What do you think?
Rate this book
Return to the Canadian West #2
Where Trust Lies
She loves her friends and students in the West, but family obligations have called her home. Where does she truly belong?After a year of teaching in the Canadian West, Beth Thatcher returns home to her family. She barely has time to settle in before her mother announces plans for a family holiday--a luxurious steamship tour along the eastern coast of Canada and the United States. Hoping to reconnect with her mother and her sisters, Beth agrees to join them, but she quickly realizes that things have changed since she went away, and renewing their close bond is going to be more challenging than she expected. There's one special thing to look forward to--letters and telephone calls from Jarrick, the Mountie who has stolen her heart. The distance between them is almost too much to bear. But can she give her heart to Jarrick when it will mean saying good-bye to her family once again--and possibly forever? And will she still want to live in the western wilds after the steamship tour opens up a world of people and places she never imagined?Then comes a great test of Beth's faith. Someone in her family has trusted the wrong person, and suddenly everything Beth knows and loves is toppled. Torn between her family and her dreams, will Beth finally discover where her heart truly belongs?A companion story to Hallmark Channel's When Calls the Heart TV series!
466 pages, Kindle Edition
First published January 27, 2015
328 people are currently reading
2309 people want to read
About the author
Janette Oke
347 books3,442 followersJanette Oke is a Canadian author known for her inspirational fiction, often set in a pioneer era and focused on female protagonists. Her debut novel, Love Comes Softly (1979), became the foundation for a successful series, followed by over 75 other novels. The first book in her Canadian West series, When Calls the Heart (1983), inspired the popular television series of the same name.
Born in Champion, Alberta, to farmers Fred and Amy (née Ruggles) Steeves during the Great Depression, Oke went on to graduate from Mountain View Bible College in Didsbury, Alberta, where she met her future husband, Edward Oke, who later became the president of the college. The couple has four children, including a daughter who has collaborated with Janette on several books.
A committed Evangelical Christian, Oke has authored numerous works exploring themes of faith. She has received various accolades for her contributions to Christian fiction, including the 1992 President's Award from the Evangelical Christian Publishers Association and the 1999 CBA Life Impact Award.
Born in Champion, Alberta, to farmers Fred and Amy (née Ruggles) Steeves during the Great Depression, Oke went on to graduate from Mountain View Bible College in Didsbury, Alberta, where she met her future husband, Edward Oke, who later became the president of the college. The couple has four children, including a daughter who has collaborated with Janette on several books.
A committed Evangelical Christian, Oke has authored numerous works exploring themes of faith. She has received various accolades for her contributions to Christian fiction, including the 1992 President's Award from the Evangelical Christian Publishers Association and the 1999 CBA Life Impact Award.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 239 reviews
April 21, 2015
I absolutely loved the first book so I had high expectations for the next one. Sadly, it didn’t quite meet the bar, but it was still enjoyable.
I believe the main reason I didn’t like this book quite as much is because the main conflict didn’t happen till the last one hundred pages. Because of that, the book felt slow and there wasn’t much happening.
I did like the amount of character development we see in Beth–and her sister, Julie–in this novel. Both girls were very naïve and way too trusting, but by the end they saw people for what we actually are–not proned to be good. We still have this ol’ flesh!
This whole book was a lesson of trust. Trust in God, family, friends, and strangers. I thought that the message was given in an excellent way; this novel wasn’t “preachy” but it also didn’t take what it was trying to say lightly.
I thought that the romance progression between Beth and Jarrick was sweet but not unrealistic. There were no sappy words that don’t mean anything, and quite frankly, no one would say! You can definitely see the Lord bringing Beth and Jarrick closer together. (Something that I really love to read about!)
I’m going to give Where Trust Lies 4/5 stars. If you love entertaining books that are clean and wholesome, with a spiritual lesson thrown in, definitely check out this series!
*Bethany House Publishers kindly sent me this book in exchange for my honest review. All opinions are my own. I was in no way compensated for this review.
I believe the main reason I didn’t like this book quite as much is because the main conflict didn’t happen till the last one hundred pages. Because of that, the book felt slow and there wasn’t much happening.
I did like the amount of character development we see in Beth–and her sister, Julie–in this novel. Both girls were very naïve and way too trusting, but by the end they saw people for what we actually are–not proned to be good. We still have this ol’ flesh!
This whole book was a lesson of trust. Trust in God, family, friends, and strangers. I thought that the message was given in an excellent way; this novel wasn’t “preachy” but it also didn’t take what it was trying to say lightly.
I thought that the romance progression between Beth and Jarrick was sweet but not unrealistic. There were no sappy words that don’t mean anything, and quite frankly, no one would say! You can definitely see the Lord bringing Beth and Jarrick closer together. (Something that I really love to read about!)
I’m going to give Where Trust Lies 4/5 stars. If you love entertaining books that are clean and wholesome, with a spiritual lesson thrown in, definitely check out this series!
*Bethany House Publishers kindly sent me this book in exchange for my honest review. All opinions are my own. I was in no way compensated for this review.
February 23, 2016
About this book:
“Beth Thatcher returns home from her first year as a schoolteacher in the mining town of Coal Valley and steps into a whole different world. Her life back among her wealthy Eastern family is a stark contrast to her primitive life in the West, and Beth isn't sure where she belongs anymore.
She barely has time to settle in before her mother announces plans for a family holiday--a luxurious steamship tour along the eastern coast of Canada and the U.S. Wishing to reconnect with her mother and sister, Beth agrees to go but quickly finds herself at odds with her mother's expectations. After enjoying complete freedom in the western wilds, Beth isn't sure what to make of her mother's ongoing efforts to direct her life--and her heart.
Beth keeps in touch with her Mountie beau, Jarrick, even as young men more of her station catch her eye. Is she ready to fully give her heart to Jarrick, knowing it will mean saying good-bye to her family and her life of privilege once again? And when Beth trusts the wrong person, will Jarrick be able to help her despite the distance between them?”
Series: Book #2 in the “Return to the Canadian West” series. (Review of #1 Here!) {There is another series that follows Beth’s aunt, Elizabeth, called the “Canadian West” series. Read Reviews of #1 Here, #2 Here, #3 Here, #4 Here, #5 Here, and #6 Here. You do not have to read the first series to understand this one, but it’s a great series to read. :) }
Spiritual Content- Many, many Prayers; Talks about God & trusting Him; ‘H’s are capital when referring to God; Many, many Scriptures are quoted & read; Bible reading; Mentions of those in the Bible; Church going & Mentions of Church going; Hymns are sung & played; Nick doesn’t believe in God.
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a ‘dumb’, a ‘stupid’ and two ‘gosh’s; Mentions of drinking & the prohibition; A mention of an attempted suicide.
Sexual Content- Julie gets two hand kisses, a boarder-line barely-above-not-detailed // semi-detailed kiss; Noticing; Embraces (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of flirting & a flirt; Girls are called dolls’, ‘scrumptious’ and ‘beauties’; A mention of human slavery; Nick doesn’t know his father; A mention of a woman who had a child without being married; Talks about marriage; Love, falling in love & the emotions.
-Beth Thatcher
P.O.V. of Beth
Set in the 1920s
332 pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- Three Stars
Early High School Teens- Four Stars
Older High School Teens- Five Stars
My personal Rating- Four Stars
Oh. Jarrick. *swoon* Can I just leave it at that? Hahaha! Really though, he was so sweet! While I think the first book in the series is a bit better, I did enjoy this one as well. Now just to wait for an announcement about a third book! Hint, hint! ;)
Next Friday there wouldn’t be a new review, but a super-awesome post! ;D
Link to review:
Coming 7/31/15
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
*I received this book for free from the Publisher (Bethany House Publishers) for this review.
“Beth Thatcher returns home from her first year as a schoolteacher in the mining town of Coal Valley and steps into a whole different world. Her life back among her wealthy Eastern family is a stark contrast to her primitive life in the West, and Beth isn't sure where she belongs anymore.
She barely has time to settle in before her mother announces plans for a family holiday--a luxurious steamship tour along the eastern coast of Canada and the U.S. Wishing to reconnect with her mother and sister, Beth agrees to go but quickly finds herself at odds with her mother's expectations. After enjoying complete freedom in the western wilds, Beth isn't sure what to make of her mother's ongoing efforts to direct her life--and her heart.
Beth keeps in touch with her Mountie beau, Jarrick, even as young men more of her station catch her eye. Is she ready to fully give her heart to Jarrick, knowing it will mean saying good-bye to her family and her life of privilege once again? And when Beth trusts the wrong person, will Jarrick be able to help her despite the distance between them?”
Series: Book #2 in the “Return to the Canadian West” series. (Review of #1 Here!) {There is another series that follows Beth’s aunt, Elizabeth, called the “Canadian West” series. Read Reviews of #1 Here, #2 Here, #3 Here, #4 Here, #5 Here, and #6 Here. You do not have to read the first series to understand this one, but it’s a great series to read. :) }
Spiritual Content- Many, many Prayers; Talks about God & trusting Him; ‘H’s are capital when referring to God; Many, many Scriptures are quoted & read; Bible reading; Mentions of those in the Bible; Church going & Mentions of Church going; Hymns are sung & played; Nick doesn’t believe in God.
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a ‘dumb’, a ‘stupid’ and two ‘gosh’s; Mentions of drinking & the prohibition; A mention of an attempted suicide.
Sexual Content- Julie gets two hand kisses, a boarder-line barely-above-not-detailed // semi-detailed kiss; Noticing; Embraces (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of flirting & a flirt; Girls are called dolls’, ‘scrumptious’ and ‘beauties’; A mention of human slavery; Nick doesn’t know his father; A mention of a woman who had a child without being married; Talks about marriage; Love, falling in love & the emotions.
-Beth Thatcher
P.O.V. of Beth
Set in the 1920s
332 pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- Three Stars
Early High School Teens- Four Stars
Older High School Teens- Five Stars
My personal Rating- Four Stars
Oh. Jarrick. *swoon* Can I just leave it at that? Hahaha! Really though, he was so sweet! While I think the first book in the series is a bit better, I did enjoy this one as well. Now just to wait for an announcement about a third book! Hint, hint! ;)
Next Friday there wouldn’t be a new review, but a super-awesome post! ;D
Link to review:
Coming 7/31/15
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
*I received this book for free from the Publisher (Bethany House Publishers) for this review.
October 7, 2015
I received an eBook ARC of Where Trust Lies by Janette Oke and Laurel Oke Logan, from the publisher Bethany House, in return for an honest review.
Where Trust Lies is the second book in the Return to the Canadian West series. It begins with Elizabeth Thatcher returning home to Toronto after her teaching year in Coal Valley Alberta ends for the summer. Her departure from Coal Valley was very bitter sweet as she had to leave behind a Mountie named Jarrick who she has begun a relationship with. Upon returning home Elizabeth learns that she is about to embark on a cruise on the St. Lawrence with her Mother, two sisters, nephew and family friends, thus putting even more miles in between her and Jarrick. While on the cruise Elizabeth juggles trying to understand her overprotective mother, while trying to reign in her spirited younger sister Julie, who has befriended some questionable shipmates.
I knew that I would like this story once I learned that it not only is it historical fiction, but it is set in Canada. It is my goal this year to read more books set in Canada and by Canadian authors. Where Trust Lies takes its readers on a cross country journey beginning in Alberta to Ontario, Quebec, New Brunswick, Prince Edward Island and Nova Scotia. The cruise also brings the Thatcher and Montclair families to a few states in the US as well. I enjoyed this part of the book very much.
Where Trust Lies, at its heart is about the relationships between mothers and daughters and sisters. What makes it even more special is that this book is written by a mother and daughter writing duo: Janette Oke and Laurel Oke Logan.
Although I found Elizabeth a bit boring at times, she had a kind and loving heart. I think it would have been interesting if the story were told from her younger sister Julie's perspective as well. I knew that her new "friends" would lead her into trouble however, I didn't think the authors would take the path they did with this storyline. Near the end of the book the plot took a bit of a dark turn but the family still kept their strong faith.
I have yet to read the first book in this series, however I look forward to purchasing and reading it. I also hope to purchase a physical copy of Where Trust Lies, as I read this in ARC from on my Kobo. The Hallmark Channel has adapted the first book in the series When Calls the Heart, which I am so excited to watch.
In conclusion I would recommend this book to those who enjoy Christian/Inspirational fiction and historical fiction. This would also make a great mother-daughter book club read. I’m looking forward to reading more by Janette Oke in the near future.
For my full review on Where Trust Lies, visit my blog:
http://mlsmanyreads.blogspot.ca/2015/...
Where Trust Lies is the second book in the Return to the Canadian West series. It begins with Elizabeth Thatcher returning home to Toronto after her teaching year in Coal Valley Alberta ends for the summer. Her departure from Coal Valley was very bitter sweet as she had to leave behind a Mountie named Jarrick who she has begun a relationship with. Upon returning home Elizabeth learns that she is about to embark on a cruise on the St. Lawrence with her Mother, two sisters, nephew and family friends, thus putting even more miles in between her and Jarrick. While on the cruise Elizabeth juggles trying to understand her overprotective mother, while trying to reign in her spirited younger sister Julie, who has befriended some questionable shipmates.
I knew that I would like this story once I learned that it not only is it historical fiction, but it is set in Canada. It is my goal this year to read more books set in Canada and by Canadian authors. Where Trust Lies takes its readers on a cross country journey beginning in Alberta to Ontario, Quebec, New Brunswick, Prince Edward Island and Nova Scotia. The cruise also brings the Thatcher and Montclair families to a few states in the US as well. I enjoyed this part of the book very much.
Where Trust Lies, at its heart is about the relationships between mothers and daughters and sisters. What makes it even more special is that this book is written by a mother and daughter writing duo: Janette Oke and Laurel Oke Logan.
Although I found Elizabeth a bit boring at times, she had a kind and loving heart. I think it would have been interesting if the story were told from her younger sister Julie's perspective as well. I knew that her new "friends" would lead her into trouble however, I didn't think the authors would take the path they did with this storyline. Near the end of the book the plot took a bit of a dark turn but the family still kept their strong faith.
I have yet to read the first book in this series, however I look forward to purchasing and reading it. I also hope to purchase a physical copy of Where Trust Lies, as I read this in ARC from on my Kobo. The Hallmark Channel has adapted the first book in the series When Calls the Heart, which I am so excited to watch.
In conclusion I would recommend this book to those who enjoy Christian/Inspirational fiction and historical fiction. This would also make a great mother-daughter book club read. I’m looking forward to reading more by Janette Oke in the near future.
For my full review on Where Trust Lies, visit my blog:
http://mlsmanyreads.blogspot.ca/2015/...
January 9, 2018
I enjoyed book one more than book two, but I realize the reason: in book one, Beth was in the rugged town, Coal Valley. Here, she is back home with her family, taking a sea tour. The setting just wasn’t my favorite. It was well done, don’t get me wrong; I just liked Coal Valley better.
The story seemed very well researched, with interesting tidbits thrown in throughout. I enjoyed Beth being with her family and how she made it a point to learn through the difficulties of sibling and parent relationships. The relationships in this book all felt so very real! And because the authors aren’t afraid of using Scripture, the solutions were from God’s Word and Biblical principles. I love that about this series so very much! There is no hesitation as to whether or not this is a Christian book. It hands-down is.
The romance between Jarrick and Beth progress long-distance. I thought it was very sweet and believable, while Beth was still focusing on God and His will.
The climax of this story was somewhat predicable if you’ve watched the When Calls the Heart TV series. It is done very differently from the movie (completely different setting and situation), but because I was looking for it, it didn’t surprise me. I still enjoyed it, though, and found myself racing to finish the book so that I could see how it resolved.
I’m looking forward to reading book three and seeing where it takes Beth and Jarrick.
The story seemed very well researched, with interesting tidbits thrown in throughout. I enjoyed Beth being with her family and how she made it a point to learn through the difficulties of sibling and parent relationships. The relationships in this book all felt so very real! And because the authors aren’t afraid of using Scripture, the solutions were from God’s Word and Biblical principles. I love that about this series so very much! There is no hesitation as to whether or not this is a Christian book. It hands-down is.
The romance between Jarrick and Beth progress long-distance. I thought it was very sweet and believable, while Beth was still focusing on God and His will.
The climax of this story was somewhat predicable if you’ve watched the When Calls the Heart TV series. It is done very differently from the movie (completely different setting and situation), but because I was looking for it, it didn’t surprise me. I still enjoyed it, though, and found myself racing to finish the book so that I could see how it resolved.
I’m looking forward to reading book three and seeing where it takes Beth and Jarrick.
April 7, 2015
I review finally! haha I finished this waaay too long ago :)
Sooo...I liked the first book in this series way better! And didn't care for this one. Here's why-
-The setting. The setting appealed to me at first, the cruise ship but overall Coal Valley as a setting is much more interesting.
-Julie! Ugh!! She's so stupid! Please excuse that, but really I can't stand her!
-The plot was at the end. This is something that usually kinda bugs me about Janette Oke's books. The main exciting, interesting part is at the end. So I was bored for most of the book except for the last chapters. It bothered me more in this book then the first book.
The only point I can give this book is I do love Beth, and Jack. And also their relationship. I just felt this book lacked what I was expecting.
Sooo...I liked the first book in this series way better! And didn't care for this one. Here's why-
-The setting. The setting appealed to me at first, the cruise ship but overall Coal Valley as a setting is much more interesting.
-Julie! Ugh!! She's so stupid! Please excuse that, but really I can't stand her!
-The plot was at the end. This is something that usually kinda bugs me about Janette Oke's books. The main exciting, interesting part is at the end. So I was bored for most of the book except for the last chapters. It bothered me more in this book then the first book.
The only point I can give this book is I do love Beth, and Jack. And also their relationship. I just felt this book lacked what I was expecting.
March 13, 2015
{About the Book}
Where Trust Lies by Janette Oke & Laurel Oke Logan
Bethany House Publishers
February 3, 2015
Historical Fiction, Western, Romance
Gentle Inspirational Fiction from the Genre's Pioneer
Beth Thatcher returns home from her first year as a schoolteacher in the mining town of Coal Valley and steps into a whole different world. Her life back among her wealthy Eastern family is a stark contrast to her primitive life in the West, and Beth isn't sure where she belongs anymore.
She barely has time to settle in before her mother announces plans for a family holiday--a luxurious steamship tour along the eastern coast of Canada and the U.S. Wishing to reconnect with her mother and sister, Beth agrees to go but quickly finds herself at odds with her mother's expectations. After enjoying complete freedom in the western wilds, Beth isn't sure what to make of her mother's ongoing efforts to direct her life--and her heart.
Beth keeps in touch with her Mountie beau, Jarrick, even as young men more of her station catch her eye. Is she ready to fully give her heart to Jarrick, knowing it will mean saying good-bye to her family and her life of privilege once again? And when Beth trusts the wrong person, will Jarrick be able to help her despite the distance between them?
{My Review}
Rating: 5 stars!
Janette Oke has done it again!! Where Trust Lies is book #2 in the Return to the Canadian West series. Which is a companion series to Janette's original, Canadian West series. I read the original series many years ago, as well as Janette's Love Comes Softly books and films. I have been a fan of Janette's for the longest time, since I was a little girl. And when I heard she writing a companion series to the Canadian West series/When Call the Heart TV series, I was so ecstatic. Janette's books have beautiful prose, they are poignant, and they are just an absolute delight to read. I always look forward to another Janette Oke book. I highly recommend it.
Where Trust Lies by Janette Oke & Laurel Oke Logan
Bethany House Publishers
February 3, 2015
Historical Fiction, Western, Romance
Gentle Inspirational Fiction from the Genre's Pioneer
Beth Thatcher returns home from her first year as a schoolteacher in the mining town of Coal Valley and steps into a whole different world. Her life back among her wealthy Eastern family is a stark contrast to her primitive life in the West, and Beth isn't sure where she belongs anymore.
She barely has time to settle in before her mother announces plans for a family holiday--a luxurious steamship tour along the eastern coast of Canada and the U.S. Wishing to reconnect with her mother and sister, Beth agrees to go but quickly finds herself at odds with her mother's expectations. After enjoying complete freedom in the western wilds, Beth isn't sure what to make of her mother's ongoing efforts to direct her life--and her heart.
Beth keeps in touch with her Mountie beau, Jarrick, even as young men more of her station catch her eye. Is she ready to fully give her heart to Jarrick, knowing it will mean saying good-bye to her family and her life of privilege once again? And when Beth trusts the wrong person, will Jarrick be able to help her despite the distance between them?
{My Review}
Rating: 5 stars!
Janette Oke has done it again!! Where Trust Lies is book #2 in the Return to the Canadian West series. Which is a companion series to Janette's original, Canadian West series. I read the original series many years ago, as well as Janette's Love Comes Softly books and films. I have been a fan of Janette's for the longest time, since I was a little girl. And when I heard she writing a companion series to the Canadian West series/When Call the Heart TV series, I was so ecstatic. Janette's books have beautiful prose, they are poignant, and they are just an absolute delight to read. I always look forward to another Janette Oke book. I highly recommend it.
July 12, 2021
I must say that I didn't enjoy this as much as the first novel, mainly due to the setting. The reason I loved the first novel was because of Coal Valley, but the entirety of this novel was basically a long cruise holiday. I definitely missed everyone from the first novel.
However, that isn't to say that this novel was entirely boring because the final arc with Julie was quite exciting (but that didn't happen until around the last 100 pages). It was also nice to see Beth mature and grow in her relationship with God. I also loved the developments between her and Jarrick!
The book just dragged a bit for me though, so I can't wait to read about Beth returning to Coal Valley!
However, that isn't to say that this novel was entirely boring because the final arc with Julie was quite exciting (but that didn't happen until around the last 100 pages). It was also nice to see Beth mature and grow in her relationship with God. I also loved the developments between her and Jarrick!
The book just dragged a bit for me though, so I can't wait to read about Beth returning to Coal Valley!
September 22, 2024
I thoroughly enjoyed this book like the others. Its feel good comfort warm read. Feels like home to me.
March 13, 2015
3.5 stars
Beth Thatcher is home for the summer after teaching in the small mining town of Coal Valley out in Canada's West. She isn't the same girl who left home the year before. As Beth looks forward to a summer of catching up with her mother and sisters, she soon realizes that perhaps she no longer belongs in the world she grew up in. A surprise cruise along Canada's east coast & the Northeastern United States has Beth wishing for the simple summer she'd planned. Yet Beth realizes that the trip is a chance to bond with her mother and sisters and perhaps bridge the gap that grown between them. When one of her family members trusts the wrong person, Beth has draw on the strength she found out West. Will her family ever be able to move forward?
I think I've outgrown Janette Oke. And that makes me rather sad. I mean I can still enjoy her books, but not like I did twenty something years ago. You see, I was between the ages of 10 and 14 when I first picked up one of Janette Oke's books. And I loved the Love Comes Softly Series and the Canadian West Series. But something happened. I grew up. I discovered authors whose stories grabbed me and wouldn't let me go. While I will always have a soft spot and fond memories of the Janette Oke books, I think that I'd be better off not requesting to review her new releases. Oh, I'll probably still read them. I can easily rent them from the library. But I seem to hold reviewing books to a different standard than the ones I read for pure pleasure. Anyway, all that is to say that my thoughts on this one may seem a little more harsh or critical than I mean to.
I enjoyed this book much more than the first in this series. I did find that it was a very slow moving book. I literally went for days without picking it up. Beth has grown up since I first met her in the first book. And her character has developed more too. But I still found her rather shallow. Though no where near as shallow as one of her sisters or a family friend.
The romance I was hoping for in this book between Beth and Jarrick, Jack from the first book, is almost nonexistent. I get the fact that they are on different sides of the continent, but I still wanted more. Sure there are a couple of phone calls and letters exchanged, but not at all what I was hoping for. I also had hoped for more of Coal Valley. I'd grown to like that little town by the end of the first book. I would have liked to revisit that community.
I really felt that this book was too long. I felt that there chapters that did nothing to move the story along. And once the climax of Beth's family member trusting the wrong person occurs, there was too much time spent describing everything.
Still fans of the Hallmark series will enjoy this book. I'm not saying that it wasn't a good book, because it was good. But like I said earlier, I think I've outgrown Janette Oke.
I received this book for free from Bethany House Publishers for the purpose of reviewing. I was not required to like the book, only give my honest opinion. My thoughts and opinions are my own.
Recommended to fans of Janette Oke, Beverly Lewis, Little House on the Prairie, Hallmark's Love Come Softly movie series, Hallmark's When Calls the Heart movie & series
Rating - 3.5 stars - It was better than the first, which I struggled through, but not stellar. Goodreads/Amazon Rating will be 3 stars.
Beth Thatcher is home for the summer after teaching in the small mining town of Coal Valley out in Canada's West. She isn't the same girl who left home the year before. As Beth looks forward to a summer of catching up with her mother and sisters, she soon realizes that perhaps she no longer belongs in the world she grew up in. A surprise cruise along Canada's east coast & the Northeastern United States has Beth wishing for the simple summer she'd planned. Yet Beth realizes that the trip is a chance to bond with her mother and sisters and perhaps bridge the gap that grown between them. When one of her family members trusts the wrong person, Beth has draw on the strength she found out West. Will her family ever be able to move forward?
I think I've outgrown Janette Oke. And that makes me rather sad. I mean I can still enjoy her books, but not like I did twenty something years ago. You see, I was between the ages of 10 and 14 when I first picked up one of Janette Oke's books. And I loved the Love Comes Softly Series and the Canadian West Series. But something happened. I grew up. I discovered authors whose stories grabbed me and wouldn't let me go. While I will always have a soft spot and fond memories of the Janette Oke books, I think that I'd be better off not requesting to review her new releases. Oh, I'll probably still read them. I can easily rent them from the library. But I seem to hold reviewing books to a different standard than the ones I read for pure pleasure. Anyway, all that is to say that my thoughts on this one may seem a little more harsh or critical than I mean to.
I enjoyed this book much more than the first in this series. I did find that it was a very slow moving book. I literally went for days without picking it up. Beth has grown up since I first met her in the first book. And her character has developed more too. But I still found her rather shallow. Though no where near as shallow as one of her sisters or a family friend.
The romance I was hoping for in this book between Beth and Jarrick, Jack from the first book, is almost nonexistent. I get the fact that they are on different sides of the continent, but I still wanted more. Sure there are a couple of phone calls and letters exchanged, but not at all what I was hoping for. I also had hoped for more of Coal Valley. I'd grown to like that little town by the end of the first book. I would have liked to revisit that community.
I really felt that this book was too long. I felt that there chapters that did nothing to move the story along. And once the climax of Beth's family member trusting the wrong person occurs, there was too much time spent describing everything.
Still fans of the Hallmark series will enjoy this book. I'm not saying that it wasn't a good book, because it was good. But like I said earlier, I think I've outgrown Janette Oke.
I received this book for free from Bethany House Publishers for the purpose of reviewing. I was not required to like the book, only give my honest opinion. My thoughts and opinions are my own.
Recommended to fans of Janette Oke, Beverly Lewis, Little House on the Prairie, Hallmark's Love Come Softly movie series, Hallmark's When Calls the Heart movie & series
Rating - 3.5 stars - It was better than the first, which I struggled through, but not stellar. Goodreads/Amazon Rating will be 3 stars.
January 1, 2015
This second book in the Return to the Canadian West series has absolutely nothing to do with the Canadian West! Instead it's a travelogue story about Beth Thatcher's summer vacation with her family while waiting to learn if her teaching contract in the small western mining town of Coal Valley will be renewed. I enjoyed the glimpse of blossoming romance between Beth and Jarrick as they exchanged letters, telegrams and telephone calls, but I felt it took too big a leap forward at the end, was rushed a little too much. I also found the middle of the story a bit tedious and slow, and wished there had been more of a central conflict for Beth to overcome; instead, the actual story tension all came from Julie, while Beth was relegated to a bystander learning to trust God as her sister's fate hangs in the balance. Being a single-POV story, much of the action happens "off-screen," but there is still more than enough of a story to get lost in for a few hours. I eagerly await the next installment -- which I hope will be a true "Return to the Canadian West" and resume the tale of Beth's life in Coal Valley!
February 19, 2015
There are so many things in this book that could be spoiled, so this is going to be a short review.
I really loved this book, and hope a third one will come out next year! I did think the ending was really predictable though. I've read a lot of books like that lately, so either I'm getting better at predicting endings and plot twists, or people are getting worse at writing them. :-/
I was swooning throughout the book though. Jarrick is so sweet and cute! Where can I find a Jarrick???
I recommend this book for girls 12 and up. I don't really think guys would enjoy it because it's really girly and romantic. Lots of talk of dresses and hairstyles and shopping and all that ;)
I really loved this book, and hope a third one will come out next year! I did think the ending was really predictable though. I've read a lot of books like that lately, so either I'm getting better at predicting endings and plot twists, or people are getting worse at writing them. :-/
I was swooning throughout the book though. Jarrick is so sweet and cute! Where can I find a Jarrick???
I recommend this book for girls 12 and up. I don't really think guys would enjoy it because it's really girly and romantic. Lots of talk of dresses and hairstyles and shopping and all that ;)
January 5, 2020
A great addition to the "Return to the Canadian West" trilogy.
May 10, 2020
2.5 stars
August 20, 2019
Elizabeth (Beth) Thatcher did not anticipate a long family vacation on a ship after returning from teaching in Coal Valley the past year. Their vacation proved to be more intense than anticipated with the turn of events that demanded money from them. The story seemed to move slowly for me until the later part where there was faster paced action. I picked up on who may be the victim and the offenders of betrayed trust early in the book. I was really disappointed in this Janette Oke and Laurel Oke Logan book. It was a book I laid down often until the very end.
This was a book purchased at a used sale from a local library, thus no review was required. I have expressed my own opinion.
This was a book purchased at a used sale from a local library, thus no review was required. I have expressed my own opinion.
October 16, 2021
This is the 2nd book in the Return to the Canadian series.Beth returns home to her family fater teaching in Coal Valley.She is barely home when her family tells her they are going on a boat to eastern coast of Canada and united States.
She is also waiting to see if she will teach in Coal Valley again and get to see Mountie Jack Thorton again.I enjoyed this story very much.
She is also waiting to see if she will teach in Coal Valley again and get to see Mountie Jack Thorton again.I enjoyed this story very much.
November 19, 2025
Stop that was so cute😭😭😭 And the drama at the end?!?! Love! 4.5⭐️
March 13, 2024
I honestly enjoyed this book more than the first. You know that everything is leading up to something, but it’s not something you’d expect.
July 11, 2024
This is the next part of the story of Beth, the school teacher in Coal Valley, but this whole book takes place in Hamilton and a cruise to New York. Beth is spending time with her family and writing letters to Jack back in Coal Valley. Here are some favorite quotes:
"'We haven't truly been keeping company at all. He's never even called on me. Not really. We've only had interactions through... everyday life (p. 22)."
"Were you never in love, Mother?... Is that what I'm feeling--this thrill at the very thought of him? Am I in love with him? (p. 24)"
"'I wanted to leave no doubt with him that my intentions toward you could be trusted. Through, of course, any future plans would require that we grow to know one another better--and it all would include much prayer as well as counsel from those who know us. But I wanted your father to know that my ultimate intention is... well, it's marriage' (p. 29)."
"'I'm very fond of you, Jarrick. And I admire your character. I'm honored by your words, and I do appreciate your candor. I do. But I can't say that I know just yet if it's the right thing for me and for you. I need time to hear what God is saying. I want to be very careful with something so important. I need to pray, wait for an answer, one that goes beyond my feelings. Is that fair? Please don't be upset' (p. 30)."
"'I think you'll find it's often the sort of journey which the protagonist doesn't desire to take that ends up telling the greatest story. The kind that has the most to teach us' (p. 42)."
"'She's a remarkable woman, really. Pay attention to her many gifts. I know that you can grow to appreciate here--the manner in which she loves, her unwavering faith--if you just try' (p. 41)."
"'I'm grateful to know you'll be in the hands of Providence in the meantime... and our good friend Emile' (p. 45)."
"'I've always wondered what... the Mounties actually do' (p. 49)."
"'The only other thing I'll tell you about him is that I've observed his conduct for almost a year, and I think he's a perfectly pleasing man. That he's just the sort of person... I could see myself marrying. I'm praying fervently for wisdom, for clear direction from God... one step at a time' (p. 52)."
"'Beth's idealized view of the world will hinder her from making a rational decision' (p. 57)."
"Why is it so difficult to earn Mother's approval? Why is she always so disparaging of me? Am I truly headstrong and uncooperative? Do I truly have an idealized view of the world, making it impossible to make some rational decisions? What am I misunderstanding about our relationship? Will there never be peace and trust between Mother and me? (p. 60)"
"She determined that she could not begrudge Mother her concerns about a man she didn't know, or her need to confide in a friend. She would honor her... Beth chose the simplest of her new dresses and slipped on the sensible new walking shoes (p. 60)."
"'Monsieur... I feel as if I've somehow stepped out into Europe this morning, or at least as I've imagined Europe. Quebec City is so much... more 'foreign' than I had expected' (p. 63)."
"Jarrick was correct in encouraging me to come along with my family (p. 72)."
"'I've always told my Victoria that she may do anything she sets her mind to. After all, we have the vote now--at long last. It only follows that many of the senseless ways in which women are excluded from positions of authority and leadership will eventually be resolved as well' (p. 83)."
"'It isn't fair. Why should we have so much when others have so little?' (p. 92)"
"'Jarrick... I wish you were here' (p. 97)."
"'My dear Beth, Hearing your voice tonight on the telephone was like music to my ears' (p. 100)."
"What if a life with Jarrick isn't truly God's will? (p. 101)"
"'Each day I carry along one of the petals from your roses which I saved in a handkerchief. They serve as a countdown of sorts until I shall see your again' (p. 112)."
"A man, perhaps, can risk being more forthcoming, but a young woman must guard her words carefully' (p. 112)."
"'It's a 'bob'... It's all the latest rage. Don't you love it, Bethie darling?' (p. 130)"
"'One must be grateful for the way God has created each of us. Or one will never be satisfied at all' (p. 134)."
"Is he trying to find a job on the cruise ship? A young man with an incomplete economics degree? And what of his family? Had they forsaken him? It made no sense to Beth (p. 138)."
"'I worked in a coal-mining town out in western Canada as a teacher last year. I can't say that I really changed things much... but we have to try. We're answerable before God at least to do our best' (p. 143)."
"'I believe we suffer because sin has taken hold of the world. And with sin comes selfishness and heartlessness and wickedness. But I also think there will be a day of reckoning, Nick, when God lays out all we've done and judges our actions. That's not as popular to talk about anymore, I suppose. We all like to hear about a God who loves and forgives and rewards. But He isn't holy and just if He doesn't deal with all those wrongs. I would never want to stand before God without having done everything in my power to extend His mercy to the people around me whenever I could' (p. 143)."
"'I heard it was really pretty here, and now I see why. The red cliffs, the bright green grass. And to top it all off, those lovely white houses perched like dainty little birds above it all' (p. 147)."
"It was quickly evident that Jarrick had not yet received her letter. But he had mailed another without waiting for her reply. Beth was so grateful he had done so (p. 154)."
"'I want to assure you that I'm praying daily that I would have the wisdom to use these long weeks of waiting as a time of preparation. God willing, I would like to be the best man that I can be before your return' (p. 154)."
"'There's talk now of Abigail Stanton buying the Grants' place to open a small restaurant and teahouse' (p. 157)."
"'Those telephones can be finicky things. I'll bet they fix the problem soon' (p. 161)."
"'I don't feel there's any privacy at all. There are always people watching... I feel as if the whole world knows we're trying to speak with each other. Surely someone could come up with a better way' (p. 163)."
"'Marriage lasts a long, long time. To be yoked together with someone... unsuitable would have tragic effects for the whole of one's lifetime, and for every facet of it. It is something to be contemplated soberly, with great care and much prayer' (p. 181)."
"'It's not that I want to steal your joy, Beth. I want to see you well-matched in the happiest and most enriching marriage possible, though I know that for every couple there will always be difficulties and hardships to overcome. But that ability to overcome requires a certain compatibility, a bond 'till death do us part,' and an unshakable faith' (p. 182)."
"Your will, Father God, Beth prayed silently as they sat together. Neither Mother's nor my own. Your will alone (p. 191)."
"'I was disappointed too about our last conversation being over all too soon. I had so much more I wanted to say' (p. 200)."
"'It sounds as if you have a very close-knit family... Your stories remind me of the gatherings at my grandpapa's... Those times are such special memories to me.' 'I don't want to give the impression that my family is perfect, Beth' (p. 202)."
"'Sometimes I'm too hard on people close to me--I probably get that from my father. I tend to expect others to be as uncompromising as I am' (p. 203)."
"'I want to be a person who makes sure the truly guilty party is found as quickly as possible--and that the judgment is fair. No scapegoats, no cutting corners on justice' (p. 205)."
"'I love you, Beth. Good-bye' (p. 207)."
"'I can only give you over to God again and again, and do my best to guide you. Solicited or not' (p. 219)."
"'Mother... thank you for your questions about Jarrick. At first I was put off by them--probably feeling like you didn't trust my judgment... But I gradually realized you had raised some important 'facts' of his life that needed to be addressed, not only for your sake but for mine too' (p. 220)."
"'I wish Father were here. He would enjoy seeing us all so happy' (p. 238)."
"'They think I'm shockingly dependent--I need to learn to stand on my own two feet!' (p. 238)"
"'Julie, a person doesn't demonstrate independence by rebelling. You do it by shouldering responsibilities, making wise, thoughtful decisions. You know that' (p. 238)."
"'Our Creator makes things grow and change--like a living cell... Our family is like one of those cells. Someday we'll split off into new families, like how a cell grows and divides, like Margaret and John did. But until then, we needed each other And no single part survives on its own. It wasn't meant to' (p. 240)."
"Heavenly Father, don't let evil win. Help me to trust in Your Great Good instead (p. 279)."
"I thought my broken heart would never heal (p. 280)."
"'Oh, Heavenly Father, give us strength. Give Julie strength' (p. 284)."
"'I've never seen so much attention given to one investigation. They're being very methodical and comprehensive' (p. 291)."
"'Only God is enough for you now' (p. 315)."
"'You understand my anger, Father. But You're not a God of hatred. Please forgive me. No matter what, I want to follow You with all my actions and all my heart. But I can't do it without Your help. Please put Your love in my heart, Your desire for mercy over retribution' (p. 317)."
"Instead of any further report, he closed his eyes and began to pray aloud for God's intervention at this moment. Beth surrendered to the tears, now of some hope, streaming down her cheeks (p. 319)."
"There would be plenty of time later for discussion. It was sufficient for now just to surround Julie's bed together and fervently thank God (p. 323)."
"'I've never prayed so much in my life! It helped a lot (p. 324)."
"'Would you like to take a walk?' (p. 329)"
"'If we had to earn God's favor by always performing perfectly, we'd all suffer as failures alone' (p. 330)."
"'Don't I get to decide who I'm going to love?' (p. 331)"
"'Only God knows. But we can't let the search for His will paralyze us. I believe that He brought us together. So I know that I can trust Him. I'm willing to set aside my fear of the unknowns in our future and take each day as it comes. The Bible says, 'In all thy ways acknowledge him, and he shall direct they paths.' It's God's promise. Can you do that with me? Let God direct our paths--even if we don't see where all it leads? Because I believe that whatever He's already walked us through together is just getting us ready for whatever He's got in store for us next. And I do know I need you beside me for that' (p. 331)."
"'I love you, Beth. I don't ever want you to leave me again' (p. 332)."
"'We haven't truly been keeping company at all. He's never even called on me. Not really. We've only had interactions through... everyday life (p. 22)."
"Were you never in love, Mother?... Is that what I'm feeling--this thrill at the very thought of him? Am I in love with him? (p. 24)"
"'I wanted to leave no doubt with him that my intentions toward you could be trusted. Through, of course, any future plans would require that we grow to know one another better--and it all would include much prayer as well as counsel from those who know us. But I wanted your father to know that my ultimate intention is... well, it's marriage' (p. 29)."
"'I'm very fond of you, Jarrick. And I admire your character. I'm honored by your words, and I do appreciate your candor. I do. But I can't say that I know just yet if it's the right thing for me and for you. I need time to hear what God is saying. I want to be very careful with something so important. I need to pray, wait for an answer, one that goes beyond my feelings. Is that fair? Please don't be upset' (p. 30)."
"'I think you'll find it's often the sort of journey which the protagonist doesn't desire to take that ends up telling the greatest story. The kind that has the most to teach us' (p. 42)."
"'She's a remarkable woman, really. Pay attention to her many gifts. I know that you can grow to appreciate here--the manner in which she loves, her unwavering faith--if you just try' (p. 41)."
"'I'm grateful to know you'll be in the hands of Providence in the meantime... and our good friend Emile' (p. 45)."
"'I've always wondered what... the Mounties actually do' (p. 49)."
"'The only other thing I'll tell you about him is that I've observed his conduct for almost a year, and I think he's a perfectly pleasing man. That he's just the sort of person... I could see myself marrying. I'm praying fervently for wisdom, for clear direction from God... one step at a time' (p. 52)."
"'Beth's idealized view of the world will hinder her from making a rational decision' (p. 57)."
"Why is it so difficult to earn Mother's approval? Why is she always so disparaging of me? Am I truly headstrong and uncooperative? Do I truly have an idealized view of the world, making it impossible to make some rational decisions? What am I misunderstanding about our relationship? Will there never be peace and trust between Mother and me? (p. 60)"
"She determined that she could not begrudge Mother her concerns about a man she didn't know, or her need to confide in a friend. She would honor her... Beth chose the simplest of her new dresses and slipped on the sensible new walking shoes (p. 60)."
"'Monsieur... I feel as if I've somehow stepped out into Europe this morning, or at least as I've imagined Europe. Quebec City is so much... more 'foreign' than I had expected' (p. 63)."
"Jarrick was correct in encouraging me to come along with my family (p. 72)."
"'I've always told my Victoria that she may do anything she sets her mind to. After all, we have the vote now--at long last. It only follows that many of the senseless ways in which women are excluded from positions of authority and leadership will eventually be resolved as well' (p. 83)."
"'It isn't fair. Why should we have so much when others have so little?' (p. 92)"
"'Jarrick... I wish you were here' (p. 97)."
"'My dear Beth, Hearing your voice tonight on the telephone was like music to my ears' (p. 100)."
"What if a life with Jarrick isn't truly God's will? (p. 101)"
"'Each day I carry along one of the petals from your roses which I saved in a handkerchief. They serve as a countdown of sorts until I shall see your again' (p. 112)."
"A man, perhaps, can risk being more forthcoming, but a young woman must guard her words carefully' (p. 112)."
"'It's a 'bob'... It's all the latest rage. Don't you love it, Bethie darling?' (p. 130)"
"'One must be grateful for the way God has created each of us. Or one will never be satisfied at all' (p. 134)."
"Is he trying to find a job on the cruise ship? A young man with an incomplete economics degree? And what of his family? Had they forsaken him? It made no sense to Beth (p. 138)."
"'I worked in a coal-mining town out in western Canada as a teacher last year. I can't say that I really changed things much... but we have to try. We're answerable before God at least to do our best' (p. 143)."
"'I believe we suffer because sin has taken hold of the world. And with sin comes selfishness and heartlessness and wickedness. But I also think there will be a day of reckoning, Nick, when God lays out all we've done and judges our actions. That's not as popular to talk about anymore, I suppose. We all like to hear about a God who loves and forgives and rewards. But He isn't holy and just if He doesn't deal with all those wrongs. I would never want to stand before God without having done everything in my power to extend His mercy to the people around me whenever I could' (p. 143)."
"'I heard it was really pretty here, and now I see why. The red cliffs, the bright green grass. And to top it all off, those lovely white houses perched like dainty little birds above it all' (p. 147)."
"It was quickly evident that Jarrick had not yet received her letter. But he had mailed another without waiting for her reply. Beth was so grateful he had done so (p. 154)."
"'I want to assure you that I'm praying daily that I would have the wisdom to use these long weeks of waiting as a time of preparation. God willing, I would like to be the best man that I can be before your return' (p. 154)."
"'There's talk now of Abigail Stanton buying the Grants' place to open a small restaurant and teahouse' (p. 157)."
"'Those telephones can be finicky things. I'll bet they fix the problem soon' (p. 161)."
"'I don't feel there's any privacy at all. There are always people watching... I feel as if the whole world knows we're trying to speak with each other. Surely someone could come up with a better way' (p. 163)."
"'Marriage lasts a long, long time. To be yoked together with someone... unsuitable would have tragic effects for the whole of one's lifetime, and for every facet of it. It is something to be contemplated soberly, with great care and much prayer' (p. 181)."
"'It's not that I want to steal your joy, Beth. I want to see you well-matched in the happiest and most enriching marriage possible, though I know that for every couple there will always be difficulties and hardships to overcome. But that ability to overcome requires a certain compatibility, a bond 'till death do us part,' and an unshakable faith' (p. 182)."
"Your will, Father God, Beth prayed silently as they sat together. Neither Mother's nor my own. Your will alone (p. 191)."
"'I was disappointed too about our last conversation being over all too soon. I had so much more I wanted to say' (p. 200)."
"'It sounds as if you have a very close-knit family... Your stories remind me of the gatherings at my grandpapa's... Those times are such special memories to me.' 'I don't want to give the impression that my family is perfect, Beth' (p. 202)."
"'Sometimes I'm too hard on people close to me--I probably get that from my father. I tend to expect others to be as uncompromising as I am' (p. 203)."
"'I want to be a person who makes sure the truly guilty party is found as quickly as possible--and that the judgment is fair. No scapegoats, no cutting corners on justice' (p. 205)."
"'I love you, Beth. Good-bye' (p. 207)."
"'I can only give you over to God again and again, and do my best to guide you. Solicited or not' (p. 219)."
"'Mother... thank you for your questions about Jarrick. At first I was put off by them--probably feeling like you didn't trust my judgment... But I gradually realized you had raised some important 'facts' of his life that needed to be addressed, not only for your sake but for mine too' (p. 220)."
"'I wish Father were here. He would enjoy seeing us all so happy' (p. 238)."
"'They think I'm shockingly dependent--I need to learn to stand on my own two feet!' (p. 238)"
"'Julie, a person doesn't demonstrate independence by rebelling. You do it by shouldering responsibilities, making wise, thoughtful decisions. You know that' (p. 238)."
"'Our Creator makes things grow and change--like a living cell... Our family is like one of those cells. Someday we'll split off into new families, like how a cell grows and divides, like Margaret and John did. But until then, we needed each other And no single part survives on its own. It wasn't meant to' (p. 240)."
"Heavenly Father, don't let evil win. Help me to trust in Your Great Good instead (p. 279)."
"I thought my broken heart would never heal (p. 280)."
"'Oh, Heavenly Father, give us strength. Give Julie strength' (p. 284)."
"'I've never seen so much attention given to one investigation. They're being very methodical and comprehensive' (p. 291)."
"'Only God is enough for you now' (p. 315)."
"'You understand my anger, Father. But You're not a God of hatred. Please forgive me. No matter what, I want to follow You with all my actions and all my heart. But I can't do it without Your help. Please put Your love in my heart, Your desire for mercy over retribution' (p. 317)."
"Instead of any further report, he closed his eyes and began to pray aloud for God's intervention at this moment. Beth surrendered to the tears, now of some hope, streaming down her cheeks (p. 319)."
"There would be plenty of time later for discussion. It was sufficient for now just to surround Julie's bed together and fervently thank God (p. 323)."
"'I've never prayed so much in my life! It helped a lot (p. 324)."
"'Would you like to take a walk?' (p. 329)"
"'If we had to earn God's favor by always performing perfectly, we'd all suffer as failures alone' (p. 330)."
"'Don't I get to decide who I'm going to love?' (p. 331)"
"'Only God knows. But we can't let the search for His will paralyze us. I believe that He brought us together. So I know that I can trust Him. I'm willing to set aside my fear of the unknowns in our future and take each day as it comes. The Bible says, 'In all thy ways acknowledge him, and he shall direct they paths.' It's God's promise. Can you do that with me? Let God direct our paths--even if we don't see where all it leads? Because I believe that whatever He's already walked us through together is just getting us ready for whatever He's got in store for us next. And I do know I need you beside me for that' (p. 331)."
"'I love you, Beth. I don't ever want you to leave me again' (p. 332)."
March 23, 2015
It’s been released! Finally, the long-awaited book 2 of the Return to the Canadian West series is available for patiently waiting fans. Where Trust Lies is the result of the mother-daughter collaboration by bestselling authors Janette Oke and Laurel Oke Logan, and was published in January of 2015 by Bethany House. Because this book is the sequel in a closely-knit series, it is highly recommended to read book 1, Where Courage Calls, before delving into the continuation of Beth Thatcher’s story. Interestingly, both books are also companion volumes to Hallmark Channel’s original television series, entitled When Calls the Heart. This exceptional program premiered in the winter of 2014 and is set to air a highly anticipated second season in April of 2015.
After opening the pages of Where Trust Lies, it is a delight to discover the story picking up just days after the closing events of Where Courage Calls. Beth Thatcher is on her way home to Toronto after spending a full school year teaching in Coal Valley. Leaving behind a classroom of children she adores, a community of people she respects, and a Mountie who may hold a piece of her heart, Beth hopes to reconnect with her family over the summer and return West in the fall. Little does she know the relaxing vacation of her dreams will transform into a nightmare before the summer is over.
As each character in the story is introduced, we truly feel as though we are meeting a living, breathing person and not merely a fictitious identity created by words on a page. Beth’s vivid near-reality, though related in third-person, allows us to enter into her thoughts and emotions, to experience circumstances through her eyes, and to anticipate along with her the possibilities of her next chapter in life. Each secondary character, from Mother to Julie to Mrs. Montclaire is also brought to life in our imaginations through convincing dialogue and word-pictures. Without a doubt, it is the character element of the story that makes it shine.
While the characters of Where Trust Lies bring the book to life, its foundation and structure is grounded in the truth of God’s word. Numerous instances depict Beth striving to seek God’s will for her life over her own, especially in matters of life-changing importance – namely, her relationship with Jarrick. When a shocking offense is aimed at the people closest to her heart, Beth’s faith is admittedly shaken, but ultimately renewed and strengthened. Interesting, interwoven relationship struggles and growths also infuse the story with depth and meaning, and cause us to look at the people we relate to in a different light.
If you have enjoyed any of Janette Oke’s books in the past, don’t miss Where Trust Lies. With its sweet yet exciting storyline filled with hope and faith, readers of inspirational fiction will not be disappointed. The previous novel in the series adds history, faith adds a firm foundation as the story builds to a can’t-put-it-down climax, and each character walks straight off the page and into our imaginations. What more can I say? Whether you have fallen in love with the Hallmark Channel’s corresponding television series, or simply enjoyed book 1 of the Return to the Canadian West, add Where Trust Lies to your to-read pile. The only negative element is found in the final pages as we say goodbye to all the characters we’ve grown to love… Clearly, the one and only remedy for this imperfection is to release a third installment!
Book has been provided courtesy of Baker Publishing Group and Graf-Martin Communications, Inc.
After opening the pages of Where Trust Lies, it is a delight to discover the story picking up just days after the closing events of Where Courage Calls. Beth Thatcher is on her way home to Toronto after spending a full school year teaching in Coal Valley. Leaving behind a classroom of children she adores, a community of people she respects, and a Mountie who may hold a piece of her heart, Beth hopes to reconnect with her family over the summer and return West in the fall. Little does she know the relaxing vacation of her dreams will transform into a nightmare before the summer is over.
As each character in the story is introduced, we truly feel as though we are meeting a living, breathing person and not merely a fictitious identity created by words on a page. Beth’s vivid near-reality, though related in third-person, allows us to enter into her thoughts and emotions, to experience circumstances through her eyes, and to anticipate along with her the possibilities of her next chapter in life. Each secondary character, from Mother to Julie to Mrs. Montclaire is also brought to life in our imaginations through convincing dialogue and word-pictures. Without a doubt, it is the character element of the story that makes it shine.
While the characters of Where Trust Lies bring the book to life, its foundation and structure is grounded in the truth of God’s word. Numerous instances depict Beth striving to seek God’s will for her life over her own, especially in matters of life-changing importance – namely, her relationship with Jarrick. When a shocking offense is aimed at the people closest to her heart, Beth’s faith is admittedly shaken, but ultimately renewed and strengthened. Interesting, interwoven relationship struggles and growths also infuse the story with depth and meaning, and cause us to look at the people we relate to in a different light.
If you have enjoyed any of Janette Oke’s books in the past, don’t miss Where Trust Lies. With its sweet yet exciting storyline filled with hope and faith, readers of inspirational fiction will not be disappointed. The previous novel in the series adds history, faith adds a firm foundation as the story builds to a can’t-put-it-down climax, and each character walks straight off the page and into our imaginations. What more can I say? Whether you have fallen in love with the Hallmark Channel’s corresponding television series, or simply enjoyed book 1 of the Return to the Canadian West, add Where Trust Lies to your to-read pile. The only negative element is found in the final pages as we say goodbye to all the characters we’ve grown to love… Clearly, the one and only remedy for this imperfection is to release a third installment!
Book has been provided courtesy of Baker Publishing Group and Graf-Martin Communications, Inc.
March 5, 2015
Where Trust Lies, Return to the Canadian West Book 2 by Janette Oke and Laurel Oke Logan continues the story of the young Elizabeth Thatcher. The cover notes that this is the companion series to the Hallmark Channel TV Series, "Where Calls the Heart". I have not followed the TV series, based on the Hallmark Channel's TV Movie of the same name. which really is based on Janette Oke's Where Calls the Heart, Return to the Canadian West Series, Book 1, but I have watched the TV Movie. I loved the movie, but I enjoyed the story of young Elizabeth (Beth) Thatcher much more than her aunt's story. I wanted her to end up with Edward, but the movie story did not continue her story. So I was very happy to receive this book. If you're like me, who enjoy Beth & Edward's story more, then it's time to continue.
At least that's what I thought Where Trust Lies continues.
Where Trust Lies continues a year after Beth had taught in Coal Valley for a year, and is returning to Toronto to her family. We get glimpses of what happened during the year, including the fact that Edward was around, but they are NOT a couple. This story is mainly about Beth reconnecting with her family, including her Father, Mother and two sisters. They reconnect through a family cruise trip of sorts with trouble in their midst. As a side story, there's also the brewing love between Jarrick "Jack" and Beth. Jarrick is a Mountie (like Edward) that covers Coal Valley. I'm not familiar with Jarrick's story or how all this happened with Beth, and I think because I'm so into Edward & Beth's story, that I can't seem to fall for Jarrick, even though he did all the right things, in his letters and in his trust of God.
There is a "characters' list" in the front of the book that tells a one liner of who each character is. For Edward, it says that he is a "future suitor" of Beth's. I kept waiting for him to show up and continue the connection he had with Beth. Unfortunately, that was not the case. He does appear, but shortly, and one just can't help but love his character. I can't wait for his story to continue, hopefully soon and most likely in book 3 of the series.
As an inspirational novel, the inner turmoil, faith and trust in God was well addressed through the various obstacles Beth and her family encountered. I particularly love how it was addressed of when you wish on vengeance on someone that hurt you or someone you love and what it means to forgive.
As a novel, it stands alone, yet gives you glimpses in the past and hopefully continuation in the next area. As a series, I can't wait for the next. Therefore, Ms. Oke and Mrs. Logan did a great job. This is a historical novel with background info well portrayed and illustrated without overtaking the story. If you love the story of "When Calls the Heart", then this is the series for you. Continue on with Beth's story and like me, look forward to her interactions with Edward. I just hope it won't take another year for Book 3 to be released.
Note: I received a free copy of this book from the publisher, Bethany House for an honest review.
At least that's what I thought Where Trust Lies continues.
Where Trust Lies continues a year after Beth had taught in Coal Valley for a year, and is returning to Toronto to her family. We get glimpses of what happened during the year, including the fact that Edward was around, but they are NOT a couple. This story is mainly about Beth reconnecting with her family, including her Father, Mother and two sisters. They reconnect through a family cruise trip of sorts with trouble in their midst. As a side story, there's also the brewing love between Jarrick "Jack" and Beth. Jarrick is a Mountie (like Edward) that covers Coal Valley. I'm not familiar with Jarrick's story or how all this happened with Beth, and I think because I'm so into Edward & Beth's story, that I can't seem to fall for Jarrick, even though he did all the right things, in his letters and in his trust of God.
There is a "characters' list" in the front of the book that tells a one liner of who each character is. For Edward, it says that he is a "future suitor" of Beth's. I kept waiting for him to show up and continue the connection he had with Beth. Unfortunately, that was not the case. He does appear, but shortly, and one just can't help but love his character. I can't wait for his story to continue, hopefully soon and most likely in book 3 of the series.
As an inspirational novel, the inner turmoil, faith and trust in God was well addressed through the various obstacles Beth and her family encountered. I particularly love how it was addressed of when you wish on vengeance on someone that hurt you or someone you love and what it means to forgive.
As a novel, it stands alone, yet gives you glimpses in the past and hopefully continuation in the next area. As a series, I can't wait for the next. Therefore, Ms. Oke and Mrs. Logan did a great job. This is a historical novel with background info well portrayed and illustrated without overtaking the story. If you love the story of "When Calls the Heart", then this is the series for you. Continue on with Beth's story and like me, look forward to her interactions with Edward. I just hope it won't take another year for Book 3 to be released.
Note: I received a free copy of this book from the publisher, Bethany House for an honest review.
July 1, 2025
A little dark for Oke, but it was still oke-kay. 😉
Now I'm just annoyed that there's no audio edition of the third book in the series.
Now I'm just annoyed that there's no audio edition of the third book in the series.
March 27, 2015
"Where Trust Lies" is the second book in the Return to the Canadian West series. The storyline picks up basically right after where the first book left off. Because it starts right after where the first book ended, I personally would not recommend this book as a stand alone as some things might not make much sense if you haven't read the first book in the series.
Beth Thatcher is returning home to her family after spending a year as a teacher in the mining town of Coal Valley. She is hoping to spend some time with her family, and while at home, she is also hoping to receive a letter of invitation to teach in Coal Valley for the next school year. However, as soon as she returns home she finds out that her family has plans to travel on a steamship tour and would like her to come along. Although she wanted to spend some time at home for awhile, Beth agrees to traveling so she can spend time with her family. However, not everything they encounter during their travels is as it seems. When something terrible happens, will Beth trust in God to help her and her family get through the devasting ordeal?
I thought "Where Trust Lies" was a good continuation of the Return to the Canadian West series. While I prefer the first book in the series to this one because I enjoyed the setting and people of Coal Valley more, I still very much enjoyed reading the continuation of Beth's story. It was interesting to read about the different places Beth and her family traveled to while on their trip. I also liked reading and finding out more about Beth's family.
Just as I liked seeing Beth's strong faith in God in the first book, I liked seeing her grow in her faith in this one as well. She is trying to figure out where God is leading her and what His will is for her life, including whether or not she is supposed to return to Coal Valley to teach again. Beth is also trying to figure out her romantic relationship with Jarrick and whether or not he is the man God wants her to be with, and if he's not, if she will be able to let him go. When something devastating occurs, Beth must also trust in God to get her and her family through the difficult time.
The pace of the story is on the slower side. While I didn't mind the pace, some may find this book boring because a lot of the story didn't have a lot of action.
Overall, I really enjoyed "Where Trust Lies" as a sequel to "Where Courage Calls"! It was a nice continuation of Beth's story with a good theme of trust. I look forward to reading more books in this series if more are published.
*I received this book for free from Bethany House Publishers in exchange for my honest review.
Beth Thatcher is returning home to her family after spending a year as a teacher in the mining town of Coal Valley. She is hoping to spend some time with her family, and while at home, she is also hoping to receive a letter of invitation to teach in Coal Valley for the next school year. However, as soon as she returns home she finds out that her family has plans to travel on a steamship tour and would like her to come along. Although she wanted to spend some time at home for awhile, Beth agrees to traveling so she can spend time with her family. However, not everything they encounter during their travels is as it seems. When something terrible happens, will Beth trust in God to help her and her family get through the devasting ordeal?
I thought "Where Trust Lies" was a good continuation of the Return to the Canadian West series. While I prefer the first book in the series to this one because I enjoyed the setting and people of Coal Valley more, I still very much enjoyed reading the continuation of Beth's story. It was interesting to read about the different places Beth and her family traveled to while on their trip. I also liked reading and finding out more about Beth's family.
Just as I liked seeing Beth's strong faith in God in the first book, I liked seeing her grow in her faith in this one as well. She is trying to figure out where God is leading her and what His will is for her life, including whether or not she is supposed to return to Coal Valley to teach again. Beth is also trying to figure out her romantic relationship with Jarrick and whether or not he is the man God wants her to be with, and if he's not, if she will be able to let him go. When something devastating occurs, Beth must also trust in God to get her and her family through the difficult time.
The pace of the story is on the slower side. While I didn't mind the pace, some may find this book boring because a lot of the story didn't have a lot of action.
Overall, I really enjoyed "Where Trust Lies" as a sequel to "Where Courage Calls"! It was a nice continuation of Beth's story with a good theme of trust. I look forward to reading more books in this series if more are published.
*I received this book for free from Bethany House Publishers in exchange for my honest review.
February 24, 2015
*Summary*
Though Elizabeth Thatcher has missed her family, she doesn't look forward to leaving her new home, teaching post, and the man she loves in Coal Valley for her former Boston home. Now, back in her old house, room, and city, Elizabeth misses Jarrick, the man she left behind, more then ever. Just as she plans to stay at home to wait for messages from Jack and for her new posting, her mom decides to go on a cruise with the family. As she settles into her old life awaiting and praying for her return to coal valley, she's beginning to wonder if she'll ever get used to life back in Boston. Will she ever get back to Jack and her beloved coal valley? Or will she be back in Boston indefinitely? Is she ready to leave behind her family-perhaps forever-to follow her dreams with Jarrick?
__________________________________________________
*What I loved*
I have fallen in LOVE with Hallmark channel's "When Calls The Heart" series so naturally I loved Elizabeth and Jack (Elizabeth calls him Jarrick). The cover is stunning and is a perfect match to Janette Oke's first, When Courage Calls.
___________________________________________________
*Not my favorite*
Despite how much I loved Janette Oke with her Love Comes Softly series and her When calls the Heart series, I honestly felt this book was seriously lacking the "Oke feel". The book had a good story line but it was really drawn out and slow and since it was set in Boston, didn't have the same simple talk as set in Coal Valley.
__________________________________________________
*My Rating*
I give Where Trust Lies...3 1/2 stars!
____________________________________________________
*My overall thoughts*
Where Trust Lies by Janette Oke and Laurel Oke Logan is the sequel to Where Courage calls. It features Elizabeth Thatcher we've all grown to know and love and is a great book to read if you want a slow read that you have a lot of time for. Janette Oke's covers are always stunning and this one is no exception!! All in all, I give Where Trust Lies 3 1/2 stars because of the pace of the story and it just wasn't nearly as good as Oke's other novels.
*I received this book from bookfun.org and the publisher in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts were my own and I was not compensated in any other way.
http://bookreviewsforchristians.blogs...
Though Elizabeth Thatcher has missed her family, she doesn't look forward to leaving her new home, teaching post, and the man she loves in Coal Valley for her former Boston home. Now, back in her old house, room, and city, Elizabeth misses Jarrick, the man she left behind, more then ever. Just as she plans to stay at home to wait for messages from Jack and for her new posting, her mom decides to go on a cruise with the family. As she settles into her old life awaiting and praying for her return to coal valley, she's beginning to wonder if she'll ever get used to life back in Boston. Will she ever get back to Jack and her beloved coal valley? Or will she be back in Boston indefinitely? Is she ready to leave behind her family-perhaps forever-to follow her dreams with Jarrick?
__________________________________________________
*What I loved*
I have fallen in LOVE with Hallmark channel's "When Calls The Heart" series so naturally I loved Elizabeth and Jack (Elizabeth calls him Jarrick). The cover is stunning and is a perfect match to Janette Oke's first, When Courage Calls.
___________________________________________________
*Not my favorite*
Despite how much I loved Janette Oke with her Love Comes Softly series and her When calls the Heart series, I honestly felt this book was seriously lacking the "Oke feel". The book had a good story line but it was really drawn out and slow and since it was set in Boston, didn't have the same simple talk as set in Coal Valley.
__________________________________________________
*My Rating*
I give Where Trust Lies...3 1/2 stars!
____________________________________________________
*My overall thoughts*
Where Trust Lies by Janette Oke and Laurel Oke Logan is the sequel to Where Courage calls. It features Elizabeth Thatcher we've all grown to know and love and is a great book to read if you want a slow read that you have a lot of time for. Janette Oke's covers are always stunning and this one is no exception!! All in all, I give Where Trust Lies 3 1/2 stars because of the pace of the story and it just wasn't nearly as good as Oke's other novels.
*I received this book from bookfun.org and the publisher in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts were my own and I was not compensated in any other way.
http://bookreviewsforchristians.blogs...
March 31, 2015
The description of "Where Trust Lies" from above is sufficient to explain the plot of this book. This is my first Janet Oke book. It was very different from what I expected.
The co-authors have done an outstanding job of researching the geographical locale, scenery and the landscape described throughout the cruise. I've been to many of the places described, and it was a trip back in time reading about those particular locations. That was definitely a high point for me.
I'm unclear as to the time frame during which this book took place, whether it is at the end of WWI or WWII. All that I could glean from the story was that some men had missed combat duty, and the descriptions of the women's clothing and hats which did little to lead me to the correct era.
Characters were varied, some more developed than others. The Thatcher family is a wealthy family with servants, and their family interactions and relationships are very formal. Mother and sisters refer to one another as "darling." They are a close-knit family, very loving and caring of one another. I felt that the characters held one another at arms length at times, most likely a trait in wealthy families. Their love for one another was clear, but concerns about one anothers' reactions arose quite frequently.
The plot was creative and very descriptive, but moved slowly until the last few pages. I wasn't sure the book would end satisfactorily. I enjoyed the book as far as the storyline goes, but it felt more Victorian than 20th century, and a faster pace would have kept my attention more adequately. This won't stop me from reading additional books by these authors. I would like to read one of Ms. Oke's earlier books as a comparison to this book. I would also like to read the prequel to this book in order to determine background information that may have influenced my reactions to this particular book.
Disclaimer: I received a copy of this book through Book Fun and Bethany House in exchange for my honest review. All opinions expressed are my own, and no monetary compensation was received for this review.
The co-authors have done an outstanding job of researching the geographical locale, scenery and the landscape described throughout the cruise. I've been to many of the places described, and it was a trip back in time reading about those particular locations. That was definitely a high point for me.
I'm unclear as to the time frame during which this book took place, whether it is at the end of WWI or WWII. All that I could glean from the story was that some men had missed combat duty, and the descriptions of the women's clothing and hats which did little to lead me to the correct era.
Characters were varied, some more developed than others. The Thatcher family is a wealthy family with servants, and their family interactions and relationships are very formal. Mother and sisters refer to one another as "darling." They are a close-knit family, very loving and caring of one another. I felt that the characters held one another at arms length at times, most likely a trait in wealthy families. Their love for one another was clear, but concerns about one anothers' reactions arose quite frequently.
The plot was creative and very descriptive, but moved slowly until the last few pages. I wasn't sure the book would end satisfactorily. I enjoyed the book as far as the storyline goes, but it felt more Victorian than 20th century, and a faster pace would have kept my attention more adequately. This won't stop me from reading additional books by these authors. I would like to read one of Ms. Oke's earlier books as a comparison to this book. I would also like to read the prequel to this book in order to determine background information that may have influenced my reactions to this particular book.
Disclaimer: I received a copy of this book through Book Fun and Bethany House in exchange for my honest review. All opinions expressed are my own, and no monetary compensation was received for this review.
February 5, 2015
As with her other books Janette and Laurel Oke have written a warm family loving sequel to their Canadian West series. I didn’t want to put it down, and as we travel on a ship up the St Lawrence and visit the beautiful and scenic areas you feel yourself walking in Beth’s shoes and enjoying God’s beauty.
If you are familiar with the previous book about Beth’s time in Western Canada as a teacher in a poor coal town, this is a continuation of her life, and her return back to her home in Toronto. She is there for only a few days when she is whisked away for a luxury cruise with Mother and Sisters, and darling nephew. Beth was reluctant to leave so soon after just arriving home, and she is searching her heart about a new love interest, who is back in the West working as a Mountie.
You will love the banter that goes on between the girls in this family, and admire the love that is shown between them. There is such concern for each other, and it shows in every way in their lives. Their sister Julie, is a talented artist, and is painting the beautiful scenery for Beth to take with her while she is teaching.
Julie seems to fully embrace the party times on the ship, and you will cringe at some of her choices. Beth tries to be there for her, and even goes out of her way to accompany her to places and events she probably wouldn’t have chosen. I had the feeling that some of Julie’s new friends were using her to pay their way.
When tragedy strikes, you really don’t see it coming, but in a way you do? The family rallies around, and help comes from unexpected places and people. I loved this book, and wanted to keep reading, but of course it had to end, but will you be satisfied with the ending? Don’t miss this one!
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Bethany House, and was not required to give a positive review.
If you are familiar with the previous book about Beth’s time in Western Canada as a teacher in a poor coal town, this is a continuation of her life, and her return back to her home in Toronto. She is there for only a few days when she is whisked away for a luxury cruise with Mother and Sisters, and darling nephew. Beth was reluctant to leave so soon after just arriving home, and she is searching her heart about a new love interest, who is back in the West working as a Mountie.
You will love the banter that goes on between the girls in this family, and admire the love that is shown between them. There is such concern for each other, and it shows in every way in their lives. Their sister Julie, is a talented artist, and is painting the beautiful scenery for Beth to take with her while she is teaching.
Julie seems to fully embrace the party times on the ship, and you will cringe at some of her choices. Beth tries to be there for her, and even goes out of her way to accompany her to places and events she probably wouldn’t have chosen. I had the feeling that some of Julie’s new friends were using her to pay their way.
When tragedy strikes, you really don’t see it coming, but in a way you do? The family rallies around, and help comes from unexpected places and people. I loved this book, and wanted to keep reading, but of course it had to end, but will you be satisfied with the ending? Don’t miss this one!
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Bethany House, and was not required to give a positive review.
February 7, 2015
I enjoyed reading Where Trust Lies, the second book in the Return to the Canadian West series by Janette Oke. (The first book in this series is Where Courage Calls.)
Beth Thatcher, our heroine, has returned for the summer. She's hoping that she'll return for another year of teaching, but, nothing has been decided upon with complete certainty. Beth has something to surprise her family with: she's fallen in love with Jarrick. And her family has something to surprise her with: a trip--a cruise.
Beth will be going on a trip with her family and friends for most of the summer. This gives readers a unique opportunity to get to know Beth's family better: her mother, her older sister, Margret, her younger sister, Julie. (Edward's mother and sister are going on this trip as well. Edward is a mountie from the first book.)
Most of the book is about this trip--this family vacation on board a cruise ship and at the various destinations where they stop. Beth has plenty on her mind: Jarrick, for one thing, and the year ahead for another. Julie also keeps Beth busy. And not always in a good way. Beth worries for her younger sister. And she's right to be concerned…in a way. Julie is young and impulsive and oh-so-trusting. She has really come alive during the trip--she's LOVING every single moment of it. And she's making so many new friends. Beth, on the other hand, is enjoying herself respectfully but not losing herself in pleasure.
Where Trust Lies is certainly dramatic in places. I did enjoy it more than I thought I would. I enjoyed it perhaps even a little bit more than the first book in the series.
Beth Thatcher, our heroine, has returned for the summer. She's hoping that she'll return for another year of teaching, but, nothing has been decided upon with complete certainty. Beth has something to surprise her family with: she's fallen in love with Jarrick. And her family has something to surprise her with: a trip--a cruise.
Beth will be going on a trip with her family and friends for most of the summer. This gives readers a unique opportunity to get to know Beth's family better: her mother, her older sister, Margret, her younger sister, Julie. (Edward's mother and sister are going on this trip as well. Edward is a mountie from the first book.)
Most of the book is about this trip--this family vacation on board a cruise ship and at the various destinations where they stop. Beth has plenty on her mind: Jarrick, for one thing, and the year ahead for another. Julie also keeps Beth busy. And not always in a good way. Beth worries for her younger sister. And she's right to be concerned…in a way. Julie is young and impulsive and oh-so-trusting. She has really come alive during the trip--she's LOVING every single moment of it. And she's making so many new friends. Beth, on the other hand, is enjoying herself respectfully but not losing herself in pleasure.
Where Trust Lies is certainly dramatic in places. I did enjoy it more than I thought I would. I enjoyed it perhaps even a little bit more than the first book in the series.
March 2, 2015
Reading a book by Janette Oke is like catching up on the lives of old friends. Her books are some of the first Christian fiction I read and I've been drawn to them ever since. When her daughter Laurel began writing with her the storylines only got stronger. The two of them combined are a beautiful compliment to the story that is being told.
Where Trust Lies is book two in the Return to the Canadian West series. Beth has returned home after spending the last school year teaching in the Canadian wilderness. If you read book one you know that Beth has become smitten with a Canadian Mountie named Jarrick. Beth is looking forward to corresponding with him over the summer break and possibly returning to Coal Valley to teach in the new school year. But upon arriving home Beth discovers her mother and sisters have other plans for her.
The women of the Thatcher family are scheduled to go on a six-week cruise. Once on the cruise Beth's younger head-strong sister Julie befriends a new crowd of young people that include two flappers. While the family has misgivings about these new people in Julie's life, they are a trusting lot and decide to give them a chance. They soon learn that you must be careful in whom you trust.
If you are a fan of the original Canadian West series or if you've enjoyed the When Calls the Heart TV series then you are sure to enjoy this companion story. All of the elements worth reading about are here. The story contains a budding romance, a bit of mystery and intrigue and above all a deep abiding faith in God.
I received a copy of this book to facilitate my review.
Where Trust Lies is book two in the Return to the Canadian West series. Beth has returned home after spending the last school year teaching in the Canadian wilderness. If you read book one you know that Beth has become smitten with a Canadian Mountie named Jarrick. Beth is looking forward to corresponding with him over the summer break and possibly returning to Coal Valley to teach in the new school year. But upon arriving home Beth discovers her mother and sisters have other plans for her.
The women of the Thatcher family are scheduled to go on a six-week cruise. Once on the cruise Beth's younger head-strong sister Julie befriends a new crowd of young people that include two flappers. While the family has misgivings about these new people in Julie's life, they are a trusting lot and decide to give them a chance. They soon learn that you must be careful in whom you trust.
If you are a fan of the original Canadian West series or if you've enjoyed the When Calls the Heart TV series then you are sure to enjoy this companion story. All of the elements worth reading about are here. The story contains a budding romance, a bit of mystery and intrigue and above all a deep abiding faith in God.
I received a copy of this book to facilitate my review.
March 13, 2015
I was THRILLED when I discovered Janette Oke was writing the first book in this series - Where Courage Calls!
Anyone who watched the wonderful movie Hallmark put out a few years ago knows that - while it was supposed to be based on her first book in the Canadian West series - it was done a bit differently.
I'll admit that it's an intriguing idea - but true fans of Janette Oke's work were more than a little surprised... or at least I was.
Then Janette and her daughter Laurel decided to write a novel about the adventures of the character from Hallmark's movie - and IT COULD NOT HAVE BEEN BETTER!
It bore certain resemblances to the film but, true to Janette's staggering talent, it was SO MUCH BETTER!
Where Trust Lies is no different in that way!
Janette Oke is a tremendous writer and it's clear her daughter has inherited that talent as well!
Since I don't watch the series (we haven't had cable for several years) I know nothing about whether or not this story lines up with what is going on but Bethany House proclaims it as a companion to the series so there must be some similar events going on there.
I refuse to give anything away but I have to commend Janette on her ability to write such emotional scenes. Who will Beth choose... What will Beth choose? Even in an age where trains cross so much more of the country, there is much that remains untamed and wild.
You will agonize right along with Beth as she tries to decide between her family and her students and friend back West - not to mention a certain Mountie who has stolen her heart...
How would you decide? I'm not sure I could...
Anyone who watched the wonderful movie Hallmark put out a few years ago knows that - while it was supposed to be based on her first book in the Canadian West series - it was done a bit differently.
I'll admit that it's an intriguing idea - but true fans of Janette Oke's work were more than a little surprised... or at least I was.
Then Janette and her daughter Laurel decided to write a novel about the adventures of the character from Hallmark's movie - and IT COULD NOT HAVE BEEN BETTER!
It bore certain resemblances to the film but, true to Janette's staggering talent, it was SO MUCH BETTER!
Where Trust Lies is no different in that way!
Janette Oke is a tremendous writer and it's clear her daughter has inherited that talent as well!
Since I don't watch the series (we haven't had cable for several years) I know nothing about whether or not this story lines up with what is going on but Bethany House proclaims it as a companion to the series so there must be some similar events going on there.
I refuse to give anything away but I have to commend Janette on her ability to write such emotional scenes. Who will Beth choose... What will Beth choose? Even in an age where trains cross so much more of the country, there is much that remains untamed and wild.
You will agonize right along with Beth as she tries to decide between her family and her students and friend back West - not to mention a certain Mountie who has stolen her heart...
How would you decide? I'm not sure I could...
January 6, 2016
I have been reading books by Jannette Oke since I was just a teenager. She was the first one to introduce me to Christian romance. In which, it was completely okay to be in love and also completely okay to never travel to a bedroom scene. I love each of her books, set in the Canadian West and this book is no different.
Beth is an amazing young woman. She comes from a privileged family and chose in the first book in this series, Where Courage Calls (make sure to read this one first,) to teach school to a group in the Canadian West. In this book, she's just come home. She's ready for some downtime with her family, and she wants to take some time to discover just how she feels about Canadian Mountie Jarrick. But her family has made other plans. Her father is headed to South America on business, and the rest of the family is headed on a cruise down the East Coast of North America.
I really enjoyed this book. I enjoyed Beth's view of how the cruise was, it's interesting to me the way things were different in a far different time than our own. I enjoyed Beth's family, her mother is truly a lady, I loved the concern she showed for the way that her girls were acting that she didn't feel seemly. Beth's sister Margret was also a great woman, I love the way that her son JW almost steals the entire book because he's so cute! And Julie, I loved her character. So trusting and generous to a fault, I was hoping that she didn't have problems because of her generosity. The ending of this book is worth waiting for!
Beth is an amazing young woman. She comes from a privileged family and chose in the first book in this series, Where Courage Calls (make sure to read this one first,) to teach school to a group in the Canadian West. In this book, she's just come home. She's ready for some downtime with her family, and she wants to take some time to discover just how she feels about Canadian Mountie Jarrick. But her family has made other plans. Her father is headed to South America on business, and the rest of the family is headed on a cruise down the East Coast of North America.
I really enjoyed this book. I enjoyed Beth's view of how the cruise was, it's interesting to me the way things were different in a far different time than our own. I enjoyed Beth's family, her mother is truly a lady, I loved the concern she showed for the way that her girls were acting that she didn't feel seemly. Beth's sister Margret was also a great woman, I love the way that her son JW almost steals the entire book because he's so cute! And Julie, I loved her character. So trusting and generous to a fault, I was hoping that she didn't have problems because of her generosity. The ending of this book is worth waiting for!
November 28, 2015
Elizabeth Thatcher returns home awaiting notice if her teaching
contract in Coal Valley will be renewed. Coal Valley is a small
western mining town where she taught the previous year. Beth
has a romantic interest there also.
Upon arriving home, she learns her mother & sisters have
planned a summer cruise. The cruise will encompass Quebec to
Prince Edward Island, Nova Scotia, Boston, New York and
Florida.
Never having been on a cruise myself, this will an enjoy sail
seen through the eyes of Elizabeth. The story presented the ups
and down of life on a cruise ship. You will learn about the way
the ship docks in various towns of interest for the passengers to
disembark to visit the site and stores in each town.
The scenery from both on & off the ships was described vividly
that you felt you were there. I love the whale watching scenes.
The author presented the relationships between the family
members and supporting characters. Some qualities that stood
out were abundant love, forgiveness, faith and trust and prayer
of all involved.
Although historical fiction, the author captured the attitudes
plus social realities of the times. The story also provides
mystery, suspense and drama.
This is the second book in Return to the Canadian West Series.
It can be read as a stand alone.
Thank you to book fun.org for this Book. My opinion is my own.
contract in Coal Valley will be renewed. Coal Valley is a small
western mining town where she taught the previous year. Beth
has a romantic interest there also.
Upon arriving home, she learns her mother & sisters have
planned a summer cruise. The cruise will encompass Quebec to
Prince Edward Island, Nova Scotia, Boston, New York and
Florida.
Never having been on a cruise myself, this will an enjoy sail
seen through the eyes of Elizabeth. The story presented the ups
and down of life on a cruise ship. You will learn about the way
the ship docks in various towns of interest for the passengers to
disembark to visit the site and stores in each town.
The scenery from both on & off the ships was described vividly
that you felt you were there. I love the whale watching scenes.
The author presented the relationships between the family
members and supporting characters. Some qualities that stood
out were abundant love, forgiveness, faith and trust and prayer
of all involved.
Although historical fiction, the author captured the attitudes
plus social realities of the times. The story also provides
mystery, suspense and drama.
This is the second book in Return to the Canadian West Series.
It can be read as a stand alone.
Thank you to book fun.org for this Book. My opinion is my own.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 239 reviews