I loved this book not only because it was a tribute to the heroes of Flight 93, but because it's a real portrait of a life. Lisa Beamer makes her beloved husband Todd come to life like a true novelist, shaping his character with tons of memories and detail.
I also think it's very interesting that Todd Beamer emerges not just as a patriot, or even as a loving family man, but as a businessman committed to success. This goes to the heart of something really flawed in our modern liberal values.
When I was in high school, we all had to read DEATH OF A SALESMAN by Arthur Miller. And the message was very clear. Salesmen, and businessmen in general, are either sad little failures or heartless tycoons. No nuance. No humanity. No in-betweens. It's eye-opening as an adult to read a book like this, about a person who was basically in sales his entire adult life yet who always, always, cared about doing the right thing and helping others.
Now on a second reading, I noticed that Todd Beamer was more like Jay Gatsby than Willy Loman. Like Gatsby, he very consciously invents himself as a hero from top to bottom based on principles and ideals. (He even makes lists just like Gatsby's on how to improve himself!) Unlike Gatbsy, however, he never allows success to tarnish his idealism or courage. His death is strikingly similar to Gatsby's. It's horrific and unexpected and on the surface it appears meaningless. Except that instead of lying around the pool in a daze Todd goes out fighting for everything that's pure and good about America.
Todd Beamer is more than just Gatsby like, he's the Gatsby Gatsby wanted to be! Of course, Lisa Beamer is very different from Daisy Buchanan. But that's because Todd Beamer was looking for different things in a wife than Gatsby. Truth instead of falsehood, courage instead of weakness, Christian values instead of shallow snobbery. And if you still don't see the Gatsby connection, there's a quote Lisa Beamer attaches from a Christian self-help book that Todd really liked. "Failure means to succeed in a way that doesn't really matter." Now that doesn't quite describe Todd Beamer, since he worked to succeed at the important things even at the cost of his own life. But it's a real insight into the life and death of Gatsby. These two books should really be taught together!
Just like The Great Gatsby, this book belongs in every high school in the country.
DEATH OF A SALESMAN . . . not so much.