These two were so perfect together & Lacey was just this optimistic ray of sunshine that Vaughn absolutely needed in his life! I loved these two and this story!
January 24, 2026
after enjoying the first book, i was excited for this one, and it did not disappoint. i had a great time again. lacey reminds me of myself trying to be my best self in high school with school, sports, etc., which made her very relatable to my younger self 🫂 i love lacey and vaughn together. they were super cutie and overall this was a super cute read!
lacey is a head cheerleader, an A+ student, vice president of student council, a good friend, and loved by her classmates. she isn’t a fan of star soccer player vaughn (he is after all her best friend’s ex). however, he needs her because his grades and spot on the team are on the line. he plans to convince her to tutor him so he can continue playing, BUT the more time they spend together, they realize they are more alike than they want to admit.
tropes: grumpy x sunshine, best friend’s ex bf, cheerleader x soccer player, tutoring the team captain, bucket list, young adult
📣📚⚽️📒✏️
lacey is a head cheerleader, an A+ student, vice president of student council, a good friend, and loved by her classmates. she isn’t a fan of star soccer player vaughn (he is after all her best friend’s ex). however, he needs her because his grades and spot on the team are on the line. he plans to convince her to tutor him so he can continue playing, BUT the more time they spend together, they realize they are more alike than they want to admit.
tropes: grumpy x sunshine, best friend’s ex bf, cheerleader x soccer player, tutoring the team captain, bucket list, young adult
📣📚⚽️📒✏️
January 16, 2026
Playing with Forever is book two of the Frost Lake High Series and it was completely adorable! This was my first arc read of 2026 and I really enjoyed this one. I don't often read YA romance, but I will read anything and everything that Rebecca writes! It was a classic cheer captain x star soccer player that was needing some help with Algebra to maintain his eligibility to play soccer. These two were opposites in everyday, definitely a grumpy x sunshine story, and I loved that Lacey brought out some positivity and ability to actually just enjoy high school for Vaughn. Overall, such a fun YA romance and I would definitely recommend this one!
February 2, 2026
This was a cute and fun read. I forgot that this series takes place in Michigan!!
I loved how enthusiastic and bubbly Lacey was. She made sure everyone always had a good time! I think a lot of it was from missing her mom and her dad being there, but not really realizing that she needed more time with him. She always tried to make others happy.
Vaughn was a little more somber as his dad was always on him trying to make him better and work harder.
I loved the loved the list and going back into the high school world!
I loved how enthusiastic and bubbly Lacey was. She made sure everyone always had a good time! I think a lot of it was from missing her mom and her dad being there, but not really realizing that she needed more time with him. She always tried to make others happy.
Vaughn was a little more somber as his dad was always on him trying to make him better and work harder.
I loved the loved the list and going back into the high school world!
January 29, 2026
When i started this book, I had to really recall my memory on what happened in the first book. I almost forgot who Vaugh was.... Once I got in the groove of the book. I remembered how much i loved Lacey. Her personality, it's just so lively! I love how much of an empath she is. She said no to tutoring Vaugh, but when he failed she felt bad and put her disdain aside to help him. She is just that person and I love that about her.
Vaugh Collins, he's not as bad as he sounds! He just wants to be the best and live up to his dads success and build his own success. I think he needs to give himself more grace. I love how Lacey and Vaugh first became friends and then slowly started falling in love with each other.
They both understood each other in different ways but similar. I think they truly were meant to be soulmates.
I really hope book three is about Rowan and i hope its Torrance (who said that). Teammates little sister, cmon, thats a trope we all want.
Vaugh Collins, he's not as bad as he sounds! He just wants to be the best and live up to his dads success and build his own success. I think he needs to give himself more grace. I love how Lacey and Vaugh first became friends and then slowly started falling in love with each other.
They both understood each other in different ways but similar. I think they truly were meant to be soulmates.
I really hope book three is about Rowan and i hope its Torrance (who said that). Teammates little sister, cmon, thats a trope we all want.
January 20, 2026
I adored this book! It’s been a while since I’ve read a YA romance, mainly cause I don’t have any auto-4-or-5-stars authors for this genre but now I gained one!
Thank you Rebecca for the ARC 🩷
Every type of romance can be cute but there is something different about high school romance. It’s simply a different kind of cute.
I loved how Lacey and Vaughn weren’t into each other right away. I don’t mind instant attraction but I LOVE when the relationship between the main characters slowly develops and this is exactly what happens here!
⚽️🎓Soccer player team captain X tutor (she’s also a cheerleader!)
💞He’s her best friend’s ex but it’s not really a forbidden trope (a pro for me, I’m not a huge fan of any type of forbidden tropes)
📋 she has a high school bucket list to complete
It wasn’t my first Rebecca’s book (but it was my first YA one!) so I knew I would enjoy the writing style. The characterization is well done, too, as always.
One of my favorite parts about Rebecca’s sports romance is the sports aspect. I love reading sports romance but I’m not exactly into any of the sports I read about, also not a fan of any team etc.
With that said - I love how Rebecca’s books do have the sports paragraphs! The actual sport really happens on page and the writing of such scenes and the amount of them is perfect. I think it’s balanced well for both parties to enjoy - sports enthusiasts and people like me ;).
While sticking to the series order is obviously advised, this book totally works as a standalone. I haven’t read the first book in the series and I don’t feel like it affected my experience with Playing with Forever negatively.
Thank you Rebecca for the ARC 🩷
Every type of romance can be cute but there is something different about high school romance. It’s simply a different kind of cute.
I loved how Lacey and Vaughn weren’t into each other right away. I don’t mind instant attraction but I LOVE when the relationship between the main characters slowly develops and this is exactly what happens here!
⚽️🎓Soccer player team captain X tutor (she’s also a cheerleader!)
💞He’s her best friend’s ex but it’s not really a forbidden trope (a pro for me, I’m not a huge fan of any type of forbidden tropes)
📋 she has a high school bucket list to complete
It wasn’t my first Rebecca’s book (but it was my first YA one!) so I knew I would enjoy the writing style. The characterization is well done, too, as always.
One of my favorite parts about Rebecca’s sports romance is the sports aspect. I love reading sports romance but I’m not exactly into any of the sports I read about, also not a fan of any team etc.
With that said - I love how Rebecca’s books do have the sports paragraphs! The actual sport really happens on page and the writing of such scenes and the amount of them is perfect. I think it’s balanced well for both parties to enjoy - sports enthusiasts and people like me ;).
While sticking to the series order is obviously advised, this book totally works as a standalone. I haven’t read the first book in the series and I don’t feel like it affected my experience with Playing with Forever negatively.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Playing with Forever is book two in the Frost Lake High series, and it completely won me over. This YA sports romance follows Lacey and Vaughn and delivers such a cute, heartfelt high school love story that’s easy to fall into.
At first, I was a little unsure because of the best friend’s ex-boyfriend trope, and I also wasn’t the biggest Vaughn fan after book one. But Rebecca Jenshak handled both so well. The situation felt realistic for a high school romance, especially since Claire and Vaughn didn’t have much in common beyond their shared drive and work ethic. That made Lacey and Vaughn’s relationship feel natural, genuine, and earned.
I loved the tutor x student and cheerleader x soccer star dynamics, paired with a classic grumpy (Vaughn) x sunshine (Lacey) vibe. The banter between them was adorable, and while they seem like complete opposites at first, they actually have a lot in common and truly balance each other out. Completing Lacey’s bucket list together was such a sweet way to deepen their bond.
Vaughn’s character development was a standout for me. Rebecca really gave him a redemption arc, and by the end, I couldn’t help but root for him. This story had all the first real love energy—innocent, emotional, and full of heart.
Overall, this was a sweet, cozy, and feel-good high school romance. At this point, whatever Rebecca Jenshak writes, I’ll absolutely read it. And I’m really hoping Rowan gets his own book next!
At first, I was a little unsure because of the best friend’s ex-boyfriend trope, and I also wasn’t the biggest Vaughn fan after book one. But Rebecca Jenshak handled both so well. The situation felt realistic for a high school romance, especially since Claire and Vaughn didn’t have much in common beyond their shared drive and work ethic. That made Lacey and Vaughn’s relationship feel natural, genuine, and earned.
I loved the tutor x student and cheerleader x soccer star dynamics, paired with a classic grumpy (Vaughn) x sunshine (Lacey) vibe. The banter between them was adorable, and while they seem like complete opposites at first, they actually have a lot in common and truly balance each other out. Completing Lacey’s bucket list together was such a sweet way to deepen their bond.
Vaughn’s character development was a standout for me. Rebecca really gave him a redemption arc, and by the end, I couldn’t help but root for him. This story had all the first real love energy—innocent, emotional, and full of heart.
Overall, this was a sweet, cozy, and feel-good high school romance. At this point, whatever Rebecca Jenshak writes, I’ll absolutely read it. And I’m really hoping Rowan gets his own book next!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
"Maybe she has changed me. Or maybe I’m just finally figuring out who I really am."
⭐️3.75
This was a cute, easy read, pretty much everything you’d expect from a YA romance with sports elements. The plot is simple to follow, and I enjoyed the bucket list concept; it was fun watching Lacey work her way through it and grow along the way.
For me, Vaughn had the strongest character development. Seeing him slowly open up and figure out who he really is, and what he wants beyond soccer, was one of the highlights of the story.
Some moments did feel a bit cliché, especially the team captain and cheerleader dynamic, and the fact that he’s her best friend’s ex wasn’t the most compelling trope for me. That said, it all makes sense given that the characters are teenagers, and it fits the overall tone of the book.
Overall, a sweet and enjoyable read.
Thank you to NetGalley and Bloom Books for the advanced e-copy.
⭐️3.75
This was a cute, easy read, pretty much everything you’d expect from a YA romance with sports elements. The plot is simple to follow, and I enjoyed the bucket list concept; it was fun watching Lacey work her way through it and grow along the way.
For me, Vaughn had the strongest character development. Seeing him slowly open up and figure out who he really is, and what he wants beyond soccer, was one of the highlights of the story.
Some moments did feel a bit cliché, especially the team captain and cheerleader dynamic, and the fact that he’s her best friend’s ex wasn’t the most compelling trope for me. That said, it all makes sense given that the characters are teenagers, and it fits the overall tone of the book.
Overall, a sweet and enjoyable read.
Thank you to NetGalley and Bloom Books for the advanced e-copy.
January 16, 2026
I’m quickly becoming a Rebecca Jenshak fan! This is my first YA book of hers and it was so sweet. It is set in high school, which isn’t always my favorite but the characters were mature and they really sucked me in. I couldn’t put this one down!
Vaughn is the captain of the soccer team and he is in desperate need of a tutor so he can stay eligible to play. Lacey is the sunshine cheerleader that is friendly to everyone except Vaughn. Lacey is best friends with Vaughn’s ex and she really makes him work for her friendship.
This was such a sweet story. I loved the chemistry and banter between Lacey and Vaughn. These two are more similar than they think and they form such a sweet connection. It really makes me want to go back and read book one in the series. I can’t wait for more from Frost Lake High!
Thank you Bloom and NetGalley for the arc!
Read if you love:
✨grumpy x sunshine
✨cheerleader FMC x soccer player MMC
✨bucket list
✨best friend’s ex
Vaughn is the captain of the soccer team and he is in desperate need of a tutor so he can stay eligible to play. Lacey is the sunshine cheerleader that is friendly to everyone except Vaughn. Lacey is best friends with Vaughn’s ex and she really makes him work for her friendship.
This was such a sweet story. I loved the chemistry and banter between Lacey and Vaughn. These two are more similar than they think and they form such a sweet connection. It really makes me want to go back and read book one in the series. I can’t wait for more from Frost Lake High!
Thank you Bloom and NetGalley for the arc!
Read if you love:
✨grumpy x sunshine
✨cheerleader FMC x soccer player MMC
✨bucket list
✨best friend’s ex
January 20, 2026
This was a cute YA high school sports romance perfect for fans of authors like Lynn Painter. I liked that the soccer player MMC had no interest in dating but ends up falling for his ex's best friend and math tutor. While she is busy trying not to cross the 'girl code' and focus on completing her dead mom's senior year bucket list that she never finished. There's lots of charming banter, outings and it was good on audio too. Definitely an enjoyable second book in the Frost Lake High series. Many thanks to Bloom Books for sending me a physical ARC copy in exchange for my honest review.
Steam level: kissing only until the epilogue when the couple are older (mild fade to black details)
Steam level: kissing only until the epilogue when the couple are older (mild fade to black details)
January 10, 2026
First ARC of the year and I LOVED it 😭 I adored the first book of this series so much- it was the first book I read in 2025, so I was super excited to have the chance to read the sequel early! Pretty much got approved and finished the book all within 10 hours 🤣
This series is so stinking sweet. It’s YA (which is not normally my jam) but I found this group of characters to be so charming and mature which I find to not always be the case with books set in high school. The romance is tender and wholesome while also having conflict without unnecessary drama. Rebecca Jenshak is an auto-read author for me and this set of books has become my favorite series of hers.
⚽️ soccer star mmc
🎉 cheerleader fmc
⚽️ grumpy / sunshine
🎉 tutor / student
⚽️ dual pov
Thank you Bloom and NetGalley for the advanced copy!
This series is so stinking sweet. It’s YA (which is not normally my jam) but I found this group of characters to be so charming and mature which I find to not always be the case with books set in high school. The romance is tender and wholesome while also having conflict without unnecessary drama. Rebecca Jenshak is an auto-read author for me and this set of books has become my favorite series of hers.
⚽️ soccer star mmc
🎉 cheerleader fmc
⚽️ grumpy / sunshine
🎉 tutor / student
⚽️ dual pov
Thank you Bloom and NetGalley for the advanced copy!
January 12, 2026
“Maybe she has changed me. Or maybe I’m just finally figuring out who I really am.” s changed me. Or maybe I’m just finally figuring out who I really am.”
Ah young love. Those confusing feelings. So innocent and pure. The excitement of something new and unexpected. It’s been awhile since a read a high school romance, and this one brought back all those experiences. Plus the pressure of grades and balancing sports.
Playing with Forever is so cute. It’s well written, and has a nice flow. This is my first book by Rebecca Jenshak and I’ll definitely pick up more.
Thank you to Bloom & Rebecca for the gifted ARC paperback!
soccer player • cheerleader • best friend’s ex-boyfriend • she has a bucket list • he’s helping her with it
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Ah young love. Those confusing feelings. So innocent and pure. The excitement of something new and unexpected. It’s been awhile since a read a high school romance, and this one brought back all those experiences. Plus the pressure of grades and balancing sports.
Playing with Forever is so cute. It’s well written, and has a nice flow. This is my first book by Rebecca Jenshak and I’ll definitely pick up more.
Thank you to Bloom & Rebecca for the gifted ARC paperback!
soccer player • cheerleader • best friend’s ex-boyfriend • she has a bucket list • he’s helping her with it
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
January 24, 2026
this book was the perfect ya romance! i loved the relationship between lacey and vaughn, i feel like they both pulled each other out of their comfort zone in different ways. the grumpy x sunshine vibes fit their characters so well and i loved the tutor dynamic to friends to more!
if you’re looking for an adorable ya book i would deff recommend this series i loved both books and im hoping we get another book for rowan’s character next!!
if you’re looking for an adorable ya book i would deff recommend this series i loved both books and im hoping we get another book for rowan’s character next!!
January 30, 2026
Super cute. And this is 4.5🌟 because it had COMPLEX NUMBERS in it and algebra2! Def YA material but super fun and cute read. Not much spice and a little more emotional than book 1. Lacey and Vaughn and a bucket list made this book just perfect. .5🌶️💧
February 6, 2026
So Cute! I'm calling it right now, the next book is going to be Rowan and Torrance (i think thats how you spell her name).
January 18, 2026
Ah, another Rebecca Jenshak gold! This book is pure sweetness, and emotionally perfect. It warms your heart, and makes you remember those times of having your first love. Its opposite attracts, with a grumpy x sunshine trope that is freaking adorable and totally high school. Lacey is the head cheerleader and all things glitter and sparkle, including her. She’s warm, peppy, and caring. She also has this grudge on her bestie’s ex, who she ends up tutoring. Cue in Vaughn. He’s the broody, captain of the soccer team with this overwhelming pressure to maintain the team’s top rank, while living up to his dad’s super star status. He has no time for girls. But being around Lacey starts to warm him and soothe all the parts that have left him stressed and empty. These two couldn’t be more perfect for each other. Both are focused on their respective sport and dreams, but they also find that being with each other fills a void they didn’t know they needed filled. It leaves you with the butterflies and the stinging sensation in your stomach because you can’t help but feel for these two! So relatable, easy to read, and one that will leave you with a smile on your face.
This was an ARC book for me, and this is my honest opinion.
This was an ARC book for me, and this is my honest opinion.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This is a cute and mildly spicy sports romance about what happens when people are willing to give up their preconceived ideas about what love is and try something new.
Lacey Kerr is the classic high school It Girl; she’s cheer captain, gets great grades, and has strong relationships with her peers. But, she’s pretty busy and just doesn’t see dating as something worth her time.
Vaughn Collins is the brooding captain and star player of the school soccer team. With the state championship approaching, he doesn’t have time to be distracted by girls. That all changes when he manages to convince Lacey to tutor him to get him back into good academic standing and back onto the field. Can both of them accept that sometimes, having a partner can be an asset rather than a liability, or will they return to their old ways?
When I first started reading this book, I found it to be slightly predictable. Lacey mostly fits into the mold of a high-achieving teenage female protagonist. Although her character is slightly more nuanced due to the caretaking role she plays for her overworked single father and the absence of her mother, the majority of her sections involve glitter and her extremely supportive group of friends.
I also found some of the details at the outset to be too much; there were two scenes involving pencils and pencil lead that nearly put me over the edge. As a middle school educator, I can say definitively that my students a) do not use mechanical pencils and b) can’t keep track of any writing utensil, leaving the floor littered with pencils by the time the bell rings each day.
However, I was able to get past these beginning details that screamed “I am establishing the setting as a high school with typical teenagers!” as the story progressed. The dialogue struck me as realistic, with some swearing, but nothing gratuitous. The parties at Boone’s house also seemed in line with something that could happen after any major high school sports game, and so, the book began to settle into something that I could enjoy, rather than cringe at.
Vaughn was the character who won me over. I delighted in his bumbling attempts at romance (e.g. the protein bar) that were so earnest, but also so off-base. I respected his inner conflict of choosing soccer vs. Lacey as well as how it played out at the end of the book without being too predictable. His relationship with his celebrity father, who is also his coach, was another point of interest in the story as they navigated their changing dynamics when Lacey entered the picture. My only complaint was that I thought it was a little much that Vaughn drove a Range Rover. Even though his dad is rich, elsewhere in the book, it is noted that they purposefully live on the quieter side of town so as not to be flashy, so it seems strange that he would drive such a nice car. But that’s a small detail in comparison to the overall development of his character.
The place where my opinion as an adult likely would diverge from that of a teenager is the bucket list. I didn’t mind that Lacey had the bucket list or that she was working toward completing it (I thought this added good structure to the story), but the updated list at the end of many chapters seemed gimmicky to me. I bet teens would love this detail, though. I know that if I had read this in high school, I probably would have crafted my own bucket list after reading this book!
There is some teen drinking, swearing, and some sexual content in this book (it stops just short of actual sex, though). My copy says it is recommended for ages 16+. I can think of a number of 8th graders who would adore the story (and Vaughn!), so I wouldn’t let those mature elements stop me from recommending it to them as an independent reading book.
This book is for anyone who wants a light and easy high school romance that also has the excitement of a sports team entering the championship part of their season, plus characters grappling with family dynamics and how to maintain their sense of self when entering a new relationship.
Thank you to SOURCEBOOKS/Bloom Books for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
Lacey Kerr is the classic high school It Girl; she’s cheer captain, gets great grades, and has strong relationships with her peers. But, she’s pretty busy and just doesn’t see dating as something worth her time.
Vaughn Collins is the brooding captain and star player of the school soccer team. With the state championship approaching, he doesn’t have time to be distracted by girls. That all changes when he manages to convince Lacey to tutor him to get him back into good academic standing and back onto the field. Can both of them accept that sometimes, having a partner can be an asset rather than a liability, or will they return to their old ways?
When I first started reading this book, I found it to be slightly predictable. Lacey mostly fits into the mold of a high-achieving teenage female protagonist. Although her character is slightly more nuanced due to the caretaking role she plays for her overworked single father and the absence of her mother, the majority of her sections involve glitter and her extremely supportive group of friends.
I also found some of the details at the outset to be too much; there were two scenes involving pencils and pencil lead that nearly put me over the edge. As a middle school educator, I can say definitively that my students a) do not use mechanical pencils and b) can’t keep track of any writing utensil, leaving the floor littered with pencils by the time the bell rings each day.
However, I was able to get past these beginning details that screamed “I am establishing the setting as a high school with typical teenagers!” as the story progressed. The dialogue struck me as realistic, with some swearing, but nothing gratuitous. The parties at Boone’s house also seemed in line with something that could happen after any major high school sports game, and so, the book began to settle into something that I could enjoy, rather than cringe at.
Vaughn was the character who won me over. I delighted in his bumbling attempts at romance (e.g. the protein bar) that were so earnest, but also so off-base. I respected his inner conflict of choosing soccer vs. Lacey as well as how it played out at the end of the book without being too predictable. His relationship with his celebrity father, who is also his coach, was another point of interest in the story as they navigated their changing dynamics when Lacey entered the picture. My only complaint was that I thought it was a little much that Vaughn drove a Range Rover. Even though his dad is rich, elsewhere in the book, it is noted that they purposefully live on the quieter side of town so as not to be flashy, so it seems strange that he would drive such a nice car. But that’s a small detail in comparison to the overall development of his character.
The place where my opinion as an adult likely would diverge from that of a teenager is the bucket list. I didn’t mind that Lacey had the bucket list or that she was working toward completing it (I thought this added good structure to the story), but the updated list at the end of many chapters seemed gimmicky to me. I bet teens would love this detail, though. I know that if I had read this in high school, I probably would have crafted my own bucket list after reading this book!
There is some teen drinking, swearing, and some sexual content in this book (it stops just short of actual sex, though). My copy says it is recommended for ages 16+. I can think of a number of 8th graders who would adore the story (and Vaughn!), so I wouldn’t let those mature elements stop me from recommending it to them as an independent reading book.
This book is for anyone who wants a light and easy high school romance that also has the excitement of a sports team entering the championship part of their season, plus characters grappling with family dynamics and how to maintain their sense of self when entering a new relationship.
Thank you to SOURCEBOOKS/Bloom Books for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I may have just found my first feel good romance to begin 2026.❤️ Yes, I realize I'm reviewing this in 2025, but Playing with Forever doesn't officially release until January 2026 so my reasoning stands.
I couldn't set this book down from the moment I picked it up. It's a wonderful view into the demands of being a top high school athlete; with everything that entails - like keeping up your grades, the extra-curriculars, the demanding workouts, and if there is time left - friends or even love. For Vaughn Collins and the way he was raised he would answer no. Outside of school, soccer is his only focus. For Lacey Kerr she finds a way to balance everything and everyone in her busy schedule so she would say yes. Lacey and Vaughn would seem like total opposites when you stand them side by side and for the most part that is true. Lacey is outgoing, bubbly, and smiles at everyone she sees, while Vaughn is stoic, introverted, and hardly says two words to those around him. However, outside appearances may be more deceiving than they appear and these two may actually have more in common they ever would have thought. Sooo, of course this book is also about the first feelings of falling in love, the crazy intensity of thinking about each other all👏 the👏 time👏, and the intense chemistry that comes along with first kisses and long make-out sessions.😍
I was completely captivated by these two and I was honestly shocked by how drawn-in I was by this story. In a way, this was Vaughn's redemption story, not that he was a villain per se, but in the first book, he is Claire's ex-boyfriend and Claire is Lacey's best friend. I don't want to say more to give away too much in either book, but even Vaughn admits he's not the greatest boyfriend because he's so singularly focused on soccer. For what it's worth, it was really nice to get his point of view and understand that he's not a bad guy, but instead just a normal teen with his own problems. Even Claire stands up for him, now that she's happy in her own relationship, saying pretty much the same thing. Lacey checks in with her a few times and it's so sweet to see these two best friends supporting one another and not have any bitterness attached to a relationship that is no longer relevant. Is it realistic at this age, probably not, but Jenshak writes it extremely well and I loved reading how close these two girls are nonetheless.
Lacey is the girl in school that makes you wonder if she ever sleeps. Head cheerleader, perfect grades, on the student council, helps everyone and always has a smile on her face...except for Vaughn. She's still a bit salty at him for dumping her best friend, but because it's Lacey, it also doesn't last long. She truly can't dislike anyone and for that I was grateful. Once she lets Vaughn in, you find out he's actually a likable guy, he just needed a chance to have his story told. It's the small things that speak volumes with him and where Lacy is boisterous with her love and friendship, his quiet emotions shouted from the rooftops. I think it's why I was so enthralled with these two, their yin and yang, but also where they met in the middle, it's what love truly is.
The friendship circle within this book is amazing. The secondary characters always enhance the story, without distracting from the plot and I love that about her writing. 🥰 It's an aspect that Jenshak does extremely well, no matter what she writes. Lacey's personality is larger than life, so it's basically a character all on its own, but the soccer team is full of fun players. I can see more books coming from this world as they each get a book.👌😍
Thank you to Netgalley, Sourcebooks, and Bloom Books for the advance review copy and all opinions are my own.
I couldn't set this book down from the moment I picked it up. It's a wonderful view into the demands of being a top high school athlete; with everything that entails - like keeping up your grades, the extra-curriculars, the demanding workouts, and if there is time left - friends or even love. For Vaughn Collins and the way he was raised he would answer no. Outside of school, soccer is his only focus. For Lacey Kerr she finds a way to balance everything and everyone in her busy schedule so she would say yes. Lacey and Vaughn would seem like total opposites when you stand them side by side and for the most part that is true. Lacey is outgoing, bubbly, and smiles at everyone she sees, while Vaughn is stoic, introverted, and hardly says two words to those around him. However, outside appearances may be more deceiving than they appear and these two may actually have more in common they ever would have thought. Sooo, of course this book is also about the first feelings of falling in love, the crazy intensity of thinking about each other all👏 the👏 time👏, and the intense chemistry that comes along with first kisses and long make-out sessions.😍
I was completely captivated by these two and I was honestly shocked by how drawn-in I was by this story. In a way, this was Vaughn's redemption story, not that he was a villain per se, but in the first book, he is Claire's ex-boyfriend and Claire is Lacey's best friend. I don't want to say more to give away too much in either book, but even Vaughn admits he's not the greatest boyfriend because he's so singularly focused on soccer. For what it's worth, it was really nice to get his point of view and understand that he's not a bad guy, but instead just a normal teen with his own problems. Even Claire stands up for him, now that she's happy in her own relationship, saying pretty much the same thing. Lacey checks in with her a few times and it's so sweet to see these two best friends supporting one another and not have any bitterness attached to a relationship that is no longer relevant. Is it realistic at this age, probably not, but Jenshak writes it extremely well and I loved reading how close these two girls are nonetheless.
Lacey is the girl in school that makes you wonder if she ever sleeps. Head cheerleader, perfect grades, on the student council, helps everyone and always has a smile on her face...except for Vaughn. She's still a bit salty at him for dumping her best friend, but because it's Lacey, it also doesn't last long. She truly can't dislike anyone and for that I was grateful. Once she lets Vaughn in, you find out he's actually a likable guy, he just needed a chance to have his story told. It's the small things that speak volumes with him and where Lacy is boisterous with her love and friendship, his quiet emotions shouted from the rooftops. I think it's why I was so enthralled with these two, their yin and yang, but also where they met in the middle, it's what love truly is.
The friendship circle within this book is amazing. The secondary characters always enhance the story, without distracting from the plot and I love that about her writing. 🥰 It's an aspect that Jenshak does extremely well, no matter what she writes. Lacey's personality is larger than life, so it's basically a character all on its own, but the soccer team is full of fun players. I can see more books coming from this world as they each get a book.👌😍
Thank you to Netgalley, Sourcebooks, and Bloom Books for the advance review copy and all opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Playing with Forever is a charming and engaging YA romance that I couldn’t put down from the first page. All of that Rebecca Jenshak magic, just the YA version. The heartfelt romance, the found family of delightful characters, the complex big feelings of first love and growing up, and the nostalgia of high school life and sports and everything in between, from maintaining grades and extracurriculars to rigorous training schedules. It's loads of fun and super cute.
Vaughn Collins, captain of the soccer team, is completely focused on soccer, while Lacey Kerr seems to effortlessly balance school, activities, friends, and family. At first glance, they could not be more different. Lacey is outgoing, bubbly, and warm, whereas Vaughn is stoic, introverted, and reserved. Yet beneath the surface, they have more in common than either realizes, and the chemistry between them is electric.
This book also explores first love in all its intensity. The nervous excitement, the constant thoughts of each other, and the passionate, tender moments that make young romance so compelling. I was completely invested in both Lacey and Vaughn. This story also serves as a kind of redemption arc for Vaughn, allowing readers to see his perspective and understand his choices, which adds nuance to his character. Lacey and her best friend Claire’s friendship is equally well-written, with no lingering bitterness despite the romantic history, which I appreciated. To be honest, I wasn't sure how I'd feel about Lacey dating her bestie's ex that we were made not to like....but their friendship weathers this well.
I love Lacey. She's smart, capable, and endlessly kind. Vaughn complements her perfectly, with quiet emotions that contrast her expressive nature. Together, they strike a beautiful balance, and their relationship is as much about friendship, understanding, and growth as it is about romance. The side characters, including friends and teammates, enhance the story without detracting from the main plot, and the high school sports environment adds energy and excitement. You know the sports are gonna be good in a Jenshak book.
Some aspects might feel a bit tropey or predictable, such as the cheerleader and soccer captain and other archetypal dynamics. But, there are authentic characters at the core of the tropes. Vaughn’s growth throughout the book is the best part, and he certainly has a much louder and compelling arc. Seeing him open up emotionally and reassess his priorities beyond soccer is compelling, and him evolving into a different kind of partner and friend is really satisfying, especially after book 1.
The sports elements are fun, though I will say I expected a bit more in a Jenshak book. The bucket list concept is charming and super cute though, and while some details may feel gimmicky to adult readers, teens will likely adore it. And this adult did too. This is mostly YA in content (some drinking and swearing, fade to black spicy type insinuations, nothing explicity), overall a sweet, lighthearted tone.
Overall, Playing with Forever is an adorable, heartfelt, and relatable YA romance. It balances high school drama, sports, friendships, and first love with deft charisma. Lacey and Vaughn’s chemistry is compelling, and the story’s blend of tenderness, humor, and emotional growth makes it a highly enjoyable read. Fans of Rebecca Jenshak’s work will not be disappointed, and this book is an excellent addition to the Frost Lake High series.
Vaughn Collins, captain of the soccer team, is completely focused on soccer, while Lacey Kerr seems to effortlessly balance school, activities, friends, and family. At first glance, they could not be more different. Lacey is outgoing, bubbly, and warm, whereas Vaughn is stoic, introverted, and reserved. Yet beneath the surface, they have more in common than either realizes, and the chemistry between them is electric.
This book also explores first love in all its intensity. The nervous excitement, the constant thoughts of each other, and the passionate, tender moments that make young romance so compelling. I was completely invested in both Lacey and Vaughn. This story also serves as a kind of redemption arc for Vaughn, allowing readers to see his perspective and understand his choices, which adds nuance to his character. Lacey and her best friend Claire’s friendship is equally well-written, with no lingering bitterness despite the romantic history, which I appreciated. To be honest, I wasn't sure how I'd feel about Lacey dating her bestie's ex that we were made not to like....but their friendship weathers this well.
I love Lacey. She's smart, capable, and endlessly kind. Vaughn complements her perfectly, with quiet emotions that contrast her expressive nature. Together, they strike a beautiful balance, and their relationship is as much about friendship, understanding, and growth as it is about romance. The side characters, including friends and teammates, enhance the story without detracting from the main plot, and the high school sports environment adds energy and excitement. You know the sports are gonna be good in a Jenshak book.
Some aspects might feel a bit tropey or predictable, such as the cheerleader and soccer captain and other archetypal dynamics. But, there are authentic characters at the core of the tropes. Vaughn’s growth throughout the book is the best part, and he certainly has a much louder and compelling arc. Seeing him open up emotionally and reassess his priorities beyond soccer is compelling, and him evolving into a different kind of partner and friend is really satisfying, especially after book 1.
The sports elements are fun, though I will say I expected a bit more in a Jenshak book. The bucket list concept is charming and super cute though, and while some details may feel gimmicky to adult readers, teens will likely adore it. And this adult did too. This is mostly YA in content (some drinking and swearing, fade to black spicy type insinuations, nothing explicity), overall a sweet, lighthearted tone.
Overall, Playing with Forever is an adorable, heartfelt, and relatable YA romance. It balances high school drama, sports, friendships, and first love with deft charisma. Lacey and Vaughn’s chemistry is compelling, and the story’s blend of tenderness, humor, and emotional growth makes it a highly enjoyable read. Fans of Rebecca Jenshak’s work will not be disappointed, and this book is an excellent addition to the Frost Lake High series.
January 20, 2026
I breezed through this second installment of the Frost Lake High series, and this time, the focus was on Lacey, the head cheerleader and A+ student as she gets sucked into tutoring Vaughn, the Captain of the soccer team, so that he can remain eligible to play with the State Championships on the horizon. Did I mention he's her best-friend's ex?!? This is a classic grumpy sunshine trope, as Lacey is everyone's cheerleader and adores fun while Vaughn seems to enjoy little more than soccer. When Lacey discovers her deceased mother's high school wish list, she decides to finish it for her and add her own tasks as a way to help her feel closer to her. As her and Vaughn grow closer and spend more tome together, he helps her complete her list, but is his focus on her taking him off his game plan?
I think what I love about this series is getting both MC's perspectives, so that l can see l their insecurities and personalities. Lacey misses her Dad who works all the time and puts a lot of pressure on herself to be involved while keeping her perfect grades. Vaughn feels the pressures of his father/coach's expectations and the distance between he and his mom who literally lives across the pond and their seemingly non-existent relationship since his parents divorce. I also love that their high school experience mimicked mine--after hangs at someone's cabin, four wheeler rides, fire pits, and Homecoming dances. Maybe it makes me nostalgic, but there's just something about small-town experiences and of course, a solid sports team to root for!
Of course there's the dreaded 3rd Act breakup, but Vaughn needed that space to realize that he could be on top of his game and still lose AND still be a good boyfriend. I loved how his team helped him see this through their supportive sharing circle where they all passed the ball and shared their insecurities and failures to help him see that they all have weaknesses and owning it just makes them human (more of this in YA sports romance!). I also enjoyed seeing how his Dad opening up to him about his mom was a part of this breakthrough as well. I wish we would have gotten a bit more about his progress with his mom besides the phone calls in the Epilogue though (he's in Europe, closer to his mom...why hasn't she visited?!?). I also l thought Claire's acceptance of Lacey and Graham dating was lacking any sort of weirdness at all, and although her and Austin are still solid in this book, I just didn't buy that it would go that smoothly for high school juniors. But maybe Claire is just a better person than me!
As always, I adore Rowan, and I am really hoping that the next book will be about him and someone who can step in and make him feel special since his absent parents can't seem to.
Thanks to Netgalley & Bloom Books for the e-ARC!
I think what I love about this series is getting both MC's perspectives, so that l can see l their insecurities and personalities. Lacey misses her Dad who works all the time and puts a lot of pressure on herself to be involved while keeping her perfect grades. Vaughn feels the pressures of his father/coach's expectations and the distance between he and his mom who literally lives across the pond and their seemingly non-existent relationship since his parents divorce. I also love that their high school experience mimicked mine--after hangs at someone's cabin, four wheeler rides, fire pits, and Homecoming dances. Maybe it makes me nostalgic, but there's just something about small-town experiences and of course, a solid sports team to root for!
Of course there's the dreaded 3rd Act breakup, but Vaughn needed that space to realize that he could be on top of his game and still lose AND still be a good boyfriend. I loved how his team helped him see this through their supportive sharing circle where they all passed the ball and shared their insecurities and failures to help him see that they all have weaknesses and owning it just makes them human (more of this in YA sports romance!). I also enjoyed seeing how his Dad opening up to him about his mom was a part of this breakthrough as well. I wish we would have gotten a bit more about his progress with his mom besides the phone calls in the Epilogue though (he's in Europe, closer to his mom...why hasn't she visited?!?). I also l thought Claire's acceptance of Lacey and Graham dating was lacking any sort of weirdness at all, and although her and Austin are still solid in this book, I just didn't buy that it would go that smoothly for high school juniors. But maybe Claire is just a better person than me!
As always, I adore Rowan, and I am really hoping that the next book will be about him and someone who can step in and make him feel special since his absent parents can't seem to.
Thanks to Netgalley & Bloom Books for the e-ARC!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Playing with Forever is my first read of 2026 and I wouldn't have wanted it any other way! A grumpy(broody) soccer star and a sunshine, glitter loving cheerleader experience young love while dealing with the pressures of high school. Vaughn is struggling with Algebra II and needs Lacey's help, but he is the guy who broke her best friends heart. They decide to leave the past in the past and get to know each other in the present, finding out that they have more in common that expected. I couldn't put down this read because of the swoon-worthy moments, high-school/young love nostalgia, and ultimately the heartfelt story about not being afraid to step out of your comfort zone.
Vaughn is a top soccer star for Frost Lake High and his dad just so happens to be the coach/retired pro-soccer player. He lives and breathes the sport, and that why is what easy to miss studying for Algebra II. He seeks help from Lacey who is just about the smartest girl in school, but he doubts she will help. After all, she never really liked him especially after be broke up with her best friend. While her best friend Claire, already forgave him, it is hard for Lacey to see the good in him, and chooses to see him arrogant, broody, and mysterious. But when Vaughn is benched for not keeping his grades up, she surprises everyone when she agrees to tutor him.
Lacey is a bubbly young woman who is full of team spirit. She is the captain of the cheerleading team, loves school, and is loyal. But Vaughn is about to test everything including her patience. She lays down the rules and if he accepts, she will tutor him and get him ready for his re-take exam. What she didn't expect was to get to know him on a personal level. Both rarely dated because they focused too much on their respective passions, soccer & getting good grades.
There was so much beauty in watching them fall for each other. Being vulnerable was hard for them, but together it came easily. I loved that a bucket list was incorporated in the story. It was not only a buffer for Lacey and Vaughn but it made every check off the list even more special. What started off a way to remember her late mother, turned into beautiful moments of stepping out of their comfort zones and cherishing life.
Playing with Forever is a 5 star romance that will find a permanent spot on your bookshelf. It is book 2 in the Frost Lake High series, but can be read as a standalone. Highly recommend to readers who enjoy the following tropes: young love, grumpy/sunshine, broody, mysterious MMC, sports romance.
Vaughn is a top soccer star for Frost Lake High and his dad just so happens to be the coach/retired pro-soccer player. He lives and breathes the sport, and that why is what easy to miss studying for Algebra II. He seeks help from Lacey who is just about the smartest girl in school, but he doubts she will help. After all, she never really liked him especially after be broke up with her best friend. While her best friend Claire, already forgave him, it is hard for Lacey to see the good in him, and chooses to see him arrogant, broody, and mysterious. But when Vaughn is benched for not keeping his grades up, she surprises everyone when she agrees to tutor him.
Lacey is a bubbly young woman who is full of team spirit. She is the captain of the cheerleading team, loves school, and is loyal. But Vaughn is about to test everything including her patience. She lays down the rules and if he accepts, she will tutor him and get him ready for his re-take exam. What she didn't expect was to get to know him on a personal level. Both rarely dated because they focused too much on their respective passions, soccer & getting good grades.
There was so much beauty in watching them fall for each other. Being vulnerable was hard for them, but together it came easily. I loved that a bucket list was incorporated in the story. It was not only a buffer for Lacey and Vaughn but it made every check off the list even more special. What started off a way to remember her late mother, turned into beautiful moments of stepping out of their comfort zones and cherishing life.
Playing with Forever is a 5 star romance that will find a permanent spot on your bookshelf. It is book 2 in the Frost Lake High series, but can be read as a standalone. Highly recommend to readers who enjoy the following tropes: young love, grumpy/sunshine, broody, mysterious MMC, sports romance.
January 23, 2026
Thank you so much to Sourcebooks & Bloom Books for the complimentary ebook & book!
This book is out now!
Last year I was introduced to Rebecca Jenshak's work and was immediately taken by it. And so I was excited to see that she also wrote young adult. And my goodness this was SO good!!! I often worry when I read YA which way it will go - more on the juvenile side or more realistic. And this one is on the more realistic side.
My heart. I absolutely love both Vaughn and Lacey. I don't know why I love reading about high school relationships. Maybe because they are just so darn sweet and make me wish that I had that kind of high school experience? Both of them felt very mature for their age. Lacey having to rely on herself a lot of time. This girl had such a good head on her shoulder; being able to balance being a teen, volunteering,head cheerleader and just being active in school. I loved her friendship with Claire and how they were so honest with one another!
"I like you. I like you a lot, and I don't want to be the guy who sucks at relationships anymore."
Vaughn beat up on himself so much and I love how supportive Lacey was to him. There was a moment that he was really down on himself and she just plopped herself down and didn't want to let him push her away. I also love how he was self aware to know that he was doing something wrong in their relationship but with that his immediate reaction was to run and blame himself. He was just so head over heels for Lacey. I love their flirty banter and for a YA things got a little spicy. Now I'm not talking like her adult books but a little bit more teasing than the average YA book (at least the ones I read).
The real villain of this book was Vaughn's dad Jude Collins. I understand he was a pro athlete and he knows what it takes to make it as a top soccer player. But dude retired to a high school soccer coach and just needs to take it down a notch. He put so much pressure on his son and wouldn't just let him be a teenager. I was happy that Vaughn stood up to him and asked to go to the homecoming again.
This is book 2 in the series and I had not read the first one but did not feel like I was missing so much in the first. I was able to figure out Austin and Claire's story from what the author provided. I am hoping that Rowan gets his own book. He was such a fun side character and I want to see him fall in love.
This book just made me so happy as I was reading. I highly recommend if you are looking for a young adult romance, acquaintances to couple, tutor x athlete romance!
This book is out now!
Last year I was introduced to Rebecca Jenshak's work and was immediately taken by it. And so I was excited to see that she also wrote young adult. And my goodness this was SO good!!! I often worry when I read YA which way it will go - more on the juvenile side or more realistic. And this one is on the more realistic side.
My heart. I absolutely love both Vaughn and Lacey. I don't know why I love reading about high school relationships. Maybe because they are just so darn sweet and make me wish that I had that kind of high school experience? Both of them felt very mature for their age. Lacey having to rely on herself a lot of time. This girl had such a good head on her shoulder; being able to balance being a teen, volunteering,head cheerleader and just being active in school. I loved her friendship with Claire and how they were so honest with one another!
"I like you. I like you a lot, and I don't want to be the guy who sucks at relationships anymore."
Vaughn beat up on himself so much and I love how supportive Lacey was to him. There was a moment that he was really down on himself and she just plopped herself down and didn't want to let him push her away. I also love how he was self aware to know that he was doing something wrong in their relationship but with that his immediate reaction was to run and blame himself. He was just so head over heels for Lacey. I love their flirty banter and for a YA things got a little spicy. Now I'm not talking like her adult books but a little bit more teasing than the average YA book (at least the ones I read).
The real villain of this book was Vaughn's dad Jude Collins. I understand he was a pro athlete and he knows what it takes to make it as a top soccer player. But dude retired to a high school soccer coach and just needs to take it down a notch. He put so much pressure on his son and wouldn't just let him be a teenager. I was happy that Vaughn stood up to him and asked to go to the homecoming again.
This is book 2 in the series and I had not read the first one but did not feel like I was missing so much in the first. I was able to figure out Austin and Claire's story from what the author provided. I am hoping that Rowan gets his own book. He was such a fun side character and I want to see him fall in love.
This book just made me so happy as I was reading. I highly recommend if you are looking for a young adult romance, acquaintances to couple, tutor x athlete romance!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 134 reviews