What do you think?
Rate this book
Sundown Girls
In the tradition of Jordan Peele and Tiffany Jackson’s The Weight of Blood, a YA thriller about a Black teen whose fight for survival forces a small southern vacation town to face its dark history of racial violence.
When sixteen-year-old Naomi Ward and her family head to a secluded cabin in the Shenandoah Valley for summer vacation they don’t know the small, mountain town of Sparksburg, Virginia has a dark and twisted past. But when they arrive, Naomi can’t shake the feeling that something about Sparksburg just isn’t right—and it smells god awful, but for some reason Naomi is the only who can smell the town’s stench. When she learns Sparksburg had once been a Sundown Town—a town where Black people weren’t allowed after sunset lest they be murdered—Naomi’s unease starts to make sense.
As Naomi digs more into Sparksburg’s violent origins, she finds herself haunted by the ghost of a girl, appearing nightly outside her window. Then she learns of two girls who’ve recently gone missing and suspects the past may still be present in Sparksburg and beneath the quaint façade of this tourist town is a palpable danger.
When Naomi decides to track the disappearance of the two girls herself, she becomes suspicious of a local man who has kindled fear in Naomi more than once. She soon learns he has a connection to one of the missing girls, and Naomi is certain he’s responsible for the disappearances.
When no one believes her, Naomi takes matters into her own hands. But to save the missing girls, she’ll have to finally face her own past trauma as a “missing girl” as she finds herself in a fight for survival.
Gripping and triumphant, L.S. Stratton tells an important and unforgettable story of racial reckoning inspired by historical events.
When sixteen-year-old Naomi Ward and her family head to a secluded cabin in the Shenandoah Valley for summer vacation they don’t know the small, mountain town of Sparksburg, Virginia has a dark and twisted past. But when they arrive, Naomi can’t shake the feeling that something about Sparksburg just isn’t right—and it smells god awful, but for some reason Naomi is the only who can smell the town’s stench. When she learns Sparksburg had once been a Sundown Town—a town where Black people weren’t allowed after sunset lest they be murdered—Naomi’s unease starts to make sense.
As Naomi digs more into Sparksburg’s violent origins, she finds herself haunted by the ghost of a girl, appearing nightly outside her window. Then she learns of two girls who’ve recently gone missing and suspects the past may still be present in Sparksburg and beneath the quaint façade of this tourist town is a palpable danger.
When Naomi decides to track the disappearance of the two girls herself, she becomes suspicious of a local man who has kindled fear in Naomi more than once. She soon learns he has a connection to one of the missing girls, and Naomi is certain he’s responsible for the disappearances.
When no one believes her, Naomi takes matters into her own hands. But to save the missing girls, she’ll have to finally face her own past trauma as a “missing girl” as she finds herself in a fight for survival.
Gripping and triumphant, L.S. Stratton tells an important and unforgettable story of racial reckoning inspired by historical events.
310 pages, Kindle Edition
First published January 27, 2026
36 people are currently reading
6777 people want to read
About the author
L.S. Stratton
4 books483 followersL.S. Stratton is an NAACP Image Award-nominated author and former crime newspaper reporter who has written more than a dozen books under different pen names in just about every genre from thrillers to romance to historical fiction. She currently lives in Maryland with her husband, their daughter, and their tuxedo cat.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 168 reviews
March 10, 2026
Fantastic YA horror/paranormal mystery! Sundown Girls follows Naomi, a Black teen girl on vacation with her family to a former sundown town where she keeps seeing the ghosts of Black girls, and in the present day girls have gone missing. Naomi is determined to uncover the truth of what is happening, but she also has a complicated past of her own to come to terms with. As a baby Naomi was kidnapped and raised by a stranger. At 15 the woman she considered her mother was imprisoned and she's struggling to adjust to life with her biological family. And if that wasn't enough, there's also a cute boy!
This was creepy and interesting with a heroine who is brash and impulsive, which kind of tracks for teenagers in a lot of cases. She acts before thinking and rarely considers the consequences, even if people around her try to get her to. But that certainly drives action in the story! I enjoyed this and thought it was a really good YA debut from an author who has written for adults. The author's note adds great context as well! I received a copy of this book from the publisher, all opinions are my own.
This was creepy and interesting with a heroine who is brash and impulsive, which kind of tracks for teenagers in a lot of cases. She acts before thinking and rarely considers the consequences, even if people around her try to get her to. But that certainly drives action in the story! I enjoyed this and thought it was a really good YA debut from an author who has written for adults. The author's note adds great context as well! I received a copy of this book from the publisher, all opinions are my own.
February 12, 2026
4.5 ⭐️ | When this story peaked my interest immediately, from the very first chapter & I had my first wait.. what moment at the end of Chapter 3, I knew this would be a great read!
First of all! What possessed Dawn & Andre to take their family to this podunct town will forever remain a mystery! The adults in this story definitely pissed me off by not listening to Naomi, when she clearly saw dangers that others simply couldn’t see! I knew they would live to regret it, I just didn’t know to what degree!
Touching on this sensitive, racially charged subject “Sundown Towns” was simply beautifully executed in this story. It was entertaining, never lost my attention. And this author absolutely has a new fan. Thank you NetGalley & Penguin Young Readers Group for an advanced reader copy.
Publication 🗓️ : 01.27.26
First of all! What possessed Dawn & Andre to take their family to this podunct town will forever remain a mystery! The adults in this story definitely pissed me off by not listening to Naomi, when she clearly saw dangers that others simply couldn’t see! I knew they would live to regret it, I just didn’t know to what degree!
Touching on this sensitive, racially charged subject “Sundown Towns” was simply beautifully executed in this story. It was entertaining, never lost my attention. And this author absolutely has a new fan. Thank you NetGalley & Penguin Young Readers Group for an advanced reader copy.
Publication 🗓️ : 01.27.26
October 22, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with an ARC of this novel. All my thoughts and opinions are my own.
Real rating: 4.25 stars
This was a nice read that kept me interested from start to finish. Although the culprit(s) were obvious and there was no surprise whatsoever in that regard, I still enjoyed my time here. I think this is a great YA novel.
Real rating: 4.25 stars
This was a nice read that kept me interested from start to finish. Although the culprit(s) were obvious and there was no surprise whatsoever in that regard, I still enjoyed my time here. I think this is a great YA novel.
March 21, 2026
A necessary read with a necessary topic.
Our FMC is dealing with the aftermath of being an abducted child and now navigating her new reality of her family after being found.
A vacation to a town that was once a Sundown town now reveals its secrets to her, her trauma allows her to tap into the gift of being a medium if you will, she is able to see the ghost of ancestors pasts, and they lead her to uncover current secrets and abductions, while also freeing the dark history of the town and assisting those whose stories were buried and never told.
I loved how the author spoke about Sundown towns that have existed and taught about other towns that were completely washed away in history.
This was a good read, and different than what I was expecting.
Our FMC is dealing with the aftermath of being an abducted child and now navigating her new reality of her family after being found.
A vacation to a town that was once a Sundown town now reveals its secrets to her, her trauma allows her to tap into the gift of being a medium if you will, she is able to see the ghost of ancestors pasts, and they lead her to uncover current secrets and abductions, while also freeing the dark history of the town and assisting those whose stories were buried and never told.
I loved how the author spoke about Sundown towns that have existed and taught about other towns that were completely washed away in history.
This was a good read, and different than what I was expecting.
October 23, 2025
This is my first time reading the author and I think I am hooked on the writing alone. The sundown towns in history are scary to me and having the history behind what they are and what could happen engulfed in the story made it interesting to put in the book. It mixed in some thriller, mystery, and horror and managing to keep the grasp of all of the topics to keep the plot flowing. I think I really hated the parents for not being able to just listen in knowing that she has been through what she went through previously. I loved how the ending came and this way she could get the closure she needs so she can live the life she deserves. The character building was phenomenal and in the end, everyone started to trust and believe that she was not crazy.
Thank you, Netgalley for the early read. This was above expectations.
Thank you, Netgalley for the early read. This was above expectations.
February 1, 2026
Sundown Girls
by: L.S. Stratton
Pub Date. Jan 27, 2026
I seriously can't begin to express how obsessed I am with L.S. Stratton! From Not So Perfect Strangers to Do What Godmother Says and In Deadly Company, every single book has blown my mind. And now, Sundown Girls?! This YA thriller is next-level amazing!
Diving into books without any prior knowledge is an exhilarating adventure, and this review will offer just a glimpse of that thrill. Meet sixteen-year-old Naomi Stoakes, who embarks on a family vacation to a town steeped in a dark, chilling history. Once a Sundown Town, this place harbored dark secrets—black individuals were forced to leave by nightfall or face dire consequences.
Upon arrival, Naomi senses an unsettling atmosphere, but the rest of her family is blissfully blind to it. As a fan of dark thrillers, I thought this young adult tale would be a breeze… but I was SO wrong! Sundown Girls is an epic mashup of horror, paranormal vibes, psychological thrills, complete with multiple trigger warnings — I am literally buzzing from this reading experience! Mark your calendars for January 2026; you will not want to miss out on this spine-tingling adventure!
Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Young Readers Group for the opportunity to read this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
by: L.S. Stratton
Pub Date. Jan 27, 2026
I seriously can't begin to express how obsessed I am with L.S. Stratton! From Not So Perfect Strangers to Do What Godmother Says and In Deadly Company, every single book has blown my mind. And now, Sundown Girls?! This YA thriller is next-level amazing!
Diving into books without any prior knowledge is an exhilarating adventure, and this review will offer just a glimpse of that thrill. Meet sixteen-year-old Naomi Stoakes, who embarks on a family vacation to a town steeped in a dark, chilling history. Once a Sundown Town, this place harbored dark secrets—black individuals were forced to leave by nightfall or face dire consequences.
Upon arrival, Naomi senses an unsettling atmosphere, but the rest of her family is blissfully blind to it. As a fan of dark thrillers, I thought this young adult tale would be a breeze… but I was SO wrong! Sundown Girls is an epic mashup of horror, paranormal vibes, psychological thrills, complete with multiple trigger warnings — I am literally buzzing from this reading experience! Mark your calendars for January 2026; you will not want to miss out on this spine-tingling adventure!
Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Young Readers Group for the opportunity to read this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
September 10, 2025
Girl?! Is this YA splatterpunk? This is so dark and good. A YA horror, mystery paranormal psychological thriller!!!! Lots of triggers in this one. Missing girls, racism, mental health, child abduction
February 13, 2026
Naomi and her family are taking a three week long vacation at a secluded cabin outside the small town of Sparksburg, Virginia. It’s a chance for them to grow closer following a year full of tense awkwardness. Because Naomi has only just reunited with her family about being kidnapped for 15 years, raised by a woman she thought was her mother. Missing her mom, and feeling disconnected to her birth family and the “Camryn” they want her to return to being, Naomi is not looking forward to this trip. And to make it worse, Sparksburg unsettles her. Stinking of rot, hiding a dark history, and girls are going missing. When Naomi has some paranormal encounters, she feels compelled to get to the bottom of whatever evil is brewing.
This was a very solid thriller. I was racing through the pages, and getting a little too invested. Naomi makes some crazy decisions that left me yelling at the book. Girl had very little self preservation and I was scared for her! But I didn’t blame her because the adults in her life had no urgency.
This book was definetly staked with a lot of elements. We have Naomi’s strained relationship with her family and the complex feelings she has for her kidnapper. Sparksburg’s horrific history as a sundown town, and the lasting impact it has had on the region. The disappearance of girls in the area and the inadequacies of law enforcement. Naomi being haunted by a young girl’s ghost, and other unexplained paranormal encounters. As well as a blooming romance between Naomi and local named Khalil.
With everything going on in this story, it sometimes felt like Naomi’s history was a little too much to add to the plot. But the more we got into the book the more I understood why it was important. Naomi’s identification as a past “missing girl” feeds into her fevered need to find these other girls, as well as why she was chosen by the spirits to uncover the truth. And seeing her desire for agency in her own life, as well as how deeply she cares about those who are ignored or overlooked, really added depth to her character.
This was a very solid thriller. I was racing through the pages, and getting a little too invested. Naomi makes some crazy decisions that left me yelling at the book. Girl had very little self preservation and I was scared for her! But I didn’t blame her because the adults in her life had no urgency.
This book was definetly staked with a lot of elements. We have Naomi’s strained relationship with her family and the complex feelings she has for her kidnapper. Sparksburg’s horrific history as a sundown town, and the lasting impact it has had on the region. The disappearance of girls in the area and the inadequacies of law enforcement. Naomi being haunted by a young girl’s ghost, and other unexplained paranormal encounters. As well as a blooming romance between Naomi and local named Khalil.
With everything going on in this story, it sometimes felt like Naomi’s history was a little too much to add to the plot. But the more we got into the book the more I understood why it was important. Naomi’s identification as a past “missing girl” feeds into her fevered need to find these other girls, as well as why she was chosen by the spirits to uncover the truth. And seeing her desire for agency in her own life, as well as how deeply she cares about those who are ignored or overlooked, really added depth to her character.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Actual Rating 3.25
Thanks to the Nancy Paulsen Books and Penguin Teens for this early copy
I went into Sundown Girls with pretty high expectations because the premise sounded so unique: a family trip in the mountains, a town with a dark past, missing girls, and a main character still healing from her own trauma. It had all the right ingredients for a great story on paper.
The story started a bit slow, not much happened plot-wise, though the buildup and character introductions were there, so it made sense. Once the mystery picked up, especially in the last quarter, I was more invested.
Naomi’s character could have been really great, but it felt short in execution. I wanted to feel empathy for her, but some of her choices made that hard. Still, watching her process her trauma and rebuild her relationship with her parents was one of the stronger parts of the book. I also liked how the story blended history, mystery, and a touch of the paranormal.
I did feel the story tried to do a little too much. The three main threads (past kidnapping, town history, and missing girls) sounded great, but never fully connected, which was a pity. Some plot points also felt rushed or underdeveloped, and a few things were left hanging by the end. The highlight of the book was the history, and I rarely learn something important from a YA book, let alone from a mystery. So kudos to that.
Overall, it is an engaging YA mystery with meaningful themes and a strong emotional theme. It didn’t fully deliver on its potential, but I still enjoyed it.
Thanks to the Nancy Paulsen Books and Penguin Teens for this early copy
I went into Sundown Girls with pretty high expectations because the premise sounded so unique: a family trip in the mountains, a town with a dark past, missing girls, and a main character still healing from her own trauma. It had all the right ingredients for a great story on paper.
The story started a bit slow, not much happened plot-wise, though the buildup and character introductions were there, so it made sense. Once the mystery picked up, especially in the last quarter, I was more invested.
Naomi’s character could have been really great, but it felt short in execution. I wanted to feel empathy for her, but some of her choices made that hard. Still, watching her process her trauma and rebuild her relationship with her parents was one of the stronger parts of the book. I also liked how the story blended history, mystery, and a touch of the paranormal.
I did feel the story tried to do a little too much. The three main threads (past kidnapping, town history, and missing girls) sounded great, but never fully connected, which was a pity. Some plot points also felt rushed or underdeveloped, and a few things were left hanging by the end. The highlight of the book was the history, and I rarely learn something important from a YA book, let alone from a mystery. So kudos to that.
Overall, it is an engaging YA mystery with meaningful themes and a strong emotional theme. It didn’t fully deliver on its potential, but I still enjoyed it.
April 4, 2026
I really enjoyed this book!
October 12, 2025
This book was definitely a YA read as Naomi (or Cam) perfectly captured the essence of a teenager trying to navigate fear, trauma, and independence. The mother in me was yelling at every dumb decision she made, even though I understood why she acted the way she did. Her parents frustrated me too at times, especially when they refused to believe her. That dynamic felt painfully realistic and added to the tension.
Naomi’s past trauma gave her character so much depth. I really felt for her as she tried to adjust to her “new” family after being pulled away from the only home she’d ever known. That inner conflict, mixed with the eerie mystery surrounding Sparksburg, made the story even more gripping. The town’s dark history and Naomi’s determination to uncover the truth kept me turning pages late into the night.
Overall, this was an excellent creepy, emotional, and thought-provoking read. It blended supernatural elements with real-world issues of race and belonging in a way that felt both haunting and meaningful. L.S. Stratton did a fantastic job crafting a story that was as chilling as it was powerful.
Thanks Netgalley and Penguin Young Readers Group | Nancy Paulsen Books for the ARC and opportunity to provide an honest review.
Naomi’s past trauma gave her character so much depth. I really felt for her as she tried to adjust to her “new” family after being pulled away from the only home she’d ever known. That inner conflict, mixed with the eerie mystery surrounding Sparksburg, made the story even more gripping. The town’s dark history and Naomi’s determination to uncover the truth kept me turning pages late into the night.
Overall, this was an excellent creepy, emotional, and thought-provoking read. It blended supernatural elements with real-world issues of race and belonging in a way that felt both haunting and meaningful. L.S. Stratton did a fantastic job crafting a story that was as chilling as it was powerful.
Thanks Netgalley and Penguin Young Readers Group | Nancy Paulsen Books for the ARC and opportunity to provide an honest review.
February 23, 2026
I was absolutely buzzing after reading Sundown Girls.
L.S. Stratton did such a great job writing this story-- where at times I felt myself becoming so aggravated with our main character Naomi. Whilst she's headstrong, and a bit brooding, she was also a little misguided but well-meaning in her efforts to help recover the lost. The horrid history of the sundown town and the missing girls' plotlines were weaved together effortlessly and had you looking at everyone in the area suspiciously. Just when you thought the culprit was obvious you may not expect who it is.
Thanks to Netgalley and Penguin Young Readers Group for the ARC. All thoughts are my own!
L.S. Stratton did such a great job writing this story-- where at times I felt myself becoming so aggravated with our main character Naomi. Whilst she's headstrong, and a bit brooding, she was also a little misguided but well-meaning in her efforts to help recover the lost. The horrid history of the sundown town and the missing girls' plotlines were weaved together effortlessly and had you looking at everyone in the area suspiciously. Just when you thought the culprit was obvious you may not expect who it is.
Thanks to Netgalley and Penguin Young Readers Group for the ARC. All thoughts are my own!
February 19, 2026
When it got really good.., the book was over. 😒
This was not a bad book honestly. But I just have so many more questions at the end. I felt like it took a lot to get to the actual point of the story. I’m all for world building because I want to feel like I am there! But idk something just didn’t hit quite right for me.
Tho this was once I a sundown town, I don’t necessarily feel like everyone there were racist or that the current crimes going on were racially motivated. In general the town seemed nice! But every town can have a few bad eggs.
The parents 🤦🏾♀️ Andre and Dawn. I feel like there was so much disconnect between them and Naomi. Like yes what happened was TERRIBLE! But how can yall expect her to hate this woman who raised her and loved her like her own. I fully understand THEIR hate for her! But to expect Naomi to feel the same immediately is ridiculous! Also forcing her to go by Camryn when she’s been Naomi for 15yrs is a little silly too. Like give her the option. Not just forcing this “new name” on her.
They also crazy for not leaving at the first sign of trouble! Granted had they left the murders would still be unsolved and more would probably happen. But the first interaction with the police would’ve had us packing up! Then a second! THEN A THIRD!!! Not to mention the fact that they really were the only black folk in town! Like nah that alone would’ve creeped me TF out! I don’t like not seeing other people that look like me. I feel like I’m not supposed to be here.
What I felt was missing from the story were answers to:
-why her “mama” kidnapped her.
-what really goes on in this town after dark?
-was Liam really possessed by the ghost of Mayor Mecham?
-the sheriff! Why bro? Just why!?
-who else has Willa visited? And why did she choose Naomi?
Idk all in all it wasn’t a bad book. It gave the uneasy vibes I was looking for. But I kinda feel like it took a while to get there as well.
This was not a bad book honestly. But I just have so many more questions at the end. I felt like it took a lot to get to the actual point of the story. I’m all for world building because I want to feel like I am there! But idk something just didn’t hit quite right for me.
Tho this was once I a sundown town, I don’t necessarily feel like everyone there were racist or that the current crimes going on were racially motivated. In general the town seemed nice! But every town can have a few bad eggs.
The parents 🤦🏾♀️ Andre and Dawn. I feel like there was so much disconnect between them and Naomi. Like yes what happened was TERRIBLE! But how can yall expect her to hate this woman who raised her and loved her like her own. I fully understand THEIR hate for her! But to expect Naomi to feel the same immediately is ridiculous! Also forcing her to go by Camryn when she’s been Naomi for 15yrs is a little silly too. Like give her the option. Not just forcing this “new name” on her.
They also crazy for not leaving at the first sign of trouble! Granted had they left the murders would still be unsolved and more would probably happen. But the first interaction with the police would’ve had us packing up! Then a second! THEN A THIRD!!! Not to mention the fact that they really were the only black folk in town! Like nah that alone would’ve creeped me TF out! I don’t like not seeing other people that look like me. I feel like I’m not supposed to be here.
What I felt was missing from the story were answers to:
-why her “mama” kidnapped her.
-what really goes on in this town after dark?
-was Liam really possessed by the ghost of Mayor Mecham?
-the sheriff! Why bro? Just why!?
-who else has Willa visited? And why did she choose Naomi?
Idk all in all it wasn’t a bad book. It gave the uneasy vibes I was looking for. But I kinda feel like it took a while to get there as well.
March 2, 2026
I was drawn to this story due to its premise. A horror/mystery with a unique setting, paranormal elements and commentary on anti-Black racism sounded right up my alley. Sadly though, this book really fell flat for me, for multiple reasons.
I really enjoyed the slow pace, and thought it was a great way to build tension, but there was so much repetitive world building that I thought was unnecessary. While I did love the inclusion of ghosts, they felt more like a plot device when they could have been explored more and expanded upon in the story. The motive for the kidnappings and murders didn't make much sense to me, and felt rushed. With more planning, it could have been a great climax to the story, but the amount of violence felt unnecessary for the motive.
Finally, as the story picked up, I found it hard to fully root for the main character. Lots of her actions weren't well thought out, very impulsive, and could've brought so much danger to her loved ones. She dealt with the mystery and gathering clues in a very irresponsible way, and it irritated me. A huge thank you to Penguin Young Readers Group and Netgalley for this ARC!
I really enjoyed the slow pace, and thought it was a great way to build tension, but there was so much repetitive world building that I thought was unnecessary. While I did love the inclusion of ghosts, they felt more like a plot device when they could have been explored more and expanded upon in the story. The motive for the kidnappings and murders didn't make much sense to me, and felt rushed. With more planning, it could have been a great climax to the story, but the amount of violence felt unnecessary for the motive.
Finally, as the story picked up, I found it hard to fully root for the main character. Lots of her actions weren't well thought out, very impulsive, and could've brought so much danger to her loved ones. She dealt with the mystery and gathering clues in a very irresponsible way, and it irritated me. A huge thank you to Penguin Young Readers Group and Netgalley for this ARC!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Loved the title, the subject matter and the pacing of this book. You hear about Sundown towns all the time and this book gave a peak into the underbelly of one and although it is fiction, truth still remains that there's a level of sinisterness lying just beneath the surface. I also enjoyed the side story of our main character and how her life intertwined with the events in the town.
thank you to Netgalley and PenguinKids for this ARC.
thank you to Netgalley and PenguinKids for this ARC.
January 14, 2026
I received an ARC from Penguin Teen Canada in exchange for an honest review.
4.5⭐️ rounded up
This story was really gripping. The writing was very engaging, and it was hard to put down.
This book starts with Naomi who has been recently reunited with her family after getting abducted as a child and being returned when she turned 15. There are a lot of layers to this book, including navigating trying to fit into her “new” family, having a new boyfriend, and also vacationing at a previous sundown town where she is seeing ghosts and young girls are going missing.
I think the one drawback for me is that I wish the ending hadn’t wrapped as quickly as it did. We get the climax of the story and resolution within 60 pages of the ending. However, overall, I really liked the story itself and seeing Naomi deal with her interpersonal issues and learning about sundown towns in general.
4.5⭐️ rounded up
This story was really gripping. The writing was very engaging, and it was hard to put down.
This book starts with Naomi who has been recently reunited with her family after getting abducted as a child and being returned when she turned 15. There are a lot of layers to this book, including navigating trying to fit into her “new” family, having a new boyfriend, and also vacationing at a previous sundown town where she is seeing ghosts and young girls are going missing.
I think the one drawback for me is that I wish the ending hadn’t wrapped as quickly as it did. We get the climax of the story and resolution within 60 pages of the ending. However, overall, I really liked the story itself and seeing Naomi deal with her interpersonal issues and learning about sundown towns in general.
February 15, 2026
A family vacation to an isolated mountain town with a brutal past turns into a search for missing girls. The town looks quaint, but its history refuses to stay buried, and the story quickly blends mystery, danger, and the supernatural. This tackles the legacy of sundown towns without feeling heavy-handed, and it sent me down a research rabbit hole afterward, which is always a sign that a story did something right.
Naomi’s family dynamics were especially compelling: being abducted as a child and then returned means she’s stuck between two lives, and you can feel that emotional tension in every interaction. Her love for the woman who raised her, paired with her biological family’s attempts to reconnect, made the home life just as layered as the mystery.
I also liked the supernatural angle. Naomi’s connection to the past felt haunting in a quiet way, even if I wished the town itself leaned harder into that eerie, collective menace. I wanted a little more Get Out energy from the community as a whole, but I get why the book kept things more subtle. It feels more realistic that way, especially for a YA story. But as you can tell, there is a lot going on here. It juggled things more successfully than I expected.
The weakest point for me was the reveal around who was responsible for the disappearances; it didn’t hit as hard as the emotional or historical elements. And yes, the adults not listening to Naomi was frustrating, but it also felt painfully accurate, especially given her history and how often Black girls are dismissed when they raise alarms.
One of the twists genuinely hurt my heart, and I appreciated the open-ended conclusion. It gave Naomi something she’s been denied for most of her life: agency and the chance to define herself outside of her trauma.
Overall, this was a thoughtful, emotionally layered YA thriller that blends history, horror, and healing in a way that stuck with me longer than I expected.
Thanks to Penguin Teen and Storygram Tours for the complimentary copy. This review is voluntary and all opinions are my own.
Naomi’s family dynamics were especially compelling: being abducted as a child and then returned means she’s stuck between two lives, and you can feel that emotional tension in every interaction. Her love for the woman who raised her, paired with her biological family’s attempts to reconnect, made the home life just as layered as the mystery.
I also liked the supernatural angle. Naomi’s connection to the past felt haunting in a quiet way, even if I wished the town itself leaned harder into that eerie, collective menace. I wanted a little more Get Out energy from the community as a whole, but I get why the book kept things more subtle. It feels more realistic that way, especially for a YA story. But as you can tell, there is a lot going on here. It juggled things more successfully than I expected.
The weakest point for me was the reveal around who was responsible for the disappearances; it didn’t hit as hard as the emotional or historical elements. And yes, the adults not listening to Naomi was frustrating, but it also felt painfully accurate, especially given her history and how often Black girls are dismissed when they raise alarms.
One of the twists genuinely hurt my heart, and I appreciated the open-ended conclusion. It gave Naomi something she’s been denied for most of her life: agency and the chance to define herself outside of her trauma.
Overall, this was a thoughtful, emotionally layered YA thriller that blends history, horror, and healing in a way that stuck with me longer than I expected.
Thanks to Penguin Teen and Storygram Tours for the complimentary copy. This review is voluntary and all opinions are my own.
February 19, 2026
Book Review 🌅🩸
thank you so much partner @penguinteen @storygramtours for the gifted copy!
Sundown Girls
by L.S. Stratton
out now!
When sixteen-year-old Naomi Ward arrives in Sparksburg, Virginia for a quiet summer in a secluded Shenandoah Valley cabin, she immediately senses something is wrong. The town carries a foul stench only she can smell and a far darker history as a former Sundown Town where Black people were once violently forced out. As Naomi digs into its past, she’s haunted by the ghost of a girl outside her window and learns that two local girls have recently gone missing.
Convinced the town’s violent history isn’t as buried as it seems, Naomi suspects a local man may be connected to the disappearances. When no one believes her, she takes matters into her own hands but to save the missing girls, she must confront her own trauma as a former “missing girl” and fight to survive the truth lurking beneath Sparksburg’s quaint façade.
🌅 My thoughts:
I absolutely loved it and flew through it. It was an easy five stars for me! It’s thrilling and emotional in equal measure, with a supernatural thread that weaves so seamlessly into the dark history of the town that the atmosphere feels heavy and palpable. The tension surrounding the missing girls, layered over Sparksburg’s violent past, made every page feel urgent. It’s haunting in more ways than one. If you’re one to skip the author’s note, PLEASE don’t. While this is fiction, Sundown Towns were horrifyingly real, and not as far removed from our present as we’d like to believe. That truth adds an even deeper weight to an already powerful story. Chilling, necessary, and impossible to ignore, this is a must read.
🔪 For thriller fans
🍿 For Joran Peele fans
👩🏾🦱 Spotlights missing black girls
🗞️ Written by a former crime newspaper reporter
Happy reading 📖🌅🩸
thank you so much partner @penguinteen @storygramtours for the gifted copy!
Sundown Girls
by L.S. Stratton
out now!
When sixteen-year-old Naomi Ward arrives in Sparksburg, Virginia for a quiet summer in a secluded Shenandoah Valley cabin, she immediately senses something is wrong. The town carries a foul stench only she can smell and a far darker history as a former Sundown Town where Black people were once violently forced out. As Naomi digs into its past, she’s haunted by the ghost of a girl outside her window and learns that two local girls have recently gone missing.
Convinced the town’s violent history isn’t as buried as it seems, Naomi suspects a local man may be connected to the disappearances. When no one believes her, she takes matters into her own hands but to save the missing girls, she must confront her own trauma as a former “missing girl” and fight to survive the truth lurking beneath Sparksburg’s quaint façade.
🌅 My thoughts:
I absolutely loved it and flew through it. It was an easy five stars for me! It’s thrilling and emotional in equal measure, with a supernatural thread that weaves so seamlessly into the dark history of the town that the atmosphere feels heavy and palpable. The tension surrounding the missing girls, layered over Sparksburg’s violent past, made every page feel urgent. It’s haunting in more ways than one. If you’re one to skip the author’s note, PLEASE don’t. While this is fiction, Sundown Towns were horrifyingly real, and not as far removed from our present as we’d like to believe. That truth adds an even deeper weight to an already powerful story. Chilling, necessary, and impossible to ignore, this is a must read.
🔪 For thriller fans
🍿 For Joran Peele fans
👩🏾🦱 Spotlights missing black girls
🗞️ Written by a former crime newspaper reporter
Happy reading 📖🌅🩸
March 6, 2026
“This kind of ‘dark history’ is hiding everywhere, but we can’t let it rule our lives. We can’t let it dictate our present either […]”
Spoiler-free:
I had lots of fun reading this. Ofc the title is what drew me in but that cover thooo 👌🏾 it gives spooky vibes and is on the fast pace side, but I wished there was more of it. Love the way this story was told and the fmc’s (Naomi) backstory was an interesting one, especially since it feels like these stories only happen in tv shows/movies. Side characters delivered, plot ate but I needed more after that ending.
Spoilers beyond this point!!!
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
“Knowing is painful, but it’s much better than not knowing at all.”
Wheww Naomi’s backstory had me in a chokehold. I feel like her visiting her abducter mom is a realistic outcome.
She was raised by her after all. Very Finding Carter vibes & I loved it. Glad Naomie connected with her real family and that Maya started acting right (bcs she had me on my last nerve).
Speaking of Maya, the other side characters were realistic and fun to read about as well. Khalil and Naomi were cute and loved Khalil’s fam as well, especially his grandma.
The sundown town aspect and history was interesting, but I wanted more of the scary spooky ghost vibes, mainly at the end when Liam’s face contorted. Doesn’t mean I dislike the direction this book went with.
Curious to see what other stories the author has written about
Spoiler-free:
I had lots of fun reading this. Ofc the title is what drew me in but that cover thooo 👌🏾 it gives spooky vibes and is on the fast pace side, but I wished there was more of it. Love the way this story was told and the fmc’s (Naomi) backstory was an interesting one, especially since it feels like these stories only happen in tv shows/movies. Side characters delivered, plot ate but I needed more after that ending.
Spoilers beyond this point!!!
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
“Knowing is painful, but it’s much better than not knowing at all.”
Wheww Naomi’s backstory had me in a chokehold. I feel like her visiting her abducter mom is a realistic outcome.
She was raised by her after all. Very Finding Carter vibes & I loved it. Glad Naomie connected with her real family and that Maya started acting right (bcs she had me on my last nerve).
Speaking of Maya, the other side characters were realistic and fun to read about as well. Khalil and Naomi were cute and loved Khalil’s fam as well, especially his grandma.
The sundown town aspect and history was interesting, but I wanted more of the scary spooky ghost vibes, mainly at the end when Liam’s face contorted. Doesn’t mean I dislike the direction this book went with.
Curious to see what other stories the author has written about
Did not finish
February 18, 2026DNF at 22%.
There is nothing really wrong with this book - I'm just extremely bored with it. I wish more was happening because the pace is very slow right now. I can't bring myself to continue reading it because I know that it will likely be a 3 star middle-of-the-road book and I'd rather read something else.
I also don't appreciate that the parents aren't even really trying to understand the MC's feelings over the woman who raised her even though she kidnapped her. Obviously, I understand their hatred of the woman, but they're not even trying to give their daughter time and acceptance. It just didn't sit well with me.
Ultimately, this one isn't for me, but I hope that it finds other readers!
There is nothing really wrong with this book - I'm just extremely bored with it. I wish more was happening because the pace is very slow right now. I can't bring myself to continue reading it because I know that it will likely be a 3 star middle-of-the-road book and I'd rather read something else.
I also don't appreciate that the parents aren't even really trying to understand the MC's feelings over the woman who raised her even though she kidnapped her. Obviously, I understand their hatred of the woman, but they're not even trying to give their daughter time and acceptance. It just didn't sit well with me.
Ultimately, this one isn't for me, but I hope that it finds other readers!
February 8, 2026
4.5 ⭐️. Interesting, thought provoking, suspenseful and absolutely gut wrenching. I felt quite emotional towards the end of the story, simply because this is black history. My grandmother was a little girl when Emmett Till was killed. She used to tell me how afraid looking at his body on the news made her feel. My maternal family came from Baltimore Maryland to Brooklyn in the 1960's. Here in NYC schools, were segregated well into the 70's. Racism rampant. Stories like this, shed light on America's unforgettable treatment of black Americans, and it hurts thinking about my ancestors surviving such a horrific and cruel life.
February 12, 2026
So you’ve been missing for 15 years and now you’re upset your real family gets anxious when you don’t check in or show up at the agreed time? Ma’am. Then you go searching for missing girls on your own during a family vacation… and get kidnapped…AGAIN?! Naomi Camryn had me ready to fight. Like girl, please get it together. BUT… beyond my frustration, the historical context really makes you pause. It forces you to think about how much Black folks have had to endure and how the legacy of sundown towns isn’t just history. It’s unsettling to realize some places like that still exist even today.
December 15, 2025
I usually don’t read much YA but I enjoyed this one and how it played out. The background of Naomi/Camryn was interesting and just seeing her navigate through that. On top of figuring stuff out in the town they went on vacation was interesting to see as well. Loves the dynamic between the family and Naomi as well and just figuring out her feelings and what actually was going on too. Thank you net galley and Nancy Paulsen books for the e arc!
January 7, 2026
3.5 ⭐️
Sundown Town was really good overall, even though the first half dragged a bit for me. Not much was happening plot-wise, but it did allow time to really get to know the main character and her background. The last 25% of the story completely pulled me in, and the ending was emotional for me. I was genuinely happy with how it all wrapped up.
Thank you Netgalley for the advanced copy!
Sundown Town was really good overall, even though the first half dragged a bit for me. Not much was happening plot-wise, but it did allow time to really get to know the main character and her background. The last 25% of the story completely pulled me in, and the ending was emotional for me. I was genuinely happy with how it all wrapped up.
Thank you Netgalley for the advanced copy!
February 17, 2026
3.5 ✨
I finished this a few days ago and sadly this one isn’t too memorable. I think it had some important conversations about sundown towns but would’ve preferred this in an adult format. However, I do think this will resonate with younger adults. I also enjoyed the authors note and the additional context behind why Stratton told this story.
I finished this a few days ago and sadly this one isn’t too memorable. I think it had some important conversations about sundown towns but would’ve preferred this in an adult format. However, I do think this will resonate with younger adults. I also enjoyed the authors note and the additional context behind why Stratton told this story.
February 13, 2026
Learned a lot about "sundown towns" and I appreciated the mention of the Tulsa Race Massacre at the end of the book. This was such an intriguing and different thriller than any I've read, and I loved it.
February 23, 2026
One of the best books I’ve read in a minute. Suspenseful, moving, and heart wrenching
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Sundown Girls is a fast paced, unflinching story about historical horrors and their impact on the lives of those in the present. The tension of Naomi trying to merge into a family that wasn't her family for the first 15 years of her life was immediately compelling, and the events Naomi digs into ratcheted up the suspense even more.
Fans of YA that explore the challenging parts of American history will devour this one!
Thanks to Penguin Young Readers and NetGalley for an ARC in exchange for my honest review.
Fans of YA that explore the challenging parts of American history will devour this one!
Thanks to Penguin Young Readers and NetGalley for an ARC in exchange for my honest review.
October 24, 2025
Thank you NetGalley for the ARC. 4.5 ⭐️
Glad I was able to read this during spooky season. It was a perfect paranormal mystery book to snuggle into.
It’s got family drama, ghosts, and murder mystery with a really good ending. I was just hoping it stayed more towards the sundown story when it came to the girls abducted. But it was a still a great story.
Glad I was able to read this during spooky season. It was a perfect paranormal mystery book to snuggle into.
It’s got family drama, ghosts, and murder mystery with a really good ending. I was just hoping it stayed more towards the sundown story when it came to the girls abducted. But it was a still a great story.
February 9, 2026
NetGalley Review: Sundown Girls by L. S. Stratton
This isn’t a thriller that’s going to shock you with a big unpredictable twist. It’s going shock you with all the truths about how Black people were and still are treated in the US.
I’m Australian, so I didn’t know what a sundown town was and it is shocking. Not that we don’t have our own racism problem here.
One of the scariest things was the unsettling feeling that Naomi was surrounded by a deep, dark treatment of people who looked like her- it was inescapable and I really felt that claustrophobic feeling as the reader.
This isn’t a thriller that’s going to shock you with a big unpredictable twist. It’s going shock you with all the truths about how Black people were and still are treated in the US.
I’m Australian, so I didn’t know what a sundown town was and it is shocking. Not that we don’t have our own racism problem here.
One of the scariest things was the unsettling feeling that Naomi was surrounded by a deep, dark treatment of people who looked like her- it was inescapable and I really felt that claustrophobic feeling as the reader.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 168 reviews