What do you think?
Rate this book
Scoring the Player
Returning from an injury, pro basketball player Salem “The Silencer” Jones is ready to resume being the best defender in the league. A league that now has an openly gay player—and not just any player but Salem’s long-time, secret crush—Arnaz Cade. He soon discovers that defending his shot with Arnaz, suddenly one of the most sought-after bachelors, might be his biggest challenge yet.
Big challenges call for big plays, like shooting his shot at a nationally televised press conference.
Go big to get the guy, right?
When it comes to romantic love, it’s a hard pass for Arnaz. Since coming out as gay, his face and name are plastered everywhere. He plans to lie low, chase championship rings, and avoid anything deeper than a one-night stand. Except there’s a gorgeous baller hellbent on scoring a shot with him, slowly breaking down Arnaz’s defenses.
Will Arnaz surrender to love or retreat deeper into his demons?
Scoring the Player is book two in the MM sports romance Chasing Rings series. Each book ends with a happily ever after, can be read as a standalone, and features a new couple.
Big challenges call for big plays, like shooting his shot at a nationally televised press conference.
Go big to get the guy, right?
When it comes to romantic love, it’s a hard pass for Arnaz. Since coming out as gay, his face and name are plastered everywhere. He plans to lie low, chase championship rings, and avoid anything deeper than a one-night stand. Except there’s a gorgeous baller hellbent on scoring a shot with him, slowly breaking down Arnaz’s defenses.
Will Arnaz surrender to love or retreat deeper into his demons?
Scoring the Player is book two in the MM sports romance Chasing Rings series. Each book ends with a happily ever after, can be read as a standalone, and features a new couple.
570 pages, Kindle Edition
Published July 25, 2025
150 people are currently reading
610 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 150 reviews
July 18, 2025
Scoring the Player is a heartfelt romance between athletes Salem, the Silencer, and Arnaz, Blue. They are two complex individuals who are deeply connected. Salem is friendly, outgoing, and open about his feelings, while Arnaz is shy, introverted, and haunted by his past. Together, they embark on a journey of self-acceptance, healing from past traumas, and learning to connect and trust the person they love most.
This story does a wonderful job of addressing difficult topics like mental health, acknowledging past trauma, and the process of healing and overcoming pain. Both Salem and Arnaz are affected by their pasts, which directly influence their present. I appreciate how both characters are learning how to navigate their relationship with all its bumps along the way.
Salem is a warm, emotionally intelligent, and patient partner for Arnaz. Arnaz loves deeply, but his past causes him to stumble quite often when handling delicate situations. Together, they really bring out the best in each other. They are both so naturally connected that watching them fall for one another is so easy and adorable to see.
Overall, this is a beautiful, emotional story that is both poignant and impactful. These two are soulmates, and watching them succumb to their feelings for one another while learning to trust and lean into their love has been a wonderful journey to witness.
*** I reviewed a complimentary copy of this story.***
This story does a wonderful job of addressing difficult topics like mental health, acknowledging past trauma, and the process of healing and overcoming pain. Both Salem and Arnaz are affected by their pasts, which directly influence their present. I appreciate how both characters are learning how to navigate their relationship with all its bumps along the way.
Salem is a warm, emotionally intelligent, and patient partner for Arnaz. Arnaz loves deeply, but his past causes him to stumble quite often when handling delicate situations. Together, they really bring out the best in each other. They are both so naturally connected that watching them fall for one another is so easy and adorable to see.
Overall, this is a beautiful, emotional story that is both poignant and impactful. These two are soulmates, and watching them succumb to their feelings for one another while learning to trust and lean into their love has been a wonderful journey to witness.
*** I reviewed a complimentary copy of this story.***
July 27, 2025
I’m so disappointed. I came in ready to love this book. Loving the Legend had everything. Emotional sincerity, blistering chemistry, a story that felt urgent and intentional. Sid and Ty made me care. Every scene felt alive. So I expected this one to stir something in me too. Anything, really. But what I got instead was a romance that felt hollow. Emotionally vacant.
Something felt off almost immediately. It’s not like Arnaz and Salem were completely flat. I saw what the author was reaching for. Arnaz carries trauma and depression. Salem is meant to be the calm, patient constant. That should work. On paper, it’s a great setup for a slow burn with weight. But the actual connection? Nothing. It felt forced. Like I was being told they were in love before I had any reason to believe it. I kept waiting for a moment to pull me in. It never came.
And then came the infamous “I waited five years for you” line. That was supposed to gut me. Instead, I stared at the page thinking, waited where? In Lucien’s bed? Don’t try to sell me pining when the man was physically and emotionally wrapped up in someone else the whole time. That line doesn’t land. It collapses under context. If Salem had a lingering crush and moved on, say that. But don’t feed me this half-hearted devotion and expect it to hit.
Which brings me to Lucien.
Lucien is not in the book constantly. But the moments he does show up? They’re some of the worst. He isn’t just the best friend. He’s also the hookup. The fallback. The guy who gets name-dropped during scenes that are supposed to center Salem and Arnaz. I guess it’s meant to be edgy or refreshing that there were no romantic feelings involved. But it’s not. It feels like the author crammed every possible side character role into one person to save space. That’s not clever. That’s just lazy. And it drags the actual romance down with it.
Every time Lucien comes up, the tone shifts. The fragile emotional thread between Salem and Arnaz snaps under the weight of a completely different dynamic. And it never adds anything. It just reminds me that there’s a third person floating around who was deeply entangled with Salem in a way that overshadows everything else.
Take this scene:
“You’ve already forgotten the French I taught you?”
“I remember the important words.”
“And what might those be?”
“Putain de merde, je veux plus, oh putain,” I rattled off.
He chuckled. “The words you made me scream during sex are the important words? I said I miss you, and I’m jealous.”
That’s not just a throwaway joke. That’s our introduction to Lucien. That’s the first thing the book wants us to know about their relationship. Not a memory. Not a real conversation. Just a reminder of their loud, casual sex. And we’re supposed to believe they’re just friends now. That it’s all in the past. So why is the first impression built entirely on what Lucien used to scream? Why is that the foundation? It doesn’t make their bond feel real. It doesn’t feel close. It just feels like the book wants to flaunt this dynamic and pretend it’s meaningful. It isn’t. It’s exhausting.
And then, this line killed whatever patience I had left:
“He looks pointedly at the cloth. It takes me a second to realize what he’s asking. I did this for Lucien all the time. ‘Have your partners never done this for you?’”
Why is Lucien still in this moment? Why, right after sleeping with Arnaz, is Salem thinking about Lucien? Why is he comparing this to what he used to do for someone else? It sucks all the intimacy out of the scene. It doesn’t matter that we’ve already been told about their past. Salem thinking about Lucien here just flattens whatever emotional build-up there was. The book acts like this isn’t jarring. Like this name-drop didn’t kill the mood entirely. It did, and after that, I stopped caring entirely. I only finished the book to write the review.
By the end, I didn’t feel moved. I didn’t feel connected. I just felt tired.
Something felt off almost immediately. It’s not like Arnaz and Salem were completely flat. I saw what the author was reaching for. Arnaz carries trauma and depression. Salem is meant to be the calm, patient constant. That should work. On paper, it’s a great setup for a slow burn with weight. But the actual connection? Nothing. It felt forced. Like I was being told they were in love before I had any reason to believe it. I kept waiting for a moment to pull me in. It never came.
And then came the infamous “I waited five years for you” line. That was supposed to gut me. Instead, I stared at the page thinking, waited where? In Lucien’s bed? Don’t try to sell me pining when the man was physically and emotionally wrapped up in someone else the whole time. That line doesn’t land. It collapses under context. If Salem had a lingering crush and moved on, say that. But don’t feed me this half-hearted devotion and expect it to hit.
Which brings me to Lucien.
Lucien is not in the book constantly. But the moments he does show up? They’re some of the worst. He isn’t just the best friend. He’s also the hookup. The fallback. The guy who gets name-dropped during scenes that are supposed to center Salem and Arnaz. I guess it’s meant to be edgy or refreshing that there were no romantic feelings involved. But it’s not. It feels like the author crammed every possible side character role into one person to save space. That’s not clever. That’s just lazy. And it drags the actual romance down with it.
Every time Lucien comes up, the tone shifts. The fragile emotional thread between Salem and Arnaz snaps under the weight of a completely different dynamic. And it never adds anything. It just reminds me that there’s a third person floating around who was deeply entangled with Salem in a way that overshadows everything else.
Take this scene:
“You’ve already forgotten the French I taught you?”
“I remember the important words.”
“And what might those be?”
“Putain de merde, je veux plus, oh putain,” I rattled off.
He chuckled. “The words you made me scream during sex are the important words? I said I miss you, and I’m jealous.”
That’s not just a throwaway joke. That’s our introduction to Lucien. That’s the first thing the book wants us to know about their relationship. Not a memory. Not a real conversation. Just a reminder of their loud, casual sex. And we’re supposed to believe they’re just friends now. That it’s all in the past. So why is the first impression built entirely on what Lucien used to scream? Why is that the foundation? It doesn’t make their bond feel real. It doesn’t feel close. It just feels like the book wants to flaunt this dynamic and pretend it’s meaningful. It isn’t. It’s exhausting.
And then, this line killed whatever patience I had left:
“He looks pointedly at the cloth. It takes me a second to realize what he’s asking. I did this for Lucien all the time. ‘Have your partners never done this for you?’”
Why is Lucien still in this moment? Why, right after sleeping with Arnaz, is Salem thinking about Lucien? Why is he comparing this to what he used to do for someone else? It sucks all the intimacy out of the scene. It doesn’t matter that we’ve already been told about their past. Salem thinking about Lucien here just flattens whatever emotional build-up there was. The book acts like this isn’t jarring. Like this name-drop didn’t kill the mood entirely. It did, and after that, I stopped caring entirely. I only finished the book to write the review.
By the end, I didn’t feel moved. I didn’t feel connected. I just felt tired.
August 3, 2025
It was something different about Arnaz and Salem. Idk I didn’t connect with this couple but I did like how layered the trauma was with these characters.
July 16, 2025
Such an amazing, emotional read. I completely devoured this book, I loved Salem and Arnaz straight from the start and I couldn’t put it down. This has easily become one of my top reads of the year, and one I will be rereading soon. If you like hurt/comfort, rivals to lovers, pining and so much heat 🥵 then I highly recommend reading Scoring the Player.
July 19, 2025
To say that I loved this book would be an understatement, am I surprised I loved it? Absolutely not. Kit Grey’s rich, radiant, intensely passionate writing style will always resonate with me and Salem and Arnaz’s story was no different. They’ve carved a place in my heart right alongside Ty and Sid just like I knew they would.
Arnaz was such a richly nuanced character, behind the angry shell was a deeply troubled, intensely feeling man that was written in a way that was messy, frustrating, complicated and complex. The author’s considerate and honest way of writing Arnaz showed how the state of our mental health can drive us to lash out, hide away and burrow deep within our hearts and minds to protect ourselves, even from things that would bring us much needed healing and joy. His journey wasn’t linear, it was fraught with self doubt, self loathing and a carefully hidden hope that someone would be patient enough to see that he was trying to reach out for…a lifeline. He got the lifeline that he deserved and more in Salem 🥹
Salem…sweet, sexy, patient, incandescent Salem. What a man 😍 The way I loved this fictional man should be worrying but honestly who would blame me? His emotional intelligence was legendary he was as considerate as he was aware of when to reach out or pull back. His indulgent patience was so swoon-worthy but he was never reduced to becoming a doormat or cruel when giving Arnaz the distance that he requested while keeping his dignity intact. He was equal parts feral dominant leader and compassionate soft caretaker. He didn’t have to choose because he was always both. I could write a hundred more paragraphs about how amazing Salem’s character is but we’d be here for 300 business days if I continued 🤣
Now let me get into the spice because my friends, it was some of the best smut I’ve read this year. Sexy, sensual, emotional, resonant every time these two came together was scorching hot 🥵 Arnaz’s transformations during sensual scenes was something I did not expect and it didn’t not disappoint…I may have drooled once or twice but whose counting 👀
This love story between two fierce, beautiful, complex, sensitive, Black men was a gorgeously written love letter to Black men everywhere. Showing that they are multifaceted and layered, sensitive and deeply feeling and so very deserving of stories that show them in the light they deserve to be seen in. I am a forever fan of Kit Grey, I will never stop being awestruck by this author’s stunning gift for beautiful, passionate stories that they continue to give the world. 🤎
Arnaz was such a richly nuanced character, behind the angry shell was a deeply troubled, intensely feeling man that was written in a way that was messy, frustrating, complicated and complex. The author’s considerate and honest way of writing Arnaz showed how the state of our mental health can drive us to lash out, hide away and burrow deep within our hearts and minds to protect ourselves, even from things that would bring us much needed healing and joy. His journey wasn’t linear, it was fraught with self doubt, self loathing and a carefully hidden hope that someone would be patient enough to see that he was trying to reach out for…a lifeline. He got the lifeline that he deserved and more in Salem 🥹
Salem…sweet, sexy, patient, incandescent Salem. What a man 😍 The way I loved this fictional man should be worrying but honestly who would blame me? His emotional intelligence was legendary he was as considerate as he was aware of when to reach out or pull back. His indulgent patience was so swoon-worthy but he was never reduced to becoming a doormat or cruel when giving Arnaz the distance that he requested while keeping his dignity intact. He was equal parts feral dominant leader and compassionate soft caretaker. He didn’t have to choose because he was always both. I could write a hundred more paragraphs about how amazing Salem’s character is but we’d be here for 300 business days if I continued 🤣
Now let me get into the spice because my friends, it was some of the best smut I’ve read this year. Sexy, sensual, emotional, resonant every time these two came together was scorching hot 🥵 Arnaz’s transformations during sensual scenes was something I did not expect and it didn’t not disappoint…I may have drooled once or twice but whose counting 👀
This love story between two fierce, beautiful, complex, sensitive, Black men was a gorgeously written love letter to Black men everywhere. Showing that they are multifaceted and layered, sensitive and deeply feeling and so very deserving of stories that show them in the light they deserve to be seen in. I am a forever fan of Kit Grey, I will never stop being awestruck by this author’s stunning gift for beautiful, passionate stories that they continue to give the world. 🤎
July 19, 2025
Scoring The Player is book two in the Chasing Rings series. This MM basketball romance story is about Arnaz and Salem.
We first met Arnaz as Sid’s teammate and best friend in Loving The Legend, but he was not what I expected him to be when it came to his story. My heart broke for Arnaz after learning about his painful past and how much it has affected his life. He has built his walls high and doesn’t date. This certainly makes things challenging for Salem when he shoots his shot with Arnaz and admits he has had a secret crush on him for years. Salem is ready to go all in and doesn’t hold back, but Arnaz is afraid and we see the struggles he faces.
Arnaz and Salem fight both on and off the court, and they take us through their ups and downs. They both have family struggles. Their journey was not easy and it had me feeling so many different emotions along the way. The hurt/comfort and mental health rep was so well written. Arnaz and Salem fought hard for their HEA, and I was so captivated by their beautiful love story.
I received an advanced copy of this book, and this is my honest review.
We first met Arnaz as Sid’s teammate and best friend in Loving The Legend, but he was not what I expected him to be when it came to his story. My heart broke for Arnaz after learning about his painful past and how much it has affected his life. He has built his walls high and doesn’t date. This certainly makes things challenging for Salem when he shoots his shot with Arnaz and admits he has had a secret crush on him for years. Salem is ready to go all in and doesn’t hold back, but Arnaz is afraid and we see the struggles he faces.
Arnaz and Salem fight both on and off the court, and they take us through their ups and downs. They both have family struggles. Their journey was not easy and it had me feeling so many different emotions along the way. The hurt/comfort and mental health rep was so well written. Arnaz and Salem fought hard for their HEA, and I was so captivated by their beautiful love story.
I received an advanced copy of this book, and this is my honest review.
July 15, 2025
"Sometimes I think you're the only person who will ever know me. Like really know me."
Whew.
*cracks knuckles*
Buckle up, y'all, I have a LOT to say about this book. It was such a tender, beautiful love story, I love to see black men be happy, playing ball, and healing trauma. Kit's books are seriously amazing for that.
Truly loved the basketball scenes, the cars, the homes. The writing style is a balance between prose and almost active verbiage? I'm not sure how to describe it, but it feels like Kit makes their characters move. Or uses words that create images in your head. I. eat. that. shit. UP.
There is something just so hnnngggghhh about Salem's pursuit of Arnaz. The well placed "baby"s? Glorious. The sex scenes were great, but the aftercare? Sold. The cake was great, but that letter? Oh baby!
Alright. Let's start with the accurate and healthy depiction of a relationship that involves a person with mental illness.
The MC is actively in trauma informed therapy, has a diagnoses, takes medications, and communicates this to his partner early on in the book.
Observe:
"I'm on meds." I nod. "I'll do my own research, but will you tell me what it's like?" His brows crease. "What it's like?" "To be you." I lean up and kiss his cheek.
THIS is how you respond to someone you're interested in that is concerned you aren't capable of the reality that is living with mental illness. Now the reason I appreciate that the MC is receiving treatment is because much of this book he's in an active pervasive state of depression and anxiety. The author does an amazing job of showing the ebb and flow.
As someone diagnosed with CPTSD and in active EMDR therapy, I found the therapy scenes to be done well without being overly descriptive, it felt like we were still in Arnaz's head experiencing therapy and not in the author's head listening to them explain all the things they learned about therapy while writing this book, if that makes sense? I loved that aspect of the book, the representation, it's also what drew me to Loving the Legend. It is cathartic for me to read books with a lot of hurt comfort and depression/anxiety because when done well I feel SEEN as well.
I marked so many quotes and moments in this book that I just loved to see. Similar to Loving the Legend, and what made me love it so much, is the way Kit allows the characters to love and be loving, set the tone or I guess the scene for who they are and what they're like through their clothes, dialogue, and physical movements. I feel this is soooo rare in a book and drew me immediately into LtL and StP.
For example:
In chapter 50 pg 400, when Salem is telling Arnaz to get the bump on his head checked? That's exactly the kind of "show not tell" I love to see in a book. When an author can use the characters actions and words to get a point across without just laying it all out in dialogue or internal monologue, I am one happy reader.
To me that scene showed consistency of character in who Salem claims to be. They are in the midst of a challenge/breaking point in their burgeoning relationship and even though Salem is angry and can't handle any extra emotional turmoil because of what he's going through, he still loves Arnaz and shows him that he cares about all the parts of him even when he's not happy with him. On the other side we're continuing to see that Arnaz who was raised in a home where the people who were supposed to care about him didn't, doesn't immediately register getting hurt/being in pain as something that should be addressed. To me this is a very consistent and realistic side effect of this specific type of trauma.
Again, this author does an incredible job of showing consistency in a character while also being informed on the topic they're covering.
Another example: Chp 55, pg 435 "I carried shame for years for needing anything from you." I stare at Mom. "And you."
Perhaps this is a lived experience for the author, or their research is just that good, but having grown up in a similarly abusive environment, I've never before seen this exact emotion shown with this level of accuracy. Safe to say I'll be taking this to my therapist as an example of how I felt in those past times.
And on a more subtle note, the way Kit describes Arnaz's home and his sister's, for those of us who did grow up with parental trauma/abuse, whew. So accurate. It's so deeply uncomfortable and difficult when you realize that when everyone else was growing a personality and feeling out likes and dislikes, you were focused on survival and not rocking the boat. Love all the nods to that experience.
On a lighter note!
I found myself chuckling/giggling whatever you want to call it quite often. I love Kit's humor, tone, and timing! My favorite two lines have got to be, "Denzel, how do you like vampires?" and "That's like a Tuesday night for you."
My only semi critical feedback is that I would have liked to see Arnaz and Salem talk more about the anxiety, depression, mental health etc. I felt like we didn't really get enough of a big talk between them without it being broken up by fighting or sex. I still think this is a four star book, but I did have this issue with Loving the Legend as well.
However I DID notice this book was even more well done that LtL and Kit does a great job of telling their story as it's ending, but if I could change one thing it'd be that we get more time with the couple while they settle their issues and THEN the jump ahead in time. Regardless, I loved every minute of this book and I'm already dying for whatever comes next.
Whew.
*cracks knuckles*
Buckle up, y'all, I have a LOT to say about this book. It was such a tender, beautiful love story, I love to see black men be happy, playing ball, and healing trauma. Kit's books are seriously amazing for that.
Truly loved the basketball scenes, the cars, the homes. The writing style is a balance between prose and almost active verbiage? I'm not sure how to describe it, but it feels like Kit makes their characters move. Or uses words that create images in your head. I. eat. that. shit. UP.
There is something just so hnnngggghhh about Salem's pursuit of Arnaz. The well placed "baby"s? Glorious. The sex scenes were great, but the aftercare? Sold. The cake was great, but that letter? Oh baby!
Alright. Let's start with the accurate and healthy depiction of a relationship that involves a person with mental illness.
The MC is actively in trauma informed therapy, has a diagnoses, takes medications, and communicates this to his partner early on in the book.
Observe:
"I'm on meds." I nod. "I'll do my own research, but will you tell me what it's like?" His brows crease. "What it's like?" "To be you." I lean up and kiss his cheek.
THIS is how you respond to someone you're interested in that is concerned you aren't capable of the reality that is living with mental illness. Now the reason I appreciate that the MC is receiving treatment is because much of this book he's in an active pervasive state of depression and anxiety. The author does an amazing job of showing the ebb and flow.
As someone diagnosed with CPTSD and in active EMDR therapy, I found the therapy scenes to be done well without being overly descriptive, it felt like we were still in Arnaz's head experiencing therapy and not in the author's head listening to them explain all the things they learned about therapy while writing this book, if that makes sense? I loved that aspect of the book, the representation, it's also what drew me to Loving the Legend. It is cathartic for me to read books with a lot of hurt comfort and depression/anxiety because when done well I feel SEEN as well.
I marked so many quotes and moments in this book that I just loved to see. Similar to Loving the Legend, and what made me love it so much, is the way Kit allows the characters to love and be loving, set the tone or I guess the scene for who they are and what they're like through their clothes, dialogue, and physical movements. I feel this is soooo rare in a book and drew me immediately into LtL and StP.
For example:
In chapter 50 pg 400, when Salem is telling Arnaz to get the bump on his head checked? That's exactly the kind of "show not tell" I love to see in a book. When an author can use the characters actions and words to get a point across without just laying it all out in dialogue or internal monologue, I am one happy reader.
To me that scene showed consistency of character in who Salem claims to be. They are in the midst of a challenge/breaking point in their burgeoning relationship and even though Salem is angry and can't handle any extra emotional turmoil because of what he's going through, he still loves Arnaz and shows him that he cares about all the parts of him even when he's not happy with him. On the other side we're continuing to see that Arnaz who was raised in a home where the people who were supposed to care about him didn't, doesn't immediately register getting hurt/being in pain as something that should be addressed. To me this is a very consistent and realistic side effect of this specific type of trauma.
Again, this author does an incredible job of showing consistency in a character while also being informed on the topic they're covering.
Another example: Chp 55, pg 435 "I carried shame for years for needing anything from you." I stare at Mom. "And you."
Perhaps this is a lived experience for the author, or their research is just that good, but having grown up in a similarly abusive environment, I've never before seen this exact emotion shown with this level of accuracy. Safe to say I'll be taking this to my therapist as an example of how I felt in those past times.
And on a more subtle note, the way Kit describes Arnaz's home and his sister's, for those of us who did grow up with parental trauma/abuse, whew. So accurate. It's so deeply uncomfortable and difficult when you realize that when everyone else was growing a personality and feeling out likes and dislikes, you were focused on survival and not rocking the boat. Love all the nods to that experience.
On a lighter note!
I found myself chuckling/giggling whatever you want to call it quite often. I love Kit's humor, tone, and timing! My favorite two lines have got to be, "Denzel, how do you like vampires?" and "That's like a Tuesday night for you."
My only semi critical feedback is that I would have liked to see Arnaz and Salem talk more about the anxiety, depression, mental health etc. I felt like we didn't really get enough of a big talk between them without it being broken up by fighting or sex. I still think this is a four star book, but I did have this issue with Loving the Legend as well.
However I DID notice this book was even more well done that LtL and Kit does a great job of telling their story as it's ending, but if I could change one thing it'd be that we get more time with the couple while they settle their issues and THEN the jump ahead in time. Regardless, I loved every minute of this book and I'm already dying for whatever comes next.
July 31, 2025
I absolutely loved the first book, it’s honestly one of my favorite book of all time! The love between Sid and Ty felt genuine and infinite. Here, I didn’t feel that with Salem and Arnaz. I didn’t get the soulmate vibe from them. It just felt like a crush. When Sid and Ty fought and « separated » we knew they will end up together. That they were endgame. They both were thinking about the other and were miserable. When we learned that Sid bought the ring when they were separated, I honestly squealed. Unfortunately, I didn’t feel the same with Salem and Arnaz. I felt like if they separated they will be fine, that they will move on easly. Sid would have never left Ty, even when things were complicated he never thought of leaving him. Here, Salem didn’t even let Arnaz explain and he just left, saying that he needed to focus on his family. Hello ?? So all this was for nothing ??? Saying that He waited 5 years for him and then leave at the first inconvenience? I found him hypocrite being mad that Arnaz was in « love » with the other guy when HE went to see his ex and let him kiss him knowing them well that Arnaz doesn’t like him. Sid would never 😌
Anyway, why was Lucien here ? What was the point of adding him in the book ?
I would have loved some jealousy scenes from Salem but we got nothing, I was really disappointed with that.
Maybe the problem is the fact that it’s in 2 POV, maybe if it was only from Arnaz POV I would’ve felt differently. In loving the legend, the fact that it was only from Ty’s POV the author had no other choice than to show the love that Sid had for Ty. In STP, since it was dual POV there was more saying than showing. That’s why I don’t really like dual POV.
I know I compare a lot with LTL, but I just can’t help it. I love Sid and Ty so much. They were really the perfect couple, and Sid the perfect boyfriend !!
Anyway, I will still continue to read books from this author because I know she can write great books. Let’s just hope that the next one will be better than this one 🤞
Anyway, why was Lucien here ? What was the point of adding him in the book ?
I would have loved some jealousy scenes from Salem but we got nothing, I was really disappointed with that.
Maybe the problem is the fact that it’s in 2 POV, maybe if it was only from Arnaz POV I would’ve felt differently. In loving the legend, the fact that it was only from Ty’s POV the author had no other choice than to show the love that Sid had for Ty. In STP, since it was dual POV there was more saying than showing. That’s why I don’t really like dual POV.
I know I compare a lot with LTL, but I just can’t help it. I love Sid and Ty so much. They were really the perfect couple, and Sid the perfect boyfriend !!
Anyway, I will still continue to read books from this author because I know she can write great books. Let’s just hope that the next one will be better than this one 🤞
July 25, 2025
Another beautiful story by Kit Grey! Loved getting to know Arnaz & Salem. Great enemies to lovers vibes. Both have family struggles. So much pining. Loved all of it. Read this book!
September 22, 2025
About me: Black woman, hoops and hip hop lover AND old school MM reader (think Torquere Press era). I stopped reading MM when I realized that Black folks were at best an after thought and most often non-existent in MM World. Even when Black people were mentioned it was clear almost no research or familiarity existed and contributions from Black culture - style, music etc went unacknowledged.
Hip-hop is the most popular genre of music in the world and has been so for more than 20 years yet in MM World 25 year olds are getting hype to obscure pop bands like the Spin Doctors (true story! name the book!) I would always joke that a major clue that some middle aged WW was writing the book would be having the young guy vibing to some old White musician. Even when MM books try to be current their point of reference would be someone like Gaga. Rappers are touring stadiums and the focus of major museum shows and covering magazines - like How Sway? Hip hop is 50 years old and definitely not niche.
Anyway, imagine my surprise when my friends kept mentioning this book (Loving the Legend) that was well written, engaging and starring two ballers. Despite the improbable sex scenes (the extreme duration, the locations (two closeted NBA players would NEVER have sex in a sports car in an F1 raceway parking lot) and just the random details (like an NBA ROTY running out for ice or drinking a beer when these guys see themselves as aesthetes and have assistants/shoppers/stylists etc.). I liked Loving the Legend and the chemistry between Sid and Ty was tangible and well-done so I was really excited about Scoring the Player.
For the most part, I liked StP especially the core love story between Salem and Arnaz. I think the characters were well drawn, the chemistry was palpable and the conflict was interesting. The author clearly took care to be reflective and empathetic of mental health.
The author is a good writer however the writing got so overwrought I just couldn’t deal anymore and started skipping parts. So! Many! Metaphors! Ms Kit is not just an authoress but a poetess as well lol. Imma need her editors and betas to step up next time please. Also I wish the author had cut some of the odd characters and storylines (dog walker, the random phone call to the agent) and focused on writing the conflicts better (the relationship between Arnaz and his parents could have used some clarifying, the radio show could have been a better plot device (imagine a NBA star publicly shooting his shot then getting blocked. The hoop shows/creators and social media would have had a field day. Black/sports roasting culture would have been fun to see rather than another yet another homophobia storyline. Despite all that, I was locked in and looking forward to the HEA. Unfortunately though the author killed my enjoyment of the book with a totally unnecessary mention of a particular kink which did nothing to enhance the story and totally degraded the characters. It did not ring true to them AT ALL and I was jolted by the mention. Thankfully it was very brief so I continued and finished the book and the ending was fine albeit rushed but man did that kill my vibe.
Hip-hop is the most popular genre of music in the world and has been so for more than 20 years yet in MM World 25 year olds are getting hype to obscure pop bands like the Spin Doctors (true story! name the book!) I would always joke that a major clue that some middle aged WW was writing the book would be having the young guy vibing to some old White musician. Even when MM books try to be current their point of reference would be someone like Gaga. Rappers are touring stadiums and the focus of major museum shows and covering magazines - like How Sway? Hip hop is 50 years old and definitely not niche.
Anyway, imagine my surprise when my friends kept mentioning this book (Loving the Legend) that was well written, engaging and starring two ballers. Despite the improbable sex scenes (the extreme duration, the locations (two closeted NBA players would NEVER have sex in a sports car in an F1 raceway parking lot) and just the random details (like an NBA ROTY running out for ice or drinking a beer when these guys see themselves as aesthetes and have assistants/shoppers/stylists etc.). I liked Loving the Legend and the chemistry between Sid and Ty was tangible and well-done so I was really excited about Scoring the Player.
For the most part, I liked StP especially the core love story between Salem and Arnaz. I think the characters were well drawn, the chemistry was palpable and the conflict was interesting. The author clearly took care to be reflective and empathetic of mental health.
The author is a good writer however the writing got so overwrought I just couldn’t deal anymore and started skipping parts. So! Many! Metaphors! Ms Kit is not just an authoress but a poetess as well lol. Imma need her editors and betas to step up next time please. Also I wish the author had cut some of the odd characters and storylines (dog walker, the random phone call to the agent) and focused on writing the conflicts better (the relationship between Arnaz and his parents could have used some clarifying, the radio show could have been a better plot device (imagine a NBA star publicly shooting his shot then getting blocked. The hoop shows/creators and social media would have had a field day. Black/sports roasting culture would have been fun to see rather than another yet another homophobia storyline. Despite all that, I was locked in and looking forward to the HEA. Unfortunately though the author killed my enjoyment of the book with a totally unnecessary mention of a particular kink which did nothing to enhance the story and totally degraded the characters. It did not ring true to them AT ALL and I was jolted by the mention. Thankfully it was very brief so I continued and finished the book and the ending was fine albeit rushed but man did that kill my vibe.
August 21, 2025
Coming back to say that I think about this book at least 3 times a day. I don’t know what that’s worth but this series is my holy grail.
July 15, 2025
Kit Grey has done it again. No amount of words can truly describe how life changing this book is. This book made me cry, smile, and feel all the emotions. Kit Grey is amazing at writing characters that make them feel so real. The way the author writes about mental health is so raw and important. Being in Arnaz’s head while reading was truly heart wrenching. My heart truly broke for him and the things he went through and struggle with. His character really moved me and his story will be stuck with me forever. Salem is just a sweetheart. The way he pursued Arnaz and him being his not so secret admirer was so heartwarming. All he wanted was to shoot his shot with Arnaz and I loved his courage and bravery to put himself out there.
Arnaz and Salem together was everything. Their journey wasn’t easy and their backgrounds may be different, Arnaz was struggling with his mental health and Salem was struggling to learn patience and understanding. They both had the fear of being happy and falling in love but there was so much yearning. Their relationship was about healing and learning how to truly go after their own happily ever after no matter the struggles they went through. They might be different, and their love is messy but their journey to their HEA was so rewarding and beautiful.
Overall, Scoring The Player is such a beautiful book and I am so honored to have read the ARC. This book and the characters are so real, raw and will truly move you emotionally. This book can be read as a stand-alone, however there are characters and events from Loving The Legend that are mentioned and you should definitely read that book first because Scoring The Player starts off where Loving The Legend ends. Please also check the trigger warnings since this book talks about heavy topics. And thank you to the author for the ARC to read and review.
Arnaz and Salem together was everything. Their journey wasn’t easy and their backgrounds may be different, Arnaz was struggling with his mental health and Salem was struggling to learn patience and understanding. They both had the fear of being happy and falling in love but there was so much yearning. Their relationship was about healing and learning how to truly go after their own happily ever after no matter the struggles they went through. They might be different, and their love is messy but their journey to their HEA was so rewarding and beautiful.
Overall, Scoring The Player is such a beautiful book and I am so honored to have read the ARC. This book and the characters are so real, raw and will truly move you emotionally. This book can be read as a stand-alone, however there are characters and events from Loving The Legend that are mentioned and you should definitely read that book first because Scoring The Player starts off where Loving The Legend ends. Please also check the trigger warnings since this book talks about heavy topics. And thank you to the author for the ARC to read and review.
July 13, 2025
4.25⭐️
There’s something about how Kit Grey writes mental health that feels raw to me. Blue(Arnanz)and Salem are so very real to me.
Arnanz is a sweet heart underneath all the haunting sadness, he is truly a sweetie who loves hard and doesn’t even know what love he deserves. Salem knows the love he deserves but also knows the love Blue deserves and when Salem slowly starts to take down the emotional walls that Blue had built up it was so heartwarming to read about. I loved getting introduced to new characters that add different elements to this story, specifically their families. Salems family is this loving and warm family that I think we all would love to have vs Blue’s family where there’s a lot of hurt and pain woven into the family for years. What I thought was interesting and I loved is that the author showed is how regardless of how a family dynamic is no family is “perfect” there can still be pain even if your family is loving ( like Salem) or like Blue where it’s ummm complicated.
I just yeah I loved reading this book thank you so much to Kit Grey and their team for this ARC!!
There’s something about how Kit Grey writes mental health that feels raw to me. Blue(Arnanz)and Salem are so very real to me.
Arnanz is a sweet heart underneath all the haunting sadness, he is truly a sweetie who loves hard and doesn’t even know what love he deserves. Salem knows the love he deserves but also knows the love Blue deserves and when Salem slowly starts to take down the emotional walls that Blue had built up it was so heartwarming to read about. I loved getting introduced to new characters that add different elements to this story, specifically their families. Salems family is this loving and warm family that I think we all would love to have vs Blue’s family where there’s a lot of hurt and pain woven into the family for years. What I thought was interesting and I loved is that the author showed is how regardless of how a family dynamic is no family is “perfect” there can still be pain even if your family is loving ( like Salem) or like Blue where it’s ummm complicated.
I just yeah I loved reading this book thank you so much to Kit Grey and their team for this ARC!!
July 16, 2025
ARC REVIEW
I was so excited to read this book after getting the sneak peek in LTL and while I went in with a different mindset of what was going to happen I quickly realized this book was not at all what I thought it was going to be and I was not mad about it at all!
Kit’s writing was elevated so much in this book. The way Arnaz’s character is written is lyrical and hauntingly beautiful. You are in his mind and you feel what he feels.
Salem is so swoony and truly everything Arnaz needs.
I absolutely loved this book and the way Kit wrote about the mental health absolutely floored me in the best way!
This book comes out end of July and you absolutely do not want to miss this one!
I was so excited to read this book after getting the sneak peek in LTL and while I went in with a different mindset of what was going to happen I quickly realized this book was not at all what I thought it was going to be and I was not mad about it at all!
Kit’s writing was elevated so much in this book. The way Arnaz’s character is written is lyrical and hauntingly beautiful. You are in his mind and you feel what he feels.
Salem is so swoony and truly everything Arnaz needs.
I absolutely loved this book and the way Kit wrote about the mental health absolutely floored me in the best way!
This book comes out end of July and you absolutely do not want to miss this one!
August 10, 2025
I absolutely loved the first book! I knew it was going to be a 5 star read from the very beginning. The love story between Sid and Ty was amazing. Sadly I didn’t get that same feeling with this book. Salem and Arnaz didn’t have me swooning and in love with them like I felt with the 1st book. That being said I will for sure read more books from this author.
August 18, 2025
THIS BOOK WAS EMOTIONAL PERFECTION.
"Do you remember the last time you clocked me? I headbutted you, and then you choked me. Do you remember the first time? I don't know how to explain what happened to me that day. Or why a three-minute scuffle led to 1,895 days of unrelenting palm, neck and chest sweats whenever I think of you."
I knew I was going to like it, because I really enjoyed this author's debut "Loving the Legend," and reading the teaser in the back of that book for this one made me a little feral-- but I did not expect to love it with all of my heart and soul- this book made me SO EMOTIONAL, you guys! Kit nailed the mental health rep in "Loving the Legend-" that book had some of the most true-to-life depictions of depression I have ever read. She hit it out of the park here as well with Salem and Blue- I cried so hard experiencing Blue's struggles-- and because of how much that touched me, the way to Salem NEVER STOPPED TRYING made me all sorts of giddy and emotional and CRAZY IN LOVE WITH HIM.
From the very beginning of this book, I knew it was something special. The fact that Salem literally decided, on a whim, that the way he was going to come out was to "shoot his shot" on National TV with Arnaz- I was obsessed with him from that moment. And then.... when the cake appeared with the letter- I READ THE DAMN LETTER THREE TIMES. It was like something out of my most romantic dreams- who IS this guy, and what right does he have to be the SWOONIEST MAN EVER WRITTEN?! Yeah. That's him. HOLY WOW.
"I want you in all the ways I can have you. You have walls, and that's okay. Walls, too, are part of a home. I'll stand outside on devotional guard, so you don't have to work so hard to protect them."
And Arnaz- talk about a SHOCKER. We don't get to scratch the surface of who he is in "Loving the Legend," but it is safe to say I did NOT expect for him to be so broken. His past was absolutely devastating, and the way he struggled every single day- and I mean STRUGGLED- it was so well written. I am not sure I have ever read an author that wrote mental health struggles in a way that spoke to me as well as this author does. I felt what Blue was feeling in my bones- I was lying in bed sniffling while reading so I didn't wake my husband but I had such a hard time keeping my feels in check- he honestly broke my heart!
I just ADORED the very public, very relentless, very overt way that Salem pursued his man-- but at the beginning, when he was initially told "no," he backed off- because that's what a gentleman does. He continued to care, and continued to pay attention to EVERY LITTLE THING about Blue as their paths crossed-- but he let Blue come to HIM- damn. Consent is hot- especially when the tension is thick so thick and we have to WAIT for it.
AT it's heart, this is a beautiful hurt/comfort romance- which this author does so wonderfully. There is a found family growing here that makes my heart happy, and I can't WAIT to see more of these crazy boys find love. This series is absolutely amazing, and I am SO impressed with this author. I will read anything she writes- cant wait for the next one!
"Do you remember the last time you clocked me? I headbutted you, and then you choked me. Do you remember the first time? I don't know how to explain what happened to me that day. Or why a three-minute scuffle led to 1,895 days of unrelenting palm, neck and chest sweats whenever I think of you."
I knew I was going to like it, because I really enjoyed this author's debut "Loving the Legend," and reading the teaser in the back of that book for this one made me a little feral-- but I did not expect to love it with all of my heart and soul- this book made me SO EMOTIONAL, you guys! Kit nailed the mental health rep in "Loving the Legend-" that book had some of the most true-to-life depictions of depression I have ever read. She hit it out of the park here as well with Salem and Blue- I cried so hard experiencing Blue's struggles-- and because of how much that touched me, the way to Salem NEVER STOPPED TRYING made me all sorts of giddy and emotional and CRAZY IN LOVE WITH HIM.
From the very beginning of this book, I knew it was something special. The fact that Salem literally decided, on a whim, that the way he was going to come out was to "shoot his shot" on National TV with Arnaz- I was obsessed with him from that moment. And then.... when the cake appeared with the letter- I READ THE DAMN LETTER THREE TIMES. It was like something out of my most romantic dreams- who IS this guy, and what right does he have to be the SWOONIEST MAN EVER WRITTEN?! Yeah. That's him. HOLY WOW.
"I want you in all the ways I can have you. You have walls, and that's okay. Walls, too, are part of a home. I'll stand outside on devotional guard, so you don't have to work so hard to protect them."
And Arnaz- talk about a SHOCKER. We don't get to scratch the surface of who he is in "Loving the Legend," but it is safe to say I did NOT expect for him to be so broken. His past was absolutely devastating, and the way he struggled every single day- and I mean STRUGGLED- it was so well written. I am not sure I have ever read an author that wrote mental health struggles in a way that spoke to me as well as this author does. I felt what Blue was feeling in my bones- I was lying in bed sniffling while reading so I didn't wake my husband but I had such a hard time keeping my feels in check- he honestly broke my heart!
I just ADORED the very public, very relentless, very overt way that Salem pursued his man-- but at the beginning, when he was initially told "no," he backed off- because that's what a gentleman does. He continued to care, and continued to pay attention to EVERY LITTLE THING about Blue as their paths crossed-- but he let Blue come to HIM- damn. Consent is hot- especially when the tension is thick so thick and we have to WAIT for it.
AT it's heart, this is a beautiful hurt/comfort romance- which this author does so wonderfully. There is a found family growing here that makes my heart happy, and I can't WAIT to see more of these crazy boys find love. This series is absolutely amazing, and I am SO impressed with this author. I will read anything she writes- cant wait for the next one!
July 17, 2025
I don't even know where to begin. This book had me up all night because I just couldn't put it down. Kit has such a powerful and REAL way of writing mental health struggles. She doesn't pretty them up to be more palatable. She shows you just how dark and scary things can get. Reading a Kit Grey book is an experience unlike any other. You're going to laugh, cry, swoon, scream and demand all the side characters get books!
Salem & Blue. I'm at a loss for words.
Salem, WHAT A MAN YOU ARE. AN ANGEL WALKING THIS EARTH. When Salem loves, he loves with everything he has and I adore this about him. He's so playful and direct. He's unabashedly himself. He's tenacious in his pursuit of Arnaz but he's never disrespectful. I absolutely worship the ground this man walks on.
Arnaz, please stop making me cry. My heart can't take it anymore. Arnaz has so many layers we didn't know about in Loving the Legend. His pain runs deep and at time his pain runs rampant. I loved his growth throughout this book as he fights tooth and nail to get ahead of the demons from past. I have never wanted an HEA for a character so bad in my life.
Okay, now lets talk about the heat advisory this book should come with. Ya girl was PANTING. PERSPIRING. DEHYDRATED. The dynamic and chemistry these two share is OFF THE CHARTS! I ate it up. Not a crumb was left. DEVOURED.
I am beyond excited to see what comes next from Kit Grey!!!!
Salem & Blue. I'm at a loss for words.
Salem, WHAT A MAN YOU ARE. AN ANGEL WALKING THIS EARTH. When Salem loves, he loves with everything he has and I adore this about him. He's so playful and direct. He's unabashedly himself. He's tenacious in his pursuit of Arnaz but he's never disrespectful. I absolutely worship the ground this man walks on.
Arnaz, please stop making me cry. My heart can't take it anymore. Arnaz has so many layers we didn't know about in Loving the Legend. His pain runs deep and at time his pain runs rampant. I loved his growth throughout this book as he fights tooth and nail to get ahead of the demons from past. I have never wanted an HEA for a character so bad in my life.
Okay, now lets talk about the heat advisory this book should come with. Ya girl was PANTING. PERSPIRING. DEHYDRATED. The dynamic and chemistry these two share is OFF THE CHARTS! I ate it up. Not a crumb was left. DEVOURED.
I am beyond excited to see what comes next from Kit Grey!!!!
July 26, 2025
There are some books that don't just make you feel—they remind you that love can be healing, brave, and life-changing. Scoring the Player is exactly that kind of book. Kit Grey beautifully delivers a story about learning to let go of your fears and accept the love you never thought you deserved.
Salem “The Silencer” Jones, back from injury and ready to dominate the court again, is strong, focused—and secretly in love with his longtime crush, Arnaz Cade, the league’s first openly gay player. Arnaz, for all his fame and talent, has built walls so high around his heart, not even a three-point buzzer-beater could break through. But Salem tries anyway—publicly, boldly, and with a sincerity that’s impossible to ignore.
What unfolds is a slow, emotional unraveling of pain, vulnerability, and hope, as Arnaz learns that Salem’s love isn’t just real—it’s healing. Watching these two men navigate fame, fear, and feelings was such a joy. The chemistry is sizzling, but the emotional depth is what truly stands out. This is a story where “I love you” feels like a lifeline rather than a promise.
Whether you're here for the sports, the romance, or the guarded-heart-falling-for-the-soft-lover trope, Scoring the Player scores big on all counts. And the best part? It reminds you that sometimes, love finds you when you think you’ve benched yourself for good.
🌟 Emotional. Uplifting. Sexy. A must-read for anyone who’s ever doubted they deserve love.
Salem “The Silencer” Jones, back from injury and ready to dominate the court again, is strong, focused—and secretly in love with his longtime crush, Arnaz Cade, the league’s first openly gay player. Arnaz, for all his fame and talent, has built walls so high around his heart, not even a three-point buzzer-beater could break through. But Salem tries anyway—publicly, boldly, and with a sincerity that’s impossible to ignore.
What unfolds is a slow, emotional unraveling of pain, vulnerability, and hope, as Arnaz learns that Salem’s love isn’t just real—it’s healing. Watching these two men navigate fame, fear, and feelings was such a joy. The chemistry is sizzling, but the emotional depth is what truly stands out. This is a story where “I love you” feels like a lifeline rather than a promise.
Whether you're here for the sports, the romance, or the guarded-heart-falling-for-the-soft-lover trope, Scoring the Player scores big on all counts. And the best part? It reminds you that sometimes, love finds you when you think you’ve benched yourself for good.
🌟 Emotional. Uplifting. Sexy. A must-read for anyone who’s ever doubted they deserve love.
July 25, 2025
Blue is the Color of Home
Dee's Grade: A+
This book! This book! This book was one of my most anticipated reads of the year and it met and exceeded every possible expectation I had for it.
Arnaz is not what who I assumed he was. He's better. He's complex and struggling and healing and hiding. I'm there for every moment of it.
Salem is suave and confident. He's the caretaker of your dreams. He also needs some care of his own.
The way this love story unfolds is brilliant. It's not linear and it's not easy. It's raw and real. The emotions explored have you right there with them every step of the way rooting for them to figure it out.
I'm still in a puddle over the way these Black men in this book are represented as men in touch with their emotions. These men are constantly working on being the best version on themselves. They are not a monolith or a stereotype. They are baking, finding peace in the woods, seeking therapy, and support amongst their peers.
You just have to read this book and experience all of this for yourself.
Dee's Grade: A+
This book! This book! This book was one of my most anticipated reads of the year and it met and exceeded every possible expectation I had for it.
Arnaz is not what who I assumed he was. He's better. He's complex and struggling and healing and hiding. I'm there for every moment of it.
Salem is suave and confident. He's the caretaker of your dreams. He also needs some care of his own.
The way this love story unfolds is brilliant. It's not linear and it's not easy. It's raw and real. The emotions explored have you right there with them every step of the way rooting for them to figure it out.
I'm still in a puddle over the way these Black men in this book are represented as men in touch with their emotions. These men are constantly working on being the best version on themselves. They are not a monolith or a stereotype. They are baking, finding peace in the woods, seeking therapy, and support amongst their peers.
You just have to read this book and experience all of this for yourself.
July 28, 2025
Scoring the Player was one of my most anticipated reads of this year and let me tell you it did not disappoint. Kit Grey has a way of making the reader have an immersive experience while reading her books. I love Salem he and Sid are top tier but Blue has a special place in my heart because I can relate to him on an emotional level. This book had it all. Plot, spice, mental health rep, basketball, romance. I mean it was utter perfection. Thank you Kit Grey for giving us Salem and Blue and for continuing to give us a glimpse of Sid and Ty in this book as well.
July 13, 2025
listen this book is a real banger okay?
you’ll cry and laugh and scream - and you’ll def walk away with an unexpected appreciation for a well-baked cake😎
you’ll also prob really enjoy all the sidney david king content bc that man steals every scene he’s in😏
i love salem and arnaz together; their chemistry is off the charts (i’ll let other people gush about it)
my favorite thing about this entire book is the bond between arnaz and his sister (my newest fictional bestie) anaïs - those two are everything and they both deserve the world❤️
17 million stars! okay bye
you’ll cry and laugh and scream - and you’ll def walk away with an unexpected appreciation for a well-baked cake😎
you’ll also prob really enjoy all the sidney david king content bc that man steals every scene he’s in😏
i love salem and arnaz together; their chemistry is off the charts (i’ll let other people gush about it)
my favorite thing about this entire book is the bond between arnaz and his sister (my newest fictional bestie) anaïs - those two are everything and they both deserve the world❤️
17 million stars! okay bye
August 1, 2025
I will wait for as long as it takes for Kit to write a book. Her characters and stories are raw, real and emotive. You live within the moments these characters experience without even realizing she put you there.
Arnaz and Salem are everything you want them to be and more. This duo fights hard for their HEA. There is humor and hope weaved throughout this book but like the first, mental health is at the forefront.
There are some heavy themes and I’d definitely check triggers if you have them but if you can go in blind I would.
The found family is still so strong in this book but also a reminder that even when we think we may know someone they may still be holding back. Truly seeing someone takes diligence and patience.
The love Salem has for Arnaz rivals Sid’s for Ty in book 1. He so badly wants to be Arnaz’s person and he doesn’t hold back.
Arnaz fights love at every turn but so desperately needs and wants it. Finding home is a back and forth battle but these two are so beautiful in the journey.
I hope you will become so immersed in their world that all the feels are palpable for you like they were for me!
I will probably add to my review in Goodreads once it’s out in the world for longer because I don’t want to give spoilers but this is book is ♾️ stars for me.
Arnaz and Salem are everything you want them to be and more. This duo fights hard for their HEA. There is humor and hope weaved throughout this book but like the first, mental health is at the forefront.
There are some heavy themes and I’d definitely check triggers if you have them but if you can go in blind I would.
The found family is still so strong in this book but also a reminder that even when we think we may know someone they may still be holding back. Truly seeing someone takes diligence and patience.
The love Salem has for Arnaz rivals Sid’s for Ty in book 1. He so badly wants to be Arnaz’s person and he doesn’t hold back.
Arnaz fights love at every turn but so desperately needs and wants it. Finding home is a back and forth battle but these two are so beautiful in the journey.
I hope you will become so immersed in their world that all the feels are palpable for you like they were for me!
I will probably add to my review in Goodreads once it’s out in the world for longer because I don’t want to give spoilers but this is book is ♾️ stars for me.
August 27, 2025
Scoring the Player was one of my most anticipated reads of 2025, but it ended up being a disappointment. After the way Loving the Legend ended, I expected a fun, light, cat-and-mouse romance with Salem and Arnaz. Instead, the story leaned into heavy angst and emotional drama, which left me more drained than entertained. That said, Kit did deliver on a few things. The mental health representation in this book is top tier!! It was clearly well-researched and handled with care. And as a lover of sports romance, I loved the way the basketball scenes were written: true on-page, play-by-play action that felt authentic and engaging. Unfortunately, that’s about where my enjoyment stopped.
Beyond that, I struggled with this story. At over 500 pages, it felt unnecessarily long yet still left key moments off-page. Side plots, like Arnaz’s father and his sister’s illness—didn’t move the story forward or receive proper resolution, making them feel more like filler than substance. The dual POV also fell short; the voices often blended together, making it difficult to distinguish between them. And while the characters are meant to be Black, the lack of descriptive detail made that aspect nearly invisible on the page.
What really fell flat was the romance. The chemistry wasn’t there, Arnaz’s development felt shallow, and Salem never fully came into focus. With the mental health storyline overshadowing everything else, the love story just didn’t land. Kit is clearly a talented writer, but this addition to the series felt forced and exhausting. I wanted to love it, but I closed the book feeling defeated
Beyond that, I struggled with this story. At over 500 pages, it felt unnecessarily long yet still left key moments off-page. Side plots, like Arnaz’s father and his sister’s illness—didn’t move the story forward or receive proper resolution, making them feel more like filler than substance. The dual POV also fell short; the voices often blended together, making it difficult to distinguish between them. And while the characters are meant to be Black, the lack of descriptive detail made that aspect nearly invisible on the page.
What really fell flat was the romance. The chemistry wasn’t there, Arnaz’s development felt shallow, and Salem never fully came into focus. With the mental health storyline overshadowing everything else, the love story just didn’t land. Kit is clearly a talented writer, but this addition to the series felt forced and exhausting. I wanted to love it, but I closed the book feeling defeated
July 29, 2025
I really loved the first book (5☆) and couldn't wait for this book BUT i had such a hard time to get into this storyline. It's partwise very heavy and dark and couldn't find a connection to Salem or Blue or between them. It took me a view days to finish the book which is rare and I am sad that i feel this way cause I had so high expectations. Never less, can't wait for the next book and happy for everyone who felt them.
July 16, 2025
Well shit. Kit Grey's done it again. Another five-star read.
We return to the 'Chasing Rings' series in Scoring the Player, and this time the focus is on Arnaz - who appeared in book 1 - and Salem.
The story pretty much picks up where the first one left off - shortly after Arnaz comes out as the first openly gay player in the NBA. Salem, who is also gay and has been pinning away for Arnaz for the last five years - decides to shoot his shot one press conference, announcing he too is gay and wants to take Arnaz on a date.
Now. In the perfect world things would be very simple. Boy meets boy. Boy likes boy. Boys eat cake together and live happily ever after. Unfortunately, things are a lot more complicated and a lot more real than that and these two have to work hard in order to earn their HEA.
Both dudes are carrying around a lot of trauma and angst, Arnaz a lot more so than Salem. As much as they are perfect for each other, it's hard to be with someone when your head keeps trying to sabotage your heart.
Their journey is as much about family and healing as it is about falling in love and making it work and I devoured it, like nom nom nom, staying up late multiple nights in a row because putting it down was really bloody hard.
Much like the last book, there are a lot of details in this book. Salem is very passionate about baking and some of the food descriptions had me discreetly wiping away drool. lol. The clothes, the cars, the houses, the people, they're all fully fleshed out making it very easy to imagine yourself in each moment of the book. Now I know for some, detailed descriptions that add to the page count can be annoying but for me I love it, the more details the better. I want to know everything.
For example... one thing I would love to know is what's up with Easton and does he get a book. The tantalizing little hint we got of him and his drama had me chomping at the bit for more and I've got all ten fingers and toes crossed that if his book isn't next, it's at least planned at some point in this series.
It's tough at the moment for me to say which book is my favourite in the series so far. They're both amazing in their own way. I did enjoy that this was dual POV whereas the first one was only from Ty's POV. I also felt like this one was slightly, slightly, less angsty than the first which made it easier to read overall because I wasn't tensed up waiting for the other shoe to drop lol.
Would I re-read them? Yes, of course, duh. I'll be reaching for them when I'm feeling a particular way and am in the mood for something angsty, spicy and character driven. Hoping to get this one on audio as well because when I read Loving the Legend it was a tandem listening/reading experience that blew my socks off and I would love to revisit these two once they're out on audio.
Check triggers before diving in. Theres a lot of mental health stuff going on in this series that some will find triggering as well as a whole host of other things. They are listed in detail at the beginning of the book.
We return to the 'Chasing Rings' series in Scoring the Player, and this time the focus is on Arnaz - who appeared in book 1 - and Salem.
The story pretty much picks up where the first one left off - shortly after Arnaz comes out as the first openly gay player in the NBA. Salem, who is also gay and has been pinning away for Arnaz for the last five years - decides to shoot his shot one press conference, announcing he too is gay and wants to take Arnaz on a date.
Now. In the perfect world things would be very simple. Boy meets boy. Boy likes boy. Boys eat cake together and live happily ever after. Unfortunately, things are a lot more complicated and a lot more real than that and these two have to work hard in order to earn their HEA.
Both dudes are carrying around a lot of trauma and angst, Arnaz a lot more so than Salem. As much as they are perfect for each other, it's hard to be with someone when your head keeps trying to sabotage your heart.
Their journey is as much about family and healing as it is about falling in love and making it work and I devoured it, like nom nom nom, staying up late multiple nights in a row because putting it down was really bloody hard.
Much like the last book, there are a lot of details in this book. Salem is very passionate about baking and some of the food descriptions had me discreetly wiping away drool. lol. The clothes, the cars, the houses, the people, they're all fully fleshed out making it very easy to imagine yourself in each moment of the book. Now I know for some, detailed descriptions that add to the page count can be annoying but for me I love it, the more details the better. I want to know everything.
For example... one thing I would love to know is what's up with Easton and does he get a book. The tantalizing little hint we got of him and his drama had me chomping at the bit for more and I've got all ten fingers and toes crossed that if his book isn't next, it's at least planned at some point in this series.
It's tough at the moment for me to say which book is my favourite in the series so far. They're both amazing in their own way. I did enjoy that this was dual POV whereas the first one was only from Ty's POV. I also felt like this one was slightly, slightly, less angsty than the first which made it easier to read overall because I wasn't tensed up waiting for the other shoe to drop lol.
Would I re-read them? Yes, of course, duh. I'll be reaching for them when I'm feeling a particular way and am in the mood for something angsty, spicy and character driven. Hoping to get this one on audio as well because when I read Loving the Legend it was a tandem listening/reading experience that blew my socks off and I would love to revisit these two once they're out on audio.
Check triggers before diving in. Theres a lot of mental health stuff going on in this series that some will find triggering as well as a whole host of other things. They are listed in detail at the beginning of the book.
July 23, 2025
An affecting examination of how trauma influences our ability to form relationships.
Scoring the Player’s greatest strength is the care and compassion it shows Arnaz Cade. Grappling with the effects of an abusive childhood, Arnaz avoids emotional intimacy and relies on a regimen of therapy and medication to keep him functioning. After Cade becomes a publicly out NBA player, human ray of sunshine Salem Jones decides to shoot his shot…on national television. While Arnaz tries to duck both Jones and his own feelings, Salem “The Silencer” is not easily put off.
The writing style is distinctive and, while similar to the previous book in the series, at times veered so near poetry as to render it less accessible, if still lovely. From both a technical perspective and the content, this is not an easy read. It is ultimately a satisfying one, though, and I was rooting for the couple. The author writes tension and intimacy with great intensity that pulls you in.
This is book two in the series and could be read as a standalone, but really why would you ever miss out on Sid King, caretaker extraordinaire? His appearances were some of my favorite parts of this book, as well. I recommend picking this up if you’re a fan of basketball romance (lots of sportsing), the previous book, or looking for a heavier, often cerebral read!
*I received an advanced copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving my review*
Scoring the Player’s greatest strength is the care and compassion it shows Arnaz Cade. Grappling with the effects of an abusive childhood, Arnaz avoids emotional intimacy and relies on a regimen of therapy and medication to keep him functioning. After Cade becomes a publicly out NBA player, human ray of sunshine Salem Jones decides to shoot his shot…on national television. While Arnaz tries to duck both Jones and his own feelings, Salem “The Silencer” is not easily put off.
The writing style is distinctive and, while similar to the previous book in the series, at times veered so near poetry as to render it less accessible, if still lovely. From both a technical perspective and the content, this is not an easy read. It is ultimately a satisfying one, though, and I was rooting for the couple. The author writes tension and intimacy with great intensity that pulls you in.
This is book two in the series and could be read as a standalone, but really why would you ever miss out on Sid King, caretaker extraordinaire? His appearances were some of my favorite parts of this book, as well. I recommend picking this up if you’re a fan of basketball romance (lots of sportsing), the previous book, or looking for a heavier, often cerebral read!
*I received an advanced copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving my review*
July 17, 2025
I was definitely very excited to dive back into this universe after finishing Loving the Legend! Let me tell you, this book exceeded every single one of my expectations! Kit has this phenomenal ability to weave critical conversations about mental health struggles into relationships in a way that keeps me learning and growing every time I read.
This book was an emotional roller coaster! I found myself getting so frustrated with Arnaz for shutting Salem out, but at the same time, my heart was soaring with joy. I laughed, cried, and literally kicked my feet in delight because of the sizzling romance unfolding! The internal struggle Arnaz faced was so relatable; it hit home in the best way possible. Often, the questioning question of “How can this person be interested or love me?” will swing itself around.
The writing was absolutely flawless, and the love story? Wow, it was definitely there!! The spicy moments even left me breathless! Kit brilliantly reminded us that love can be beautifully messy and is always a journey. Mental health issues are real for so many, and it’s all about how we support and love those in crisis, even when we may not fully understand what they’re going through.
Honestly, the world needs more characters like Salem and Sid! And oh, the cameos from Ty and Sid were such a delightful treat, bringing us back to where this journey began. I can’t wait for the next book, I'm already buzzing with anticipation!
This book was an emotional roller coaster! I found myself getting so frustrated with Arnaz for shutting Salem out, but at the same time, my heart was soaring with joy. I laughed, cried, and literally kicked my feet in delight because of the sizzling romance unfolding! The internal struggle Arnaz faced was so relatable; it hit home in the best way possible. Often, the questioning question of “How can this person be interested or love me?” will swing itself around.
The writing was absolutely flawless, and the love story? Wow, it was definitely there!! The spicy moments even left me breathless! Kit brilliantly reminded us that love can be beautifully messy and is always a journey. Mental health issues are real for so many, and it’s all about how we support and love those in crisis, even when we may not fully understand what they’re going through.
Honestly, the world needs more characters like Salem and Sid! And oh, the cameos from Ty and Sid were such a delightful treat, bringing us back to where this journey began. I can’t wait for the next book, I'm already buzzing with anticipation!
July 28, 2025
Obsessed is an understatement because OMG 😱, I love I love it, First off the gamessss, I have never even been so engrossed with the games in books but for some reasons, I sat down and paid attention and I understood Arnaz obsession with the way Salem plays.
Secondly, The love that Arnaz and Salem had for each other, even when Salem was upset, he still was there for Arnaz sis, stepped in when he saw that Arnaz wanted to beat someone 😂😂😂, I love them so much because their obsession was so lovely to look at, the dates, the foot rub, cuddles and their intimacy was sweet🙈💕
Thirdly, The mental health rep,when Ty organized an event for people going through things to voice it out, I was down.
Fourthly, the found family 👌
Fifthly, Salem said even love wouldn’t make me not play well and I love it, he loved hard but he made sure he was still on his game and when to take a step back
Safe to say, this book had me on a choke hold because I giggled, felt so emotional, blushed and laughed ☺️
Secondly, The love that Arnaz and Salem had for each other, even when Salem was upset, he still was there for Arnaz sis, stepped in when he saw that Arnaz wanted to beat someone 😂😂😂, I love them so much because their obsession was so lovely to look at, the dates, the foot rub, cuddles and their intimacy was sweet🙈💕
Thirdly, The mental health rep,when Ty organized an event for people going through things to voice it out, I was down.
Fourthly, the found family 👌
Fifthly, Salem said even love wouldn’t make me not play well and I love it, he loved hard but he made sure he was still on his game and when to take a step back
Safe to say, this book had me on a choke hold because I giggled, felt so emotional, blushed and laughed ☺️
August 30, 2025
Ugh, man....I was SO stinking excited for this, and it didn't disappoint at all!!! I absolutely freaking LOVED her first book, and I don't know if this topped Sid and Ty...that book was in my tiny list of 6 star books..but it was close. She writes characters and emotion so well, you feel what her characters feel. Like in Loving the Legend, one is struggling hard with his mental health and the other is an absolute master class of a supportive partner. Man, if the world was full of Sid's and Salem's, it would be such a better place. The healing through this book is beautiful, and man that epilogue got me 😭😭. For all the pain, healing and romance...there is still lots of spice. And like everything else, she excels at writing moving, deeply emotional spicy scenes.
I absolutely can't wait for her next release!!! ohhhh and I also can't wait for this to release on audio because Loving the Legend was a masterpiece in writing but audio somehow made it even better!!
I absolutely can't wait for her next release!!! ohhhh and I also can't wait for this to release on audio because Loving the Legend was a masterpiece in writing but audio somehow made it even better!!
July 16, 2025
4.5 ⭐️
I read Loving the Legend by Kit Grey and absolutly loved it. I knew for sure that I had to read Scoring the Player. I needed to see Arnaz find love.
Arnaz and Salem’s love was perfect and it was the best way to depict their relationship. The way that mental health was shown was so emotional and raw but also a learning experience. Arnaz working through so much and learning that it is okay to love and be loved and Salem learning patience and how to love the way his “Blue” needs to was everything.
Kit Gray has for sure been added to any auto buy list! I can’t wait to get the physical copies on my shelf.
Thank you Kit Grey for the ARC!
I read Loving the Legend by Kit Grey and absolutly loved it. I knew for sure that I had to read Scoring the Player. I needed to see Arnaz find love.
Arnaz and Salem’s love was perfect and it was the best way to depict their relationship. The way that mental health was shown was so emotional and raw but also a learning experience. Arnaz working through so much and learning that it is okay to love and be loved and Salem learning patience and how to love the way his “Blue” needs to was everything.
Kit Gray has for sure been added to any auto buy list! I can’t wait to get the physical copies on my shelf.
Thank you Kit Grey for the ARC!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 150 reviews