Many novelists also write short stories and it’s not at all unusual that they would publish them as collections. Very few seem to publish as many collections as Christopher Fowler, for whom “Old Devil Moon” was his ninth short story collection in around twenty years of being a published author; by comparison, Stephen King has only released eight short story collections in over forty years of publishing. The one thing these authors do have in common is that I am a huge fan of both and will read however many collections they put out.
Fowler specialises in urban horror, setting his scariest stories in places that will be familiar to many, such as in “Invulnerable”, which is a story of abuse that is effectively news more often than fiction these days, but told with a gentle touch that doesn’t sensationalise it. “The Threads” is also a story of a couple on holiday in a North African city who think themselves superior to the locals in education and breeding, but find out the hard way that isn’t the case. “The Twilight Express” is ostensibly about a funfair, but more about being emotionally trapped, which can be a horror to some and “Starless” tells a story of an aftermath of a serious public transport incident, similar to 7/7, but puts a very interesting angle on it which, like “Invulnerable”, deals with a potentially sensitive subject in a non-sensationalist way.
Fowler also keeps an eye on traditional horror and fantasy subjects. “Forcibly Bewitched” has old style enchantments and magic spells, but has a typical Fowler twist and “Turbo Satan” is an interesting combination of technology and magic, with an entirely unexpected ending. “Let’s Have Some Fun” has a wonderfully up to date feel with another nice twist and “The Spider Kiss” starts off as an almost straight police buddy story, before becoming far more unpleasant and fantastical. Interestingly, “The Uninvited” works in almost a reverse fashion, seemingly edging towards familiar horror territory, but then provided a surprisingly non-supernatural ending.
Fowler’s love of history, both real and imagined comes through as well. “Old Friends” mixes classic cinema with modern life, whilst “The Lady Downstairs” and “Heredity” look to the past, with the former being a Sherlock Holmes story and the latter would have worked as a “Downton Abbey” sub-plot until the slightly sensational ending. “Red Torch” evokes the days of cinema long past and has the feel of something autobiographical in tone, such is the personal nature of the story.
Finally, there are the touches of Fowler’s humorous side here as well. “That’s Undertainment” mocks modern cinema and “The Night Museum” is a very funny tour of a highly unusual museum. But Fowler can also do serious and emotional and “All Packed” is perhaps the best story here, as it deals with a common subject in such beautiful writing and is perhaps the most honest and heartfelt piece of writing here.
I didn’t feel as if this was Fowler’s best story collection, as there wasn’t a huge amount of consistency to it. There is a huge variation in themes and emotions evoked here, as well as multiple changes of pace. As with every Fowler collection, there are scares and laughs and you learn as well as being entertained in some parts. But there is so much here that it doesn’t feel as if it has settled down at any point and the stories sometimes feel as if the original contents list was dropped on the floor and the book put together in the order they were picked up in, as if there wasn’t quite enough time to try and remember which order they had been in originally.
Fowler’s collections are always worth reading, but the incoherency of this collection means that starting with this one isn’t recommended.